Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

so you think that the reaction will NOT take place at 400C as in millettes study but it could happen alittle over 400C as in basiles experiments?

basile-

"I have a stainless steel resistive heating element... little less than a quarter of an inch across... and by controlling the amount of electricity that flows through the strip, I can heat it up to pretty much any temperature that I want.... (Temperatures were) somewhere a little over 400 degrees centigrade typically."
Yes. Why is that an issue? You do realise that Fig 29; a DSC trace, in the Harrit et paper shows this don't you?

Do you know why Millette used 400°C? Do you know why that temperature and not any higher? Do you even know why Millette was heating his samples? Hint: it was nothing to do with the production of a reaction between materials in the sample or the production of iron containing microspheres.

I wish Basile would write all this down. It's far easier to understand what his equipment is if he tells us what his equipment is and at what temperature he's using it at. A little over 400°C could be 446.7°C for all we know. Why is he not measuring the temperature precisely? Why is he not telly us what the precise temperature is?

Why the youtubery? Why can't he write a paper?
 
Senemut,

in the video that YOU linked to, where Basile specifically analysed (and heated) chip #13 - when he placed that specimen on the steel strip and applied electric current to it to heat it...
  1. What temperature did the strip start out before current was switched on?
  2. At what temperature did it peak?
  3. How long after heating started did it take to reach peak temperature?
  4. What average heating rate does this compute to?
  5. At what time did the speciment start to react?
  6. What temperature did the strip have when the specimen started to react?
  7. What temperature did the specimen have when it started to react?
  8. How long did the reaction take till completion?
  9. What temperature did the strip have at the end of the reaction?
  10. What temperature did the specimen (or its residues) have at the end of the reaction?

If any of your replies, except perhaps to the first question, is something other than "I don't know", please explain how you know!

This excercise should make you aware that Basile's claim "(Temperatures were) somewhere a little over 400 degrees centigrade typically." is meaningless when discussing this experiment and the analysis of its residues.

it sounds like millette put his chips into a furnace at 400C. if he put his chips in before he heated it up, then how long did it take the furnace to heat up??


millette's study-
"Chips of interest were ashed in a muffle furnace using a NEY Temperature Programmable furnace operated at 400oC for 1 hour. The gray layer remained intact..."
 
Yes. Why is that an issue? You do realise that Fig 29; a DSC trace, in the Harrit et paper shows this don't you?

yes you think that at 400C, the gray layer will not produce iron and silicon rich spheres and at 430Cish, they will produce iron and silicon rich microspheres?
the trace shows that the sample reacted around 430C.
Do you know why Millette used 400°C? Do you know why that temperature and not any higher? Do you even know why Millette was heating his samples? Hint: it was nothing to do with the production of a reaction between materials in the sample or the production of iron containing microspheres.
yep. i have searched all over and they reccommend furnace ashing at 450C. ive even seen up to 500C. so why did millette use 400C. what was the temp in his lab protocol manual for ashing paint? for what i can gather from the book link below:
"ASTM test methods for pigment content of paint by low temperature furnace ashing (450C) (d 4451) is a low temperature ashing method useful for all coatings that do not contain organic pigments."


http://books.google.com/books?id=ri...5brg&hl=en#v=snippet&q=furnace ashing&f=false
I wish Basile would write all this down. It's far easier to understand what his equipment is if he tells us what his equipment is and at what temperature he's using it at. A little over 400°C could be 446.7°C for all we know. Why is he not measuring the temperature precisely? Why is he not telly us what the precise temperature is?
true...but from his ignition tests and the dsc tests, the chips jones and crew/basile react around 430C.
 
it sounds like millette ... millette's study ...

We are not talking about Millette.

Stop the dodging. You linked to Basile's video. I had a few questions about Basile's video:

Senemut,

in the video that YOU linked to, where Basile specifically analysed (and heated) chip #13 - when he placed that specimen on the steel strip and applied electric current to it to heat it...

  1. What temperature did the strip start out before current was switched on?
  2. At what temperature did it peak?
  3. How long after heating started did it take to reach peak temperature?
  4. What average heating rate does this compute to?
  5. At what time did the speciment start to react?
  6. What temperature did the strip have when the specimen started to react?
  7. What temperature did the specimen have when it started to react?
  8. How long did the reaction take till completion?
  9. What temperature did the strip have at the end of the reaction?
  10. What temperature did the specimen (or its residues) have at the end of the reaction?


If any of your replies, except perhaps to the first question, is something other than "I don't know", please explain how you know!

This excercise should make you aware that Basile's claim "(Temperatures were) somewhere a little over 400 degrees centigrade typically." is meaningless when discussing this experiment and the analysis of its residues.



Can't you answer a question? Not one? Ever? Please note that ALL 10 questions are about Basile and Basile's experiments and Basile's video and Basile's data. I ask them because YOU linked to Basile's video and made claims about Basile's data. If your reply contains the words "Millette" or "Harrit", it is an inappropriate answer. Make sure your answers each reference Basile's work and Basile's video!
 
We are not talking about Millette.

Stop the dodging. You linked to Basile's video. I had a few questions about Basile's video:

Senemut,

in the video that YOU linked to, where Basile specifically analysed (and heated) chip #13 - when he placed that specimen on the steel strip and applied electric current to it to heat it...

  1. What temperature did the strip start out before current was switched on?
  2. At what temperature did it peak?
  3. How long after heating started did it take to reach peak temperature?
  4. What average heating rate does this compute to?
  5. At what time did the speciment start to react?
  6. What temperature did the strip have when the specimen started to react?
  7. What temperature did the specimen have when it started to react?
  8. How long did the reaction take till completion?
  9. What temperature did the strip have at the end of the reaction?
  10. What temperature did the specimen (or its residues) have at the end of the reaction?


If any of your replies, except perhaps to the first question, is something other than "I don't know", please explain how you know!

This excercise should make you aware that Basile's claim "(Temperatures were) somewhere a little over 400 degrees centigrade typically." is meaningless when discussing this experiment and the analysis of its residues.



Can't you answer a question? Not one? Ever? Please note that ALL 10 questions are about Basile and Basile's experiments and Basile's video and Basile's data. I ask them because YOU linked to Basile's video and made claims about Basile's data. If your reply contains the words "Millette" or "Harrit", it is an inappropriate answer. Make sure your answers each reference Basile's work and Basile's video!
and you know what basile had to say about that.
basile-

"I have a stainless steel resistive heating element... little less than a quarter of an inch across... and by controlling the amount of electricity that flows through the strip, I can heat it up to pretty much any temperature that I want.... (Temperatures were) somewhere a little over 400 degrees centigrade typically."


tell me why millette only heated his chips to 400C when the ASTM standard is 450C?
"ASTM test methods for pigment content of paint by low temperature furnace ashing (450C) (d 4451) is a low temperature ashing method useful for all coatings that do not contain organic pigments."

what temp is his labs protocol about heating paint in a furnace?
 
yep. i have searched all over and they reccommend furnace ashing at 450C. ive even seen up to 500C. so why did millette use 400C. what was the temp in his lab protocol manual for ashing paint? for what i can gather from the book link below:
"ASTM test methods for pigment content of paint by low temperature furnace ashing (450C) (d 4451) is a low temperature ashing method useful for all coatings that do not contain organic pigments."
There is a very simple reason why Millette chose 400°C and not 450°C or for that matter any other temperature above 430°C. Even if d4451 recommends 450°C for low temperature ashing he'd be a fool to use that temperature. He's not a fool so he didn't.

Do you know why? Hint: What could possibly happen at 430°C and above?

What was the purpose of using low temperature ashing that Millette employed? Hint: He tells you why.

If you can answer those simple questions then you will have answered all of your questions. It really isn't difficult to figure out.
 
There is a very simple reason why Millette chose 400°C and not 450°C or for that matter any other temperature above 430°C. Even if d4451 recommends 450°C for low temperature ashing he'd be a fool to use that temperature. He's not a fool so he didn't.
millette states in his paper:
"The analytical procedures used to characterize the red/gray chips were based on the criteria for the particles of interest in accordance with the recommended guidelines for forensic identification of explosives5 and the ASTM standard guide for forensic paint analysis and comparison."

guess what, ASTM E1610-02 does mention the low temperature ashing but not the furnace ash technique. but the astm standard (astm d 4451) for the furnace technique state that 450C be used.
you know why? Hint: What could possibly happen at 430°C and above?
you tell me? since his chips are just paint, then the organic stuff turns to soot. you are someone told me that since he knew he had paint that there was no reason to go to 430C to see if it reacted. but if he wants to follow the ASTM standards, then he needs to heat the furnace to 450C.

What was the purpose of using low temperature ashing that Millette employed? Hint: He tells you why.
that is the technique using an "oxygen plasma" to get rid of the organic matrix so one can analyze the pigments and inorganic stuff. similar to the furnace technique but only uses 150C of heat from what i have read.

If you can answer those simple questions then you will have answered all of your questions. It really isn't difficult to figure out.

there is absolutely NO reason not to go to 450C as ASTM D 4451 states. all it is doing is turning the organic stuff to soot.
 
and you know what basile had to say about that.
basile-

"I have a stainless steel resistive heating element... little less than a quarter of an inch across... and by controlling the amount of electricity that flows through the strip, I can heat it up to pretty much any temperature that I want.... (Temperatures were) somewhere a little over 400 degrees centigrade typically."
...

You think this is sufficient to analyse Basile's experiment? Then you can naw answer the 10 question:

In the video that YOU linked to, where Basile specifically analysed (and heated) chip #13 - when he placed that specimen on the steel strip and applied electric current to it to heat it...

  1. What temperature did the strip start out before current was switched on?
  2. At what temperature did it peak?
  3. How long after heating started did it take to reach peak temperature?
  4. What average heating rate does this compute to?
  5. At what time did the speciment start to react?
  6. What temperature did the strip have when the specimen started to react?
  7. What temperature did the specimen have when it started to react?
  8. How long did the reaction take till completion?
  9. What temperature did the strip have at the end of the reaction?
  10. What temperature did the specimen (or its residues) have at the end of the reaction?

Or admit that NONE of these questions can be answered, given the information you have from Basile.
 
millette states in his paper:
"The analytical procedures used to characterize the red/gray chips were based on the criteria for the particles of interest in accordance with the recommended guidelines for forensic identification of explosives5 and the ASTM standard guide for forensic paint analysis and comparison."
Well done - you now know why Millette was using an ashing technique. You will now know that it had nothing to do with iron microspsheres or producing some sort of reaction with the particles in the material.

guess what, ASTM E1610-02 does mention the low temperature ashing but not the furnace ash technique. but the astm standard (astm d 4451) for the furnace technique state that 450C be used.
So what? Doesn't matter what the standard says. If you knew the answer to the next question then you'd know why.

you tell me? since his chips are just paint, then the organic stuff turns to soot. you are someone told me that since he knew he had paint that there was no reason to go to 430C to see if it reacted. but if he wants to follow the ASTM standards, then he needs to heat the furnace to 450C.
I will tell you why he didn't use 450°C or any other temperature above 430°C. It's so simple I thought that even you would be able to figure it out.

Lets do an analogy. Lets say I want you to weigh a single red m&m and post the result at JREF. Easy eh? However, before you weigh the sweet you must eat it. How can you weigh the sweet if you've destroyed the sweet by eating it?

Why would Millette use a temperature that would destroy the very particles he wanted to analyse?


You have it all round the wrong way. Millette assumed nothing. He would have read the Harrit et al paper in order to assess which methods and criteria to use on his own dust samples so that he could ensure he had the same material that Jones had.

He will have noticed that exposing the chips to a temperature of 430°C would likely DESTROY the aluminosilicate hexagonal platelets and the rhomboidal iron oxide particles which he wanted to study via TEM-SAED, because the Harrit paper suggests that a reaction of some kind takes place at that temperature.


You never destroy a sample for analysis unless it's absolutely necessary. This is why DSC is so poor. It's the last test you'd do because it destroys the sample completely.

Millette used a temperature that was high enough to do the job he wanted, but low enough not to destroy the particles he was interested in and which then could be analysed by a technique that would definitively prove what they were.

that is the technique using an "oxygen plasma" to get rid of the organic matrix so one can analyze the pigments and inorganic stuff. similar to the furnace technique but only uses 150C of heat from what i have read.
So what? Who cares? We know why he used an ashing technique, he tells us what equipment he used, who cares about the temperature? The temperature is not important for the purpose of ashing so long as it's below the temperature at which the particles of interest are destroyed and high enough to extract inorganic constituents from an organic film.

there is absolutely NO reason not to go to 450C as ASTM D 4451 states. all it is doing is turning the organic stuff to soot and reacting the material destroying the very particles he wanted to examine.
ftfy

You are wrong. There is EVERY reason not to got to 450°C. 450°C (450>430) is above the temperature at which the material is shown to react destroying the particles in the carbon matrix.

There is no way anyone competent who knows what he is doing is going to get near to a temperature of 430°C and risk destroying what they want to look at, well maybe except you, but then we know you haven't got the faintest clue.

If you want to examine something, don't destroy it first.
;)
 
Why would Millette use a temperature that would destroy the very particles he wanted to analyse?
destroy? if it is paint then that is the residue it will leave at 450C.

You have it all round the wrong way. Millette assumed nothing. He would have read the Harrit et al paper in order to assess which methods and criteria to use on his own dust samples so that he could ensure he had the same material that Jones had.
if he assumed nothing then he would have done the ASTM stardard for furnace ash and do it at 450C.

He will have noticed that exposing the chips to a temperature of 430°C would likely DESTROY the aluminosilicate hexagonal platelets and the rhomboidal iron oxide particles which he wanted to study via TEM-SAED, because the Harrit paper suggests that a reaction of some kind takes place at that temperature.
if he assumes nothing then he would have heated the temp to 450C and analyzed the residue accordingly. that what makes it a standard. others can replicate the experiment and get the same results if it is the same material. you and he is also assuming that the aluminosiclicate hexagonal plts and the iron particles would be destroyed. how do you know that is a fact? oystien is all over chip 13 in basile experiment. from what oystein said about chip 13 post reaction "Do you realize the red layer is red because it contains iron oxide pigments." well, one can NOT say that millettes chips and jones/basile are the same type of material because millette did not heat his up to 450C in the furnace experiment (or do a dsc for that matter). if he had, the organic stuff would turn to soot and then if the paint had formed iron and silicon rich microspheres, we would see that in the end.


You never destroy a sample for analysis unless it's absolutely necessary. This is why DSC is so poor. It's the last test you'd do because it destroys the sample completely.
true.... for your point of it being the last test you'd do because it destroys the sample.

Millette used a temperature that was high enough to do the job he wanted, but low enough not to destroy the particles he was interested in and which then could be analysed by a technique that would definitively prove what they were.
how would 450C destroy the particles?

You are wrong. There is EVERY reason not to got to 450°C. 450°C (450>430) is above the temperature at which the material is shown to react destroying the particles in the carbon matrix.
if you assume nothing, then he would have assumed that the material was similar and not the same and went ahead and heated it up to 450C in the furnace according to the ASTM standard.

There is no way anyone competent who knows what he is doing is going to get near to a temperature of 430°C and risk destroying what they want to look at, well maybe except you, but then we know you haven't got the faintest clue.

If you want to examine something, don't destroy it first.
;)

your assuming it was destroyed.
 
Senenmut: A quote from here: "Upon heating, kaolinite starts to lose water at approximately 400 °C, and the dehydration approaches completeness at approximately 525 °C."
Such dehydration can be accompanied with some changes of pigment particles morphology.

So if Millette found kaolinite in non-heated chips, it was very reasonable to do ashing at the lowest temperature possible, not to destroy what should analyzed/microphotographed.
 
I give up. Senemut is either being obtuse on purpose or beyond teaching. Back onto ignore you go Senenmut.
 
"ASTM test methods for pigment content of paint by low temperature furnace ashing (450C) (d 4451) is a low temperature ashing method useful for all coatings that do not contain organic pigments."
Note that this procedure is for testing pigment contents of paints. Millette did not assume beforehand that it was a pigment and his aim was not to test the pigment content of paint.
 
I give up. Senemut is either being obtuse on purpose or beyond teaching. Back onto ignore you go Senenmut.

of coarse....hard questions that need to be answered. so do you think oystein was right in saying that basiles chip #13 post reaction still had a red layer due to iron oxide pigments?
 
Senenmut: A quote from here: "Upon heating, kaolinite starts to lose water at approximately 400 °C, and the dehydration approaches completeness at approximately 525 °C."
Such dehydration can be accompanied with some changes of pigment particles morphology.

So if Millette found kaolinite in non-heated chips, it was very reasonable to do ashing at the lowest temperature possible, not to destroy what should analyzed/microphotographed.
one will still know it was kaolin but you have to heat the sample higher to get to metakaoline. so the kaolin will not get "destroyed" at 450C.
"Disordered kaolinite dehydroxylates between 530 and 570 °C, ordered kaolinite between 570 and 630 °C."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metakaolin
 
Note that this procedure is for testing pigment contents of paints. Millette did not assume beforehand that it was a pigment and his aim was not to test the pigment content of paint.

read ASTM 1610 - 02 standard guide for forensic paint analysis and comparison. from millettes paper:
"The analytical procedures used to characterize the red/gray chips were based on the criteria for the particles of interest in accordance with the recommended guidelines for forensic identification of explosives5 and the ASTM standard guide for forensic paint analysis and comparison."
 
of coarse....hard questions that need to be answered. so do you think oystein was right in saying that basiles chip #13 post reaction still had a red layer due to iron oxide pigments?

This is the photo of post-reaction residuers of chip #13:

Basile_43_08_Chip13_MicroAfterBurning.jpg


Please describe in minute detail the large particle near the top left corner and the large particle to the right of center! Please make sure you describe the color, and the shape!

Then see this photo of Chip #13 pre-reaction:

Basile_39_00_Chip13_Photo.jpg


and telll us if you see anything that resembles the two large particles you just described in color and shape!






Next up, I have 10 question which you haven't answered yet - please don't dodge them any longer:

In the video that YOU linked to, where Basile specifically analysed (and heated) chip #13 - when he placed that specimen on the steel strip and applied electric current to it to heat it...

  1. What temperature did the strip start out before current was switched on?
  2. At what temperature did it peak?
  3. How long after heating started did it take to reach peak temperature?
  4. What average heating rate does this compute to?
  5. At what time did the speciment start to react?
  6. What temperature did the strip have when the specimen started to react?
  7. What temperature did the specimen have when it started to react?
  8. How long did the reaction take till completion?
  9. What temperature did the strip have at the end of the reaction?
  10. What temperature did the specimen (or its residues) have at the end of the reaction?


Or admit that NONE of these questions (except perhaps the first) can be answered, given the information you have from Basile.
 
You think this is sufficient to analyse Basile's experiment? Then you can naw answer the 10 question:

In the video that YOU linked to, where Basile specifically analysed (and heated) chip #13 - when he placed that specimen on the steel strip and applied electric current to it to heat it...

  1. What temperature did the strip start out before current was switched on?
  2. At what temperature did it peak?
  3. How long after heating started did it take to reach peak temperature?
  4. What average heating rate does this compute to?
  5. At what time did the speciment start to react?
  6. What temperature did the strip have when the specimen started to react?
  7. What temperature did the specimen have when it started to react?
  8. How long did the reaction take till completion?
  9. What temperature did the strip have at the end of the reaction?
  10. What temperature did the specimen (or its residues) have at the end of the reaction?

Or admit that NONE of these questions can be answered, given the information you have from Basile.

spin it however you would like oystein, your a smart guy. take what basile said and leave it at that. email him if you want answers. im not going to put words into his mouth that he did not say.
 
spin it however you would like oystein, your a smart guy. take what basile said and leave it at that. email him if you want answers. im not going to put words into his mouth that he did not say.

Exactly.

  1. He did not say at what temperature the strip started out before current was switched on, but we can guess with high confidence that ot will be around normal room temperature.
  2. He did not say at what temperature it peaked, so you don't know the answer, but it very probably is somewhere between 430°C and very roughly 800 °C
  3. He did not say how long after heating started did took to reach peak temperature, but it seems to have been only a few seconds for a few hundreds of °C
  4. He did not say what average heating rate does this computes to, but it must be several 1,000 °C/min - compare this to Farrer's DSC test which was 10°/min.
  5. He did not say at what time the speciment started to react, so you can't know it - again, seconds after heating began
  6. He did not say what temperature did the strip had when the specimen started to react, because we know neither the time, nor the heating rate, nor do we have a direct measurement.
  7. He did not say what temperature the specimen had when the sepcimen started to react, but it must have been somewhat lower than the temperature of the strip, given the obvious fact that temperature is conveyed with some lag
  8. He did not say how long the reaction take took till completion - agaib a few seconds.
  9. He did not say what temperature the strip had at the end of the reaction - it could be several hundreds of °C higher than at the start given the heating rate, or just a few, if the peak temp wasn't much higher. You can't know.
  10. He did not say what temperature the specimen (or its residues) had at the end of the reaction - you just can't know.

Do you understand now that Basile's statement that he "could" heat the strip to any temperature he wanted and that ot would "typically" go to 430°C tells you nothing at all about the temperatures at which things in the video happened to Chip #13? This is because we KNOW as a certain fact that the strip and the specimen experienced an extreme temperature gradient during the experiment, and Basile did not say anything about it!


But he did say that the red layer contained no more than 2.6% by weight irom
He did say that the droplets are about 50% by weight iron
He did say that there were several such droplets, around 50 µm across
And from this follows that there was much more iron in those droplets post reaction than there was in the red layer pre-reaction.
So you need to acknowledge that Basile must be wrong if he thinks the iron-rich droplets formed from the red layer:
There is much too little iron in the red layer!
There is much too little aluminium in the red layer!
There is way too much hydrocarbons in the red layer!
All that Basile says proves convincingly that the red layer cannot possibly be thermitic, and that the reaction shown in the video is not powered by a thermitic reaction!


Now please compare said two large particles in the top left, and right of center in this image...

Basile_43_08_Chip13_MicroAfterBurning.jpg


...to what you see in this image...

Basile_39_00_Chip13_Photo.jpg


... with a view to describing shapes and colors! Do you recognize any similarities?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom