This is a good example of lying.
With nothing more than wishful thinking, you've stated as fact that Dr. Jones is displaying spectra for a LaClede paint chip.
MM
Oh, is it?
Let's see, MM, if you can answer a few questions that help us to discern whether my hypothesis is well supported or not:
1. Do you accept as TRUE that LaClede Steel Company painted the WTC floor trusses with a primer paint that has the formulation:
Epoxy: 71.5 % | Iron oxide: 15.7% | Al-silicate: 11.7% | Strontium chromate: 1.1% (balance: rounding error)
2. Do you accept as TRUE that, as Kevin Ryan, Frank Legge and Mark Basile have stated, you find red WTC primer in the WTC dust?
3. Do you accept as TRUE that is is therefore POSSIBLE that
some of those chips could be LaClede primer?
4. Do you accept as TRUE that an XEDS spectrum of this LaClede primer at 20 keV would look like this:
5. Do you accept as TRUE that bright red iron oxide pigments are typically 100-200 nm in size and rhombic in shape?
6. Do you accept as true that Kaolin clay typically looks like this:
7. Do you accept as TRUE that Kaolinite is an Aluminium Silicate with the sum formula Al
2Si
2O
5(OH)
4 - so there are equal amounts of Si and Al in it?
8. Do you accept as TRUE that the EDS spectra of the red layers of chips a-d, shown in
Fig 7, look VERY much like the simulated LaClede spectrum above?
9. Do you accept as TRUE that the iron oxide grains shown in chips a-d, for example in
Fig. 8, have the shape and size of bright red iron oxide PIGMENTS?
10. Do you accept as TRUE that the plates found in chips a-d have the same shape and are of the same order of magnitude as typical plates of kaolin clay?
11. Do you accept as TRUE that
Fig 10 shows that, in chip a, Al and Si have basically an identical distribution, and are located where there are plates in the corresponding BSE image?
12. Do you accept as TRUE that
Fig. 11a shows proof that Al and Si are found in practically equal amounts in those plates?
13. Do you thus accept as TRUE that these plates contain Al and Si in equal amounts, just like Kaolin does?
14. Do you accept as TRUE that
Fig 6, the EDS spectra of the gray layers of chips a-d, essentially shows the signature of oxidized iron, with small amounts of carbon an manganese?
15. Do you accept as TRUE that the steel that LaClede used for the floor joists was an alloy with manganese and low carbon?
16. Do you thus accept as TRUE that the elemental signature of the gray layers of chips a-d is consistent with the floor truss steel?
17. Do you accept as TRUE that the elemental signature of the gray layers of chips a-d is consistent with the paint LaClede used on the floor trusses?
17 questions, MM. I fully expect you to dodge all 17 of them, but we all know that you read them, and we all know why you won't answer them.
And I will LOL. Runn, MM, run!
