Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Just to pick one tidbit from your Gish Gallop: there is no definitive evidence that WTC7 fell AT "Free Fall", due to measurement uncertainties, and there is a very real possibility it fell at ABOVE "Free Fall". This also can be explained by non-Controlled Demolition collapse mechanisms.

In any case, where's your evidence of your explosives? Find any? No one has that I can discern. No clear residue distinguishable from primer paint, no detonators, no suspects on tape or confessing, no paper trail, no financing, no statements, emails or memos, no Thermite bright light, no explosive sounds, and no use of a similar method of Controlled Demolition as you propose, on a steel frame building.

By the way, what kind of material is your patent designed for?

See, that's the magic of super-dooper-magic-nano-thermite: It has whatever properties it needs in order to make the controlled demolition theory work. Hush-a-boom! No explosive flash! :rolleyes:
 
Is there such a thing as an "appeal to gullibility" fallacy?

Because I think this may be one.


(interesting paintings though, Roger)

I'm pretty sure it's just word salad. I parse it as "Next you will be telling me that [run on sentence] because you were told it did."

Of course, there's the fact that 7 didn't collapse in 6.5 seconds unless one ignores the EMP, and it may not have been in freefall, and freefall is not necessarily an indication of CD, as shown by Truthers being unable to actually provide regular CDs that fall at freefall.

Oh, and it didn't fall into it's own footprint.

And the NIST did more than just plug data into a computer, and they weren't the only ones who investigated the collapse.

And no one said that the fires were "ordinary". Just the method of their initiation would make them exceptional.

So, yeah, every word in that post is wrong.

Tell you what, Remo; no truther has wanted to answer this question in any kind of detail. Let's see if you're the first. A fairly simple question.

How is it possible for the bad guys to know almost exactly how WTC 1 would collapse in order for them to plant their charges and wiring where they wouldn't be disrupted by the falling debris?
 
How is it possible for the bad guys to know almost exactly how WTC 1 would collapse in order for them to plant their charges and wiring where they wouldn't be disrupted by the falling debris?
Not to mention the impact of a jet airliner. ;)
 
No Evidence for "Energetic Thermitic Material"

To the argument.

pp 21 of the Harrit/Jones paper states 'The evidence for active, highly energetic thermitic material in the WTC dust is compelling'. Reported 'highly energetic reactions, iron-rich sphere formation so that the product must have been molten', 'to be expected from thermitic reactions' and that 'These observations reminded us of nano-thermite fabricated at LLNL and elsewhere.."[pp23]

They have no evidence. Since they reacted their material under air instead of an inert atmosphere, they cannot rule out the interpretation that all of the energy released was from combustion of the carbon epoxy matrix. At best, a blockhead mistake that would embarrass a chemistry undergraduate. At worst, a deliberate attempt at scientific fraud. Their data is equally consistent with paint. Dr. Millette's test results confirm that it is indeed paint.
 
iron-rich sphere formation so that the product must have been molten'
Have any of them ever addressed the fact you can easily create your own "iron-rich spheres" simply using a Bic lighter on steel wool? :o
 
To the argument.

pp 21 of the Harrit/Jones paper states 'The evidence for active, highly energetic thermitic material in the WTC dust is compelling'. Reported 'highly energetic reactions, iron-rich sphere formation so that the product must have been molten', 'to be expected from thermitic reactions' and that 'These observations reminded us of nano-thermite fabricated at LLNL and elsewhere.."[pp23]

Patent 5 505 799 pertains to Government/ LLNL nanoengineered explosives., 'reactive elements that have the capability of considerably more heat 'involving a plurality of very thin stacked multilayer structures etc [as above and read the patent] with a clearly stated intention to further refine going forward and not intended to be limiting by its filing . so that we have
. A paper identifying energetic material chips in the DUST 'reminding the the authors of nano-thermite fabricated at LLNL'
. A patent filed 1993 establishing High end development of energetic materials by LLNL that are of the kind identified in 1.

As I struggle with the essentially [creatio]nist HYPOTHESIS; an unproven UNTESTED THEORY morphing the OBSERVABLE 2.25 second FREE FALL of building 7; A complex 81 Vertically columned 47 storied steel framed high-rise suddenly straight down in 6.5 seconds to its own plan area "in the manner of controlled demolition" - all concrete pulverized into thermitic material and iron-rich microsphere riddled DUST., as I struggle with the observable building behaviour deconstructed into 'the result of 'Normal Office furnishings fires", burning around ONE column girder seat [of three at that join] on ONE floor [12] where photograph shows the fire OUT at critical Pinnochio Sunder axial 'thermal expansion' moment,
- where 3/4" shear studs at 22" centers break because of 'differential thermal expansion stresses created in the model by turning heat off the concrete floor slabs sat direct on the beams/girders to achieve differential stresses[NCSTAR1-9:352]
Where thermal expansion data is input on 'unrestrained beams', and where the critical girder shear-studs are excluded from input, and 'unusual' [6%] per volume iron-rich spheres are attributed to 'rust burn' in 'elevator furnaces',
- a THEORY constructed on computer algorithms held in secret
- a declared 'New Phenomenon' in building science never seen before nor since 911 [where are the skeptics when you need them],
- Where eyewitness TESTIMONY of explosive events within the building and of Molten metal 'flowing like a foundry' 'like it was lava, in a volcano' cannot even be given HONOR of official record ,

......as I struggle with that agnotological THEORY being accepted as REAL by any sentient being, the need to argue finer points of chemical chip layering possibles in the face of patent projected variables reminds me fully of the sinister Karl Rove:

" We're an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you're studying that reality.....judiciously, as you will, - we'll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and thats how things will sort out. We're history's actors....and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do"
Were you drunk when you wrote that? Why can't you stay on topic?

I'll explain it very simply. Your claim is the equivalent of claiming that a patent for a 4 legged wooden table explains the presence of a banana.

The thermite patent you quote doesn't have any elements that match the material in the Bentham paper. The material in the paper is red paint adhered to rusted steel.

Before you continue spamming please read the Harrit et al paper and then this thread. It's all explained.
 
My response to this thread was merged onto another without acknowledgment on this original Millette stream, thus leaving it unaswered here.
...

It is patently and obviously FALSE of you to claim that your original post, and your responses, are "unaswered here". All your posts and all your replies are in this thread here - where it belongs: The Discussion of the Excellent Analysis of Jones latest [2009] paper. It should raise bright red flags thgat you dare to write such obviously FALSE things here! Are you consciously being dishonest, or can't you read sequentially?

YOU claim this patent bears resemblance to what Jones (Harrit e.al.) claims they found. This is not in any way a response to what Millette found: Millette found that all ingredients of the red layer are highly typical for ordinary paint, AND that there is no thermite whatsoever in the chips.


In any case, I responded to your original post about that patent (post # 828 here) two posts later (#830). Ivan Kminek, too, responded to +828. You neither acknowledged nor responded to these responses.
Instead, you SPAMMED basically the same stuff again, 4 weeks later, as # 832. This time, cjnewson88, Sunstealer, Dave Rogers, elMondoHummus, alienentity, myself again responded to the meat of your argument - adressing the argument, all of us soundly refuting it.

Your response was #844 - and ad-hom attack ("Next you will be telling me you BELIEVE some ... just because you were told ..."). You did NOT address our arguments, or defend your own. Later you reposted the same old, and whined a bit about posts being moved - and context being disrupted - which is not true.


I addressed your argument that the patent somehow is significant wrt to Harrit's red-gray chips. Here, I repost it for you:

Hi Remo,

I see that you have been spamming this patent at 911Blogger, which was found by Dirk Gerhardt aka Sitting-Bull (a leading German truther with whom I had an agreeable conversation oover dinner this april) and presented by Dirk at 911Blogger in its own blog post.

This patent describes alternating layers of
  • an elemental metal (titanium, beryllium, aluminum, lithium, calcium, zirconium or yttrium)
  • a metal oxide (copper oxide, gallium oxide, zinc oxide, molybdenum oxide, nickle oxide, cobalt oxide, tin oxide or germanium oxide)
  • an organic material (only example given is carbon, which, if elemental, is NOT an organic material)
Each layer 10 to 10,000 angstroms thick (1 nm to 1 µm), and built up by magnetron sputtering.
(the patent also mentions iron oxide and manganese oxides as typical materials in thermites)

Sitting-Bull thinks this patent is interesting because it talks of "layers", "multiple layers" even, and believes it can explain in particular the multi-layered chip that Harrit e.al. show in Fig. 31.


It is very stupid to think that the red-gray chips somehow are an application of that patent or a similar technology! Many reasons why:

  1. The layer thickness of the patent is at most 1 µm thick. The layers of the chips are at least 10 µm thick
  2. The layers in the patent consists of (more or less) pure materials, in particular the metal layer is really just pure metal, and the organic layer just organic material. In the red gray chips, there is no layer of pure light metal
  3. The invention posits that layers of metal and metal oxide be separated by a layer of carbon. There is no carbon layer between any two other layers in Harrit's e.al. study
  4. The multi-layered Chip from Fig 31 is characterized, according to Harrit e.al. in their text, by a significant lead (Pb) content. The patent mentions 17 different canditate metals or metal oxides; lead or lead oxide are not among them. Its layers are 20-90 µm thick

As you can see, Remo, the material described by the patent has only the mpst superficial similarity with any of the red-gray chips, but really the chips cannpt be an implementation of the invention, or even react in the way the invention describes.


It takes a truther to be gullible enough to consider this patent "a great find".



Please address my arguments, and defend yours!
 
It is patently and obviously FALSE of you to claim that your original post, and your responses, are "unaswered here". All your posts and all your replies are in this thread here - where it belongs: The Discussion of the Excellent Analysis of Jones latest [2009] paper. It should raise bright red flags thgat you dare to write such obviously FALSE things here! Are you consciously being dishonest, or can't you read sequentially?

In fairness, Oystein, the post you quoted, as well as some others, were moved by the moderators into this thread from the Millette thread, which is apparently where he wanted to have this discussion. However, as it is more germane to the current thread, I can see why the mods moved it, and I would humbly suggest that instead of getting riled up about it, he simply deal with it and relocate his center of attention to this thread.
 
In fairness, Oystein, the post you quoted, as well as some others, were moved by the moderators into this thread from the Millette thread, which is apparently where he wanted to have this discussion. However, as it is more germane to the current thread, I can see why the mods moved it, and I would humbly suggest that instead of getting riled up about it, he simply deal with it and relocate his center of attention to this thread.

Yes, but remember what I wrote and what is also true: "All your posts and all your replies are in this thread here - where it belongs". I should have added "all replies to all your posts were also moved here, so no context is lost".

Remo claims this patent describes a material similar to what Jones claims the red-gray chips are, and not what Millette describes. That's why the move was perhaps justified. Remo tries to make the move an excuse to not address the lot of responses already given to him, and that is simply dishonest. He ought to stop the whining and comlaining, acknowledge the responses, address them - and if he does so both honestly and intelligently, he should admit that this patent describes nothing that resembles in any significant way the red-gray chips.
 
The MIX

I don't mind where the discussion is, as long as it is in one place and in total. For my part beginning with the patent filing : US Govt.LLNL 1993 Nanoengineered explosives Abstract. Followed by the CONCLUSION :"While a particular embodiment of the invention has been illustrated and described, and specific materials, thicknesses, and processing procedures have been set forth to explain the principles of the invention, such are not intended to be limiting. Modifications and changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art, and it is intended that the invention be limited only by the scope of the appended claims." This speaks to the resemblance and significance of energetic [incendiary] material found by Harrit/Jones in the DUST of 911 and the FREE FALL demolition of WTC7.

With respect addressing responses already given, and with regard WTC7. The OBSERVABLE building behavior- the central issue of FACT, is that the building was an 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed high rise THAT DROPPED SUDDENLY and ENTIRELY "in the manner of controlled demolition" into its own plan area, AT FREE FALL for 2.25 seconds as corroborated by NIST [shamed into acknowledgment by David Chandler] THAT that 2.25 second FREE FALL phase of the overall 6.5 sec + global destruct phase was, by proper equation, 108 ft more or less of the building height width and length, or equal to an eight storied subsection of the entire building that HAD to have CEASED ALL resistance AT THE SAME MOMENT to achieve the observable building behavior. That is, ALL load bearing responsibilities over an 8 storied subsection of a complex steel framed high-rise in an INSTANT ceased to function.

THE QUESTION is, and in terms of this discussion, what acted on those hundreds of joins ALL at one moment if not the 'up 'till then' ONLY known method of bringing complex steel framed structures down at FREE FALL? by highly skilled 'practitioners in the arts' of incendiary explosive technologies?

Enter Shyam Sunder and the creatioNIST "New Phenomena"®

The NIST THEORY(unproven untested computer construct protected by states secrets privilege) has it that ONE office furnishings fire on ONE floor created heat enough to expand 4 large steel beams between columns 44 and 79, beginning at 103º[coffee anyone?], enough to break dozens of 3/4" shear-studs@22" centers holding the floor panels to the beams in composite, something never recorded before nor since in building science. A fire NIST insist took place on level twelve where later photographic evidence show the fires OUT prior to 'critical collapse initiation'. Fires that by NISTs own calculations 'roam', unable to remain in any one place for more that 30 minutes, yet, somehow, for the FIRST TIME in history created fires hot enough to HEAT the BEAMS but NOT the CONCRETE floor slabs sat directly upon them, [NCSTAR1-9:352], thus creating the differential stresses [in the model] enough to expand the steel[but not the concrete which thermally expands more or less the same under heat], snap all the studs over 4 major beams, not SAG the beams, as gravity would demand, but push straight out in-front, in one direction like Pinocchio's nose, 'walking' the girder between 44 and 79 off its seat at 79. We later find documents showing that that girder had one if not two lines of shear studs NOT equated in the model, that the axial expansion input data was on 'unrestrained' steel in a 'Thermal Expansion' model not factoring 'conductivity'. HOWEVER, and none the less, the untested THEORY goes on from that critical shear-stud break in a split second to the Column/Girder seat connection FAIL 'dropping' the girder onto floor twelve, creating a 'cascade collapse' down 7-9 floors at that point, within 1.5 seconds give or take a split second. pop pop pop pop. This THEORY does not satisfactorily address the other TWO girder connections at the critical fail point. None the less, the HYPOTHESIS has it, that column 79 suddenly became completely naked of any girder joins over a 7 to 9 story area about 2 seconds after critical fail. That the 'loose' column 79 - ONE of EIGHTY ONE, flailed about PULLING the PENTHOUSE 35 stories above straight down to the ground in about 2 seconds, give or take. then, spreading in a split second 'sequentially' over the entire 24 inner CORE column area, bringing the whole INSIDE structure down, without perceivable external damage.
Not bad for an office furnishings fire.
Only then did the global drop suddenly occur at free fall. Which is from WHERE we measure FREE FALL. So that suddenly, over 8 stories, Sunder would have it, all perimeter columns, INSTANTLY 'gave up the ghost' dropping the entire structure AT FREE FALL into its own plan area. ALL concrete pulverized into fine powder DUST that was later found to be 6% by volume iron rich spheroids. The known fingerprint of thermitic reactions having taken place. DUST later found to contain energetic material chips as yet undiscovered or undisclosed by Millette, reminding the authors of nanothermates engineered by LLNL.
 
an eight storied subsection of the entire building that HAD to have CEASED ALL resistance AT THE SAME MOMENT to achieve the observable building behavior. That is, ALL load bearing responsibilities over an 8 storied subsection of a complex steel framed high-rise in an INSTANT ceased to function.
That's just how collapses happen.

Like here:

Or here:

Or here:


ETA: Recently explained here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8505476#post8505476

Enter Shyam Sunder and the creatioNIST "New Phenomena"®
Hogwash. Pure ignorance of a phenomenon that is very real and well known by the people who matter: engineers.
 
Last edited:
This speaks to the resemblance and significance of energetic [incendiary] material found by Harrit/Jones in the DUST of 911 and the FREE FALL demolition of WTC7.

No it doesn't. As I've already explained, it's just boilerplate text, and of no significance whatsoever.

The OBSERVABLE building behavior- the central issue of FACT, is that the building was an 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed high rise THAT DROPPED SUDDENLY and ENTIRELY "in the manner of controlled demolition" into its own plan area, AT FREE FALL for 2.25 seconds as corroborated by NIST [shamed into acknowledgment by David Chandler] THAT that 2.25 second FREE FALL phase of the overall 6.5 sec + global destruct phase was, by proper equation, 108 ft more or less of the building height width and length, or equal to an eight storied subsection of the entire building that HAD to have CEASED ALL resistance AT THE SAME MOMENT to achieve the observable building behavior. That is, ALL load bearing responsibilities over an 8 storied subsection of a complex steel framed high-rise in an INSTANT ceased to function.

There are so many falsehoods in this that it's difficult to know where to start. Firstly, WTC7 did not drop "suddenly," but showed sufficiently significant signs of impending collapse at least two hours before it finally fell that firefighters were reluctant to enter it. Secondly, it did not fall into its own plan area, but damaged several surrounding buildings and left a debris field that covered an adjacent four-lane highway. Thirdly, there is no suich thing as a drop "in the manner of a controlled demolition. Fourthly, velocity traces show that the collapse was close to free fall over about 2.25 seconds. Fifthly, NIST did not comment on this initially because it was of no particular significance in determining the initiation mechanism, and were in no sense "shamed" into acknowledging Chandler's very minor comments. Sixthly, the statement that all load-bearing capability was lost instantaneously is clearly disproven by three observations: (a) the prior collapse of the mechanical penthouses and connecting structures, (b) the clearly visible king in the north face during collapse, and (c) the equally clearly visible southward rotation of the entire structure during collapse.

Apart from that, though, you got the length of the multi-storey buckle about right.

THE QUESTION is, and in terms of this discussion, what acted on those hundreds of joins ALL at one moment if not the 'up 'till then' ONLY known method of bringing complex steel framed structures down at FREE FALL? by highly skilled 'practitioners in the arts' of incendiary explosive technologies?

No, the question is, why are you so determined to believe that reality is something other than it is?

Dave
 
... For my part beginning with the patent filing : US Govt.LLNL 1993 Nanoengineered explosives Abstract. Followed by the CONCLUSION :"While a particular embodiment of the invention has been illustrated and described, and specific materials, thicknesses, and processing procedures have been set forth to explain the principles of the invention, such are not intended to be limiting. Modifications and changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art, and it is intended that the invention be limited only by the scope of the appended claims." This speaks to the resemblance and significance of energetic [incendiary] material found by Harrit/Jones in the DUST of 911 and the FREE FALL demolition of WTC7.
No, it doesn't. Several poster, including myself, have addressed the SUBSTANCE of both the patent and the Harrit paper and refuted the silly and far-fetched idea that both resemble each other in any significant way.

They don't.

You have not addressed the substantial, detailed and concrete refutations already given to you. Please go back in the thread and do so now. Ignoring all those refutations doesn't make then go away, it only makes you look ignorant.


With respect addressing responses already given, and with regard WTC7. ...
There is zero evidence that connects the red-gray chips or that patent with WTC7.

In fact, Harrit e.al. specifically point out that one of their samples was collected even before WTC7 collapsed. There is no other mention of WTC7 in the paper.

Consequently none of the responses already given even mentions WTC7. So why are you bringing it up? All of the responses address the substance of the patent and the substance of the Harrit paper. Not WTC7

I snipped a lengthy text that addressed neither the substance of the patent nor the substance of the Harrit paper nor the substance of the responses already given. Your debate performance so far is subterranean. You need to do much much better. Or are you a government-payed disinfo shill out to give the Truth Movement a bad reputation for inept debate skills?
 
This patent describes alternating layers of
  • an elemental metal (titanium, beryllium, aluminum, lithium, calcium, zirconium or yttrium)
  • a metal oxide (copper oxide, gallium oxide, zinc oxide, molybdenum oxide, nickle oxide, cobalt oxide, tin oxide or germanium oxide)
  • an organic material (only example given is carbon, which, if elemental, is NOT an organic material)
Each layer 10 to 10,000 angstroms thick (1 nm to 1 µm), and built up by magnetron sputtering.
(the patent also mentions iron oxide and manganese oxides as typical materials in thermites)

Sitting-Bull thinks this patent is interesting because it talks of "layers", "multiple layers" even, and believes it can explain in particular the multi-layered chip that Harrit e.al. show in Fig. 31.


It is very stupid to think that the red-gray chips somehow are an application of that patent or a similar technology! Many reasons why:

  1. The layer thickness of the patent is at most 1 µm thick. The layers of the chips are at least 10 µm thick
  2. The layers in the patent consists of (more or less) pure materials, in particular the metal layer is really just pure metal, and the organic layer just organic material. In the red gray chips, there is no layer of pure light metal
  3. The invention posits that layers of metal and metal oxide be separated by a layer of carbon. There is no carbon layer between any two other layers in Harrit's e.al. study
  4. The multi-layered Chip from Fig 31 is characterized, according to Harrit e.al. in their text, by a significant lead (Pb) content. The patent mentions 17 different canditate metals or metal oxides; lead or lead oxide are not among them. Its layers are 20-90 µm thick

As you can see, Remo, the material described by the patent has only the mpst superficial similarity with any of the red-gray chips, but really the chips cannpt be an implementation of the invention, or even react in the way the invention describes.


It takes a truther to be gullible enough to consider this patent "a great find".


Though i'm not a nanothermite supporter, i can hardly understand the arguments given here:

What matters is the existence of multilayer technology which uses Carbon layers to make a thermitic reaction explosive.

-1 micron or 10 thickness does not really matter, you can tune the thickness to fit your needs
- The list of metal oxydes is not meant to be exhaustive here, i dont see why iron oxyde or any other allowing an aluminothermic reaction could not have its place in the list
- You say there is no carbon Layer in Jones chips: what about Fig 32 and Fig 33
- Pb percentage not given for multilayer chip and absent in other chips.
might be not relevant or a small contamination ...

For me this patent gives real support to the possibility of explosive nanothermite. If i dont buy nanothermite it's for other reasons (complexity of this technology, not much better than conventionnal explosives, if this explosive nanothermite is responsible for the immense section of wall columns
representing about ten floors and a third of a facade (100 tons: the mass of a Boeing 757) thrown at 90km / hour, two soccer field lengthes away from the North tower foot) this would have produced a huge explosion sound that would have been noticed many kms away)
 
let me add that discussing dust analysis performed years after 9/11 is a lost of time because there is no free and reliable access to wtc dust now so even if the Jones results were perfect you would have to trust the authors of the publication as any other witness and one knows that this is not possible given how serious would be the implications of the discoveries...

kinematical analysis of 9/11 CNN videos is much more relevant because material accessible to everybody and reliable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom