Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

I don't understand these two statements.
The spectra in Harrit e.al. aren't all the same - Fig 14 differs so markedly from Fig 7, you can'd hand-wave that. Also, Harrit e.al. point out in the text how they found other chips with different spectra: Some contain lead, others don't. Some contain copper, others don't. Some contain barium, others don't. In the spectra of post-DSC residue, one contained significant titanium, others didn't.

So already in Harrit e.al. it is obvious that there are several kinds of chips with, obviously, different EDS spectra.

What does it mean then when you say "chips have the same spectrum as in the S Jones publication"? I think you are specifically referring to Fig 6 and 7, o.e. chips a-d?

For the elements found in very small fractions, you can never exclude a contamination so i'm only refering to the the main signature : and it is already important to notice that this signature alone is almost the same for the red material of all chips including mine and surprising if these chips (abundant in the dust according Jones) are of very different origins.

The option "some fresh nanothermite particles were added to some samples before being sent to the independent investigators" can be ruled out as nothing in the Harrit e.al. paper, and nothing in any other work (i.e. Mark Basile's) describes nanoparticles of elemental Al. There simply is no unreacted nanothermite.

the reaction producing molten iron alone is the proof that there was a thermitic reaction even if all the rest of the investigation were complete nonsense and this is why i'm still wondering why they didnt only publish a two pages paper with the photo of a few chips before and after heating.
This would have avoided the endless debate.

if all the rest of the investigation rules out elemental Al as you say, may be it's because this part of the investigation was carried out on the kaolinite chips, not the ones that reacted in a thermitic way.

There also is no indication that a thermite reaction has taken place, for example no proof of both reaction products, includung Al oxide.

There is of course evidence of thermitic reaction because seeing a big iron rich sphere after reaction which was not there before as they show on their photos is definitely conclusive. Most of the Al2O3 escapes in a thermitic reaction.

All that Jones and his collaborators are left with is some microspheres of varying compositions. As far as I can see, they have done no competent qualitative and quantitative analysis of these spheres; and their explanation for when and how these were created is highly dubious.

these sphere are mostly iron spheres and their presence is the perfect smoking gun. There is absolutely no way how burning carbon could have melt this iron: this is possible in a furnace where heat can accumulate up to the temperatures above melting point of iron, but for a reacting microscopic particle heat cannot accumulate so its only the reaction involving the iron as a final product that could produce these microspheres.
Notice also that the microspheres in the photos are much to big to imagine that these were already there before the reaction, somehow hidden in the chip.
 
You seem to be a little bit paranoid, Henryco:cool: why to think about "smuggling" of some samples of "nanothermite" anywhere, when all chips simply look and behave like paints? No red/gray chips behave like nanothermites, since e.g. in the documented ash (Bentham paper), unreacted red iron oxide is still massively present and iron-oxide based microspheres are comparatively rare. Also your chips behave like paints (e.g. carbon polymer binder is burned out and inorganic pigments remain basically unchanged). Question is why the most of your chips was "simply red".

We expect (Sunstealer's idea) that iron-rich microspheres shown by Harrit et al are created from the attached iron oxide-based gray layers or their fragments. Then, no wonder that iron rich microspheres were not formed in your purely red chips.

The matter of oxidation of aluminium nanoparticles (rounded in reality, not in the form of platelets found by Harrit and Millette) has been discussed thoroughly here in JERF. Here is a general agreement that aluminium nanoparticles must be oxidized to the considerable extent, since the instantly formed aluminium oxide layer is usually some 4-7 nm "thick":cool: (this is btw one of the reasons why any practical thermitic nanoaluminium should not be produced in the form of e.g. ultrathin platelets and other forms with too high surface/volume ratio, which means high oxidation)
 
Last edited:
You seem to be a little bit paranoid, Henryco:cool: why to think about "smuggling" of some samples of "nanothermite" anywhere, when all chips simply look and behave like paints? No red/gray chips behave like nanothermites. Also your chips behave like paints (e.g. carbon polymer binder is burned out and inorganic pigments remain basically unchanged). Question is why the most of your chips was "simply red".

We expect (Sunstealer's idea) that iron-rich microspheres shown by Harrit et al are created from the attached iron oxide-based gray layers or their fragments. Then, no wonder that iron rich microspheres were not formed in your purely red chips.

There was no genuine gray layer on my chips except one but there was gray deposits which appeared to be already made of many small spheres, as if the chips had already reacted before.
http://www.darksideofgravity.com/redreds.pdf
When i heated those chips , one of them even released a small sphere, which would seem to confort Sunstealer idea except that,

- This is very different from what i can see on jones photos.

- if i had obtained their photos (huge appearing microspheres , i mean not much smaller than the chip they originated from) i would have concluded as they did because i'm afraid there is no way how their such big microspheres could have been hidden in the gray layer , which in Jones photos never include spheres at all (at the contratry to my gray deposits)
 
For the elements found in very small fractions, you can never exclude a contamination so i'm only refering to the the main signature : and it is already important to notice that this signature alone is almost the same for the red material of all chips including mine and surprising if these chips (abundant in the dust according Jones) are of very different origins.
You are hand-waving, Henryco.

Calcium in Fig 14 is not a very small fraction, it is THE dominating metal. It cannot be all contamination, for there is much too much Ca, relative to sulfur, in that spectrum to explain it away as gypsum surface contamination. If Harrit e.al. think it's contamination, it does not suffice if they suspect that, they'd have to show it! They put a SEM on that chip before bathing it needlessly in MEK; SEM would have been a wonderful tool to literally show surface contamination - yet Harrit e.al. have nothing to show.
So you handwave that spectrum and that chip.

About the multilayered chip in Fig. 31, they write (I quote from page 28) "An example is shown in Fig. (31) which shows significant Pb along with C, O, Fe, and Al and displays multiple red and gray layers."
It's "significant Pb", Henryco, not a "very small fraction"! The other spectra do not contain significant Pb (it would easily show its M-alpha level at 2.35 keV if there was at least 0.5% by weight in the material)
So you handwave that chip.

I have just quantitatively analysed Fig 25. of a post-DSC residue, Its Ti K-alpha peak, being 1/3 that of the lighter Al, would indicate that this chip originally contained ca. 40% as much Ti as Al. (Rough estimate of the composition of that particular material: Fe 41%, C 20%, O 20%, Si 8%, Al 5%, Ca 4%, Ti 3%; I ignored S). If you want to hand-wave 3% Ti, but at the same time maintain your claim that we are looking at the result of what was essentially and significantly the oxidation of Al, with Al making up only 5% of the total mass - well, feel free, but I am calling you on arbitrary hand-waving to fit your prejudice.
So you hand-wave that chip and its residue.

the reaction producing molten iron alone is the proof that there was a thermitic reaction even if all the rest of the investigation were complete nonsense and this is why i'm still wondering why they didnt only publish a two pages paper with the photo of a few chips before and after heating.
...
Because you are dead wrong about this.

Thermite is not the only reaction that produces iron-rich spheres. A multitude of reactions does. Iron-rich spheres, as well as silicate-rich spheres, are abundant in many types of ashes from mixed fuels, such as houshold waste or wood.

Iron-rich spheres can't surpise, especially if you start out with a specimen that already consists mostly of an iron-rich substance - the gray layer.

If you want to do a before and after, photos are not the main thing to do. What you'd really want to do is:
Before: Show your speciment contains substantial amounts of both elemental Al and iron oxide (more than 5% by weight elemental Al, more than 15% by weight of iron oxide; actually, you'd want both to make up 80% or more of the total material, but I feel generous). You, Jones e.al. and Basile have all failed to show this. In fact, Basile has shown that the red layer of his favorite chip contains less than 2% Al (but not if and how that is bound) and less than 3% iron; his numbers prove that less than 5% of the weight of the red layer could hypothetically be thermite. This should immediately strike you as all the proof that you need to know that this is not thermitic material at all.
After: Show your residue now contains substantial amounts of alumunium oxide. Neither Harrot e.al. nor Basile have even attempted that!

So you see: Everyone so far has totally failed to demonstrate that thermite was present before, and thermite reside present after.


Besides: All the post-DSC photos (Fig. 20 etc.) show the red layer still red after the reaction, so the iron oxide pigments have not been reduced! No thermite reaction happened with them! It is obvious, Henryco!
 
There was no genuine gray layer on my chips except one but there was gray deposits which appeared to be already made of many small spheres, as if the chips had already reacted before.
http://www.darksideofgravity.com/redreds.pdf
Or perhaps as if such micro-spheres are really just a common and expected occurrence in such dust?

When i heated those chips , one of them even released a small sphere, which would seem to confort Sunstealer idea except that,

- This is very different from what i can see on jones photos.

- if i had obtained their photos (huge appearing microspheres , i mean not much smaller than the chip they originated from) i would have concluded as they did because i'm afraid there is no way how their such big microspheres could have been hidden in the gray layer , which in Jones photos never include spheres at all (at the contratry to my gray deposits)

But the red layers of all the chips - Jones's, Basile's, yours - contains waaaaaaaaaaaay too little aluminium to account for the large relative volume of molten iron residue that you imply. They even contain too little iron!
The conclusion is almost inevitable that the iron-rich sphere resulted from heating the gray to 700°C (or even more) while in the presence of a burning layer of organic polymer.
 
MIX

Kminek. Oystein. Is it true that neither of you have either seen touched nor physically experimented upon ANY samples of WTC dust as reported on Blogger.? That your arguments rest upon data presented in the literature.
Is that true.
 
Kminek. Oystein. Is it true that neither of you have either seen touched nor physically experimented upon ANY samples of WTC dust as reported on Blogger.? That your arguments rest upon data presented in the literature.
Is that true.

By golly! You nailed that one on the head, remo :)
(Have you, btw?)
We trust that the experimental data published by Drs. Harrit, Jones and Farrer as well as that sort-of published by Mark Basile is the best and most significant data out there and reliable (before the Millette study, of course).

It so turns out that these data sets are already sufficient to resoundingly reject the main conclusions these researchers have drawn. No further experiments necessary.

However, I was involved in commissioning the follow-up study by Dr. Millette: I gave a number of recommendations and helped finance it.

Dr. Millette is a million times better in this sort of experimental analysis than I could ever be.
That's why we hired him.

He is also much much better and experienced than Jones, Harrit, Farrer, Basile in that particular field of research, namely forensically identifying materials in left-overs of chaotic events.
That's why we have advised Jones, Harrit, Farrer, Basile to also go to an experienced forensic lab.




P.S.: Tell me, remo, were you trying for a cheap score? ;)
 
Last edited:
Kminek. Oystein. Is it true that neither of you have either seen touched nor physically experimented upon ANY samples of WTC dust as reported on Blogger.? That your arguments rest upon data presented in the literature.
Is that true.
Have you?

No thermite product was found fused to WTC steel.
Is that true? Yes
Jones was fired for spreading nonsense at BYU?
Is that true? Yes, he took early retirement.
Jones had to publish this paper in a vanity journal, it has a bogus conclusion.
Is that true? Yes
Jones had to start a silly on-line journal because his school and other journals would not publish the nonsense he had?
Is that true? Yes

Jones endorsed the thermite in the ceiling tiles made up by Hoffman. Do you agree with that? How does the fantasy of dust chips work with the ceiling tiles?

The thermite you talked about has to made in a lab. How did they sputter the thermite on to WTC components? Why was no iron from thermite found on WTC? What is the other evidence for thermite?

In Jones fantastic paper, the thermite was placed in the WTC; but; Why would anyone plant thermite in buildings when the fires systems were disabled by the aircraft impact, and the office fires gave off the heat energy of 2,600 TONS of thermite prior to collapse? With no fire systems working, the building would be totaled.

With thermite all over the WTC, as Jones seems to imply, why did lower floors not ignite on 911, before or after collapse?

Why did someone who planted thermite in the WTC need aircraft and 19 terrorists?

Jones is too nice to imagine 5 terrorists rushing the cockpit and killing the pilots by quickly and without warning running a knife along their throats, an instant solution to pilots who would stop them as soon as they were asked to leave the cockpit. Jones hates war and is paranoid about his government, he does not care what he makes up to discredit his unknown bad guys. He made up thermite was used to destroy the WTC complex, and ignores the real terrorists. He is aiding the terrorists, sowing the seeds of doubt. The good part, only a fringe few fall for the thermite nonsense.

Why does Jones and company have to make up fantasy to cover for 19 terrorists. Why make up lies about thermite? What is the goal, who benefits? 11 years no progress.
 
Nanoengineered explosives

Thank you.
It is important for me to understand the paradigm. Who is doing the talking. The experienced hands-on Professor/ technician/ laboratory worker physically originating the data, or those contending by computer analysis their presented works ...
Edited by LashL: 
Edited for civility.
when they think they have found something.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thank you.
It is important for me to understand the paradigm. Who is doing the talking. The experienced hands-on Professor/ technician/ laboratory worker physically originating the data, or those contending by computer analysis their presented works ...
Edited by LashL: 
Edited for civility.
when they think they have found something.
Their work can be backed up by an scientist. Can Jones and company's? ;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Nano-engineered explosives - from WTC dust - A fantasy

Thank you.
It is important for me to understand the paradigm. Who is doing the talking. The experienced hands-on Professor/ technician/ laboratory worker physically originating the data, or those contending by computer analysis their presented works ...
Edited by LashL: 
Edited for civility.
when they think they have found something.
I am a lowly Engineer with a masters, and a pilot who flew heavy jets. The paper is bogus - I can't find any one in my graduating classed or the labs I worked with who agree with Jones. Who have you asked, who is not a nut in 911 truth, with an engineering degree or a chemist, that agree with Jones? No one.

Nothing to debunk, it failed to be published in a real journal. They paid to have it published, other journals refused.

Jone is doing the crowing, he found Al and Fe in his dust, two of the top four elements in the earth's crust. A layperson understands the conclusion is nonsense.

If someone doubts the paper conclusion is nonsense, they can take the paper to an expert and find out. How many independent engineers and scientist agree with Jones? Less than 0.01 percent. Shall we now vote on science? Why did Jones make up the claim about thermite doing the WTC in? Political bias, anti-war?

Who have you asked? Why can't Jones support his own claim on 60 Minutes? 20/20, ABC, CBS, NBC? Why can't the paper go to a real journal on chemistry?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You mean like Millette? ;)

Yes, but something that actually gets published somewhere, and makes some effort to positively ID the red-grey chips and confirm or disprove that iron microspheres are produced when they are ignited. Who is going to do that work?
 
Yes, but something that actually gets published somewhere, and makes some effort to positively ID the red-grey chips and confirm or disprove that iron microspheres are produced when they are ignited. Who is going to do that work?
Who cares? If memory serves Millette is doing some similar work. There really is no hurry. Jones ideas haven't caught any serious attention.

One things for certain. There was no "thermite" in Jones chips. (unless you claim his data's wrong).
 
Yes, but something that actually gets published somewhere, and makes some effort to positively ID the red-grey chips and confirm or disprove that iron microspheres are produced when they are ignited. Who is going to do that work?

I do wonder why you care if something is published somewhere when its not written by a truther. How many peer reviewed articles have truthers published on 911 again?
 
Kminek. Oystein. Is it true that neither of you have either seen touched nor physically experimented upon ANY samples of WTC dust as reported on Blogger.? That your arguments rest upon data presented in the literature.
Is that true.

Remo: I noticed your pots on 911Blogger: ".......generated the peaks via computer program!!?!? no laboratory testing.?!? ... WHERE have I heard this b4 !? kmimek too shadow boxing. I am conned all over again."

It follows from these comments:

1) You have no idea what is a content of the threads "Origin of the paint" and "Millette study" here, which is rather strange, after all these months you have spent here. You should therefore acknowledge that up to this March, we had collected indirect arguments/clues that chips (a) to (d) (Bentham paper) are Laclede primer paint; but starting this March, we have (thanks to Chris Mohr and Jim Millette) many experimental proofs that we were right (chips are paints, probably mostly Laclede paint - or perhaps some very similar paint sometimes):rolleyes:

2) You have no idea that computer simulation of spectra (not only in XEDS, but also in NMR, IR and other spectroscopy) and their comparison with the real spectra are important/integral/routine part of chemical analyses novadays. E.g., I am using simulated NMR spectra with the real ones on daily basis. And if the real and simulated XEDS spectra are so strikingly similar like in the case of chips (a) to (d) and Laclede paint, they of course prove an identity of the measured stuff, believe or not:cool:

(Btw, I have registered on 911Blogger yesterday, but I think that it does not make to try to contribute there. S. Jones decides not to answer many important Oystein's questions/objections and instead, he uses purely evasive tactic, e.g. "inventing" some new "suspicious" chips like this one on Fig, 31):D
 
Last edited:
There was no genuine gray layer on my chips except one but there was gray deposits which appeared to be already made of many small spheres, as if the chips had already reacted before.
http://www.darksideofgravity.com/redreds.pdf
When i heated those chips , one of them even released a small sphere, which would seem to confort Sunstealer idea except that,

- This is very different from what i can see on jones photos.

- if i had obtained their photos (huge appearing microspheres , i mean not much smaller than the chip they originated from) i would have concluded as they did because i'm afraid there is no way how their such big microspheres could have been hidden in the gray layer , which in Jones photos never include spheres at all (at the contratry to my gray deposits)

Thanks for the link, Henryco. Looking at your photos, I wouldn't say that your chips are mostly purely red. They frequently contain fragments of gray layers and you even wrote: "The chips commonly present shiny gray areas even before heating!" or "Many shiny gray metallic spots at the surface or inclusions (?) in the red material". So why should I think that they are something completely different that Harrit's chips? They still look like paint chips with some remnants of attached gray rust:cool:
 
Jones' paper failed to make it to a real journal; 911 truth can't answer why

Well, wingnut, In all your flying about, did you ever see a complex 47 storied steel framed high rise EVER disintegrate at the speed of no resistant FREE FALL straight down into itself due to 'normal office furnishings fires'?
Wingnut? You can't get any real engineers to verify Jones folly, so you have to spread general woo.

What is that speed of free fall, please, a number. lol

Free fall straight down, is not true, but this is the best 911 truth has.

A building burned with not fire fighting and it fell. I have never seen a building on fire with not water and nor fire fighting survive. I have seen many building with fires fought which were totaled by fire.

This thread is about thermite, the lie made up by Jones without evidence. In his paper there is not evidence of thermite. A false claim. This is why no journals have published Jones work, it is nonsense. Go ahead, take the work to an engineer who is not in 911 truth, the fake movement which spreads fantasy. How many have you taken the paper to, in person?

Free fall? lol, WTC 7 took over 16 seconds to collapse, not close to free fall. Why lie about it? I have seen two high rise building burn, fire fought, building totaled; ordinary office fires. Failure is 911 truth, and Jones' fantasy of thermite. Fooled by nuts on 911. What did 60 Minutes say about Jones? Have they stopped laughing?


There are 17oo Engineers and architects and other EXPERTS with masters and any other number of letters to their NAMES saying you are WRONG,. and maybe its time to LISTEN to THEM telling us WHY it was not possible for those buildings to do what they did without explosive sequences.
1700 who can't publish one paper that proves they are not nuts on 911. They signed up for what? Gage made a million dollars spreading lies, he has done nothing.
They did not say I was wrong, they signed up for woo, they are nuts.
1700 nuts who can't do physics, they have degrees, but they are not using science, they are spreading lies.

But go ahead, take their work to 60 Minutes and break the big story; 1700 nuts sign up for woo. It will be a funny show about failed engineers, people who fall for delusions and crazy claims of thermite. They have no clue who did it, or how, they "just" know. No evidence, a fake paper. Where is the Pulitzer Jones? Why did the newspapers fail to get a Pulitzer with this fantastic story? Too bad there is no evidence for thermite. No Pulitzer. 1700 nuts who can't read for comprehension to see the false conclusion. I like the low temperature burning imaginary thermite, called dust. Paper has more heat energy. lol

You never answered why the heat energy of ordinary office fires equal to over 2,600 TONS of thermite is not enough heat to destroy the WTC steels straight and cause collapse. How much of the thermite is needed in your fantasy, in Jones fantasy world of woo, and vanity journals.

JonesHarritDelusion.jpg

Oops, the chips, the dust does not match thermite.
JetFuelandWoodBeatThermite.jpg

Jet fuel beats thermite, so does wood. I bet butter does too, and sugar. What say you? How much thermite was used in the Jones fantasy?
Does the super-nano-thermite have more energy per kg than thermite?

1 engineer against 1700. And I won. No Pulitzer for 1700, and not a single article in a real journal. We in the neoNWO are in control, we can control the weather, chem-trails, earthquakes, and tailor thermite so it leaves no products behind. Jones found some Al and Fe in what looks like some clay and other not thermite stuff. Watergate broke and was Pulitzer Prize winning story in a year or two - 11 years, thermite and Jones remain paranoid conspiracy theory, and theorist.
 
Sitting Bull announced in 911Blogger that his fiction book Nanospuren (in German) is now freely available here.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom