Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Hi, Henryco

At first as for your second contribution: you really have not noticed Jim Millette's study/replication of Harrit's paper? Contrary to your claim, reliable access to WTC dust with a clean chain of custody is indeed available, and probably not only in Millette's lab.

You really do think (similarly to Remo) that any new found patent on any new kind of thermite published before 2001 supports somehow thermite hypothesis of CD of WTC? Why?
And why we should consider even multilayered thermites prepared by such extremely elaborate methods as magnetron sputtering? Multilayered thermites could be very probably prepared also by other similar methods (e.g. by deposition of oxides/metals in very high vacuum, which we are using in our lab in Prague); still such thermite production is clearly impractical and uneconomical for any purpose; not speaking about the problem, how such complex machines like magnetron sputtering or vacuum deposition devices were "smuggled" to the WTC steel constructions, together with tens of tons of raw materials (and necessary operators):cool: But in this matter, we are probably in no contradiction, as I read your first post.
 
Last edited:
I sent a link to Sunstealer's analysis and this entire thread and got this response from Jim Millette the dust study guy:

Chris, thanks for the post. These data are consistent with our analysis. In addition to the SEM-EDS result consistent with kaolinite, we also confirmed kaolinite with FTIR and TEM-Electron Diffraction. I am afraid I have had to put the research on the back burner while I attend to other projects. Hopefully I will get back to it soon. Jim

Dang! I hope he can get back to it soon too! Chris
 
OK, Chris, thanks for the news:)

I think that the overall interest on 9/11 conspiracy theories is generally fading out (both among truthers and debunkers), but the final, official report of Jim Millette will be still important and interesting not only for us in JREF.
I already do not "hope" that the Jim's final report will include some explicit mention on the "Laclede primer" as a probable material of the most/many red-gray chips, but even so, I am quite happy with this study;) Therefore, thanks again:cool:
 
...
Though i'm not a nanothermite supporter, i can hardly understand the arguments given here:
I suppose that's what makes many truthers_ They don't understand arguments.

What matters is the existence of multilayer technology which uses Carbon layers to make a thermitic reaction explosive.
A patent doesn't mean the technology exists, works, has ever been used, or has been used.
Least of all it means the red-gray chips are such technology.

-1 micron or 10 thickness does not really matter, you can tune the thickness to fit your needs
Why would the patent put a limit on the thickness, if it doesn't matter?

...
- You say there is no carbon Layer in Jones chips: what about Fig 32 and Fig 33
Pk. Does the chip in Fig 32/33 have a meta layer, or a metal oxide layer? Of so which metal, which metal oxide?

You won't be able to answer this. Because you don't know. The chip in fig. in 32/33 is not characterized to any useful or even scientific degree - did you not notice that?

All the other chips do not have such a carbon layer.
They also don't have a metal layer.

- Pb percentage not given for multilayer chip and absent in other chips.
might be not relevant or a small contamination ...
FALSE.
The paper says "significant" Pb, if I recall correctly; even if it doesn't say so, the mere fact that they mention that this chips is characterized by Pb speaks against your idea. You are obviously grasping at straws.

For me this patent gives real support to the possibility of explosive nanothermite.
There is a possibility that an army of midgets with saws destroyed the towers.
There is a possibility that midgets exist.
There is a possibility that saws exist.
There is a possibility that midgets with saws exist.

So what? There is no evidence for midgets with saws at the WTC.

There is no evidence that a material that conforms with the patent was used or found at the WTC.
There is no evidencer any WTC tower was brought down with explosives.
There is no evidencer any WTC tower was brought down with thermite.
There is no evidencer any WTC tower was brought down with explosive thermite.

If i dont buy nanothermite it's for other reasons (complexity of this technology, not much better than conventionnal explosives, if this explosive nanothermite is responsible for the immense section of wall columns
representing about ten floors and a third of a facade (100 tons: the mass of a Boeing 757) thrown at 90km / hour, two soccer field lengthes away from the North tower foot) this would have produced a huge explosion sound that would have been noticed many kms away)
Exactly.

But that you don't understand that this patent has nothing whatsoever to do with anything that Harrit e.al. deswcribed or imagined speaks volumes about your ability to apply science and reason to things you read.
 
Funny in the decade+ not a single truther has presented a single video cutting a girder in half via thermite.

Sorry, this is a stupid post.

What do you think the absemce of such evidence proves? And if a truther showed just such a video, what would that prove?
(Hint: In both cases nothing of relevance wrt WTC)

John Cole has cut some I-bars with thermite. Are you aware of those experiments?
 
Several off topic posts removed to AAH. This thread is about Jones' paper and paint chips. If you don't care about that and instead want to talk about something else, go and do it somewhere else.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Cuddles
 
... John Cole has cut some I-bars with thermite. Are you aware of those experiments?

John Cole proved thermite was not used on 911. The set up he had to go through, makes the use of thermite the idea idiots come up with to satisfy their delusional conspiracy theories based on ignorance and bias. Jones made up thermite, then he published a paper, waves his hands, declares thermite is in WTC dust.
 
Sorry, this is a stupid post.
What do you think the absemce of such evidence proves? And if a truther showed just such a video, what would that prove?
(Hint: In both cases nothing of relevance wrt WTC)

John Cole has cut some I-bars with thermite. Are you aware of those experiments?

Erm, I'm not sure why you feel the need to be rude but OK, if "thermite" or its many imaginary variations were actually used/useful for horizontally cutting steel girders there would be any number of YouTube videos demonstrating such. But it's not used and it's not useful for this purpose and as such only exists in truthers' imaginations. Cole's experiments "proved" he could create small vertical gouges in girders but failed to actually cut a single one.

John Cole proved thermite was not used on 911. The set up he had to go through, makes the use of thermite the idea idiots come up with to satisfy their delusional conspiracy theories based on ignorance and bias. Jones made up thermite, then he published a paper, waves his hands, declares thermite is in WTC dust.
That's the one single video I've been able to find. IIRC, Cole uses "thermite" to generate a waterfall of sparks and only partially cut a bolt (which he then uses a sledgehammer to knock off). Then he laboriously welds a massive custom fitted thermite filled bracket to attach inside a girder. This results in a vertical (not horizontal) slash in the girder. Not severed.
 
There are run-down buildings all over America that the owners would love to demolish. Why don't Truthers offer an owner to take one down with thermite, gratis? It would be comedy gold.
 
Erm, I'm not sure why you feel the need to be rude but OK, if "thermite" or its many imaginary variations were actually used/useful for horizontally cutting steel girders there would be any number of YouTube videos demonstrating such. But it's not used and it's not useful for this purpose and as such only exists in truthers' imaginations. Cole's experiments "proved" he could create small vertical gouges in girders but failed to actually cut a single one.


That's the one single video I've been able to find. IIRC, Cole uses "thermite" to generate a waterfall of sparks and only partially cut a bolt (which he then uses a sledgehammer to knock off). Then he laboriously welds a massive custom fitted thermite filled bracket to attach inside a girder. This results in a vertical (not horizontal) slash in the girder. Not severed.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLrPxFCLNkA
Cole made horizontal cuts into vertical stuff.

I still wonder: What do you think the absence of such evidence would have proved? And since a truther showed just such a video, what does that prove?
(Hint: In both cases nothing of relevance wrt WTC)

Thermite burns hot enough to melt steel, and so it is really just a matter of finding an engineering solution to make devices that can demolish buildings with thermite. It is still stupid to assume that presence or absence of a video showing the same proves anything with regard to thermite actually being used.
 
There are run-down buildings all over America that the owners would love to demolish. Why don't Truthers offer an owner to take one down with thermite, gratis? It would be comedy gold.
I did a whole thread with that proposition. They never took up the challenge

Going in circles and never getting anywhere is what the Truthers are all about.
 
Circus.

With regard Jonathon Coles experimentation and 'going in circles'.
The same argument applies to variables possible in thermitic material application [tool] advances as it does to the US Nanoengineered Explosives Patent :"While a particular embodiment of the invention has been illustrated and described, and specific materials, thicknesses, and processing procedures have been set forth to explain the principles of the invention, such are not intended to be limiting. Modifications and changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art, and it is intended that the invention be limited only by the scope of the appended claims. "

Rudimentary backyard example was made of BASIC thermitic material power. The modification and changes possible in application of material, the TOOLING of it to specifically create 911 demolitions are unknown to this forum. Thats all you are arguing. That you don't actually KNOW how it was done, by what variation, therefor even in the face of all evidence that it WAS DONE., it wasn't.

Anytime you find a forum with 1700 Architects and Engineers putting their reputations on the line arguing FOR the cartooNIST reports, PUT it UP.


To deny LLNL patent material similarity with analyzed material by Harrit etal because 1993 material does not match 2001 specifics [ie: 1.The layer thickness of the patent is at most 1 µm thick. The layers of the chips are at least 10 µm thick. 2.The layers in the patent consists of (more or less) pure materials, in particular the metal layer is really just pure metal, and the organic layer just organic material. In the red gray chips, there is no layer of pure light metal 3. The invention posits that layers of metal and metal oxide be separated by a layer of carbon. There is no carbon layer between any two other layers in Harrit's e.al. study. 4.The multi-layered Chip from Fig 31 is characterized, according to Harrit e.al. in their text, by a significant lead (Pb) content. The patent mentions 17 different canditate metals or metal oxides; lead or lead oxide are not among them. Its layers are 20-90 µm thick]
argues in the face of the patent explicitly discussing the same material invention intending to not be limited in technique or material configuration. I see your arguments answered in the abstract and conclusion offered by the patent. I argue the words as expressed answer your questions. We cannot know the specific modifications and changes that have taken place intervening by virtue of the secrecy involved in the industries.
[Please read again. Abstract: A complex modulated structure of reactive elements that have the capability of considerably more heat than organic explosives while generating a working fluid or gas. The explosive and method of fabricating same involves a plurality of very thin, stacked, multilayer structures, each composed of reactive components, such as aluminum, separated from a less reactive element, such as copper oxide, by a separator material, such as carbon. The separator material not only separates the reactive materials, but it reacts therewith when detonated to generate higher temperatures. The various layers of material, thickness of 10 to 10,000 angstroms, can be deposited by magnetron sputter deposition. The explosive detonates and combusts a high velocity generating a gas, such as CO, and high temperatures. Conclusion : "While a particular embodiment of the invention has been illustrated and described, and specific materials, thicknesses, and processing procedures have been set forth to explain the principles of the invention, such are not intended to be limiting. Modifications and changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art, and it is intended that the invention be limited only by the scope of the appended claims. " ]
 
With regard Jonathon Coles experimentation ...
That experiment proved thermite was not used on 911. Did you comprehend that? Yes? No? Your thermite junk has nothing to do with 911, and proves thermite was not used. You debunk yourself, the same as Balsamo, Gage, and Jones.

... Anytime you find a forum with 1700 Architects and Engineers putting their reputations on the line arguing FOR the cartooNIST reports, PUT it UP. ...
You have no idea what the goal of NIST was. Millions of engineers will tell you thermite is nuts, but you will never take the time to check; it is better if you remain happy with your fantasy and the do nothing movement, 911 truth. 1700 nuts fooled by Gage's fraud. Gage lies and makes over a million dollars. 1700 nuts can't figure it out. 60 Minutes will laugh you out of the studio, unless they do a show on how people fall for idiotic ideas, as in, "What were they Thinking". lol

Not one of my engineering peers believes in your nonsense and idiotic lies. More than 10,000. I got the failed A&E nuts beat by thousands. We know the nuts in A&E make up less than 0.01 percent of all engineers. If we voted on your lies of thermite you would be below 1 percent approval. You lost this one, because you picked the crazy claims of 911 truth before thinking twice.

How do you fall for idiotic lies from 911 truth? Why can't you take your claims to News Sources? Why can't you get one school of engineering to back your claims? Why can't you get any engineering group to back your claims?

Another failed attack on NIST; and NIST is not needed to understand the WTC complex was destroyed by impacts and fires, caused by terrorists. Better than you unnamed bad guys and imaginary thermite story. Nukes exist, as does thermite, but both were not used to cause damage on 911. You failed, fooled by Gage who is an expert at collecting money so he can collect more money from fools. Gage makes over an million, poor Balsamo lives in the basement of his dumbed down cult members, boxing up DVDs to mail out.
 
Last edited:
CreatioNIST report

I see.
When did you last sit down with your ten thousand engineers and agree to this? Have many of your millions of engineering peers actually looked at the detail of the creatioNIST hypothesis? Maybe next time you do, in countering the information AE are trying to get through your thick skull, you can run a few questions past them. See how they relate to FREE FALL of a complex 47 storied 81 vertically columned steel framed high rise in 6.5 seconds into its own footprint, all concrete floors pulverized to DUST, due to 'Normal Office Furnishings Fires' on ONE floor around ONE girder/column seat failure where the critical moment in the HYPOTHESIS is 'created' in the model by outright defrauding the data input. Offer to study NCSTAR1-9:352. Watch how many of them understand the 108' of no resistant FREE FALL due to 'Normal Office Furnishings Fires' is counter intuitive..

Odds on, there will be several hundred thousands of them never HEARD of WTC7. Why is that? Odds are equal to that, several hundreds of thousands of them would thereafter be a little concerned about your anger in defending the cartooNIST reports in the face of forensics proving them to be fraud.

I'd be really interested to know how you understood Jonathon COLES presentation "proves thermite was NOT used on 911".?
 
Last edited:
First of all, I never heard anyone, let alone a debunker, claim or suspect that thermite was used in the clean-up operations. Thermite ist sometimes used to weld steel, sometimes to destroy machinery, but I am not aware that it is useful or even superior for cutting up debris. Do you have a source on that?
Correct. It burns hot and fast but is not "directional" and generally drips away in the pull of gravity. Good for burning a hole down through an engine block but not at all effective for cutting horizontally through a vertical steel girder.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLrPxFCLNkA
Cole made horizontal cuts into vertical stuff.
Maybe you didn't get all the way though the video? At about 9:05 he places thermite on top of a horizontal girder which makes a towering fountain of sparks and a vertical cut in the beam which he then has to stand upright and "break" in half.

At about 9:50 he bolts a large pre-formed steel framed thermite charge against a vertical girder. After another fountain of sparks he has managed to partially burn horizontally through one flange.

Did I miss it somewhere when he horizontally cut a vertical girder in half?

I still wonder: What do you think the absence of such evidence would have proved? And since a truther showed just such a video, what does that prove?
(Hint: In both cases nothing of relevance wrt WTC)
Not "proven" but certainly given strong credence to the theory it's not possible? Assumption being that after a decade of "research" truthers could have managed to horizontally cut through a vertical girder using thermite. As fond as they are of Youtube, there's really only one possible reason there aren't any to be found.

Thermite burns hot enough to melt steel, and so it is really just a matter of finding an engineering solution to make devices that can demolish buildings with thermite. It is still stupid to assume that presence or absence of a video showing the same proves anything with regard to thermite actually being used.
You seem kind of wrapped up about semantics here. Let me rephrase things.

Yes, using an as of yet unknown engineering system thermite could theoretically be used to cut horizontally though a vertical girder. Likewise, using an as of yet unknown engineering system lava could theoretically be used to cut horizontally though a vertical girder. Or, using an as of yet unknown engineering system nuclear waste could theoretically be used to cut horizontally though a vertical girder

Heck, using an as of yet unknown engineering system a water jet could theoretically be used to cut horizontally though a vertical girder.

None of which is relevant to the truthers' claims that "thermite" is currently used in actual CD. If it were a common (or even feasible) CD technique there would be any amount of evidence supporting it. The lack of evidence certainly does not prove it doesn't exist but of course neither does the lack of evidence for Bigfoot. OTOH, the people making the claims about thermite/Bigfoot have the burden of proof on them.
 
Last edited:
I see.
When did you last sit down with your ten thousand engineers and agree to this? Have many of your millions of engineering peers actually looked at the detail of the creatioNIST hypothesis? Maybe next time you do, in countering the information AE are trying to get through your thick skull, you can run a few questions past them. See how they relate to FREE FALL of a complex 47 storied 81 vertically columned steel framed high rise in 6.5 seconds into its own footprint, all concrete floors pulverized to DUST, due to 'Normal Office Furnishings Fires' on ONE floor around ONE girder/column seat failure where the critical moment in the HYPOTHESIS is 'created' in the model by outright defrauding the data input. Offer to study NCSTAR1-9:352. Watch how many of them understand the 108' of no resistant FREE FALL due to 'Normal Office Furnishings Fires' is counter intuitive..

Odds on, there will be several hundred thousands of them never HEARD of WTC7. Why is that? Odds are equal to that, several hundreds of thousands of them would thereafter be a little concerned about your anger in defending the cartooNIST reports in the face of forensics proving them to be fraud.

I'd be really interested to know how you understood Jonathon COLES presentation "proves thermite was NOT used on 911".?
Remo - this thread is for discussion of the Jones Thermite paper. If you are going to claim that your patent matches the material found then please use quotes from the paper and a more coherent posting style to do so. I'll have to report you again for off-topic spamming otherwise.

The material that Jones had is paint. I showed this back in 2009 and earlier this year that conclusion has been backed by a study by Jim Millette. Why don't you argue the science instead of spamming/trolling?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom