To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

VonNeumann - As usual, you are wrong, you dishonest fool.
I would happily say everything that I've written to you, and much more, face to face. I can assure you that I would enjoy it more than you would.
You are howling in pain, Complexity. You are pained by some of what I say, so much so, that you are trying to punish me. ...and you are frustrated because the more you try to punish me, the worse you make it for yourself. You are not punishing me - but if it makes you feel better, I am and probably others are, feeling quite sadly moved by your display of feelings.
 
VonNeumann - As usual, you are wrong, you dishonest fool.

I would happily say everything that I've written to you, and much more, face to face. I can assure you that I would enjoy it more than you would.
You are howling in pain, Complexity. You are pained by some of what I say, so much so, that you are trying to punish me. ...and you are frustrated because the more you try to punish me, the worse you make it for yourself. You are not punishing me - but if it makes you feel better, I am and probably others are, feeling quite sadly moved by your display of feelings.
Maybe it’s just me, but can anyone see how this response correlates with the quoted text?:confused:
 
No, it's not. Reality may not be particularily comforting, nor easy to understand at times, but it is in no way "wierd" in the sense you seem to mean it.
.
I never based anything about the strangeness of reality on what is "comforting" or not. I guess you do not know what I mean by "weird". If you do not think QM is weird, you simply, once again have a different threshold than I do. We both admit we do not have the level of physics education to have gone through QM maths but I'm sure you have at least read the popular stuff like Schroedinger's cat, many worlds interpretation, EPR paradox, Bell's theorem, delayed choice experiment... Do you think "weird" an inappropriate word for at least some of that?
 
Maybe it’s just me, but can anyone see how this response correlates with the quoted text?:confused:
It correlates to the fact that he never addresses what I say except with emotion. He is extremely angry at me. The only reason for it I can fathom is my questioning of fundamentals is something for which he is trying to punish me, by calling me names.
 
It correlates to the fact that he never addresses what I say except with emotion. He is extremely angry at me. The only reason for it I can fathom is my questioning of fundamentals is something for which he is trying to punish me, by calling me names.

For someone who claims to think outside the box, you sure seem to have trouble looking at things from angles other than your own.
 
It correlates to the fact that he never addresses what I say except with emotion. He is extremely angry at me. The only reason for it I can fathom is my questioning of fundamentals is something for which he is trying to punish me, by calling me names.
I’d say that the vast majority of the posts I’ve read from Complexity are quite blunt, and I can see how they might appear hostile. Though, I wouldn’t consider them to be written from any sort of emotional pain, nor would I reason that the attitude displayed by Complexity is in any way directly related to your line of questioning. I think that is this is probably just the way he is, and he would be this way with or without any association you two may have had.

Of course, this is just my opinion, and I’m sure he will correct me if I’m wrong. I’m also sure he’ll have a reply to your post as well. I look forward to reading either; I find how he frankly states his opinions to be rather refreshing.
 
For someone who claims to think outside the box, you sure seem to have trouble looking at things from angles other than your own.
You are quoting my response to a response from an individual who is extremely emotional. Said person expressed no angle different from mine. ... except that he called me a name. In previous posts, all he did was call me names. You defend this?

You are in the same camp? I start a thread to stir up some discussion and you do not like what I started? Why post something to address me unless you "have an angle other than my own" to express. ...or post something to say "yes, we will never know but what's the use in talking about it". Discussion. Discussion. That's what forums are for. Not for anger and name calling. [i presume too much]

Instead, you take the time to tell me I do not think outside the box because I identify what is the REAL reason the name-caller posts. I note you approve of it.
 
I’d say that the vast majority of the posts I’ve read from Complexity are quite blunt, and I can see how they might appear hostile. Though, I wouldn’t consider them to be written from any sort of emotional pain, nor would I reason that the attitude displayed by Complexity is in any way directly related to your line of questioning. I think that is this is probably just the way he is, and he would be this way with or without any association you two may have had.

Of course, this is just my opinion, and I’m sure he will correct me if I’m wrong. I’m also sure he’ll have a reply to your post as well. I look forward to reading either; I find how he frankly states his opinions to be rather refreshing.
Ironically, I probably agree with Complexity on more than he would presume. I read some of his posts on the subject of IQ and I had very closely the same ideas as he did on the subject. But you underestimate how well I have Complexity figured out. I am sincere when I say I am here to see what other people think, but mostly I am interested in what they think about what they think.
 
You are quoting my response to a response from an individual who is extremely emotional. Said person expressed no angle different from mine. ... except that he called me a name. In previous posts, all he did was call me names. You defend this?

You are in the same camp? I start a thread to stir up some discussion and you do not like what I started? Why post something to address me unless you "have an angle other than my own" to express. ...or post something to say "yes, we will never know but what's the use in talking about it". Discussion. Discussion. That's what forums are for. Not for anger and name calling. [i presume too much]

Instead, you take the time to tell me I do not think outside the box because I identify what is the REAL reason the name-caller posts. I note you approve of it.

No, what I called you on was exactly this, "...my response to a response from an individual who is extremely emotional. Said person expressed no angle different from mine. ... except that he called me a name. ..." You make no effort to try to see why he has the reaction he does, rather you respond with arrogance and presumption that he is emotionally distraught.

I never stated that what I thought of Complexity's comments. What I did state was that your responses seemed in contridiction to your stated mindset. Don't put words in my mouth (on whether I approve of Complexity or not), I don't know where they've been.

Even in your post that I am responding to, you exhibit the same behavior. Instead of trying to see my point of view on your actions, you assume that I have Complexity's back, as it were.
 
re OP

Can any of us prove that what we sense is "real" and not just a dream? Could it be more like a computer simulation?
There seems to be no need for anyone but you to prove this conjecture.

By definition, Science is constrained in scope to that which can be empirically demonstrated. A relationship that can be demonstrated between what our senses send to our brain, our observations, and an external objective reality, must be performed via the same observation mechanism. So can we validate objectively?
Yes we can 'validate objectively' anything that is empirically demonstrated.
(but i don't really understand the slant of the middle sentence in that paragraph. it appears to me to be irrelevant to the question asked.)

We humans accept on faith, because we have to, that we individually exist and that the Real World really exists external to us. So is it not an illusion or a preferred paradigm, this idea, that only those things are real which can be Scientifically proven?
I cannot really grok what you are getting at in this paragraph either.
I personally accept that I exist within (and as a part of) the real world.
However I do not believe this 'on faith', but believe this because I observe it to be true. I cannot speak for the rest of 'we humans'.
So I would have to reject your conjecture.

If we think it valid to accept this fundamental level on faith, then we must remember that every Scientific construct lies on that foundation. I am curious what others think about this.
Thanks for that reminder there.
And thanks for for the opportunity to tell you what I think about this.
 
In the OP I asked if reality could be "more like a computer simulation" and you said:
I think so, ...
I am interested in whether you say it could be because we cannot rule it out, or whether you say it could be because you correlate any observations toward that conjecture.
 
There seems to be no need for anyone but you to prove this conjecture.

Yes we can 'validate objectively' anything that is empirically demonstrated.
(but i don't really understand the slant of the middle sentence in that paragraph. it appears to me to be irrelevant to the question asked.)

I cannot really grok what you are getting at in this paragraph either.
I personally accept that I exist within (and as a part of) the real world.
However I do not believe this 'on faith', but believe this because I observe it to be true. I cannot speak for the rest of 'we humans'.
So I would have to reject your conjecture.

Thanks for that reminder there.
And thanks for for the opportunity to tell you what I think about this.
Nah, I don't need it proven. Most the time I feel about the whole thing pretty much as you stated it here. Someone else suggested I use the word "assumption" instead of "faith". I think they mean the same thing but recognize that assumption is sort of a euphemism. Sort of like cost-effective is for "cheap". This thread would not have attracted discussion if the OP were stated "Are there any assumptions in Science?".
 
Nah, I don't need it proven.
Personally, I'd like to see it proven, although I have little faith ( :) ) that it can be.

Most the time I feel about the whole thing pretty much as you stated it here. Someone else suggested I use the word "assumption" instead of "faith". I think they mean the same thing but recognize that assumption is sort of a euphemism. Sort of like cost-effective is for "cheap". This thread would not have attracted discussion if the OP were stated "Are there any assumptions in Science?".

I think that is itself a subject warranting some discussion-- is there a difference between a scientific assumption, axiom, whatever you want to call it, and religious faith? I can think of one big one off the top of my head: science doesn't pretend that its fundamental assumptions are absolute truth. It admits that they could be wrong, and would in theory welcome arguments tending to show that they are wrong (though, as many have observed, it's hard to imagine what an argument that external reality does not exist would look like). On that basis, I think we might argue that scientific axioms are not "faith" in the pejorative sense; instead, they are necessary assumptions consciously made so that the system can get off the ground, and are subject to revision at any time should more information become available. I doubt the same can be said of most religious systems (although the Dalai Lama has said some encouraging things about the flexibility of Buddhist belief in light of science).
 
There is no step by step empirical observation, nor is there a step by step hypothetical specific process where a moderately small machine such as chlorophyll could have self-organized. But you and others would claim that it did, even without the specificity of the process.

"Self"-organised ? What's that ? Obviously, it did not organise itself if it didn't exist before. I'm not beign obtuse. I'm just pointing out that this tactic of mislabeling terms and processes to make them appear more ridiculous is very tiresome.

Therefore, the best you can do is to vaguely paint the idea that if this and that happened "just so", then it would not be impossible for it to have happened. Therefore, it happened.

Then perhaps you'd care to ask people with an actual specialty in those fields and stop interpreting what people here say.

This is the form of explanation that is apparently satisfactory to those who assign high probability to self-organization on that level.

I remember a specific post in which someone speculated as to how chlorophyll could have been formed in a series of gradual steps. You must've missed that one.

I think it is accurate to say that the claims that there is evidence for such self-organization are riddled with patches of stretched belief - of a sort of confidence that things could just happen that way.

I think it's accurate to say thay no claim or evidence that is contrary to your beliefs will convince you.

And, Belz, do not be so offended by my pointing it out. It is OK to have confidence that there will be more detail in the future. Do you really think I would be disappointed if there were? I'm not saying that gaps mean you have to abandon the idea. But just understand that the gaps may be insufficient for others to have the same confidence in the theory.

Of course. I'm just saying that you are unnecessarily skeptical, which to me points to a specific agenda, on your part.
 
You are howling in pain, Complexity. You are pained by some of what I say, so much so, that you are trying to punish me. ...and you are frustrated because the more you try to punish me, the worse you make it for yourself. You are not punishing me - but if it makes you feel better, I am and probably others are, feeling quite sadly moved by your display of feelings.

Well, that's it. Von has moved into woo land.
 
I never based anything about the strangeness of reality on what is "comforting" or not. I guess you do not know what I mean by "weird". If you do not think QM is weird, you simply, once again have a different threshold than I do. We both admit we do not have the level of physics education to have gone through QM maths but I'm sure you have at least read the popular stuff like Schroedinger's cat, many worlds interpretation, EPR paradox, Bell's theorem, delayed choice experiment... Do you think "weird" an inappropriate word for at least some of that?

Yes, I do. QM doesn't seem particularily wierd, once you understand what the terms really mean.

For example, the "wave function" doesn't mean a particle is at many places at once, and is a wave, until it collapses into a particle. It means until we spot the particle we don't know WHERE it is.
 
Von said:
There is no step by step empirical observation, nor is there a step by step hypothetical specific process where a moderately small machine such as chlorophyll could have self-organized. But you and others would claim that it did, even without the specificity of the process. Therefore, the best you can do is to vaguely paint the idea that if this and that happened "just so", then it would not be impossible for it to have happened. Therefore, it happened.
I don't know about chlorophyll, but there are some fairly specific hypotheses about how the eye evolved. There is a lot of work on the evolution of the ribosome. Here's a paper on the subject:

http://eurekah.com/chapter.php?chap...27&PHPSESSID=5d8c1efe1521011a80d0efa7239ecd77

You're right that there is an element of "faith" in scientific theories as the evidence is compiled. The trick is to continue to compile the evidence. What I do not understand is why anyone would reject evolution as faith-based and then fall back on a supernatural explanation that is entirely faith-based with no intention of it ever being otherwise. Does utter faith make people feel more secure than an empirical/faith mixture?

~~ Paul

Edited to add: A Pubmed search of "evolution chlorophyll" turns up 695 entries.
 
Last edited:
Personally, I'd like to see it proven, although I have little faith ( :) ) that it can be.



I think that is itself a subject warranting some discussion-- is there a difference between a scientific assumption, axiom, whatever you want to call it, and religious faith? I can think of one big one off the top of my head: science doesn't pretend that its fundamental assumptions are absolute truth. It admits that they could be wrong, and would in theory welcome arguments tending to show that they are wrong (though, as many have observed, it's hard to imagine what an argument that external reality does not exist would look like). On that basis, I think we might argue that scientific axioms are not "faith" in the pejorative sense; instead, they are necessary assumptions consciously made so that the system can get off the ground, and are subject to revision at any time should more information become available. I doubt the same can be said of most religious systems (although the Dalai Lama has said some encouraging things about the flexibility of Buddhist belief in light of science).

I think this is a great response. We have faith in science because it allows us to question it...it evolves...and the evidence and general framework is built upon basics and tools and understandings that humans share --the meaning is the same no matter which language we speak--the results, predictions, and tools are the same...anyone can learn it and understand it and utilize the information. For example, pi is a universal tool. You can trust it to get the area of a circle and utilize it in all sorts of forumulations without have to know why it works--but the evidence is there should you require more than faith. With religous faith, the evidence doesn't seem readily apparent or definable...the use of any given tenent or the validity of claims is often not apparent. Would you say a person has "faith" in math if she uses a formula, but doesn't no why it works...only that it does? If you use a calculator to arrive at a sum total, are you putting faith in the calculator? When you fly on an airplane, does that imply "faith" in science you may not understand?

Yes, I have faith in science if the above is what you mean by faith...but it's based on a whole life experience of accumulated use and evidence--science has earned my faith...but even if I lost faith, I'm free to go back and look at the evidence to reassess my trust and understanding...and if questioned as to why I believe something, I feel confident that I would have compelling answers--

But there is another kind of faith...it's based on feelings and "inner knowingness" and untestable claims and immeasurable concepts and unclear definitions--it seems to expect a strong conviction despite very weak support--that is what most people seem to mean when they mean faith--they mean placing trust in the unknowable...believing without or despite evdence-- People pretend that this faith is noble--the key to higher truths and deep wisdom...but I think this type of faith is a really poor substitute for the former.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom