Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Hmm ok, Peter, so the stub was most probably covered with carbon.

Still, the EDS-maps shows many spots with some Al outside of the chip, and fewer with O and C, fewer still with Fe, right?

Is my logic correct:

  1. Since Jones's software plotted dots for Al outside of the specimen, it recorded some raw EDS data with x-ray-counts for Al-K-alpha for locations outside of the chip, regardless of what was really there.
  2. The raw data apparently contains more x-ray counts for Al outside of the chip than for any of the other four elements he mapped.
  3. It would thus be possible to pull out raw EDS data for a spot outside of the chip and plot it as an EDS graph for that spot, that features an apparent lot of Al and little else.
  4. It is possible that Fig 17 is such a plot for a spot outside of the chip, selected for high Al-ratio from the raw data of the mapping run.
  5. Such a result would constitute a measurement error
  6. It can go unnoticed by the operator if he fails to check the location from which this spectrum was won



(Link works - thanks)
 
Last edited:
Hmm ok, Peter, so the stub was most probably covered with carbon.

Still, the EDS-maps shows many spots with some Al outside of the chip, and fewer with O and C, fewer still with Fe, right?

Is my logic correct:

  1. Since Jones's software plotted dots for Al outside of the specimen, it recorded some raw EDS data with x-ray-counts for Al-K-alpha for locations outside of the chip, regardless of what was really there.
  2. The raw data apparently contains more x-ray counts for Al outside of the chip than for any of the other four elements he mapped.
  3. It would thus be possible to pull out raw EDS data for a spot outside of the chip and plot it as an EDS graph for that spot, that features an apparent lot of Al and little else.
  4. It is possible that Fig 17 is such a plot for a spot outside of the chip, selected for high Al-ratio from the raw data of the mapping run.
  5. Such a result would constitute a measurement error
  6. It can go unnoticed by the operator if he fails to check the location from which this spectrum was won



(Link works - thanks)







Let me just say I think that analyzing this kind of very small, poor conducting specimens is very difficult. It is difficult to put into a few words just how their analyses where performed, or for that matter just which particular EDAX system they used, and how they used it. Dangers everywhere.

1. Yes the Al outside the chip is a puzzle. I have this feeling that it is artifact.

2. Yes, the count rate does seem high.

3. I don’t know if you can do that, the scanned raster is an analogue continuous sweep, the x rays derived from any point on the specimen XY are simply added to the total number of counts, but I do not know what their system was capable of.


4. Yes it could be, the plot of fig 17, and the x ray map, don’t have to be the same acquisition.

5. It would constitute cheating in my opinion.

6. It depends on the system capability, I have tried to find out which system they used, but even EDAX own website does not give any information on the EDAX X-ray energy Dispersive spectrometry (XEDS) system.

If the operator just acquired a spectrum from some part of the specimen, and then stored it he would not know where the spectrum was derived from, (if he moved the specimen) unless the system knew where the stage was, in XYZ, tilt, and rotation. Although modern computer controlled stages can remember where the stage was in XY, I don’t know if they can remember Z, tilt, and rotation, anyway, the resolution of the stage motors would not be better than about 100 microns so you would not be able to find your place anyway.

These notes are based on some assumptions as I do not know exactly what EDS system they used. They are though, assumptions based on many years working with SEM’s.
You are doing grand work out there, keep it up.




Peter.
 
Last edited:
5. It would constitute cheating in my opinion.

This seems to be another case of you lot assuming a lot of things you have no basis for, such as assuming they did only one measurement and based their whole paper on only one measurement for figure 17, instead of them using figure 17 because it was a typical example of many measurements.

This also seems like another case of amateurs talking out their arse.

If you think you can back up your assumptions then publish in a reviewed paper, or ask Millette to do it.

Somehow I think that will never happen.
 
This seems to be another case of you lot assuming a lot of things you have no basis for, such as assuming they did only one measurement and based their whole paper on only one measurement for figure 17, instead of them using figure 17 because it was a typical example of many measurements.

This also seems like another case of amateurs talking out their arse.

If you think you can back up your assumptions then publish in a reviewed paper, or ask Millette to do it.

Somehow I think that will never happen.

This seems to be another case of you assuming a lo tof things you have no basis for, as in assuming Dr. Millette will not do something just because you want to.

ETA: Also, if you think you can support the paper than why don't you publish something in a peer reviewed paper? Replicate the process and get it peer reviewed. We know the Bentham paper didn't go through a peer review process, so if you feel that the findings of that study is iron clad. Replicate and publish it somewhere that isn't pay to play.
 
Last edited:
This seems to be another case of you lot assuming a lot of things you have no basis for, such as assuming they did only one measurement and based their whole paper on only one measurement for figure 17, instead of them using figure 17 because it was a typical example of many measurements.

This also seems like another case of amateurs talking out their arse.

If you think you can back up your assumptions then publish in a reviewed paper, or ask Millette to do it.

Somehow I think that will never happen.

Your comment would not be so stupid if it was not numbered 5 in the post you quoted.



Your fail has been quoted for those who rightfully ignore you. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
This seems to be another case of you lot assuming a lot of things you have no basis for, such as assuming they did only one measurement and based their whole paper on only one measurement for figure 17, instead of them using figure 17 because it was a typical example of many measurements.

This also seems like another case of amateurs talking out their arse.

If you think you can back up your assumptions then publish in a reviewed paper, or ask Millette to do it.

Somehow I think that will never happen.


It would be nice if you could address the content of the post.

It is very, very, important to understand the nature of what we see, and not what we want to see.


Peter May.
 
Last edited:
...We know the Bentham paper didn't go through a peer review process...

Actually, this is FALSE and the opposite is true: We do know that the paper went through a peer-review process. David Griscom is one of the referees. I have seen and read a paper copy of the peer-review in full. It is 12 pages, it full to the brim with recommendations to change the paper draft (which, unfortunately, I did not see), and it is addressed to a journal editor, not the authors. Griscom does not know who selected him as a referee ;)
 
jtl: ...assuming they did only one measurement and based their whole paper on only one measurement for figure 17, instead of them using figure 17 because it was a typical example of many measurements.

Peter M: It would be nice if you could address the content of the post.

I did address the content, you are basing your "content" on assumptions that do not hold water. If you think it does, publish.

Actually, this is FALSE and the opposite is true: We do know that the paper went through a peer-review process.

Correcting stupid hogwash, good for you Oystein.
 
Nuts peer review Jones failed paper of fantasy thermite.

Actually, this is FALSE and the opposite is true: We do know that the paper went through a peer-review process. David Griscom is one of the referees. I have seen and read a paper copy of the peer-review in full. It is 12 pages, it full to the brim with recommendations to change the paper draft (which, unfortunately, I did not see), and it is addressed to a journal editor, not the authors. Griscom does not know who selected him as a referee ;)
David? lol, like the fate of woo steps in, makes David Griscom a referee, who is pure woo.

Are you serious? David is a nut on 911.

... I implore my fellow physicists and engineers who may have the time, expertise, and (ideally) supercomputer access to get to work on the physics of the World Trade Center collapses and publish their findings in refereed journals like, say, the Journal of Applied Physics.

The issue of knowing who was really behind the 9/11 attacks is of paramount importance to the future of our country, because the "official" assumption that it was the work of 19 Arab amateurs (1) does not match the available facts and (2) has led directly to the deplorable Patriot Act, the illegal Iraq war, NSA spying on ordinary Americans, repudiation of the Geneva Conventions, and the repeal of habeas corpus (a fundamental point of law that has been with us since the signing of the Magna Carta in 1215). http://www.davidgriscom.com/

You are right, the paper when through a peer review of nuts, who failed to understand there was no thermite used on 911.

Peer review of nuts, who can't figure out 911 given the answers, and 11 years. Jones makes insane claims, then people make up a fake conclusion.
 
Last edited:
David? lol, like the fate of woo steps in an makes David Griscom a referee, who is pure woo.

Are you serious? David is a nut on 911.

You are right, the paper when through a peer review of nuts, who failed to understand there was no thermite used on 911.

Yes, I am serious. He really had a TON of remarks on the original draft - in a way, that means there was a lot to be corrected there, and that which he remarked mostly was alright.
More interesting all the long pages of recommendations he didn't write :p

He thinks the paper's final version is flawless:
http://impactglassman.blogspot.com/2010/09/911-truth-evidence-of-energetic.html

David Griscom said:
I was one of the referees of the Harrit et al. paper. The editors asked for my opinion. And after about two weeks of studying what the authors had written, checking relevant references, and gathering my thoughts, I finally provided my advice to authors in 12 single-spaced pages, together with my recommendation to the Editors that they publish the paper after the authors had considered my suggestions.

... And I found absolutely nothing to criticize in the final version of the Harrit et al. paper!
The first time I read the paper, I found a couple if things to criticize. That was before I understood the first thing about SEM, EDS, DSC, pigments, polymers.
 
Yes, I am serious. He really had a TON of remarks on the original draft - in a way, that means there was a lot to be corrected there, and that which he remarked mostly was alright.
More interesting all the long pages of recommendations he didn't write :p

He thinks the paper's final version is flawless:
http://impactglassman.blogspot.com/2010/09/911-truth-evidence-of-energetic.html


The first time I read the paper, I found a couple if things to criticize. That was before I understood the first thing about SEM, EDS, DSC, pigments, polymers.

David, is a nut on 911. http://www.aneta.org/911experiments_com/Griscom/Old911Hypothesis/index.htm
the most important damage done by the explosives was not thermal but due to the shock waves they created. Shock-wave physics (I'm a physicist by the way) was not part of my education,
Now thermite is an explosive, with a shock-wave. Ironically, they took a picture of the chip burning, like some sugar burning. Oops, sugar has too much energy compared to thermite.
 
Last edited:
David, is a nut on 911.

Now thermite is an explosive, with a shock-wave. Ironically, they took a picture of the chip burning, like some sugar burning. Oops, sugar has too much energy compared to thermite.

Yep. Look:
David Griscom said:
Each of the Twin Towers comprised about 400,000 cubic yards of concrete and about 200,000 pounds of flammables. Both the concrete and the flammables were turned to dust
...
Assuming the flammables to have been 100% wooden furniture, there would have been about 250 cubic yards of sawdust blended with those 400,000 cubic yards of pulverized concrete. Just how vigorously do you expect this 1600-to-one-diluted sawdust would burn?

Not strong on facts.

400,000 cubic yards concrete per tower? Let's see:
110 floor slabs
63x63 meters
0.1 meters concrete
is 110x63x63x0.1 m3 = 43,659 m3 is ca. 60,000 cubic yards.
Griscom wrong by factor of 6.7

200,000 pounds of flammables per tower? Let's see:
In each towerm there were workstations for what - 15,000 emplpyees? Let's say it was so.
Each has 10 filing folders, each folder is 3 pounds of paper - 30 pounds.
Each has a computer keyboard. That's 2 pounds of plastic. Computer and screen: 8 more pounds - 10 pounds of plastic
Each has a desk. That's 50 pounds of wood. If the legs are metal.
That's 90 pounds of flammables per employee. 15,000 employes: we are at 1,350,000. Oops already wrong by a factor of almost 7. And we aren't done yet.
We have 2,500 people dead people in the towers. They weigh 160 pounds each. Corpses are flammable, too! 400,000 pounds. Oops! Dead people alone are twice the flammables in Griscom's illusion! And we aren't doe yet.
Carpets: At least a pound per square meter (cheapest quality). We have 400,000 m2 used area in each tower. 400,000 pounds. oops!
I have a total of 2,150,000 pounds of flammables already. Haven't even started on plumbing, haven't started on other furniture. Griscom wrong by a factor of almost 11 now, 15 when I am done.

"1600-to-one-diluted sawdust"? Concrete wrong by 7x, flammables wrong by 14x, that's 1600-to-one wrong by factor of 100. 16-1 suddenly.

Dr. Griscom, that wasn't too hard. Check facts often?
 
"We know the Bentham paper didn't go through a peer review process, so if you feel that the findings of that study is iron clad. Replicate and publish it somewhere that isn't pay to play."
"Actually, this is FALSE and the opposite is true: We do know that the paper went through a peer-review process. David Griscom is one of the referees. I have seen and read a paper copy of the peer-review in full."
"Correcting stupid hogwash, good for you Oystein."

Yes.

Kudos to Oystein for acknowledging this.

MM
 
Last edited:
Actually, this is FALSE and the opposite is true: We do know that the paper went through a peer-review process. David Griscom is one of the referees. I have seen and read a paper copy of the peer-review in full. It is 12 pages, it full to the brim with recommendations to change the paper draft (which, unfortunately, I did not see), and it is addressed to a journal editor, not the authors. Griscom does not know who selected him as a referee ;)

Unless I'm mistaken, they didn't make any of the corrections with the paper. I could be wrong, I was trying to find where I saw the post in another thread. I was digging through to locate. If they didn't make the changes, wouldn't that be the same as not going through the peer review?

ETA: Furthermore, not that I care what any of JTL or MM's opinions are, that is one aspect of what I said. You didn't address any of the rest of my statement. If you think the paper is so iron clad then why don't you stop pointing fingers at other people to replicate the study and do it your *********** self?
 
Last edited:
Oystein - I can see where you are coming from with regards to Fig 17 and the matching 10 KeV used in the EDX mapping, however, that same KeV setting is, in my opinion, a tenuous stretch to Jones, or whomever, picking out a specific EDX spectrum from the mapping data.

I'm not sure if that is even possible, (I've never heard of that being done), because each scan would have to have specific positional data for each individual reading with specific count data for that individual point available to the operator - I don't know, so that's for someone with much deeper knowledge and experience to say whether it's possible.

I just can't see a SEM operator doing it even if that data is available because you have to manually trawl through multiple spectra, when the quicker, easier alternative is simply to perform a scan on an area of interest. The operator may chose a different KeV for all sorts of reasons.

As I understand it, and I may be wrong, it was Farrer that either performed the operation of the SEM or over saw it. The SEM data in the paper is actually something that I think is very good, although personally I like to see count and the specific area analysed indicated, but it's not essential.

I can fully appreciate that "eureka" moment of thinking I've found something! - I did it with regard to the gray layer and thinking it was Micaceous Iron Oxide when I first read the paper nearly 4 years ago, but soon after realised I was wrong.

There is a danger of looking at minutiae and seeing things that are not there, just as truthers or any other conspiracy theorist looks at video and see something innocuous yet considers it important.

We know the material is red paint from Harrit et al's own data. Millette confirms this, so I don't think that it's important to go any further. Harrit, Jones, Farrer and Basile have not responded with anything new, nor have they released the data they promised or continued any further promised study.

It's dead - only a curiosity.
 
Unless I'm mistaken, they didn't make any of the corrections with the paper. I could be wrong, I was trying to find where I saw the post in another thread. I was digging through to locate. If they didn't make the changes, wouldn't that be the same as not going through the peer review?
...

They did make changes.

Here's the story: There is this German Truther Dirk Gerhardt aka Sitting-Bull who likes to converse with the big-shot truthers. He sometimes translates English language Truthing to German. At one point, Griscom sent him his 12 pages of peer-review to have them translated, but then Griscom had second thoughts and told Gerhardt not to pass anything along. But Gerhardt offers anyone to have a look at a paper copy. I took him up on this offer last year in April: We met for lunch at a nice restaurant in Hamburg, had a long chat, and I got to read the piece.

I didn't take any notes, and procrastinated to no end on my intention to blog about it.

What I can tell you though is that the review was about a draft that was quite different from the final paper. For example, Griscon recommended leaving out quite a number of figures, and it was quite apparent that they heeded many of those recommendations. There isn't an awful lot more that I remember content-wise. One thing was that Griscom pointed out that the red layer is probably red because there are iron oxide grains in it, like in red paints, and that they should think about if that could be used to make an argument. (They didn't). Also, he wanted to read more about silicon and the role it could have played in nanothermite (they didn't write anything about that).
I guess I remember thise items precisely because they weren't acted on, but many others they apparently did pick up.
 
What specific qualification or experience does Griscom have in materials characterisation, materials analysis or forensic metallurgy?

Where are the independent reviewers with relevant qualifications? There aren't any - that's why it was published in a pay to publish journal, whose editor subsequently resigned.

We've been through this hundreds of times. The paper has no merit.
 
They did make changes.

Here's the story: There is this German Truther Dirk Gerhardt aka Sitting-Bull who likes to converse with the big-shot truthers. He sometimes translates English language Truthing to German. At one point, Griscom sent him his 12 pages of peer-review to have them translated, but then Griscom had second thoughts and told Gerhardt not to pass anything along. But Gerhardt offers anyone to have a look at a paper copy. I took him up on this offer last year in April: We met for lunch at a nice restaurant in Hamburg, had a long chat, and I got to read the piece.

I didn't take any notes, and procrastinated to no end on my intention to blog about it.

What I can tell you though is that the review was about a draft that was quite different from the final paper. For example, Griscon recommended leaving out quite a number of figures, and it was quite apparent that they heeded many of those recommendations. There isn't an awful lot more that I remember content-wise. One thing was that Griscom pointed out that the red layer is probably red because there are iron oxide grains in it, like in red paints, and that they should think about if that could be used to make an argument. (They didn't). Also, he wanted to read more about silicon and the role it could have played in nanothermite (they didn't write anything about that).
I guess I remember thise items precisely because they weren't acted on, but many others they apparently did pick up.

So I guess Sunstealer said it way better than me. I couldn't remember what it was about the "peer review" that made it useless. I was more aiming towards the paper didn't go through a proper process which made it not eligible to be posted in credible scientific forums\magazines\journals.

I apologize for my ignorace, and not researching what I was trying to say before hand. I believe my point still stands, the paper is ignored by the scientific field at large because it's inaccurate.
 
Last edited:
"We know the Bentham paper didn't go through a peer review process, so if you feel that the findings of that study is iron clad. Replicate and publish it somewhere that isn't pay to play."
"Actually, this is FALSE and the opposite is true: We do know that the paper went through a peer-review process. David Griscom is one of the referees. I have seen and read a paper copy of the peer-review in full."
"Correcting stupid hogwash, good for you Oystein."
"ETA: Furthermore, not that I care what any of JTL or MM's opinions are, that is one aspect of what I said. You didn't address any of the rest of my statement. If you think the paper is so iron clad then why don't you stop pointing fingers at other people to replicate the study and do it your *********** self?"

Why would we attempt to replicate a study we are in agreement with?

There is a problem when a scientist falsely claims to have replicated the study, fails to get the new study peer-reviewed, and then attempts to use the findings as the basis for debunking.

MM
 
Why would we attempt to replicate a study we are in agreement with?

There is a problem when a scientist falsely claims to have replicated the study, fails to get the new study peer-reviewed, and then attempts to use the findings as the basis for debunking.

MM

Mind boggling. The goal of the study was to accurately distinguish what the red\gray layers consisted of, chemically. That was the impression that I got from what Mohr told me. I know he may have said replicate, or whatever the case might be. Truthers don't find the information to be factual in the Millette report, and most debunkers disagree with the majority of the Bentham paper. Millette hasn't failed to get the new study peer reviewed, the study isn't completed. You're outright lying right there, and you should know it. You've read the threads saying he's is attempting to gather paint samples to test in comparison. He's creating the paper, and it has been presented at scientific gatherings. Which is more than the Bentham paper has been.

The "debunkers" here use the findings as a basis for debunking because of the results of chemical evaluation. Those results are factual.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom