This kind of arrogance is a disease on this forum. If you can prove that Harrit´s references pertaining the DSC tests in air state that they also have tests in inert gas along side them to validate the tests in air, then provide quotes, please.
Jtl, What are you talking about? Harrit et al not only did not perform any serious test to rule-out WTC paints; they even did not follow “superthermite protocol” of Tillotson and Gash! They measured their DSC under
air, contrary to Tillotson and Gash
(although this important detail was missing in the paper of Tillotson and Gash)
Here are responses of Tillotson and Gash to
Moorea (available in Oystein’s blog or
here):
Gash:
“Thanks for your interest in the paper. As you correctly point out DSC in an O2 atmosphere will combust the organic impurities and greatly add to the energy release. However the DSC in question was done in ultra pure nitrogen. Since that publication we have considered the effect that pyrolyzing (which is essentially what we are doing) the organics may cause the formation of organic char that may coat the inorganic particles, effectively passivating them and making them less reactive (e.g, less enthalpy). While that may or may not be the case over the years we have come to rely less and less on the enthalpy from DSC for irreversible reactions as an absolutely accurate value.
In irreversible high energy processes the solid is undergoing many changes that may lead to inefficient heat transfer tot he DSC sensor and thus an inaccurate heat flow measurement. At the time of publication, we had more faith in the absolute value of these measurements. That is not to say DSC is not useful, quite the contrary. It gives us a reasonable idea how energetic a composition may be, it identifies decomposition temperatures, and is very accurate for determining the enthalpy of reversible heat flow (e.g., phase transitions, melting etc..). Since the publication of that paper we have found that combustion calorimetry is a far more accurate way to determine reaction enthalpy. And yes, with our organic impurity we find higher enthalpies for sol-gel thermites than regular thermites (due to the combustion of the organic in O2). …
Thanks for your comments.
Alex (Gash)"
And…
Tillotson:
"The experiment was performed as Alex described...in ultra pure nitrogen as is standard technique here at LLNL.
Tom Tillotson"
You see? When following thermitic reaction, even for sol-gel thermites with the minimum content of organics,
DSC must be measured under inert, to obtain results free of exotherms of organics burning. (
Of course, these measurement can be further accompanied with the testing under air, to get more info about material.) The less is the DSC under air itself usable for proving thermitic reaction in the stuffs with prevailing organics, like WTC red/gray chips.
And read carefully all the stuff which was written by Gash as the expert
Nobody is arguing that polymer burning would not provide an exotherm, but Harrit does argue that this exotherm would not be as narrow as his DSC curves and that it would not get you molten iron spheres. More importantly, Harrit does suggest that the presence of iron oxide before ignition and elemental iron after ignition does indicate (thermite)reduction, which is the opposite to your suggested polymer burn. To use your own words, which part of this do you not understand?
I already showed you calorimetric curves which clearly show that
Harrit was wrong and exotherms for e.g. epoxy heating under air can be pretty similar to the exotherms in Bentham paper. If it was not enough, I can past here many other similar curves for burning of polymers with references.
Or, has Harrit presented any set of data which conclusively shows something else? Remember that DSC is not very suitable method for the investigation of thermal/oxidative decay of polymers, results are not really reliable. Various exotherms can be measured even for the same polymer, for numerous reasons. Combustion calorimetry is much better
(as noted also by Tillotson for his thermites).
As for iron-rich (not iron) microspheres, I agree, they can (in principle) come from thermitic reaction. But this reaction was not proven in any other way, so other possibilities are indeed open
(e.g. some transformation of gray layers in contact with reducing polymer char).
Inert gas is not needed to prove reduction. I realize that you have some theories that you think are better explanations for Harrit´s data, but it is time to produce some data to support your imagination! It seems that Millette´s current research would be the perfect opportunity to put you money where your mouth is.
I agree that we do not currently have better
(conclusive, and/or based on some "paint papers") explanation for iron-rich microspheres than that of Harrit et al.
The XRD tests are obviously on chips as identified by fig7, like all the other tests. The MEK tests in the paper said the silicon is not bound to the aluminum which is why they ruled out kaolin and therefore your LaClede paint. The XRD seems to confirm this. There is calcium silicates and aluminates in the Tnemec pigment, but I was under the impression that there was aluminum oxide instead because one of you guys denied any aluminum compounds in Tnemec some while back on this forum. Sorry for the confusion. But since the only aluminum in Tnemec is bound in a compound it seems those tests also eliminate Tnemec.
Are you sure that Jones measured XRD for chips like those in Fig. 7? It is of course possible, but should be first confirmed by Jones. Anyway, if Jones did not identify kaolinite by his XRD measurements just for such chips, he should reconsider the validity of results, since kaolinite was identified by Millette by several independent methods pretty clearly.
In your post, you quoted Jones:
"Even under a good optical microscope, one can see the difference between the primer paint and the red/gray chips; see for example, recent photomicrographs by Jon Cole. While both are present in the WTC dust, the primer paint is rather flexible and non-glossy whereas the red thermitic material is rigid and rather brittle and glossy under white light illumination. It is the observed brittleness that evidently led to the fracturing of the red material into small fragments during the destruction of the buildings. Further, after soaking in MEK, the red/gray chips (still wet with MEK) remained very hard, easy to pick up with forceps without deforming. OTOH, primer paint chips became very flexible and limp after soaking and still wet with MEK."
This info from Jones seems to be interesting. One kind of chips (glossy, rigid) can be one paint, whereas the second one (more flexible and limp after soaking) can be another paint. No problem. This could be a feasible way how to distinguish between these two kinds of chips (or perhaps two groups of chips) for Jim Millette

. This could be a clue how to choose chips which can form microspheres during heating
(should be "rigid and rather brittle and glossy", in contrast to other, more flexible and non-glossy chips, since just these chips were regarded as thermitic by Jones). In any case, any further chip tested as for microsphere formation during heating must contain gray layer.
(We have perhaps already discussed these Jones' sentences, but I'm not sure.)