Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Could someone explain what the point of this "resistivity" test was? Obviously it was not used to eliminate paint chips because it was done on chips with a gray layer. They're not stupid enough to believe this gray layer wouldn't be a factor (or their followers would believe them when they told them it wasn't) , right? :confused:

Did they run a base to show the gray layer was not conductive?
 
Last edited:
"False.

A 10 micron layer of a material with a resistivity of 1010 ohm·m will yield a measurement 100,000 ohm, not "virtually zero".

A probe with a sharp tip can easily stick into such a layer, further diminishing the 5 micron distance and thus the measured resistance.
"
"So you do not believe that an electrical resistance of 100,000 ohms when compared to 10 ohms, is not like comparing an insulator to a conductor?"
"I didn't say that. Pressure with a sharp tip can easily reduce the distance and current can find its way through a shorter path if it exists. At such short distances, other effects can come into play. Either way it is a measuring method with high enough uncertainties as to make it unreliable and thus inconclusive.

Not to mention that we have absolutely no idea of what chip they tested for resistivity, because they didn't show an analysis; all we know is that it's different from the rest in that it has little gray layer.
"

The test does not have to be precise.

Unless the red surface is badly pitted, most probes should successfully touch at least one red point cleanly. Any 'misread' chips represent some time wastage during later research. A lot less time is wasted when such a useful discovery is put to good use by helping reduce the tedious process of picking from a large number of magnetically qualifying WTC dust chips.

Once it was discovered how low the electrical resistance was in the red layers of chips that later ignited in the DSC, it made no sense for the researchers to abandon this useful knowledge and continue selecting magnetically-isolated chips using a 'hit or miss' method.


"Of course they used "tabulated values".

That is what a Resistivity Reference Table does.

LaClede paint, has "tabulated values" which would clearly cause a failed grade in the 10 ohm Resistivity test and would not have qualified for DSC testing."
"Yet you can provide no evidence for your claim that they DID use it, when there's no such claim in any relevant section about isolation of chips. That's just wishful thinking "

Dr. Jones, one of the original Bentham Paper authors, has previously posted his disappointment about Dr. Millette ignoring the Resistivity Test results for the red layer as reported in the Bentham Paper.

Would you doggedly pick through a large group hoping to find what you wanted when you knew of a quick 'n easy test that would help make your selections easier?

Of course if you did not want to find the chips of interest, the Resistivity test would be an easy way to find chips that were likely paint or some other material with high electrical resistance.

After creating a big pile of isolated chips, it is up to the researcher to decide which chips they are interested in.

If Dr. Millette had fully read the Bentham Paper, he would have know about the usefulness of the quick Resistivity measurement.

MM
 
The test does not have to be precise.

You missed this part. :rolleyes:

Not to mention that we have absolutely no idea of what chip they tested for resistivity, because they didn't show an analysis; all we know is that it's different from the rest in that it has little gray layer.

Any thoughts on why he wont release any data? How much is "little", exactly?
 
Last edited:
Could someone explain what the point of this "resistivity" test was? Obviously it was not used to eliminate paint chips because it was done on chips with a gray layer. They're not stupid enough to believe this gray layer wouldn't be a factor (or their followers would believe them when they told them it wasn't) , right? :confused:

Did they run a base to show the gray layer was not conductive?
It amazes me that they didn't separate the red and gray layers, especially for DSC. This may well be quite fiddly, but it's easy enough to do.
 
The test does not have to be precise.

Unless the red surface is badly pitted, most probes should successfully touch at least one red point cleanly. Any 'misread' chips represent some time wastage during later research. A lot less time is wasted when such a useful discovery is put to good use by helping reduce the tedious process of picking from a large number of magnetically qualifying WTC dust chips.

Once it was discovered how low the electrical resistance was in the red layers of chips that later ignited in the DSC, it made no sense for the researchers to abandon this useful knowledge and continue selecting magnetically-isolated chips using a 'hit or miss' method.
But as you well know this wasn't stated in the paper. How can anyone follow up if this method is not explicitly stated in the paper?

This method was not used in the isolation of chips.

All you are doing by taking this ridiculous line is to show another inadequacy in the paper.
 
Last edited:
Could someone explain what the point of this "resistivity" test was? Obviously it was not used to eliminate paint chips because it was done on chips with a gray layer. They're not stupid enough to believe this gray layer wouldn't be a factor (or their followers would believe them when they told them it wasn't) , right? :confused:

Did they run a base to show the gray layer was not conductive?

It was like this:

Once there was a bunch of 9 brave knights. They knew deep in their hearts that they held nano-thermite in their hands, because a great prophet was in their midst who had once foreseen that a woman would come, and lo, a bag full of magic dust she would deliver!

And now they were looking on that dust. And they spoke unto themselves: "If only we were forensic experts! What can we do??"

And then a great powwow was held, and one of them said: "We could use the flames of hell!", and another said "let's employ invisible rays!" and yet another said "we must sink it into stinky liquid!" The last one to speak was the Prophet himself: "Fools! You have no concept! The secret of electricity - that will confuse the detractors!"

And then they swarmed out, and they did all sorts of things to the dust.
 
It amazes me that they didn't separate the red and gray layers, especially for DSC. This may well be quite fiddly, but it's easy enough to do.

They would have if the objective was to determine what the dust consisted of. As we all know, that was not the objective of this paper. ;)

It was like this:

Once there was a bunch of 9 brave knights. They knew deep in their hearts that they held nano-thermite in their hands, because a great prophet was in their midst who had once foreseen that a woman would come, and lo, a bag full of magic dust she would deliver!

And now they were looking on that dust. And they spoke unto themselves: "If only we were forensic experts! What can we do??"

And then a great powwow was held, and one of them said: "We could use the flames of hell!", and another said "let's employ invisible rays!" and yet another said "we must sink it into stinky liquid!" The last one to speak was the Prophet himself: "Fools! You have no concept! The secret of electricity - that will confuse the detractors!"

And then they swarmed out, and they did all sorts of things to the dust.

:D

(They do seem to approach things like kids with new toys).
 
Last edited:
Kminek: What are you talking about? Harrit et al not only did not perform any serious test to rule-out WTC paints;

Why are you talking about paints in this respect? I asked you if the people whom developed superthermite did tests in air, and if so if they also repeated them in inert air to confirm the results of the air tests? So, in the references given by Harrit, are there no ignition tests in air?

“Thanks for your interest in the paper. As you correctly point out DSC in an O2 atmosphere will combust the organic impurities and greatly add to the energy release. However the DSC in question was done in ultra pure nitrogen.
And yes, with our organic impurity we find higher enthalpies for sol-gel thermites than regular thermites (due to the combustion of the organic in O2). …

First of all, you refer to a partial email by some JREF member, which raises alarm bells. Then it only refers to one paper and ignition in nitrogen in that paper. What about all the other papers Harrit refers to? Finally this email makes it rather clear that the authors have also done tests in air, which makes me believe that some other papers may include air tests.

If this is true then this JREF email would be a clear exercise in cherry picking. I have started to download some of those papers so I will check myself.

I already showed you calorimetric curves which clearly show that Harrit was wrong and exotherms for e.g. epoxy heating under air can be pretty similar to the exotherms in Bentham paper. If it was not enough, I can past here many other similar curves for burning of polymers with references.

Yes provide some sources. Someone pointed out to me that polymers and epoxies can have very different qualities depending on their detailed composition and for what they are made. It seems that there are very volatile forms(even explosive) of this stuff and also very stable forms. I presume superthermite skeletons are based on the volatile stuff while the paints are thermally stable, as suggested by Harrit´s essay on the Tnemec paint. Make sure not to confuse the two opposing forms.

I agree that we do not currently have better (conclusive, and/or based on some "paint papers") explanation for iron-rich microspheres than that of Harrit et al.

I think we agreed before that tests are needed for gray layer hypothesis.

Are you sure that Jones measured XRD for chips like those in Fig. 7? It is of course possible, but should be first confirmed by Jones. Anyway, if Jones did not identify kaolinite by his XRD measurements just for such chips, he should reconsider the validity of results, since kaolinite was identified by Millette by several independent methods pretty clearly.

Very important point here is that former objections to Harrit´s MEK tests were based on the assumption that fig14 shows Tnemec without kaolin while chips a to d shows LaCLede with kaolin, but since both paints(Tnemec and LaClede) have aluminum compounds, this objection is no longer possible. The MEK tests seperated the silicon and aluminum in fig14 so there can be no compound, and it seems Harrit rightly say their chips do not have kaolin.


This info from Jones seems to be interesting. One kind of chips (glossy, rigid) can be one paint, whereas the second one (more flexible and limp after soaking) can be another paint. No problem. This could be a feasible way how to distinguish between these two kinds of chips (or perhaps two groups of chips) for Jim Millette. This could be a clue how to choose chips which can form microspheres during heating (should be "rigid and rather brittle and glossy", in contrast to other, more flexible and non-glossy chips, since just these chips were regarded as thermitic by Jones). In any case, any further chip tested as for microsphere formation during heating must contain gray layer.

Agreed.
 
Did MM seriously just compare finding thermite in the chips from the wtc dust to finding a needle in a haystack?

I was under the impression that MM believed that thermite was ubiquitous in the wtc dust. Supposedly thermite laden dust falling into the underground areas of the debris pile allowed for the months long existence of molten steel.

The above quote is from the Millette thread, but my reply doesn't belong there. It made me just think of something:

On page 23 in ATM:

Harrit e al said:
1. How Much of the Energetic Red Material Survived
During the WTC Destruction?


In the sample provided by collector J. MacKinlay the fraction of red/gray chips was roughly estimated. Fifteen small chips having a total mass of 1.74 mg were extracted from a 1.6 g sample of dust from which readily identifiable glass and concrete fragments had been removed by hand. Thus the fraction of red/gray chips was approximately 0.1% by weight in the separated dust Another sampling showed 69 small red/gray chips in a 4.9 g sample of separated dust. Further samples are being analyzed to refine this estimate. The fall of the WTC Towers produced enormous clouds of dust whose total mass is difficult to ascertain; but clearly the total mass of red/gray chips in the WTC dust must be substantial given the fraction observed in these samplings.

Two thoughts:
  • Harrit e.al. count chips without making any mention that they separated these 15 and 69 chips, either before or after counting, from red-gray chips that are paint or otherwise non-thermitic. They must have assumed at the time they published this that ALL red-gray chips are essentially the same, and all thermitic, while NONE are paint
  • Harrit has famously concluded from this 0.1% fraction that there must have been hundreds of tons of that stuff in the towers. Now, since truthers also like to think that this thermite is responsible for the elevated temperatures of the debris pile, what can 0.1% of thermite in the heap do? As a first approximation, let's consider the fact that pure thermite can heat itself up by more than 2000 K. If you mix that with inert debris (such as concrete or steel) at a ratio of 1:1000, you can expect that the thermite would be capable to heat the mix by more than 2 K. Wow! :D
 
Why are you talking about paints in this respect? I asked you if the people whom developed superthermite did tests in air, and if so if they also repeated them in inert air to confirm the results of the air tests? So, in the references given by Harrit, are there no ignition tests in air?

First of all, you refer to a partial email by some JREF member, which raises alarm bells. Then it only refers to one paper and ignition in nitrogen in that paper. What about all the other papers Harrit refers to? Finally this email makes it rather clear that the authors have also done tests in air, which makes me believe that some other papers may include air tests.

If this is true then this JREF email would be a clear exercise in cherry picking. I have started to download some of those papers so I will check myself.

Check it:cool:

Yes provide some sources. Someone pointed out to me that polymers and epoxies can have very different qualities depending on their detailed composition and for what they are made. It seems that there are very volatile forms(even explosive) of this stuff and also very stable forms. I presume superthermite skeletons are based on the volatile stuff while the paints are thermally stable, as suggested by Harrit´s essay on the Tnemec paint. Make sure not to confuse the two opposing forms.

I can divide substantial flaws of Bentham paper into three categories:

1) Wrong partial or final conclusions (no comment, has been discussed ad nauseam).

2) Wrong or non-sensical methods, e.g. test with oxyacetylene torch or comparison with unspecified paints.

3) Bad or horribly incomplete literature research. One glaring example can be seen in the claim that since chips contained nanosized inorganic particles, it must be indeed some super-duper-nano military material:D
Namely, Harrit et al did not know anything about epoxy chemistry (as well as you;)), and they did zero research as for (e.g. thermal) behavior of polymers as binders in paints ;). Also, their own knowledge on the organic stuffs/ polymers (which prevailed in the chips) seems to be a plain zero, according to their paper.
This is an apparent and blatant professional failure especially for Harrit.

But back to your inquiry. You wrote that Harrit "does not think" that calorimetric curves for combustion of polymers could be as "narrow" as Bentham curves. You see? You are able to believe this guy without any experimental proof, whereas you tend not to believe in real literature data I submitted here as a polymer chemist. You know, it is pretty normal to check in the available literature how this and this stuff may behave. And Harrit again failed in this respect.
Anyway, here are more MCC (microcalorimetric combustion curves) for some polymers (usually pure polymers and composites with something), with references below and polymers measured. (And I repeat (together with Gash) that DSC does not necessarily provide reproducible results, therefore it is not a method of the first choice for possible future measurements).
:

picture.php


http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0254058410007339 , epoxy resin

picture.php


http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0141391009004236, polystyrene

picture.php


http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0040603112000925, epoxy


picture.php


http://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2012/jm/c2jm35479a/unauth , epoxy

picture.php


http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1359835X12000826 polypropylene,

(There are some other MCC curves for other polymers available, which show exotherms at higher or lower temperatures, sometimes with two or more "peaks", but I just chose curves which are close to Bentham curves.)


Very important point here is that former objections to Harrit´s MEK tests were based on the assumption that fig14 shows Tnemec without kaolin while chips a to d shows LaCLede with kaolin, but since both paints(Tnemec and LaClede) have aluminum compounds, this objection is no longer possible. The MEK tests seperated the silicon and aluminum in fig14 so there can be no compound, and it seems Harrit rightly say their chips do not have kaolin.

Jtl, what are you talking about??? Is it your topic here these unpublished alleged XRD results of Jones? Have you see any of these results? No is the answer.
Prior their publishing (at least in some white paper or so), their validity/importance is of course a plain zero ;) No need to discuss them.
 
Last edited:
Jtl: and finally as regards your sentence:

"I presume superthermite skeletons are based on the volatile stuff while the paints are thermally stable, as suggested by Harrit´s essay on the Tnemec paint."

In the case of "superthermite skeletons" you are right, only volatile stuffs are created;)

In the case of paints, Harrit is again confused, here with "a little help" of NIST report.

Harrit wrote: "Notice, that the primer paint – being basically a ceramic material – is chemically stable at temperatures up to 800 C."

But, as I've already mentioned several times, if the primer paint under scope was Tnemec, this paint cannot be regarded as a ceramic material; according to the specification, it contained quite a lot of organics: alkyd, linseed stuffs. NIST report was simply not really correct in this tiny detail.

So, for Tnemec (or Laclede or any other paint based on combustible polymeric binder and incombustible pigments), we can expect the typical thermal behavior of paints: at high temperatures under air, all organics/polymers are completely combusted and only inorganic pigments remain.

If Harrit considered this obvious and fully expected finding (paint layer basically remains to be a layer after heating, because of remaining inorganic pigments) as a proof of stability, well, then the paint is stable in this regard.
Otherwise, no paint (with any usual carbon-based polymer binder) can be regarded as really thermally stable. Binder is always combusted, no way how to avoid these inevitable processes.

(Indeed, you can add some flame retardants into polymer, or use highly brominated - or other halogenated - polymers or silicon polymers etc, but all this can only slow down the pyrolysis and the thermal/oxidative degradation of the polymer. At and above 700 degrees under air, all organic polymers would be combusted anyway).:cool:
 
Last edited:
...
Very important point here is that former objections to Harrit´s MEK tests were based on the assumption that fig14 shows Tnemec without kaolin while chips a to d shows LaCLede with kaolin, but since both paints(Tnemec and LaClede) have aluminum compounds, this objection is no longer possible. The MEK tests seperated the silicon and aluminum in fig14 so there can be no compound, and it seems Harrit rightly say their chips do not have kaolin.
...
This claim is unsubstantiated, and the assumption that the MEK chip is a different material (possibly Tnemec) than chips a-d (very likely LaClede) is still valid.

Jones claims, and you parrot uncritically, that the MEK-treatment "separated" Al and Si. However, no data exists that shows Al and Si were spacially associated in that chip before the MEK treatment. Jones failed to do the same tests before and after soaking in MEK, so any claim that the MEK-treatment changed anything (beyond the swelling and change in consistence that is described and quantified) is mere speculation. It rests on the unfounded and most certainly FALSE assumption that this chip is the same material as chip a, of which they show XEDS maps for Al and Si in Fig. 10.

Fig 10 indeed gives a very strong indication that in that chip Al and Si are chemically associated, AND that both reside in the hexagonal platelets thar are visible in Fig. 10a. Fig. 7 shows that the overall ratio of Al:Si in chip a (and b-d) is equal to unity (1:1; within the margin of error of XEDS measurement), and Fig 10a shows that this unity also holds true for the hexagonal platelets. Fog 10, again, shows that both Al and Si are associated with these platelets, and these platelets only. It is therefore reasonable that these regularly shaped hexagonal platelets are the crystalline form of a chemical compound consisting of Al and Si in equal numbers, plus oxygen. A prime candidate for such a compound is Aluminium silicate, specifically Al2Si2O5(OH4). And guess what? That is the formula of kaolin. And guess what? Kaolin is a naturally occurring mineral, and it forms hexagonal platelets that are often on the order of 1 micron wide and tens of nanometers thin - exactly as observed in Fig. 8 and 9.! These kaolin platelets tends to stack "book"-like - exactly as observed in Fig 8c. And guess what one of the major industrial uses of kaolin is? Yep, paint!
So all the evidence presented in Harrit e.al. speaks for chips a-d containing Kaolin as the only substance with Al and Si in it - and no silica, no elemental Al, no alumina.

So we made a prediction: If you select red-gray, magnetic chips from WTC dust that have an overall XEDS pattern essentially equal to those in Fig. 6 and 7, you will find these platelets again, and will find through competent analytical methods (e.g. FTIR, TEM) that these are kaolin clay. We hired a forensic lab to test that hypothesis, which was solely nased on Harrit's findings, anf found the hypothesis to be 100% verified.

That's how science works.

We further hypothesised that these chips a-d are specifically LaClede primer, which also contains a small amount of strontium chromate. So we predicted that Millette would find strontium chromate in similar chips. As it turns out, he did not yet find that. Which is quite a disappointment.
BUT
Harrit reports strontium and chromium in chip a through SEM-XEDS
AND Farrer reports having found strontium and chromium in (unspecified) chips via TEM!
So the search is still on.


Back to the MEK-soaked chip.

Does it have the same XEDS pattern as chips a-d? The best answer is "no", based on a critical comparison of Fig 14 with Fig. 7. I would at least expect you to answer "we don't know". Jones himself now regrets not having cleaned that chip before soaking and before doing Fig. 14 - in other words, Jones admits he presented bad data there.
Does this chip have those hexagonal platelets? Answer is: You don't know!
Does this chip have Al and Si associated with each other before MEK-soaking? Answer is: You don't know!
Does this chip have Al and Si assoctiated with those platelets? Answer is: You don't know - twice over!
Is there any other property that we know to be shared by chips a-d and the MEK-chip? Thermal behaviour? You don't know! (Because you don't know if any, and which, of these chips were thermally tested) Electric resistivity? You don't know! (because they tested only one chip, and we don't know what kind of chip that was) Behaviour after soaking with MEK? You don't know! (Because we know of no MEK-testing on chips a-d)
So in short: You don't know if the MEK-chip was the same material, and contained those hexagonal platelets that have Al and Si in a 1.1 ratio!


Now what about the hypothesis that that chip was Tnemec? Tnemec contains quite a lot of minerals, among then silica (SiO2) and calcium aluminates (CaxAlyOz). Note that the former contains Si but no Al, while the latter contains Al but no Si. In fact, the Tnemec formulation, as we know it, contains no compound within which Al and Si are chemically bound to each other. In contrast, the LaClede primer contains no compound in wich Al or Si are NOT bound to the other.
So it is entirely expected in Tnemec to find Al and Si NOT spacially associated with each other - just what Jones demonstrates in Fig 15-18!
The only thing that speaks against Tnemec would be the ominous Fig. 17, an XEDS spectrum done at only 10 kV beam energy, which shows no Ca. We would expect Al to be associated with Ca, but it's not showing. Why? Well, in Fig. 17, the graph is flat at 0 just beyond the little Si-peak at ca. 1.8 keV. The first Ca-peak would be at a considerably higher value, about 3.7 keV. So one suspicion (which I'd assign a low probability of being true) is that the choice of low beam energy results in Jones' equipment simply not recording any peaks much beyond 2 keV, and thus missing Ca altogether. My other suspicion is that this particular measurement wasn't even from the chip, but somehow measured the aluminium stub that the chip was placed on. Further possibilities are that the formula for Tnemec that we look at is not the one actually used back around 1970 (the MSD sheet on the proprietary Tnemec pigmen that Harrit found is not dated to that time 40 years ago!) and contains some Al; or that this isn't Tnemec after all (which isn't really a problem for us; it would be nice to be able to pinpoint the source of each chip, but that's not necessary to rule out thermite and conclude paint). At any rate, Fig. 14 indicated that the overall Al-content of that chip is minimal - under 1% - so it couldn't be "thermitic" by nature anyway.
 
Re: resistivity tests.

The test does not have to be precise.

Unless the red surface is badly pitted, most probes should successfully touch at least one red point cleanly. Any 'misread' chips represent some time wastage during later research. A lot less time is wasted when such a useful discovery is put to good use by helping reduce the tedious process of picking from a large number of magnetically qualifying WTC dust chips.

Once it was discovered how low the electrical resistance was in the red layers of chips that later ignited in the DSC, it made no sense for the researchers to abandon this useful knowledge and continue selecting magnetically-isolated chips using a 'hit or miss' method.





Dr. Jones, one of the original Bentham Paper authors, has previously posted his disappointment about Dr. Millette ignoring the Resistivity Test results for the red layer as reported in the Bentham Paper.

Would you doggedly pick through a large group hoping to find what you wanted when you knew of a quick 'n easy test that would help make your selections easier?

Of course if you did not want to find the chips of interest, the Resistivity test would be an easy way to find chips that were likely paint or some other material with high electrical resistance.

After creating a big pile of isolated chips, it is up to the researcher to decide which chips they are interested in.

If Dr. Millette had fully read the Bentham Paper, he would have know about the usefulness of the quick Resistivity measurement.

MM



If a test "doesn't have to be (some undefined level of) precise", then there is no purpose in doing it.

Measurements of resistivity using two hand held probes are utterly useless.

They don't measure surface resistivity, they don't measure bulk resistivity.

The same operator can do the same test on a sample & get answers that vary by orders of magnitude, depending on probe separation, pressure, humidity, surface contamination, sample preparation, etc, etc, etc.

This is exactly why there are developed standards & equipment for doing this sort of test.

If you want to get numbers that mean anything, then you 4 point probes or concentric annular probes in a controlled test fixture.

You follow approved, accepted standard test methods.

For insulators, ASTM D257.
For conductors, ASTM B193.

Why do you think that professionals spend an enormous amount of effort developing standardized test methods? Personal amusement? Lack of anything to occupy their time? Unused funds sitting in bank accounts?

The complete waste of time is "doing non-standard, undocumented tests with flawed test methods".

Jones, again, shows himself to be an incompetent amateur.

Milette does materials testing for a living. He is not an amateur.
 
Last edited:
...
(Indeed, you can add some flame retardants into polymer, or use highly brominated - or other halogenated - polymers or silicon polymers etc, but all this can only slow down the pyrolysis and the thermal/oxidative degradation of the polymer. At and above 700 degrees under air, all organic polymers would be combusted anyway).:cool:

To add a bit here: Indeed fire-retardant organic polymers are typically halogenated. Nothing of the sort was specified for LaClede, nothing of this sort is contained in Tnemec, and if those chips did contain such halogenated polymers, we would have spotted the relevant halogen, often bromine, chlorine or fluor, consistently in the Harrit paper. Phosphorus, too, can be in such compounds. So we'd want to look for XEDS peaks at 0.69 keV (F), 2.82 keV (Cl), 1.48 keV (Br, L-alpha)*) or 2.02 keV (P). The only XEDS spectrum that has any of these (tiny bits of Cl and P) is Fig 18 from a region in the MEK-chip with high Fe-concentration. Don't know if any of the Tnemec ingredients would be expected to have Cl or P.





*) This value is dangerously close to the K-alpha of the ever present Al, so Br stands a risk of being hidden under the Al peak
 
I wonder whether this all important resistivity test was carried out on the surface of the chip(s), after all Harrit and the truthers maintain that these chips had surface contamination. Did they wash the chip before using the probes? ;)
 
I wonder whether this all important resistivity test was carried out on the surface of the chip(s), after all Harrit and the truthers maintain that these chips had surface contamination. Did they wash the chip before using the probes? ;)

I don't think that usual/expected surface contamination with usual inorganics (calcium sulfate and similar) can change substantially the overal conductivity of chips. Except the situation when chips are wet (hence highly conductive ionic water solutions of inorganics can be formed on the chips), which is not the case here.
 
"This test does not have to be precise.

Unless the red surface is badly pitted, most probes should successfully touch at least one red point cleanly. Any 'misread' chips represent some time wastage during later research. A lot less time is wasted when such a useful discovery is put to good use by helping reduce the tedious process of picking from a large number of magnetically qualifying WTC dust chips.

Once it was discovered how low the electrical resistance was in the red layers of chips that later ignited in the DSC, it made no sense for the researchers to abandon this useful knowledge and continue selecting magnetically-isolated chips using a 'hit or miss' method.

Dr. Jones, one of the original Bentham Paper authors, has previously posted his disappointment about Dr. Millette ignoring the Resistivity Test results for the red layer as reported in the Bentham Paper.

Would you doggedly pick through a large group hoping to find what you wanted when you knew of a quick 'n easy test that would help make your selections easier?

Of course if you did not want to find the chips of interest, the Resistivity test would be an easy way to find chips that were likely paint or some other material with high electrical resistance.

After creating a big pile of isolated chips, it is up to the researcher to decide which chips they are interested in.

If Dr. Millette had fully read the Bentham Paper, he would have know about the usefulness of the quick Resistivity measurement."
"Re: resistivity tests.

If a test "doesn't have to be (some undefined level of) precise", then there is no purpose in doing it.

Measurements of resistivity using two hand held probes are utterly useless.

They don't measure surface resistivity, they don't measure bulk resistivity.

The same operator can do the same test on a sample & get answers that vary by orders of magnitude, depending on probe separation, pressure, humidity, surface contamination, sample preparation, etc, etc, etc.

This is exactly why there are developed standards & equipment for doing this sort of test.

If you want to get numbers that mean anything, then you 4 point probes or concentric annular probes in a controlled test fixture.

You follow approved, accepted standard test methods.

For insulators, ASTM D257.
For conductors, ASTM B193.

Why do you think that professionals spend an enormous amount of effort developing standardized test methods? Personal amusement? Lack of anything to occupy their time? Unused funds sitting in bank accounts?

The complete waste of time is "doing non-standard, undocumented tests with flawed test methods".

Jones, again, shows himself to be an incompetent amateur.

Milette does materials testing for a living. He is not an amateur.
"

If you are performing what is in effect, a simple continuity test with an Ohm Meter, precision is not an issue.

If you need very accurate resistance measurements to a precise number of decimal places, than a precise Resistivity test would be required.

But the Bentham Paper scientists determined through observation, that the observed 10 ohm-m red-layer resistivity values were indeed a useful determinant for removing paint chips and other high resistance substances from the large magnetically-isolated chip pile.

They published this test method because they found that it was definitely a very effective means of quickly locating chips of interest, as well as eliminating all the paint and other chips showing high resistivity.

MM
 
There's a little more context to this resistivity-issue in the Harrit paper, namely Fig. 3 and its discussion, on page 10f:

ActiveThermiticMaterial_Fig03_orig.jpg

Fig. (3). A series of images of the same group of particles extracted by magnet from sample 2. The color photomicrograph in (a), obtained by VLM, locates and identifies the red/gray particles. An SE image (b) acquired by SEM gives a better indication of size and shape of the particles, and a BSE image (c) shows, by grayscale intensity, the difference in average atomic number between the red layer, gray layer and other dust particles.

The text says:

"Fig. (3) shows three images for comparison of views of the same set of chips using different methods. Fig. (3a) is a VLM photomicrograph of a group of particles, which shows the red material and in some cases the adhering gray material. Fig. (3b, c) are, respectively, a secondary electron (SE) image and a backscattered electron (BSE) image of the same group of particles, using a scanning electron microscope (SEM) without a conductive coating over the sample. It can be seen in the SE image that the red layer of the particles has very bright regions caused by a slight accumulation of charge under the electron beam, owing to the relatively poor conductivity of the red layer (see Discussion section). The BSE image shows the red layer darker than the gray layer,"​
So Fig. 3b, the SE image, indicates that the red layers of these chips have a "relatively poor conductivity", which, inversely, is equivalent to "they have a relatively good resistance".

"Relatively" to what? I suggest relative to the gray matter! Even though all of the sample is left uncoated, the gray material generally does not seem to accumulate a negative charge from the electron beam, so it is conductive!

Now, I have no experience at all with SEM, and with interpreting SE images. I see that, apparently, the red layers to not completely and uniformly charge up, but that they, too, have areas that remain relatively dark. Would this indicate that those areas aren't as poorly conductive / well insulation as the bright regions? Or is that more likely a feature of surface geometry or something like that?

Also, can we judge the degree to which the red material charges up, from that image, and place limits on the conductivity/resistivity? Does this image suggest that the red layer has a higher resistivity than the approximately 10 ohm-m given for the one specimen on page 27?

10 ohm-m is a value somewhere in the span tabulated for drinking water (water with some, but not many, solubles in it). Sea water has somewhat a lower resistivity, silicon and damp wood a somewhat higher. (Source: WP)

We believe the magnetic attraction of the chips is due to the gray layer containing some proportion of magnetite. Do your own google search - I found that magnetite, when relatively pure (used as an anode, for example), and also as a mineral, has a conductivity perhaps two or three orders of magnitude higher (resistivity two or three orders of magnitude lower) than this 10 ohm-m value, but a higher resistivity when found impure in rocks, for example. Hematite on the other hand is pretty much an isolator in most contexts, and so is kaolin (and epoxy, too).

So the darker areas in Fig 3b, if characterized by some mix of magnetite with hematite and other iron oxides, and of course impurities, could be expected to have a resistivity not far removed from 10 ohm-m - and the red layer would then have a higher resistivity. But - orders of magnitude? How many?
 
If you are performing what is in effect, a simple continuity test with an Ohm Meter, precision is not an issue.

If you need very accurate resistance measurements to a precise number of decimal places, than a precise Resistivity test would be required.

But the Bentham Paper scientists determined through observation, that the observed 10 ohm-m red-layer resistivity values were indeed a useful determinant for removing paint chips and other high resistance substances from the large magnetically-isolated chip pile.

They published this test method because they found that it was definitely a very effective means of quickly locating chips of interest, as well as eliminating all the paint and other chips showing high resistivity.

MM
Physical accuracy IS required if you may end up poking your probe at a layer with totally different conductivity, or your probe hits some material that in turn is in contact with the other material.

Face it, the conductivity test was not done using a controlled method. Neither you, nor I, nor apparently the papers authors, have any indication as to how wide a results would be returned if the test were to be repeated, because only a single measurement is presented. If I am wrong, show me the list of measurements and the variation of the test.

As it stands, the test is not completely characterized and therefore does not prove anything, it is a single data point done with a one-off manual test.
 
There's a little more context to this resistivity-issue in the Harrit paper, namely Fig. 3 and its discussion, on page 10f:

[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/ActiveThermiticMaterial_Fig03_orig.jpg[/qimg]
Fig. (3). A series of images of the same group of particles extracted by magnet from sample 2. The color photomicrograph in (a), obtained by VLM, locates and identifies the red/gray particles. An SE image (b) acquired by SEM gives a better indication of size and shape of the particles, and a BSE image (c) shows, by grayscale intensity, the difference in average atomic number between the red layer, gray layer and other dust particles.

The text says:

"Fig. (3) shows three images for comparison of views of the same set of chips using different methods. Fig. (3a) is a VLM photomicrograph of a group of particles, which shows the red material and in some cases the adhering gray material. Fig. (3b, c) are, respectively, a secondary electron (SE) image and a backscattered electron (BSE) image of the same group of particles, using a scanning electron microscope (SEM) without a conductive coating over the sample. It can be seen in the SE image that the red layer of the particles has very bright regions caused by a slight accumulation of charge under the electron beam, owing to the relatively poor conductivity of the red layer (see Discussion section). The BSE image shows the red layer darker than the gray layer,"​
So Fig. 3b, the SE image, indicates that the red layers of these chips have a "relatively poor conductivity", which, inversely, is equivalent to "they have a relatively good resistance".

"Relatively" to what? I suggest relative to the gray matter! Even though all of the sample is left uncoated, the gray material generally does not seem to accumulate a negative charge from the electron beam, so it is conductive!

Now, I have no experience at all with SEM, and with interpreting SE images. I see that, apparently, the red layers to not completely and uniformly charge up, but that they, too, have areas that remain relatively dark. Would this indicate that those areas aren't as poorly conductive / well insulation as the bright regions? Or is that more likely a feature of surface geometry or something like that?

Also, can we judge the degree to which the red material charges up, from that image, and place limits on the conductivity/resistivity? Does this image suggest that the red layer has a higher resistivity than the approximately 10 ohm-m given for the one specimen on page 27?

10 ohm-m is a value somewhere in the span tabulated for drinking water (water with some, but not many, solubles in it). Sea water has somewhat a lower resistivity, silicon and damp wood a somewhat higher. (Source: WP)

We believe the magnetic attraction of the chips is due to the gray layer containing some proportion of magnetite. Do your own google search - I found that magnetite, when relatively pure (used as an anode, for example), and also as a mineral, has a conductivity perhaps two or three orders of magnitude higher (resistivity two or three orders of magnitude lower) than this 10 ohm-m value, but a higher resistivity when found impure in rocks, for example. Hematite on the other hand is pretty much an isolator in most contexts, and so is kaolin (and epoxy, too).

So the darker areas in Fig 3b, if characterized by some mix of magnetite with hematite and other iron oxides, and of course impurities, could be expected to have a resistivity not far removed from 10 ohm-m - and the red layer would then have a higher resistivity. But - orders of magnitude? How many?

I do not see what connection you are trying to make?

A Resistivity reading would not subject the sample to a high voltage electron beam.

A 9V battery in a Multimeter should suffice.

Because of its 10 ohm-m resistivity, I do not believe anyone would recommend the red-layer material for wiring their house.

But even a 5-year old could quickly learn how to select low resistance chips. Well maybe not. But certainly any young adult.

What makes it easy is the huge gap between 10 and 1010 ohm-m. Fortunately, 10 ohms is an easy reading to obtain compared to useful readings below 0.

On the old Simpson Multimeters on the 105 Ohm Scale, the meter would be swinging from one end to the other measuring 10 ohm vs 1010 ohm resistances.

The resistivity of the gray-layer is irrelevant if it is the resistivity of the red-layer which is being tested.

The Bentham Paper said the chips were discernible by eye and range up to 3mm.

As long as one of the probes is electrically contacting the red-layer surface, and assuming the other probe is also electrically contacting the red-layer or the gray-layer, a useful reading should be obtainable. Red to red is best as it eliminates the possible addition of resistance from the gray layer.

MM
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom