Exactly.
- He did not say at what temperature the strip started out before current was switched on, but we can guess with high confidence that ot will be around normal room temperature.
- He did not say at what temperature it peaked, so you don't know the answer, but it very probably is somewhere between 430°C and very roughly 800 °C
- He did not say how long after heating started did took to reach peak temperature, but it seems to have been only a few seconds for a few hundreds of °C
- He did not say what average heating rate does this computes to, but it must be several 1,000 °C/min - compare this to Farrer's DSC test which was 10°/min.
- He did not say at what time the speciment started to react, so you can't know it - again, seconds after heating began
- He did not say what temperature did the strip had when the specimen started to react, because we know neither the time, nor the heating rate, nor do we have a direct measurement.
- He did not say what temperature the specimen had when the sepcimen started to react, but it must have been somewhat lower than the temperature of the strip, given the obvious fact that temperature is conveyed with some lag
- He did not say how long the reaction take took till completion - agaib a few seconds.
- He did not say what temperature the strip had at the end of the reaction - it could be several hundreds of °C higher than at the start given the heating rate, or just a few, if the peak temp wasn't much higher. You can't know.
- He did not say what temperature the specimen (or its residues) had at the end of the reaction - you just can't know.
Do you understand now that Basile's statement that he "could" heat the strip to any temperature he wanted and that ot would "typically" go to 430°C tells you nothing at all about the temperatures at which things in the video happened to Chip #13? This is because we KNOW as a certain fact that the strip and the specimen experienced an extreme temperature gradient during the experiment, and
Basile did not say anything about it!
But he did say that the red layer contained no more than 2.6% by weight irom
He did say that the droplets are about 50% by weight iron
He did say that there were several such droplets, around 50 µm across
And from this follows that there was much more iron in those droplets post reaction than there was in the red layer pre-reaction.
So you need to acknowledge that
Basile must be wrong if he thinks the iron-rich droplets formed from the red layer:
There is much too little iron in the red layer!
There is much too little aluminium in the red layer!
There is way too much hydrocarbons in the red layer!
All that Basile says proves convincingly that the red layer cannot possibly be thermitic, and that the reaction shown in the video is not powered by a thermitic reaction!
Now please compare said two large particles in the top left, and right of center in this image...
[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/MarcBasilePresentation/Basile_43_08_Chip13_MicroAfterBurning.jpg[/qimg]
...to what you see in this image...
[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/MarcBasilePresentation/Basile_39_00_Chip13_Photo.jpg[/qimg]
... with a view to describing shapes and colors! Do you recognize any similarities?