Three Orthodox Jews and a Coptic Christian walk into a Levantine Bar

When I did a tour of Jerusalem, the guide took us to a sculpture of a giant menorah and said the building it was in front of was where the government sat.

So it is the capital city in all but name.
And?

Yes, the Israelis have housed the Knesset and most of the ministries in Jerusalem; but who could stop them? That is quite another matter than that other states recognize Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. And the USA moving their embassy to Jerusalem comes very, very close to a formal recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital.

(of course, to put a fine line on it, the capital is not necessarily the government's seat).

Walking roughshod over the Jerusalem question, as well as, in case of the UN resolution, the settlements question, makes that Trump has pissed off the Palestinians in two of the three stumbling blocks (the third being the right of return) in previous peace talks.
 
That would certainly explain my lack of sympathy for the Palestinians.w... And somehow this all transformed them into one of America's closest allies.

Just like with Russia the right on conquest trumps all. So we need to end all those sanctions over that BS Ukrainian issue. If the Ukranians wanted their own state they needed to properly lay down and accept Russian leadership.
 
Why is it even up to Trump to have a preference? Isn't that an Israeli issue?

ETA: I know it's sensitive. I'm not a fan of Israeli overreach. But IMO the Palestinians are not very far along in the process of forming a state. They are fixated on injustices of which there have been many, but it doesn't seem to help them get their act together politically. Israeli Jews knew how to go about forming a nation. I don't think Arabs in the area had much experience of that.
 
Last edited:
Why is it even up to Trump to have a preference? Isn't that an Israeli issue?

ETA: I know it's sensitive. I'm not a fan of Israeli overreach. But IMO the Palestinians are not very far along in the process of forming a state.

Yea it is almost as if the decades it has been since they had things like function infrastructure matter. Kudos on Isreal though they have managed to get to the point where fewer and fewer people can remember the last day that they had power for 24 continuous hours.

http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-almasri-no-electricity-in-gaza-20170820-story.html

And we can forget about closing the settlements those are here to stay forever, to large a percentage of the Israeli population lives in them.

So we can finally accept that this two state solution is never going to happen and it is political fiction. As I see it the only solutions are ethnic cleansing or formal apartheid.
 
It's in the early stages, they so far have "listened". Read the linked article.
It notes the plan is decidedly short on detail.

It seems to all boil down to "were are friends, because we are all enemies of Iran, so surely we shall cut a deal".

They won't.
 
If this whole affair goes bad, how long will it be before Trump denies involvement and blames it all on Jared?
 
So we can finally accept that this two state solution is never going to happen and it is political fiction.
Netenyahu has repeatedly sworn on his mother's grave and evey other Jewish mother's grave that he will never accept a two-state solution, and he was one of those who called for Rabiln to be killed as a race-traitor for doing so. It's a founding principle of Likud and defines the Revisionists (who tried to kill ben Gurion for pretending to accept it).

As I see it the only solutions are ethnic cleansing or formal apartheid.
There's an informal apartheid option : just wall the Palestinians into ghettos. They are, after all, aliens in the Land and should be grateful for not being cleansed.

Another intifada would provide a welcome distraction for Netenyahu and Trump in difiicult times for them both. Just saying.
 
Let's not forget that Trump is going to recognize Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. That is, the whole of Jerusalem, not "West Jerusalem". The eastern half of Jerusalem is occupied territory. Israel has annexed it as Israeli territory, but that's not recognized by anyone in the world. Moreover, since 1967 Israel has been expanding the city limits of Jerusalem. Israel has been building Jewish settlements (i.e., settlements for Jewish Israelis) in East Jerusalem, and they've been pulling all kind of tricks on the inhabitants of East Jerusalem to drive them out. These are all so-called "facts on the ground" that Israel creates in order to let the Palestinians have even less than the 22% of former Mandate Palestine that the West Bank and Gaza constitute.

When Trump recognizes Jerusalem as Israel's capital, he de facto also recognizes the annexation of East Jerusalem and endorses these policies.
 
Why is it even up to Trump to have a preference? Isn't that an Israeli issue?
The Israelis declared Jerusalem as their capital decades ago. West Jerusalem is their official seat of government. However, East Jerusalem is not officially recognized by the international community as Israeli territory. Trump's preference breaks with international convention, but agrees with the official Israeli position on Jerusalem.
 
Why is it even up to Trump to have a preference? Isn't that an Israeli issue?
The matter is that Trump the USA recognizes, as only country in the world, Jerusalem (AFAICS the whole of Jerusalem) as Israel's capital. That's the issue.

I heard today on the radio that apparently, Congress had already passed a law that the USA should move its embassy to Jerusalem, during the Clinton years. However, the law had a loophole, and Clinton, Bush the Lesser and Obama all dutifully signed a waiver each six month to postpone implementing the law.

The only upside to this, as I can see it, is that never again any Arab nation or the Palestinians will view the USA as a honest peace broker. Of course, it never was.
 
The matter is that Trump the USA recognizes, as only country in the world, Jerusalem (AFAICS the whole of Jerusalem) as Israel's capital. That's the issue.
Not quite the only country. Israel also recognizes Jerusalem as their capital.

I heard today on the radio that apparently, Congress had already passed a law that the USA should move its embassy to Jerusalem, during the Clinton years. However, the law had a loophole, and Clinton, Bush the Lesser and Obama all dutifully signed a waiver each six month to postpone implementing the law.
So much for having our cake and eating it too. Trump just wants to eat the cake.

The only upside to this, as I can see it, is that never again any Arab nation or the Palestinians will view the USA as a honest peace broker. Of course, it never was.
Nor did they ever view the US that way in the first place. Nor are the Arab nations or the Palestinians honest peace brokers.

But maybe that's an oversimplification. The US goes through a rolling regime change on a 4-8 year cycle. Each previous president has declined to recognize Jerusalem, and waived the legislature's requirement to put the embassy there.

Each President has taken their own approach to brokering peace. I think that it's more reasonable and accurate to say that each successive US president may or may not be seen as an honest peace broker, depending on how they act towards the peace process. It's not really correct to refer to the US as a whole in this context, as if it were a monolithic entity with a consistent long-term executive branch policy. Things vary greatly from president to president.

I know it's fashionable to blame Trump for everything, and prophesy the direst possible consequences for every little thing he does. But it's probably not correct to say that because of this, other stakeholders will never see the US as an honest broker in the peace process. I think that the leaders in the region probably understand that each president must be dealt with on his own terms.
 
Last edited:
My guess is that some Fundamentalist nutjob in the administration has suggested that they should just rebuild Solomon's Temple so that Jesus will come back and solve everything...
That word implies there was a Temple of Solomon in the first place. There's not a shred of evidence for that; in fact, all archaeological evidence points to Jerusalem only being a small village in "Solomon"'s times.

One wonders when they'll start blaming diaspora Jews for delaying the Rapture, and advocate they be made to go to Israel. Which Netenyahu would not object to at all.
Would it really be beneficial to Israel or its leaders if five million US Jews would immigrate to Israel? In the 1940s and 1950s, the Mizrahim provided cheap labour that the Zionist founders found themselves too good for (and the Mossad helped a hand with that migration with bombing campaigns in Iraq and Egypt). Ditto the Russian Jews that migrated in the 1990s. But well-educated, good earning US Jews? They'd only be competition.
 
Not quite the only country. Israel also recognizes Jerusalem as their capital.
Really? :jaw-dropp No, they don't recognize Jerusalem as their capital, they designate it. Recognition is for other countries.

Nor did they ever view the US that way in the first place. Nor are the Arab nations or the Palestinians honest peace brokers.
You seem to have a problem with simple English words. A peace broker is a third party that helps to get a peace treaty. So obviously, the Palestinians cannot be a broker because they're one of the warring parties. Ditto for Lebanon, Syria, Iraq and a few other Arab states that are still at war with Israel from 1948 on.

But maybe that's an oversimplification. The US goes through a rolling regime change on a 4-8 year cycle. Each previous president has declined to recognize Jerusalem, and waived the legislature's requirement to put the embassy there.

Each President has taken their own approach to brokering peace. I think that it's more reasonable and accurate to say that each successive US president may or may not be seen as an honest peace broker, depending on how they act towards the peace process. It's not really correct to refer to the US as a whole in this context, as if it were a monolithic entity with a consistent long-term executive branch policy. Things vary greatly from president to president.

I know it's fashionable to blame Trump for everything, and prophesy the direst possible consequences for every little thing he does. But it's probably not correct to say that because of this, other stakeholders will never see the US as an honest broker in the peace process. I think that the leaders in the region probably understand that each president must be dealt with on his own terms.
I bet that for many years, moving the embassy back to Tel Aviv (or any other place) will be a precondition for the Arab side to even try the USA as a broker.
 
The new Trump Hotel embassy I am sure will be magnificent, how much is it going to cost?

Hopefully less than a wall.

If construction costs get too high, Trump could do what he has often done in the past. Don't pay the sub contractors.
 
At least he explicitly mentioned the fact that there is a border dispute down the middle of Jerusalem and said the decision to recognize Jerusalem does not imply any position on how that dispute is to be resoved - i.e. he accepts the status quo that East Jerusalem is Palestinian.

Still wishy-washy and short on detail about future peace, except that Saudi Arabia looms large.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom