Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

I do not see what connection you are trying to make?

A Resistivity reading would not subject the sample to a high voltage electron beam.

A 9V battery in a Multimeter should suffice.

Because of its 10 ohm-m resistivity, I do not believe anyone would recommend the red-layer material for wiring their house.

But even a 5-year old could quickly learn how to select low resistance chips. Well maybe not. But certainly any young adult.

What makes it easy is the huge gap between 10 and 1010 ohm-m. Fortunately, 10 ohms is an easy reading to obtain compared to useful readings below 0.

On the old Simpson Multimeters on the 105 Ohm Scale, the meter would be swinging from one end to the other measuring 10 ohm vs 1010 ohm resistances.

The resistivity of the gray-layer is irrelevant if it is the resistivity of the red-layer which is being tested.

The Bentham Paper said the chips were discernible by eye and range up to 3mm.

As long as one of the probes is electrically contacting the red-layer surface, and assuming the other probe is also electrically contacting the red-layer or the gray-layer, a useful reading should be obtainable. Red to red is best as it eliminates the possible addition of resistance from the gray layer.

MM

Listen to yourself - assuming, should. In other words, conjecture in the absence of real data.
 
jtl: Why are you talking about paints in this respect? I asked you if the people whom developed superthermite did tests in air, and if so if they also repeated them in inert air to confirm the results of the air tests? So, in the references given by Harrit, are there no ignition tests in air?
First of all, you refer to a partial email by some JREF member, which raises alarm bells. Then it only refers to one paper and ignition in nitrogen in that paper. What about all the other papers Harrit refers to? Finally this email makes it rather clear that the authors have also done tests in air, which makes me believe that some other papers may include air tests.

If this is true then this JREF email would be a clear exercise in cherry picking. I have started to download some of those papers so I will check myself.

Kminek: Check it

Why don´t you just answer the questions? Did you not check for yourself before you threw mud at the tests in air?

You know, it is pretty normal to check in the available literature how this and this stuff may behave. And Harrit again failed in this respect.

They did perform tests on paints, which goes further than just checking papers for theoretical behavior. I agree they should have included a DSC trace for those samples to compare.

(There are some other MCC curves for other polymers available, which show exotherms at higher or lower temperatures, sometimes with two or more "peaks", but I just chose curves which are close to Bentham curves.)

And as predicted it is possible to get curves that are close to the Bentham peaks before those epoxies are mixed with flame-retardants, but then they start to get much fatter and as you say sometimes you have multiple peaks spreading over a wide range. What we need is an epoxy paint sample, see comment below.

So, for Tnemec (or Laclede or any other paint based on combustible polymeric binder and incombustible pigments), we can expect the typical thermal behavior of paints: at high temperatures under air, all organics/polymers are completely combusted and only inorganic pigments remain.

If Harrit considered this obvious and fully expected finding (paint layer basically remains to be a layer after heating, because of remaining inorganic pigments) as a proof of stability, well, then the paint is stable in this regard.
Otherwise, no paint (with any usual carbon-based polymer binder) can be regarded as really thermally stable. Binder is always combusted, no way how to avoid these inevitable processes.

What Harrit says is quite clear. NIST did tests on Tnemec which show that this paint is thermally stable to something like 700 degrees, i.e. it does not ignite at those temperatures, which does NOT suggest that chips of this paint with a ray layer would ignite at 430 and produce spheres. Maybe LaCLede would be more likely?

Jtl, what are you talking about??? Is it your topic here these unpublished alleged XRD results of Jones? Have you see any of these results? No is the answer.
Prior their publishing (at least in some white paper or so), their validity/importance is of course a plain zero No need to discuss them.

That is one way to look at things. Of course Jones and Basile et al could say the same thing about all the theories discussed on this forum, since none of you have done any tests and published the results.:blush:
 
So you do not believe that an electrical resistance of 100,000 ohms when compared to 10 ohms, is not like comparing an insulator to a conductor?

MM

Typically, when I'm making sure something is total isolated, I look for greater than 1 or 2 megohms. I would say 100kΩ is a bad connection but so is 10Ω. It really depends on the voltage and amps.

The circuits I'm testing for isolation (from the frame etc) are 12 - 80VDC up to 800 amps. 100KΩ would bleed current through in that scenario and fail the insulation test.
 
That is one way to look at things. Of course Jones and Basile et al could say the same thing about all the theories discussed on this forum, since none of you have done any tests and published the results.:blush:

You seem to have forgotten Jim Millette. :D

What tests have you done and where are your results :blush:
 
Why don´t you just answer the questions? Did you not check for yourself before you threw mud at the tests in air?

Hehe;)
I read "superthermite papers" cited in Bentham papers many months ago. Just... follow me.
Sometimes, authors did some "tests" even under air, since they could be sure that they had a kind of thermite.
But important in our respect is the plain fact that Harrit et al compared their DSC curves with one single "superthermite" curve published in paper 28. And since this curve was measured under pure nitrogen, and Gash explained in detail why in his e-mail, it was a duty of Bentham authors to run their DSC experiments under inert as well. They did not do that, hence they failed to follow original protocol. And all their DSC results are fully compatible with the combustion of polymer binder under air;)

They did perform tests on paints, which goes further than just checking papers for theoretical behavior. I agree they should have included a DSC trace for those samples to compare.

Sigh... Tests (namely solubility tests) on unspecified paints are pretty idiotic, as I have tried to explain you several times. Some paints (binders in them) are insoluble, some are soluble, some swell to various extent in a good solvent. Bentham team provided by these tests only one info: they did not know what they were talking about:D

And as predicted it is possible to get curves that are close to the Bentham peaks before those epoxies are mixed with flame-retardants, but then they start to get much fatter and as you say sometimes you have multiple peaks spreading over a wide range. What we need is an epoxy paint sample, see comment below.

I mentioned that other MCC curves for other polymers than epoxy can have sometimes even two well separated peaks or can be broad. But for epoxy resins, curves I saw are pretty close to Bentham DSC curves. Some of them are shown in my post 1410. It is very apparent for anyone who does not suffer temporary blindness that they represent a very good match with DSC curves in Bentham paper, in a clear contradiction with the curve of superthermite from paper of Tillotson and Gash:cool:

What Harrit says is quite clear. NIST did tests on Tnemec which show that this paint is thermally stable to something like 700 degrees, i.e. it does not ignite at those temperatures, which does NOT suggest that chips of this paint with a ray layer would ignite at 430 and produce spheres. Maybe LaCLede would be more likely?

No, you are wrong and Harrit was wrong as well. I repeat, if Tnemec contains organic polymer binder (alkyd-linsees resin), this binder is inevitably combusted at some temperature range under air, but fairly below 700 degrees. I can easily bet all my money that I am right;)
But you can be right that Tnemec is not the source of microspheres we see in Bentham paper. Who knows.
You have anyway brought here one interesting info. You quoted Jones who claims that some chips are non-glossy and hard (and are WTC paint according to Jones, probably Tnemec, since Jones owned the samples of Tnemec for comparison). Others are more glossy and softer/more flexible, according to Jones, who thinks that they are thermitic. This could mean that they form microspheres when heated. And they can be Laclede paint, as you noted. All this might be a good clue how to separate chips suitable for possible heating tests:cool:

Perhaps it's a time to ask Jim Millette (with a necessary help of Chris Mohr): please, have you observed that some of your chips (their red layers) look glossy under microscope, whereas others are non-glossy/dull?
 
Last edited:
Hehe;)
I read "superthermite papers" cited in Bentham papers many months ago. ... they failed to follow original protocol.
Wait - hasn't jtl already detailed, bullet by bullet, the protocol given by the LNLL scientiests, and documents how Harrit e.al. followed it bullet by bullet? Or ... he has not?? :eek:


You have anyway brought here one interesting info. You quoted Jones who claims that some chips are non-glossy and hard
Actually, I brought that here ;)

(and are WTC paint according to Jones, probably Tnemec, since Jones owned the samples of Tnemec for comparison). Others are more glossy and softer/more flexible, according to Jones, who thinks that they are thermitic.
Urr I am too lazy at the moment to re-read, but wasn't it the other way round? Tnemec chips more ductile und dull, "thermitic" chips more brittle and glossy?
 
Oystein: Sorry for the mismatch, you are right, according to Jones, some chips should be more ductile and dull, other should be more brittle and glossy;)

And sorry again, if you brought this topic here before Jtl.

Personally, I have very limited experience with optical microscopy, so I don't know how easy is to distinguish e.g. dull and glossy materials. And from the Millette's micrographs, it is not clear if chips differ somehow in this respect.
 
I do not see what connection you are trying to make?

A Resistivity reading would not subject the sample to a high voltage electron beam.

A 9V battery in a Multimeter should suffice.

Because of its 10 ohm-m resistivity, I do not believe anyone would recommend the red-layer material for wiring their house.

But even a 5-year old could quickly learn how to select low resistance chips. Well maybe not. But certainly any young adult.

What makes it easy is the huge gap between 10 and 1010 ohm-m. Fortunately, 10 ohms is an easy reading to obtain compared to useful readings below 0.
On the old Simpson Multimeters on the 105 Ohm Scale, the meter would be swinging from one end to the other measuring 10 ohm vs 1010 ohm resistances.

The resistivity of the gray-layer is irrelevant if it is the resistivity of the red-layer which is being tested.

The Bentham Paper said the chips were discernible by eye and range up to 3mm.

As long as one of the probes is electrically contacting the red-layer surface, and assuming the other probe is also electrically contacting the red-layer or the gray-layer, a useful reading should be obtainable. Red to red is best as it eliminates the possible addition of resistance from the gray layer.

MM
I didn't know they had meter long chips.
 
You still have nothing remotely like the DSC conditions
How do you know? You don't know that!

and you don´t get the molten iron spheres.
How do you know? You don't know that!

"Bloomery" still needs about 1100 degrees air temp and prolonged exposure to carbon monoxide to work,
Nope.

Again it does NOT get you iron, you end up with "sponge iron" that is porous and filled with slag,
How do you know? You don't know that!

prone to oxidation and ignition from air exposure.
Wouldn't the same be true for iron from a thermite reaction? Yes, it would - another excellent reason to do the DSC test under inert gas until residue has cooled to room temperature.

This is besides the fact that this "sponge iron" is not melted, so no spheres!
How do you know? You don't know that!
 
Kminek: I read "superthermite papers" cited in Bentham papers many months ago. Just... follow me.
Sometimes, authors did some "tests" even under air, since they could be sure that they had a kind of thermite.
But important in our respect is the plain fact that Harrit et al compared their DSC curves with one single "superthermite" curve published in paper 28. And since this curve was measured under pure nitrogen, and Gash explained in detail why in his e-mail, it was a duty of Bentham authors to run their DSC experiments under inert as well.

I was right, the developers did tests in inert atmosphere and sometimes in air, depending on papers. The tests in air were NOT followed up with tests in inert to confirm them, and the authors do not state that it must be done.
So there is absolutely no reason to throw mud at the DSC tests in air.

And all their DSC results are fully compatible with the combustion of polymer binder under air

And I am sure Millette will be glad to prove you right with paint tests, but until then words are cheap.

Sigh... Tests (namely solubility tests) on unspecified paints are pretty idiotic, as I have tried to explain you several times. Some paints (binders in them) are insoluble, some are soluble, some swell to various extent in a good solvent.

They did MEK and ignition tests on paints, and in this case I was actually talking about the ignition tests. I have agreed that it is a weakness that they did not show the results in the paper, so this should make Millette´s job easier.

No, you are wrong and Harrit was wrong as well. I repeat, if Tnemec contains organic polymer binder (alkyd-linsees resin), this binder is inevitably combusted at some temperature range under air, but fairly below 700 degrees. I can easily bet all my money that I am right But you can be right that Tnemec is not the source of microspheres we see in Bentham paper. Who knows.

And this "some temperature" is actually 650 for Tnemec, where it starts to charr, if we believe NIST.

You quoted Jones who claims that some chips are non-glossy and hard (and are WTC paint according to Jones, probably Tnemec, since Jones owned the samples of Tnemec for comparison). Others are more glossy and softer/more flexible, according to Jones, who thinks that they are thermitic. This could mean that they form microspheres when heated.
And they can be Laclede paint, as you noted. All this might be a good clue how to separate chips suitable for possible heating tests

Oystein provided quote, but yes I have mentioned that Jones has given more information about paint chips vs his suspected thermite chips. Some chips should remain hard after MEK and that seems the most obvious tests to find the right chips, along with those visual clues.
 
Originally Posted by jtl
... NIST did tests on Tnemec which show that this paint is thermally stable to something like 700 degrees, ... .:blush:

Source? Page number, etc.

Where did NIST say it? Can you post your sources, or did you google some 911 truth junk and post it without checking? What report was it in?

:blush::blush::blush:, is this your source?
 
...
And I am sure Millette will be glad to prove you right with paint tests, but until then words are cheap.
Why? Harrit e.al. already agree that their DSC test is consistent with combustion of the (unknown to them, competently identified as epoxy by Millette) organic matrix:
"It is striking that some of the red/gray chips release more energy in kJ/g than does ordinary thermite, as shown in the blue bar graphs above. The theoretical maximum for thermite is 3.9 kJ/g [27]. We suggest that the organic material in evidence in the red/gray chips is also highly energetic, most likely producing gas to provide explosive pressure."​
The highlited suggestion is confirmed by Millette: Epoxy is indeed highly energetic - having about 5 times the energy density (20 kJ/g vs. 3.9 kJ/g) of ideal thermite. Since also there was a LOT more organic matrix (>50 wt%) in all of the red layers than there could have been thermite (<10 wt%), given the low proportion of Al and high proportion of C, it becomes quickly clear that the energy output of the organic combustion must be >25x that of the thermite's energy output.
Also, epoxy does ignite around 400 °C - somewhat depending on circumstances, oc fourse - while all the nanothermite documented in the papers cited by Harrit e.al. do not.

In other words: Millette doesn't need to do any paint chips - Harrit's result on "unknown" red-gray chips already confirm what Ivan claimed: DSC result is compatible with organic combustion of organic paint binder (such as epoxy).

(Harrit's little remark about "producing gas to provide explosive pressure" is of course nonsense: None of the chips ever exploded - unless heated with a torch that clearly provides a zillion times the heat and power the chip's own combustion could ever reach; you can "explode" entirely chemically inert particles with such a torch!)

Some chips should remain hard after MEK and that seems the most obvious tests to find the right chips, along with those visual clues.
Did they select chips a-d via this method before doing the SEM and XEDS analysis on them? No, of course not!
Did they select the four chips they wasted in the DSC via this method before the DSC test? No, of course not!
Did they test the mult-layered chip with Pb this way, which Jones finds so important today? No, of course not!
Did they test the chip with the carbon layer that way? Who knows?

So was this test actually used by Jones and friends to isolate and "find the right chips" chips? No, of course not!
So what the hell are you talking about? Why are you shilling for Jones? Let me ask you this: Is Jones paying you money to shill here?
 
Last edited:
I am currently listening very careful to Niels Harrit's presentation at the "Toronto Hearings". Video of the full presentation here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I51fDKsuJ_I

He tells a lot of things we already know, show many of the Figures from their paper, etc. I want to emphasize a few things that I think are of current interest:

1. "They" have a large amount (5 gallons?!) of dust from a new donation
2. Harrit confirms that chip isolation has only 2 steps
3. Image 2 indeed shows "our" chips a-d
4. Harrit considers the evidence for elemental Al to be merely "indirect"
5. Harrit admits flame test is not scientific
6. Harrit thinks their DSC curve is narrower than Tillotson's
7. Harrit still didn't know there was more than one WTC primer
8. Harrit knows that iron oxide makes red paint red

Point by point:

1. "They" have a large amount (5 gallons?!) of dust from a new donation
Harrit said:
[6:35] And we see here Professor Jones taking this sample and treating it the way that Kevin just described. We put this dust into a plastic bag and applied a magnet onto it. I'll show you in a little while, and you get the opportunity yourself to do this, but on another sample. Because this emerged quite recently from New York City: A big jar, 5 gallons, of dust. This is the biggest, actually, sample of dust I've ever seen. I haven't seen this one, but last morning, I got a sample from this jar, and it is here [shows a plastic bag with perhaps 100 cm3 of dust], and it's huge. This is a lot, relatively, to what we used to get of samples from people.

2. Harrit confirms that chip isolation has only 2 steps

I'll quote this at lenght - Harrit does indeed go to great length to explain how they isolated the red-gray chips!
Harrit said:
[7:31] So I have not … I have taken actually a small sample out of this bag, put it into a smaller bag, here [shows a smaller plastic bag with perhaps 2 or 3 cm3 of dust], and I also brought a little magnet, here, and I will give you all an opportunity to play around with it. I have to put down the microphone and I have to [..?..] eventually. Or you can hold it [gives mike to someone else]. What I shall do, while I bring this to the panel members, you should take the bag horizontally, or you could also put it vertically, then apply the magnet to the dust, and you'll see something coming along. Play a little with it! The challenge for you is to isolate a black line of particles following the curvature of the magnet. The magnetic field is strongest at the edges. So try to pull out some magnetic material from the bulk, and eventually isolate what probably will be a black line of small particles. And this, I will tell you in a little while what this would be. Two words of caution: Please don't open the plastic bag! This is one. Next, don't let this magnet get too close to your Rolex! Chances are, you'll never get it off again. And cell phones etc., so be careful. And we can have it working all around, you're all welcome to try this.
[9:15] [Harrit walks around the room. Camera zooms out. You can see about 40 people in the room]
[9:57, Harrit] This picture has also been shown by Kevin Ryan, and this is some of the stuff you can isolate from the dust by means of the magnet. This is the raw dust, and most of it, what you'll see here, the black stuff, are these iron spheres, which have already been mentioned several times so far, with a little bit of luck, you may also get a chance to see – I don't know about this sample, I just got it yesterday morning, I don't know how much is in it – but these red – we call them “chips” – is what we're gonna talk about for the next 20 minutes or half hour.
After this, he talks jumps into description and characterization (micrographs, SEM, XEDS) of chips, with hinting at any further separation and isolation.

3. Image 2 indeed shows "our" chips a-d

At least I was never quite sure if the presentation of the four chips a-d begins with Fig. 5, or if these are already shown in the photos of Fig. 2. Harrit confirms this now:
Harrit said:
[12:07] In all four samples we found these red-gray chips. These [showing Fig. 2] are the samples a, b, c and d.

4. Harrit considers the evidence for elemental Al to be merely "indirect"
Harrit said:
[20:20] [Shows Fig. 17] And if you apply in an area where there is only aluminium, like here, you see aluminium and very little silicon. This means that the silicon and the aluminium are separate entities, and the aluminium can move around as a consequence of the swelling with the MEK. This is an indirect, but a good, proof of that we have the presence of elemental aluminium, which is very very important. But it is not the strongest evidence we have.

5. Harrit admits flame test is not scientific
Harrit said:
[22:36] [Shows Fig 22] This experiment is a little difficult to demonstrate because they are so small, so you have to believe me that the experimentalist here is applying a micro-torch, and to the left of the flame, there is – it's a tiny chip – he's moving the flame from right to left, and what happens we he reached the chip is, you can see, those siting close here, you can see a yellow flame sticking out. In this experiment actually he could feel something was hitting his hand, but he could not find the particle afterward. This we have found on many other occasions. This is not – showing it could take off like this is not very scientific.

6. Harrit thinks their DSC curve is narrower than Tillotson's

[25:24] - [26:54]: Harrit shows Fig. 29.
Harrit said:
[26:30]So this is the only comparison we have, and actually the one we got out of WTC is better in terms of it is narrower

7. Harrit still didn't know there was more than one WTC primer

Just listen to his presentation from [27:33] to [31:00]. He often refers to "the primer" on the WTC, and means "Tnemec" exclusively.


8. Harrit knows that iron oxide makes red paint red

This may be trivial, but important nevertheless:
Harrit said:
[28:25] The primer paint is also red, because it does indeed contain also iron oxide, which is red.
 
Oystein: Thanks:cool:

It has been actually almost sure that chips from Fig. 2 are the same as in Fig. 5.
But, isn't there some mention in Harrit's lecture that the same chips (a) top (d) were also heated in the DSC device? Or at least one of them? This would be really helpfull for us. But it is not very probable, since these chips were broken in order to get crossections for XEDS. And why to put smaller/broken chips into DSC, when the whole chips were also available (provided that all chips closely examined were considered as the same material, which was the /false/ presumption of Bentham authors).

(I appreciate that Harrit is now able to admit that "ignition tests" with oxyacetylene torch were "unscientific", since ignited particles usually simply "disappeared" after ignition. Good start. Now he should also admit that these tests were unscientific in principle, since extremely hot flame of this torch would indeed ignite/melt/"explode" anything;))
 
Last edited:
I am currently listening very careful to Niels Harrit's presentation at the "Toronto Hearings". Video of the full presentation here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I51fDKsuJ_I

He tells a lot of things we already know, show many of the Figures from their paper, etc. I want to emphasize a few things that I think are of current interest:

1. "They" have a large amount (5 gallons?!) of dust from a new donation

Which shows they're not intellectually serious. If they were, they'd be sending samples to researchers and forensic labs all over the world. I'd love to see how much alumina (byproduct of thermite) is in the dust, what with "hundreds of tons" of thermite having been used!

6. Harrit thinks their DSC curve is narrower than Tillotson's.

Which shows that Harrit is an idiot.
 
But the Bentham Paper scientists determined through observation, that the observed 10 ohm-m red-layer resistivity values were indeed a useful determinant for removing paint chips and other high resistance substances from the large magnetically-isolated chip pile.

They published this test method because they found that it was definitely a very effective means of quickly locating chips of interest, as well as eliminating all the paint and other chips showing high resistivity.

MM

You (and others) are COMPLETELY wrong regarding how you think the resistivity were used in the Bentham paper. I just got an email from Harrit. Here is what it said.

No, I didn't notice any previous mail, and no, I do not have time to dig into the files to answer your questions, since the decisive test for the chips were the formation of iron spheres upon cumbustion. If any regular "paint" can do that - and if it was applied in WTC - many other questions could be answered. The resistivity test were done in random on the chips already isolated as described. The information obtained must be considered "supplementary material".
Best
NH

They took random chips out of their already isolated pile to perform random resistivity tests in order to determine if they matched samples of OTHER paint resistivity-wise. They assumed that every chip they separated with the criteria using a magnet and red/gray layers WERE thermitic. They used the random resistivity tests of some chips to try and show that the ENTIRE isolated pile were not paint chips.

If they HAD separated paint chips form the original isolated pile, they would have done tests to show the composition and compared THAT to the thermitic chips to show the difference and not rely on OTHER paint samples or the NIST report for the actual paint composition.

Not only that, but others here have found another primer paint used.

Once again, you (and others) try to put your own spin on things instead of finding out from the source.

Pure laziness...

Also, if someone can answer a question, since when is "steel primer paint" considered "regular paint". Wouldn't you, as a scientist, want to test like substances? Meaning, why didn't they look for and test primer paint in the sample piles and test those? Why compare to "regular paint" from outside sources?
 
They published this test method because they found that it was definitely a very effective means of quickly locating chips of interest, as well as eliminating all the paint and other chips showing high resistivity.
MM

Let me show you once again just how wrong you are MM. Staright from the horse's mouth (Harrit):

No, I didn't notice any previous mail, and no, I do not have time to dig into the files to answer your questions, since the decisive test for the chips were the formation of iron spheres upon cumbustion. If any regular "paint" can do that - and if it was applied in WTC - many other questions could be answered. The resistivity test were done in random on the chips already isolated as described. The information obtained must be considered "supplementary material".
Best
NH

Do you see the hilited part of your quote where you say the resistivity test eliminated ALL THE PAINT AND OTHER CHIPS"? Do you see the hilited part of Harrit's quote?

How does one eliminate ALL THE PAINT AND OTHER CHIPS from the already isolated pile using a RANDOM selection of chips?

:rolleyes:
 
Let me show you once again just how wrong you are MM. Staright from the horse's mouth (Harrit):

Do you see the hilited part of your quote where you say the resistivity test eliminated ALL THE PAINT AND OTHER CHIPS"? Do you see the hilited part of Harrit's quote?

How does one eliminate ALL THE PAINT AND OTHER CHIPS from the already isolated pile using a RANDOM selection of chips?

:rolleyes:

Misinterpret much?

Did Dr. Harrit say some of the randomly selected chips from the isolation pile
that measured 10 ohm-m were found to be paint?

Ah no.

Dr. Harrit et al's paper clearly indicated that 'chips of interest' shared that low resistance in common.

MM
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom