To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

The title is "to what extent does:" ... it's not a yes/no question. You answered "science does not equal.." but I was suggesting a grey scale.
If you want to think about a "grey scale", consider my response to be right at one end of it. The assumption that the universe exists and is observable is the only sensible approach to take (although you are, of course, welcome to take any approach you wish, and see how far it gets you).

Of course I do not propose the abandonment of science. The flippant responses you see on this thread, before this thread turned into a discussion are from those so-called-skeptics who become very nervous when fundamental questions such as those of this thread, are asked. You do not prefer my term "faith" because you believe it contributes a "religious" connotation. You may not agree, but I believe that the nervous and mean/rude reactions to perfectly good philosophical inquiry, suggests that some so-called-skeptics are very "religious" about their belief structure. Belief should be a cerebral activity yet they react from their brain stem
These responses were nothing to do with me.

My personal interests have to do with leading edge Science, of course at a superficial level. The fact that we must postulate very strange ideas, more than ever, to generate theory for gravity means we cannot hold on too tightly to old classical beliefs. For instance, apparently the belief that we live in a continuous (as in analog, or non-discrete) universe is still taken on faith by many scientists. Is that still a question? ...whether space/time and everything in it is fundamentally discrete?
Science relies on the assumption that observations we make are a reflection of reality. Any development of theories has to take the observed evidence into account. If a theory doesn't agree with the observations, it ain't reality that's got a problem.

To scoff intensely at the idea that we live in a simulation shows religious bias, IMO. Where I believe I tinged some nerves with this proposition (on another thread) is that I suggested that a simulation reality plausibly suggests a designer :eek: . This causes the weak to have a limbic "knee jerk reaction", because they "know" that is impossible. If this comes from "knowledge" why do they use their cerebellum/medula to do the talking for them?
The idea that we may be inside a simulation is pointless, as there is no way of knowing whether it is a simulation or not, much as there is no way of knowing absolutely whether or not the entire universe was created five seconds ago. So this doesn't really help any argument about whether or not there was a "designer". The only approach that makes any sense is to make the assumption that the universe is real and observable.

I have read that Lee Smolin, who is working on unifying gravity theory with QM, uses the paradigm that there is nothing outside this universe.
That's pretty much a definition of "universe".

I note that at the same time, if I begin to understand him, that there are postulated hidden things within this universe. I probably misunderstand, but it seems that hidden and within might be the semantic equivalent of outside of the universe.
It depends on what he means by "hidden", I suppose. Is he postulating these "hidden things" as some sort of way of connecting QM with the larger scale?
 
Van N if you can get over to London I will happily take you to pieces in a face to face. Bear in mind when I was in uniform people tried to kill me so it takes a lot to get me worried.
 
Van N if you can get over to London I will happily take you to pieces in a face to face. Bear in mind when I was in uniform people tried to kill me so it takes a lot to get me worried.
OK, so I was wrong. I give too much credit to presumption of human dignity.
 
Yes, I do. QM doesn't seem particularily wierd, once you understand what the terms really mean.

For example, the "wave function" doesn't mean a particle is at many places at once, and is a wave, until it collapses into a particle. It means until we spot the particle we don't know WHERE it is.
Firstly, I'd point you to what Feynman said about those who claim to understand QM (he says that means they don't understand it).

Secondly, I was not speaking of the phenomenon of wave/particle duality. I was speaking of the non-locality observations. They may be due to the same thing - but the non-locality that makes faster than light signalling "seem" to happen, is strange. I am surprised, if you are aware of this even as superficially as I am, that you do not find it astonishingly strange (weird = astonishingly strange ??).
 
Personally, I'd like to see it proven, although I have little faith ( :) ) that it can be.
I'm glad you said that because that is not what I meant by "Nah, I don't need it proven". ...if you mean you thought I meant I think it is a priori.

I meant that I'm not staying awake at night with an unresolved issue on this. I am, as you are, not expecting ever to see certain things proven - and this is one of them.
 
Can any of us prove that what we sense is "real" and not just a dream? Could it be more like a computer simulation?

Yes, it could be, but the only reasonable assumption to make with our current evidence is that what appears to be real, is real.

This does not mean we take this assumption on faith, however. We make the assumption for practical reasons, not emotional reasons.

We humans accept on faith, because we have to, that we individually exist and that the Real World really exists external to us.

Not faith. See above.

If we think it valid to accept this fundamental level on faith, then we must remember that every Scientific construct lies on that foundation.

No.

Science works, we can see that. We have no good reason to believe it will stop working tomorrow, so we'd have to be stupid to use anything else.

If the Universe isn't real, it does a good enough impression of something that is for science to be successful.
 
Firstly, I'd point you to what Feynman said about those who claim to understand QM (he says that means they don't understand it).

I don't care what he said. If no one can understand QM then it's a useless theory. It clearly isn't.

Secondly, I was not speaking of the phenomenon of wave/particle duality.

I was. I was merely using it as an example that people use sometimes to point out how "wierd" QM is, when it's just their misunderstanding of the theory that is at works. Not that I claim to understand it particularily well, either.

I was speaking of the non-locality observations. They may be due to the same thing - but the non-locality that makes faster than light signalling "seem" to happen, is strange.

Is it ? Tell me, Von, what is the theoretical speed limit of space-time ?

I am surprised, if you are aware of this even as superficially as I am, that you do not find it astonishingly strange (weird = astonishingly strange ??).

See my question above.
 
I don't know about chlorophyll, but there are some fairly specific hypotheses about how the eye evolved. There is a lot of work on the evolution of the ribosome. Here's a paper on the subject:

http://eurekah.com/chapter.php?chap...27&PHPSESSID=5d8c1efe1521011a80d0efa7239ecd77

You're right that there is an element of "faith" in scientific theories as the evidence is compiled. The trick is to continue to compile the evidence. What I do not understand is why anyone would reject evolution as faith-based and then fall back on a supernatural explanation that is entirely faith-based with no intention of it ever being otherwise. Does utter faith make people feel more secure than an empirical/faith mixture?

~~ Paul

Edited to add: A Pubmed search of "evolution chlorophyll" turns up 695 entries.
I think any person has to believe in what they are doing. ...needs to have faith in what they are doing. It is like guessing the outcome of a story - but it is more than that. Salesmen must believe in their product. Because of grant money etc, there is a lot to salesmanship in the scientific realm. I worked many years in applications research and development, and note that the project will get cancelled if you do too much thinking out loud about your doubts.

About the word faith again here: John Readers' book Missing Links has an interesting passage in it. He concludes that "preconceived notions have played a fundamental role in the study of fossil man", because "fossils are often so broken, distorted or incomplete that different authorities may stress different features with equal validity, and the points distinguishing their interpretations may be so slight or unclear that each depends as much upon the proponents' preconceived notions as upon the evidence of thee fossil".

He also says "it is remarkable how often the first interpretations of new evidence have confirmed the preconceptions of its discoverer".

John Gribbin's book The First Chimpanzee is from where I mined those quotes from Missing Links and he segueys to the next chapter with "..Bearing all this in mind then, we now present the traditional story of man's ancestry, a story based on faith, hope, and a tableful of fossil scraps."

So he was libertarian in the use of the word "faith" there perhaps, but it still speaks to my point even with the use of the terms "preconceived notions" and "preconceptions".

On the other thread, when nylonase was brought up, I thought I presented a useful analogy about the preconceived notions rising out of paradigm vs paradigm. I said that frame shifting could be employed by one clever enough to write the instruction manual for some widget. It would be remarkably clever if someone could write an instruction book where there were, say, five steps and it were expressed in the text as one sentence. Every time you shift the letters in that one sentence, say to the left a given amount of characters, the sentence reads a new sentence which is the next instruction. That would be much more tough than to make an instruction manual all from palendromes, I suppose.

When I presented frame shift as such a clever mechanism, it looks more to me like design than it looks like it could have been designed by evolutionary mechanisms, my position was scoffed at. I think these mutually orthogonal angles of seeing evidence are simply due to this phenomenon of "preconceived notions".

I think in Sagan's Contact, he tried to present a cute sort of thing similarly in the digits of pi. I read it 20 years ago so I hope I have this right. So many digits deep into pi he fictionalized a raster that presented the image of a circle along with the formula c=pi2r. For science fiction, that was pretty darn cool for "the old one showing his hand in the design of the universe", so to speak. OTOH, of course, if pi is a normal distribution, ...of course that picture is in there somewhere!

That Sagan idea in mind: that is the way I might look at frame-shift - the designer is showing off. Hey - it could happen :) .

See? It is all in the: paradigm, faith, presumption, preconceived notions, assumptions...etc.
 
Last edited:
I don't care what he said. If no one can understand QM then it's a useless theory. It clearly isn't.

I was. I was merely using it as an example that people use sometimes to point out how "wierd" QM is, when it's just their misunderstanding of the theory that is at works. Not that I claim to understand it particularily well, either.

Is it ? Tell me, Von, what is the theoretical speed limit of space-time ?

See my question above.
I didn't think I said one single thing in that post that was controversial. Feynman's comment about understandability of QM had no relationship to the usefulness of QM. Of course QM is useful - we would not be communicating with PCs on the internet if it were not. I think you are merely arguing semantically on "understand".

On SOL, I again was not trying to be controversial. Einstein's special theory postulates first that the speed of light is C in all frames. IF that is so, then it is impossible for signalling to cause instantaneous change across the universe, and so IF you accept relativity, another explanation is required. When I brought this up before someone said "information" was not conveyed and I thought they thought I was talking about the old group velocity paradox. If not, I did not understand their point, either.

Suffice to say, Belz, and then lets drop it, that EPR Paradox is still unresolved and all explanations for all that stuff I think is strange and Belz does not think it is so strange. OK?
 
Yes, it could be, but the only reasonable assumption to make with our current evidence is that what appears to be real, is real.

This does not mean we take this assumption on faith, however. We make the assumption for practical reasons, not emotional reasons.
.
Yes, well all that is acceptable to me. You posit Faith= emotional assumptions.

My question to you: Do you think some individuals, who claim to be totally bound by scientific thinking, still fail to keep emotion out of their assumptions?
 
Well, that's it. Von has moved into woo land.
:) ...at least you have some interesting points, Belz. You don't come right out and say that I piss you off and call me names. Elsewise, I might think you were pathologically upset - which I am sure you are not (...yet, anyway).
 
:) ...at least you have some interesting points, Belz. You don't come right out and say that I piss you off and call me names. Elsewise, I might think you were pathologically upset - which I am sure you are not (...yet, anyway).

That's because I naively think that everyone can be reasoned with using logical arguments.
 
We humans accept on faith, because we have to, that we individually exist and that the Real World really exists external to us. So is it not an illusion or a preferred paradigm, this idea, that only those things are real which can be Scientifically proven?

I disagree, Von.

If science were to accept those things as being absolutely true, then I would agree that faith is involved.

But science does not seem to do that. It seems instead to, at most, simply hold that there is a very large amount of evidence in that direction and virtually none in the opposite. Or, variously, some scientists treat it merely as an operational asumption rather than a proven truth.

Additionally, good science doesn't hold that unproven things are not real or don't exist, but merely that we don't presently KNOW that they exist.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We humans accept on faith, because we have to, that we individually exist and that the Real World really exists external to us. So is it not an illusion or a preferred paradigm, this idea, that only those things are real which can be Scientifically proven? QUOTE]

I disagree, Von.

If science were to accept those things as being absolutely true, then I would agree that faith is involved.

But science does not seem to do that. It seems instead to, at most, simply hold that there is a very large amount of evidence in that direction and virtually none in the opposite. Or, variously, some scientists treat it merely as an operational asumption rather than a proven truth.

Additionally, good science doesn't hold that unproven things are not real or don't exist, but merely that we don't presently KNOW that they exist.

Indeed. I would dare summarize as:

provisional agreement == scientific paradigm != absolute truth
 
Yes, well all that is acceptable to me. You posit Faith= emotional assumptions.

My question to you: Do you think some individuals, who claim to be totally bound by scientific thinking, still fail to keep emotion out of their assumptions?

Sure, why not.
 
My question to you: Do you think some individuals, who claim to be totally bound by scientific thinking, still fail to keep emotion out of their assumptions?
I don't claim anything as absurd as being totally bound by scientific thinking. No one's perfect.
 
from what i can see VN is defintley locked into a paradigm with no exit
 
You are howling in pain, Complexity. You are pained by some of what I say, so much so, that you are trying to punish me. ...and you are frustrated because the more you try to punish me, the worse you make it for yourself. You are not punishing me - but if it makes you feel better, I am and probably others are, feeling quite sadly moved by your display of feelings.
Wrong again, as usual.

I'm actually having a pretty good day. Looking forward to the weekend, of course.

Must scrape you off of my shoes before I wander into better posts.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom