Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Other reasons Harrit –Jones chips are not (sol-gel) nano- thermite, and cannot melt steel.
1) Nano-thermite sol-gel Fe2O3/Al burns expelling sparks. Basile claimed nano-thermite (sol-gel) chip burn experiment does not, just a flame, like Kminek’s burn test of paint.


1-s2.0-S002230930100477X-gr2.gif

Sol-gel nano-Fe2O3/Al burning
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S002230930100477X

Basile’s chip burn

2) There’s not enough energy even if the chips were nano-thermite, in the thin Harrit chips to warm the steel more than a few degrees, let alone melt ¼” thick steel. This has been shown elsewhere by others.
 
ProfJones again at 911Blogger - now he is dodging:

ProfJones said:
Agreement reached on a collaboration to study WTC dust

in well-equipped laboratories. The "interested scientist" in the above blog and I will collaborate on further studies, particularly of the red/gray chips, and we have agreed on doing XRD (X-ray diffraction) and DSC (Differential Scanning Calorimeter) studies in particular. It appears that at least two other scientists will be involved.

I'm excited about this! as I am about on-going alternative-energy studies. Looks like I will be pursuing both lines of research for the near future.

I will write up a more formal blog to announce this collaboration soon.

Remo -- I would rather do experiments such as this, and get solid empirical answers, rather than engaging in "endless" debates at Jref or truthaction.


This, after he claimed
"I would like to see JohnA and Snowcrash and a few others at truthaction respond fairly and scientifically to my letter above"
and
"Let me know what the debunkers say to this letter (above), would you? ... A few years back, I tried to get onto jref so that I could speak there -- and they refused to allow me to join!"



He is avoiding scientific and critical comments like the plague. remo, do you notice how Mr Jones, just like you, refused to even acknowledge criticism?
Do you notice how no comment by ME has been allowed in that thread?

Do you notice how the Twoof Movement practices censorship and self-censorship?
 
ProfJones again at 911Blogger - now he is dodging:




This, after he claimed
"I would like to see JohnA and Snowcrash and a few others at truthaction respond fairly and scientifically to my letter above"
and
"Let me know what the debunkers say to this letter (above), would you? ... A few years back, I tried to get onto jref so that I could speak there -- and they refused to allow me to join!"



He is avoiding scientific and critical comments like the plague. remo, do you notice how Mr Jones, just like you, refused to even acknowledge criticism?
Do you notice how no comment by ME has been allowed in that thread?

Do you notice how the Twoof Movement practices censorship and self-censorship?

Considering the kinds of things that have already been said about him, I can't say I blame Jones for not wanting to get into endless debates here.

This is an interesting development and probably deserves its own thread.
 
I wish to give a brief apology - I quoted Jones's statements as "Dr Jones" when I should have quoted "Prof Jones". I hope he and others understand that this was an oversight on my part and not intended. My apologies to Professor Jones.
 
A fellow named zica comments:

zica said:
Dr. Jones,

I'm wondering if you could at least take a look at the URL remo has provided (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=140017&page=26) and give a response here about some of the arguments they are presenting. I'm not asking you to spend all day on this. I'm sure it can be a real time sucker and you are a busy man. They have accused you of lying about a few things and some of them should be fairly easy to clear up.
More importantly, zica, we have provided facts and scientific reasoning that needs to be considered by those who still cling to the (false) belief that any of the red gray chips are "thermitic".

In particular, ProfJones hasn't realized, and urgently needs to realize
  1. that there were more steel primers used on WTC twin tower steel than Tnemec
  2. that another primer, the LaClede standard primer used on the floor joists, accounts PEFFECTLY not only for any and all data on chips a-d in the Bentham paper, but additionally for the Strontium and Chromium signals that Dr. Farrer and Dr. Harrit have said they found in the same chips
  3. that Dr. Millette did indeed identify a crystal structure for Al-silicate (specifically: kaolin) in red-gray chips that are a match for chips a-d in the Harrit paper
  4. that his own current blog post at 911Blogger, where he suspects that Millette looked at different kinds of chips, implies that indeed there were several different kinds of red-gray chips in WTC dust that were seperable by magnet and have the same XEDS and SEM appearance as chips a-d
  5. that the Bentham paper provides clear proof that Harrit, Jones, Farrer e.al. themselves looked at different kinds of chips
  6. that no evidence has been presented that the MEK-soaked chip reported on in the Bentham paper is the same material as chips a-d. Quite the contrary: All evidence provided by Harrit e.al. themselves suggests it is a different material
  7. that this MEK-soaked chip is very likely Tnemec primer, as its XEDS spectrum is almost identical to the XEDS spectrum of Tnemec from WTC perimeter columns as presented by ProfJones himself
  8. that Dr. Farrer didn't present any characterisation of the chips he destroyed in the DSC experiment, so it is unknown which kind or kinds of the various different kinds of red-gray chips he burned there; the DSC experiment is thus not reproducible
  9. that the DSC is not a competent test to find out the identity of an unknown material
  10. that competent tests include FTIR and TEM-SAED
  11. that Dr. Millette has done these competent tests and has thus shown there is no elemental Al in the chips
  12. that ProfJones's team must publish their own FTIR- and TEM-data before they do any further tests - their holding back of this crucial data must be viewed with highest suspicion! ProfJones, is there anything your team is hiding??

zica said:
...
Hat's off to remo for at least attempting to have a discussion with them.
...
As this thread bears witness, remo is not at all trying to "have a discussion with" us. In fact, the contrary is true: remo is studiously avoiding any discussion with us!

He has copied and pasted texts from elsewhere to the JREF forum, for example this useless patent about magnetosputtered layers of whatever, or the blog post by ProfJones. We have commented on the merits of remo's posts - remo has never even in the slightest way responded to the substance of the criticism - he is not discussing his own contributions at all!


zica, if you think I am wrong, if you think remo was "attempting to have a discussion with" us, then I am sure you can link and point to a post where he does that, perhaps along with a brief explanation of why you consider any of remo's posts here to be a discussion of the subject matter - thanks!


zica, one other thing:
Do YOU acknowledge that
  1. ProfJones is not responding to any criticism
  2. nor is any of his peers
  3. nor is remo
  4. 911Blogger totally censors opposing views on the subject matter - or do you see any post loke mine on 911Blogger? I sure posted a couple or three, but none were approved.
zica, remo, do you approve of, or protest against, the censorship that's daily exercised at 911Blogger?
 
I have just composed a blog post that responds to Jones's recent article at 911Blogger_

Steven Jones and Jeff Farrer confirm four of my claims concerning red-gray chips

I'd appreciate some proof reading, comments and corrections!

By the way: ProfJones, Dr. Farrer, remo and zica are of course invited to respond directly to my blog! I believe/hope comments can be written anonymously without any log-in. I wish I could comment on Dr. Farrer's valuable remarks over at 911Blogger, but I get censored there. Is really none of you in scientific reason and criticism? Why do more experiments when you have a back-log of old experiments with unpublished results?

Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer: When will you publish the full results of the TEM- and FTIR experiments you did on those chips years ago?
remo, zica: Would you please urge Dr. Farrer and Dr. Jones over at 911Blogger to publish these TEM- and FTIR results before new experiments are done? It should be obvious that more results could be of great help to the unknown scientist, or any scientist, willing to do a replication!




(remo, by the way: You are now complaining at 911Blogger that we would not discuss NIST with you. That is FALSE. We would, but only in the appropriate threads. Since you posted here, in a thread on red-gray chips, we would be happy to debate you on that, but not on NIST. I hope you will correct the wrong impression you gave over there, and also recognize that 911Blogger exercises censorship while JREF does not)
 
Last edited:
I reported Remo's off-topic post as being off-topic that's why it was pulled. He seems to not understand that threads have topics and that he is free to post material in a topic that is relevant.

Incidentally just to add some additional information. Jones talks about Farrer having problems with analysis using TEM.

He did not see a pattern demonstrating that aluminum was in a form he recognized by this method, which surprised us.
Kaolin is not considered to be a totally crystalline structure. In fact it's usually described as being amorphous with long range ordering. Degrees of crystallinity range across samples.

Again kaolin fits in with the material they are looking at.
 
the MIX

To be clear.
#1048 "You are now complaining at 911Blogger that we would not discuss NIST with you. That is FALSE. We would, but only in the appropriate threads. Since you posted here, in a thread on red-gray chips, we would be happy to debate you on that, but not on NIST. I hope you will correct the wrong impression you gave over there, and also recognize that 911Blogger exercises censorship while JREF does not"

Please refer #1018 "Dust was created in large amounts both from the very extensive fires (it's called "ashes" then) and from the >100 tons of TNT equivalent of potential energy that gravity converted to destruction.
What energy source do you have in mind that was responsible for the findings you have in mind"

To which I responded : #1040

To suggest the apocalyptic energies witnessed that day; the energy required to pulverize that amount of concrete into finest powder to make it FLOW in churning HOT volcanic ash storms through the streets of Manhattan: to hypothesise that the firepower fragmenting and ejecting so much material in such a short amount of time at such speed to such a degree and in such symmetry was gravity .......that any connection could be made between the sudden FREE FALL of these complex steel framed structures; their complete rapid and total explosive disintegration ....and 'normal office fires' initiating 'gravitational collapse', beggars - outrages the conscious will. That pearl don't fit the oyster mister. Buildings do not ACT like this by just "falling". "Falling" buildings fall, over, here or there; there are clips of buildings dropped straight down two floors or three by demolition with follow-up destruct sequences failing, and the entire building crunches some, leans maybe, sometimes FALLS OVER, but, does NOT loose shape..HOLDS its shape. does not disintegrate into pyroclastic flow. Does not Speed UP through structure of greatest resistance. Does not explode itself into a neat little pile - the walls folded over its pile so neat and tidy observers just naturally, intuitively, said 'controlled demolition".

Somewhere among the pejoratives above, it was asserted "100 tons of TNT equivalent of potential energy that gravity converted to destruction". This is misrepresentation of science and observable building behavior. Of what we SAW, and runs counter to the eyewitness and forensic evidence of violent demolition. The question 'what 'converted' the 'gravity' to destruction is the one we are asking. Suddenly? What was added to the quietly standing smoldering mix to convert static and rigid building structure to rampant moving explosive energy racing itself down the flanks of this apocalypt to utter destruction?

More properly, you would say, gravity 'assisted' the continuous explosive/incendiary ignitions in chain-reaction. 100 ton TNT is a stab at an energetic supply equivalent IN EXCESS of those energies INHERENT in the buildings as they sat, burning; but EXCESS was required to DO what we saw DONE. It could have been more. could have been less. Depends who you read. Who will ever know? What the substances WERE is the question this little witch hunt is on [those skilled in the arts]. What was used to do the [inside] job to explode the towers all the way down at increasing speeds into fragments and DUST leaving molten pools is this particular question. Professors Jones/Harrit found thermitic material, you deny it. We will see . Sulfur of course was found [USGS open-file 01-0429, NYT etc] anomalous to normal 'collapse dust' as were the 6% iron microspheres by mass you say, being 'unusual' by Lee, but, which like the molten iron 'running down the channel rails like we was [sic] in a foundry", was left a dead question, just as EVERY reference to explosive events before during and after aircraft strike were killed in later editions of the narrative.
The study of metal fragments certainly found example of temperatures way in excess of 'normal office furnishings fires' .

Steel Framed High Rises DO NOT collapse into fragments and pulverized concrete due to 'normal office furnishings fires' and gravity. Thats a story for your pet GOAT produced by illusioNIST. con. packaged by professional liars, and deviant agnotologists.
To accept it?...with all the evidence otherwise??..that is another profession entirely."

- end of post -

Which was 'pulled' for being 'off-topic'. [#1049 I reported Remo's off-topic post as being off-topic that's why it was pulled. He seems to not understand that threads have topics and that he is free to post material in a topic that is relevant.]

Whereas, it was clearly addressing the allowed post#1018.

It could be fairly concluded from that action an unwillingness to argue additional energy required for FREE FALL of a complex steel framed high rise, the creatioNIST report 'fire induced sequential building collapse/normal office furnishings fires', and the practiced censorship of it.
 
To be clear. ...

Jones/Harrit found thermitic material, ...

Steel Framed High Rises DO NOT collapse into fragments and pulverized concrete due to 'normal office furnishings fires' and gravity. Thats a story for your pet GOAT produced by illusioNIST. con. packaged by professional liars, and deviant agnotologists.
To accept it?...with all the evidence otherwise??..that is another profession entirely."

...
It could be fairly concluded from that action an unwillingness to argue additional energy required for FREE FALL of a complex steel framed high rise, the creatioNIST report 'fire induced sequential building collapse/normal office furnishings fires', and the practiced censorship of it.
??? Most your post is off topic, already in AAH, and poppycock based on lack of knowledge of fire, engineering, physics, math, and other topics. Moving off topic stuff is not censorship, it is the inability to start your own thread or move your nonsense to the correct thread.

Jones lied, no thermite was found. If he is not telling lies, he is incompetent, has problems with reality. Do you understand the paper? You should be skeptical of the thermite claims when they had to pay, pay money to publish their paper. No journal would publish their failed paper, they had to pay. 11 years, the collapse can be explain by experts and physics. Got Physics? If not get a reality based expert to help you with the numbers.

Pulitzer Prize winning claims, had to be posted in a vanity journal. If Jones was right, Journals would be publishing Jones stuff; but it is fantasy, nonsense. No thermite, no Pulitzer. Jones remains a conspiracy nut.


911 Blogger's censorship, not letting people post is a fact. This is off topic, will not help Jones. People are not allowed to freely post on topic at 911 Blogger - the truth is not allowed.

Why were you fooled by Jones paper? Which part made you think thermite was found?
 
Last edited:
...
Whereas, it was clearly addressing the allowed post#1018.
...
What a sad, little, pathetic excuse to run away from the topic at hand and ignore the arse-slapping you have recieved on the topic! Do truthers know no shame at all???


8 paragraphs of my post #1018 discuss studies of WTC dust and what materials might be in it. 1 paragraph picks up your (only slightly off-topic insertion) of kinetic energy. This 1 paragraph actually intended to ask you with which chemicals allegedly found in the dust you want to replace, or add to, the kinetic energy.


You chose not to respond to any of the 8 paragraphs on WTC dust. You missed the direction at which the 1 other paragraph went and took it entirely off-topic in a long post that failed to mention any dust study at all.




Now remo,
Do you assert the right to post off-topic?
Will you ever address ANY of the many questions asked of you that are on-topic?
Will you, or will you not, discuss WTC dust in this thread?
Will you, or will you not, respond to the cristicism of that silly idea that you brought here that this patent would explain features in WTC dust?

Please indicate if you are willing and able to discuss in this threads topics that fall within the thread topic, and abstain from derailing fully into off-topic territory!
 
Steven Jones responds to JREF:

Further comments and questions for JREFer's

So here is my reply, ProfJones

ProfJones said:
So Zica, I did spend some time going through Jref comments; some are scientific and apropos and worth reading.
What good is it to announce you read scientific and worthy arguments, when you totally, absolutely refuse to address or even acknowledge a single one of them? ProfJones, You don't actually expect us to answer your new questions before you haven't addressed ours - or do you?

I'll anyway expand the courtesy and respond to the couple of points you have addressed at us - before repeating some of the issues you have so far failed to address or even acknowledge. I hope you will return the courtesy. Finally, I will address some pf the other issues you talk about in that latest comment of yours, particularly the issue of XRD tests you have already commissioned.


ProfJones said:
1. Why do iron-rich spheres appear in the residue of the red/gray chips following ignition in the DSC, ...
We don't know why iron-rich spheres apear in the residue, and you don't know either. The main reason for this is that your team failed to give the readers of your paper any clue which kind, or kinds, of red-gray chips Dr. Farrer wasted in the DSC experiment.
  • Was it the kind of chips of which chips a-d are (Fig 2-11) an example of - those with kaolin as the Al-bearing pigment, that are an almost picture-perfect match for LaClede Steel primer?
  • Or was it the kind of chip represented by the MEK-soaked chip (Fig. 12-18) that so very much differes from chips a-d, but whose elemental spectrum is a surprisingly good match for the spectrum of Tnemec primer, as you, ProfJones, have presented a while ago in Sydney?
  • Or was it perhaps the multilayered kind of red-gray chip shown in Fig 31, that contains significant Pb, a feature entirely absent from the two other kinds of chips I just mentioned?
  • Or was it perhaps the kind of chips that you suspect Millette was looking at and which, as you imply, can also be found in WTC dust and extracted by a magnet - the kind that contains a few TiO2 pigments (of which your Fig. 25 might show some post-DSC residue of - that residue that Farrer found in the DSC contains the very Titanium signal that you claim was absent from the allegedly "thermitic" chips!)
  • Or was it chips of any of the various other kinds that may be found, perhaps rich in copper or barium, as your paper suggests on page 28?
You see, ProfJones, without a proper characterization of the materials that Dr. Farrer put in the DSC, it is impossible to interprete the results competently.
ProfJones said:
...ignition in the DSC, which also provides a sharply-peaked heat trace?
First of all, ProfJones, I think the first a leading question - you imply that the heat traces are sharply-peaked, I say they are not, or not all of them.

Take a look at all four traces, plus the trace by Tillotson and Gash that you reference:

DSC-overlaid2.png


Tillotson and Gash's curve peaks at ca. 5 Watts/gram. Your specimens from the Intermont and White dust samples both exceed that value of 5 Watts/gram over a range from ca. 380°C to 460°C - at a heating rate of 10°C/min, this means these two chips were smoldering above the peak power of Tillotson's nanothermite for an amazing 8 minutes! Of course, the base of these peaks is even much wider than that. In short: That was a very slow reaction indeed! Tillotson's graph stayed above 2 Watts/gram for a little under 6 minutes, which is what I would consider its "peak" during which the bulk of the thermite reaction happened. Of your 4 samples, only MacKinlay 1 has a narrower peak, the three others peak above 2 Watts/gram much much longer. So I would ask you, ProfJones: Why are the two peaks for the Intermont and the White sample so very wide compared to actual nanothermite?

ProfJones said:
Do these results not imply SOME type of highly exothermic reaction, beyond that which can be reached by burning paint in air? That is -- where do the iron-rich spheres ( in the ignition residue) come from?
No - you have it all backwards.

There is nothing unusual about the power, the peak width or the energy release of your four specimen of unknown provenience, considering that they all probably consist mostly (70%-80% by weight, typically) of some unknown organic matrix that burns under air - as your paper freely admits on page 28 of your paper.

Your results, ProfJones, actually "imply SOME type of highly exothermic reaction, beyond that which can be reached by burning thermite".

All the XEDS spectra that you have produced on the red layers (particularly Fig's 7 and 14) suggest strongly that the organic component of the red layer is roughly 65-85% of the mass, with the remaining 15-35% being distributed over inorganic substances that include various metals. Marc Basile has quantified his "lucky chip #13" and found it contains >70% carbon alone - which implies more than 85% by weight of some hydrocarbon. On the other hand, the same chip contains only traces of iron and aluminium, such that even if all the Al were elemental and it was all married with all the Fe2O3, there would be less than 5% thermite in the red layer. Considering that thermite has an energy density of <4 kJ/g, but practically all organic substances have energy densities of >15 kJ/g, it follows directly from Basile's study that >98% of the heat of reaction comes from the organic matrix, not from thermite.

Your MEK-soaked chip, ProfJones, is shown in Fig. 14 to contain more C, more O, more Ca, more Si, more S, more Fe and possibly even more Zn than Al. In fact, I am sure you will find that if you run a quantification routine on that spectrum, you will find that it shows less than 1% by weight Al in that chip's red layer (I ran XEDS simulations and estimate 0.6%). With that little Al, the chip could at most contain 4%, more likely <2.4% (most likely 0%, of course) thermite. At the same time, it seems to be about 40% by weight carbon, which would imply close to 50% organic matrix. Again, the energy content of that very real organic matrix exceeds that of the only hypothetical maximum thermite content by a factor of at least 50!

So if your four specimens in the DSC released 1.5-7.5 kJ/g of energy, rest assured that at most 0.03-0.15 kJ/g of that came from thermite. This is too little to even affect the organic matrix much: Given typical values for the heat capacity and enthalpy of gasification of typical organic polymers such as epoxy, the little thermite in the matrix wouldn't even heat the matrix enough to bring it to the brink of decomposition, let alone turn it to gas.


ProfJones, these are the facts that you must face: Your own data, presented in the Harrit e.al. paper, and corroborated by the work of Marc Basile and Dr. Millette, proves convincingly that none of the red gray chips are thermitic.


I don't know why you found this or that kind of spheres in the residue. What I do know is that you found too little (if any at all) Al before any ignition, no Al-oxide after, but too much heat. It all speaks for organic comustion as the main, if not sole, source of reaction heat. Can you exclude, for example, that the organic material, upon being heated, released CO or H2, which then reduced some of the iron oxide (either within the red layer, or of the gray steel layer of oxidized steel)?

Sorry ProfJones, your team is sitting on the samples, your team refuses to release any to your critics, your team did the experiments, your team did and/or documented the experiments inexpertly. It is not our duty to find the answers to the querstions that your experiments failed to address. It is, however, your duty, ProfJones, to respond to valid criticism of your conclusions. I am waiting.


ProfJones said:
2. Our Figures 31,32 in the Active Thermitic Materials paper show multiple layers, and Fig. 33 shows the composition of the "light gray" layer. We published these results, and any future study of the WTC dust should also look for these multiple-layered red-gray chips. I intend to explore the dust once again for such multi-layered chips with the new (and skeptical) collaborating scientist.
Now my question to the Jref fellows: It is difficult to see how a "paint" applied to steel could result in such multiple-layered chips as we observed in the WTC dust and published -- have you attempted to account for the multiple-layered chips which we reported finding in the WTC dust? Millette does not mention them.
I am flabbergasted, ProfJones!

What have these chips shown in Fig. 31-33 to do with the other, different kinds of chips on which you did the bulk of the study? The multilayered chip contains "significant Pb" (page 28) - which none of the other chips do. ProfJones, Wouldn't you agree that this chip must be a different material than any of the chips, or their residues, whose spectra are shown in Fig. 7, 11, 14, 16, 17, 18, 21, 25, 26 - you never show Pb in any of these (just 1% Pb in a paint chip of similar composition as chips a-d, with C, O, Al, Si and Fe, would result in a very clear XEDS peak at 2.35 keV, the M-alpha level of Pb, a peak that would be about as prominent as, or even more prominent than, the L-alpha and K-beta peaks of iron at 0.82 and 7.06 keV, respectively, as simulations tools tell us).

So ProfJones, when you dismiss Millette's TEM data as "a different material" because it contains Ti, why do you not also dismiss that multilayered chip, as it most clearly is a different material?

All the conclusions of the Bentham paper rest in no way at all on that multi-layered chip. Instead, they rest on your test results on chips a-d which are all clearly single-layered, the MEK-soaked chip, which is clearly single-layered, and several unknown, uncharacterized, unidentified chips that Dr. Farrer wasted in the DSC.

To even think that the multi-layered chip might be the same material as any of those that went into your conclusions is naive. To ask us, or scientists determined to replicate your tests to consider it, borders on deceptive.

The same goes for the chip in Fig 33 -it clearly must be considered a different material, as the gray layer has no resemblence with the gray layers of chips a-d, except that it is gray.

ProfJones, asking us such nonsense questions doesn't improve your standing. Please try to focus on those experimental results, and those specimens, and those kinds of chips, that you used to form your conclusions! You see, your conclusions do not follow from your data. Don't try to distract from that uncomfortable situation by running away to the discussion of different materials, on which we can only speculate due to a glaring lack of useful data!


Now, ProfJones, there were a few questions to you implied in the posts here that you say you already read, but you did not address them. Please be so kind and do so now:

The first four questions I ask of you follow from the four points I raised yesterday in my own blog, where I offered a response to your current article at 911Blogger:
Steven Jones and Jeff Farrer confirm four of my claims concerning red-gray chips

  1. Do you acknowledge, ProfJones, that (a) there were more primer paints used on WTC steel than the Tnemec formulation you have been talking about so far, most notably the primer by LaClede Steel Company with which the floor joists were painted, (b) the spectra as well as the appearance of chips a-d are a very good match for the LaClede primer formulation (as well as for the LaClede steel - a low-carbon-manganese alloy), (c) that LaClede primer contains a small amount of Strontium Chromate, (d) that Dr. Farrer's finding of small amounts of both Sr and Cr may corroborate the conclusion that some of the chips, including chips a-d, may be LaClede primer on LaClede steel, (e) it is possible that even more different kinds of primers were used on the twin tower cores (for which no brand or specification is known) and WTC7, and other structures?
  2. Can you please acknowledge that, as per Dr. Farrer's comments from september 9th, you can't exclude the conclusion that the platelets in chips a-d are kaolin after all? They contain either as much Si as, or slightly more than, Al, and also a large amount of O (Fig. 11a; compare the C:O ratio there with that in Fig 7 to detrmine that most of the O in Fig 11a must be associated with Si and Al)? As your XRD and TEM data was inconclusive, you should acknowledge that kaolin is a possibility, and elemental Al unproven!
  3. Since you now don't know any longer, and have good reason to doubt, that Tillotson and Gash did their DSC under air, are you ready to cast doubt on the usefulness of the DSC tests Farrer did for the Harrit e.al. paper, and particularly retract the conclusions drawn from it, until the issue has been cleared up? This in light of the facts I gave you avove: That XEDS data shows that only 2% or less of the energy released in Farrer's tests would come from thermite, but 98-100% from reactions of the dominant material, the organic matrix, under air"
  4. Most importantly, ProfJones, could yoiu please clearly acknowledge that you understand by now that the red-gray chips aren't all the same material, and that thus test results gained from one chip can't be assumed to apply to another chip unless you show first that both have the same composition? Please keep in mind that ir was YOU, ProfJones, who suggested that a red-gray chip may be of a different material, if it contains one element that some other red-gray chip does not! When you answer this, please consider the implication this realization has on the conclusions of the Harrit e.al. paper. In particular: Do you realize that the MEK-soaked chip must be a material different from that of chips a-d, and that thus the finding that the MEK-soaked chip may have contained a trace (clearly <1%) of elemental Al cannot validly applied to either chips a-d, in which all the Al seems to be contained in the kaolin-like, Si-, O- and Al-rich platelets, or the unknown chips that Dr. Farrer wasted in the (probably) incorrectly done DSC test?

As this post is growing very long, I shall leave my questions at that. They address some of the information you provided a few days ago, so I hope you will be happy to reply to them and clarify what you think about the implications!




Now some comments on the remainder of your latest comment:

ProfJones said:
The geologist PhD that I am now collaborating with wrote to me:
"Our lab is prepared to identify any mineral by XRD, and we often run patterns of kaolinite and aluminum metal."
This sounds good: It is probably good that a geology PhD will be doing this. Please tell me it's not Dr. Griscom (who holds a PhD in physics, but is a member of the Geological Society of America). Also, I understand that XRD is a competent method (as opposed to the DSC and MEK tests) to characterize a range of materials. For example, Tillotson and Gash used (P)XRD to determine that a reaction product of their nano-thermite composition was Al2O3. If this researcher actually does a DSC test, perhaps you could pass on the suggestion that he does (P)XRD both before and after the DSC test, with a specific view to determining presence of alumina and iron oxide pre- and post-burning?

ProfJones said:
That is the way science proceeds generally -- experiments and publication (as we did)
Your team wrote in the 2009 Harrit e.al. paper (oage 26): "The Gash report describes FTIR spectra which characterize this energetic material. We have performed these same tests and will report the results elsewhere." As far as I am aware, ProfJones, the FTIR results have not been published. I urge you and your collaborators to do this noa as soon as possible, ideally before any other team spends money and time on experiments that may turn out to be superfluous if you had already published your results!

ProfJones said:
as I wrote to my new collaborator -- we must resolve to publish our findings, whatever these turn out to be.
Full agreement, ProfJones! In particular, it is generally recognized today as the ethical duty of any researcher to publish even negative or inconclusive results, as these can be as valubale as positive ones. So...
ProfJones said:
I will say that after our paper was published, we went to another lab trying to get XRD patterns that would definitively resolve the question of whether elemental aluminum was present. But like Dr Farrer's TEM results, there was no clear pattern of ANY aluminum-bearing compound in the XRD results. These results have surprised me, not satisfied me. So we go to further experiments.
...I am surprised, and slightly dismayed, that your team has not only withheld the crucial FTIR and TEM data from public scrutiny, but also XRD results! Why, ProfJones?? Why did you publish the results from all the incompetent tests, and none from the competent tests?? You are certainly aware how that must taste to a true sceptic of your science?


ProfJones, it is high time, very high time, and extremely urgent, that you, Dr. Farrer, Niels Harrit and whoever else got to do work on your dust samples, publish ALL your data ASAP! At the very least, I ask you sincerely to call your collaborators and get from them a very clear statement if end when they are going to fully disclose the experimental data already obtained! Perhaps I might suggest that we don't wait till you all get the time to write a clean paper that would be fit for journal publication, and rather just compile the data as is, with a few annotations, perhaps similar to Dr. Millette's preliminary report? Such data "dumps" might well be hosted at the Journal of 9/11 Studies - why not ask its editors, Frank Legge and Kevin Ryan? What do you think, ProfJones?
 
http://www.911blogger.com/news/2012-09-08/letter-regarding-redgray-chip-analyses#comment-257544

remo said:
But. Seriously, Zica..all... http://www.takeourworldback.com/millettepaintchips.htm as linked by Poseiden.......
("Poseidon" posted further up in that 911Blogger post - and he also debated me and Ivan in the comment section of my blog post "Another primer at the WTC: LaClede Standard Primer")


remo, I wonder if you and the censors of 911Blogger, who allowed Poseidon's post but denied mine, read what Poseidon wrote - first two sentences:

Poseidon said:
The study by Dr. Jim Millette has confirmed that the red/gray chips found in the dust associated with the destruction of the World Trade Center (WTC) are paint chips. The WTC steel featured several different primer paints, with Tnemec used for the perimeter columns, and Laclede - which contains no zinc - for the floor trusses.

I wonder if you (and ProfJones) agree or disagree with Poseidon's interpretation of the Jones/Farrer/Harrit paper?
 
not banned, just censored

[Note: This post is a reply to this comment by zica at 911Blogger]


Hi zica,

thanks for standing up for free, yet courteous speech.

No, I am not banned here. I can login freely and I can compose and submit comments. However, by default, my comments are not displayed until a moderator approves. This latter step never happens. Or well, it happened exactly once, and for the first time, on september 10th when I congratulated Jon Gold for having received 1000 signatures on his current petition in time for the anniversary. Which proves there is no software glitch and no automatism that would bin my posts.

I have signed up here some time in spring, and have written perhaps a dozend comments, chiefly on posts about the Millette study and red-gray chips. I criticized AE911Truth for blatantly misrepresenting Millette's conclusions - that was CENSORED. I wrote to Frank Legge about a misconception he had about the gray layer - CENSORED. I commented on that obscure and irrelevant patent that SittingBull dug up, and that remo and ProfJones seized upon, and why the material described therein is not the material the Harrit/Jones red-gray chips are made of - CENSORED. I had a comment on a post by ProfJones where he linked to an article by onkologist Dr. Mercola - it wasn't allowed. I corrected a few errors, misrepresentations and omissions in a recent post on retired Italian judge Imposimato - CENSORED.

zica, I have several of the comments copied and pasted to a text document for my own records. I could post them elsewhere, so you can decide for yourself if I was censored because of my conduct, or because of my content. For me, it is clear: Criticism, correction of errors, and open debate are not desired by the moderators of 911Blogger. They seem determined to shield the Movement from certain uncomfortable facts.

I exchanged a few emails with one moderator, John Wright, back in March, and he promised I wasn't censored for content, and that he would look into my non-allowed comments. Nothing came of this. It was only after that when I started to occasionally save my attempts at comments.

So naturally I will not spend much more time trying to write here before the situation isn't clarified.

(This comment posted both at 911Blogger and JREF)
 
The judgement calls of the censors at 911Blogger are getting bizarre now. Headline:

911 Blogger allows Holocaust Denial, censors Science!


In the current thread on Letter regarding red/gray chip analyses, they allowed this comment by user "Poseidon":
Poseidon said:
"Gas chambers"? Which gas chambers would those be? The delousing chambers with very high cyanide levels in the walls, that were used to save human lives? ...
Yet about three comments that I posted, which addressed the science of red-gray chip analysis, were CENSORED.

I wonder if remo, ProfJones or SittingBull agree that 911Blogger should host Holocaust Denialism, but censor scientific criticism of 9/11 claims?!
 
Last edited:
Jones paper backed by bigots. Not surprised, already dumbed down with hate, neoNAZIs are ripe for believing Jones' folly.

Urrr no. Poseidon has stated clearly that Jones's conclusions are wrong and that the chips are paint.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom