To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

I am often blunt when writing to people who irritate or disappoint me. I see no point in wasting words in general; least of all, when addressing someone who will try to evade all but direct hits.

Some people truly make me angry, though I don't think that has happened yet on this forum.

I tend to be a much better advocate for others than for myself, and my anger usually appears in defense of others.

I interact with people differently and, I hope, appropriately.

I don't think that VonNeumann has me figured out nearly as well as he believes, but that is neither here nor there.

Some people on this forum have gotten an idea of what I'm about, and I thank them for sharing with me what they've seen. It is a view I don't normally have and it has been very helpful.
 
Can any of us prove that what we sense is "real" and not just a dream? Could it be more like a computer simulation?

If we think it valid to accept this fundamental level on faith, then we must remember that every Scientific construct lies on that foundation. I am curious what others think about this.

The question is perfectly valid, if quite old.

The fundamental nature of perception of reality in an argument like this goes back as far as the parable of Socrates' Cave in Book VII of Plato's "Republic." It was revisited by Decartes, who made a good stab at the beginning, but then his religion got in the way. It experienced a revival as the "brains in vats" argument after Penfield's famous neurological experiments. It is now most popularly associated with "The Matrix" -- but is essentially the same question if you strip away the hip black vinyl clothes and Lawrence Fishburne's pseudo-Zen-like babble.

Too many posts in this thread are unnecessarily dismissive...in my opinion because no one laid out what was a given premise of the argument and what was to be proven. To carry on a productive discussion on the subject, you have to agree on a set of axioms, and I think much of the vitriol comes from people arguing from completely different starting points.

The OP seems to be asking the basic fundamental philosophical question "what can I presume?" It's the standard "brains in vats" question. (For a very good reference of this question and other's related to the nature of reality, I recommend William Poundstone's "Labyrinths of Reason").

Summary:

PHILOSOPHICAL PART
- It is impossible to prove with absolute certainty the existance of anything other than the existance of your own consciousness.
- If you operate from that premise then all knowledge, including scientific observation and methods, are only as valid as your confidence that your perception of reality is valid.
- To this extent the OP author is correct, barring any quibbles one has about the connotations of the word "faith." I for one think it's perfectly fine, but then I don't automatically imbue the word with religious overtones.
- This matters only to the extent that you are interested in the philosophical ramifications, not the practical ones. My reading is that the fundamental philosophical principles is what the OP asked about.

OBSERVATIONAL PART
- But, despite the philosophical curiousity about absolute proofs, we (well, I at least) have no evidence that brings reality into such a question that we (well, I) suspect that "brains in vats" is a part of reality.
- The universe appears to function in a way consistant with observation. Science appears to work in the observable universe, therefore it is a useful tool to explain events in that universe.
- The "brains in vats" argument is moot when it comes to the practical aspect of using science to explain and explore the universe, up until the point when an observation points to evidence of you being a brain in a vat.

INTERESTING SIDE QUESTIONS
- "Brains in vats" does raise some interesting questions, though, about the true nature of reality. Suppose you are a brain in a vat being fed electrical impulses. According to the theory, you cannot prove that 2+2=4. For all you know 2+2=54,824, but the electrical impulses being fed to your brain tell you that 2+2 must equal 4. There is no way to prove otherwise. But what about the color red? One can argue the color red *must* exist in the "real" world...otherwise how could the signals being fed to your brain mimic a sensory perception that does not exist?
- Similarly, the emotions and perceptions one feels are real, regardless of what input produces them.


SUMMARY OF THE SUMMARY:

In the pure abstract concept the OP author is right. One must concede that one's own perception of reality sufficiently models reality for science to be valid.
But, since no evidence exists otherwise, the point is moot for all practical purposes.

- Timothy
 
In all fairness, this thread belongs in the Philosophy and Religion forum. The concepts and arguments are 0% paranormal; 100% philosophy.

- Timothy
 
INTERESTING SIDE QUESTIONS
- "Brains in vats" does raise some interesting questions, though, about the true nature of reality. Suppose you are a brain in a vat being fed electrical impulses. According to the theory, you cannot prove that 2+2=4. For all you know 2+2=54,824, but the electrical impulses being fed to your brain tell you that 2+2 must equal 4. There is no way to prove otherwise. But what about the color red? One can argue the color red *must* exist in the "real" world...otherwise how could the signals being fed to your brain mimic a sensory perception that does not exist?
Why should the colour red exist in the real world? If we are just brains in vats, we get every sensation from the electrical impulses. Colours do not need to exist at all. The impulses do not have "mimic" a sensory perception, they just have to "create" them.
 
Oh, no. Please, by all means: what is the theoretical speed limit for space-time ?
Which theory? Mine? I already stated Special Theory: Speed of Light is C in all frames of reference. I do not know why you didn't take that as the answer to your question.

I happen to believe that first proposition of Special Theory of R is true for most if not all cases.

But in QM, I am aware that strange stuff happens, like energy from nowhere, or jumping backward in time. I think I understood it to be allowed without violating first law of thermodynamics or without violating velocity c, is that with taking Heisenberg's uncertainty principle into account, things can go crazy and come back normal in a Planck-time and all is well. So at those virtual moments in time, I suppose velocities can be infinite, but they are between clock ticks and don't manifest as "real" (whatever real is). That's the way I like to think of it - for what it is worth.

Was that a sufficient answer to what you needed to your question?
 
In all fairness, this thread belongs in the Philosophy and Religion forum. The concepts and arguments are 0% paranormal; 100% philosophy.

- Timothy
I think you make a valid point. It is also true that this forum is about "General Skepticism". I posted here because what I am curious about is what people think who have assigned to themselves the label "skeptic", about this meta-level of thinking.
 
from what i can see VN is defintley locked into a paradigm with no exit
Have you noticed that mostly, I just ask questions? Do you think you truly know my paradigm? I am still pretty malleable, so how can you? Don't you see there is some wobble, or dither to my paradigm? It is part of being an "isotropic skeptic". Where you say "from what i can see VN is definitely locked" - I would revise that to "from what i allow myself to see ...".
 
William Poundstone's "Labyrinths of Reason"
I read "Recursive Universe" by Poundstone some 20 years ago. I liked his way of looking at things so I'll probably like this other book you brought up.

I appreciate that you and others have taken the time to reply with some interesting thoughts on the OP.
 
Why should the colour red exist in the real world? If we are just brains in vats, we get every sensation from the electrical impulses. Colours do not need to exist at all. The impulses do not have "mimic" a sensory perception, they just have to "create" them.
That's why I said "One can argue..." because it's been done before. It was one of Descartes musings on the topic, specifically that the subjective sensations of colors were real even if he was being deceived by an evil genius. Descartes concluded that one's own subjective feelings were the only thing one could be certain of. Pain, love, hunger could all be caused by electronic impulses, but the *feelings* experienced are real. You can try to extrapolate that to the subjective sensation of "red" and then argue whether it's possible for an evil genius to produce something that doesn't exist even as a concept in his world. I'm not insisting on the validity of the argument, I'm just repeating it as an interesting question for further examination.

- Timothy
 
"Self"-organised ? What's that ? Obviously, it did not organise itself if it didn't exist before. I'm not beign obtuse. I'm just pointing out that this tactic of mislabeling terms and processes to make them appear more ridiculous is very tiresome.
No. It is not a mislabel. It is tiresome to me that you are so argumentative about stuff that I don't even see what you see is the controversy:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self_organization

I remember a specific post in which someone speculated as to how chlorophyll could have been formed in a series of gradual steps. You must've missed that one.
I haven't had the time yet to go read the link.

I think it's accurate to say thay no claim or evidence that is contrary to your beliefs will convince you.
We've been through this before. I used to be convinced. I no longer am. I could change in the future. It is possible I could change if I really saw the kind of evidence that was not of the same kind I've already seen. I don't worry about it and neither should you.

Of course. I'm just saying that you are unnecessarily skeptical, which to me points to a specific agenda, on your part.
OK - that's what you think. Got it. What kind of agenda do you think I have? I remember you said, in the last thread, in reaction to my saying that I was getting good material, that I must be collecting stuff to share "with your creationist friends" I think you said:) .LOL LOL. Do you really think I would go to church lady and show her all this stuff - especially my own far-out musings? If you are paranoid, maybe you should worry that I might be a contributing writer to Psychology Today and doing a piece on "What Skeptics Believe", "The Dichotomy of Skeptic Psychology", or "Is Skepticsim a Religion?", etc...:D
 
Last edited:
No. It is not a mislabel. It is tiresome to me that you are so argumentative about stuff that I don't even see what you see is the controversy:

Okay. That wasn't a sentence.

Do you deny that creationists and IDers use the term "self"-organisation as a caricature ?

We've been through this before. I used to be convinced. I no longer am. I could change in the future. It is possible I could change if I really saw the kind of evidence that was not of the same kind I've already seen.

Well, you've ignored almost every argument, so far. Could you name examples of evidence that could convince you ?

I don't worry about it and neither should you.

I don't worry. I'm just annoyed.

OK - that's what you think. Got it. What kind of agenda do you think I have?

Confirming your beliefs.

I remember you said, in the last thread, in reaction to my saying that I was getting good material, that I must be collecting stuff to share "with your creationist friends" I think you said:) .LOL LOL.

<to myself> "Lol". Damn, that is SUCH a lame acronym. Why don't people use "hahaha" and be done with it ?

If you are paranoid, maybe you should worry that I might be a contributing writer to Psychology Today and doing a piece on "What Skeptics Believe", "The Dichotomy of Skeptic Psychology", or "Is Skepticsim a Religion?", etc...:D

Skepticism cannot be a religion. If you're religious about your atheism, then you're no skeptic.
 
INTERESTING SIDE QUESTIONS
- "Brains in vats" does raise some interesting questions, though, about the true nature of reality. Suppose you are a brain in a vat being fed electrical impulses. According to the theory, you cannot prove that 2+2=4.

This is a misstatement of the theory.

Mathematical truths, like all tautologies, are probable not by observation, by by introspection and knowledge of the words mean. Even to a brain in a vat, 2+2 still equals 4 (assuming that we can come to an appropriate understanding of the symbols 2,4, +, and "equals"), in the same way that we can prove that all red things are red, that no unmarried man is married. It doesn't matter whether or not "unmarried men" exist -- the same argument proves all unicorns are unicorns, because that's what the word means.
 
I think you make a valid point. It is also true that this forum is about "General Skepticism". I posted here because what I am curious about is what people think who have assigned to themselves the label "skeptic", about this meta-level of thinking.

You can't be "skeptic" about speculations. In fact, every advancement in our knowledge arise, in some way or the other, because speculations.

The problem begins when some people start to believe that their speculations are "real" and the rest of the world "stupid" because nobody believes what they see as "the ultimate truth".
 
Last edited:
The best I can do is accept with 100% certainty that human-level-or-higher consciousness has existed, or does exist. :boxedin:

Well, it's impossible to arrive at any useful conclusion if you don't. And, a priori, the thought that our mind doesn't really exist seems incoherent. It's not, but assuming that nothing exists, not even your "self", is not very practical.

But that's a point we can make against solipists, too. Sure enough, we're not 100% sure that the universe exists, but assuming that it doesn't is not a practical position for scientific purposes.
 
Actually, the answer seems to be that space-time can move at pretty much any speed. In fact, the "speed of light" actually is faster than c if you take expansion into account.

But is that "wierd"?
Belz, go google "wierd"[sic]:) .

Methinks you are waxing a little nonsense here (go read what you said "space-time can move"? Is that what you meant?). SOL=c by definition. But you mean, I think, c > 3x10^10cm/s? OK - even if photons, at the expansion front of the expanding universe (if such exists), 'seeing' nothing in front of them, not even space (yet), may appear to travel at a velocity: v > c, observed from OUR frame of reference. But Special T of R says it still travels v=c observed from its local frame. Of course from the photon's frame of reference, time is frozen so the photon is not moving at all! I hope I've got my relativity 101 down correctly here.

So you ask if I think relativity is weird? When I first learned about it, I did. I think the weirdest thing about relativity is that it is a 100 year old theory and it still has not been re-cast into descretized form! The reason for this, I believe is because it is very difficult, and the other reason is the whole basis of my isotropic skepticism: because it will require significant paradigm shift to create the models. For "Classical" relativity (a seeming oxymoron) we assume a continuous space-time. I believe when it is finally figured out how to do integrate STofR and QM, then the conclusions drawn from the unified gravity theory will be very strange [understatement].

But you ask me if relativity is weird and I digressed. I'll say that most people who have at least superficially learned of the twin paradox might say it is weird. Why would a biological organism age more slowly in an inertial frame that is either moving fast w.r.t. a reference frame or age more slowly in an inertial frame in which there is a much stronger gravitational field? I have my own way of looking at it and so it is no longer weird to me. For most people I think it begs "why?".

I don't know why I am saying so much here, but you keep asking me about speed of light, and I already told you what I think is a good example of weird: the EPR paradox - go down that path and it just gets more weird. And now I can't even remember why we are talking about "what's weird"!:confused:
 
Okay. That wasn't a sentence.
What wasn't?

Do you deny that creationists and IDers use the term "self"-organisation as a caricature ?
Did you look at my link to the encyclopaedia? It did not reveal any bias from the IDers/creationists. I think it is a term from complexity theory.


Well, you've ignored almost every argument, so far. Could you name examples of evidence that could convince you ?
You make me wish I had ignored your attempt to argue something about whether the speed of light is weird. I do not know what you are getting at there and other times I have not been able to find a reference point from which we could launch meaningful dialog. Sometimes I ignored you due to answering posts from 10 people at a time. I'll try to address a thing or two you'd like to re-post, if you wish. I also, believe I gave a good response to a couple of arguments and the counter (from others or maybe from you, I can't remember) struck me as an impasse. We have different worldviews. What's the use when we have unreconcilable differences and so little time?

I think one difference between us, and it might be our relative ages, is that I do not expect to have anyone cry uncle or concede that they are just now convinced so that they will make fundamental changes to their worldview because of something I say. That is unrealistic. Don't be annoyed, man - that's life.
I don't worry. I'm just annoyed.
Sincerely, Belz... I'm just chillin' ...having a good time. If I were so easily annoyed, I am sure I'd just go do something else.



Confirming your beliefs.
Well, that is an interesting supposition. Perhaps in a reverse way, you are right. Remember, I used to be of a different worldview that fit in well, right here. Now, by listening to many of you, I can hear myself and the types of things I used to say and think. It is an astonishing thing, Belz. This is worthwhile for me to try to explain to you. You will just have to take it at face value: when I listen to most of the things, for instance, things spoken in defense of evolution, I can swear to you that most of what I hear I have either said myself or is a paraphrase of my exact mindset. It was a very slow process for me to increase my threshold of credulity toward evolution, which just happened mostly due to the influence of a physicist friend of mine. Then, rather suddenly, my threshold of credulity reached a critical point, and it was a subtle crisis of belief. The flip-flop changes state. I don't think it is nearly the same thing as discovering evolution after having been brought up with a religious up bringing. Evolution used to be my religion - and I NEVER would have admitted it, but now I can see it. For all of you out there who I am totally irritating, never mind challenging this. It is merely a statement of my own personal observation - so what's to argue about. I'm not trying to say to anyone - you need to do this, too.



<to myself> "Lol". Damn, that is SUCH a lame acronym. Why don't people use "hahaha" and be done with it ?
...deep question, Belz:rolleyes:


Skepticism cannot be a religion. If you're religious about your atheism, then you're no skeptic.
...OK. Now, why do have trouble with my terms "darwin-faither" and "so-called-skeptic"?- you AGREE with me. I agree - it SHOULDN'T be, but for some it IS. OK? Don't take the label unless the shoe fits...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom