I don't know about chlorophyll, but there are some fairly specific hypotheses about how the eye evolved. There is a lot of work on the evolution of the ribosome. Here's a paper on the subject:
http://eurekah.com/chapter.php?chap...27&PHPSESSID=5d8c1efe1521011a80d0efa7239ecd77
You're right that there is an element of "faith" in scientific theories as the evidence is compiled. The trick is to continue to compile the evidence. What I do not understand is why anyone would reject evolution as faith-based and then fall back on a supernatural explanation that is entirely faith-based with no intention of it ever being otherwise. Does utter faith make people feel more secure than an empirical/faith mixture?
~~ Paul
Edited to add: A Pubmed search of "evolution chlorophyll" turns up 695 entries.
I think any person has to believe in what they are doing. ...needs to have faith in what they are doing. It is like guessing the outcome of a story - but it is more than that. Salesmen must believe in their product. Because of grant money etc, there is a lot to salesmanship in the scientific realm. I worked many years in applications research and development, and note that the project will get cancelled if you do too much thinking out loud about your doubts.
About the word faith again here: John Readers' book
Missing Links has an interesting passage in it. He concludes that "preconceived notions have played a fundamental role in the study of fossil man", because "fossils are often so broken, distorted or incomplete that different authorities may stress different features with equal validity, and the points distinguishing their interpretations may be so slight or unclear
that each depends as much upon the proponents' preconceived notions as upon the evidence of thee fossil".
He also says "it is remarkable how often the first interpretations of new evidence have confirmed the preconceptions of its discoverer".
John Gribbin's book
The First Chimpanzee is from where I mined those quotes from Missing Links and he segueys to the next chapter with "..Bearing all this in mind then, we now present the traditional story of man's ancestry, a story based on
faith, hope, and a tableful of fossil scraps."
So he was libertarian in the use of the word "faith" there perhaps, but it still speaks to my point even with the use of the terms "preconceived notions" and "preconceptions".
On the other thread, when nylonase was brought up, I thought I presented a useful analogy about the preconceived notions rising out of paradigm vs paradigm. I said that frame shifting could be employed by one clever enough to write the instruction manual for some widget. It would be remarkably clever if someone could write an instruction book where there were, say, five steps and it were expressed in the text as one sentence. Every time you shift the letters in that one sentence, say to the left a given amount of characters, the sentence reads a new sentence which is the next instruction. That would be much more tough than to make an instruction manual all from palendromes, I suppose.
When I presented frame shift as such a clever mechanism, it looks more to me like design than it looks like it could have been designed by evolutionary mechanisms, my position was scoffed at. I think these mutually orthogonal angles of seeing evidence are simply due to this phenomenon of "preconceived notions".
I think in Sagan's Contact, he tried to present a cute sort of thing similarly in the digits of pi. I read it 20 years ago so I hope I have this right. So many digits deep into pi he fictionalized a raster that presented the image of a circle along with the formula c=pi2r. For science fiction, that was pretty darn cool for "the old one showing his hand in the design of the universe", so to speak. OTOH, of course, if pi is a normal distribution, ...of course that picture is in there somewhere!
That Sagan idea in mind: that is the way I might look at frame-shift - the designer is showing off. Hey - it could happen

.
See? It is all in the: paradigm, faith, presumption, preconceived notions, assumptions...etc.