Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

It would not have been approved if it was determined that the Bentham Paper findings had insufficient research to back them up.

Your amateur sideline opinions have no credibility, especially given the extent of your bias.

MM
Point flew over your head again.

We were talking about the ability to duplicate the study. No one was talking about backing up their findings. Millette used the same methods used to isolate the chips as described in their paper. Now they claim their not the same because he didn't use methods that were not described (only talked about outside of the work)

See how that is?
 
He could have further separated his larger magnetically isolated chips by taking a quick 'n easy resistance readings.

He could have heated the chips to +430C without involving DSC.

Many chips were removed from the WTC dust with a magnet, and because the majority appeared to be paint or other materials, there is a strong likelihood that the chips Dr. Millette selected from his pile for further testing were not a good match for those described as chips of interest by the Bentham Paper authors.

And if do not think a magnet would have picked up a large number of chips, try drawing a magnet through some ordinary beach sand and observe the results.

MM

This is complete BS.

The fact is Harrit, Jones, and the rest assumed ALL the red/gray chips were thermitic in nature and tested them to prove that very fact. Go read every single one of their accounts and statements. Never once do they state in their paper that ANY of the red/gray chips failed to produce thermitic results or fail to show a thermitic composition.

Show me one quote from the Bentham paper that states any of the magnetically attracted, red/gray chips were tested and found to be paint or other material and NOT thermitic in nature.

You can't.

This is why I keep getting vague answers from Jones and Harrit about which chips they actually performed the resistivity tests on. I asked both Harrit and Jones if they ran the resistivitiy tests on all the chips in the paper. No response. They avoidied the question like the plague. Harrit says they ran the resitivity tests on RANDOM red/gray chips and those were all low resistance (paint according to them). Nowhere does Harrit or anyone else state that ANY of the red/gray chips from their initial isolation pile showed high resistivity, thus being paint or other material. How is that even possible? The odds of randomly selecting thermitic chips every time using a random selction method is astronomical. I'd be going to Vegas if I were them.

This is the exact reason they needed to get samples and characteristics of paint from OUTSIDE the isolation pile. They are saying that ALL the magnetically attracted, red/gray chips are thermitic.

You continually say they separated the initial isolated pile into low and high resistivity piles. Why did they not get a red/gray, magnetically attracted PAINT chip and compare it's resitance to a thermitic red/gray, magnetically attracted chip? According to you they were right there in front of them.

Can you explain why, if the resistivity test was so important in selecting the correct chips, Harrit, during his Toronto Hearings video, never mentions the resistivity test when he passes the bag of dust around to the people in the audience? He supplies them with a magnet. That's it.

So MM, go find me any quote or test result from anyone responsible for that paper that says at least ONE red/gray, magneticaly attracted chip was NOT themritic in nature, but was in fact paint or other material.

This, in my eyes, is a HUGE problem for them which is why they won't answer a direct question and continue to beat around the bush.

If they admit they didn't perform the resisitivity tests on all their chips tested in the paper, then they admit that Millette tested the correct chips and they look like liars.

If they say they DID perform the resisitivity tests to seaparate the red/gray chips from the intial isolation pile, then they look like fools because they had paint chips right in front of them to test, but optioned to go with external samples. Complete idiocy.

Furthermore, why was the resistivity test explanation towards the back of the paper and not in the isolation portion of the paper? Why did Harrit, in one of his emails to me, refer to it a "supplementary" information gained from "random" red/gray chips?
 
More proof that Harrit and his group think they proved that ALL the red/gray, magnetically attracted chips that they isolated, were all thermitic.

Quote from the beginning of the paper:
In June 2007, Dr. Steven Jones observed distinctive bi-layered chips, with both a red and a gray layer, in a sample of the WTC dust. Initially, it was suspected these might be dried paint chips, but after closer inspection and testing, it was shown that this was not the case. Further testing was then performed on the red/gray chips in an attempt to ascertain their composition and properties.

Does anyone see any distinction between them finding thermitic red/gray chips and red/gray chips of another material?

The hilited sentence says they wanted to ascertain their compostion and properties. If they did indeed find different types of thermtic chips (paint, thermitic, other materials), then why were the thermitic properties the only ones published in the paper?
 
MM,

Taken directly from the Bentham paper's conclusion:
Based on these observations, we conclude that the red layer of the red/gray chips we have discovered in the WTC dust is active, unreacted thermitic material, incorporating nanotechnology, and is a highly energetic pyrotechnic or explosive material.

If they did indeed find different kinds of red/gray, magnetically attracted chips (paint, themritic, and other types), why did they not state that in their conclusion above?

Why do they explicitly state the red layer of the red/gray chips is un-reacted thermitic material, and not say that SOME of the red/gray chips were un-reacted thermitic material?

I'll tell you why.

It's because they assumed that ALL the red/gray chips were thermitic from the start.

That's why their paper reads the way it does. That's why you can't find ONE quote that says they found or tested any red/gray chips that WEREN'T thermitic.
 
MM,

Can you tell me why, in the quote below from the Bentham paper, they make no mention whatsoever about the resisitivity test as a from of isolation from the other chips, yet they mention the magnet and red/gray layer criteria mentioned in the isolation potion at the beginning of the paper?
At approximately 2.5 mm in length, the chip in Fig. (2a) was one of the larger chips collected. The mass of this chip was approximately 0.7 mg. All of the chips used in the study had a gray layer and a red layer and were attracted by a magnet. The inset image in Fig. (2d) shows the chip in cross section, which reveals the gray layer. The gray layer is also partially visible in Fig. (2b). Similarities between the samples are already evident from these photographs.
 
Actually they do (maybe not a good explanation but it's an explanation).

Variations in peak height as well as yield estimates are not surprising, since the mass used to determine the scale of the signal, shown in the DSC traces, included the mass of the gray layer. The gray layer was found to consist mostly of iron oxide so that it probably does not contribute to the exotherm, and yet this layer varies greatly in mass from chip to chip.
​
(Section 3 p. 19)
Just to clear up any confusion. They are explaining the difference between the exotherms (peaks) at around 430°C and their analysis is valid. I was talking about the endotherms (troughs) for two of curves between approximately 570°C and 680°C.
 
They have met the burden of proof by having their research findings published in a peer reviewed paper.

The "burden of proof" is on equally credible scientists to produce a peer reviewed paper that successfully debunks those findings.

I am sorry but your unrelated rant only qualifies as bs.

MM

Paraphrasing the great Inigo Montoya:

I use those words - I know what they mean.

You use those words - you do not know what they mean.:D
 
Just to clear up any confusion. They are explaining the difference between the exotherms (peaks) at around 430°C and their analysis is valid. I was talking about the endotherms (troughs) for two of curves between approximately 570°C and 680°C.
Oops, I misread. You're right of course.
 
I had another new revelation this morning: I think I have found the probable reason why Jones thinks he found elemental Al in the MEK-chip - and is honest about it!


To recap:

The MEK-Chip, presented in Fig. 12-18, was a red-gray chip that most likey was chipped off the WTC perimeter columns, as the red layer is almost certainly Tnemec primer, according to the XEDS-Spectrum of the entire chip in Fig. 14.

Fig. 16-18 are three SEM-EDS-Spectra from different, albeit unspecified spots on that chip, taken after it had been soaked in MEK. Strangely, while Fig 14 was recorded at 20 keV, as most other spectra in the paper, and Fig 16, was, too, Jones did Fig 17 at only 10 keV, and Fig. 18 at 15 keV. No reason is given.

Of particular interes is Fig 17 (10 keV), since it shows mainly a large Al-peak, much smaller C- and O-peaks, and tiny traces of Mg, Fe and Si. A quantitative interpretation of that result would indeed show too many Al-atoms and too few O-atoms, such that a significant proportion of the Al would have to be elemental. There is no elemental Al in Tnemec, and it is pretty unlikely to find small particles of Al contaminating the surface of such a chip.

So I have already suggested that perhaps this spectrum somehow picks up signal mostly from the sample holder, which in such electron microscopes is often an aluminium stub. Either the electron beam was pointed at the sample holder outright, or this is somehow a "reflection" of stub-signal, reflecting from the "steep" (almost perpendicular to the holder surface) edge of the chip on the lower left as shown in Fig 15, the EDS-map of a part of that chip after soaking:



But I have wondered: Jones couldn't be that stupid!? He'd have to see and know somehow that his beam is pointed at an inopportune spot - he'd have to be aware of the deceptive nature, not?

But then it struck me:


Fig 17 was recorded at 10 keV
Fig 15 was recorded at 10 keV! (the EDS map)



And this is what I think happened here:

When you record an EDS-map, your SEM machine basically records many individual EDS-spectra from many spots - of which we can think of as "pixels". So if the SEM scans, say, 200 x 150 "pixels", it actually records 30,000 EDS-spectra for 30,000 spots - that goes into the raw data. From that raw data, software computes the colored map images.
As we can see in Fig. 15, the raw data included raw data, i.e. individual EDS-spectra, for spots outside of the chip, many of which are shown in purple as "contain Al". Fewer contain high O or C, fewer still high Fe, and none high Si.

I think that Jones did not pick a "region of high aluminum concentration on the MEK-soaked red chip" to run a seperate EDS spectrum on when he obtained Fig. 17; rather; I think he just dug into the raw data from the EDS mapping, grabbed the individual spectrum with the highest Al-count or -proportion, and that's what he presented. I think it is well possible that he never checked where on the EDS-map that spectrum was from, and never became aware he had picked one from outside the chip!


(ETA: Two minor questions open in my mind:
a) Why doesn't the Al-map show Al everywhere outside of the chip? -> Perhaps the equipment, running in standard configuration, is smart enough to filter out most of the signal that's not from specimens - but obviously it records some of such signal - it's clearly there in the raw data, not very obtrusive, and available to be picked
b) Why 15 keV for Fig. 18? That spectrum also shows P and Cl, which otherwise don't appear anywhere else. I consider that an inconsequential quirk for the time being.)
 
Last edited:
Oystein: After the first reading, I'm not sure if I understand.

You think that the spectrum on Fig. 17 was taken in the area outside the chip? And all authors overlooked this, although this spectrum had such a crucial importance for their conclusions?
 
Oystein: After the first reading, I'm not sure if I understand.

You think that the spectrum on Fig. 17 was taken in the area outside the chip? And all authors overlooked this, although this spectrum had such a crucial importance for their conclusions?

Yes.

The colored dots outside of the chip in Fig 15 prove that the SEM-EDS run produced XEDS-data for points outside of the chip.

The maps themselves show that what the device measured outside of the chip was mostly Al, some C and O, and little of everything else.

Again, when you tell your SEM-machine to create an EDS-map, it really creates individual EDS-spectra for many many points - probably with a low number of individual electrons fired or x-rays counted, to save time. When you do a dedicated EDS for a spot, you probably count thousands of x-rays - 10,000 perhaps. Depends a little; I understand that in some modes, the machine stops as soon as the first edge energy level has reached a count of, say, 1,000 or 2,000 x-ray photons. When you do an EDS-map, and you scan possibly thousands of individual spots, your total x-ray count per spot is going to be much lower - perhaps 100, that order of magnitude. With a low count, you will surely catch the dominant elements, while creating larger statistical variation, possibly missing (or overestimating!) traces - and also you get much less noise ("Bremsstrahlung", that broad, low hill of noise that you see in all spectra, but seems to be almost absent past the Si-signal in Fig 17)


So when Jones ran the EDS-map, his equipment produced, as raw data, many (thousands, probably) of individual EDS-spectra, each with a relatively low count of x-rays. I am sure there is a way to dig into the raw data and pick out the spot with the highest count for Al. Pull it out, plot it as an EDS spectrum, and voilà, that's Fig. 17.

The raw data of course also contains positional data, but if you forget to copy-and paste it to your notebook, or to even look at it, you might miss the fact it's not even on your specimen, but from one of those bright purple pixels outside that are shown in the Al-map! You see, raw data is just a long columns of numbers. Some of those numbers denote the spot position and size. You can look at those numbers all day long and not get if they do not correspond to a spot on the specimen. You'd have to do an extra step and tell your software to show you where that spot is relative to the BSE image that the maps are superimposed with.

And all the other authors won't catch it, if Jones passes the data along without the positional information.
 
Last edited:
I had another new revelation this morning: I think I have found the probable reason why Jones thinks he found elemental Al in the MEK-chip - and is honest about it!


To recap:

The MEK-Chip, presented in Fig. 12-18, was a red-gray chip that most likey was chipped off the WTC perimeter columns, as the red layer is almost certainly Tnemec primer, according to the XEDS-Spectrum of the entire chip in Fig. 14.

Fig. 16-18 are three SEM-EDS-Spectra from different, albeit unspecified spots on that chip, taken after it had been soaked in MEK. Strangely, while Fig 14 was recorded at 20 keV, as most other spectra in the paper, and Fig 16, was, too, Jones did Fig 17 at only 10 keV, and Fig. 18 at 15 keV. No reason is given.

Of particular interes is Fig 17 (10 keV), since it shows mainly a large Al-peak, much smaller C- and O-peaks, and tiny traces of Mg, Fe and Si. A quantitative interpretation of that result would indeed show too many Al-atoms and too few O-atoms, such that a significant proportion of the Al would have to be elemental. There is no elemental Al in Tnemec, and it is pretty unlikely to find small particles of Al contaminating the surface of such a chip.

So I have already suggested that perhaps this spectrum somehow picks up signal mostly from the sample holder, which in such electron microscopes is often an aluminium stub. Either the electron beam was pointed at the sample holder outright, or this is somehow a "reflection" of stub-signal, reflecting from the "steep" (almost perpendicular to the holder surface) edge of the chip on the lower left as shown in Fig 15, the EDS-map of a part of that chip after soaking:

[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/th_ActiveThermiticMaterial_Fig15_a-d.jpg[/qimg]

But I have wondered: Jones couldn't be that stupid!? He'd have to see and know somehow that his beam is pointed at an inopportune spot - he'd have to be aware of the deceptive nature, not?

But then it struck me:


Fig 17 was recorded at 10 keV
Fig 15 was recorded at 10 keV! (the EDS map)



And this is what I think happened here:

When you record an EDS-map, your SEM machine basically records many individual EDS-spectra from many spots - of which we can think of as "pixels". So if the SEM scans, say, 200 x 150 "pixels", it actually records 30,000 EDS-spectra for 30,000 spots - that goes into the raw data. From that raw data, software computes the colored map images.
As we can see in Fig. 15, the raw data included raw data, i.e. individual EDS-spectra, for spots outside of the chip, many of which are shown in purple as "contain Al". Fewer contain high O or C, fewer still high Fe, and none high Si.

I think that Jones did not pick a "region of high aluminum concentration on the MEK-soaked red chip" to run a seperate EDS spectrum on when he obtained Fig. 17; rather; I think he just dug into the raw data from the EDS mapping, grabbed the individual spectrum with the highest Al-count or -proportion, and that's what he presented. I think it is well possible that he never checked where on the EDS-map that spectrum was from, and never became aware he had picked one from outside the chip!


(ETA: Two minor questions open in my mind:
a) Why doesn't the Al-map show Al everywhere outside of the chip? -> Perhaps the equipment, running in standard configuration, is smart enough to filter out most of the signal that's not from specimens - but obviously it records some of such signal - it's clearly there in the raw data, not very obtrusive, and available to be picked
b) Why 15 keV for Fig. 18? That spectrum also shows P and Cl, which otherwise don't appear anywhere else. I consider that an inconsequential quirk for the time being.)




There may be several reasons why there are few, or no counts for Al, in x ray maps from the specimen holder.
When the specimen is mounted, and if it is a non conducting, or a poor conductor it is usual to paint the entire surface of the stub with an aqueous solution of graphite, a commercial version of which is called Aquadag, the specimen would then be affixed to the stub before the solution has dried.

The Al will then be opaque to the electron beam. Painting carefully around the edges will ensure that the best possible contact is made with the holder. This procedure will also help to reduce surface charging.

Harrit Jones et al state the following.

For general surface analysis in the SEM, dust samples
were mounted to carbon conductive tabs.

These tabs, may, or may not have been selected to cover all, or part of the Al specimen holder.

Reducing the gun voltage would indicate that charging might have been a problem.

Charging will certainly affect the X ray mapping results.

Surface topography will affect the quality of any X ray analysis.

It may be of interest to read just how difficult it is to get really good results from specimens containing Oxygen.

Interestingly this report was produced by NIST

http://www.google.se/url?sa=t&rct=j...scq9NZsaoj2Ju9XOQ&sig2=pm8lc_3M5Am8PbkcJAFzrQ

Carbon conductive tabs
http://www.emsdiasum.com/microscopy/products/sem/conductive.asp


One thing though, in Fig 15 the Carbon map, no Carbon is evident outside the chip.
 
Last edited:
Thanls Peter.

Nit sure I understand everything, and its consequences, yet :blush:

No C? :confused:


The second link gives me a Error 404
 
"In fact, I suspect that Fig. 17 is the result of improper handling. The pedestal on which the specimen is mounted in the SEM-XEDS machine tyically is made of aluminium, and I suspect that somehow Jones picked up Al-signal from the pedestal when he focused on the very edge of the chip. Remember, Fig 15a shows Al peculiarly concentrated on that edge, and even shows lots of Al outside of the chip! Alternatively, the fact that these egdes are far from being oriented perpendicularly to the line of sight of the instrument is a problem - this geometric property influences the measurement in difficult to gauge degrees. Ideally, the surface that you scan ought to be flat, smooth and perpendicular to your electron beam or x-ray-detector's line of sight. None of this is the case here."

"The colored dots outside of the chip in Fig. 15 prove that the SEM-EDS run produced XEDS-data for points outside of the chip.

The maps themselves show that what the device measured outside of the chip was mostly Al, some C and O, and little of everything else.

Again, when you tell your SEM-machine to create an EDS-map, it really creates individual EDS-spectra for many many points - probably with a low number of individual electrons fired or x-rays counted, to save time. When you do a dedicated EDS for a spot, you probably count thousands of x-rays - 10,000 perhaps. Depends a little; I understand that in some modes, the machine stops as soon as the first edge energy level has reached a count of, say, 1,000 or 2,000 x-ray photons. When you do an EDS-map, and you scan possibly thousands of individual spots, your total x-ray count per spot is going to be much lower - perhaps 100, that order of magnitude. With a low count, you will surely catch the dominant elements, while creating larger statistical variation, possibly missing (or overestimating!) traces - and also you get much less noise ("Bremsstrahlung", that broad, low hill of noise that you see in all spectra, but seems to be almost absent past the Si-signal in Fig. 17)


So when Jones ran the EDS-map, his equipment produced, as raw data, many (thousands, probably) of individual EDS-spectra, each with a relatively low count of x-rays. I am sure there is a way to dig into the raw data and pick out the spot with the highest count for Al. Pull it out, plot it as an EDS spectrum, and voilà, that's Fig. 17.

The raw data of course also contains positional data, but if you forget to copy-and paste it to your notebook, or to even look at it, you might miss the fact it's not even on your specimen, but from one of those bright purple pixels outside that are shown in the Al-map! You see, raw data is just a long columns of numbers. Some of those numbers denote the spot position and size. You can look at those numbers all day long and not get if they do not correspond to a spot on the specimen. You'd have to do an extra step and tell your software to show you where that spot is relative to the BSE image that the maps are superimposed with.

And all the other authors won't catch it, if Jones passes the data along without the positional information.
"

You are still trying to prove that you can do better research by just sitting in front of your computer performing amateur speculation..

Bentham Paper said:
"The next XEDS spectrum (Fig. 17) was acquired from a region that showed a high concentration of aluminum. Using a conventional quantification routine, it was found that the aluminum significantly exceeded the oxygen present (approximately a 3:1 ratio). Thus, while some of the aluminum may be oxidized, there is insufficient oxygen present to account for all of the aluminum; some of the aluminum must therefore exist in elemental form in the red material. This is an important result. Aluminum particles are covered with a layer of aluminum oxide irrespective of size, thus it is reasonable to find a significant oxygen content with the aluminum, given the very high surface area to volume ratio of these very fine particles."

benthamfig15acfig17.jpg


There are strong Al readings across the chip and not just on the extreme edge.

MM
 
Last edited:
You are still trying to prove that you can do better research by just sitting in front of your computer performing amateur speculation..

[qimg]http://img534.imageshack.us/img534/1419/benthamfig15acfig17.jpg[/qimg]

There are strong Al readings across the chip and not just on the extreme edge.

MM

Afraid he might find something?
 
You are still trying to prove that you can do better research by just sitting in front of your computer performing amateur speculation..

[qimg]http://img534.imageshack.us/img534/1419/benthamfig15acfig17.jpg[/qimg]

There are strong Al readings across the chip and not just on the extreme edge.

MM

MM, which source tells you that the EDX spectum of a region in which "aluminum had a high concentration" was taken "across the chip"?

And why is there such a little amount of silicon in Fg 17 if the spectra was taken "across the chip"?
 
"MM, which source tells you that the EDX spectum of a region in which "aluminum had a high concentration" was taken "across the chip"?

And why is there such a little amount of silicon in Fg 17 if the spectra was taken "across the chip"?
"

I fail to see your point?

Bentham Paper said:
"Focusing the electron beam on a region rich in silicon, located in Fig. (15e), we find silicon and oxygen and very little else (Fig. 16). Evidently the solvent has disrupted the matrix holding the various particles, allowing some migration and separation of the components. This is a significant result for it means that the aluminum and silicon are not bound chemically."

benthamfig15aefig.jpg


Would it make you happier if I said significant other locations across the chip?

Fig. 15(c) Al and Fig. 15(e) Si would seem to be self-explanatory once you compare them to the Fig. 15(a) Reference

Quibble much?

MM
 
Thanls Peter.

Nit sure I understand everything, and its consequences, yet :blush:

No C? :confused:


The second link gives me a Error 404


Mr. Oystein states.
(ETA: Two minor questions open in my mind:

a) Why doesn't the Al-map show Al everywhere outside of the chip?

If you don’t want the beam to see/excite the Al. specimen holder, cover it with graphite, Aquadag, or Carbon covers. They are also used to present a really nice black background for the specimen.

Harrit Jones et al state the following.

For general surface analysis in the SEM, dust samples
were mounted to carbon conductive tabs.

The Harrit Jones et al paper, figure 15, shows the maps for Fe, Al, and O. The same maps you have posted.

Note the Al. map. If the Al specimen holder was not covered with Graphite or Carbon, there would be less atomic number contrast between the Al stub, and the Al in the chip, but because there is contrast means the Al. specimen holder could be covered with something, or that part of the specimen holder is in shadow due to some specimen, EDX detector geometry problem, but here I speculate a bit.

The carbon cover tabs are not really important, I just included them to show how they look.The link below should work.

http://www.emsdiasum.com/microscopy/products/sem/conductive.aspx#77825
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom