Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

This is the photo of post-reaction residuers of chip #13:

[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/MarcBasilePresentation/Basile_43_08_Chip13_MicroAfterBurning.jpg[/qimg]

Please describe in minute detail the large particle near the top left corner and the large particle to the right of center! Please make sure you describe the color, and the shape!
light pinkish...if it is iron oxide particles, then millette could heat his furnace to 450C to get rid of the organic matrix and see if those indeed are iron pigments. ;)

Then see this photo of Chip #13 pre-reaction:

[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/MarcBasilePresentation/Basile_39_00_Chip13_Photo.jpg[/qimg]

and telll us if you see anything that resembles the two large particles you just described in color and shape!


dark reddish. do you agree with sunstealer that the sample will be destroyed at 450C that would be in accordance to ASTM standards for doing a furnace ash test?
pertaining to the gray layer, the slide does say the inside of the chip. did he push aside the gray layer that didnt do anything (which he has stated before)? i couldnt say now could i.
 
Do you understand now that Basile's statement that he "could" heat the strip to any temperature he wanted and that ot would "typically" go to 430°C tells you nothing at all about the temperatures at which things in the video happened to Chip #13? This is because we KNOW as a certain fact that the strip and the specimen experienced an extreme temperature gradient during the experiment, and Basile did not say anything about it!
do you think that when millette put his in the furnace at 400C that they did not experience an extreme temp gradient?
 
light pinkish...if it is iron oxide particles, ...
Got any other idea what could give this this color, given Basile's data and words?

then millette could heat his furnace to 450C to get rid of the organic matrix and see if those indeed are iron pigments. ;)
He did exactly that. 400°C of course were sufficient. He used 400 °C in the muffler, got thusly rid of the organic matrix, then identified, using the competent methods FTIR and TEM-SAED, iron oxide and kaolin. Why didn't Basile use any such competent method to analyse the residue? Why did Harrit e.al. (Farrer, actually) use both FTIR and TEM, but never published the results?



dark reddish.
Do you have any idea why it might be reddish?

pertaining to the gray layer, the slide does say the inside of the chip. did he push aside the gray layer that didnt do anything (which he has stated before)? i couldnt say now could i.
Exactly. You couldn't say because Basile didn't say. I can say it for you: No, he did not. It is obvious. You see the remains of the red and the gray layer. The high amount of iron in the post-reaction droplets compared to the low amount of iron in the red layer pre-reaction is total and sufficient proof of that.


Basile's analysis, and his presentation thereof, is incompetent crap, very inexpertly done, a shameful piece of stupidity for someone allegedly experienced in material analysis. But it is good enough to prove conclusivele that this stuff is not thermitic at all.
 
do you think that when millette put his in the furnace at 400C that they did not experience an extreme temp gradient?

I am not talking about Millette. YOU introduced Basile as your witness, linked to Basile's video.

Please acknowledge that
  • Basile says the red layer has no more than 2.6% iron
  • Basile says the red layer has no more than 1.7% aluminium
  • Basile says the iron-rich droplets are around 50 µm in diameter
  • Basile says the iron-rich droplets have an iron content of ca. 50% by mass
  • Basile says there are several such iron-rich droplets in the post reaction residue
  • Basile's data and words don't allow you to state any temperature, or range of temperatures, at which the reaction shown in the video of chip #13 occurred

After all, all this is arguments from the source YOU linked to.

From all this follows conclusively that
  • >99% of the chemical energy of the chip must come from the organic matrix
  • <1% of the chemical energy of the chip can come from thermite, if any at all
  • The low max possible content of thermite is too little to have a serious effect on the organic matrix (cannot turn it to gas)
  • The chip is thus not thermitic by nature at all
  • There is much too little iron in the red layer to have formed the iron-rich droplets
  • The iron-rich droplets must thus have formed from the gray layer
  • All of the conclusions that Basile draws fromn the data he presents are FALSE
 
He did exactly that. 400°C of course were sufficient. He used 400 °C in the muffler, got thusly rid of the organic matrix, then identified, using the competent methods FTIR and TEM-SAED, iron oxide and kaolin. Why didn't Basile use any such competent method to analyse the residue? Why did Harrit e.al. (Farrer, actually) use both FTIR and TEM, but never published the results?

according to ASTM (which millette sites in his paper to have followed) he should have heated it up to 450C. scientists follow protocols because it can be replicated. you know i cant answer the farrer question.

you still didnt answer my question:
do you agree with sunstealer that the sample will be destroyed at 450C that would be in accordance to ASTM standards for doing a furnace ash test?
 
I am not talking about Millette. YOU introduced Basile as your witness, linked to Basile's video.
sunstealer stated that jones and millettes chips are one in the same. your claiming since basile heated his chips the way he did, the gray layer created what we see. well, millette put his chips into a furnace that was 400C. that would also heat the chips up very quickly since they are so small. you need to apply your logic to millettes gray layer as well if you think they are the same material.
 
according to ASTM (which millette sites in his paper to have followed) he should have heated it up to 450C. scientists follow protocols because it can be replicated. you know i cant answer the farrer question.
...

Which protocol did Basile follow?
Which protocol did Harrit follow?
Which protocol did Jones follow?
Which protocol did Farrer follow?
Which protocol did Ryan follow?
Which protocol did Farnsworth follow?
Which protocol did Legge follow?
Which protocol did Roberts follow?
Which protocol did Larson follow?

Can their experiments be replicated? (No)
Can Basile's experiment with chip #13 be replicated? (No)
Can Farrer's DSC experiment be replicated? (No)

Why is it wrong to do this ashing at 400°C rather than 450°C
Can Millette's experiment be replicated? (Yes, it can)

Don't you feel a little stupid you bring arguments like this?


Please acknowledge all the things Basile said!
Please recognize they prove what I said: No thermite reaction, iron droplets not from red layer!
If you don't agree, please explain why!
 
Which protocol did Basile follow?
Which protocol did Harrit follow?
Which protocol did Jones follow?
Which protocol did Farrer follow?
Which protocol did Ryan follow?
Which protocol did Farnsworth follow?
Which protocol did Legge follow?
Which protocol did Roberts follow?
Which protocol did Larson follow?
they did NOT state they were following any protocols. it would be cooler if they did:D whereas millette said "in accordance with the recommended guidelines for forensic identification of explosives and the ASTM standard guide for forensic paint analysis."

Can their experiments be replicated? (No)
basile did replicate what jones found.

Can Basile's experiment with chip #13 be replicated? (No)
sure. gotta have the same material.
Can Farrer's DSC experiment be replicated? (No)
sure, with the same types of chips.

Why is it wrong to do this ashing at 400°C rather than 450°C
Can Millette's experiment be replicated? (Yes, it can)
if other scientists did not want to follow astm standards concerning the furnace ash and heat up to 400C instead of 450C. not very scientific is that.

Don't you feel a little stupid you bring arguments like this?
not at all.


Please acknowledge all the things Basile said!
Please recognize they prove what I said: No thermite reaction, iron droplets not from red layer!
If you don't agree, please explain why!

iron droplets not from red layer? he stated the gray layer did not do anything at alittle over 400C. millette said his gray layer did not do anything at 400C
 
they did NOT state they were following any protocols. it would be cooler if they did:D whereas millette said "in accordance with the recommended guidelines for forensic identification of explosives and the ASTM standard guide for forensic paint analysis."
I am glad you agree that Millette, by following protocol, did a more cpmpetent study than all the others.
His well-reasoned choice to apply a slightly lower temperature shows his competence further.

basile did replicate what jones found.
He did not replicate the experiments:
Basile did no replication of XEDS tests on the gray layer
Basile did no replication of the electron microscopy
Basile did no replication of the DSC tests
Basile did no replication of the MEK test

Basile's conclusions match in general terms Jones's
But
Jones's conclusions do not follow from Jones's data
Basile's conclusions do not follow from Jones's data

sure. gotta have the same material.
WRONG.
We don't know the heating rate of the steel strip
We don't know the peak temperature of the steel strip
The chip pre-heating is insufficiently characterized to allow confidence in identification
The residues are insufficiently characterized to allow comparison

sure, with the same types of chips.
WRONG
Because Farrer forgot to characterize the chips he DSCed. They had at least 6 different types of red-gray chips.
We don't know which of the six or more kinds he used, so the experiment cannot be replicated.

if other scientists did not want to follow astm standards concerning the furnace ash and heat up to 400C instead of 450C. not very scientific is that.
What Millette did was scientific
What Harrit, Jones, Farrer, Ryan, Basile etc. did was incompetent garbage, but good enough to prove "no thermite"

not at all.
You should

iron droplets not from red layer? he stated the gray layer did not do anything at alittle over 400C. millette said his gray layer did not do anything at 400C
You could not answer the 10 questions.

It follows you don't know that the steel strip heating peaked at only 400°C

If you understood at all what Basile did and what we have been talkinbg about today, you'd understand that he very probably reached a much higher temoperature, but you can't know which.

Useless, incompetent expermient. Basile is clueless.
 
I am glad you agree that Millette, by following protocol, did a more cpmpetent study than all the others.
His well-reasoned choice to apply a slightly lower temperature shows his competence further.
competence or incompetence or did someone suggest to him to do it at a lower temp. what is his lab protocol for the themp on paint and furnace ash? how is he competent if ASTM standards state the temp for furnace ash to be 450C? it will still get rid of the organic material for him to test what is left over.

you still have not answered this:
do you agree with sunstealer that the sample will be destroyed at 450C which in the temp that would be in accordance to ASTM standards for doing a furnace ash test?
 
bump this question for oystein
sunstealer stated that jones and millettes chips are one in the same. your claiming since basile heated his chips the way he did, the gray layer created what we see. well, millette put his chips into a furnace that was 400C. that would also heat the chips up very quickly since they are so small. you need to apply your logic to millettes gray layer as well if you think they are the same material.
 
competence or incompetence or did someone suggest to him to do it at a lower temp.
His own intelligence and competence. He knew from Farrer's DSC tests that the chips might burn too vigorously at 450 °C, therefore he chose a lower temp.
Doing it at 450 °C would have been stupid given the work by Farrer he was going to check.

Senemut, you want people to do stupid experiments. We have had enough stupid experiments. Jones's experiments were stupid. Basile's experiments were stupid. Why do you want more stupid experiments?

what is his lab protocol for the themp on paint and furnace ash? how is he competent if ASTM standards state the temp for furnace ash to be 450C? it will still get rid of the organic material for him to test what is left over.
Did 400 °C also suffice?
What would be gained by doing at 450 °C? Please be very specific!

you still have not answered this:
do you agree with sunstealer that the sample will be destroyed at 450C which in the temp that would be in accordance to ASTM standards for doing a furnace ash test?
Irrelevant. Stupid question.
Millette made a good and competent call to do it at 450 °C.
The results confirm he did a competent test: The organic matrix was removed, and he was left with the very mineral pigments he wanted to analyse. A competent experiment well done.
 
bump this question for oystein
sunstealer stated that jones and millettes chips are one in the same. your claiming since basile heated his chips the way he did, the gray layer created what we see. well, millette put his chips into a furnace that was 400C. that would also heat the chips up very quickly since they are so small. you need to apply your logic to millettes gray layer as well if you think they are the same material.

No. What a stupid question.

You don't know how (how quickly, to what peak temperature) basile heated his chip.
Not comparable at all to what Millette did, because Basile did an incompetent test and documented it insufficiently.
 
His own intelligence and competence. He knew from Farrer's DSC tests that the chips might burn too vigorously at 450 °C, therefore he chose a lower temp.
Doing it at 450 °C would have been stupid given the work by Farrer he was going to check.
burn to vigoroulsy at 450C to do what exactly? that is why they heat the paint to get rid of the organic material.

Senemut, you want people to do stupid experiments. We have had enough stupid experiments. Jones's experiments were stupid. Basile's experiments were stupid. Why do you want more stupid experiments?
oh coarse only you and the debunkers are not stupid. i want to do more experiments to get to the bottom of this issue.


Did 400 °C also suffice?
What would be gained by doing at 450 °C? Please be very specific!
to follow ASTM standards so scientists around the world can expect to find the same thing if it is the same material.


I
rrelevant. Stupid question.
Millette made a good and competent call to do it at 450 °C.
The results confirm he did a competent test: The organic matrix was removed, and he was left with the very mineral pigments he wanted to analyse. A competent experiment well done.
you mean he did it at 400C when the ASTM states it should have been done at 450C.
 
No. What a stupid question.

You don't know how (how quickly, to what peak temperature) basile heated his chip.
Not comparable at all to what Millette did, because Basile did an incompetent test and documented it insufficiently.

its not a stupid question...no more stupid than yours.
 
Originally Posted by Oystein
"His own intelligence and competence. He knew from Farrer's DSC tests that the chips might burn too vigorously at 450 °C, therefore he chose a lower temp.
Doing it at 450 °C would have been stupid given the work by Farrer he was going to check."

you yourself stated the pinkish tint from post reaction chip 13 was from the iron oxide. check out the thermitic paper. those post dsc chips look alittle pink too. if it is iron oxide, then the chip was not "destroyed" as sunstealer thought they would be if heated to 450C. so what do you think is going to change. why are you so resistant to holding to the standards and heat the furnace up to 450C?
 
Last edited:
you yourself stated the pinkish tint from post reaction chip 13 was from the iron oxide. check out the thermitic paper. those post dsc chips look alittle pink too. if it is iron oxide, then the chip was not "destroyed" as sunstealer thought they would be if heated to 450C. so what do you think is going to change. why are you so resistant to holding to the standards and heat the furnace up to 450C?

Does this have anything to do with identifying a compound as "thermetic". :confused:
 
Exactly.

  1. He did not say at what temperature the strip started out before current was switched on, but we can guess with high confidence that ot will be around normal room temperature.
  2. He did not say at what temperature it peaked, so you don't know the answer, but it very probably is somewhere between 430°C and very roughly 800 °C
  3. He did not say how long after heating started did took to reach peak temperature, but it seems to have been only a few seconds for a few hundreds of °C
  4. He did not say what average heating rate does this computes to, but it must be several 1,000 °C/min - compare this to Farrer's DSC test which was 10°/min.
  5. He did not say at what time the speciment started to react, so you can't know it - again, seconds after heating began
  6. He did not say what temperature did the strip had when the specimen started to react, because we know neither the time, nor the heating rate, nor do we have a direct measurement.
  7. He did not say what temperature the specimen had when the sepcimen started to react, but it must have been somewhat lower than the temperature of the strip, given the obvious fact that temperature is conveyed with some lag
  8. He did not say how long the reaction take took till completion - agaib a few seconds.
  9. He did not say what temperature the strip had at the end of the reaction - it could be several hundreds of °C higher than at the start given the heating rate, or just a few, if the peak temp wasn't much higher. You can't know.
  10. He did not say what temperature the specimen (or its residues) had at the end of the reaction - you just can't know.

Do you understand now that Basile's statement that he "could" heat the strip to any temperature he wanted and that ot would "typically" go to 430°C tells you nothing at all about the temperatures at which things in the video happened to Chip #13? This is because we KNOW as a certain fact that the strip and the specimen experienced an extreme temperature gradient during the experiment, and Basile did not say anything about it!


But he did say that the red layer contained no more than 2.6% by weight irom
He did say that the droplets are about 50% by weight iron
He did say that there were several such droplets, around 50 µm across
And from this follows that there was much more iron in those droplets post reaction than there was in the red layer pre-reaction.
So you need to acknowledge that Basile must be wrong if he thinks the iron-rich droplets formed from the red layer:
There is much too little iron in the red layer!
There is much too little aluminium in the red layer!
There is way too much hydrocarbons in the red layer!
All that Basile says proves convincingly that the red layer cannot possibly be thermitic, and that the reaction shown in the video is not powered by a thermitic reaction!


Now please compare said two large particles in the top left, and right of center in this image...

[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/MarcBasilePresentation/Basile_43_08_Chip13_MicroAfterBurning.jpg[/qimg]

...to what you see in this image...

[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/MarcBasilePresentation/Basile_39_00_Chip13_Photo.jpg[/qimg]

... with a view to describing shapes and colors! Do you recognize any similarities?

One more thing. Thermite yields almost 50% by weight aluminum oxide (alumina). Since alumina's density is about half that of iron, thermite yields almost twice as much alumina as iron, by volume. Where is the aluminum oxide?
 
[truther mode] We don't know how this secrete "nano-thermite" works, we just know it must have (praise Lord Gage and all his disciples) [/end well...you know]

I believe the nano-termite workers carry the aluminum oxide back to the mound so the queen can make more soldier nano-termite helmets. :dig:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom