Three Orthodox Jews and a Coptic Christian walk into a Levantine Bar

What the hell are you talking about? I didn't say anything even remotely like this. I said that Israel's desire to keep the Golan Heights has a tactical component because they've been attacked from that border before. To my knowledge, Israel was not the aggressor in any war ever.
Cough cough. 1956. And define "aggressor"; in 1967, the Israeli army attacked first.
In any case, it's historically wrong to say that Jews took possession of Palestinian land. Palestine was an absolute wasteland when both Jews and Arabs starting building a presence at the turn of the 20th century.
Do you have a reference for that claim? :rolleyes:
 
So you're relying on the rule of so? I personally am not uniformly against negotiating with terrorists, even if I agreed with that description. It's just a form of asymmetrical warfare employed for achieving political goals. At least it used to be; now it seems to be violence for the hell of it. Or an orgasm for end-of-the-world types.

I just wondered if anyone had tried it. Territorial disputes can be resolved. Holy wars can't. How many deaths do you suppose Yasser Arafat caused? And were most of them Israeli or Palestinian? I get that you're angry but I don't cede the moral high ground to anyone in this dispute, except Israelis (and Arabs) committed to peacefully changing Israel's domestic policy re: occupied territories.

I can only hope that the rule of unintended consequences kicks in and heads off or at least mitigates the disaster this has the potential to be. Could anything cause Israel to walk back its claim to all of Jerusalem?

Are Trump's Saudi pals going to pat him on the back for this?

Exactly god gave the entire region to the jewish people and they will take it no matter how long the current residents have been living there. It is just like how the trail of tears was a high point in american history, Jackson wouldn't let laws of man or morals stand in the way of getting the land god had given to the american people from the savages. Same thing with taking Jerusalem from the muslims, Israel would never let boarders stand in the way of what is theirs by grace of god.
 
They were refugees who saw forming a Jewish state as the only possible means forward. I don't think they were relying on God so much as on statements made by the British government. And some of them probably weren't against alternatives to Palestine.

Then Trump didn't kill it, did he? And Israel has removed some settlers, there's no inherent reason to believe it can't be done.

It only removed settlers because they were is tactically unsupportable locations, the strategically sound ones are never going anywhere. And there is a difference between forceably relocating 10,000 people from tactically unsound locations and 800,000. We are talking 13% of the total population after all.

But by right of conquest it is theirs and we need to stop this idea that you can't just take what you want.
 
Netenyahu would use it to project himself as a new Ezra, and if they brought their capital with them just think what it would do for house prices, a massive boost for the property-owning classes he actually represents.

The Blood and Soil settler movement would adore the idea, so Netenyahu couldn't say a word in opposition to it without going the way of Rabin.

It is nice to see a moto that works so well for both the Nazi party and jewish settlers.
 
Dude, what?

First of all, I said it was one consideration, not the only consideration.

Second, has Russia been under constant threat of attack from Crimea for seventy years? Did Crimea invade Russia on the holiest day of the Russian year?

False equivalency is false.

It was enough to make your argument on, so stand by your argument as a principle or not.
 
Netenyahu has repeatedly sworn on his mother's grave and evey other Jewish mother's grave that he will never accept a two-state solution, and he was one of those who called for Rabiln to be killed as a race-traitor for doing so. It's a founding principle of Likud and defines the Revisionists (who tried to kill ben Gurion for pretending to accept it).

Except he has said he would accept a two state solution, and the Likud platform was redrafted long ago to remove that plank.
 
Last time I checked, you didn't get people on your side by pissing them off first.

At the same time, if it becomes clear you can't get them on your side, then not pissing them off doesn't accomplish anything.

So we are formally giving up on a two state solution, figure we will endorse apartheid or ethnic cleansing?

Who's giving up on the two state solution?

The only upside to this, as I can see it, is that never again any Arab nation or the Palestinians will view the USA as a honest peace broker. Of course, it never was.

Why should this change any negotiations? There never was any proposal where Israel would give up Jerusalem entirely, the only issue of contention is if "Palestine" would have it's capital in East Jerusalem.

The bottom line is this really doesn't change anything. The Palestinian side is upset soley because they think allowing Israel to have the capital they want lends legitimacy to the very existence of Israel.
 
At the same time, if it becomes clear you can't get them on your side, then not pissing them off doesn't accomplish anything.



Who's giving up on the two state solution?



Why should this change any negotiations? There never was any proposal where Israel would give up Jerusalem entirely, the only issue of contention is if "Palestine" would have it's capital in East Jerusalem.

^Yes, exactly.


The bottom line is this really doesn't change anything. The Palestinian side is upset soley because they think allowing Israel to have the capital they want lends legitimacy to the very existence of Israel.

Yes. We (Israelis) consider Jerusalem the capital no matter what anyone says. But we were tense about the embassy move from TLV to Jerusalem because of the violence that is coming from the Palestinian reaction. They plan the "three days of rage" beginning tomorrow (friday). We just do not want more chaos and violence. But there will be anyway.

It will be centered in Jerusalem, but we were told this morning to be alert and careful in Tel Aviv too (I am in Tel Aviv now) because violence may break out here too.

I am still going to the shuk tomorrow and running errands as usual. We have been through this many times before. We can not just sit home and hide just because the Palestinians are going on a rage. Again.
 
The US. We are formally recognizing the conquest of Jerusalem now, why stop there? Really long ago the boarders became untenable as a result of the settlements.

You really are clueless and have no idea what you are talking about regarding the Israeli/Palestinian issues.
 
You really are clueless and have no idea what you are talking about regarding the Israeli/Palestinian issues.

It is clear that Israel will take what ever it chooses and nothing can stop it and anyone who objects is a terrorist. That is the simple reality of it.
 
Well they happened to be living in the land god gave to the jews that was their mistake after all. That is why taking it by force was the only logical option.

Zionists prior to 1947 purchased the lands they built on.

During the Israeli war of independence, Muslim Arabs who fled their lands were not allowed back, and their lands were taken by the state. This also happened to Jewish refugees from areas that were taken by Arab forces.

Today Zionists still purchase lands from Arab land-owners. Characterizing this as “taking by force” is at best uninformed, and at worst disinformation motivated by bigotry and a desire to be incendiary.

The idea of a two state solution has been dead for a long time, you would be talking about forcibly relocating 10% of the israeli population out of the occupied territories. The settlements have succeeded in making the land israel. So the only solutions are recognizing it as an apartheid state or cleansing the palestinians to preserve the jewish ethnostate.

The only obstacle to a two state solution is that there hasn’t been any serious negotiations about it since Arafat walked out of Camp David back in 2001. Abbas keeps coming up with new reasons not to come to the table.

Settlements can be moved, or not, lands can be swapped, borders can be negotiated. It all requires negotiations.

You would certainly happily give up all your land and your home to anyone who asked right?

A straw man, and an incendiary one at that.
 
Last edited:
It is clear that Israel will take what ever it chooses and nothing can stop it and anyone who objects is a terrorist. That is the simple reality of it.

One thing that could stop it would be a negotiated two state solution with clearly recognized borders, yet getting the Palestinian side to the table is seen as wrong for some reason?
 
Zionists prior to 1947 purchased the lands they built on.

During the Israeli war of independence, Muslim Arabs who fled their lands were not allowed back, and their lands were taken by the state. This also happened to Jewish refugees from areas that were taken by Arab forces.

Today Zionists still purchase lands from Arab land-owners. Characterizing this as “taking by force” is at best uninformed, and at worst disinformation motivated by bigotry and a desire to be incendiary.

Plenty certainly are. Say the army decides it needs it as a command post, there you go you lose your house. Sucks to be you. Or you could try to live upstairs and get shot.

https://www.hrw.org/news/2017/11/28/israel/palestine-un-settlement-business-data-can-stem-abuse


Settlements can be moved, or not, lands can be swapped, borders can be negotiated. It all requires negotiations.

Yep and every year the boarders of what will have to stay Israeli get larger. Seems to be working quite well as a low intensity conflict.
 
One thing that could stop it would be a negotiated two state solution with clearly recognized borders, yet getting the Palestinian side to the table is seen as wrong for some reason?

There kind of already are boarders, we are just going to pretend they aren't there and don't matter because it is inconvenient for them to stay as they are.
 
Plenty certainly are. Say the army decides it needs it as a command post, there you go you lose your house. Sucks to be you. Or you could try to live upstairs and get shot.

War sucks all around. We should put an end to this one especially for the sake of the Palestinian people who, being the weaker party, suffer even more than the Israelis.

Yep and every year the boarders of what will have to stay Israeli get larger. Seems to be working quite well as a low intensity conflict.

Again, the fastest and easiest way to put a halt to it is to bring both sides together to negotiate final borders.

There kind of already are boarders, we are just going to pretend they aren't there and don't matter because it is inconvenient for them to stay as they are.

There are armistice lines that are now called "the Green Line". At the end of the Israeli war of independence all sides agreed they are not final borders.
 
War sucks all around. We should put an end to this one especially for the sake of the Palestinian people who, being the weaker party, suffer even more than the Israelis.
From someone who's clearly pro-Israel, that sounds pretty paternalistic.

But then, there must first be someone to talk to on the Palestinian side. Or, the Palestinians must first recognize Israel as a Jewish state - never mind that 20-25% of the citizens of Israel are not Jewish. Or whatever the excuse-du-jour from the Israeli government is not to talk.

Again, the fastest and easiest way to put a halt to it is to bring both sides together to negotiate final borders.

There are armistice lines that are now called "the Green Line". At the end of the Israeli war of independence all sides agreed they are not final borders.
That doesn't invalidate the fact that all territory beyond the Green Line counts as occupied territory. Building settlements there which house 100s of 1000s Jewish Israelis, with their exclusive "slegs vir Jode" roads contravenes international law. Surely you'll also advocate that Israel revert the West Bank (and East Jerusalem) to the status quo ante, i.e., evacuates all those illegal settlers before starting negotiations? :rolleyes:

And yes, Israel has been using the excuse of "military use" for obvious civilian settlements in the West Bank/East Jerusalem, that's a plain fact.
 
Yes. We (Israelis) consider Jerusalem the capital no matter what anyone says.
Oh, but you do value when others recognize it as such as well. It may not be a big bargaining chip, but it nevertheless is one, and Trump gave that away. Next he'll try to press the Palestinians into accepting Abu Dis and not East Jerusalem as capital. The new Saudi king may already have done so, though the content in that NYT article is contested by other sources.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom