Can any of us prove that what we sense is "real" and not just a dream? Could it be more like a computer simulation?
If we think it valid to accept this fundamental level on faith, then we must remember that every Scientific construct lies on that foundation. I am curious what others think about this.
The question is perfectly valid, if quite old.
The fundamental nature of perception of reality in an argument like this goes back as far as the parable of Socrates' Cave in Book VII of Plato's "Republic." It was revisited by Decartes, who made a good stab at the beginning, but then his religion got in the way. It experienced a revival as the "brains in vats" argument after Penfield's famous neurological experiments. It is now most popularly associated with "The Matrix" -- but is essentially the same question if you strip away the hip black vinyl clothes and Lawrence Fishburne's pseudo-Zen-like babble.
Too many posts in this thread are unnecessarily dismissive...in my opinion because no one laid out what was a given premise of the argument and what was to be proven. To carry on a productive discussion on the subject, you have to agree on a set of axioms, and I think much of the vitriol comes from people arguing from completely different starting points.
The OP seems to be asking the basic fundamental philosophical question "what can I presume?" It's the standard "brains in vats" question. (For a very good reference of this question and other's related to the nature of reality, I recommend William Poundstone's "Labyrinths of Reason").
Summary:
PHILOSOPHICAL PART
- It is impossible to prove with absolute certainty the existance of anything other than the existance of your own consciousness.
- If you operate from that premise then all knowledge, including scientific observation and methods, are only as valid as your confidence that your perception of reality is valid.
- To this extent the OP author is correct, barring any quibbles one has about the connotations of the word "faith." I for one think it's perfectly fine, but then I don't automatically imbue the word with religious overtones.
- This matters only to the extent that you are interested in the philosophical ramifications, not the practical ones. My reading is that the fundamental philosophical principles is what the OP asked about.
OBSERVATIONAL PART
- But, despite the philosophical curiousity about absolute proofs, we (well, I at least) have no evidence that brings reality into such a question that we (well, I) suspect that "brains in vats" is a part of reality.
- The universe appears to function in a way consistant with observation. Science appears to work in the observable universe, therefore it is a useful tool to explain events in that universe.
- The "brains in vats" argument is moot when it comes to the practical aspect of using science to explain and explore the universe, up until the point when an observation points to evidence of you being a brain in a vat.
INTERESTING SIDE QUESTIONS
- "Brains in vats" does raise some interesting questions, though, about the true nature of reality. Suppose you are a brain in a vat being fed electrical impulses. According to the theory, you cannot prove that 2+2=4. For all you know 2+2=54,824, but the electrical impulses being fed to your brain tell you that 2+2 must equal 4. There is no way to prove otherwise. But what about the color red? One can argue the color red *must* exist in the "real" world...otherwise how could the signals being fed to your brain mimic a sensory perception that does not exist?
- Similarly, the emotions and perceptions one feels are real, regardless of what input produces them.
SUMMARY OF THE SUMMARY:
In the pure abstract concept the OP author is right. One must concede that one's own perception of reality sufficiently models reality for science to be valid.
But, since no evidence exists otherwise, the point is moot for all practical purposes.
- Timothy