Three Orthodox Jews and a Coptic Christian walk into a Levantine Bar

When it comes to Israel/Palestine, there is no It's-pretty-obvious-if-you-think-about-it solution to be had.
 
I noticed he never says "Palestine", always "the Palestinians".
That's one step up from Golda Meir who denied Palestinians existed at all.

When it comes to Israel/Palestine, there is no It's-pretty-obvious-if-you-think-about-it solution to be had.
It's sort-of like Northern Ireland but then different. ;)

I think there's one pretty easy solution for Jerusalem, though. Nuke the place. Turn Mount Doom Temple Mount into an enormous glass crater. That pisses everyone off equally, and nobody can complain that the other party got more. See also Solomon's judgment.
 
How many are going to die because of this decision? I think it's pretty good odds that someone bombs something and declares it's revenge for this move.
 
It certainly makes the US more of a target. I wouldn't be surprised if this puts US citizens in the region in the cross hairs of radicals.
 
Classic Trump. He does basically nothing, makes news and people freak out. This magnificent embassy will be built out of the same material as our giant Southern border wall.
 
The Israelis declared Jerusalem as their capital decades ago. West Jerusalem is their official seat of government. However, East Jerusalem is not officially recognized by the international community as Israeli territory. Trump's preference breaks with international convention, but agrees with the official Israeli position on Jerusalem.

Upnext we will side with Taiwan as the official government of china, or as officially part of china so that the rebel government in it can finally be suppressed.
 
Now it's rumoured for a few days that Trump will announce to recognize Jerusalem as capital of Israel, which is against conventions the UN and the international community have established since the late 60s. Tel Aviv is the capital of Israel.


First of all, Tel Aviv is not the capital of Israel. According to Israel itself, Jerusalem is the capital.

Second of all, pretending the capital is Tel Aviv is stupid. When a diplomat has to interact with the Israeli government, he/she goes to Jerusalem. The Knesset is in Jerusalem. The President and Prime Minister are in Jerusalem.

Imagine the outrage if every country in Europe refused to recognize Washington as the capital of the US and moved all their embassies to Newark, New Jersey.

I do agree that recognizing Jerusalem may inflame Palestinian passions, may lead to violence and may set the peace process back. I also agree that it's a political act aimed at a small contingent of wealthy, orthodox Republican donors and some end-of-days Christians.

But, as a talking head on CNN said today, refusing to recognize Jerusalem hasn't really led to peace in the last 50 years; recognizing basic reality probably won't disturb that lack of progress at all.
 
Last edited:
Yea it is almost as if the decades it has been since they had things like function infrastructure matter. Kudos on Isreal though they have managed to get to the point where fewer and fewer people can remember the last day that they had power for 24 continuous hours.
No, I get that, I totally do. And my knowledge of history is woefully incomplete. But there wasn't much in Palestine to begin with, and Jews, fresh from the Holocaust, were determined to build a nation. (I don't know how determined they were to build it in Palestine, however). And this situation evolved into a multi-generational injustice - a tragedy - I agree. But it sometimes seems that Arabs in the region are their own worst enemies. Their uprisings ended up in more dead Palestinians and expanded Israeli territory. Coming from Europe, Zionists had some knowledge of how to organize, create a state, build infrastructure and affect public opinion. And they were very motivated. The Palestinian Arabs weren't stupid; they just did not have a lot of experience in organizing. And frankly, the existence of dispossessed Palestinian Arabs was a giant boon to the political fortunes of some Muslim leaders who used it to unite factions that otherwise hated each other. Sworn enemies needed those camps. And Trump has given them a huge gift.

So we can finally accept that this two state solution is never going to happen and it is political fiction. As I see it the only solutions are ethnic cleansing or formal apartheid.
You might be right, but that's a pretty big leap. There are Israelis against settlements; there is public opinion in the rest of the world; the Trump administration is not necessarily permanent. Has the whole of Jerusalem ever been considered Israeli territory in the international community? I don't think all is lost.

If official recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital plays a role in the end-times fantasies of religious nuts? That's my biggest worry, because they are crazy and very well financed. And not just the Christian nuts, either. I'll be watching events, queasily.
 
Last edited:
Today was a very tense day. Everyone was very worried/scared/stressed about what Trump was going to say.

We had to wait until 8pm (Israel time) for Trump's live speech. The wait was nerve wracking. All my co-workers and friends said the same thing. Leave the U.S. embassy in Tel Aviv! We do NOT need more chaos and bloodshed in the region. We became more stressed as the wait wore on. Finally, to ease the tension we all said that Trump must be bluffing/putting on a show for his base, and that his announcement would be vague meaningless words that would change nothing, so we could then relax and forget about it.

Still, about 20 of us gathered after work to wait for the statement.

After Trump made his statement we were all stunned. We walked out of the room and no one said a word. That NEVER happens with Israelis. We always have something to say. But we were too shocked. We could not believe what he had said. But we know the chaos that he has now caused across the region.

I feel sick to my core. It is almost 11 pm and I have get up at 4am for work.

Thank you to those in this thread who are civil. The rest of you can continue talking about "nuking Jerusalem", not caring about how many deaths that would cause, it just makes you "feel better" to write it. For some sick reasons. You can also talk about your "expert knowledge" about Israel even though you have never lived here.

Some of my friends will die in the next days or weeks. It could be me. (I have no family left. None. They are all dead).

People will die, all because of Trump's decision----which we did not want.
 
When it comes to Israel/Palestine, there is no It's-pretty-obvious-if-you-think-about-it solution to be had.
Did those oil-wealthy Arab states ever try to buy back territory from Israel so Palestinians could have their own homeland? It would have rankled for sure, but was it ever proposed to use oil wealth in this way?
 
Zivan, what do you think of the official Israeli government position that Jerusalem is the capital of Israel?

Would you say you put more value in the opinion of the international community than in the resolutions of your own democratically-elected government?

Do you attribute any deaths to your government's position on Jerusalem? How many more deaths do you think will be caused by Trump's recognition of your government's position, beyond the deaths that were going to be caused anyway by your own government?

Do you attribute any deaths by the hands of Palestinian militants over Israeli policy to the Palestinian militants themselves?
 
No, I get that, I totally do. And my knowledge of history is woefully incomplete. But there wasn't much in Palestine to begin with, and Jews, fresh from the Holocaust, were determined to build a nation. (I don't know how determined they were to build it in Palestine, however). And this situation evolved into a multi-generational injustice - a tragedy - I agree. But it sometimes seems that Arabs in the region are their own worst enemies. Their uprisings ended up in more dead Palestinians and expanded Israeli territory. My theory is that coming from Europe, Zionists had some knowledge of how to organize, create a state, build infrastructure and affect public opinion. And they were very motivated. The Palestinian Arabs weren't stupid; they just did not have a lot of experience in organizing. And frankly, the existence of dispossessed Palestinian Arabs was a giant boon to the political fortunes of some Muslim leaders who used it to unite factions that otherwise hated each other. Sworn enemies needed those camps. And Trump has given them a huge gift.

Well they happened to be living in the land god gave to the jews that was their mistake after all. That is why taking it by force was the only logical option.
You might be right, but that's a pretty big leap. There are Israelis against settlements; there is public opinion in the rest of the world; the Trump administration is not necessarily permanent. Has the whole of Jerusalem ever been considered Israeli territory in the international community? I don't think all is lost.

If official recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital plays a role in the end-times fantasies of religious nuts? That's my biggest worry, because they are crazy and very well financed. And not just the Christian nuts, either. I'll be watching events, queasily.

The idea of a two state solution has been dead for a long time, you would be talking about forcibly relocating 10% of the israeli population out of the occupied territories. The settlements have succeeded in making the land israel. So the only solutions are recognizing it as an apartheid state or cleansing the palestinians to preserve the jewish ethnostate.

You would certainly happily give up all your land and your home to anyone who asked right?
 
Did those oil-wealthy Arab states ever try to buy back territory from Israel so Palestinians could have their own homeland? It would have rankled for sure, but was it ever proposed to use oil wealth in this way?

So we need to view israel as common thugs holding the palestinians for ransom?

So much for not negotiating with terrorists.
 
If official recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital plays a role in the end-times fantasies of religious nuts? That's my biggest worry, because they are crazy and very well financed. And not just the Christian nuts, either. I'll be watching events, queasily.


These advisers of Trump themselves seem to be kind of religious nuts. Kushner is very small-lipped in public, but isn't he a Lubavitcher? And Greenblatt and Friedman are apparently on record (I'll have to backcheck this) as being proponents of "Greater Israel", which in its full demand means they want the land between the Nile and Euphrates as God promised. This can only be reached by war of course.

Interesting op-ed by David Hearst:

Middle East Eye said:
[...] The support of Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud and religious nationalists from Jewish Home are a given, but they are wearily familiar. The exotic and temptingly alien support comes from a new generation of Gulf Arab superbrats - young, irreverent, dune bashing, selfie taking, in your face, and appearing in a coup near you.

Under Trump they have a formed an axis of Arab autocrats, whose geopolitical ambition is as large as their wallets. They really do think they have the power to impose their will not just on the shards of a Palestinian state, but on the region as a whole.

Under construction, at least in their minds, is a network of modern police states, each wearing a lip gloss of western liberalism. All see Likud as their natural partners, and Jared Kushner as their discreet interlocutor. [...]


Superbrats, I like that. But what would happen in a case of war? The first thing to go up in flames are their palaces and glass towers at the southern bank of the Persian gulf. And even with the (unlikely) support of US bleeding hearts on the ground, with a coalition of spoiled inbreds against the three regional 80 million nations with real armies - Iran, Turkey and Egypt, well, - let's hope cooler heads will prevail.
 
On the other hand this does raise the odds of Trumps signature war being in the middle east instead of Korea. Though both doesn't seem unlikely.
 
Did those oil-wealthy Arab states ever try to buy back territory from Israel so Palestinians could have their own homeland? It would have rankled for sure, but was it ever proposed to use oil wealth in this way?

It's called Jordan. They even annexed the West Bank, before going to war with Israel and losing it.
 
Today was a very tense day. Everyone was very worried/scared/stressed about what Trump was going to say.
Obviously, since I don't live in the region, my stake is not nearly as high as yours. But I too feel sick about the possibilities, so know that Israelis of your stripe aren't alone in your anxiety.

But are there other Israelis who think this is great? Who would prevail politically in Israel at this time?

People will die, all because of Trump's decision----which we did not want.
If precedence holds, plenty of them will be Palestinians.
 
Did those oil-wealthy Arab states ever try to buy back territory from Israel so Palestinians could have their own homeland? It would have rankled for sure, but was it ever proposed to use oil wealth in this way?


I doubt it. Syria, Lebanon and Egypt don't have all that much oil money. Also, there's the inescapable fact that Israel needs the Palestinian territories for defensive purposes. The Golan Heights are, um, high. They're hills looking down on the rest of Israel. Handing over the high ground would be tactically insane.

Still, I agree with your general point. Arab nations have happily sent arms and armor to the Palestinians when they could have used that money for civilian purposes. The reason is hate. It's that simple.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom