hummmm....didnt basile's react around 430C and not need be heated up to 700-900C?
yep, so his did NOT produce any iron rich spheres or "iron film" as basile describes in this vid-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h1VmaCl4HwU
around 430C it reacts to produce iron rich microspheres and "iron films" inside the reacted chip. did henryco's do that?
A
do do you agree or disagree with sunstealers quote-
"when it comes to the analysis between the material Jones examined and the material Millette examined because the data shows
they are one and the same."
Senenmut: I don't know/remember if Basile measured the temperature of the heating element, but let us suppose so and the element had a temperature 430 degrees at the moment of chip ignition, as claimed. Such temperature is quite suitable for burning of the polymeric binder, as is apparent e.g. from the Jim Millette's study (he used one-hour
ashing at 400 degrees C, in order to burn out all the organics).
This particular Basile's chip ignited, so it had definitely higher temperature at this moment
(but we don't know what temperature). Anyway, the chip after burning was dark (because of incomplete burning of polymer binder, which was transformed to char, we can see it at time 43:00 in the video) and I do not think that they were really "iron droplets" or even "iron films" in this piece of paint ash. Basile's XEDS of "iron based droplet" shows
(time 47:00 in the video) 53 % of Fe, 22 % of O, around 6 % of Si and Al and 9 % of C. The Fe/O ratio in Fe
2O
3 is ca 2.3, the same ratio in Fe
3O
4 is ca 2.5; the Fe/O ratio in Basile's XEDS of droplet was 2.4, so according to this spectrum that droplet was just
iron oxide(s), contaminated with Si, Al and C stuffs.
Henryco heated his chips in some oven and he did not follow what exactly happened in the oven (if some chips were ignited, creating flame). He wrote that he did not find any new iron-richer microspheres
(or similar objects) after heating. But most of his chips were probably "red-red", so they did not contain gray layer of rusted steel. I consider Sunstealer's hypothesis that iron-richer microspheres are formed from gray layers as highly plausible, therefore no wonder that they were not created in Henryco's chips.
Although we do not know exactly what kinds of chips were heated by Basile and Henryco, their thermal behavior is compatible with
paints generally and there is absolutely no reason why to suspect that they were something else
