Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

"One thing was that Griscom pointed out that the red layer is probably red because there are iron oxide grains in it, like in red paints, and that they [the Bentham Paper scientists] should think about if that could be used to make an argument. (They didn't)."

FALSE.

You have no idea what they did or did not "think about", and most certainly they addressed the issue of paint.

MM
 
FALSE.

You have no idea what they did or did not "think about", and most certainly they addressed the issue of paint.

MM

Remember, MM, the folling is always correct:

Miragememories said:
I fail to see your point?
Right, you fail to see my point.

:D



Here is the point: The red paint is red, because the iron oxide grains......................? Can you fill in the dots? Perhaps the answer, as a result of Harrit and friends thinking hard and long about Griscom's recommendation, contains the answer?
Or perhaps: "The red layer is red because..........................."
Go, MM. quote the answer, it's in paper - or isn't it?
:D

Alternatively:

Run, MM, runnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!!! :D :D
 
Sunstealer: What specific qualification or experience does Griscom have in materials characterisation, materials analysis or forensic metallurgy?

Where are the independent reviewers with relevant qualifications? There aren't any - that's why it was published in a pay to publish journal, whose editor subsequently resigned.

We've been through this hundreds of times. The paper has no merit.
Edited by Gaspode: 
Removed breach of rule 12.


it should be noted that forensic metallurgy would be useful to study the thermite-cut surface of a metal beam, but studying the chemical reaction of the suspected agent is in the realm of chemical physics, so the Bentham Open Chemical Physics Journal is the right medium.

Does Griscom have the credentials to review a chemical physics paper? Let´s see:
I am the principal author of 109 papers (and a co-author of an additional 81) in peer-review journals. And have refereed a least 600, and possibly as many as 1000, manuscripts. So you would be right in calling me an aficionado of articles published in scientific journals. And I found absolutely nothing to criticize in the final version of the Harrit et al. paper! Apropos, twelve of my own publications have appeared in the American Institute of Physics’ Journal of Chemical Physics (an old fashioned paper journal), so it is accurate to say that chemical physics (of inorganic materials) is my main specialty.
Edited by Gaspode: 
Removed breach of rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Oystein: Can you fill in the dots?

Griscom: I found absolutely nothing to criticize in the final version of the Harrit et al. paper!

MM can point to Harrit´s published paper that was reviewed by a very impressive scientist. You are still waiting for a WTC dust paper by a scientist with charges of fraud on his back for his past WTC dust papers. Can you fill in the dots?
 
LOL, when your peers are as nuts as you are; Jones and Griscom

MM can point to Harrit´s published paper that was reviewed by a very impressive scientist. You are still waiting for a WTC dust paper by a scientist with charges of fraud on his back for his past WTC dust papers. Can you fill in the dots?
David L. Griscom, Ph.D. ???

Really, impressive for 911 truth cult members, but crazy to the rational world. Jones paper has not made 60 Minutes? What would be a Pulitzer Prize winning story if true, ends up being the rant of insane old men who have fantasy of thermite.
http://www.drivehq.com/folder/p1720199/03889269.aspx
Someone who thinks "All Hijacked Passengers Survived" reviewed a paper with a fantasy conclusion, and say it is good.

It gets worse.
http://www.aneta.org/911experiments_com/Griscom/Old911Hypothesis/index.htm
http://impactglassman.blogspot.com/2007/01/hand-waving-physics-of-911.html
http://www.davidgriscom.com/
 
Last edited:
Lol

Does anyone fancy having a whip round to get Millette's work peer reviewed in Benthan Science.

Thanks jtl
 
...
Harrit Jones et al state the following.

For general surface analysis in the SEM, dust samples
were mounted to carbon conductive tabs.
...

Harrit has provided some more detail on their sample holders in a reply to Dennis Rancourt's post-publication peer-review:

http://board.gulli.com/thread/1537495-die-sich-abzeichnende-neue-weltordnung/307/#post13593325


(He commits the error again to mix up tests and results on chips a-d with tests and results on the MEK-chip. I am 99% certain those two sets of experiments were done at widely different times, and probably by different persons; my reason to assume this is the large difference in data quality and systematic approach. So whatever measures of quality control were done on chips a-d - by Jeff Farrer, I think - cannot be applied directly to the MEK-chip - Jones, I suspect, or perhaps Farnsworth).
 
Harrit has provided some more detail on their sample holders in a reply to Dennis Rancourt's post-publication peer-review:

http://board.gulli.com/thread/1537495-die-sich-abzeichnende-neue-weltordnung/307/#post13593325


(He commits the error again to mix up tests and results on chips a-d with tests and results on the MEK-chip. I am 99% certain those two sets of experiments were done at widely different times, and probably by different persons; my reason to assume this is the large difference in data quality and systematic approach. So whatever measures of quality control were done on chips a-d - by Jeff Farrer, I think - cannot be applied directly to the MEK-chip - Jones, I suspect, or perhaps Farnsworth).

Thanks for the link Oystein.

But as usual, you ignore everything in Dr. Harrit's lengthy and thoughtful response that is not in agreement with your bs hypothesis.

Truly pathetic on your part, but I do appreciate the link.

MM
 
Thread to discuss the excellent analysis of Jones latest paper

Oystein: Harrit has provided some more detail on their sample holders in a reply to Dennis Rancourt's post-publication peer-review:

http://board.gulli.com/thread/153749.../#post13593325

This is yet another confirmation of the impression I get from this forum, you so called "debunkers" keep repeating hogwash that you know has been debunked long ago.

Edited by Gaspode: Removed breach of rule 12.

Edited by LashL: 
Removed further breach.


For the rest of you lot, it is about time to publish Millette´s paper if you still think that is going to happen at all, which seems unlikely at this point.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks for the link Oystein.

You're welcome.

By the way, you forgot to reply to this:


Remember, MM, the folling is always correct:
Miragememories said:
I fail to see your point?
Right, you fail to see my point.

:D



Here is the point: The red paint is red, because the iron oxide grains......................? Can you fill in the dots? Perhaps the answer, as a result of Harrit and friends thinking hard and long about Griscom's recommendation, contains the answer?
Or perhaps: "The red layer is red because..........................."
Go, MM. quote the answer, it's in paper - or isn't it?
:D

Alternatively:

Run, MM, runnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!!! :D :D



it is about time to publish Millette´s paper if you still think that is going to happen at all, which seems unlikely at this point.

Millette started on his studies in december 2011, if I remember correctly (could be november), created his raw data about a year ago, and presented a good deal of it to us, and to a professional forensic conference in late february 2012 - less than a year ago. His data collection efforts are ongoing. I expect him to publish later this year.

I have a few questions for you:
  1. How long ago did Harrit et al. produce their FTIR data?
  2. How long ago did Harrit et al. announce that they WILL publish their FTIR data?
  3. Do you expect them to actually publish their FTIR data?
  4. If yes, when? If not, why not?
  5. How long ago did Steven Jones produce his XRD data?
  6. Do you expect Steven Jones to publish his XRD data?
  7. If yes, when? If not, why not?
  8. How long ago did Jeff Farrer produce his TEM data?
  9. Do you expect Jeff Farrer to publish his TEM data?
  10. If yes, when? If not, why not?

These are ten (10) questions.
I want you to answer all ten (10) questions.
I fully expect you to dodge all ten (10) questions.

Run, jtl, ruuunnnnnnnnnn! :D
 
You're welcome.

By the way, you forgot to reply to this:


Remember, MM, the folling is always correct:

Right, you fail to see my point.

:D



Here is the point: The red paint is red, because the iron oxide grains......................? Can you fill in the dots? Perhaps the answer, as a result of Harrit and friends thinking hard and long about Griscom's recommendation, contains the answer?
Or perhaps: "The red layer is red because..........................."
Go, MM. quote the answer, it's in paper - or isn't it?
:D

Alternatively:

Run, MM, runnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!!! :D :D

Write coherently and keep your typos to a minimum and you might get more responses.

Also, your chronic failure to respond to rebuttals makes replying to your question floods a total waste of time.

MM
 
Write coherently and keep your typos to a minimum and you might get more responses.
LOL
How many typos were there in the post that you quoted and dodged? :D

Also, your chronic failure to respond to rebuttals makes replying to your question floods a total waste of time.

MM
How do you know? You never try!

Maybe you could be a little more tolerant considering English is not his native language.

(I know, you're only using this as an excuse)
Ohh no need to defend me here - one of my professors at the major American graduate school I went to once commended me for writing the best English of all his students - and he specifically included the American students. Most of my typos are really just typos and not due to any spelling problems I might have as a non-native speaker - I am just sloppy then.

And of course, you are right in your assessment of MM's pathetic foul. He reached another low point on his flight from honesty and decency ;)
 
Vanity Journal only Journal that publishes woo of Jones and Harrit

This is yet another confirmation of the impression I get from this forum, you so called "debunkers" keep repeating hogwash that you know has been debunked long ago. ...
Debunkers for Jones' folly? Thermite was not used on 911. The facts debunk Jones insane thermite in the ceiling tiles nonsense. Hogwash is the conclusion made by Jones and Harrit, the DSC do not match, and 911 truth has no clue what DSC is used for. Double failure.

... hogwash about Harrit et al, the paper, the reviewer, the editor, and the publisher. If he f
Edited by LashL: 
Removed quote of moderated content.
Outsiders? LOL, you think there is an audience for your thermite fantasy, and you think you are winning with a paper which makes silly conclusion of thermite. Hogwash, is what 911 truth has to back up Jones' failed paper on thermite.

... For the rest of you lot, it is about time to publish Millette´s paper if you still think that is going to happen at all, which seems unlikely at this point.
There are many studies of WTC. No thermite was found by rational researchers. Jones and Harrit are conspiracy nuts on 911 issues, and they only fool a few fringe paranoid conspiracy theories who lack knowledge in chemistry.

"For the rest of you lot,"
? Really? What did 60 minutes say about the failed fantasy conclusion of thermite in Jones' silly paper, published in a vanity journal?

Jones made up the conclusion before he started with dust collected by who?
...
1. Jones' Analysis was biased, and focused on finding a particular outcome from the get go. As a result, the analysis and subsequent paper ignore, or at best GLAZE OVER the issue of other possible sources of their Red/Grey Chips.

2. Jones' did not address, outside of a dismissive "it is contamination" the presence of Chromium and Zinc in at least one sample, and with this in mind, the possibility that the Sodium spikes in the Spectra, may have also been Zinc. There was no washing of the samples in order to eliminate contamination as a possiblity (or to rule it in).

3. All of the other LEGITIMATE analysis of dust from the WTC GZ had a considerable quantity of Paint in the dust samples. Yet there is no mention of paint particles within the samples that Jones had, and if they were found, how they were separated from the red/grey chips. I find the magnet method poor, because as we all know, paint from the WTC could have been found in the form of bilayered particles, due to peel off or rust/corrosion, and as a result, a magnet would work on them also.

4. I have a problem with the Journal that Jones selected to submit/publish his article with. There is mention of a personal connection between one of the lead scientists producing the paper, and the editorial board. There is a wealth of information indicating that the journal is a "Vanity" "Pay to publish" journal that solicited for members of the editorial boards for its various journals via viral email schemes to unqualified, unrelated (in field of knowledge) academics.

TAM:)
It is funny how the DSCs don't match; does all of 911 truth ignore evidence?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
MM: Also, your chronic failure to respond to rebuttals makes replying to your question floods a total waste of time.

Oystein: How do you know? You never try!

MM is telling the truth, there is no point responding to you Oystein because any answer goes in one ear and out the other. You still present your "the MEK chip is Tnemec" nonsense no matter what, and you just tried to present an old theory as something new even though Rancourt offered it 2 years ago and Harrit debunked it 2 years ago(http://board.gulli.com/thread/153749.../#post13593325) The same thing with your "fill in the dots" comment about Griscom in post 1562, which you repeat in post 1572 despite the fact that Griscom himself has given you an answer(indirectly) and I reminded you in post 1564:
Griscom: I found absolutely nothing to criticize in the final version of the Harrit et al. paper!

And again the same thing with your repeated bs about Harrit et al not releasing important data:
I have a few questions for you:

How long ago did Harrit et al. produce their FTIR data?
How long ago did Harrit et al. announce that they WILL
publish their FTIR data?
Do you expect them to actually publish their FTIR data?
If yes, when? If not, why not?
How long ago did Steven Jones produce his XRD data?
Do you expect Steven Jones to publish his XRD data?
If yes, when? If not, why not?
How long ago did Jeff Farrer produce his TEM data?
Do you expect Jeff Farrer to publish his TEM data?
If yes, when? If not, why not?

This has been answered already and of course that has been ignored by you as always:

MM can point to Harrit´s published paper that was reviewed by a very impressive scientist. You are still waiting for a WTC dust paper by a scientist with charges of fraud on his back for his past WTC dust papers. Can you fill in the dots?

You obviously cannot fill in the dots. If Millette manages to publish his paper, and especially if he manages to do it without getting more fraud charges, you can start to demand more data from Harrit et al, and you would get it. Until then you are in no position to make demands...so go run Oystein...ruuuuun...and go change the subject for the umpteenth time and run.:D
 
Last edited:
If Millette managed to publish his paper, and especially if he manages to do it without getting more fraud charges, you can start to demand more data from Harrit et al. Until then you are in no position to make demands.

I love this part. You guys will call it fraud regardless. That's how your group works. :rolleyes:

How's the effort to get that withheld data going?
 
Jones Fantasy Thermite Scam Failed in Vanity Journal

... If Millette manages to publish his paper, ....:D
Why did 60 Minutes skip Jones paper of woo?

Why is Millette's paper needed, Jones' paper fails all by itself.

Why can't you take Jones' paper to ABC, CBS, NBC, CNN, and break the big inside job? Is it due to the fact it is a fantasy, the conclusions is nonsense?

When the Jones delusion first hit the Vanity Journal, I found the spectrum he publish was like aluminum on steel tubes, like heating stuff. Rust and Aluminum - two of the big elements on earth; Al, O, Fe. lol, they discovered dust.
And that is 911Truth.

The product of Jones red chips looks a lot like an ALUMINIZED steel tube damaged by heat.
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/steeltubewithAl.jpg
Not thermite, not burnt thermite, just ALUMINIZED STEEL HEATER TUBES suffering damage from heat.

Plus his samples are not consistent for much save debris from the WTC that have rust and Al in them along with other elements you find in glass, steel, paint, clay and other items all found in the WTC without making up this paper about thermite.

We are lucking no one found cookie crumbs in the dust, we would have energy levels 11 times greater than TNT as Jones published a paper on butter extracted from cookie crumbs found at the WTC from 911, 11 times greater energy density than TNT. Now that would be a cool pay to publish paper. "Cookie Crumbs Confirm Inside Job with 11 Times the Energy of TNT".
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom