Ivan Kminek
Muse
- Joined
- Jun 15, 2011
- Messages
- 906
Senenmut: I'm not sure if you are still so confused or you are just trolling
Some remarks:
- We do not know the exact advices/rules given for the paint ashing in the norm ASTM 1610-02 (it must be purchased and it's expensive). Do you know them, do you have this document? Anyway, the purpose of ashing (getting-rid of organic binder) can be simply accomplished even at 400 degrees C, as shown by Millette (he only found some particles of soot, which were remnants of incompletely burned binder). No matter what the norm says. If you think that Millette did something wrong, send him your complaint
- Once again, the expected behavior of paint for dummies: at ca 400 degrees and above, paint binder is degraded, volatilized and finally evaporated, leaving sometimes some graphitic stuffs (soot, char). Inorganic pigments remain, but their morphology or even chemical composition (e.g. content of water) can be changed above 400 degrees (this stands for both kaolinite and iron oxide). Therefore, ashing should be done at the lowest working temperature in order not to change pigments.
- We do not know the highest temperature to which Basile's chip was heated. Remember that this chip burned with a visible flame, so this flame was able to increase the temperature even more, chip was "puffed" and gray layer was destroyed to the objects seen in Basile's micrograph. On the other hand, Millette heated chips only to 400 degrees, so gray layer was not changed at such a low temperature and without the influence of real burning (without the formation of flame).
- As for iron oxide: in all heated chips after heating, we still clearly see red layers. No matter if they were heated to 700 degrees C (Harrit), 900 degrees C (Henryco), or to unknown temperature allegedly above 400 degrees C (Basile). In all cases, this finding (unchanged color of iron oxide) proves that iron oxide did not reacted by thermitic reaction
and only carbon stuffs (polymer binder) reacted/burned. And, no wonder when chips contained only kaolinite as a source of Si and Al signals in XEDS spectra (as shown by Millette, and by Harrit for chips (a) to (d).)
(Btw, here is a chapter in the book Fundamentals of Forensic Science, named Paint Analysis (Chapter 16))

Some remarks:
- We do not know the exact advices/rules given for the paint ashing in the norm ASTM 1610-02 (it must be purchased and it's expensive). Do you know them, do you have this document? Anyway, the purpose of ashing (getting-rid of organic binder) can be simply accomplished even at 400 degrees C, as shown by Millette (he only found some particles of soot, which were remnants of incompletely burned binder). No matter what the norm says. If you think that Millette did something wrong, send him your complaint
- Once again, the expected behavior of paint for dummies: at ca 400 degrees and above, paint binder is degraded, volatilized and finally evaporated, leaving sometimes some graphitic stuffs (soot, char). Inorganic pigments remain, but their morphology or even chemical composition (e.g. content of water) can be changed above 400 degrees (this stands for both kaolinite and iron oxide). Therefore, ashing should be done at the lowest working temperature in order not to change pigments.
- We do not know the highest temperature to which Basile's chip was heated. Remember that this chip burned with a visible flame, so this flame was able to increase the temperature even more, chip was "puffed" and gray layer was destroyed to the objects seen in Basile's micrograph. On the other hand, Millette heated chips only to 400 degrees, so gray layer was not changed at such a low temperature and without the influence of real burning (without the formation of flame).
- As for iron oxide: in all heated chips after heating, we still clearly see red layers. No matter if they were heated to 700 degrees C (Harrit), 900 degrees C (Henryco), or to unknown temperature allegedly above 400 degrees C (Basile). In all cases, this finding (unchanged color of iron oxide) proves that iron oxide did not reacted by thermitic reaction
(Btw, here is a chapter in the book Fundamentals of Forensic Science, named Paint Analysis (Chapter 16))
Last edited: