Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

MM: you wrote (and I have overlooked): "Dr. Jones has publicly stated that there were a lot of red/gray chips collected, many of which were paint, and that their elimination by Resistivity testing significantly reduced the number of chips to be examined prior to further testing."

Any link or other info?

MM: you wrote (and I have overlooked): "Dr. Jones has publicly stated that there were a lot of red/gray chips collected, many of which were paint, and that their elimination by Resistivity testing significantly reduced the number of chips to be examined prior to further testing."

Any link or other info?
 
The reported Resistivity Test values between thermitic red-layered chips, and the paint red-layered chips, were 10 to 10,000,000,000.

That's conductors lying beside insulators.

Red layer materials with that high a Resistivity, will still show virtually zero conductivity even if one probe is deliberately placed on the gray layer.

MM
This is plain FALSE.

Totally INCORRECT.

Absolutely WRONG.

They did not test any "paint red-layered chips".
The referenced paper did not test "chips".

Why do you make up such easily spotted lies? Everybody here knows already that everything you ever write here has a high probability of being FALSE, but you should not make it THIS easy to spot your lies.

from the Bentham Paper said:
"...we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 1010 ohm-m."

FALSE?

Are you suggesting that none of the red-layered chips were paint?

Harrit et al knew that red-layered chips that were paint would show very high electrical resistance as was tabulated.

That is not the same as saying that all red-layered chips with high Resistivity values were paint.

If your LaClede primer paint has a low Resistivity of around 10 ohm-m, it would start to help your case.

"… Specific resistivities were from ca 10x1010 to 10x1014 Ohm/cm (probably), which is basically in accordance with the range of resistivities of pure insulating polymers.

Btw, I've just tried to measure the resistivity of my Laclede imitation chip, using simple two probe method (two strips of silver paste were first applied to make good contacts, their distance was ca 3 mm). But, for my multimeter Agilent U1242A, the resistance is too high (not measurable).

Anyway, my claim that Harrit et al did not refer to some specified materials when comparing the electrical resistivity was basically wrong, I repeat. Mea culpa:rolleyes:

MM
 
Last edited:
Kminek: after your post No 1637, I decided not to answer to you anymore. Why should I bother myself again with the another truther who e.g. wrote: „Harrit first uses DSC test to show that it is energetic because he replicates procedure by people that developed superthermite, so saying this is a useless test is absolute garbage.“?

This your sentence is the absolute garbage, according to me. Heating of chips under air would have some value, if it were accompanied by tests under inert. But heating test only under air is useless.

Clearly, heating of WTC red/gray chips under air must be accompanied for sure by some exotherm of carbon stuff (polymer) burning, which part of this our claim you still do not understand?

This kind of arrogance is a disease on this forum. If you can prove that Harrit´s references pertaining the DSC tests in air state that they also have tests in inert gas along side them to validate the tests in air, then provide quotes, please.

Nobody is arguing that polymer burning would not provide an exotherm, but Harrit does argue that this exotherm would not be as narrow as his DSC curves and that it would not get you molten iron spheres. More importantly, Harrit does suggest that the presence of iron oxide before ignition and elemental iron after ignition does indicate (thermite)reduction, which is the opposite to your suggested polymer burn. To use your own words, which part of this do you not understand?

Inert gas is not needed to prove reduction. I realize that you have some theories that you think are better explanations for Harrit´s data, but it is time to produce some data to support your imagination! It seems that Millette´s current research would be the perfect opportunity to put you money where your mouth is.

As for Jones‘ chat about XRD, I already wrote you in my post 1563:
„I’m not sure if I understand. Jones ruled out kaolin for WHAT kind of chips? Do you know? If his chip for XRD measurements was Tnemec (or other paint… well, material different from Laclede), no wonder that Jones did not find kaolin(ite). Options are still the same (materials with kaolinite, and another materials without kaolinite.) No room for amorphous aluminium and other rather mystical stuffs."

Moreover, if Jones did not identified any aluminium stuff (including aluminium) in some (unknown) chip(s), isn’t it an evidence that such chip(s) cannot indeed be thermite (or at least aluminothermite)?
Anyway, Jones did not show us any real XRD, therefore this „info“ has zero value at present. There is no reason/way to analyze such data, since we do have any real data.

(Note: As for your sentence "What about Tnemec aluminum oxide, could it be an amorphous form", I already wrote you: there was no aluminum oxide in Tnemec, what are you talking about? Try to concentrate next time.)

The XRD tests are obviously on chips as identified by fig7, like all the other tests. The MEK tests in the paper said the silicon is not bound to the aluminum which is why they ruled out kaolin and therefore your LaClede paint. The XRD seems to confirm this. There is calcium silicates and aluminates in the Tnemec pigment, but I was under the impression that there was aluminum oxide instead because one of you guys denied any aluminum compounds in Tnemec some while back on this forum. Sorry for the confusion. But since the only aluminum in Tnemec is bound in a compound it seems those tests also eliminate Tnemec.:rolleyes:
 
ProfJones:
Even under a good optical microscope, one can see the difference between the primer paint and the red/gray chips; see for example, recent photomicrographs by Jon Cole. While both are present in the WTC dust, the primer paint is rather flexible and non-glossy whereas the red thermitic material is rigid and rather brittle and glossy under white light illumination. It is the observed brittleness that evidently led to the fracturing of the red material into small fragments during the destruction of the buildings. Further, after soaking in MEK, the red/gray chips (still wet with MEK) remained very hard, easy to pick up with forceps without deforming. OTOH, primer paint chips became very flexible and limp after soaking and still wet with MEK. There can be no mistaking the distinction.

There is no point arguing about how clear or unclear the original paper is about some procedures, these comments are pretty clear. If Millette finds this information vague then he simply has to contact Jones directly.
 
There is no point arguing about how clear or unclear the original paper is about some procedures, these comments are pretty clear. If Millette finds this information vague then he simply has to contact Jones directly.
I think it's cute how you accept Jones word without question. (or data) ;)

I think that's called faith.
 
Last edited:
This your sentence is the absolute garbage, according to me. Heating of chips under air would have some value, if it were accompanied by tests under inert. But heating test only under air is useless. Harrit et al knew very well (or they had to know) that carbon stuffs prevailed in their chips, therefore it was their scientific duty to perform tests also under inert, to rule out the e.g. paints as very apparent culprits. Their red/gray chips with prevailing organics were „miles away“ from quoted Tillotson „superthermite“, which contained only some traces (up to 10 %) of organics, formed during sol-gel proces. Moreover, these low molar mass organics had to quickly evaporate during heating of superthermite chips, leaving basically no organics at all.
Clearly, heating of WTC red/gray chips under air must be accompanied for sure by some exotherm of carbon stuff (polymer) burning, which part of this our claim you still do not understand?

But since you have asked me twice, I will repeat my asnwers from my previous posts, which you probably overlooked or did not understand or so.

„We are internet forum, not scientific commitee or so. I'm just trying to analyze available data, playing with them, having some rather strange fun with all this stuff, and learning some new things in material science, which is indeed good for my own carrier of polymer chemist.“
E.g., since Basile’s images are pretty messy, he did not really prove his claims by them, and I have indeed full right to have my own view. If Basile has some better data what exactly happened e.g. to gray layer in his chip Lucky Thirteen, he should provide us with them.
Without them, no conclusion can be made.

As for Jones‘ chat about XRD, I already wrote you in my post 1563:
„I’m not sure if I understand. Jones ruled out kaolin for WHAT kind of chips? Do you know? If his chip for XRD measurements was Tnemec (or other paint… well, material different from Laclede), no wonder that Jones did not find kaolin(ite). Options are still the same (materials with kaolinite, and another materials without kaolinite.) No room for amorphous aluminium and other rather mystical stuffs."

Moreover, if Jones did not identified any aluminium stuff (including aluminium) in some (unknown) chip(s), isn’t it an evidence that such chip(s) cannot indeed be thermite (or at least aluminothermite)?

Anyway, Jones did not show us any real XRD, therefore this „info“ has zero value at present. There is no reason/way to analyze such data, since we do have any real data.

(Note: As for your sentence "What about Tnemec aluminum oxide, could it be an amorphous form", I already wrote you: there was no aluminum oxide in Tnemec, what are you talking about? Try to concentrate next time;).)

Harrit, Jones, and Farrer have now had 4 years to do a test that could be easily done in a single day. Their failure to do so proves that they they are operating within an agenda, something no sincere and conscientious scientist would ever do.
 
There is no point arguing about how clear or unclear the original paper is about some procedures, these comments are pretty clear. If Millette finds this information vague then he simply has to contact Jones directly.

Jones is a conspiracy nut, who needs to talk to him? Jones lives in a fantasy world. Why would Millette contact a lair, Jones who has an idiotic fantasy of thermite? Jones faked a study of dust so they could claims thermite as the conclusion.

Millette did not find thermite. Can't be improved. How will you back in thermite to save your fantasy 911 theories?
 
This kind of arrogance is a disease on this forum. If you can prove that Harrit´s references pertaining the DSC tests in air state that they also have tests in inert gas along side them to validate the tests in air, then provide quotes, please.

Nice truther quote jtl, Is it not time for Harrit et al to prove something ?

Even better how about jtl or Senenmut provide some proof ;)

Lol a match made in heaven in more than one way :D
 
FALSE?

Are you suggesting that none of the red-layered chips were paint?

Yes, FALSE. WRONG. INCORRECT. Quite possibly another LIE.

Are you suggestring that the tabulated values were from bi-layered red-gray chips pulled from WTC dust by a magnet?

What they found tabulated was the resistivity of a paint (not chips) not attached to a conductive (magnetic!) gray layer of spalled steel surface not based, as are LaClede and part of the Tnemec vehicle, on epoxy.

All this obvious as the cloudless daytime sky is blue.

Why do you make up lies? Why do you defend lies? Everybody here can see that you are lying - even, I am sure, jtl and ergo (those probably justapprove of your lies - they are Truthers, after all. It's the Truther thing to do)
 
...
The XRD tests are obviously on chips as identified by fig7, like all the other tests. The MEK tests in the paper said the silicon is not bound to the aluminum which is why they ruled out kaolin and therefore your LaClede paint. ...

Can you show us the data that proves the MEK-soaked chip can be identified as having the same XEDS fingerprint as the kaolin-bearing chips a-d - Fig 7?

I can show you that most clearly that MEK-soake chips has a very DIFFERENT fingerprint and cannot be the same kind of material:
Why red-gray chips aren't all the same

The short version is: Fig 14, the XEDS spectrum of the whole MEK-chip, is either worthless due to contamination, or it is 100% proof that this chip is differtent from Fig. 7. There exists no other XEDS spectrum of that entire chip, and thus Jones has not proven that this chip is the same material.



But I am glad you come to accept that a comparison of XEDS spectrum of clean chip with Fig. 7 is a necessary step to determine if we are talking about the same material! As it were, that is precisely how Millette did it.
 
There is no point arguing about how clear or unclear the original paper is about some procedures, these comments are pretty clear. If Millette finds this information vague then he simply has to contact Jones directly.

ProfJones at the time believed there was only one primer paint used in all the WTC, namely Tnemec.

He was mistaken, wrong, in error.

Since there are many kinds of paints, you'd first need to distinguish all paint materials from all non-paint materials, soak them all in MEK systematically, and only then could you start to have a solid basis for such claims and methods.

Jones did none of that. Therefore, this method is not valid.

Also, it is clear that he didn't use that test on all chips presented in the study. The second reason why suggesting this method falls flat on its face.
 
Red layer materials with that high a Resistivity, will still show virtually zero conductivity even if one probe is deliberately placed on the gray layer.
False.

A 10 micron layer of a material with a resistivity of 1010 ohm·m will yield a measurement 100,000 ohm, not "virtually zero".

A probe with a sharp tip can easily stick into such a layer, further diminishing the 5 micron distance and thus the measured resistance.
 
This kind of arrogance is a disease on this forum. If you can prove that Harrit´s references pertaining the DSC tests in air state that they also have tests in inert gas along side them to validate the tests in air, then provide quotes, please.

Jtl, What are you talking about? Harrit et al not only did not perform any serious test to rule-out WTC paints; they even did not follow “superthermite protocol” of Tillotson and Gash! They measured their DSC under air, contrary to Tillotson and Gash (although this important detail was missing in the paper of Tillotson and Gash):cool:

Here are responses of Tillotson and Gash to Moorea (available in Oystein’s blog or here):

Gash:

“Thanks for your interest in the paper. As you correctly point out DSC in an O2 atmosphere will combust the organic impurities and greatly add to the energy release. However the DSC in question was done in ultra pure nitrogen. Since that publication we have considered the effect that pyrolyzing (which is essentially what we are doing) the organics may cause the formation of organic char that may coat the inorganic particles, effectively passivating them and making them less reactive (e.g, less enthalpy). While that may or may not be the case over the years we have come to rely less and less on the enthalpy from DSC for irreversible reactions as an absolutely accurate value.

In irreversible high energy processes the solid is undergoing many changes that may lead to inefficient heat transfer tot he DSC sensor and thus an inaccurate heat flow measurement. At the time of publication, we had more faith in the absolute value of these measurements. That is not to say DSC is not useful, quite the contrary. It gives us a reasonable idea how energetic a composition may be, it identifies decomposition temperatures, and is very accurate for determining the enthalpy of reversible heat flow (e.g., phase transitions, melting etc..). Since the publication of that paper we have found that combustion calorimetry is a far more accurate way to determine reaction enthalpy. And yes, with our organic impurity we find higher enthalpies for sol-gel thermites than regular thermites (due to the combustion of the organic in O2). …

Thanks for your comments.

Alex (Gash)"


And…

Tillotson:

"The experiment was performed as Alex described...in ultra pure nitrogen as is standard technique here at LLNL.

Tom Tillotson"


You see? When following thermitic reaction, even for sol-gel thermites with the minimum content of organics, DSC must be measured under inert, to obtain results free of exotherms of organics burning. (Of course, these measurement can be further accompanied with the testing under air, to get more info about material.) The less is the DSC under air itself usable for proving thermitic reaction in the stuffs with prevailing organics, like WTC red/gray chips.

And read carefully all the stuff which was written by Gash as the expert;)

Nobody is arguing that polymer burning would not provide an exotherm, but Harrit does argue that this exotherm would not be as narrow as his DSC curves and that it would not get you molten iron spheres. More importantly, Harrit does suggest that the presence of iron oxide before ignition and elemental iron after ignition does indicate (thermite)reduction, which is the opposite to your suggested polymer burn. To use your own words, which part of this do you not understand?

I already showed you calorimetric curves which clearly show that Harrit was wrong and exotherms for e.g. epoxy heating under air can be pretty similar to the exotherms in Bentham paper. If it was not enough, I can past here many other similar curves for burning of polymers with references.

Or, has Harrit presented any set of data which conclusively shows something else? Remember that DSC is not very suitable method for the investigation of thermal/oxidative decay of polymers, results are not really reliable. Various exotherms can be measured even for the same polymer, for numerous reasons. Combustion calorimetry is much better (as noted also by Tillotson for his thermites).

As for iron-rich (not iron) microspheres, I agree, they can (in principle) come from thermitic reaction. But this reaction was not proven in any other way, so other possibilities are indeed open (e.g. some transformation of gray layers in contact with reducing polymer char).

Inert gas is not needed to prove reduction. I realize that you have some theories that you think are better explanations for Harrit´s data, but it is time to produce some data to support your imagination! It seems that Millette´s current research would be the perfect opportunity to put you money where your mouth is.

I agree that we do not currently have better (conclusive, and/or based on some "paint papers") explanation for iron-rich microspheres than that of Harrit et al.

The XRD tests are obviously on chips as identified by fig7, like all the other tests. The MEK tests in the paper said the silicon is not bound to the aluminum which is why they ruled out kaolin and therefore your LaClede paint. The XRD seems to confirm this. There is calcium silicates and aluminates in the Tnemec pigment, but I was under the impression that there was aluminum oxide instead because one of you guys denied any aluminum compounds in Tnemec some while back on this forum. Sorry for the confusion. But since the only aluminum in Tnemec is bound in a compound it seems those tests also eliminate Tnemec.:rolleyes:

Are you sure that Jones measured XRD for chips like those in Fig. 7? It is of course possible, but should be first confirmed by Jones. Anyway, if Jones did not identify kaolinite by his XRD measurements just for such chips, he should reconsider the validity of results, since kaolinite was identified by Millette by several independent methods pretty clearly.

In your post, you quoted Jones:
"Even under a good optical microscope, one can see the difference between the primer paint and the red/gray chips; see for example, recent photomicrographs by Jon Cole. While both are present in the WTC dust, the primer paint is rather flexible and non-glossy whereas the red thermitic material is rigid and rather brittle and glossy under white light illumination. It is the observed brittleness that evidently led to the fracturing of the red material into small fragments during the destruction of the buildings. Further, after soaking in MEK, the red/gray chips (still wet with MEK) remained very hard, easy to pick up with forceps without deforming. OTOH, primer paint chips became very flexible and limp after soaking and still wet with MEK."


This info from Jones seems to be interesting. One kind of chips (glossy, rigid) can be one paint, whereas the second one (more flexible and limp after soaking) can be another paint. No problem. This could be a feasible way how to distinguish between these two kinds of chips (or perhaps two groups of chips) for Jim Millette:cool:. This could be a clue how to choose chips which can form microspheres during heating (should be "rigid and rather brittle and glossy", in contrast to other, more flexible and non-glossy chips, since just these chips were regarded as thermitic by Jones). In any case, any further chip tested as for microsphere formation during heating must contain gray layer.

(We have perhaps already discussed these Jones' sentences, but I'm not sure.)
 
Last edited:
False.

A 10 micron layer of a material with a resistivity of 1010 ohm·m will yield a measurement 100,000 ohm, not "virtually zero".

A probe with a sharp tip can easily stick into such a layer, further diminishing the 5 micron distance and thus the measured resistance.

So you do not believe that an electrical resistance of 100,000 ohms when compared to 10 ohms, is not like comparing an insulator to a conductor?

MM
 
...
In your post, you quoted Jones:
"Even under a good optical microscope, one can see the difference between the primer paint and the red/gray chips; see for example, recent photomicrographs by Jon Cole. While both are present in the WTC dust, the primer paint is rather flexible and non-glossy whereas the red thermitic material is rigid and rather brittle and glossy under white light illumination. It is the observed brittleness that evidently led to the fracturing of the red material into small fragments during the destruction of the buildings. Further, after soaking in MEK, the red/gray chips (still wet with MEK) remained very hard, easy to pick up with forceps without deforming. OTOH, primer paint chips became very flexible and limp after soaking and still wet with MEK."


This info from Jones seems to be interesting. One kind of chips (glossy, rigid) can be one paint, whereas the second one (more flexible and limp after soaking) can be another paint. No problem. This could be a feasible way how to distinguish between these two kinds of chips (or perhaps two groups of chips) for Jim Millette:cool:. This could be a clue how to choose chips which can form microspheres during heating (should be "rigid and rather brittle and glossy", in contrast to other, more flexible and non-glossy chips, since just these chips were regarded as thermitic by Jones). In any case, any further chip tested as for microsphere formation during heating must contain gray layer.

(We have perhaps already discussed these Jones' sentences, but I'm not sure.)

I found that Jones quote here, and posted it in this thread a couple of days ago or so (I hope it got move, along with all the other stuff, from the Millette-thread).

Assuming that Tnemec is "rather flexible and non-glossy", and LaClede is "rigid and rather brittle and glossy", that would, in my judgement, provide one explanation for why more LaClede is found in the dust than Tnemec: The brittler the paint, the more easily it might spall.
 
I've never seen any photomicrographs from Jon Cole.

Neither have I.

And: Stupid question for folks here, plus a small tangent - I've seen references to a second round of spectroscopy, specifically X-Ray Powder Diffraction (XRD) being done by Jones, but I've yet to actually see those results. Where have the XRD plots themselves been published?
 
"FALSE?

Are you suggesting that none of the red-layered chips were paint?

Harrit et al knew that red-layered chips that were paint would show very high electrical resistance as was tabulated.

That is not the same as saying that all red-layered chips with high Resistivity values were paint.

If your LaClede primer paint has a low Resistivity of around 10 ohm-m, it would start to help your case.
"
"… Specific resistivities were from ca 10x1010 to 10x1014 Ohm/cm (probably), which is basically in accordance with the range of resistivities of pure insulating polymers.

Btw, I've just tried to measure the resistivity of my Laclede imitation chip, using simple two probe method (two strips of silver paste were first applied to make good contacts, their distance was ca 3 mm). But, for my multimeter Agilent U1242A, the resistance is too high (not measurable).

Anyway, my claim that Harrit et al did not refer to some specified materials when comparing the electrical resistivity was basically wrong, I repeat. Mea culpa:rolleyes:
Yes, FALSE. WRONG. INCORRECT. Quite possibly another LIE.

Are you suggestring that the tabulated values were from bi-layered red-gray chips pulled from WTC dust by a magnet?

What they found tabulated was the resistivity of a paint (not chips) not attached to a conductive (magnetic!) gray layer of spalled steel surface not based, as are LaClede and part of the Tnemec vehicle, on epoxy.

All this obvious as the cloudless daytime sky is blue.

Why do you make up lies? Why do you defend lies? Everybody here can see that you are lying - even, I am sure, jtl and ergo (those probably justapprove of your lies - they are Truthers, after all. It's the Truther thing to do)

Of course they used "tabulated values".

That is what a Resistivity Reference Table does.

LaClede paint, has "tabulated values" which would clearly cause a failed grade in the 10 ohm Resistivity test and would not have qualified for DSC testing.

MM
 
I found that Jones quote here, and posted it in this thread a couple of days ago or so (I hope it got move, along with all the other stuff, from the Millette-thread).

Assuming that Tnemec is "rather flexible and non-glossy", and LaClede is "rigid and rather brittle and glossy", that would, in my judgement, provide one explanation for why more LaClede is found in the dust than Tnemec: The brittler the paint, the more easily it might spall.

Exactly:cool: Moreover, floor trusses were extremely deformed during collapses, therefore the spalling of brittle primer had to be highly enhanced there.

It's a pity that we do not know anything about original (declared) gloss of Tnemec red primer for perimeter steel. For Laclede primer, we know from the specification that the supposed gloss was 30 to 50, which should be medium gloss, according to wiki.

Anyway, if more glossy/harder chips are Laclede (supposed prevailing chips e.g. for DSC, just statistically), we should perhaps advice Jim Millette in sense: Please, try to find more glossy/harder bi-layered red/gray chips with well-proven structure/composition and heat them in some oven up to 700 degrees C under air (heating rate 10 degrees/min). And please, show us the results, namely micrographs of the ash:cool:

Or another possibility: Please, Jim Millette, forget it;)
 
Last edited:
LaClede paint, has "tabulated values" which would clearly cause a failed grade in the 10 ohm Resistivity test and would not have qualified for DSC testing.

Oh, it has?

Then please show that table - give us a citation :)


(Of course, "LaClede paint" <> "tiny Chip of Laclede paint on conductive, magnetic layer of spalled structural steel", so any tabulated value would simply not apply here.)

(Of course, even if it did apply, that is not a method Jones has actually used to isolate any of the at least 11 chips discussed elsewhere in the paper - yiu just don't know whether this low ohm-m value applies to chips a-d, whether it applies to the MEK-chip, whether it applies to any of the four chip Farrer wasted in that spectacularly stupid and incorrectly done DSC test, whether it applies the multi-layered chip, and whether it applies to the chip with the carbon layer.)
 
So you do not believe that an electrical resistance of 100,000 ohms when compared to 10 ohms, is not like comparing an insulator to a conductor?

MM
I didn't say that. Pressure with a sharp tip can easily reduce the distance and current can find its way through a shorter path if it exists. At such short distances, other effects can come into play. Either way it is a measuring method with high enough uncertainties as to make it unreliable and thus inconclusive.

Not to mention that we have absolutely no idea of what chip they tested for resistivity, because they didn't show an analysis; all we know is that it's different from the rest in that it has little gray layer.


LaClede paint, has "tabulated values" which would clearly cause a failed grade in the 10 ohm Resistivity test and would not have qualified for DSC testing.
Yet you can provide no evidence for your claim that they DID use it, when there's no such claim in any relevant section about isolation of chips. That's just wishful thinking, MM.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom