Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Senenmut: I'm not sure if you are still so confused or you are just trolling:boggled:

Some remarks:

- We do not know the exact advices/rules given for the paint ashing in the norm ASTM 1610-02 (it must be purchased and it's expensive). Do you know them, do you have this document? Anyway, the purpose of ashing (getting-rid of organic binder) can be simply accomplished even at 400 degrees C, as shown by Millette (he only found some particles of soot, which were remnants of incompletely burned binder). No matter what the norm says. If you think that Millette did something wrong, send him your complaint;)

- Once again, the expected behavior of paint for dummies: at ca 400 degrees and above, paint binder is degraded, volatilized and finally evaporated, leaving sometimes some graphitic stuffs (soot, char). Inorganic pigments remain, but their morphology or even chemical composition (e.g. content of water) can be changed above 400 degrees (this stands for both kaolinite and iron oxide). Therefore, ashing should be done at the lowest working temperature in order not to change pigments.

- We do not know the highest temperature to which Basile's chip was heated. Remember that this chip burned with a visible flame, so this flame was able to increase the temperature even more, chip was "puffed" and gray layer was destroyed to the objects seen in Basile's micrograph. On the other hand, Millette heated chips only to 400 degrees, so gray layer was not changed at such a low temperature and without the influence of real burning (without the formation of flame).

- As for iron oxide: in all heated chips after heating, we still clearly see red layers. No matter if they were heated to 700 degrees C (Harrit), 900 degrees C (Henryco), or to unknown temperature allegedly above 400 degrees C (Basile). In all cases, this finding (unchanged color of iron oxide) proves that iron oxide did not reacted by thermitic reaction:cool: and only carbon stuffs (polymer binder) reacted/burned. And, no wonder when chips contained only kaolinite as a source of Si and Al signals in XEDS spectra (as shown by Millette, and by Harrit for chips (a) to (d).)

(Btw, here is a chapter in the book Fundamentals of Forensic Science, named Paint Analysis (Chapter 16))
 
Last edited:
Senenmut: I'm not sure if you are still so confused or you are just trolling:boggled:

Some remarks:

- We do not know the exact advices/rules given for the paint ashing in the norm ASTM 1610-02 (it must be purchased and it's expensive). Do you know them, do you have this document? Anyway, the purpose of ashing (getting-rid of organic binder) can be simply accomplished even at 400 degrees C, as shown by Millette (he only found some particles of soot, which were remnants of incompletely burned binder). No matter what the norm says. If you think that Millette did something wrong, send him your complaint;)
they are on the internet. you can also find them referenced in google books here and there. i did email him.
ftp://tetco-it.ir/ASTM 2004 PART II...Appearance/D 4451 - 85 R96 _RDQ0NTETUKVE.pdf


ftp://tetco-it.ir/ASTM 2004 PART II...iences_ Terminolog/E 1610 - 02 _RTE2MTA_.pdf


- Once again, the expected behavior of paint for dummies: at ca 400 degrees and above, paint binder is degraded, volatilized and finally evaporated, leaving sometimes some graphitic stuffs (soot, char). Inorganic pigments remain, but their morphology or even chemical composition (e.g. content of water) can be changed above 400 degrees (this stands for both kaolinite and iron oxide). Therefore, ashing should be done at the lowest working temperature in order not to change pigments.
450C is the standard for the furnace ash and at that temp, it shouldnt "damage" the chip like sunstealer thinks. heck, even oystein thinks post reaction of chip 13 (basile) that the pinkish tint is iron oxide. even post dsc (jones) there is a pink tint here and there. you know the temp at which kaolin transforms.

- - We do not know the highest temperature to which Basile's chip was heated. Remember that this chip burned with a visible flame, so this flame was able to increase the temperature even more, chip was "puffed" and gray layer was destroyed to the objects seen in Basile's micrograph. On the other hand, Millette heated chips only to 400 degrees, so gray layer was not changed at such a low temperature and without the influence of real burning (without the formation of flame).
well, he claims the gray layer was not destroyed and the red layer is the thermitic one. also, the slide says the pic is of the "inside" of the chip. he said he heated it alittle over 400C. you guys can nit pick this all you want and spin it however you see fit.

- - As for iron oxide: in all heated chips after heating, we still clearly see red layers. No matter if they were heated to 700 degrees C (Harrit), 900 degrees C (Henryco), or to unknown temperature allegedly above 400 degrees C (Basile). In all cases, this finding (unchanged color of iron oxide) proves that iron oxide did not reacted by thermitic reaction:cool: and only carbon stuffs (polymer binder) reacted/burned. And, no wonder when chips contained only kaolinite as a source of Si and Al signals in XEDS spectra (as shown by Millette, and by Harrit for chips (a) to (d).)

so your saying the chips were not "destroyed" if one heats it above 400C? and you even admit that the polymer binder reacted/burned which is what we want to do in the furnace. of coarse dealing with the kaolinite, you are speaking of millettes chips and not of jones/basilie's chips. i offered millette cash to do the furnace test again at 450C according to astm standards.

so what do you say we try and get millette to do the furnace test at 450C per astm standards!
 
they are on the internet. you can also find them referenced in google books here and there. i did email him.
ftp://tetco-it.ir/ASTM 2004 PART II...Appearance/D 4451 - 85 R96 _RDQ0NTETUKVE.pdf


ftp://tetco-it.ir/ASTM 2004 PART II...iences_ Terminolog/E 1610 - 02 _RTE2MTA_.pdf



450C is the standard for the furnace ash and at that temp, it shouldnt "damage" the chip like sunstealer thinks. heck, even oystein thinks post reaction of chip 13 (basile) that the pinkish tint is iron oxide. even post dsc (jones) there is a pink tint here and there. you know the temp at which kaolin transforms.


well, he claims the gray layer was not destroyed and the red layer is the thermitic one. also, the slide says the pic is of the "inside" of the chip. he said he heated it alittle over 400C. you guys can nit pick this all you want and spin it however you see fit.



so your saying the chips were not "destroyed" if one heats it above 400C? and you even admit that the polymer binder reacted/burned which is what we want to do in the furnace. of coarse dealing with the kaolinite, you are speaking of millettes chips and not of jones/basilie's chips. i offered millette cash to do the furnace test again at 450C according to astm standards.

so what do you say we try and get millette to do the furnace test at 450C per astm standards!
lol, even your sig is nonsense.
 
... so what do you say we try and get millette to do the furnace test at 450C per astm standards!
"The CIA owns everyone of any significance in the major media."
--Former CIA Director William Colby (ironic, a made up quote, not really from Colby, to go with made up lies from Jones)
BS statement, means nothing unless backed by evidence. The same for thermite. Jones' paper makes up the conclusion of thermite, a BS statement not backed by evidence. I see a trend.

Lawrence issued orders to his sub‑editors in which he threatened to fire any U.S. News employee who was found to have entered into a formal relationship with the Agency.
Some evidence, now you are stuck moving the goalposts for your fake sig, say U.S. News is not significant for your fake quote, thus making the delusion of Colby come true, which he never said. It could be said major media owns the CIA because they can take CIA input and use it to investigate stories - shadow the CIA.

The data in Jones paper does not match thermite. Jones made up thermite to satisfy his political bias, he blames the earthquake in Haiti on the USA. Something is wrong with Jones, he is ill or has aged into a politically bias nut who will say anything against the evil government. Jones was fired from his job, allowed to call it retirement. If Jones had found thermite, it is a Pulitzer Prize winning event. Where is the Pulitzer? It is not given for fraud.

Jones Fraud is fringe, exposing his fraud is not big news. Nuts like Jones are ignored by all significant news source because the CIA owns them, LOL. Why were you fooled by Jones' lie? Why can't you take the dust and do the study? You have no evidence to save Jones' Fraud. DSC trace does not match thermite. Why would you do a DSC for the dust to compare to thermite; it makes no sense. I don't think you have a clue what DSC is used for. The DSC in Jones paper does not match thermite.

Based on these observations, we conclude that the red layer of the red/gray chips we have discovered in the WTC dust is active, unreacted thermitic material,
They found dust, stuff from the WTC collapse, wave their hands and declare thermite. It looks more like clay used for coatings, a better conclusion.

Why are you not overtly supporting thermite? Your posts don't rise to the level of supporting thermite. Why? Did Jones find the thermite that was used to destroy the WTC? No, fire destroyed the WTC. Jones found junk and made up nonsense to support his delusion. Jones believes thermite visited the WTC and Christ visited America. He is batting 1000.
 
Last edited:
...
450C is the standard for the furnace ash and at that temp, it shouldnt "damage" the chip like sunstealer thinks ...

But Basile, Harrit and Farrer think it would.

If 450°C doesn't damage the chip, would 400 °C do?

Can you explain why furnace ashing is done, how it is done, and why the parameters are recommended as they are, particularly the 450 °C?

Can you then explain, in scientific terms, why doing it at 400 °C is wrong, given the actual results that Millette got? In what way are his results affected by a 50 °C lower temp?




At what temperature did Basile make his chip react? Was that a proper way to do it? What was the objective?
 
Senenmut: OK, thanks for the links to the norm ASTM 1610-02. For unkonwn reason, it does not work today for me (perhaps the server is currently unavailable), but I basically remember some important points.

First of all, a quote from the section "Significance and Use": available on astm.org: "This document is not intended as a detailed methods description or rigid scheme for the analysis and comparison of paints, but as a guide to the strengths and limitations of each analytical method."


As I remember, the recommended temperature of muffle ashing is 450+/-25 degrees C. So as you can see, the norm doesn't require firmly 450 degrees C.

As I remember, the main goal of paint ashing in this norm is to provide data for gravimetric determination of paint pigments (mass of original paint - mass of paint after ashing = percentage of pigments). This is also why recommended starting mass of paint is high, ca 10 grams. Absolutely incomparable to the masses of tiny WTC chips. And it seems that the preservation of pigment particles morphology is not really goal here. But since I do not have the access to the norm, that's all for the moment.

As for your sentence "So what do you say we try and get millette to do the furnace test at 450C per astm standards!"

If you want, pay for it:cool: And I can tell you for sure in advance what will be found: again just chips with the red layers, in which polymer binder is burned out and inorganic pigments remain:rolleyes:

As for your sentence: "Of coarse dealing with the kaolinite, you are speaking of millettes chips and not of jones/basilie's chips."
As for Basile's chips, we have no data as regards Si-Al pigment(s) morphology. We can only see XEDS of the chip "Lucky Thirteen", in which Al and Si peaks are of the similar heights (Al peak is slightly smaller), which indicates kaolinite (provided that only one such pigment is present). As for Jones'es chips, kaolinite was clearly found/identified in chips (a) to (d). In other cases, we do not have data. As for Millette, he found only kaolinite in his chips as a source of Al and Si XEDS signals, nothing else:cool:
 
Last edited:
Senenmut: and finally as for your sentence: "well, he (Basile) claims the gray layer was not destroyed and the red layer is the thermitic one."

Could you provide me with the source/link/image? In the transcription of interview with Basile published in 911Blogger , I can only read: "But (gray layer) doesn't ignite, it's just the red layer that ignites." This claim does not mean that gray layer was not destroyed/dissintegrated during heating. It only means that it did not ignite, I think;)
 
Senenmut: OK, thanks for the links to the norm ASTM 1610-02. For unkonwn reason, it does not work today for me (perhaps the server is currently unavailable), but I basically remember some important points.

First of all, a quote from the section "Significance and Use": available on astm.org: "This document is not intended as a detailed methods description or rigid scheme for the analysis and comparison of paints, but as a guide to the strengths and limitations of each analytical method."


As I remember, the recommended temperature of muffle ashing is 450+/-25 degrees C. So as you can see, the norm doesn't require firmly 450 degrees C.

As I remember, the main goal of paint ashing in this norm is to provide data for gravimetric determination of paint pigments (mass of original paint - mass of paint after ashing = percentage of pigments). This is also why recommended starting mass of paint is high, ca 10 grams. Absolutely incomparable to the masses of tiny WTC chips. And it seems that the preservation of pigment particles morphology is not really goal here. But since I do not have the access to the norm, that's all for the moment.
astm1610 does not mention furnace ashing. it does mention the low temp ashing but i can only find furnace ashing in astm 4451. once you do the furnace test at 450C and get to the pigments, one can easily do the tests.


As for your sentence "So what do you say we try and get millette to do the furnace test at 450C per astm standards!"

If you want, pay for it:cool: And I can tell you for sure in advance what will be found: again just chips with the red layers, in which polymer binder is burned out and inorganic pigments remain:rolleyes:
cool.

As for your sentence: "Of coarse dealing with the kaolinite, you are speaking of millettes chips and not of jones/basilie's chips."
As for Basile's chips, we have no data as regards Si-Al pigment(s) morphology. We can only see XEDS of the chip "Lucky Thirteen", in which Al and Si peaks are of the similar heights (Al peak is slightly smaller), which indicates kaolinite (provided that only one such pigment is present). As for Jones'es chips, kaolinite was clearly found/identified in chips (a) to (d). In other cases, we do not have data. As for Millette, he found only kaolinite in his chips as a source of Al and Si XEDS signals, nothing else:cool:
they say elemental al you say no elemental al. ok.
 
Last edited:
Senenmut: and finally as for your sentence: "well, he (Basile) claims the gray layer was not destroyed and the red layer is the thermitic one."

Could you provide me with the source/link/image? In the transcription of interview with Basile published in 911Blogger , I can only read: "But (gray layer) doesn't ignite, it's just the red layer that ignites." This claim does not mean that gray layer was not destroyed/dissintegrated during heating. It only means that it did not ignite, I think;)

from that interview you linked:
basile-
"But the gray layer basically seems to be largely iron, although there's some other stuff that's integrated into it too, it seems to have a fairly high carbon and oxygen content as well. But it doesn't ignite, it's just the red layer that ignites. I think if you had a big enough chunk of this, uh.. that I can envision that the gray layer would probably wind up getting consumed into this molten mass of iron that might be produced, but with these small chips you don't get the progression of the event to that level... But I can only speculate."

from what basile is saying and from the context of the sentence, the gray layer did not do anything.
 
Senenmut: OK. Btw, we have this set of still images from Basile's video available:

picture.php


Gray layer is visible from the beginning to the end and it seem that it is somehow enlarged/deformed during chip burning, although not substantially (?). Therefore it is still possible that this layer was somehow dissintegrated during chip burning (since iron oxides forming gray layer are not flexible at all), but we don't see it.

Ad your sentence: "they say elemental al you say no elemental al. ok."
Only Harrit et al said: "elemental Al" (judging from one single XEDS spectrum of swollen MEK chip in Fig. 17). Henryco did not say it and also Basile did not find any aluminium.
 
Last edited:
...
they say elemental al you say no elemental al. ok.

Who is "they"? Harrit e.al.?

Where exactly do they say "elemental al" - what specimen does it refer to - and in which specimems did they NOT find elemental al?

Did Basile find elemental Al?
How much total Al did Basile find? Would that amount be enough to make a thermitic material?
Did Basile find anything nano-sized?
What did Basile find? Please give a short summary of all of Basile's findings which are backed by and based on his actual measurements!
 
Senenmut: OK. Btw, we have this set of still images from Basile's video available:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=890&pictureid=6499[/qimg]

Gray layer is visible from the beginning to the end and it seem that it is somehow enlarged/deformed during chip burning, although not substantially (?). Therefore it is still possible that this layer was somehow dissintegrated during chip burning (since iron oxides forming gray layer are not flexible at all), but we don't see it.
thanks for that pic. ive been looking for that! as you stated, the gray layer is still there after ignition. the red layer expands. maybe the red layer under the gray layer is what made it deformed.



Ad your sentence: "they say elemental al you say no elemental al. ok."
Only Harrit et al said: "elemental Al" (judging from one single XEDS spectrum of swollen MEK chip in Fig. 17). Henryco did not say it and also Basile did not find any aluminium.
the scientist in the thermitic paper came to that conclusion. of coarse henryco did not find elemental aluminum since he heated his chips to 900C and they did not react. different type of chip, probably the same type as millette....the ones with a carbon matrix instead of silicon mixed into the matrix (jones/basile's chips).

here basile speaks of aluminum at 6:14.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZNQq7XBLwc&feature=player_embedded
 

Yes. He speaks about aluminium. Like what you can or can't buy at the locel five-and-dime.

Is there any data? Do you know of any data that Basile has produced concerning aluminium in the red-gray chips?

Like
  1. How much total Al was there in his red layer, and in his gray layer?
  2. Did he show any Al-rich particles? What were their sizes?
  3. Did he find any Al after the ignition?
  4. Did he determine if and how Al was chemically bound?

Senemut, please to answer all four questions. You will find that the answer you can give, as well as the answers that you can't give, indicate very strongly that Basile's own data speaks strongly AGAINST thermite.
For that matter, why did you ignore my previous post? The one where I asked the following questions:

Who is "they"? Harrit e.al.?

Where exactly do they say "elemental al" - what specimen does it refer to - and in which specimems did they NOT find elemental al?

Did Basile find elemental Al?
How much total Al did Basile find? Would that amount be enough to make a thermitic material?
Did Basile find anything nano-sized?
What did Basile find? Please give a short summary of all of Basile's findings which are backed by and based on his actual measurements!​


Had you seriously and honestly attempted to answer these questions, you'd be much closer already to understanding that Basile did not find anything nano-tech, and did not find anything thermitic.
 
The MIX

The patent clearly states reactive materials can be chosen from a large number of organic inorganic and reactive elements. carbon, aluminum, beryllium, titanium, copper oxide, lithium, zirconium and yttrium with all kinds of possible mixtures. Copper oxide, gallium oxide molybdenum oxide, nickle oxide cobalt oxide, tin oxide, germanium oxide. Remember, a particular embodiment of the invention as you argue it is only ONE of a multitude under invention. Processing procedures, changes, modifications are not intended to be limited. Those skilled in the art of manufacturing high end explosive/incendiaries do not intend to be limited in their material mix. USGS recorded organic carbon, sulfur, copper, lead manganese zinc barium titanium magnesium molybdenum spheroids as well as the aluminum iron silicon and calcium in parts per million in DUST samples all over Manhattan. Huge amounts of elemental sulfur. along with the 6% by volume iron rich spheroids.

Gravity sure does grind a Mighty HOT and a mighty FINE grind you would have to say.
 
Senenmut: last time for Basile's chip "Lucky 13" after burning.

Here is how this chip looked after burning:

picture.php


We can clearly see that chip is dark/black because of incomplete burning of polymer binder (leaving char/soot).

Here is again a micrograph:

picture.php


Although this image is messy, I would say now that blue/gray objects denoted as "iron droplets" by Basile may be parts of gray layer of rusted steel protruding from char/soot "environment", therefore they have rounded shapes. But this is just another working hypothesis, nothing more:cool: Anyway, judging from the set of images of burning, it seems that in this case, gray layer was not substantially dissintegrated (contrary to Haritt's chips heated in DSC machine).

Remo:
, OK, we already know, you found a patent. This is clearly a proof of inside job. Enjoy it:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
The patent clearly states reactive materials can be chosen from a large number of organic inorganic and reactive elements. carbon, aluminum, beryllium, titanium, copper oxide, lithium, zirconium and yttrium with all kinds of possible mixtures. Copper oxide, gallium oxide molybdenum oxide, nickle oxide cobalt oxide, tin oxide, germanium oxide.
Did Harrit e.al., Basile, or Millette, find any beryllium, titanium, copper oxide, lithium, zirconium, yttrium, copper oxide, gallium oxide molybdenum oxide, nickle oxide cobalt oxide, tin oxide, germanium oxide?
If not, why even mention it?

Does the patent mention iron oxide?

Remember, a particular embodiment of the invention as you argue it is only ONE of a multitude under invention. Processing procedures, changes, modifications are not intended to be limited. Those skilled in the art of manufacturing high end explosive/incendiaries do not intend to be limited in their material mix.
So you are saying that whatever is found, it is covered by the patent? What a convenient view to take ;)

USGS recorded organic carbon,
Why is that interesting? Does the patent talk about organic carbon (answer: No. It talks about elemental, i.e. inorganic, carbon)

sulfur, copper, lead manganese zinc barium titanium magnesium molybdenum spheroids as well as the aluminum iron silicon and calcium in parts per million in DUST samples all over Manhattan.
Can you explain which of these findings is remarkable, and why? If the USGS were to analyse dirt I scratch from under the concrete tiles on my terrace, would you think they would not find sulfur, copper, lead manganese, zinc barium, titanium, magnesium, as well as the aluminum, iron, silicon, and calcium "in parts per million"? (Answer all of these elements will always be found in at least trace amounts ("parts per million", ppm) in any dust in our city or natural environments. They are found in the earth's crust in average amounts of >10,000 parts per million (aluminum, iron, silicon, calcium, magnesium), >1,000 ppm (manganese, titanium), >100 ppm (sulfur, barium) and >10 ppm (copper, lead, zinc); all of these except barium have very specific uses in building materials)

Huge amounts of elemental sulfur.
I don't believe this at all. Please provide evidence for that claim!

along with the 6% by volume iron rich spheroids.
This is FALSE. The USGS did NOT find "6% by volume iron rich spheroids". No one found "6% by volume iron rich spheroids"; only RJ Lee found "6% by mass iron rich spheroids", the USGS along with all other research teams found around 2% by mass of the element iron, with no reference to particle shape; most of this iron would be oxides and other chemical compounds, only part of it found in spheroids.

Gravity sure does grind a Mighty HOT and a mighty FINE grind you would have to say.
Dust was created in large amounts both from the very extensive fires (it's called "ashes" then) and from the >100 tons of TNT equivalent of potential energy that gravity converted to destruction.
What energy source do you have in mind that was responsible for the findings you have in mind



remo, your posts leave the impression that you are mightily impressed by latin words and scientific terms, even more so when they come in long lists and fat clusters, but don't even start to grasp what they mean. Most of what you write is totally irrelevant and does not even amount to an argument.

You NEVER respond to specific questions - why is that so?
Please go back to post 905 and give direct answers to the direct questions directed at you!
Please go back to post 868 and specifically address the specific arguments I raised there!

Not addressing arguments and questions makes it look like you are incapable of answering questions and understanding arguments!
 
mix

AS is posted on 911blogger 9.8.2012 from Prof.Jones.quote:"The following letter (with minor edits) has been sent to a scientist who recently contacted me regarding his intention to perform a study of the WTC dust, particularly the red/gray chips that we found in WTC dust samples. Included are some comments on a report by James R. Millette on red material which he found in WTC dust, sent to me by this scientist as a PDF file.

Dear [Interested Scientist],

Yes, I would encourage you to do a follow-up study on the World Trade Center dust, after you have carefully read our “Active Thermitic Materials...” paper. [Niels Harrit, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven Jones, et al. "Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe", THE OPEN CHEMICAL PHYSICS JOURNAL, April 2009.]

Among the most salient observations in that paper are these:

1. the observation of elemental-iron-rich spheres in the ash following ignition of the red/gray chips in the Differential Scanning Calorimeter (DSC),
2. the sharp peaking of the heat-traces in each case for the ignition of red/gray chips in the DSC (Figure 19).

Therefore, I am pleased that you propose to do DSC analyses along the lines that we preformed; as you noted, James Millette did NOT do DSC analyses at all for his report MVA9119. What a shame, really, and I hope you will do better as you propose.

...

Edited by LashL: 
Snipped for compliance with Rule 4. Please, do not copy and paste lengthy tracts of text from elsewhere. Instead, cite a short passage and the source.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.

Therefore, I am pleased that you propose to do DSC analyses along the lines that we preformed;

Does this mean they are going to release the data that shows what samples they actually used in the DSC?

What happens when it shows the exact same thing? Will you then believe their own data shows their was no thermite reaction?

Let me guess, you'll ask him what you need to think.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom