Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

So in essence you can't. No surprises there as usual.

Very poor link - I've read that a dozen times and I've asked Henryco numerous questions years ago but he couldn't even label his do his powerpoint so the labels on the graphs were cut off.

He never actually shows you what he heated. From what I can gather he looks to have separated the red layer and heated that.

he does frequent the site so lets ask him.

henryco, did you ever heat up the chips with the red and gray layer or did you just heat up the red layer?
 
You expect me to watch an hour of crap?

Why can't you twoofers do a proper job and and transcribe the points from the video or at least give a time for what to look at?

Why can't you halt the video and take a print screen for the part that is going to answer my question?

Why are you so lazy?

lazy is as lazy does...:rolleyes:

i think you and i both know the details. thats about all i got to say.
 
Thermite/thermate can be used to cut metal but it cannot be timed for sequential demolition. Note that in all the youtube videos of demolitions that timed charges are used. The vagaries of heat transfer and the time thermite takes to cut through a structural component preclude its use in demolitions.

Good one, got a link on that?
 
You expect me to watch an hour of crap?

Why can't you twoofers do a proper job and and transcribe the points from the video or at least give a time for what to look at?

Why can't you halt the video and take a print screen for the part that is going to answer my question?

Why are you so lazy?

Senemut can use some of the leg-work I have done on the video of the Basile presentation that I did here:
http://oystein-debate.blogspot.de/2012/03/how-mark-basile-confirms-that-red-gray.html
I have shown there, using Basile's data as presented in this video, that the maximum concentration of thermite in that chip is less than 5% - which leaves open the possibilty (exceeding likely of course) that it is = 0%

In another blog post I have shown that when you mix <5% thermite with >87% polymer binder (and traces of other, unexplained, minerals thrown in for good measure), the heat of the thermite reaction doesn't even suffice to warm the organic binder enough to ignite it, or turn much of it to gas:
http://oystein-debate.blogspot.de/2012/06/too-little-thermite-to-blow-up-mark.html
This post contains a screen shot with the information Basile provides about how he heated the chip. We have no idea how much energy he pumped into the steel strip or the chip, we have not the slightest idea how hot the steel strip got, and Senemut makes a FALSE statement when he says that Basile heated his sample to 430° degrees.

It is overwhelmingly likely in Basile's experiment that the steel strip through which Basile ran electric current heated the organic (probably epoxy) binder to either its ignition point or its boiling point (or perhaps to both, in rapid succession), and that the gas release seen in the video comes from that reaction of the organic binder - NOT from thermite.
 
Last edited:
Good one, got a link on that?

Practical experience will have to suffice. There are often not links or references on what does not work for a given problem; e.g., scissors are not used to drill oil wells but it may be tough to find a link that says that.

Look at the applications of thermite/thermate use. If demolition companies could use a quiet, low cost demolition agent for the final collapse sequence, they would. Note that those same demolition companies use all sorts of things to minimize the use of explosives and direct the fall of the buildings such as precuts and cabling. My theory has to do with the correlation of hacksaw and socket set sales right before the collapse and the fact that Cheny owned stock in Sears Roebuck. That is definitely the smoking ratchet.
As a point of interest, things are not blown "up"; that is a waste of explosive power. Key elements are cut or blown sideways and gravity does the rest.
 
Practical experience will have to suffice. There are often not links or references on what does not work for a given problem; e.g., scissors are not used to drill oil wells but it may be tough to find a link that says that.

Look at the applications of thermite/thermate use. If demolition companies could use a quiet, low cost demolition agent for the final collapse sequence, they would. Note that those same demolition companies use all sorts of things to minimize the use of explosives and direct the fall of the buildings such as precuts and cabling. My theory has to do with the correlation of hacksaw and socket set sales right before the collapse and the fact that Cheny owned stock in Sears Roebuck. That is definitely the smoking ratchet.
As a point of interest, things are not blown "up"; that is a waste of explosive power. Key elements are cut or blown sideways and gravity does the rest.

You know the building makes a pretty big noise when it hits the ground.They do the rest so they can predict where it is going to fall as not to damage surrounding structures... just sayin'
 
hummmm....didnt basile's react around 430C and not need be heated up to 700-900C?

yep, so his did NOT produce any iron rich spheres or "iron film" as basile describes in this vid-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h1VmaCl4HwU



around 430C it reacts to produce iron rich microspheres and "iron films" inside the reacted chip. did henryco's do that?

A
do do you agree or disagree with sunstealers quote-
"when it comes to the analysis between the material Jones examined and the material Millette examined because the data shows they are one and the same."

Senenmut: I don't know/remember if Basile measured the temperature of the heating element, but let us suppose so and the element had a temperature 430 degrees at the moment of chip ignition, as claimed. Such temperature is quite suitable for burning of the polymeric binder, as is apparent e.g. from the Jim Millette's study (he used one-hour ashing at 400 degrees C, in order to burn out all the organics).

This particular Basile's chip ignited, so it had definitely higher temperature at this moment (but we don't know what temperature). Anyway, the chip after burning was dark (because of incomplete burning of polymer binder, which was transformed to char, we can see it at time 43:00 in the video) and I do not think that they were really "iron droplets" or even "iron films" in this piece of paint ash. Basile's XEDS of "iron based droplet" shows (time 47:00 in the video) 53 % of Fe, 22 % of O, around 6 % of Si and Al and 9 % of C. The Fe/O ratio in Fe2O3 is ca 2.3, the same ratio in Fe3O4 is ca 2.5; the Fe/O ratio in Basile's XEDS of droplet was 2.4, so according to this spectrum that droplet was just iron oxide(s), contaminated with Si, Al and C stuffs.

Henryco heated his chips in some oven and he did not follow what exactly happened in the oven (if some chips were ignited, creating flame). He wrote that he did not find any new iron-richer microspheres (or similar objects) after heating. But most of his chips were probably "red-red", so they did not contain gray layer of rusted steel. I consider Sunstealer's hypothesis that iron-richer microspheres are formed from gray layers as highly plausible, therefore no wonder that they were not created in Henryco's chips.

Although we do not know exactly what kinds of chips were heated by Basile and Henryco, their thermal behavior is compatible with paints generally and there is absolutely no reason why to suspect that they were something else:cool:
 
Last edited:
Senemut can use some of the leg-work I have done on the video of the Basile presentation that I did here:
http://oystein-debate.blogspot.de/2012/03/how-mark-basile-confirms-that-red-gray.html
I have shown there, using Basile's data as presented in this video, that the maximum concentration of thermite in that chip is less than 5% - which leaves open the possibilty (exceeding likely of course) that it is = 0%

In another blog post I have shown that when you mix <5% thermite with >87% polymer binder (and traces of other, unexplained, minerals thrown in for good measure), the heat of the thermite reaction doesn't even suffice to warm the organic binder enough to ignite it, or turn much of it to gas:
http://oystein-debate.blogspot.de/2012/06/too-little-thermite-to-blow-up-mark.html
This post contains a screen shot with the information Basile provides about how he heated the chip. We have no idea how much energy he pumped into the steel strip or the chip, we have not the slightest idea how hot the steel strip got, and Senemut makes a FALSE statement when he says that Basile heated his sample to 430° degrees.

It is overwhelmingly likely in Basile's experiment that the steel strip through which Basile ran electric current heated the organic (probably epoxy) binder to either its ignition point or its boiling point (or perhaps to both, in rapid succession), and that the gas release seen in the video comes from that reaction of the organic binder - NOT from thermite.
Thank you. I understand that Basile heated LaClade now. His heating rate is extremely high. If we assume that the chip he heated is identical in composition to the ones heated in the DSC, even though we don't know anything about those chips from the Harrit paper, and if we assume that the chip ignites at 430°C, then given the chip ignited after 5 seconds then his heating rate is

60/5*430 = 5160°C per minute!!

With no thermocouple reading then the test is pretty meaningless except for the fact we can see that the sample is not explosive. lol.

I'm given to the theory that LaClade will burn when the epoxy ignites around 430°C, but Tnemec red is relatively stable to higher temperatures and this explains the differences seen.
 
Sunstealer: As I read in the mentioned screenshot from Basile's lecture, this chip was not ignited after 5 seconds of heating, but the electrical current was applied ca 5 seconds after the chip was placed on the heating element and camera was switched on. And what we can see in the video? Chip was ignited after ca 4-5 seconds of filming, which should mean that the real heating rate was even much higher than 5000 degrees per minute! These 7 amperes simply heated the element almost instantly to the temperatures high enough for chip ignition.

No wonder that this chip ignited. During very rapid heating, degradation of polymer binder is indeed very rapid as well, leading to the rapid evolvement of even gaseous degradation products. These have not enough time to "espace" from the chip, therefore they form a flammable mixture with surrounding air, which can auto-ignite.

Although Basile's chip could be easily epoxy-based Laclede paint chip, I am not so sure that Tnemec Red paint is relatively more stable to higher temperatures. It also contains a lot of organic polymer binder (alkyd-linseed based), which massively degrades/burns above 400 degrees C.
 
Last edited:
Surely the Nanothermite Industry, like any other, would like to expand its market share and its profits. Surely, they are interested in touting the superior qualities of nanothermite for demolition work over inferior methods using conventional explosives: its reliability, its power, its silence, at least in Hush-A-Boom mode - eliminating damage claims for window breakage from adjoining properties.

Although the tendency of nanothermite demolitions to destroy every other building within a couple of hundred yards may offset that last advantage somewhat.

Dave
 
Sunstealer: As I read in the mentioned screenshot from Basile's lecture, this chip was not ignited after 5 seconds of heating, but the electrical current was applied ca 5 seconds after the chip was placed on the heating element and camera was switched on. And what we can see in the video? Chip was ignited after ca 4-5 seconds of filming, which should mean that the real heating rate was even much higher than 5000 degrees per minute! These 7 amperes simply heated the element almost instantly to the temperatures high enough for chip ignition.

No wonder that this chip ignited. During very rapid heating, degradation of polymer binder is indeed very rapid as well, leading to the rapid evolvement of even gaseous degradation products. These have not enough time to "espace" from the chip, therefore they form a flammable mixture with surrounding air, which can auto-ignite.

Although Basile's chip could be easily epoxy-based Laclede paint chip, I am not so sure that Tnemec Red paint is relatively more stable to higher temperatures. It also contains a lot of organic polymer binder (alkyd-linseed based), which massively degrades/burns above 400 degrees C.
I'm looking at http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs//build05/PDF/b05032.pdf specifically Page 433 (147/258 in adobe) and 439 - 442 which shows Tnemec red after exposure to 650°C for 1hr.
 
I'm looking at http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs//build05/PDF/b05032.pdf specifically Page 433 (147/258 in adobe) and 439 - 442 which shows Tnemec red after exposure to 650°C for 1hr.

Well, in this specific case I'm not sure if NIST report is really right, describing Tnemec Red used for perimeter columns/panels as "essentially ceramic coating".
Although we do not know the ratio between pigments and organics in this primer, there should be still a lot of non-volatile organics in the crosslinked (cured) Tnemec primer. According to specification, around 60 % of mass of vehicle are such "non-volatiles" (alkyd/linseed resins/oils, which mostly crosslinked during curing, forming insoluble and infusible polymeric network), some 35 % are volatiles (thinners).
All these organic/polymeric "non-volatiles" in the cured paint are indeed thermally/oxidatively degraded as in the case of Laclede paint, resulting in paint cracking, scale formation, etc., as described in NIST report.

From this limited set of data, I wouldn't be able to judge if Tnemec paint was more thermally stable than Laclede paint; and it also depends on what we regard as the signs of higher thermal stability. Such stability can be connected, e.g., with the coherence (mechanical properties) of the paint film upon heating to some temperature, or something like this.
Anyway: whereas we do know what is the real thermal behavior of Tnemec primer paint (from NIST), we have no data as regards Laclede primer paint.
 
Last edited:
Since I'm a little bit bored in this very hot summer day, I have tried to make some calculations how it was with the Basile's heating element. Here they are (without any guarantee, of course, perhaps it's a matter for some electrical engineer here, who is just by accident bored as well:cool:):

Basile's element was made of stainless steel with the resistance 90 µΩ-cm (wiki). Its dimension in mm were: thickness t = 0.048 mm; width b = 2.4 mm; length l = 6 mm.

According to calculations made using formulas in this web , such element should have electrical resistance ca 50 Ω (at room temperature, I neglect here the increase of resistance during heating).

If the power supply used for the resistivity heating of the element was set to provide constantly ca 7 amperes, the necessary voltage was roughly 350 volts (from Ohm's law, U = I x R = 7 x 50).

It should mean that power output going to the element was U x I = 350 x 7 = 2450 W! Such energy was indeed able to heat up this tiny element very, very quickly!

(Sorry for not really correct terminology, as well as for any mistakes I could made. It's not important anyway and Basile's "study" probably does not deserve any calculations, perhaps including wrong ones:rolleyes:)
 
Last edited:
Sunstealer: As I read in the mentioned screenshot from Basile's lecture, this chip was not ignited after 5 seconds of heating, but the electrical current was applied ca 5 seconds after the chip was placed on the heating element and camera was switched on. And what we can see in the video? Chip was ignited after ca 4-5 seconds of filming, which should mean that the real heating rate was even much higher than 5000 degrees per minute! These 7 amperes simply heated the element almost instantly to the temperatures high enough for chip ignition.

No wonder that this chip ignited. During very rapid heating, degradation of polymer binder is indeed very rapid as well, leading to the rapid evolvement of even gaseous degradation products. These have not enough time to "espace" from the chip, therefore they form a flammable mixture with surrounding air, which can auto-ignite.

Although Basile's chip could be easily epoxy-based Laclede paint chip, I am not so sure that Tnemec Red paint is relatively more stable to higher temperatures. It also contains a lot of organic polymer binder (alkyd-linseed based), which massively degrades/burns above 400 degrees C.

I recall my recent couch-table-top experiment with candle and some random chips of various organic materials. A clean piece of hard clear plastic from a toothbrush burned vigorously (couple of seconds), developing gas and leaving only a tiny bit of char, when placed on a piece of household aluminium wrap which, when put directly above a candle flame, would heat up very quickly, probably to 500-600 °C. The same material would mostly decompose slowly over a lengthy period of time (tens of seconds) and leave a lot of char when placed on glas shard that heats up much more slowly above the candle flame.

It frightens me to think that the Twoof Movement is leaving it Basile to organize (and Rick Shaddock to finance) an independent lab experiment. Basile seems to me like a genuinly honest person, but he can't be the brightes bulb in the christmas tree...
 
are you trying to say if millette's did react around 430C and produced iron and silicon rich microspheres, would i say the paper is a farce?

Yes.


or if he heated his chips and they showed similar spikes and did not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres?

Sure.

or coarse another option is millette heats the chips and they show a very different spike.....

Then what? Can you explain how this could happen when all the other tests show the compounds to be identical?

Can you tell us which chips were which in the DSC tests Harrett et al performed?
 
Last edited:
Senemut can use some of the leg-work I have done on the video of the Basile presentation that I did here:
http://oystein-debate.blogspot.de/2012/03/how-mark-basile-confirms-that-red-gray.html
I have shown there, using Basile's data as presented in this video, that the maximum concentration of thermite in that chip is less than 5% - which leaves open the possibilty (exceeding likely of course) that it is = 0%

In another blog post I have shown that when you mix <5% thermite with >87% polymer binder (and traces of other, unexplained, minerals thrown in for good measure), the heat of the thermite reaction doesn't even suffice to warm the organic binder enough to ignite it, or turn much of it to gas:
http://oystein-debate.blogspot.de/2012/06/too-little-thermite-to-blow-up-mark.html
This post contains a screen shot with the information Basile provides about how he heated the chip. We have no idea how much energy he pumped into the steel strip or the chip, we have not the slightest idea how hot the steel strip got, and Senemut makes a FALSE statement when he says that Basile heated his sample to 430° degrees.

It is overwhelmingly likely in Basile's experiment that the steel strip through which Basile ran electric current heated the organic (probably epoxy) binder to either its ignition point or its boiling point (or perhaps to both, in rapid succession), and that the gas release seen in the video comes from that reaction of the organic binder - NOT from thermite.

you know me, i like making false statements!!

this is what mark basile had to say:

Mark Basile:
"No, I basically have a setup where I have a stainless steel resistive heating element, that I basically use that's ... oh... what is it... It's about little less than a quarter of an inch across and I basically.. you know... using tweezers and micromanipulators or whatever put the chips basically in the center of the strip, and then by controlling the amount of electricity that flows through the strip, I can heat it up to pretty much any temperature that I want. I don't bring them, you know, anywheres near, you know, the temperatures to do anything harmful to them, but just up enough to basically get them to ignite, and they ignite in the region of... oh... somewhere a little over 400 degrees centigrade typically, and uhm.... When they ignite, you know, I basically have just recorded them burning and then after the fact you can open them up and look inside for these uh.. these iron droplets and films that I spoke of earlier."



http://911blogger.com/node/20998
 
Senenmut:
I consider Sunstealer's hypothesis that iron-richer microspheres are formed from gray layers as highly plausible, therefore no wonder that they were not created in Henryco's chips.
i think basile has reacted a few more of these than sunstealer has!
basile also says this about the gray layer:

"But the gray layer basically seems to be largely iron, although there's some other stuff that's integrated into it too, it seems to have a fairly high carbon and oxygen content as well. But it doesn't ignite, it's just the red layer that ignites. I think if you had a big enough chunk of this, uh.. that I can envision that the gray layer would probably wind up getting consumed into this molten mass of iron that might be produced, but with these small chips you don't get the progression of the event to that level... But I can only speculate."
 
i think basile has reacted a few more of these than sunstealer has!
basile also says this about the gray layer:

"But the gray layer basically seems to be largely iron, although there's some other stuff that's integrated into it too, it seems to have a fairly high carbon and oxygen content as well. But it doesn't ignite, it's just the red layer that ignites. I think if you had a big enough chunk of this, uh.. that I can envision that the gray layer would probably wind up getting consumed into this molten mass of iron that might be produced, but with these small chips you don't get the progression of the event to that level... But I can only speculate."

What's your point. The gray layer is oxidized steel that the paint (red layer) was once adhered to. Not exactly rocket science here. :rolleyes:
 
basile also says this about the gray layer:

"But the gray layer basically seems to be largely iron, although there's some other stuff that's integrated into it too,
That one sentence proves Basile has no idea what he is talking about. No one who knows anything about materials science would describe oxidised iron or steel in that way. You don't integrate carbon or manganese into iron or indeed treat these elements as a separate component of the material.

What Basile is doing is he's looking at the EDX spectrum and treating each element individually without understanding that for example whenever oxygen is present you are highly likely to have oxides in the sample. He doesn't seem to understand that if iron and carbon are present then there is a very high likelyhood that the material will contain iron carbon phases such as those found in steels.

He's embarrassing. If you know what you are on about you can see that he doesn't have any idea what he is saying just by looking at his delivery. He's fooling the uneducated.

With someone who has such a poor grasp and who uses completely inappropriate words and phrases to describe phenomena that he's observed then it's almost impossible to garner much useful information from him.

He uses the word ignite but we have little idea if he understands the difference between "ignite" and "banana". Yes the oxidised steel may not ignite but that doesn't mean it's not part of a reaction such as reduction due to carbon released from the burning of an organic material namely paint.

Yes he can speculate but that's utterly pointless. Twoofers will still lap it up though. /shakes head.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom