Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

I changed your bolding in order to highlight the real important part of this quote. Jones actually doesn't report any test of paint chips, he just refers to values fixed in literature.

What part of; "Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material." do you fail to understand?

If you wish to stay in denial, go for it.

MM
 
The Bentham Paper shows they found the Resistivity Test made candidate chips (chips of interest) identifiable.
Well, perhaps identifiable.
But that is not what you claimed:
You claimed that "Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'" - as "actually did so back then, "not that one could do so in future tests.
You claimed that "not every chip tested had such a low resistance" - where is the quotes support for that?
You claimed that they measured "paint chips" which "had a very high resistance".
I asked you support those three claims.


Bentham Paper:"We measured the resistivity of the red material (with very little gray adhering to one side) using a Fluke 8842A multimeter in order to compare with ordinary paints, using the formula:
...
This supports none of the three claims I asked you to support:
Neither the claim that "Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'"
Nor the claim that "not every chip tested had such a low resistance"
Nor the claim that they measured "paint chips" which "had a very high resistance".

Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 1010 ohm-m [31]."
This supports none of the three claims I asked you to support:
Neither the claim that "Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'"
Nor the claim that "not every chip tested had such a low resistance"
Nor the claim that they measured "paint chips" which "had a very high resistance".


To support my contention that Dr. Jones was quite familiar with the Resistivity Test
Which is none of your three earlier claims which I asked you to support with quotes as evidence.
This supports none of the three claims I asked you to support:
Neither the claim that "Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'"
Nor the claim that "not every chip tested had such a low resistance"
Nor the claim that they measured "paint chips" which "had a very high resistance".

and that he felt it was a valuable method for separating 'chips of interest' from paint;
I didn't ask you to show evidence for how Jones felt.

I asked you to show evidence that he did in fact use that method to find 'chips of interest'
I asked you to show evidence that they had in fact test results from chips with a higher resistance.
I asked you to show evidence that they did in fact test paint chips and that those had a high resistance.


Dr. Jones @9/11Blogger:

"Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints –
"Checked" - not "used this to select chips of interest"
"Paints" not "paint chips from the dust"

consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal.
Apparently, Jones implies that the red-gray chips all had this low resistivity, and none had a higher resistivity, as you claim.
Jones does not say that they tested paint chips.

There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material.
Sincerely,

Steven E. Jones"
Dr. Jones is not sincere.

None of this is evidence that he did in fact use that method to find 'chips of interest'
None of this is evidence they had in fact test results from chips with a higher resistance.
None of this is evidence that they did in fact test paint chips and that those had a high resistance.


Of course the above quotes are very familiar to you, but apparently you choose to ignore their meaning.
I am very familiar with them.

They still support none of the three claims you made and which I asked you to support:
You claimed that "Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'" - as "actually did so back then, "not that one could do so in future tests.
You claimed that "not every chip tested had such a low resistance" - where is the quotes support for that?
You claimed that they measured "paint chips" which "had a very high resistance".


I can assure you, I am not running.
LMAO
 
What part of; "Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material." do you fail to understand?

If you wish to stay in denial, go for it.

MM

Instead of being arrogant, just show me the part where Jones tested the resistivity of tnemec or laclede paint chips!
 
...
Dr. Harrit et al's paper clearly indicated that 'chips of interest' shared that low resistance in common.
...

Wrong.

Dr. Harrit et al's paper mentions the test being done on one (1) isolated chip that isn't further characterized except for its size.

For chips (plural) to "share" a common trait, you'd have to show that indeed you need more than one chip has that common trait.
Dr. Harrit et al's paper does no such thing.
 
In his May 2009 letter titled WHY THE RED/GRAY CHIPS ARE NOT PRIMER PAINT, Niels Harrit attempted to figure out the composition of the Tnemec primer that was specified for the perimeter columns, and specifically its Zinc- and Magnesium content. He committed a few serious errors, which I will now correct, to come up with a better estimate of what the composition MAY have been.

He references two tables with ingredients:

First, the Tnemec composittion as documents by NIST in NCSTAR 1-3C, Appendix D, Table D-1. This is actually two tables:

Pigment:
Iron Oxide|35.9%
Zinc Yellow|20.3%
Tnemec pigment (proprietary) |33.7%
Diat. Silica|10.1%
SUM | 100.0%
Vehicle (grouped and summed by me)
Raw and bodied Linseed oil|41.5%
Resins and agent|26.3%
Thinners|32.3%
SUM | 100.1%

Harrit's first mistake is to ignore that the (inorganic) pigments add up to 100%, and that the organic vehicle ingredients also add up to 100% (plus rounding error). He assumes in his discussion that, for example, Zinc Yellow is 20.3% of the wet paint, and that the (volatile) thinners are 32.3% of the wet paint.
He thinks that, when the 32.2% volatile thinners evaporate, and 67.8% solids are left, that then the Zinc Yellow would be (20.3/67.8)=29.9% of the dry paint.
This is of course WRONG. Pigments and vehicle are mixed in some proportion. If, for example, the pigments are 40% of the dry paint, and the vehicle then thus 60% of the dry paint, then Zinc Yellow would be (40% * 20.3%) = 8.1% of the dry paint. In this case, Harrit would have overestimated the Zinc-content by a factor of ca. 3.7


However, we do not know the proportion of pigment:vehicle in the wet or dry paint. As we will see, this can be estimated from further data.


The second table that Harrit uses comes from a Material Safety Data Sheet for Series 010 Tnemec Primer Red, dated 04/11/2003.

A word of caution: This data is 36 years younger than the Tnemec composition documented for the WTC in 1967! It is extremely likely that the recipe has been changed since! It is still a "modified alkyd" based primer, though.

This table lists ingredients only roughly:
Ingredient|lower bound %|exact %|upper boud %
Zinc compounds||2.98|
Organic Cobalt comp.||.10|
Iron Oxide Fume|1||5
Iron Oxide Fume|6||10
Quartz||4.36|
Talc|21||30
Ca silicates and aluminates|6||10
Amorph. Silica|1||5
Mineral Spirits, as Stoddard solvent||22.71|
SUM | 35 | 30,15 | 60
So the sum of all listed ingredients adds up to a value between 65.15% (lower bound) to 90.15% (upper bound). Not 100%! Where is the rest?

It is a bit strange that a pigment would include Stoddard solvent (white spirit) - if that is, as Harrit assumes, a pigment!

But looking at another, more contemporary MSDS from Tnemec, for example this for Series 10 Tnemec Primer Red Modied Alkyd Paint, we see there that there is still 10-30% talc, 1-5% quartz, 10-30% Stoddard solvent, 5-10% Ca-aluminates and silicates, 6-15% iron oxide fume, 1-5% Zinc compounds etc - but this time it also lists Alkyd Resin (10-30%), which is in line with the old 1967 composition (while some of the pigments are not!).

So I conclude:

Harrit's second mistake is to assume that the MSDS is for the proprietary Tnemec pigment, which makes up 33.7% of the pigment, when in fact it is the MDSD for the ready wet paint, as sold.

This mistake has two major effects:
First, he adds the Stoddard solvent (or 33.7% of it) to the volatile thinner, which he deducts in addition to the thinner he deducts for the vehicle composition, further increasing the overestimation of Zinc Yellow
Secondly, it makes him underestimate the Ca, Mg and Al content derived from the MSDS data.


Harrit's third mistake isn't quite as bad: He assumes that the paint composition hasn't changed from 1967 to 2003. We have to keep this in mind.


Now, knowing that the MSDS actually shows ingredients of the wet paint, we can use it to estimate the vehicle:pigment ratio! Here is how:

- The 1967 specification has 32.3% Thinners
- The 2003 MSDS has 22.71% Stoddard solvent
- I claim both are one and the same. I find it reasonable to assume that an alkyd based red primer formulated with thinner would in 2003 still have about the same ratio of thinner:resin+oil (volatile:non-volatile components). So if 22.71% of wet paint is 32.3% of vehicle, then vehicle is 22.71/32.3 = 70.3% of the wet paint, and pigments are 29.7% of the wet paint!

After the thinners evaporate, the composition of the dried paint is then
Iron Oxide|13.8%
Zinc Yellow|7.8%
Tnemec pigment|12.9%
Diat. Silica|3.9%
Vehicle|61.6%
Note that Harrit had a result of 34% Zinc Yellow in dry paint - wrong by a factor of more than 4.3!
(Actually, as linseed oil dries, it oxidizes, adding some mass of oxygen from air. On the other hand, I am not sure to what drying extent reactions also release some mass, so perhaps that cancels out to some extent)


I still have these pesky 12.9% of "Tnemec pigment (proprietary)", and I can only speculate what that is. The MSDSs list significant amounts of Talc (Mg3Si4O12H2), Calcium Silicates (Ca2SiO4) and Calcium Aluminates (Ca3Al2O6), so perhaps this Tnemec pigment is mostly mafde of these?


Assuming that the Tnemec pigment is 6 parts Talc, 1 part Ca-Silicates and 1 part Ca-Aluminates, and assuming that the sum formula of the vehicle is dominated by oxidized triglycerides from the linseed oil, averaging C9O4H16, I computed the following first guess for the elemental composition of 1967 Tnemec Red:

H: 5.3%
C: 35.4%
O: 36.0%
Mg: 1.9%
Al: 0.3%
Si: 4.9%
Ca: 1.5%
Cr: 2.2%
Fe: 9.6%
Zn: 2.8%

Note that the entire content of Ca, Mg and Al is based on very uncertain assumptions for the Tnemec proprietary pigment, as are 2/3 of the Si.


I ran this composition through a XEDS simulation - result and discussion in the next post.
 
Last edited:
Here is my XEDS simulaton for my first version of the 1967 Tnemec composition. Again, I made an assumption that the 12.9% proprietary Tnemec pigment might be
9.7% Talc (Mg3Si4O10(OH)2)
1.6% Calcium Silicates (Assumed as Ca2SiO4)
1.6% Calcium Aluminates (Assumed as Ca3Al2O6)

This is what it comes out as:

TnemecComposition1-MCsimulationofbulk20keV_zps53f6b0c0.png


Comparing this to the XEDS of primer paint from a WTC memorial that Jones presented in late 2009 (see my blog) reveals a few problems:

JonesPrimerPaint-2m48s_bottomright.jpg



1. I have too much Mg
2. I have too little Zn
3. I have too little Ca
4. I have proooobably too little Al
5. I have no S
6. I have no K
7. The C-peak is strangely low

Some possible explanations:

The 2003 and 2011 MSDSs for series 10 Tnemec red contain very serious amount of Talc - above 10 and 20%. I only put in just below 10%, and the magnesium comes out far too high. The best explanation would be that Tnemec changed the recipe and now includes a lot of Talc, back then there was little. I am pretty sure this has to be so.

I don't know any ingredient that would explain sulfur in Jones's XEDS. Could be the "driers and anti-skin" and/or "suspension agents" in the Temec vehicle that I kinda ignored.
But I also have to account for a very high Ca-peak in the real-world measurement.
Both together make me tend to think that gypsum contamination may be quite pervasive after all. It was descibed, for example by Steven Badger, working with RJ Lee, as 25% of the total dust, and even more of the very fine particulate.
Also, I am thinking about Calcium Carbonate, either as contamination or as ingredient. Any ideas/comments on that? Potassium Carbonate, too?

I can easily fix the somewhat low Al-peak by speculation on relatively more Ca-Aluminates, at the expense of Talc. I can also increase Ca-Silicates at the expense of Talc, to close the gap on Ca.

So I guess my next Composition will have a Tnemec pigment looking more like this:
6 1 part Talc
1 part Ca-Silicates
1 part Ca-Aluminates

And then I'll throw in some gypsum and some K, to see how I need of those to match the S- and K-peaks!

(Assuming some contamination helps me explain why Zn is too low)
 
Last edited:
What part of; "Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material." do you fail to understand?

If you wish to stay in denial, go for it.

MM

Major screw-up alert!

If they did perform the resistivity tests on the initial isolated pile to into red/gray layered chips, attracted by magnet, with low resistance (thermitic) and red/gray layered chips, attracted by magnet, with high resistance (paint), then why did they not run tests on those high resistance paint chips and publish the reports?

They had red/gray paint chips separated out from the initial pile yet that chose to get results from "other" paint types!

Don't you get how ridiculously stupid that is?

How did they miss that?
 
Why would he be so interested in how useful it was in sorting-out all the paint chips if he never used it?

Just to reiterate.

If they had separated out magnetically attracted, red/gray PAINT chips out of the initial isolated pile of red/gray chips, why did they use EXTERNAL REFERENCES and EXTERNAL "OTHER" PAINT to compare the thermitic red/gray chips to?

According to you and Harrit's group, they had the paint chips right there in front of them!!

:boggled:
 
Thanks a lot, Oystein!

I would omit Ca and S "issues", since there is a quite general "agreement" among both debunkers and truthers that massive surface contamination with calcium sulfate from wallboards is more than probable for unwashed chips.

Looking at the too high "Zn" peak for Jones' Tnemec hip, isn't it so that at the same position, Na peak is expected, therefore the overall peak at this position is (can be) a sum (superposition) of signals of both those elements?

(Also, K peak can be attributed to some contaminant or impurity in some pigment, as well as Mg: Almond explained us in the past that "Mg is simply everywhere as contaminant". But, Mg peak is higher in your valuable simulation than in MEK chip...)

Here is a Fig. 14 from Bentham paper (unwashed/unsoaked MEK chip):

picture.php


I would basically say that this spectrum is in a quite good accordance with your simulated spectrum of Tnemec (except Ca, S and Mg peaks)...
 
Last edited:
Thanks a lot, Oystein!

I would completely omit Ca and S "issues", since there is a quite general "agreement" among both debunkers and truthers that massive surface contamination with calcium sulfate from wallboards is more than probable for unwashed chips.
...
(Also, K peak can be attributed to some contaminant or impurity in some pigment, as well as Mg: Almond explained us in the past that "Mg is simply everywhere as contaminant".
True, but I am doing it to get a feel for how much contamination there might be in those spectra (Fig 14 and Jones's Tnemec sample). I am fairly confident that the answer is: Really not so very much. If, for example, it turns out that, say, 5% gypsum and 1% K-whatever as surface contamination suffice to get a good spectrum match, then we know that 95% of what's left is the paint sample itself! If we then determine <1% Al in the sample with contamination, it will stay <1% Al in a sample cleaned of gypsum and and other stuff!

Looking at the too high "Zn" peak for MEK chip, isn't it so that at the same position, Na peak is expected, therefore the overall peak at this position is (can be) a sum (superposition) of signals of both those elements?
Possible in theory, but where do we get Na from? I am clearly fudging parameters here, to make actual Tnemec ("on steel") match theoretical Tnemec ("on paper"), and I would like to do so with as few unknown entities as possible. Gypsum is a rather obvious "unknown entities", but the sources for K and Na are less obvious, in my opinion.

But, Mg peak is higher in your very valuable simulation than in MEK chip...)
Right, which is, IMO, sufficient proof that even the lower bound of Talv content found in the 2003 and 2011 MSDSs is too high, and thus inconsistent, with experimental 1967 Tnemec. I am therefore free to reduce the Talc-content to make this data point fit, and increase the Calcium-compounds accordingly. You'll see, it will be a pretty nice fit.

As for the discrepancy in C/O ratio, some part of it can be caused by the necessarily imprecise input for polymer binder, some can be perhaps caused by some artifacts of measurements...
Yes, C and O are always somewhat all over the place. I wiki'ed "linseed oil" and "alkyd" and "polyester resin" and made half-intelligent guesses which sum-formulas best apply to that Tnemec formula. I decided on a molar C:O ratio of 9:4. In undried linseed oil, the dominant component of the wet paint, it's actually close to 9:2, and I merely assumed that drying (oxidation) would add another 2 parts O. I could re-run my sim with an alternative ration of 9:3, that would increase the C-peak and decrease the O-peak and really help to get a better match - or maybe I find a good polymer scientist somewhere who has a better grasp on estimating those ratios :D

I would say (after the first quick glance) that only your points 1. a and 7 are really "points". You just brought another good (although indirect) evidence that MEK chip was Tnemec primer chip:cool:
It's gonna get better ;)

Once I have a fairly good model for 1967 Tnemec and an idea about gypsum contamination, I can increase/devrease the gypsum part to perhaps also match Fig. 14!
 
Sorry, before your have answered, I deleted my original post and substituted it by other one (which shows the XEDS of MEK chip). But does not matter that much.

As for Na a K, I would say that they can be present in some pigments as impurities, why not?
 
Last edited:
Sorry, before your have answered, I deleted my original post and substituted it by other one (which shows the XEDS of MEK chip). But does not matter that much.
No problem ;)

As for Na a K, I would say that they can be present in some pigments as impurities, why not?
Can, but quite unnecessary.

Oystein: As for chemistry/curing/oxidation of alkyd/linseed resins, it is pretty complex (see e.g https://openaccess.leidenuniv.nl/bitstream/handle/1887/2309/01.pdf?sequence=2) and all I can say now is that you are right and during oxidation, some oxygen is indeed added to the resin elemental composition...

That's alright for the time being; getting the C-peak right is always the most difficult thing; it affects the overall mass, and thus the percentage of, for example, Al in the sample; but there isn't room for a huge error here. Less than factor 2. I am always keeoing an eye on Al-content vs. Fe-content and organic content, and it doesn't matter much if this Fig 14 chip has 0.8% Al or 1.6% or 0.4% - all these numbers are clearly much too little.

And as you will soon see (working on it!), contamination is really very little! :)
 
Alright, I got the Tnemec formula!


A few posts ago, I showed why the 1967 Tnemec composition is approximately this (by weight):

Iron oxide|Fe 2 O 3 |13.8%
Zinc Chromate|ZnCrO 4 |7.8%
Diat. Silica|SiO 2 |3.9%
Proprietary Pigment | ? | 12.9%
Sum of pigments |...| 38.4%
Vehicle|C 9 O 3-4 H 16 |61.6%
SUM |...| 100%

The proportion of Pigment:Vehicle may be off somewhat, but this will not have a great effect overall. I am more interested in the ratios of the metals amongst each other - having C and O off doesn't affect that.
In the end, vehicle percentage won't be off by more than +/- 20%.

The more important unknown here is the proprietary Tnemec pigment. In a previous post, I gave reasons why among its major components may be
Talc (Mg3Si4O12H2)
Calcium Silicates (probably Ca2SiO4)
Calcium Aluminates (probably Ca3Al2O6)

In my first simualtion, I assumed that talc would be dominant among these three, as the 2003 and 2011 MSDSs show a high talc content:
9.7% talc
1.6% Al-Silicates
1.6% Al-Aluminates
but it turned out that the actual amount of Magnesium meaured by Jones in actual Tnemec is much too low for that. i concluded that Tnemec Corp must have changed that pigment.



Now the new data:

In my next sim, I speculated that perhaps the 12.9% Proprietary Pigment is 4.3% each of the three substances mentioned.
The resulting XEDS-Spectrum os this:
http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums...ion2-analyticalsimofbulk20keV_zps2eeaa9bf.png
Closer to Jones's spectrum, but still too much Mg, too little Ca:

JonesPrimerPaint-2m48s_bottomright.jpg


But the next pass was satisfying, with
2.3% talc
6.3% Ca-silicates
4.3% Ca-aluminates

TnemecComposition3-MCsimulationofbulk20keV_zps5eeac552.png


This time I am happy with the relative abundance of Mg and Al. My Zn-peak is lower than Jones's, but my Cr-peak higher. This could well be the making of Jones's SEM-equipment vs. how my simulator works. That Zn-peak near 1.0 keV is the L-alpha level of Zn. It appears as if Jones's L-alpha level of Fe also is relatively higher compared to his K-alpha than my Fe L-alpha.
(We know that there should be equal molar amounts of Zn and Cr, as Zn-Chromate is the only compound in that paint which has these two elements)


Still, I am missing S and K, and my Ca peak is too low.
So I played around a bit with different levels of contamination with gypsum and potassium, and here is my best result:

TnemecComposition3Contam1-MCsimulationofbulk20keV_zps6227440a.png


Compared with Jones, and gauging S and K against the Mg and Al peaks (both K-alpha), it seems like this level of contamination, with 2% gypsum and 0.5% potassium, is slightly overestimated. Ca is still not quite on the same lavel, but close enough.
0.5% pure potassium would probably mean ca. 2% of some potassium compound - so it would seem that Jones's paint chip has on the order of 3-5% contamination with gypsum and perhaps something else. This something else could easily be within the paint, not on the surface, while 2% gypsum on the surface might be reasonable.


So since I got a really nice match with Jones's piece of actual Tnemec, I say that the composition of Tnemec in fact be modeled as:
Pigment: 38.4%
Iron oxide|Fe 2 O 3 |13.8%
Zinc Chromate|ZnCrO 4 |7.8%
Diat. Silica|SiO 2 |3.9%
Ca-Silicates||6.3%
Ca-Aluminates||4.3%
Talc||2.3%[/COLOR]

Vehicle: 61.6%

Where the Pigment:Vehicle ratio may also be anywhere between 50:50 and 30:70; but I commit to the ratios minerals / metals amongst each other!
 
Oystein: great, thanks!

But since it is a Valentine' day, I'm going now to some pub with my girlfriend Daniela and I will study this your post tommorow...
 
Finally, I tried to match my Tnemec-Formula, plus gypsum and potassium, with Fig 14:

ActiveThermiticMaterial_Fig14.jpg


This proved to be not quite as easy. A combination that matches some feautures qualitatively is

88.75% Tnemec
+ 11% Gypsum
+ 0.25 Potassium (=ca. 1% Potassium-compound)

TnemecComposition3Contam2-MCsimulationofbulk20keV_zpsa262cc42.png


This has relatively too little Fe - perhaps Jones caught a little bit of gray layer? A little too much Si, or too little Ca. Didn't want to add more gypsum, as I felt the sulfur peak is enough.


Anyway, this should give us a feel, and I am confident in the followng claims:

  • The MEK-soaked chip really IS Tnemec: I get a very nice match for Mg, Zn, Cr, Al; Si and Fe are in the ballpark
  • There really is some contamination, but it is on the order of no or little more than 15% of the total weight. In turn this means that ca. 85% of that signal can in fact be traced to the chip
  • Not necessary to bitch about missing Zn - it's really quite exactly what must be expected from the 1967 Tnemec specification.
  • This Tnemec formulation contains 0.8-0.9% by weight Al. Fig 14 is a close enough match with my simulated Tnemec, with little contamination, that we can conclude that this chip really contains not significantly more than 1% Al, and most likely <1%. With this little Al, it's preposterous to think it might be "thermitic"


That's all, folks :)
 
Instead of being arrogant, just show me the part where Jones tested the resistivity of tnemec or laclede paint chips!

Show me that either of those two paints have a tabulated electrical resistivity approaching 10 ohm-m and I'll better understand your insistence.

MM
 
Show me that either of those two paints have a tabulated electrical resistivity approaching 10 ohm-m and I'll better understand your insistence.

MM
What would be better is if you could show they could make these measurements (consistently) using the crude methods the admitted to using.

Did they actually show this data or are you just believing they did it? :rolleyes:
 
Hey Running MM!

Show me that either of those two paints have a tabulated electrical resistivity approaching 10 ohm-m and I'll better understand your insistence.

MM
LOL :D

Right after you show me that
  • ..."Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'" - as in "actually did so back then", not "one could do so in future tests".
  • ..."not every chip tested had such a low resistance" - As in "Dr. Jones measured chips that had a higher resistance"
  • ...they measured "paint chips" which "had a very high resistance". Or any red-gray "paint chips" for that matter.


LMAO :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom