I don't understand these two statements.
The spectra in Harrit e.al. aren't all the same - Fig 14 differs so markedly from Fig 7, you can'd hand-wave that. Also, Harrit e.al. point out in the text how they found other chips with different spectra: Some contain lead, others don't. Some contain copper, others don't. Some contain barium, others don't. In the spectra of post-DSC residue, one contained significant titanium, others didn't.
So already in Harrit e.al. it is obvious that there are several kinds of chips with, obviously, different EDS spectra.
What does it mean then when you say "chips have the same spectrum as in the S Jones publication"? I think you are specifically referring to Fig 6 and 7, o.e. chips a-d?
For the elements found in very small fractions, you can never exclude a contamination so i'm only refering to the the main signature : and it is already important to notice that this signature alone is almost the same for the red material of all chips including mine and surprising if these chips (abundant in the dust according Jones) are of very different origins.
The option "some fresh nanothermite particles were added to some samples before being sent to the independent investigators" can be ruled out as nothing in the Harrit e.al. paper, and nothing in any other work (i.e. Mark Basile's) describes nanoparticles of elemental Al. There simply is no unreacted nanothermite.
the reaction producing molten iron alone is the proof that there was a thermitic reaction even if all the rest of the investigation were complete nonsense and this is why i'm still wondering why they didnt only publish a two pages paper with the photo of a few chips before and after heating.
This would have avoided the endless debate.
if all the rest of the investigation rules out elemental Al as you say, may be it's because this part of the investigation was carried out on the kaolinite chips, not the ones that reacted in a thermitic way.
There also is no indication that a thermite reaction has taken place, for example no proof of both reaction products, includung Al oxide.
There is of course evidence of thermitic reaction because seeing a big iron rich sphere after reaction which was not there before as they show on their photos is definitely conclusive. Most of the Al2O3 escapes in a thermitic reaction.
All that Jones and his collaborators are left with is some microspheres of varying compositions. As far as I can see, they have done no competent qualitative and quantitative analysis of these spheres; and their explanation for when and how these were created is highly dubious.
these sphere are mostly iron spheres and their presence is the perfect smoking gun. There is absolutely no way how burning carbon could have melt this iron: this is possible in a furnace where heat can accumulate up to the temperatures above melting point of iron, but for a reacting microscopic particle heat cannot accumulate so its only the reaction involving the iron as a final product that could produce these microspheres.
Notice also that the microspheres in the photos are much to big to imagine that these were already there before the reaction, somehow hidden in the chip.