Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Wurlitzer and Circus.

The Harrit Jones Thermite paper on page ONE explicitly introduces itself to "The collapses of the Three tallest WTC buildings as being remarkable for their completeness, near free-fall speed [AT free fall #7], their striking radial symmetry and the surprisingly large volume of fine toxic DUST., which was found, upon examination as presented in the paper, to contain bi-layered chips with both red and gray layering, thought initially to be dried-paint. Upon analysis as described in the paper, these chips were found to be energetic thermitic material of a kind reminding the authors of nanothermites fabricated at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and elsewhere[pp23]
That is the paper we are discussing.
The patent filing regarding the patent 5,505,799 Government/LLNL/Nanoengineered explosives clearly show similarities of materials pertaining to the Harrit Jones Paper. Both of which attest to the materials being existant and within that conversation are the demolitions of WTC complex.
The NIST reports are germane to any and all parts of the discussion set up by the Harrit/Jones paper. NIST produced an Hypothesis [New Phenomena] "fire induced sequential building collapse : due to Normal Office Furnishings Fires' ; as alternative to the up until then, only known method of destroying steel framed high rises in the observed manner. obvious demolitions. Discussing the 'science' of FREE FALL is not spamming. If the only alternative to some kind of thermitic material attack on 911 is the 'sequential building collapse due to ordinary office furnishings fire" of the creatioNIST reports, then I can see why I make you so angry.
Dr. Millette is not going to find the energetics found by Harrit/Jones this time any more than he did in at least two other studies he has participated in. Has that been disclosed on the forum? Have the deep interconnections between NIST and the nanothermite industry been disclosed on this forum? .
The NIST report IS the argument. Is the entire ONE SIDE of the dichotomy. YET it is so flawed disclaimers had to be made within to explain itself. FEMA gave its hypothesis a "low probability of occuring ". The central critical moment concerning WTC7 fail, was engineered by computer modeling protected by states secrets privilege.
As skeptics, there are more questions in the NIST reports than answers yet this forum continues to denounce any possibility of fraud.
 
Last edited:
... As skeptics, there are more questions in the NIST reports than answers yet this forum continues to denounce any possibility of fraud.
The Jones paper is nonsense. If you can prove otherwise, Please, team with a newspaper and earn the Pulitzer.

Headline could read, "JREF Poster Earns Pulitzer for Washington Post". In a fantasy world.

Reality based headline would read, "60 Minutes exposes JREF poster as Gullible". Reality.

You were fooled by nuts in 911 truth who can't understand thousands of pages of NIST, which you never read. You were also fooled by 911 truth nuts who lied, and said it was thermite; reading the paper it is clear they did not find thermite. They say they found it, but the paper proves otherwise. No wonder there is no Pulitzer, no newspaper would back the paper after the reality based chemist experts see the paper.

Where is the Pulitzer? Only in a fantasy.

LOL, please start your fraud report on NIST, a new thread; include some math, use some differential equations to impress JREF and the World.

...
I'd be really interested to know how you understood Jonathon COLES presentation "proves thermite was NOT used on 911".?
I am an engineer. However, any kid can see the video by the paranoid conspiracy theorist Cole, and armed with a grade school education understand after seeing WTC steel, there was zero thermite used. Why can't you see fraud in Jones' Paper. Jones made up the "thermite did it" lie, 4 years after 911 based on nothing. He then faked a paper conclusion to fool people like you - Jones fooled you. When you finally wake up, you will be upset with the nuts who made up the lies you repeat freely without checking.

How many engineers, not in 911 truth nut groups, have you contacted to help you, since your grade school education failed to save you from woo?
 
Last edited:
....which was found, upon examination as presented in the paper, to contain bi-layered chips with both red and gray layering, thought initially to be dried-paint. Upon analysis as described in the paper, these chips were found to be energetic thermitic material of a kind reminding the authors of nanothermites fabricated at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and elsewhere[pp23]
That's already been debunked. If you read the thread you'll see.


That is the paper we are discussing.
I'm well aware of what we are discussing - go back and read the thread. I show that the material is paint. This has been confirmed independently too.

The patent filing regarding the patent 5,505,799 Government/LLNL/Nanoengineered explosives clearly show similarities of materials pertaining to the Harrit Jones Paper.
Go into this in minute detail. This is your main claim. Focus solely on this. How are there similarities? List them and back your claim with references to both the paper and the patent.

Dr. Millette is not going to find the energetics found by Harrit/Jones this time any more than he did in at least two other studies he has participated in. Has that been disclosed on the forum? Have the deep interconnections between NIST and the nanothermite industry been disclosed on this forum? .
Then I suggest you head on over to this thread http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=231314 so you can discuss his results. I'll guarantee you that you won't have a leg to stand on when it comes to the analysis between the material Jones examined and the material Millette examined because the data shows they are one and the same.
 
Correct. It burns hot and fast but is not "directional" and generally drips away in the pull of gravity. Good for burning a hole down through an engine block but not at all effective for cutting horizontally through a vertical steel girder.
I highlighted what I think is the more interesting point. Cutting stuff horizontally isn't impossible, it is merely highly uneffective and requires wasteful solutions where efficient ones already exist.

Maybe you didn't get all the way though the video? At about 9:05 he places thermite on top of a horizontal girder which makes a towering fountain of sparks and a vertical cut in the beam which he then has to stand upright and "break" in half.

At about 9:50 he bolts a large pre-formed steel framed thermite charge against a vertical girder. After another fountain of sparks he has managed to partially burn horizontally through one flange.

Did I miss it somewhere when he horizontally cut a vertical girder in half?
I didn't say "he horizontally cut a vertical girder in half", I said "Cole made horizontal cuts into vertical stuff."
Thanks for confirming that.

Not "proven" but certainly given strong credence to the theory it's not possible?
But Cole has already shown that it is possible to cut horizontally through at least part of a flange with hand-made standard thermite in a back-yard low-tech configuration. It isn't hard to extrapolate from there and declare that of course it will be possible to cut vertical steel elements in half using some variety of thermite if only you put enough engineering effort and material to the task. It would probably just be quite inefficient.

...
You seem kind of wrapped up about semantics here. Let me rephrase things.

Yes, using an as of yet unknown engineering system thermite could theoretically be used to cut horizontally though a vertical girder. Likewise, using an as of yet unknown engineering system lava could theoretically be used to cut horizontally though a vertical girder. Or, using an as of yet unknown engineering system nuclear waste could theoretically be used to cut horizontally though a vertical girder

Heck, using an as of yet unknown engineering system a water jet could theoretically be used to cut horizontally though a vertical girder.
Exactly.

My favorite "engineering" solution to mock the thermite theory is "an army of midgets with saws".

Surely thermite, lava, nuclear waste, water jets or midgets with saws can cut horizontally through steel, and you could devide a James-Bond-villainish machinery using these ingredients to destroy any building in the world.

None of which is relevant to the truthers' claims that "thermite" is currently used in actual CD. If it were a common (or even feasible) CD technique there would be any amount of evidence supporting it. The lack of evidence certainly does not prove it doesn't exist but of course neither does the lack of evidence for Bigfoot. OTOH, the people making the claims about thermite/Bigfoot have the burden of proof on them.
Yes.

But showong that it is possible to destroy the twin towers with thermite (lava, nuclear waste, water jets, saws) is NOT such a proof.
And absence of a show that it is possible to destroy the twin towers with thermite (lava, nuclear waste, water jets, saws) is NOT proof that it's impossible.

What truthers need to do is present evidence that thermite (lava...) was actually used in the WTC. It would help much if they could describe the engineering solution in sufficient detail, such that can make predictions about what sort of evidence to expect. Basically, their entire theory rests on the presence of iron-rich microspheres, as the red-gray chips have been shown beyond the shadow of a doubt to not be paint on steel scale, and not thermitic at all. These spheres are anything but specific for the method or any solution proposed so far (they are common in many types of ashes and apparently even form when you incinerate chips of primer paint on steel scale). They'd better show some severed steel parts whose ends show peculiar signs of having been melted apart. Such steel members do not exist.
 
...
The patent filing regarding the patent 5,505,799 Government/LLNL/Nanoengineered explosives clearly show similarities of materials pertaining to the Harrit Jones Paper.

Several responses to your initial posting of this patent have shown on great detail why these materials are NOT similar.

You have not addressed these arguments.

Can you now finally support your claim that the material descibed in patent 5,505,799 "clearly show similarities of materials pertaining to the Harrit Jones Paper" by quoting from both the patent and the Harrit Jones Paper the relevant properties of either? Thanks.

(Layer thickness, proposed chemical substances, degree of mixing, method of application would be some of the properties I'd expect you to address)



As an aside: What's the connnection between that patent and LLNL? :confused:
 
That's already been debunked. If you read the thread you'll see.



I'm well aware of what we are discussing - go back and read the thread. I show that the material is paint. This has been confirmed independently too.

Go into this in minute detail. This is your main claim. Focus solely on this. How are there similarities? List them and back your claim with references to both the paper and the patent.

Then I suggest you head on over to this thread http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=231314 so you can discuss his results. I'll guarantee you that you won't have a leg to stand on when it comes to the analysis between the material Jones examined and the material Millette examined because the data shows they are one and the same.

so this guy heats his red gray chips up to 900C and they do NOT react but when mark basile heats his up.....wow check out that reaction!

henryco-
http://www.darksideofgravity.com/marseille_gb.pdf

mark basile-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S1TwVACENAo

same material?? or does henryco and millette have a particular material that does not react and jones and basile have a similar but different material that does react.
 
Therm*te Demolitions

Thermite/thermate can be used to cut metal but it cannot be timed for sequential demolition. Note that in all the youtube videos of demolitions that timed charges are used. The vagaries of heat transfer and the time thermite takes to cut through a structural component preclude its use in demolitions. Consider that the towers fell in about 15 seconds. That means the average time per floor was less than 200 milliseconds. This was the result of gravity as it was too fast for anything else. About all that could be claimed was that thermite/thermate was used to start the collapse. The question then is how can one tell the difference between a thermite initiated collapse and a fire weakened steel collapse. One can't, of course, so all the "evidence" for thermite based on collapse videos is also evidence for a fire weakened steel collapse.
As to the Jones paper, Jones' own thermodynamics say that he was burning paint binder in the DSC as the exotherm was too high for thermite or any combination of thermite and the explosives he shows in his paper.
 
Senenmut: Whereas Remo apparently hasn't read our threads on "suspicious" red-gray chips (and he has no idea why we are so pretty sure that these chips are paints), you should perhaps know more. Anyway, once again for you:

ANY paint with organic polymeric (carbon-based) binder inevitably "reacts" when heated under air to high temperatures 700-900 degrees C. Its binder simply burns at these conditions.

Also, Henryco's chips simply burned, leaving red inorganic ash. A quote: "Chips... remain red, burn most of their carbon but other elements remain in the same proportion."

And, of course, also polymer binder in Basile's chips simply burned, as we see in his video:cool:

All red-gray closely analyzed chips are the "same material" in sense that they are all some paints. Why is it so difficult to comprehend or accept this simple, natural and highly plausible explanation?
 
Last edited:
Senenmut: Whereas Remo apparently hasn't read our threads on "suspicious" red-gray chips (and he has no idea why we are so pretty sure that these chips are paints), you should perhaps know more. Anyway, once again for you:

ANY paint with organic polymeric (carbon-based) binder inevitably reacts when heated under air to high temperatures 700-900 degrees C. Its binder simply burns at these conditions.
hummmm....didnt basile's react around 430C and not need be heated up to 700-900C?
Also, Henryco's chips simply burned, leaving red inorganic ash. A quote: "Chips... remain red, burn most of their carbon but other elements remain in the same proportion."
yep, so his did NOT produce any iron rich spheres or "iron film" as basile describes in this vid-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h1VmaCl4HwU


And, of course, also polymer binder in Basile's chips simply burned, as we see in his video:cool:
around 430C it reacts to produce iron rich microspheres and "iron films" inside the reacted chip. did henryco's do that?

A
all red-gray closely analyzed chips are the "same material" in sense that they are all paints. Why is it so difficult to comprehend or accept this simple, natural and highly plausible explanation?
do do you agree or disagree with sunstealers quote-
"when it comes to the analysis between the material Jones examined and the material Millette examined because the data shows they are one and the same."
 
so this guy heats his red gray chips up to 900C and they do NOT react but when mark basile heats his up.....wow check out that reaction!

henryco-
http://www.darksideofgravity.com/marseille_gb.pdf

mark basile-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S1TwVACENAo

same material?? or does henryco and millette have a particular material that does not react and jones and basile have a similar but different material that does react.
Reading comprehension isn't your forte is it? My question has nothing to do with two other people heating chips up.

However,

Can you give me detailed data on the chips that Basile and Henryco heated up. What's the EDX spectrum of the chips heated? What's the heating rate? What equipment was used etc. As far as I'm concerned both Henryco and Basile are incompetent with their analysis and offer little information.

I've seen better write ups by 16 year-olds than theirs. Their writing is a joke.
 
do do you agree or disagree with sunstealers quote-
"when it comes to the analysis between the material Jones examined and the material Millette examined because the data shows they are one and the same."
So where does Basile come into this?

Give a comparison of the chip Basile heated and the samples Jones and Millette had. Are they the same? Show where you get the information from. Don't just post a youtube video.
 
Reading comprehension isn't your forte is it? My question has nothing to do with two other people heating chips up.

However,

Can you give me detailed data on the chips that Basile and Henryco heated up. What's the EDX spectrum of the chips heated? What's the heating rate? What equipment was used etc. As far as I'm concerned both Henryco and Basile are incompetent with their analysis and offer little information.

I've seen better write ups by 16 year-olds than theirs. Their writing is a joke.

http://www.darksideofgravity.com/marseille_gb.pdf
 
So where does Basile come into this?

Give a comparison of the chip Basile heated and the samples Jones and Millette had. Are they the same? Show where you get the information from. Don't just post a youtube video.

you know the answers....i still have money burning a hole my pocket that i was going give to chris mohr to do a dsc test on millette's chips.
here's a youtube vid for ya:D

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h1VmaCl4HwU
 
you know the answers....i still have money burning a hole my pocket that i was going give to chris mohr to do a dsc test on millette's chips.
here's a youtube vid for ya:D

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h1VmaCl4HwU
If Chris was to get Millette to do a DSC test on the chips and the results were identical to Harretts would you then admit the paper is a farce and they found paint? If not, explain why.
 
If Chris was to get Millette to do a DSC test on the chips and the results were identical to Harretts would you then admit the paper is a farce and they found paint? If not, explain why.

are you trying to say if millette's did react around 430C and produced iron and silicon rich microspheres, would i say the paper is a farce?

or if he heated his chips and they showed similar spikes and did not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres?

or coarse another option is millette heats the chips and they show a very different spike.....
 
Last edited:
Wow! A Nanothemite INDUSTRY!

Dr. Millette is not going to find the energetics found by Harrit/Jones this time any more than he did in at least two other studies he has participated in. Has that been disclosed on the forum? Have the deep interconnections between NIST and the nanothermite industry been disclosed on this forum? .

Surely the Nanothermite Industry, like any other, would like to expand its market share and its profits. Surely, they are interested in touting the superior qualities of nanothermite for demolition work over inferior methods using conventional explosives: its reliability, its power, its silence, at least in Hush-A-Boom mode - eliminating damage claims for window breakage from adjoining properties. (Discretion will probably dictate silence regarding its use on 9-11, though.)

Concrete manufacturers certainly used the Windsor Madrid fire to tout their product's superior fire-resistance.

Surely, the Nanothermite Industry could be persuaded to arrange a demonstration test of its product on some run-down building, offering its use gratis to a demolition company. TNT, RDX, and PETN manufacturers will not be sleeping well!
 
Surely, the Nanothermite Industry could be persuaded to arrange a demonstration test of its product on some run-down building, offering its use gratis to a demolition company. TNT, RDX, and PETN manufacturers will not be sleeping well!

You're some kind of subversive, right? You got a black helicopter ... I've seen it. Shill 9!91!!911!
 
So in essence you can't. No surprises there as usual.

Very poor link - I've read that a dozen times and I've asked Henryco numerous questions years ago but he couldn't even label his do his powerpoint so the labels on the graphs were cut off.

He never actually shows you what he heated. From what I can gather he looks to have separated the red layer and heated that.
 
Surely the Nanothermite Industry, like any other, would like to expand its market share and its profits. Surely, they are interested in touting the superior qualities of nanothermite for demolition work over inferior methods using conventional explosives: its reliability, its power, its silence, at least in Hush-A-Boom mode - eliminating damage claims for window breakage from adjoining properties. (Discretion will probably dictate silence regarding its use on 9-11, though.)

Concrete manufacturers certainly used the Windsor Madrid fire to tout their product's superior fire-resistance.

Surely, the Nanothermite Industry could be persuaded to arrange a demonstration test of its product on some run-down building, offering its use gratis to a demolition company. TNT, RDX, and PETN manufacturers will not be sleeping well!

Obviously the Big Boom industry is keeping it down.
 
Last edited:
you know the answers....i still have money burning a hole my pocket that i was going give to chris mohr to do a dsc test on millette's chips.
here's a youtube vid for ya:D

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h1VmaCl4HwU
You expect me to watch an hour of crap?

Why can't you twoofers do a proper job and and transcribe the points from the video or at least give a time for what to look at?

Why can't you halt the video and take a print screen for the part that is going to answer my question?

Why are you so lazy?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom