To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

Ah, now you're changing your mind again!




A refutation is uninteresting if no one in the history of the Universe has ever made such an argument in the first place.

As I keep repeating, you need to prove that many believers employ such an argument.


I'm still waiting.

1) How am I changing my mind?
2) The argument that is employed, that this refutes, is the argument of "you reject/refute/etc my theory because it is not consistent with your status quo/paradigm." If you don't feel that this argument is used by people, then there isn't much I can do to help you.

As an aside, if people didn't use this _general_ form of a logical fallacy there wouldn't be a formal definition of it in debate.
 
A refutation is uninteresting if no one in the history of the Universe has ever made such an argument in the first place.

As I keep repeating, you need to prove that many believers employ such an argument.

I'm still waiting.

Ian, are you really that blind regarding your very own thinking? You do it all the time. You believe that BECAUSE nobody here buys your "arguments" then we all are stupid and you are a genious!

LOL! and YOU talk about the "closed minded"!
 
Ian said:
A refutation is uninteresting if no one in the history of the Universe has ever made such an argument in the first place.

As I keep repeating, you need to prove that many believers employ such an argument.

I'm still waiting.
I gave you two links. Click on the first one and search for "Galileo". Click on the second one and search for "Newton".

~~ Paul
 
The argument that is employed, that this refutes, is the argument of "you reject/refute/etc my theory because it is not consistent with your status quo/paradigm."

Of course the prevailing paradigm influences our beliefs. Why for example do you think that in the west belief in reincarnation is much less prevalent than a more general belief in "a life after death"? Why do people generally not believe in sorcery anymore? The less we think about such issues the more likely we will be to simply implicitly take on board common beliefs of our culture. This is where thinking for yourself comes in handy. Observing that people laugh at Bozo the clown in no shape or form demonstrates this to be false.

If you don't feel that this argument is used by people, then there isn't much I can do to help you.

You keep changing your mind about the argument that people are supposed to be employing. Yes they do say that you reject my beliefs because of the prevailing paradigm. I agree with them that this certainly has a major influence on many people in what they believe (everyone, not just skeptics).
 
Can any of us prove that what we sense is "real" and not just a dream? Could it be more like a computer simulation?

By definition, Science is constrained in scope to that which can be empirically demonstrated. A relationship that can be demonstrated between what our senses send to our brain, our observations, and an external objective reality, must be performed via the same observation mechanism. So can we validate objectively?

We humans accept on faith, because we have to, that we individually exist and that the Real World really exists external to us. So is it not an illusion or a preferred paradigm, this idea, that only those things are real which can be Scientifically proven?

If we think it valid to accept this fundamental level on faith, then we must remember that every Scientific construct lies on that foundation. I am curious what others think about this.

The famous French philosopher René Descartes said, "Cogito ergo sum",
Which translates basically to, "I think therefore I am".

From my perspective you could be a creation of my own imagination and to you I could be as well. However there is a point in which a person has to make a decision in what to accept as reality and what to set aside. It all depends on where to draw the line.

There could be a brand of soda pop called Coca Cola on a planet that orbits the star HR 7001. Because at this moment we do not have the ability to thoroughly scan any orbiting planets and search under every stone or ice crevice. This possibility doesn't seem likely but it "could" be true. If in the future we do have the ability to thoroughly check any planets orbiting HR 7001 specifically for Coca Cola brand products remotely then it is up the individual to decide if they "trust" the scanning device. If even further into the future there is a transport to these distant planets and the individual could go see for his or herself that there are no Coca Cola products that were originally produced on these baron planets and after observing with their own eyes that there is nothing to be found regarding Coca Cola at the time of observation the individual has a choice to trust what they see with their eyes or the choice not to.

Here in lies the problem, if this is all a computer simulation we still have consequences within this simulation. If I put my hand in the flame on the stove for a long enough period of time my hand will be burned and I will most likely experience pain. I could quite possibly have a tumor in my brain that I am unaware of and this tumor affects the brain in a way that my nerves do not feel the effects of something hot. It could be true but most likely not. If this reality is not real while the consequences experienced within this reality are then a line has to be drawn. Will the individual work with the reality that which surrounds them and try to experience positive consequences or will the individual choose to ignore their reality and ask questions of why they are experiencing such negative consequences?

I am not saying that if you accept reality you will not experience negative consequences but more so how to avoid some negative consequences while finding or creating positive ones. If you do not like the reality you exist in then do what you can to change it using what exists within it.
 
Last edited:
I would presume that each of you would behave much differently one-on-one, eye-to-eye, with me than you do in a pack. Such is the forum culture - it is all on stage.
VonNeumann - As usual, you are wrong, you dishonest fool.

I would happily say everything that I've written to you, and much more, face to face. I can assure you that I would enjoy it more than you would.
 
All this talk about a simulation seems to me to be empty speculation typical for philosophers. If there is no way to know if we live in a simulation or not, why bother speculating? Nothing changes: I am just as real as before, the universe is unaltered, everything is like it has always been! So who cares? It is parallel speculation to that about whether some God created the universe and everything: if he has not interfered since creation, there is no way of telling, and the speculation becomes futile.
Now, if somebody could come up with arguments that would make the simulation theory testable, then it would be quite a different matter!
 
No it's not. Von's contention is that beign anti-establishment is necessarily a good thing, because those who don't are close-minded. He doesn't understand that sometimes, beign skeptical leads you to agree with the established theories.

Thank you for verbalizing what I was too frustrated to get out succinctly.
 
VonNeumann said:
Perhaps you should read about quantum gravity or read Feynman's QED, for starters. Whatever reality is, it is more weird than you might think.

No, it's not. Reality may not be particularily comforting, nor easy to understand at times, but it is in no way "wierd" in the sense you seem to mean it.

Interesting Ian said:
Yes people believe they are like Galileo or whoever in that sense. That includes me.

Well that proves Bodhi Dharma Zen's point.
 
Steenkh said:
All this talk about a simulation seems to me to be empty speculation typical for philosophers. If there is no way to know if we live in a simulation or not, why bother speculating? Nothing changes: I am just as real as before, the universe is unaltered, everything is like it has always been! So who cares? It is parallel speculation to that about whether some God created the universe and everything: if he has not interfered since creation, there is no way of telling, and the speculation becomes futile.
Now, if somebody could come up with arguments that would make the simulation theory testable, then it would be quite a different matter!
Perhaps philosophers think that eventually someone might come up with a logical proof that one metaphysic is more accurate than another. I'm not holding my breath.

~~ Paul
 
Answer the question: when did anyone here ever claim that evolution is "just so" ?
There is no step by step empirical observation, nor is there a step by step hypothetical specific process where a moderately small machine such as chlorophyll could have self-organized. But you and others would claim that it did, even without the specificity of the process. Therefore, the best you can do is to vaguely paint the idea that if this and that happened "just so", then it would not be impossible for it to have happened. Therefore, it happened.

This is the form of explanation that is apparently satisfactory to those who assign high probability to self-organization on that level. I think it is accurate to say that the claims that there is evidence for such self-organization are riddled with patches of stretched belief - of a sort of confidence that things could just happen that way.

If there is a step-by-step explanation for the evolution of chlorophyll, I will be glad to be corrected. ...and I mean a step by step explanation with all the gaps reasonably filled and without the "just so" hand waving.

And, Belz, do not be so offended by my pointing it out. It is OK to have confidence that there will be more detail in the future. Do you really think I would be disappointed if there were? I'm not saying that gaps mean you have to abandon the idea. But just understand that the gaps may be insufficient for others to have the same confidence in the theory.

It reminds me that I was accused of having no imagination when it comes to filling in the gaps. That's kind of funny to me because of the irony; most of the time I am accused of having an unbridled imagination.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom