Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Oystein - good work.

I've long been of the opinion that there are two different materials in the DSC trace - Red and blue is one material, black and green are different material, simply because their curves are different. Black and green show a significant endotherm whereas the other two don't. Harrit et al offer no explanation for this.

Usually an endotherm for melting is quite sharp so I've always doubted whether the endotherm starting around 570°C correlates with melting. I may have a bit of a look at this and ask around a few people I know.
 
Oystein: I agree with Sunstealer: good work:cool:

(I read some parts of Ferranti's thesis in the past, but I've forgotten details...)

Although I am still not so sure that these four chips can be divided into two groups/materials because of the shapes of DSC curves, this "proposal" sounds reasonably;)
 
If the resistance is 10 ohm per meter then a chip a mm long would have a resistance of .01 ohm. I doubt if your old Simpson meter or the Fluke they used could measure .01 ohm.

The Fluke can read as low as 0.001 ohms accurately once properly calibrated.

MM
 
The Fluke can read as low as 0.001 ohms accurately once properly calibrated.

MM

And now we are back to...

What record does Harrit, et al have of a Measurement System Analysis that shows a reliable and repeatible set of measurements on the chips in question and comparitive chips so a statistically valid comparitive analysis can be performed, taking into account not only the measuring device, for you have to include variations from operator to operator and the process for fixturing the chips in question and probing the proper layer of the chips?
 
And now we are back to...

What record does Harrit, et al have of a Measurement System Analysis that shows a reliable and repeatible set of measurements on the chips in question and comparitive chips so a statistically valid comparitive analysis can be performed, taking into account not only the measuring device, for you have to include variations from operator to operator and the process for fixturing the chips in question and probing the proper layer of the chips?

What I want MM to explain is why, when according to him they had separated the red/gray chips into low and high resistance piles, they didn't test any of the red/gray paint chips that were separated out? Why did they need to go OUTSIDE the box and get results from other paint chips?

According to MM, they clearly had red/gray paint chips...
 
"The Fluke can read as low as 0.001 ohms accurately once properly calibrated."
"Specs for the 80 series Fluke

Resistance
Maximum Resistance: 50 MΩ
Accuracy: Fluke 83 V: ±(0.4%+1)
Fluke 87 V: ±(0.2%+1)
Maximum Resolution: 0.1Ω


http://www.fluke.com/fluke/USEN/Digital-Multimeters/Fluke-80-Series-V.htm?PID=56135

At .001 ohm the resistance of the test leads and the chip to probe resistance (IOW noise) will prevent any meaningful reading to be taken.
"

That's nice but we are not talking about the 80 series Fluke which is a portable industrial field use DMM.

The Bentham Paper cites the Fluke 8842A Bench DMM which is not the same.

It has 100 μΩ resolution with a 20 ohm range.

With proper calibration lead resistance can be compensated for.

MM
 
That's nice but we are not talking about the 80 series Fluke which is a portable industrial field use DMM.

The Bentham Paper cites the Fluke 8842A Bench DMM which is not the same.

It has 100 μΩ resolution with a 20 ohm range.

With proper calibration lead resistance can be compensated for.

MM

So let's see the reults for each chip tested with it. And an MSA to show we can trust the reults are from a dependable process.
 
This discussion has really lost sight of the forest for the trees.

The burden of proof is on Harrit, Jones, et al to demonstrate that their samples are thermite. They have used a DSC test as evidence that it is thermite.

A DSC, properly done, is of little value as evidence of what something IS, but it is of value as evidence of something is not. It's analogous to a litmus paper test. (In my career as an industrial chemist, I did many "quick and dirty" tests to determine what something is not.)

Suppose you bring me a sample of liquid and ask me "Is this a solution of hydrochloric acid in water?" I dip some litmus paper into it, and it does not turn pink. I then tell you, "No, it is not a solution of hydrochloric acid." What is it actually? Could it be tap water? A fluorinated hydrocarbon? It could be either one, or any of many other things, but we know it isn't hydrochloric acid. If all you wanted to know was whether or not it's aqueous HCl, we can close the books. If you want to know what it actually is, we'll need to do more tests.

If it does turn pink, then it may be hydrochloric acid, or it may be any of many other things. It is very unlikely to be tap water. If you want to know what it actually is, we need to do more tests.

If, however, if I mix your sample into some acetic acid and dip some litmus paper into it, then the test is per se worthless even as a negative test, because the acetic acid itself will make the litmus paper turn pink. Fail. A mistake only an utter boob would make, or a charlatan. An incompetent boob, though an honest one, would re-do the test.

A DSC test, properly done, is analogous to a litmus test. A flat reading, done under an inert atmosphere, shows it is not thermite. If you are only interested in whether or not it is thermite, you can close the books here. If you want to know what it really is, we'll need to do more tests. (Millette's tests are overwhelming evidence that it is paint.)

What Harrit et al have done with the DSC test is analogous to doing the litmus test in HAc, since they knew their samples had a combustible organic resin. Doing the DSC in air absolutely invalidates it. They are either incompetent boobs, or charlatans. A proper re-do of the DSC test under an inert atmosphere could be easily done in a single day, with plenty of time left over for a long lunch and coffee breaks. Their failure to do so, after four years, proves to me beyond all doubt that they are not mere incompetent boobs, but that they are charlatans, and the people who follow them are fools.
 
Last edited:
"This discussion has really lost sight of the forest for the trees.

The burden of proof is on Harrit, Jones, et al to demonstrate that their samples are thermite. They have used a DSC test as evidence that it is thermite.
"

They have met the burden of proof by having their research findings published in a peer reviewed paper.

The "burden of proof" is on equally credible scientists to produce a peer reviewed paper that successfully debunks those findings.

I am sorry but your unrelated rant only qualifies as bs.

MM
 
They have met the burden of proof by having their research findings published in a peer reviewed paper.

The "burden of proof" is on equally credible scientists to produce a peer reviewed paper that successfully debunks those findings.

I am sorry but your unrelated rant only qualifies as bs.

MM

They have not met the burden of proof, because their results (especially their interpretation of them) could not be duplicated.
 
Oystein - good work.

I've long been of the opinion that there are two different materials in the DSC trace - Red and blue is one material, black and green are different material, simply because their curves are different. Black and green show a significant endotherm whereas the other two don't. Harrit et al offer no explanation for this.
Actually they do (maybe not a good explanation but it's an explanation).

Variations in peak height as well as yield estimates are not surprising, since the mass used to determine the scale of the signal, shown in the DSC traces, included the mass of the gray layer. The gray layer was found to consist mostly of iron oxide so that it probably does not contribute to the exotherm, and yet this layer varies greatly in mass from chip to chip.
​
(Section 3 p. 19)
 
My highlighting
This discussion has really lost sight of the forest for the trees.

The burden of proof is on Harrit, Jones, et al to demonstrate that their samples are thermite. They have used a DSC test as evidence that it is thermite.

A DSC, properly done, is of little value as evidence of what something IS, but it is of value as evidence of something is not. It's analogous to a litmus paper test. (In my career as an industrial chemist, I did many "quick and dirty" tests to determine what something is not.)

Suppose you bring me a sample of liquid and ask me "Is this a solution of hydrochloric acid in water?" I dip some litmus paper into it, and it does not turn pink. I then tell you, "No, it is not a solution of hydrochloric acid." What is it actually? Could it be tap water? A fluorinated hydrocarbon? It could be either one, or any of many other things, but we know it isn't hydrochloric acid. If all you wanted to know was whether or not it's aqueous HCl, we can close the books. If you want to know what it actually is, we'll need to do more tests.

If it does turn pink, then it may be hydrochloric acid, or it may be any of many other things. It is very unlikely to be tap water. If you want to know what it actually is, we need to do more tests.

If, however, if I mix your sample into some acetic acid and dip some litmus paper into it, then the test is per se worthless even as a negative test, because the acetic acid itself will make the litmus paper turn pink. Fail. A mistake only an utter boob would make, or a charlatan. An incompetent boob, though an honest one, would re-do the test.

A DSC test, properly done, is analogous to a litmus test. A flat reading, done under an inert atmosphere, shows it is not thermite. If you are only interested in whether or not it is thermite, you can close the books here. If you want to know what it really is, we'll need to do more tests. (Millette's tests are overwhelming evidence that it is paint.)

What Harrit et al have done with the DSC test is analogous to doing the litmus test in HAc, since they knew their samples had a combustible organic resin. Doing the DSC in air absolutely invalidates it. They are either incompetent boobs, or charlatans. A proper re-do of the DSC test under an inert atmosphere could be easily done in a single day, with plenty of time left over for a long lunch and coffee breaks. Their failure to do so, after four years, proves to me beyond all doubt that they are not mere incompetent boobs, but that they are charlatans, and the people who follow them are fools.

They have met the burden of proof by having their research findings published in a peer reviewed paper.

The "burden of proof" is on equally credible scientists to produce a peer reviewed paper that successfully debunks those findings.

I am sorry but your unrelated rant only qualifies as bs.
MM
Oystein
Yes, what we do is very good and has already received respect and serious attention from some of the smarter members of the truth movement, who start to question why Harrit, Jones and Farrer are holding back TEM and FTIR data, why they and Ryan never release any dust to independent testers, why Gage is unwilling to pay for an independent test, and why basically nothing has happened in 3 years since the publication of the Bentham paper.
It's MM doing the BSing here.
The value of the tests is in verifying or falsifying the thermite hypothesis. Ferrer has the DSC equipment and chips. The thermite camp could DSC test the chips under an inert atmosphere, if they haven't done so already, to determine if the chips thermite combust.
 
Last edited:
They have not met the burden of proof, because their results (especially their interpretation of them) could not be duplicated.

Until a contrary peer-reviewed paper is published, there is no proof that the Bentham paper findings could not be duplicated.

MM
 
Until a contrary peer-reviewed paper is published, there is no proof that the Bentham paper findings could not be duplicated.

MM

The point flew over your head. There is not enough detail in their paper to actually duplicate the experiments.

You even help support this by having to seek comments from the authors to clarify/define these procedures.

Peer-review would have done this before the paper got published.
 
Last edited:
The point flew over your head. There is not enough detail in their paper to actually duplicate the experiments.

You even help support this by having to seek comments from the authors to clarify/define these procedures.

Peer-review would have done this before the paper got published.

It would not have been approved if it was determined that the Bentham Paper findings had insufficient research to back them up.

Your amateur sideline opinions have no credibility, especially given the extent of your bias.

MM
 
It would not have been approved if it was determined that the Bentham Paper findings had insufficient research to back them up.

Your amateur sideline opinions have no credibility, especially given the extent of your bias.

MM

The research consisted of a check for $800, peer review was when it cleared the bank.
 
Last edited:
Until a contrary peer-reviewed paper is published, there is no proof that the Bentham paper findings could not be duplicated.

MM

Ok, so their results HAVE NOT been duplicated. Therefore they still HAVE NOT met the burden of proof. Especially since their interpretation regarding the DSC indicating thermite does not match the experimental results.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom