Three Orthodox Jews and a Coptic Christian walk into a Levantine Bar

I doubt it. Syria, Lebanon and Egypt don't have all that much oil money. Also, there's the inescapable fact that Israel needs the Palestinian territories for defensive purposes. The Golan Heights are, um, high. They're hills looking down on the rest of Israel. Handing over the high ground would be tactically insane.

Makes it easy to justify Russia's annexation of the crimea. Strategic goals win out and it is wrong to criticize russia for this. Might does make right.
 
How many are going to die because of this decision? I think it's pretty good odds that someone bombs something and declares it's revenge for this move.

No JREF prize for predicting that a lot of people are going to die because of this decision. Given the agenda of our fascist demagogue and unregistered sex offender-in-chief, it's not entirely crazy to suspect that might be the intent.
 
That would certainly explain my lack of sympathy for the Palestinians.
There are regular people, being used as pawns in dynamics that they can't control. In the 1960s the dispute was about territory. Territorial disputes can be resolved. Holy wars can't. It has become very convenient for some Arab and other Muslim nations to have this sore festering; it helps hard-liners on both sides. That includes Trump as well. I have sympathy for anyone caught up in that BS.

I hope you're not among the faithful End Times enthusiasts. You bring something to the board. But if that is where you're coming from, it taints any legitimate conservative points you might make.
 
Makes it easy to justify Russia's annexation of the crimea. Strategic goals win out and it is wrong to criticize russia for this. Might does make right.
Russia did vote for the resolution condemning settlements, though. In this case I'm somewhat relieved about their regional influence. Venal beats crazy religious in my book.
 
Israel is a sovereign nation-state. Jerusalem is their capital - which, as the only sovereign nation-state that controls any part of Jerusalem, is perfectly valid and entirely appropriate.

Now if only the anti-Semitic demagogues in neighboring nation-states (and the anti-Semitic demagogues elsewhere in the world for that matter, including the "Western" world) could be reasoned with. But you can't reason with the unreasonable, sad to say.
 
Zivan, what do you think of the official Israeli government position that Jerusalem is the capital of Israel?

Would you say you put more value in the opinion of the international community than in the resolutions of your own democratically-elected government?

Do you attribute any deaths to your government's position on Jerusalem? How many more deaths do you think will be caused by Trump's recognition of your government's position, beyond the deaths that were going to be caused anyway by your own government?

Do you attribute any deaths by the hands of Palestinian militants over Israeli policy to the Palestinian militants themselves?


I do not think you understand....

I, and everyone I know are in shock right now. Security has been stepped up. I just told a friend not to go to Jerusalem tomorrow because there may be road blocks and he will not be able to get back to work Sunday morning (work week here is Sun - thurs).

We have been told to not be in large groups anyway (difficult in a tiny country).

Everyone is in danger. I am numb.

And you expect me to get into a political discussion with you? Now???? While you are safe far away, and I am in danger?

You seem to have no empathy, or understand the situation on the ground here. Now.
 
So we need to view israel as common thugs holding the palestinians for ransom?

So much for not negotiating with terrorists.
So you're relying on the rule of so? I personally am not uniformly against negotiating with terrorists, even if I agreed with that description. It's just a form of asymmetrical warfare employed for achieving political goals. At least it used to be; now it seems to be violence for the hell of it. Or an orgasm for end-of-the-world types.

I just wondered if anyone had tried it. Territorial disputes can be resolved. Holy wars can't. How many deaths do you suppose Yasser Arafat caused? And were most of them Israeli or Palestinian? I get that you're angry but I don't cede the moral high ground to anyone in this dispute, except Israelis (and Arabs) committed to peacefully changing Israel's domestic policy re: occupied territories.

I can only hope that the rule of unintended consequences kicks in and heads off or at least mitigates the disaster this has the potential to be. Could anything cause Israel to walk back its claim to all of Jerusalem?

Are Trump's Saudi pals going to pat him on the back for this?
 
Today was a very tense day. Everyone was very worried/scared/stressed about what Trump was going to say.
`
Obviously, since I don't live in the region, my stake is not nearly as high as yours. But I too feel sick about the possibilities, so know that Israelis of your stripe aren't alone in your anxiety.
T
hank you for your kind words.

But are there other Israelis who think this is great? Who would prevail politically in Israel at this time?

I know (from the news) that that there are some Israelis who bizarrely think this is great. I do not know any personally. I asked my boss today (who is as sick/shocked about this as I am) if he had any friends/family that thought differently than him. He looked at me like he was shocked I would even ask such a thing and said they all think the same as him about it.

No one knows what will happen next politically.


People will die, all because of Trump's decision----which we did not want.
If precedence holds, plenty of them will be Palestinians.

The Palestinians have already planned "Three days of rage" and to target Israelis (that includes Arab Israelis). Westerners do not seem to care about deaths of Arabs if they are also Israeli citizens. That does not make sense to me.
 
Well they happened to be living in the land god gave to the jews that was their mistake after all. That is why taking it by force was the only logical option.
They were refugees who saw forming a Jewish state as the only possible means forward. I don't think they were relying on God so much as on statements made by the British government. And some of them probably weren't against alternatives to Palestine.

The idea of a two state solution has been dead for a long time, you would be talking about forcibly relocating 10% of the israeli population out of the occupied territories.
Then Trump didn't kill it, did he? And Israel has removed some settlers, there's no inherent reason to believe it can't be done.

The settlements have succeeded in making the land israel.
Not really.
WaPo: Israeli police begin forced removal of Amona settlers in the West Bank

So the only solutions are recognizing it as an apartheid state or cleansing the palestinians to preserve the jewish ethnostate.
Your imagination may not be the final word in what's possible.

You would certainly happily give up all your land and your home to anyone who asked right?
You understand what a load of straw this is, right?
 
Last edited:
No one knows what will happen next politically.


Best thing I would think is you get Netanyahoo out of the way over one of his corruption cases and present a friendlier face to the region. I understand you people are shocked, and thanks for sharing your view with us, but I also think the really important players are wary of what is played here and nobody of them wants war.
 
Israel is a sovereign nation-state. Jerusalem is their capital - which, as the only sovereign nation-state that controls any part of Jerusalem, is perfectly valid and entirely appropriate.
Sovereignty is not a one-way street. It has to be recognized to mean much. The rest of the world does not agree that the sovereign state of Israel includes all of Jerusalem.

Now if only the anti-Semitic demagogues in neighboring nation-states (and the anti-Semitic demagogues elsewhere in the world for that matter, including the "Western" world) could be reasoned with.
The anti-Semitic demagogues would be screwed without their anti-Israel narrative. They need it to exist. For very reasonable reasons. But assuming I'm wrong. How would you go about reasoning with them over the issue of Israel? "Israel has nukes, you don't, shut up?" I don't think that's a solution. "Hitler took their house, so they're taking your house, see? It all works out!"

But you can't reason with the unreasonable, sad to say.
And that includes those Israelis who think that they should occupy as much of the Middle East as they want, because they want it. You think those settlers are being "reasonable"? No, they are being deliberately provocative, and I don't really blame them, but they are dangerous ideologues. They don't have to live in trailers on the West Bank. The situation is a tragedy, born of an earlier tragedy, and of long-fallen empires, and who wins? Hard-liners on both sides. Defense contractors. The individuals getting pieces of the $100B or so Germany has paid in reparations.

I'd love to see Jews and Muslims unite to fleece evangelical Christians with tours of so-called holy sites. That would be a reasonable solution, IMO.
 
Thank you to those in this thread who are civil. The rest of you can continue talking about "nuking Jerusalem", not caring about how many deaths that would cause, it just makes you "feel better" to write it. For some sick reasons.
My apologies. That was over the line. That was my cynicism about the endless "peace process" that I don't think I'll see a successful conclusion in my lifetime (nor yours I guess). And the status of Jerusalem is one of the principal stumbling points there. FWIW, I didn't mean casualties with that, just that no-one could get the place.
 
Last edited:
Would it really be beneficial to Israel or its leaders if five million US Jews would immigrate to Israel?
In the 1940s and 1950s, the Mizrahim provided cheap labour that the Zionist founders found themselves too good for (and the Mossad helped a hand with that migration with bombing campaigns in Iraq and Egypt). Ditto the Russian Jews that migrated in the 1990s. But well-educated, good earning US Jews? They'd only be competition.

Netenyahu would use it to project himself as a new Ezra, and if they brought their capital with them just think what it would do for house prices, a massive boost for the property-owning classes he actually represents.

The Blood and Soil settler movement would adore the idea, so Netenyahu couldn't say a word in opposition to it without going the way of Rabin.
 
That's just a bit of play for the gallery. Amona is an outpost, an "illegal" settlement of only 200 people that's not endorsed by the government. The total number of inhabitants in the settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem is about 800,000.

I'd love to see Jews and Muslims unite to fleece evangelical Christians with tours of so-called holy sites. That would be a reasonable solution, IMO.
:thumbsup:
 
My apologies. That was my cynicism about the endless "peace process" that I don't think I'll see a successful conclusion in my lifetime (nor yours I guess). And the status of Jerusalem is one of the principal stumbling points there. FWIW, I didn't mean casualties with that, just that no-one could get the place.
The peace process has been a sham after Rabin's murder. He made the mistake of actually seeking peace before total victory, and paid the price.

I see a conflict arising within Israel, between the Blood and Soil movement and the Israelis who pay and occasionally fight for them. Another intifada will not be popular with the latter group, who will lay the blame on Netenyahu. This is a purely symbolic move, of no practical value, creating unknowable risks for Israel and Israelis just when Netenyahu is under the cosh. What a slimeball that man is.

A perfect pairing with Trump, of course.
 
Last edited:
Makes it easy to justify Russia's annexation of the crimea. Strategic goals win out and it is wrong to criticize russia for this. Might does make right.


Dude, what?

First of all, I said it was one consideration, not the only consideration.

Second, has Russia been under constant threat of attack from Crimea for seventy years? Did Crimea invade Russia on the holiest day of the Russian year?

False equivalency is false.
 
Dude, what?

First of all, I said it was one consideration, not the only consideration.

Second, has Russia been under constant threat of attack from Crimea for seventy years? Did Crimea invade Russia on the holiest day of the Russian year?

False equivalency is false.
Do you really believe that a clique of European Jews defended themselves out of Europe and into possession of so much Palestinian land and property, while the aggression has all been Arab? Don't you find that bizarre?

The Balfour Declaration is a century old, and was predicted to cause a century of conflict : that was a rhetorical century, of course, but not inaccurate. And there's no end in sight, because no Israeli leader can declare peace with the nationalist project incomplete, which it is as long as any Arabs remain in the Land. From Dan to Beersheba, as promised. Blood and Soil and God, what a toxic combination, and with Netenyahu involved you can add "and Profit".
 
Do you really believe that a clique of European Jews defended themselves out of Europe and into possession of so much Palestinian land and property, while the aggression has all been Arab? Don't you find that bizarre?


What the hell are you talking about? I didn't say anything even remotely like this. I said that Israel's desire to keep the Golan Heights has a tactical component because they've been attacked from that border before. To my knowledge, Israel was not the aggressor in any war ever.

In any case, it's historically wrong to say that Jews took possession of Palestinian land. Palestine was an absolute wasteland when both Jews and Arabs starting building a presence at the turn of the 20th century.
 
Please forgive my cynicism, but I think that Trump just trolled the bulk of "the Arab world" which is in fact a fractious bunch of quarreling narcissists, and about 2/3 of the useful idiots who go along with the narrative that holds Israel to be wrong by default simply because the sun comes up. That covers most of Europe, and a variety of noise makers in the UN.

And having trolled them all, he sits back and watches for the reaction. But unlike very talented trolls, he'll not be able to STFU and just watch the fun. He'll twit some silly nonsense in a few days ...

Bibi thinks Trump has his back. I think that's about as funny as this joke gets.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom