Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Misinterpret much?

Did Dr. Harrit say some of the randomly selected chips from the isolation pile
that measured 10 ohm-m were found to be paint?

Ah no.

Dr. Harrit et al's paper clearly indicated that 'chips of interest' shared that low resistance in common.

MM

That isn't what you said. You said that the resistivity test was used as a criterion for selecting the chips. This is patently false, according to Harrit's own words; the resistivity test was performed post facto. Please acknowledge your error.
 
That isn't what you said. You said that the resistivity test was used as a criterion for selecting the chips. This is patently false, according to Harrit's own words; the resistivity test was performed post facto. Please acknowledge your error.


Post facto...after the isolation by magnet.

Never did I say it was useful before the isolation by magnetism.

MM
 
Misinterpret much?

Did Dr. Harrit say some of the randomly selected chips from the isolation pile
that measured 10 ohm-m were found to be paint?

Ah no.

No, YOU did!

Dr. Jones has publicly stated that there were a lot of red/gray chips collected, many of which were paint, and that their elimination by Resistivity testing significantly reduced the number of chips to be examined prior to further testing.

MM

You clearly say they eliminated paint chips from the first isolated sample (using a magnet and the visual red/gray layers as a criteria to determine the first sample) by the resistivity tests.

For crying out loud MM, do you even comprehend what you post???!!!

The spinning you are know doing to save your butt is making me dizzy.

:boggled:
 
Misinterpret much?

Did Dr. Harrit say some of the randomly selected chips from the isolation pile
that measured 10 ohm-m were found to be paint?

Ah no.

Again. YOU did. Here is another post of yours.

Nowhere has Dr. Jones et al indicated that the Resistivity test was only used once.

Why would he be so interested in how useful it was in sorting-out all the paint chips if he never used it?

He certainly expected Dr. Millette to.

You CLEARLY say that it was useful in removing paint chips from the sample.

So according to you, after all your garbage, this is how the testing went.

1. They seperated red/gray layered chips from the original samples FIRST by using a magnet AND making sure all the chips had red/gray layers
2. Then they performed the resistivity tests on the isolated group for sort out all the paint chips
3. Then they performed all the other tests in the paper

Is that correct MM? Did I misinterpret what you think was done? You've changed your explanation so many times now in order to look like you're correct that you can't even keep track of what you've said.

You CLEARLY think they had determined which red/gray layered chips were paint chips and which were thermitic. If that is the case, why were these paint chips not tested to see what their composition was? Why were no paint chips tested? Why did they have to use other sources of paint chips to compare/test if they separated them?

You're in a world of hurt my friend.

;)
 
No, YOU did!

You clearly say they eliminated paint chips from the first isolated sample (using a magnet and the visual red/gray layers as a criteria to determine the first sample) by the resistivity tests.

For crying out loud MM, do you even comprehend what you post???!!!

The spinning you are know doing to save your butt is making me dizzy.

:boggled:

Sigh.

Read much or is English a foreign language for you?

The resistivity test was used on isolated chips.

Harriet et al said in their paper that it was a useful method for eliminating paint chips (very high resistance) from 'chips of interest' (very low resistance - 10 ohms).

MM
 
Sigh.

Read much or is English a foreign language for you?

The resistivity test was used on isolated chips.

Harriet et al said in their paper that it was a useful method for eliminating paint chips (very high resistance) from 'chips of interest' (very low resistance - 10 ohms).

MM

So, below is the order you think they did the testing then correct?
1. They seperated red/gray layered chips from the original samples FIRST by using a magnet AND making sure all the chips had red/gray layers
2. Then they performed the resistivity tests on the isolated group for sort out all the paint chips
3. Then they performed all the other tests in the paper

Another question MM. If they in fact separated paint chips from the original isolated pile, why didn't they perform and tests on them? Why didn't they determine what the composition of those paint chips were instead of citing NIST's report and the composition of the paint used? Why did they test chips from an outside source if they determined paint chips in the samples?

You're WAY off base.
 
Misinterpret much?

Did Dr. Harrit say some of the randomly selected chips from the isolation pile
that measured 10 ohm-m were found to be paint?

Ah no.

Just in case you missed it.

YOU are the one that said they used the resistivity test to separate out the paint chips. Here is your quote:

Nowhere has Dr. Jones et al indicated that the Resistivity test was only used once.

Why would he be so interested in how useful it was in sorting-out all the paint chips if he never used it?

He certainly expected Dr. Millette to.


bolding is mine

MM

Pay close attention now MM. The "it" in the second hilited part of you quote refers to "the Resistivity test" in the first hilited part of your quote.

So, did you or did you not imply that Jones et al use the resistivity test to separate out the paint chips from the original isolated sample?
 
Just in case you missed it.

YOU are the one that said they used the resistivity test to separate out the paint chips. Here is your quote:



Pay close attention now MM. The "it" in the second hilited part of you quote refers to "the Resistivity test" in the first hilited part of your quote.

So, did you or did you not imply that Jones et al use the resistivity test to separate out the paint chips from the original isolated sample?

Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest' because it was discovered that they had a very low resistance of 10 ohm-m.

Obviously, not every chip tested had such a low resistance.

It was found that paint chips had a very high resistance.

So yes, it is safe to say that the initial isolation pile represented a collection of chips comprised of paint, other magnetically attracted materials, and 'chips of interest'.

By selecting chips with a low resistance of 10 ohm-m, Dr. Jones was indeed separating them from high resistance chips (paint etc.).

MM
 
Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest' because it was discovered that they had a very low resistance of 10 ohm-m.
Can you provide a quote as evidence that "Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'"? Thanks.

Obviously, not every chip tested had such a low resistance.
Can you provide a quote as evidence that "not every chip tested had such a low resistance"? Or that they tested any other chip than the one described in the paper? Or that they ever tested any chip which they considered to be paint? Thanks.

It was found that paint chips had a very high resistance.
Can you provide a quote as evidence that they measured any "paint chips" at all and that they "had a very high resistance"? Thanks.
 
Can you provide a quote as evidence that "Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'"? Thanks.

Have you forgotten the reference to this subject in the Bentham Paper?

Have you forgotten Dr. Jones's comments on this subject at 9/11Blogger?

Can you provide a quote as evidence that "not every chip tested had such a low resistance"? Or that they tested any other chip than the one described in the paper? Or that they ever tested any chip which they considered to be paint? Thanks.

Since they found that paint chips gave very high resistance readings, I do not understand why you are asking whether every chip they resistivity-tested had a low resistance?

Can you provide a quote as evidence that they measured any "paint chips" at all and that they "had a very high resistance"? Thanks.

See my first response. You have made it abundantly clear you've thoroughly perused the Bentham Paper so it is baffling that you would ask such inane questions.

MM
 
Have you forgotten the reference to this subject in the Bentham Paper?

Have you forgotten Dr. Jones's comments on this subject at 9/11Blogger?



Since they found that paint chips gave very high resistance readings, I do not understand why you are asking whether every chip they resistivity-tested had a low resistance?



See my first response. You have made it abundantly clear you've thoroughly perused the Bentham Paper so it is baffling that you would ask such inane questions.

MM
I recommend you refresh yourself on what the letter "s" indicates, 'MM
 
Have you forgotten the reference to this subject in the Bentham Paper?

Have you forgotten Dr. Jones's comments on this subject at 9/11Blogger?
No I haven't forgotten them.
Why don't you quote them? You will find that these quotes will not support your assertion that in fact "Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'".

Since they found that paint chips gave very high resistance readings, I do not understand why you are asking whether every chip they resistivity-tested had a low resistance?
I ask because I want to know if anything Jones or Harrit ever wrote supports your assertion that "not every chip tested had such a low resistance" Or that they ever tested any chip which they considered to be paint.

So please - quote, MM!

See my first response. You have made it abundantly clear you've thoroughly perused the Bentham Paper so it is baffling that you would ask such inane questions.
Ok, so you can't provide a quote to prove that they measured any "paint chips" at all and that they "had a very high resistance". I knew that you could not and would not.


Run, MM, run, while we laugh at your fleeing butt! :D
 
See my first response. You have made it abundantly clear you've thoroughly perused the Bentham Paper so it is baffling that you would ask such inane questions.

MM

Have you read the section about the resistivity test? Here it is.
7. Could the Red Chip Material be Ordinary Paint?
We measured the resistivity of the red material (with very
little gray adhering to one side) using a Fluke 8842A multimeter in order to compare with ordinary paints, using the
formula:
Specific resistivity = RA / L
where R = resistance (ohms); A = cross-sectional area (m
2
); L
= thickness (m).
Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5
mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude
less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 10
10
ohm-m [31].

Can you please point out where in that section (or any other section for that matter) they say they tested actual paint chips. Or did they just refer to the resistances in the paper noted in reference note 31:
Abu Ayana YM, El-Sawy SM, Salah SH. Zinc-ferrite pigment for corrosion protection. Anti-Corros Methods Mater 1997; 44(6): 381-8

So, as Oystein has asked:
Can you provide a quote as evidence that they measured any "paint chips" at all and that they "had a very high resistance"? Thanks.
 
Last edited:
So yes, it is safe to say that the initial isolation pile represented a collection of chips comprised of paint, other magnetically attracted materials, and 'chips of interest'.

Answer something MM. How did they know they had "paint chips" in that pile of "magnetically attracted material, high resistance" chips that they separated out form the initial isolated pile?

Were they just assuming there were paint chips in that isolated pile?

If they KNEW they had paint chips (not sure how they determined that), why weren't those paint chips tested and the results published? Why did they need to refer to outside sources for paint resistivity measurements and paint composition? That's a major blunder n my book.
 
MM - you have been found out making rubbish up. It was obvious you were doing so from the start because the paper is quite clear with regard to the electrical test. We now have quotes from the authors of the paper which clearly conflict with your false made up version of events.

You don't have the courage or moral fortitude to own up to your mistake and are now just twisting like a worm on a hook.

You are the perfect example of dishonesty that all truthers show. Give it up. Admit you were wrong.
 
MM - you have been found out making rubbish up. It was obvious you were doing so from the start because the paper is quite clear with regard to the electrical test. We now have quotes from the authors of the paper which clearly conflict with your false made up version of events.

You don't have the courage or moral fortitude to own up to your mistake and are now just twisting like a worm on a hook.

You are the perfect example of dishonesty that all truthers show. Give it up. Admit you were wrong.

What I think is this.

They assumed the entire pile of chips they isolated by the red/gray layer visual and magnet attraction criteria were ALL thermitic in nature. They took a random selection of chips from that isolated pile and did a resistivity test on them. They then determined that the results of the few random chips tested via resistivity (all being low resistivity) were used to stereotype the entire isolated pile as being low resitivity, therefore not being paint.

If you had chips that all had the same red/gray layer, were all attracted to a magnet, and you KNEW some were paint chips, why on God's green earth would you not test a red/gray layered, magnetically attracted "paint chip" and compare the results to that of a red/gray layered, magnetcially attracted "thermictic chip" to see what the differences were?
 
What I think is this.

They assumed the entire pile of chips they isolated by the red/gray layer visual and magnet attraction criteria were ALL thermitic in nature. They took a random selection of chips from that isolated pile and did a resistivity test on them. They then determined that the results of the few random chips tested via resistivity (all being low resistivity) were used to stereotype the entire isolated pile as being low resitivity, therefore not being paint.

If you had chips that all had the same red/gray layer, were all attracted to a magnet, and you KNEW some were paint chips, why on God's green earth would you not test a red/gray layered, magnetically attracted "paint chip" and compare the results to that of a red/gray layered, magnetcially attracted "thermictic chip" to see what the differences were?

This quote from the Bentham paper further supports the notion that they assumed the entire pile of red/gray, magneticaly isolated chips were ALL thermitic and none were paint.

In June
2007, Dr. Steven Jones observed distinctive bi-layered chips, with both a red and a gray layer, in a sample of the WTC
dust. Initially, it was suspected these might be dried paint chips, but after closer inspection and testing, it was shown that this was not the case. Further testing was then performed
on the red/gray chips in an attempt to ascertain their composition and properties.

There is no quote or test anywhere that I can find in the Bentham paper that shows or proves that "paint chips" or other "non-thermitic chips" were in the initial isolated pile.
 
Why would he be so interested in how useful it was in sorting-out all the paint chips if he never used it?

Yet another question MM. How can one sort out ALL the paint chips from the isolated pile by selecting random chips from said pile as quoted in Harrit's email to me below:
The resistivity test were done in random on the chips already isolated as described.
 
"Can you provide a quote as evidence that "Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'"? Thanks."
"Have you forgotten the reference to this subject in the Bentham Paper?

Have you forgotten Dr. Jones's comments on this subject at 9/11Blogger?"
"No I haven't forgotten them.
Why don't you quote them? You will find that these quotes will not support your assertion that in fact "Dr. Jones used the Resistivity Test to find 'chips of interest'.

I ask because I want to know if anything Jones or Harrit ever wrote supports your assertion that "not every chip tested had such a low resistance" Or that they ever tested any chip which they considered to be paint.

So please - quote, MM!

Ok, so you can't provide a quote to prove that they measured any "paint chips" at all and that they "had a very high resistance". I knew that you could not and would not.
."

The Bentham Paper shows they found the Resistivity Test made candidate chips (chips of interest) identifiable.

Bentham Paper:"We measured the resistivity of the red material (with very little gray adhering to one side) using a Fluke 8842A multimeter in order to compare with ordinary paints, using the formula:

Specific resistivity = RA / L
where R = resistance (ohms); A = cross-sectional area (m2); L = thickness (m).

Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 1010 ohm-m [31]."

To support my contention that Dr. Jones was quite familiar with the Resistivity Test and that he felt it was a valuable method for separating 'chips of interest' from paint;

Dr. Jones @9/11Blogger:

"Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material.

Why would he not measure the electrical resistivity of his red material (discussed in our paper [Bentham Paper]) right off? That's what gets me – he could have saved himself a lot of time. Finally he gets to TEM analysis, and finds that he has titanium oxide! How can he claim its the same material? What a waste of time. I hope you will not make the same mistake.

Sincerely,

Steven E. Jones"

Of course the above quotes are very familiar to you, but apparently you choose to ignore their meaning.

I can only assume your failure to comprehend the obvious stems from your anguish.
The Resistivity Test destroys your beloved LeClede Paint hypothesis.

"Run, MM, run, while we laugh at your fleeing butt! :D"

I can assure you, I am not running.

MM
 
Last edited:
"... Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 1010 ohm-m [31]."

I changed your bolding in order to highlight the real important part of this quote. Jones actually doesn't report any test of paint chips, he just refers to values fixed in literature.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom