Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Urrr no. Poseidon has stated clearly that Jones's conclusions are wrong and that the chips are paint.
Right, but is he the one saying Jones did find thermite on his chips? lol, the plot gets dumber.

Paint with thermite? Contaminated by SRFM? Wow, it is worse than I thought.

Millette study fails to refute crucial findings by Harrit et al
http://www.takeourworldback.com/millettepaintchips.htm#SFRMUpgrade
How the accelerants were applied
An outline of the likely WTC1 demolition scenario is necessary in order to account for why the red/gray chips would have active accelerant material on the outer surface of the red layer of unwashed chips whilst containing no elemental aluminum within the chips. On the outer surface of the structural steel, e.g., floor trusses, is a layer of oxidized steel known as mill scale. Adjacent to this is the primer paint, and adjacent to that is the spray-applied fire resistive material (SFRM), popularly termed "fireproofing". The red/gray "chips" are flakes of primer (red layer) and mill scale (gray layer). The adhesion strength of the epoxy binding the primer to the mill scale can exceed the adhesion of the mill scale to the steel substrate, which is much lower than the ultimate strength of steel. After destruction / removal of the SFRM, whether by office fires, aircraft impact, building collapse or arson accelerant, flakes of the two middle layers remain as the "red/gray chips".

Who posted this?
http://www.takeourworldback.com/millettepaintchips.htm#SFRMUpgrade
Who is the neoNAZI?
It is hard to tell what they believe, what they say.
Jones is pure BS, he has problems, spreading lies about 911.

Wow, it gets worse. Yes, someone says it is paint, but the findings of Jones are thermite, but it was in the ...
contamination from accelerant material, embedded within the 3 inches of SFRM directly in contact with the primer, remained on other unwashed chips and was responsible for the post-ignition iron-rich spheres
Better get bigger tent, they are adding sub idiot claims to the mix.

Was this for you?
Debunkers, with their minor success regarding paint chips, may have won a battle, but they have lost the war.
I was reading quickly; now that you "corrected" me, it is much worse than what I thought. Who posted and backs the paint chips are contaminated by lots of thermite in the SFRM? remo, or the p-guy?
 
...Was this for you?
Yeah, I guess ot was!
Ivan and I had a discussion with Poseidon on my own blog. He is a smart guy, have to give him that, he understood my arguments and the science behind them, had a few of valid points and some good ideas.

But then...

I was reading quickly; now that you "corrected" me, it is much worse than what I thought. Who posted and backs the paint chips are contaminated by lots of thermite in the SFRM? remo, or the p-guy?
... he came up with his own brand of lunacy :D Which is when the debate on my blog ended ;)

It's like him and me agreeing on reasons why Christianity is bunk, only to find that he believes in YHW/Allah after all and has invented his own radical islamic sect :boggled:
 
Last edited:
At 911Blogger, zica and Sitting-Bull have now expressed their disagreement with the moderation policies - thanks to both!

I submitted a reply to this comment by rm. Since the expectation is that mods will not approve of my posting, I repost it here:


Applies to all

(Note: This comment will also be posted at JREF inj the expectation that 911Blogger moderators will censor me again: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=140017&page=27 )


<blockquote>People sincerely committed to exposing the falsehoods of the 9/11 official story should ask themselves, when they encounter those encouraging such views within the movement--does this really sound like something that will help this effort?</blockquote>
Full agreement.

This reasoning applies vis-a-vis <i>every</i> claimant, claim and argument in the movement.

Particularly, people sincerely committed to exposing the falsehoods of the 9/11 official story should ask themselves if the claim by Harrit and Jones that the red-gray chips are "actrive thermitic material" (specifically: elemental Al and iron oxide in nano-sized particles) is true, or if it is false and a liability. They will find it is not true. It is FALSE - yet it is so widely believed by so many - here, at AE911Truth, and on so many boards.

This will come back to haunt you. The sooner you allow a reasoned, scientific debate, ask hard questions of ProfJones and his collaborators and demand truthful answers instead of evasions and new speculations, the better for your movement.


<b>ProfJones</b>, can you acknowledge that the various red-gray chips represent several <i>different</i> materials? You even implied as much in this very post when you speculated that Dr. Millette may have looked at a different material when he analyzed a red-gray chip with TEM.

<b>ProfJones</b>, can you acknowledge that there were at least two, possibly more, <i>different</i> primer paints applied to WTC steel, and that specifically there was the LaClede primer on the floor joists? These probably had a greater painted surface than the Tnemec-primed perimeter columns, and can thus be expected to be more plentiful in the dust.

<b>ProfJones</b>, can you at this time state clearly that your team has NO evidence that the platelets in chips a-d are anything but Kaolin, and that you could't identify elemental Al in them?

<b>ProfJones</b>, can you acknowledge that Dr. Farrer's finding of Strontium and Chromate may corroborate the hypothesis that these chips a-d are in fact LaClede primer on spalled, oxidized steel - a paint formulation whose XEDS spectrum would match those in Fig 7 almost perfectly and which contains traces of Sr-chromate?

<b>ProfJones</b>, can you acknowledge that you are inforned about the observation that the XEDS spectrum of Tnemec paint that you presented in Sydney is remarkably similar to that of the MEK-soaked chip, whle that chip's spectrum is very much different from that of chips a-d?

<b>ProfJones</b>, wouldn't agree that you should suspend any and all judgment on the validity and usefulness of DSC testing until your team figures out how (and why!) the experts at LLNL did it, and refrain from making any recommendations to other scientists?

In short, <b>ProfJones</b>, can you admit that your conclusions in the 2009 paper are facing serious challenges of fact and logic in 2012?

<b>ProfJones</b>, I think you should refrain from confusing the debate by dragging in red herrings and speculation like the multilayered chip (which is so obviously different from all the others) or an obscure patent for a material that has nothing in common with any of the chips. You should stop appealing to imagination, and instead acknowledge and apply facts and scientific reasoning.


AE911Truth has written in a newsletter to all their fans that "Millette comcluded the chips aren't paint". This was WRONG - Millette concluded the opposite: That every characteristic of the chips is consistent with paint; he merely has not YET identified the paint brand, and said that SOME chips aren't Tnemec.
AE911Truth should thus be URGED to retract this FALSE claim they made earlier and include a correction in their nexr newsletter.


And every reader of 911Blogger should be genuinly sceptic and critical! Do not assume that a person is wrong because he is actiive at JREF, or that another person is right because he has a PhD and believes what you believe!


This is the time now to see if 911Blogger is committed to open discourse and actual truth.​
 
Originally Posted by remo
But. Seriously, Zica..all... http://www.takeourworldback.com/millettepaintchips.htm as linked by Poseiden.......

That "article" is one big bundle of stupid. It's a typical conspiracist word salad that takes forever to make no substantive claims backed by anything other than speculation.

I've seen birthers who have a similar style. Idiots see stuff like that and say, "Boy, he sure uses a lot of words! He must know what he's talkin' about!"
 
Last edited:
Well, for one, and to comment only on the part that is on topic here, in the conclusions it says:

If some chips were thermitic and some were merely paint, then it would be highly unlikely that Harrit et al would end up with thermitic chips with elemental Al and keep getting Fe spheres after heating, whilst Millette consistently got Laclede paint.
​
It's not true that "Millete consistently got Laclede paint". He merely selected for study the chips that matched samples a-d, which were most likely Laclede paint or similar.

Interestingly, it goes on to say that

The best fit to the data is that all chips were paint chips (and some were different primers) but some elemental Al from the accelerant remained after the MEK soak.
​

And later, it fails again to understand the scope of Millette's work when stating that

The best explanation for Millette's conflicting results of no elemental aluminum or thermitic reactions is the fact that Millette washed his chips.
​
 
A couple of notes to zica at 911Blogger:

1. I read all new comments up until now

2. Thanks again for helping the debate by posting my texts!

3. I will attend a wedding today and won't have time for a substantive reply before tomorrow, so please be little patient.

4. Just one thing: Can you suggest another convenient name for people believing in alternative theories for 9/11 (this is putting it as politely as I can)? The word "truther" in my mind is neither applicable nor acceptable, as what these people believe is usually quite untrue, IMO.

5. I obviously cannot control how other JREF posters talk about you, and expect that you won't hold the conduct of others against me. But rest assured that I do on occasion report abuses here, or privately or publicly ask JREF members to please clean up their act. Ask beachnut for example, I wrote him such mails more than once, most recently just a few days ago (on another topic).

6. I believe part of the reason that you or ProfJones can post, but my posts don't appear, is that I am on a status where all my posts are automatically queued for manual moderator approval, while yours are automatically approved. Is that so - your posts are shown publicly immediately after you submitted them? If yes, then there could possibly be an issue of moderators being on vacation, soundly asleep, overwhelmed, uninterested or lazy, rather than a series of conscious decisions to censor me and approve, for example, of Poseidon's HD rant.

7. Cross-posting, or importing debates from other forums, is usually a no-no and may be against the Membership Agreement here - I'd have to check up on that. I hope JREF mods allow it in this case as it seems to currently be the best or only way to serve the JREF purpose in this particular case: To address and expose irrational believes and educate the public about why they are wrong. I'd much prefer if either you guys would sign up here, or 911Blogger would give me a more prefered status.

Have a nice day y'all.
 
Last edited:
Well, for one, and to comment only on the part that is on topic here, in the conclusions it says:

If some chips were thermitic and some were merely paint, then it would be highly unlikely that Harrit et al would end up with thermitic chips with elemental Al and keep getting Fe spheres after heating, whilst Millette consistently got Laclede paint.
​
It's not true that "Millete consistently got Laclede paint". He merely selected for study the chips that matched samples a-d, which were most likely Laclede paint or similar.

Interestingly, it goes on to say that

The best fit to the data is that all chips were paint chips (and some were different primers) but some elemental Al from the accelerant remained after the MEK soak.
​

And later, it fails again to understand the scope of Millette's work when stating that

The best explanation for Millette's conflicting results of no elemental aluminum or thermitic reactions is the fact that Millette washed his chips.
​

As I said, it's one giant bundle of stupid. We're never told what this "accelerant" is, but it apparently contains elemental aluminum, and it's water soluble.:eye-poppi:boggled:And the writer gives no evidence. It's pure cargo-cult science.
 
As I said, it's one giant bundle of stupid. We're never told what this "accelerant" is, but it apparently contains elemental aluminum, and it's water soluble.:eye-poppi:boggled:And the writer gives no evidence. It's pure cargo-cult science.

Poseidon's theory is "incendiaries made of elemental Al and some oxidizer other than iron oxide were part of the spray-on fire proofing they renewed after 1993".

But since that theory is off topic over there, I think it is off topic here. Let's not get distracted.
 
Out of interest, and since I have seen people raise doubts about this, has the existence and true definition (along with the explosive properties) of Nano-thermite ever been confirmed (especially existence in 2001)?

On a sidenote, as a Dane, I think the state of Denmark ought to make an official apology for Niels Harrit, and confirm that he in no way constitutes the Danish standard for practicing science...
 
Out of interest, and since I have seen people raise doubts about this, has the existence and true definition (along with the explosive properties) of Nano-thermite ever been confirmed (especially existence in 2001)?

On a sidenote, as a Dane, I think the state of Denmark ought to make an official apology for Niels Harrit, and confirm that he in no way constitutes the Danish standard for practicing science...
He is a conspiracy theorist, he makes up silly comments about 911 and helped Jones publish a failed paper with a crazy conclusions. Crazy happens.

It is funny, they found Al and Fe in their dust, two of the top four elements found in the earth's crust.

I would hate to have a contest who has the most nuts who make crazy claims.

The velocity of thermite reaction is not as fast as an explosive. You could argue it is not an explosive, but 911 truth nuts will show you one that kind of fizzles and bangs and say, "see". They leave out the numbers, and speed of reaction.
 
Wow, a lot of a new stuff here:cool:

S. Jones has just added a new reaction to Oystein's post in 911Blogger.

Jones wrote: "Wait – “basing this claim on the FALSE assumption that Tnemec was the only primer used.” What nonsense! I never made such an claim. Who made this claim anyway? I'm challenging you to back up your assertion."
Prof. Jones, read e.g. Harrit's white paper http://ae911truth.org/downloads/documents/primer_paint_Niels_Harrit.pdf. It is based on the assumption that only one red steel primer was used in WTC. And the same assumption has been used in all truthers documents, including "official" web AE911Truth etc.

As expected, Jones still uses the old "iron-rich microspheres formation" argument, nothing new in this respect.

But later on, Jones tries to confuse truthers on 911Blogger even more, now with the "lead argument".

Oystein wrote: "The multilayered chip contains "significant Pb" (page 28) - which none of the other chips do."
Jones replied: "Why do you keep saying there is no lead when there was lead? Now, it is true that the SEM-XEDS did not disclose lead as did the TEM data; this I think is partly because the TEM data were acquired at higher electron-beam energies. The lead (Pb) is there in our samples."

And what exactly is written in Bentham paper? "We have observed that some chips have additional elements such as potassium, lead, barium and copper. Are these significant, and why do such elements appear in some red chips and not others? An example is shown in Fig. (31) which shows significant Pb along with C, O, Fe, and Al and displays multiple red and gray layers."

So, there was perhaps some lead in some chips, but we have no direct proof (as Oystein noted). Why you did not present at least some table with XEDS composition of your "lead chips", Prof. Jones? Anyway, very apparently, those chips can be just paints with some lead compounds, frequently used in primers. But why they should be thermites, Prof. Jones?

Jones also came with the "mystery" of multilayered chip on Fig. 31: "So again, how do you “account for the multiple-layered chips which we reported finding in the WTC dust? Millette does not mention them."

Prof. Jones
, my explanation is like this: Millette did not find such multilayered chips since they are rare in the dust. You showed only one or two chips of this sort (Fig. 31, 32), you did not present XEDS analyses of their red layers and we have again no reason to think that they are anything else than paints (or perhaps some deffects in paint layers):rolleyes:

Jones also wrote: "Look, Oystein, why don't you put a sample of Tnemec primer in MEK and soak it, and see whether it becomes limp (as I say) or remains very hard under forceps? Do debunkers ever do experiments? I say, do the experiment and let us know what you find! "

Does it mean that the swelling of MEK chip was compared with the authentic sample of Tnemec primer in Bentham paper? Tell us, Prof. Jones! Up to now, we have had no idea what kind of paint you used in your "swelling tests";)
(Btw, such test could be quite easy to accomplish, several chips of Tnemec from some WTC monument, bottle of MEK solvent and ordinary microscope would suffice...
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
He is a conspiracy theorist, he makes up silly comments about 911 and helped Jones publish a failed paper with a crazy conclusions. Crazy happens.

It is funny, they found Al and Fe in their dust, two of the top four elements found in the earth's crust.

I would hate to have a contest who has the most nuts who make crazy claims.

The velocity of thermite reaction is not as fast as an explosive. You could argue it is not an explosive, but 911 truth nuts will show you one that kind of fizzles and bangs and say, "see". They leave out the numbers, and speed of reaction.

As a chemist, he should at least have had some idea of what he was doing, which he clearly had not. But of course, crazy people exist everywhere :)

BTW the Danish prime minister at the time was allegedly in on it :) He was told that the tower (not sure which) was close to collapse, and then he had a confirmation that it had actually happened. Striking evidence! That would make the "job" both inside and outside :D
 
... some more quotes from S. Jones' response to Oystein post on 911Blogger:

"First, Does payment motivate your efforts to defend the “official story” of 9/11? Note: I receive zero payments for my research on 9/11, and lost my university position seeking the truth about 9/11."
This quote is perhaps interesting in several aspects. First, Prof. Jones expectably suspects that Oystein is a payed government shill. Not really Truth, I would say, since as I know, Oystein has only payed some his money, for Jim Millette's falsification of Bentham paper, seeking the truth about 9/11 (together with me and other people including truthers here).

In this respect, it is interesting that Jones basically ignores preliminary results of this Millette's study, for which we payed. He only asks why Oystein is not willing to find another "suspicious" multilayered chips and do other experiments, like chips swelling in MEK etc. Prof. Jones, you seem to completely forget that we have necessary experimental results from the real scientific falsification of Bentham paper which was accomplished (thanks to Chris Mohr), and although the conclusions are preliminary, results clearly show some "epoxy resin coating with primarily iron oxide and kaolin clay pigments". A perfect match for "Laclede primer, btw, but anyway and for sure some red paint (e.g. because of prevailing organic polymeric material, etc).
Prof. Jones, we have some/many new experimental results as for red-gray chips from WTC dust. Where are yours?
 
Last edited:
Today was perhaps the last summer sunday of the year, so I was outside and enjoyed the sun and played a little game of bare-footed football (the English sport that is actually played with your feet and with an actual ball) with some friends, until I stepped on a wasp and was stung. Result: I am not in the mood to research and reply at length tonight.

Just four quick remarks.

1. ProfJones writes "Does payment motivate your efforts to defend the “official story” of 9/11?"

Answer: No.

I trust that anyone who thinks about that question for even 10 seconds will realize that it is not the kind of question that actually expects to retrieve information, but rather a passive-aggressive, insinuating, suggestive statement. ProfJones, please retract that question, even though I already answered it. It is insulting. As you perhaps know, insults inform us about the character of the insulter, not the insulted.

Besides, whether my arguments are valid or not depends in no way, shape or form on whether I am payed for anything by anyone. Please address the argument, not the arguer.


2. ProfJones writes: "this anonymous Oystein fellow ... why does he hide behind anonymity? ... will you identify yourself in the interest of transparency and truth?"

First, I am not entirely anonymous. Coincidentally, your (ProfJones's) appreciated[1] supporter Sitting-Bull wrote in his blog just yesterday: "Mein Fazit: Wenigstens traut sich „Oystein“ aus der Anonymität heraus, gibt seiner Gegenrede einen Namen und ein Gesicht, ich bin überzeugt, er meint es ernsthaft und aufrichtig, auch wenn ich vieles von dem, was er schlussfolgert, in keinster Weise nachvollziehen kann und ihn bestenfalls als „verrannt“ bezeichnen würde (was er sicherlich im Gegenzug auch von mir denken wird)" (my emphasise). Partial Translation: "My conclusion: At least Oystein dares to step out of anonymity, gives his opposing speech a a name and a face...". Sitting-bull repeated this at 911Blogger: "Oystein is not anonymous, at least I met him and know his name. You can see a picture of him and me in my latest blog entry".

Now to answer you: No, I will not disclose my real name publicly. The reason is rather mundane: While you are already retired and enjoy retirement benefits you can't lose, I am self-employed and still have at least 20 years of career ahead of me. My name is very rare - I don't want potential future business partners, who may google my name, give the impression that this hobby of debunking the false science of 9/11 CTs is what I am all about. However, on the condition that my name remains off the public record, I'd have no problems talking to you directly and using my real name and standard email address. Just one other condition, to build a measure of minimum trust: Take back the question whether I get payed or not.
I just don't know at this time how to contact you privately.

Besides, whether my arguments are valid or not, whether my claims are true or not, depends in no way, shape or form on my name, face, education or your knowldege of these. Please address the arguments, not the arguer!


3. You are arguing with unpublished experimental data with which you don't seem to be really familiar. It is nonsense to expect me to respond to your statements about Pb in the TEM data, if I don't have the TEM data. Please see to it that it gets published ASAP. Have you asked Dr. Farrer (or any other collaborator that may have unpublished data) to commit to a due date to publish it all? If not, please do so now! We are waiting for the FTIR, TEM and XRD data!


4. ProfJones writes "I say, do the experiment and let us know what you find!"

Unnecessary. I fully accept the data of the experiments already done, by your team, by Marc Basile, by Dr. Millette. Each set of data taken alone suffices to come to the conclusion that the chips are likely various paints and probably none are thermitic. Taken all data that's already on the table together, that conclusion is inevitable. There remains no trace of prima facie evidence that there is thermite in these chips. I trust that when you and your collaborators have published all your data, including the FTIR, TEM and XRD results, that conclusion will become clear to many who so far believed you: You have not found any significant elemental Al. With that finding, thermite is off the table. No further experiment is necessary.



[1] ProfJones wrote on 09/08/2012: "I appreciate people like you, sittingbull and others, who have the time and stomach to deal with the debunkers." (my emphasise)
 
Last edited:
I'm ready to admit that there are different kind of chips in the dust because i found only one red-grey chip in all my 4 samples (of different origins) exactly fitting the description by S Jones publication , but unfortunately lost it for further investigations (appart from microscopic inspection and spectroscopy).
All the other chips i had was red on both faces and did not produce molten iron when heated even at much more than 400°C.
Instead their carbon content seemed to have burned (carbon disappeared after heating) .

The red material in all those chips have the same chemical spectra as in Jones paper.

So the intriguiing question for me was : how can it be that in this dust there are so many (easy to catch with a magnet) chips with exactly the same spectra and yet of completely different kinds:

- some produce molten iron when heated according Jones and collaborators and i can hardly imagine that carbon burning would be enough to melt the iron content of the chips

-some others do not and actually involve kaolinite according millette and others

for me there is no other possible answer but: either there are liers in this debate (i dont know who are the liers) or (and) some of the samples were manipulated: either some fresh nanothermite particles were added to some samples before being sent to the independent investigators (so no nanothermite originally in WTC dust) or some other samples were heated before being sent to investigators to prevent them discover unreacted nanothermite particles which were indeed in the wtc dust.

This is why i have given up this investigation a long time ago because eventually you need to rely on other people (dust suppliers, possible intermediaries, other investigators).
I think this nanothermite debate is just a waste of time and it was triggered on this purpose.

I have another problem with the nanothermite hypothesis which i 'm surprised nobody else have talked about here: how could there remain unreacted aluminium nanoparticles in the dust several years after given the extremely fast aging (oxydation) of Al nanoparticles in air.

So i came back to the towers kinematic analysis because then you just need
one perfectly reliable material: the CNN video.

F H-C
 
I'm ready to admit that there are different kind of chips in the dust because i found only one red-grey chip in all my 4 samples (of different origins) exactly fitting the description by S Jones publication ,
...
The red material in all those chips have the same chemical spectra as in Jones paper.
I don't understand these two statements.
The spectra in Harrit e.al. aren't all the same - Fig 14 differs so markedly from Fig 7, you can'd hand-wave that. Also, Harrit e.al. point out in the text how they found other chips with different spectra: Some contain lead, others don't. Some contain copper, others don't. Some contain barium, others don't. In the spectra of post-DSC residue, one contained significant titanium, others didn't.

So already in Harrit e.al. it is obvious that there are several kinds of chips with, obviously, different EDS spectra.

What does it mean then when you say "chips have the same spectrum as in the S Jones publication"? I think you are specifically referring to Fig 6 and 7, o.e. chips a-d?

So the intriguiing question for me was : how can it be that in this dust there are so many (easy to catch with a magnet) chips with exactly the same spectra and yet of completely different kinds:

- some produce molten iron when heated according Jones and collaborators and i can hardly imagine that carbon burning would be enough to melt the iron content of the chips

-some others do not and actually involve kaolinite according millette and others

for me there is no other possible answer but: either there are liars in this debate (i dont know who are the liars) or (and) some of the samples were manipulated: either some fresh nanothermite particles were added to some samples before being sent to the independent investigators (so no nanothermite originally in WTC dust) or some other samples were heated before being sent to investigators to prevent them discover unreacted nanothermite particles which were indeed in the wtc dust.
...

The option "some fresh nanothermite particles were added to some samples before being sent to the independent investigators" can be ruled out as nothing in the Harrit e.al. paper, and nothing in any other work (i.e. Mark Basile's) describes nanoparticles of elemental Al. There simply is no unreacted nanothermite.

The Harrit e.al. paper is titled "Active Thermitic Material found...", implying, in context, that they found significant amounts of elemental Al in the relevant chips. They did not. There also is no indication that a thermite reaction has taken place, for example no proof of both reaction products, includung Al oxide.

All that Jones and his collaborators are left with is some microspheres of varying compositions. As far as I can see, they have done no competent qualitative and quantitative analysis of these spheres; and their explanation for when and how these were created is highly dubious.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom