Three Orthodox Jews and a Coptic Christian walk into a Levantine Bar

You really are clueless and have no idea what you are talking about regarding the Israeli/Palestinian issues.
Do you also have an actual argument against what ponderingturtle said?

Because that's exactly what the settlements are - facts on the ground that are very hard, if not impossible to reverse. All Israeli governments have clearly said that large settlement blocks like Ariel are unnegotiable and must remain Israeli in a final settlement. And as these large blocks run along most of the Green Line between Israel and the West Bank, there's also little opportunity for compensation elsewhere. Or it must be Lieberman's proposal to give Arab villages in the Galilee to the Palestinian state. :rolleyes:
 
Exactly god gave the entire region to the jewish people and they will take it no matter how long the current residents have been living there. It is just like how the trail of tears was a high point in american history, Jackson wouldn't let laws of man or morals stand in the way of getting the land god had given to the american people from the savages. Same thing with taking Jerusalem from the muslims, Israel would never let boarders stand in the way of what is theirs by grace of god.
More straw than a Bethlehem manger. I'm not sure who exactly you're arguing with but it's not me.
 
The misspellings of “borders” as “boarders” in this thread are entertaining. When I reas that I imagine that the Palestinians are just renting rooms at Yitzak’s boardinghouse awaiting a settlement deal.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Well, I guess I don't have to tell you the consequences so far, nothing unexpected or too dramatic.

As to the broader thread topic though, Trump has, also on Wednesday, called on Saudi Arabia to immediately and completely lift the blockade of Yemen. Long overdue and very important as the humanitarian situation is absolutely grave.
 
What the hell are you talking about? I didn't say anything even remotely like this. I said that Israel's desire to keep the Golan Heights has a tactical component because they've been attacked from that border before.
Your argument is that, having stolen the coastal lands, Israel is justified in stealing more land to secure the proceeds. Where's the limit to that?

To my knowledge, Israel was not the aggressor in any war ever.
Which is to say a clique of Europen Jews defended themselves from 1890's Europe into possession of the lands and property of so many native Palestinians in 1949, said natives mostly being expelled, living in strange lands amongst strangers, penniless and dependent on the UN for shelter and food.

In fact the Yishuv launched a long-planned war of conquest and ethnic cleansing in which they had some success, particularly against unarmed civilians, but ultimately failed to complete on the first attempt, despite outnumbering and out-gunning what armed opposition there was. Hence the second and more successful effort in 1967.

Out of interest, how do you imagine it happened?

In any case, it's historically wrong to say that Jews took possession of Palestinian land. Palestine was an absolute wasteland when both Jews and Arabs starting building a presence at the turn of the 20th century.
Rubbish. Palestine was one of the most prosperous districts of the Ottoman Empire for centuries. It was also the most urbanised and most literate. You have fallen for Zionist propaganda.
 
Except he has said he would accept a two state
solution...
and afterwards repeated that he wouldn't, just to make sure everybody understood he didn't mean it. A genuine act of such profound betrayal would have seen him long dead by now.
... and the Likud platform was redrafted long ago to remove that plank.
The people who joined Likud when it was the fundamental plank (many of them because it was, of course) haven't changed their minds, and nobody think it's anything other than window-dressing for people like you to reference.
 
Don't know if this will be the end of it but violence erupting is hurting mostly Palestinians. Only one reported dead - a Palestinian. I guess I can understand the anger that leads to spontaneous riots, but these really weren't spontaneous as far as I can tell. CNN reported that Friday was to be the culmination but I read somewhere that Friday was going to be the beginning.

At the risk of drawing more straw-man attacks, I really have to wonder how long it will take Palestinians to realizing that uprisings and attacks are not helping. Which of course means I must be OK with Israel seizing land because God gave it to them. Just to save a certain poster the trouble of playing that broken record again.

Off to see what Al Jazeera says.

ETA: Two Palestinians killed. I just hope it doesn't get worse.
 
Last edited:
At the risk of drawing more straw-man attacks, I really have to wonder how long it will take Palestinians to realizing that uprisings and attacks are not helping.


Well what if your grandfather already figured out that nothing in his power seems to help? What would that do to your decision-making process?
 
So Donald Trump is a bad man because - unlike his predecessors - he implemented the clear will of Congress ?

And what happened to these "Days of Rage" ? Any more than happens every Friday in East Jerusalem and the Occupied Territories ?

Is it only me that thinks the Arab protests about the embassy move to be somewhat muted and "pro forma" ?

The UN never recognised any Arab claim on any part of Jerusalem. It was supposed to be a 'corpus seperandum'. So why is it then that Trump is accused of attempting to "change the status" of the city, whereas the 1988 PLO claim on East Jerusalem as their capital was met with silent acceptance from the UN ?

Here's what I think. If the Israeli's where to formally surrender Jerusalem to the PLO, move all their citizens out, and create a new capital next to a rock in the Negev desert, then... SUDDENLY... that rock would be revealed by the PLO as being the centre of Palestinian culture, and "Islamic scholars" would reveal that Muhammed once urinated on that rock, making it the 4th most holy site in the Islamic World, and that it was another example of the injustices against the Palestinian People, and there must be Days Of Rage against the vile Zionist feet trampling the Noble Damp Rock.

And so on, and so forth.

Sod 'em all, and well done Donald Trump.
 
Last edited:
I think you are missing something here Roofgardner. Prior to the war of 1967, East Jerusalem was part of the state of Jordan. The international community and the UN recognise that the territories Israel occupies as a result of their success in that war are occupied illegally. In the 50 years since there has been no peace treaty and no resolution to the problem of Israel's activities in the illegally occupied lands such as settlement building or the security wall. The status of East Jerusalem should be handled as part of a final peace settlement between the state of Israel and the Palestinian people who were dispossessed during the war of 1967. For the Orange Clown in the White House to make this unilateral declaration breaks all common sense rules of diplomatic procedure as recognised by most of the world, including the USA's traditional allies in the West. That he is doing it largely at the behest of extremist Christians who hope to speed the coming of Armageddon and the Rapture is even more worrying.
 
... that he is doing it largely at the behest of extremist Christians who hope to speed the coming of Armageddon and the Rapture is even more worrying.
I doubt that. I think Netenyahu asked Trump to do it, and Jared Kushner, who is Jewish and therefore understands Israel stuff, said it was a good idea. And Obama hadn't done it. A score for Trump.

Netenyahu got a distraction when he's feeling a serious need for one, but I doubt it's really working for him.
 
'A gift to extremists': Pence's Jerusalem speech draws Palestinian anger

Middle East Eye said:
[...] Pence, who arrived in Israel late on Sunday, gave a speech laden with religious references to the Israeli parliament, the Knesset, on Monday afternoon, in which he announced that the United States was officially planning to move its embassy to Israel in Jerusalem by the end of 2019.

“In the story of the Jews, we’ve always seen the story of America,” Pence, a fervent conservative Christian, told Israeli parliamentarians, in a speech which fell firmly in line with the Evangelical Zionist narrative drawing a parallel between the American pilgrims and the Biblical Jewish exodus.

In a statement, Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) Secretary-General Saeb Erekat denounced Pence’s “messianic discourse” as a “gift to extremists.” [...]


The text about the "Evangelical Zionist narrative" linked in the quote is pretty informative if you aren't familiar with the topic. Keep barf bag ready.
 
'A gift to extremists': Pence's Jerusalem speech draws Palestinian anger

Except that literally everything draws Palestinian anger. That's the problem, is that their "moderates" qualify as extremists by any rational scale.

At some point to get to peace you need to figure out what that looks like to you and move towards it. That Palestinians never do that is why many people think they don't want peace.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom