DGM
Skeptic not Atheist
How can he claim its the same material? What a waste of time. I hope you will not make the same mistake.
Kind of strange they refuse to share any of their material, huh?
How can he claim its the same material? What a waste of time. I hope you will not make the same mistake.
-The presence of reduced iron (less oxygen than needed for even FeO) in these spheres (see our Figures 20 and 21) implies that a transfer of oxygen has taken place, from iron oxide to aluminum. High temperatures are also needed for the formation of iron-rich spheres (spheres formed from liquid due to surface tension), further indicating a highly exothermic thermitic reaction.
-When Dr Farrer burned epoxy paint in the DSC, it gave a very broad thermal trace, NOT at all like the spiked exothermic DSC peak in our Fig 19. This is one of the many tests he did to check things.
-Later, we mixed up some ultra-fine aluminum and iron-oxide powders thus making a type of nano-thermite (but with no organic matrix). This was run in the DSC at BYU in an inert atmosphere up to 700C – and it did not ignite! We concluded that oxygen may be important to get the reaction initiated.
Another key observation that we made:
3. Migration of aluminum in the red material as it was soaked for hours in MEK solvent, evident from Figure 15 in our paper.
-We performed experiments soaking epoxy paint chips in MEK as well. As we reported in our paper, the red material swells but remains hard under forceps after soaking for many hours. OTOH, the epoxy paint became very flimsy after soaking in the MEK for a similar length of time. This is yet another test which distinguishes the red/gray chips from paint!
-Dr Farrer and I did some work with Transmission Electron Microscopy after the paper was published, looking at aluminum-containing platelets which we were able to isolate quite well in the thin sample. We found that the Al and Si are in fact NOT in equal amounts; the Al:Si ratio came out to approximately 0.92 (based on atomic wt %, TEM focused on a platelet.) How could this be the mineral kaolinite as you suggest, for which the Al:Si ratio is exactly 1.0? Formula: Al2Si2O5(OH)4 .
Did Millette see an aluminum pattern demonstrating it occurs in the form of kaolinite?
-We did TEM analysis also, years ago now, but we did not see any titanium in the red/gray chips! (Referring specifically to the clean-surface chips; see Figs. 6 and 7 in our published paper.) More and more, it appears that Millette was simply not looking at the same material that we studied.
{Steven Jones quotes}
-You suggest that you would like to ignite the red material in an inert atmosphere, which is not a bad idea but there are caveats. Dr Farrer of our team contacted one of the LLNL scientists about this issue, and was informed that the LLNL tests of nano-thermite were performed in air; which is why we did our tests in air also. Thus, we could make direct comparisons with the LLNL data on nano-thermite fabricated at the LLNL laboratory.
-Later, we mixed up some ultra-fine aluminum and iron-oxide powders thus making a type of nano-thermite (but with no organic matrix). This was run in the DSC at BYU in an inert atmosphere up to 700C – and it did not ignite!
-Dr Farrer and I did some work with Transmission Electron Microscopy after the paper was published, looking at aluminum-containing platelets which we were able to isolate quite well in the thin sample. We found that the Al and Si are in fact NOT in equal amounts; the Al:Si ratio came out to approximately 0.92 (based on atomic wt %, TEM focused on a platelet.) How could this be the mineral kaolinite as you suggest, for which the Al:Si ratio is exactly 1.0? Formula: Al2Si2O5(OH)4 .
AS is posted on 911blogger 9.8.2012 from Prof.Jones.quote:"The following letter (with minor edits) has been sent to a scientist who recently contacted me regarding his intention to perform a study of the WTC dust, particularly the red/gray chips that we found in WTC dust samples. Included are some comments on a report by James R. Millette on red material which he found in WTC dust, sent to me by this scientist as a PDF file.
Dear [Interested Scientist],
Yes, I would encourage you to do a follow-up study on the World Trade Center dust, after you have carefully read our “Active Thermitic Materials...” paper. [Niels Harrit, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven Jones, et al. "Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe", THE OPEN CHEMICAL PHYSICS JOURNAL, April 2009.]
Among the most salient observations in that paper are these:
1. the observation of elemental-iron-rich spheres in the ash following ignition of the red/gray chips in the Differential Scanning Calorimeter (DSC),
2. the sharp peaking of the heat-traces in each case for the ignition of red/gray chips in the DSC (Figure 19).
Therefore, I am pleased that you propose to do DSC analyses along the lines that we preformed; as you noted, James Millette did NOT do DSC analyses at all for his report MVA9119. What a shame, really, and I hope you will do better as you propose.
...
-You suggest that you would like to ignite the red material in an inert atmosphere, which is not a bad idea but there are caveats. Dr Farrer of our team contacted one of the LLNL scientists about this issue, and was informed that the LLNL tests of nano-thermite were performed in air; which is why we did our tests in air also. Thus, we could make direct comparisons with the LLNL data on nano-thermite fabricated at the LLNL laboratory.
As has been pointed out already, the first part of this paragraph is a lie. Jones is referring to a paper by then LLNL scientists Tom Tillotson, Alexander Gash and others. I have copies of email from both Gash and Tillotson in which they explain that...
-You suggest that you would like to ignite the red material in an inert atmosphere, which is not a bad idea but there are caveats. Dr Farrer of our team contacted one of the LLNL scientists about this issue, and was informed that the LLNL tests of nano-thermite were performed in air; which is why we did our tests in air also. Thus, we could make direct comparisons with the LLNL data on nano-thermite fabricated at the LLNL laboratory.
An "Al:Si ratio" of "approximately 0.92" means there is actually more silicon than aluminium in those platelets - which is a much bigger problem for Jones's thermite theory than for kaolinite. The former should have a lot more Al than Si (in fact, Jones, Harrot e.al. offer no explanation at all for the presence of Si!), or no Si at all....
-Dr Farrer and I did some work with Transmission Electron Microscopy after the paper was published, looking at aluminum-containing platelets which we were able to isolate quite well in the thin sample. We found that the Al and Si are in fact NOT in equal amounts; the Al:Si ratio came out to approximately 0.92 (based on atomic wt %, TEM focused on a platelet.) How could this be the mineral kaolinite as you suggest, for which the Al:Si ratio is exactly 1.0? Formula: Al2Si2O5(OH)4 .
Millette shows several TEM-EDS images taken from Al-Si-rich plates. They all show the Al- and Si-peaks almost equal, or the Si-peak being slightly higher than the Al-peak - just as Jones has them. So yes, Al:Si ratio would indeed corroborate that Millette was looking at the same material that Jones reports on....-The accuracy of the TEM analysis should allow you (and Millette) to determine if you are indeed looking at the same material that we reported on, beginning with the Al:Si ratio.
The obvios problem of course: Farrer and Jones have not published their TEM-data anywhere so that we could actually compare anything!-I encourage you to do TEM analysis as we have done.
Yes, we know thatStudying electron-diffraction patterns obtained with the TEM, Dr. Farrer found that that the iron-oxide was in the form Fe2O3.
This is patently absurd. The Al-Si-rich platelets are very obviously crystalline. Millette found the very same plateles that look exactly the same as the Jones/Farrer platelets in shape, size (all dimensions), behaviour (the sometimes form stacks), EDS spectrum, average atomic weight and relative abundance. Millette DID manage to get TEM-SAED crystal patterns from them. I'd suggest that Farrer isn't good enough at this.He did not see a pattern demonstrating that aluminum was in any crystalline form, which surprised us. It may be that the aluminum was in a non-crystalline form.
Yes, Millette did "see an aluminum pattern demonstrating it occurs in the form of kaolinite".Did Millette see an aluminum pattern demonstrating it occurs in the form of kaolinite? His report does state:
-Millette report: "TEM-SAED-EDS analysis of a thin section of the red layer showed equant-shaped particles of iron consistent with iron oxide pigments and plates of kaolin clay (Figures 20 and 21). The matrix material of the red coating layer was carbon-based. Small numbers of titanium oxide particles consistent with titanium dioxide pigment and some calcium particles were also found (Appendix F).”
This is plainly disingenous!-We did TEM analysis also, years ago now, but we did not see any titanium in the red/gray chips! (Referring specifically to the clean-surface chips; see Figs. 6 and 7 in our published paper.)
More and more it appears that Jones is either incompetent or dishonest when he comments on Millette's or even his own study.More and more, it appears that Millette was simply not looking at the same material that we studied.
Any self respecting and able scientist will be sure not to make the same mistakes and show the same degree of ignorance as Mr. Jones[**].-Why would he not measure the electrical resistivity of his red material (discussed in our paper) right off? That's what gets me – he could have saved himself a lot of time. Finally he gets to TEM analysis, and finds that he has titanium oxide pigment! How can he claim its the same material? What a waste of time. I hope you will not make the same mistake.
Sincerely,
Steven E. Jones"
Dr Jones spreads woo, and those who can't think for themselves suck it up and repeat the insane delusion thermite was used to destroy the WTC. Is Dr Jones insane, his claim of thermite is?, he implies the earthquake in Haiti was a false flag operation, and never struck down wild speculation about the same. That is pathetic, spreading delusions about a disaster. Dr Jones is anti-Bush, or something, that had him make up thermite. Jones sees aluminum coming out the corner of the WTC, turning silvery as it cools, waves his hands, claims thermite.AS is posted on 911blogger 9.8.2012 from Prof.Jones.quote:"...? What a waste of time. I hope you will not make the same mistake.
Sincerely,
Steven E. Jones"
end
911 truth definition of truth - slander.I hope you don't mind but I copied it over to a jref thread that has been liberally slandering your work.
Submitted by remo on Sat, 09/08/2012 - 5:35pm.
Why are some people who spread delusion so personable, not knowing they are spreading insane claims.I don't mind.
Let me know what the debunkers say to this letter (above), would you? this would include the guys at truthaction also...
A few years back, I tried to get onto jref so that I could speak there -- and they refused to allow me to join!
I appreciate people like you, sittingbull and others, who have the time and stomach to deal with the debunkers.
I'm a researcher, not a debater, but I will stand up for the truth and just wish I had more time.
Thanks again.
Steve
Dr Jones is not all there. He had to pay to have his paper published because it is BS. They study "dust", found a coating from the WTC or other buildings in the area, and declare it is super secret nano-thermite. It is so funny, it is sad.The only reason we don't approve a registration is if they do not include the required information, so if someone provides the required information (which is first name, last name, country and state if in the USA) the account is approved (subject to the usual checks that we use to identify such naughtiness as sock puppets).
that have the capability of considerably more heat than organic explosives ...
Hello remo,
Africanus, Redwood and Ivan Kminek have offered detailed and substantive criticism and discussion of the claims you copied and pasted as an errand runner and poster boy for Mr. S. Jones. I hope you will respond to that criticism and discussion by in turn addressing the specific and substantive points with specific and substantive replies of your own.
Please indicate here if you don't understand the science behind the argument and are thus incapable of participating in a reasond debate on the issue!
remo, you should start to entertain the possibility in your head that Farrer, Harrit and Jones are simply incompetent when it comes to analysing mineral pigments! Don't believe Mr. Jones just because he posts it on a board that share your own favorite delusions!
Watch out:
http://www.911blogger.com/news/2012-09-08/letter-regarding-redgray-chip-analyses
Steven Jones wants to talk to us
...
ProfJones said:I don't mind.
Let me know what the debunkers say to this letter (above), would you? this would include the guys at truthaction also...
A few years back, I tried to get onto jref so that I could speak there -- and they refused to allow me to join!
I appreciate people like you, sittingbull and others, who have the time and stomach to deal with the debunkers.
I'm a researcher, not a debater, but I will stand up for the truth and just wish I had more time.
Thanks again.
Steve
Submitted by ProfJones on Sat, 09/08/2012 - 5:43pm
ProfJones said:Neils Harrit recommended
that I make a modification for clarity -- which I have done. Here is the revised portion:
"I encourage you to do TEM analysis as we have done. Studying electron-diffraction patterns obtained with the TEM, Dr. Farrer found that that the iron-oxide was in the form Fe2O3. He did not see a pattern demonstrating that aluminum was in a form he recognized by this method, which surprised us. There are possible explanations for this; see for example http://www.tms.org/pubs/journals/jom/0203/perepezko-0203.html . I'll leave it at that for now. I have encouraged Dr. Farrer to write up and publish his TEM findings."
The reference here speaks of amorphous aluminum alloys; I have found that even the existence of this amorphous form relating to aluminum is surprising to some scientists who somehow had not heard of it.
Remo, you may wish to call attention to this revised section, this edit.
It may be that the debunkers will simply ignore this essay; I hope not. Nothing yet at truthaction that I can see.
I encourage replies that are "to the science" and evidence-based, rather than hollow and slanderous ad hominem ("to the man") attacks.
Submitted by ProfJones on Sun, 09/09/2012 - 6:22am
Jon Cole said:I also appreciate....
...all those with differing natural abilities spreading the truth. Each of us has our own strengths and weaknesses, and whether it's critical research like what Prof. Jones does, or making presentations, debating, street actions, writing, music or whatever, it all helps.
And I think like the Hippocratic oath in medicine, ("first, do no harm") the important thing is to avoid intentionally (knowingly) spreading disinformation, or expressing excessive internal arguments, which could do more harm than good to the "patient" of truth...and exactly what our distractors want.
Submitted by Jon Cole on Sun, 09/09/2012 - 12:23pm
zica said:jref thread
Hi remo,
Could you post the URL for the jref thread?
Thanks!
Submitted by zica on Sun, 09/09/2012 - 12:44pm
ProfJones said:Very well said, Jon.
I have much appreciated your clear and instructive videos of your experiments.
A friend of mine has told me about how the truthaction group has gone over to the side of vehemently attacking co-workers in the 9/11 truth-seeking movement in ad hominem fashion. It is sad; this for instance from a 3 Sept 2012 posting there:
"I've gotten nothing but anger from know it all activists claiming Jones was legitimate - and DRG - and Gage - and Legge - "
as he goes on in various posts attacking us. Kevin Ryan is also attacked (e.g. Snowcrash post 6 Sept 2012). I'm called a "liar" and a "fraud" there, but without backing up those slanderous epithets that I can see.
I have a great deal of respect for DR Griffin, Richard Gage, Frank Legge and Kevin Ryan, and these vehement personal attacks are bewildering, coming from fellows who claim to be a 9/11 truth activists themselves. And they probably are -- but why cannot they RESPECTFULLY deal with others in the 9/11 truth movement who like to use SCIENCE to advance the truth, or with whom they may disagree for some reason? Why must they attack us with epithets and divide the movement?
I would like to see JohnA and Snowcrash and a few others at truthaction respond fairly and scientifically to my letter above. And re-think their attacks on those who take a scientific, evidence-based approach to challenging the official story of 9/11.
--Steven Jones
'One advantage of becoming a JREF member is that the Membership Agreement protects YOU from being abused and talked to uncivilly in the forum.' Not my experience at all. About as accurate as the illusioNIST report.
wow, illusioNIST - wow. A baseless claim, kind of makes your claims more crazy. Jones has to claim all NIST scientist and engineers are in on the big conspiracy he can't define. Jones is very personable, but sure does spread crazy claims - he fooled you. Don't worry, if you do this right it will only cost you some humble pie - whereas many cons involve thousands of dollars lost.... quote:'One advantage of becoming a JREF member is that the Membership Agreement protects YOU from being abused and talked to uncivilly in the forum.' Not my experience at all. About as accurate as the illusioNIST report.
It appears both subscribers are banned from each others sites? Why is that? Less ad hominem over on blogger than here tho. Why would that be a surprise? I ask jref admin. to allow the URL below on even tho I have only 9 postings. This is important to the matter.
...
911Blogger censors said:The post has been submitted for moderation and won't be listed publicly until it has been approved.
Letter regarding red/gray chip analyses
Submitted by ProfJones on Sat, 09/08/2012 - 1:30pm
[...]
ProfJones said:Note added, based on comments received 9-9-12 from Dr. Jeffrey Farrer.
1. Dr. Farrer contacted Dr. Tillotson of LLNL regarding the LLNL production and ignition of nano-thermite; Dr Tillotson said the experiments were likely done in atmosphere. After publication of our paper, others have suggested that the experiments in the LLNL publication were performed in an inert atmosphere; so the picture is not clear to us at this time and further contact with the LLNL scientists is advised. It would be best to run studies in both atmosphere and in an inert gas.
2. The DSC run with the ultra-fine aluminum and iron-oxide (which did not ignite in atmosphere) may have been heated to approximately 800 degrees centigrade. Jeff will check his notes.
3. It would be desirable for the interested scientist to do more tests in the DSC of the type we did with epoxy paint. We have a sample of actual primer paint used on the World Trade Center, available for testing. The XEDS analysis shows that this WTC-paint has a chemical signature which dramatically differs from that of the red material we reported on (Figure 7 in our paper).
4. The interested scientist is encouraged to do the MEK-soak test along with SEM analyses.
5. With regard to the 0.92 ratio, Jeff notes that he did not use standards for the TEM/XEDS analysis so this ratio could be consistent with unity. The interested scientist is encouraged to use standards for the TEM/XEDS so this ratio can be pinned down definitively.
6. Jeff notes that in his TEM analyses he observed “very small (nanometer-scale) Pb particles in the TEM samples” as well as strontium and chromium in small amounts. (Much of the TEM analysis was performed at higher magnification than used in the SEM analysis done in the paper.) Thus, red/gray chips which match ours will show these same elements under TEM analysis. I have searched Millette's plots (as presented so far) and see no indication of strontium (Sr) or lead (Pb) in his samples.
Dr Millette had no need to perform DSC. The exercise is one of materials characterisation, i.e. I have an unknown material, what is it?Dr Jones said:The following letter (with minor edits) has been sent to a scientist who recently contacted me regarding his intention to perform a study of the WTC dust, particularly the red/gray chips that we found in WTC dust samples. Included are some comments on a report by James R. Millette on red material which he found in WTC dust, sent to me by this scientist as a PDF file.
Dear [Interested Scientist],
Yes, I would encourage you to do a follow-up study on the World Trade Center dust, after you have carefully read our “Active Thermitic Materials...” paper. [Niels Harrit, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven Jones, et al. "Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe", THE OPEN CHEMICAL PHYSICS JOURNAL, April 2009.]
Among the most salient observations in that paper are these:
1. the observation of elemental-iron-rich spheres in the ash following ignition of the red/gray chips in the Differential Scanning Calorimeter (DSC),
2. the sharp peaking of the heat-traces in each case for the ignition of red/gray chips in the DSC (Figure 19).
Therefore, I am pleased that you propose to do DSC analyses along the lines that we preformed; as you noted, James Millette did NOT do DSC analyses at all for his report MVA9119. What a shame, really, and I hope you will do better as you propose.
Your specimens contained a carbon based matrix which is readily shown in your paper.Dr Jones said:The presence of reduced iron (less oxygen than needed for even FeO) in these spheres (see our Figures 20 and 21) implies that a transfer of oxygen has taken place, from iron oxide to aluminum. High temperatures are also needed for the formation of iron-rich spheres (spheres formed from liquid due to surface tension), further indicating a highly exothermic thermitic reaction.
Which epoxy based paint? Do you have the material data sheet? The paper makes mention of testing on epoxy paint but never states what that paint is.Dr Jones said:When Dr Farrer burned epoxy paint in the DSC, it gave a very broad thermal trace, NOT at all like the spiked exothermic DSC peak in our Fig 19. This is one of the many tests he did to check things.
Another red-herring that would never have made it into the paper had it been peer reviewed by a materials engineer. There is no point in carrying out a straight forward test and then waste valuable text in a paper if that test doesn't add to the exercise of characterisation.Dr Jones said:Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material.
Already answered by Moore34.Dr Jones said:You suggest that you would like to ignite the red material in an inert atmosphere, which is not a bad idea but there are caveats. Dr Farrer of our team contacted one of the LLNL scientists about this issue, and was informed that the LLNL tests of nano-thermite were performed in air; which is why we did our tests in air also. Thus, we could make direct comparisons with the LLNL data on nano-thermite fabricated at the LLNL laboratory.
Atmospheric oxygen is not required to get the reaction started. I cannot fathom why such educated people could not have performed the most basic research to see that such a conclusion is fundamentally wrong. Thermite is famous for not requiring external atmospheric oxygen to produce the reaction.Dr Jones said:Later, we mixed up some ultra-fine aluminum and iron-oxide powders thus making a type of nano-thermite (but with no organic matrix). This was run in the DSC at BYU in an inert atmosphere up to 700C – and it did not ignite! We concluded that oxygen may be important to get the reaction initiated.
There are thousands of paint formulations so testing one will not give any indication of a trend.Dr Jones said:You say that the exothermic peaks we observed in the DSC (our Figure 19) could be due to burning of epoxy paint. Not according to our experiments -- that is, when Dr Farrer burned epoxy paint in the DSC, it gave a very broad thermal trace, NOT at all like the spiked exothermic DSC peaks in Fig 19. Igniting paint in the same DSC is one of many tests performed to double-check our experiments, and I urge you to do similar tests.
He didn't need to. His methods determined exactly what the material consisted of without DSC.Dr Jones said:Please keep these facts in mind as you undertake DSC studies – which I welcome! Yes, I was surprised that James Millette did not even perform DSC studies.
The chip soaked in MEK was not the same material as specimens a, b, c and d in the Bentham paper.Dr Jones said:Another key observation that we made:
3. Migration of aluminum in the red material as it was soaked for hours in MEK solvent, evident from Figure 15 in our paper.
If you compare frames c) aluminum and e) silicon in Fig. 15, you will see regions where the aluminum is clearly separated from the silicon. This argues against the red material being kaolinite as you and Millette suggest.
As I've shown above you didn't realise you had two different paints in your red/gray samples.Dr Jones said:We performed experiments soaking epoxy paint chips in MEK as well. As we reported in our paper, the red material swells but remains hard under forceps after soaking for many hours. OTOH, the epoxy paint became very flimsy after soaking in the MEK for a similar length of time. This is yet another test which distinguishes the red/gray chips from paint!
Already answered by Redwood.Dr Jones said:Dr Farrer and I did some work with Transmission Electron Microscopy after the paper was published, looking at aluminum-containing platelets which we were able to isolate quite well in the thin sample. We found that the Al and Si are in fact NOT in equal amounts; the Al:Si ratio came out to approximately 0.92 (based on atomic wt %, TEM focused on a platelet.) How could this be the mineral kaolinite as you suggest, for which the Al:Si ratio is exactly 1.0? Formula: Al2Si2O5(OH)4 .
The accuracy of the TEM analysis should allow you (and Millette) to determine if you are indeed looking at the same material that we reported on, beginning with the Al:Si ratio.
Rhombodedral Fe2O3 is easily determined because of the particle shape. TEM would only confirm what would already be known by a quick look at the particle in the SEM.Dr Jones said:I encourage you to do TEM analysis as we have done. Studying electron-diffraction patterns obtained with the TEM, Dr. Farrer found that that the iron-oxide was in the form Fe2O3.
He's not familiar with kaolin.Dr Jones said:He did not see a pattern demonstrating that aluminum was in a form he recognized by this method, which surprised us.
No, it's kaolin.Dr Jones said:There are possible explanations for this; see for example http://www.tms.org/pubs/journals/jom/0203/perepezko-0203.html . I'll leave it at that for now.
Yes he did. See Fig 19. There are also pages 48-51.Dr Jones said:I have encouraged Dr. Farrer to write up and publish his TEM findings. Did Millette see an electron diffraction pattern demonstrating that aluminum occurs in the form of kaolinite? His report does state:
Millette report: "TEM-SAED-EDS analysis of a thin section of the red layer showed equant-shaped particles of iron consistent with iron oxide pigments and plates of kaolin clay (Figures 20 and 21). The matrix material of the red coating layer was carbon-based. Small numbers of titanium oxide particles consistent with titanium dioxide pigment and some calcium particles were also found (Appendix F).”
Millette used your exact same methodolgy using a magnet to separate chips from the dust.Dr Jones said:We did TEM analysis also, years ago now, but we did not see any titanium in the red/gray chips! (Referring specifically to the clean-surface chips; see Figs. 6 and 7 in our published paper.) More and more, it appears that Millette was simply not looking at the same material that we studied.
Red/gray particles that matched the criteria (attracted to a magnet and an EDS Al-Si-Fe spectrum) were then considered particles of interest and subjected to additional analytical testing.
No, the electrical resistivity test is unimportant and not required one bit if you want to characterise the material properly. In fact doing so IS wasting time (which is why Millette didn't do it) because you could have used that time to perform a better test that would give definitive answers (which is exactly what Millette did).Dr Jones said:Why would he not measure the electrical resistivity of his red material (discussed in our paper) right off? That's what gets me – he could have saved himself a lot of time.
I hope that you use your own experience and expertise to make a judgement for yourself based upon methods and techniques that will actually characterise the material properly rather than using techniques such as DSC, MEK soaking and Electrical Resistivity measuring that don't.Dr Jones said:Finally he gets to TEM analysis, and finds that he has titanium oxide! How can he claim its the same material? What a waste of time. I hope you will not make the same mistake.
Why bother? Why not use a technique that will definitively prove what the material contains.Dr Jones said:Note added, based on comments received 9-9-12 from Dr. Jeffrey Farrer.
1. Dr. Farrer contacted Dr. Tillotson of LLNL regarding the LLNL production and ignition of nano-thermite; Dr Tillotson said the experiments were likely done in atmosphere. After publication of our paper, others have suggested that the experiments in the LLNL publication were performed in an inert atmosphere; so the picture is not clear to us at this time and further contact with the LLNL scientists is advised. It would be best to run studies in both atmosphere and in an inert gas.
2. The DSC run with the ultra-fine aluminum and iron-oxide (which did not ignite in atmosphere) may have been heated to approximately 800 degrees centigrade. Jeff will check his notes.
You certainly do, it's called Fig 14 in the Bentham paper.Dr Jones said:3. It would be desirable for the interested scientist to do more tests in the DSC of the type we did with epoxy paint. We have a sample of actual primer paint used on the World Trade Center, available for testing. The XEDS analysis shows that this WTC-paint has a chemical signature which dramatically differs from that of the red material we reported on (Figure 7 in our paper).
Why bother? What does that test achieve?Dr Jones said:4. The interested scientist is encouraged to do the MEK-soak test along with SEM analyses.
I'll leave the reader to judge this one.Dr Jones said:5. With regard to the 0.92 ratio, Jeff notes that he did not use standards for the TEM/XEDS analysis so this ratio could be consistent with unity. The interested scientist is encouraged to use standards for the TEM/XEDS so this ratio can be pinned down definitively.
Strontium and Chromium eh? Why would strontium and chromium be present in thermite?Dr Jones said:6. Jeff notes that in his TEM analyses he observed “very small (nanometer-scale) Pb particles in the TEM samples” as well as strontium and chromium in small amounts. (Much of the TEM analysis was performed at higher magnification than used in the SEM analysis done in the paper.) Thus, red/gray chips which match ours will show these same elements under TEM analysis.
You won't see strontium because Sr exhibits K alpha and K beta peaks at 14.1 and 15.8 KeV respectively, which is off the scale in Millettes spectra. Infact you don't see Sr in the spectra of specimens a-d in the Bentham paper, however, we know they are there because your own data shows you.Dr Jones said:I (Dr. Jones) have searched Millette's plots and see no indication of strontium (Sr) or lead (Pb) in his samples, but he does report titanium (Ti) which we do not see. Thus, his samples do not appear to be the same material as what we reported on.