You missed the part where Basile shows that chips #13, which "is approximately 2.1 mm x 1.6 mm in size" = ~3,36 mm
2 = 0.003,36 cm
2 (screenshot from 39:00)...
[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/MarcBasilePresentation/Basile_39_00_Chip13_Photo.jpg[/qimg]
... so the red layer, at a thickness of, let's say, 50 microns (= 0.05 mm = 0.005 cm) has a volume of 0,168 mm
3, or 168,000,000 µm
3, or 0.000,016,8 cm
3.
Or you missed the part where Basile shows that the red layer of chip #13 contains only about 1.7-2.6% iron (screenshot from 39:30) ...
[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/MarcBasilePresentation/Basile_39_30_Chip13_XEDS.jpg[/qimg]
... but has more than 72% carbon and 20% oxygen, so it is mostly some hydrocarbon, so the density of that red material is 1.5 g/cm
3 or less (pure epoxy has 1.2; mixing epoxy with much more iron oxide than Basile found, and kaolin, would give the resulting paint about 1.5), so we can estimate that the red layer weighs about 0.000,025,2 g..
From this we can deduce that it contains no more than 0.000,025,2 g * 2.6% = 0.000,000,655,2 g of iron.
If you reduced all that iron (which is bound as oxide) to elemental metal and isolated it, it would take up a volume of 0.000,000,655,2 g / 7.5 g/cm
3 = 0.000,000,087,36 cm
3, or 0.000,087,36 mm
3, or 87,360 µm
3.
If you formed one sphere of iron from all of that pure iron in the red layer, you can compute the volume of the sphere thusly:
Volume of a sphere is V = 4/3 pi r
3, so r = cubic_root(V / (4/3 pi)), in this case cubic_root(87,360 µm
3 / 4,12) = ~27.5 µm
Diameter then would be 55 µm.
Now look at one such droplet drom the residue of chip #13 (screenshot at 47:00):
[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/MarcBasilePresentation/Basile_47_00_AnotherIronParticle_Composition.jpg[/qimg]
This droplet alone has an average diameter of more than 50 µm, and it is by far not the only one (screenshot from 43:08):
[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/MarcBasilePresentation/Basile_43_08_Chip13_MicroAfterBurning.jpg[/qimg]
Basile points to several "iron droplets formed from thermite reaction" from #13. Hard to gauge how large they are - there is a size marker that's not clearly visible due to low video/image quality, but it is a marker of 100 µm (or 300 µm?), so it is fair to assume that they all are in the tens of µm across. Much too much of these droplets, they can't possibly come from the little bit of iron in the red layer, even if you take into account that these droplets are only half iron by mass
*)!
Now take a clooose look again at this last screenshot - this time not at the greyish blobs that Basile points to, but at the large reddish chips flakes (top left, right of center). Say what - there is some red layer left over from the reaction?? Do you realize the red layer is red because it contains iron oxide pigments? Do you realize it only stays red as long as the iron oxide is still iron oxide and reduced to iron, and still in the ca 100 nm particle size that makes it a bright red pigment?
Where is the gray layer in that image? Do you see any amount of gray layer that is still in original shape, edgy and all? If the red layer reacted and the gray layer did not, would you not expect to find some left over gray layer instead of left-over red-layer?
Senemut, did you miss all that?
Have you read my blog posts?
- How Mark Basile confirms that red-gray chips are not thermitic ("the hydrocarbon matrix provides more than 100 times the heat that thermite possibly could. The conclusions are inevitable: The red-gray chip is not thermitic by nature"...)
- Too little thermite to blow up Mark Basile's chip (" 5% Thermite in an organic matrix make no difference. On its on, it couldn't warm the matrix even to onset decomposition, it could not destroy more than a small fraction of the polymer molecules, and it would be incapable of doing any significant work on anything outside of the chip. Whatever reaction is observed in the video of chip #13 burning, it is not driven by a thermite reaction.")
*) The screenshot at 47:00 shows Fe: 53%; O: 21%; C: 8%; Al: 5%; Si: 8%; and traces of other elements. The mass ratio of Fe:O in the iron oxides at the surface of steel is anywhere between 2.3:1 (Fe2O3) and 3.5:1 (FeO); in this droplet, it's 2.5:1. Given the imprecision of Basile's measurements, and the range of possible Fe:O-rations for oxidized steel surfaces, it is easily possible that there is enough O to allow for all the iron to be oxidized and the Si and Al to be Al-silicate, perhaps with some silica, too.