...
Very important point here is that former objections to Harrit´s MEK tests were based on the assumption that fig14 shows Tnemec without kaolin while chips a to d shows LaCLede with kaolin, but since both paints(Tnemec and LaClede) have aluminum compounds, this objection is no longer possible. The MEK tests seperated the silicon and aluminum in fig14 so there can be no compound, and it seems Harrit rightly say their chips do not have kaolin.
...
This claim is unsubstantiated, and the assumption that the MEK chip is a different material (possibly Tnemec) than chips a-d (very likely LaClede) is still valid.
Jones claims, and you parrot uncritically, that the MEK-treatment "separated" Al and Si. However, no data exists that shows Al and Si were spacially associated in that chip before the MEK treatment. Jones failed to do the same tests before
and after soaking in MEK, so any claim that the MEK-treatment changed anything (beyond the swelling and change in consistence that is described and quantified) is mere speculation. It rests on the unfounded and most certainly FALSE assumption that this chip is the same material as chip a, of which they show XEDS maps for Al and Si in Fig. 10.
Fig 10 indeed gives a very strong indication that in that chip Al and Si are chemically associated, AND that both reside in the hexagonal platelets thar are visible in Fig. 10a. Fig. 7 shows that the overall ratio of Al:Si in chip a (and b-d) is equal to unity (1:1; within the margin of error of XEDS measurement), and Fig 10a shows that this unity also holds true for the hexagonal platelets. Fog 10, again, shows that both Al and Si are associated with these platelets, and these platelets
only. It is therefore reasonable that these regularly shaped hexagonal platelets are the crystalline form of a chemical compound consisting of Al and Si in equal numbers, plus oxygen. A prime candidate for such a compound is Aluminium silicate, specifically Al
2Si
2O
5(OH
4). And guess what? That is the formula of kaolin. And guess what? Kaolin is a naturally occurring mineral, and it forms hexagonal platelets that are often on the order of 1 micron wide and tens of nanometers thin - exactly as observed in Fig. 8 and 9.! These kaolin platelets tends to stack "book"-like - exactly as observed in Fig 8c. And guess what one of the major industrial uses of kaolin is? Yep, paint!
So all the evidence presented in Harrit e.al. speaks for chips a-d containing Kaolin as the only substance with Al and Si in it - and no silica, no elemental Al, no alumina.
So we made a prediction: If you select red-gray, magnetic chips from WTC dust that have an overall XEDS pattern essentially equal to those in Fig. 6 and 7, you will find these platelets again, and will find through competent analytical methods (e.g. FTIR, TEM) that these are kaolin clay. We hired a forensic lab to test that hypothesis, which was solely nased on Harrit's findings, anf found the hypothesis to be 100%
verified.
That's how science works.
We further hypothesised that these chips a-d are specifically LaClede primer, which also contains a small amount of strontium chromate. So we predicted that Millette would find strontium chromate in similar chips. As it turns out, he did not yet find that. Which is quite a disappointment.
BUT
Harrit reports strontium and chromium in chip a through SEM-XEDS
AND Farrer reports having found strontium and chromium in (unspecified) chips via TEM!
So the search is still on.
Back to the MEK-soaked chip.
Does it have the same XEDS pattern as chips a-d? The best answer is "
no", based on a critical comparison of Fig 14 with Fig. 7. I would at least expect you to answer "
we don't know". Jones himself now regrets not having cleaned that chip before soaking and before doing Fig. 14 - in other words, Jones admits he presented bad data there.
Does this chip have those hexagonal platelets? Answer is:
You don't know!
Does this chip have Al and Si associated with each other before MEK-soaking? Answer is:
You don't know!
Does this chip have Al and Si assoctiated with those platelets? Answer is:
You don't know - twice over!
Is there any other property that we know to be shared by chips a-d and the MEK-chip? Thermal behaviour?
You don't know! (Because you don't know if any, and which, of these chips were thermally tested) Electric resistivity?
You don't know! (because they tested only one chip, and we don't know what kind of chip that was) Behaviour after soaking with MEK?
You don't know! (Because we know of no MEK-testing on chips a-d)
So in short:
You don't know if the MEK-chip was the same material, and contained those hexagonal platelets that have Al and Si in a 1.1 ratio!
Now what about the hypothesis that that chip was Tnemec? Tnemec contains quite a lot of minerals, among then silica (SiO
2) and calcium aluminates (Ca
xAl
yO
z). Note that the former contains Si but no Al, while the latter contains Al but no Si. In fact, the Tnemec formulation, as we know it, contains no compound within which Al and Si are chemically bound to each other. In contrast, the LaClede primer contains no compound in wich Al or Si are NOT bound to the other.
So it is entirely expected in Tnemec to find Al and Si NOT spacially associated with each other - just what Jones demonstrates in Fig 15-18!
The only thing that speaks against Tnemec would be the ominous Fig. 17, an XEDS spectrum done at only 10 kV beam energy, which shows no Ca. We would expect Al to be associated with Ca, but it's not showing. Why? Well, in Fig. 17, the graph is flat at 0 just beyond the little Si-peak at ca. 1.8 keV. The first Ca-peak would be at a considerably higher value, about 3.7 keV. So one suspicion (which I'd assign a low probability of being true) is that the choice of low beam energy results in Jones' equipment simply not recording any peaks much beyond 2 keV, and thus missing Ca altogether. My other suspicion is that this particular measurement wasn't even from the chip, but somehow measured the aluminium stub that the chip was placed on. Further possibilities are that the formula for Tnemec that we look at is not the one actually used back around 1970 (the MSD sheet on the proprietary Tnemec pigmen that Harrit found is not dated to that time 40 years ago!) and contains some Al; or that this isn't Tnemec after all (which isn't really a problem for us; it would be nice to be able to pinpoint the source of each chip, but that's not necessary to rule out thermite and conclude paint). At any rate, Fig. 14 indicated that the overall Al-content of that chip is minimal - under 1% - so it couldn't be "thermitic" by nature anyway.