This discussion has really lost sight of the forest for the trees.
The burden of proof is on Harrit, Jones, et al to demonstrate that their samples are thermite. They have used a DSC test as evidence that it is thermite.
A DSC, properly done, is of little value as evidence of what something IS, but it is of value as evidence of something is not. It's analogous to a litmus paper test. (In my career as an industrial chemist, I did many "quick and dirty" tests to determine what something is not.)
Suppose you bring me a sample of liquid and ask me "Is this a solution of hydrochloric acid in water?" I dip some litmus paper into it, and it does not turn pink. I then tell you, "No, it is not a solution of hydrochloric acid." What is it actually? Could it be tap water? A fluorinated hydrocarbon? It could be either one, or any of many other things, but we know it isn't hydrochloric acid. If all you wanted to know was whether or not it's aqueous HCl, we can close the books. If you want to know what it actually is, we'll need to do more tests.
If it does turn pink, then it may be hydrochloric acid, or it may be any of many other things. It is very unlikely to be tap water. If you want to know what it actually is, we need to do more tests.
If, however, if I mix your sample into some acetic acid and dip some litmus paper into it, then the test is per se worthless even as a negative test, because the acetic acid itself will make the litmus paper turn pink. Fail. A mistake only an utter boob would make, or a charlatan. An incompetent boob, though an honest one, would re-do the test.
A DSC test, properly done, is analogous to a litmus test. A flat reading, done under an inert atmosphere, shows it is not thermite. If you are only interested in whether or not it is thermite, you can close the books here. If you want to know what it really is, we'll need to do more tests. (Millette's tests are overwhelming evidence that it is paint.)
What Harrit et al have done with the DSC test is analogous to doing the litmus test in HAc, since they knew their samples had a combustible organic resin. Doing the DSC in air absolutely invalidates it. They are either incompetent boobs, or charlatans. A proper re-do of the DSC test under an inert atmosphere could be easily done in a single day, with plenty of time left over for a long lunch and coffee breaks. Their failure to do so, after four years, proves to me beyond all doubt that they are not mere incompetent boobs, but that they are charlatans, and the people who follow them are fools.