Dave Rogers
Bandaged ice that stampedes inexpensively through
But in case of the photographs shown by Jones and co there is absolutely no ambiguity because the diameter of the spheroid is huge compared to the thickness of the chip so you could not have missed them at microscopy inspection before putting them in the DSC .
So i'm sorry to repeat again that their evidence is very strong (and i can see no possibility to ignore this) that it is indeed a reaction that melted iron and produced the microspheres.
The principal reason to ignore it is that you have tried and failed to replicate this specific result. What you're saying is that your samples, after reaction, contain microspheres that could have been present before reaction, and it's only Harrit et al's samples that contain microspheres that could not have. That's not a reason to believe Harrit et al's results, it's a reason to doubt them.
Impossible for a combustion with air oxygen of a micron sized particle to concentrate enough heat on it to melt iron.
And unnecessary. As you point out below, the microspheres are not pure iron, they contain oxygen. Have you quantified how much? Is there reason to suspect the presence of any free iron?
In your dreams!! iron oxyde and Aluminum react in this way if Alu is elemental, and nanoparticles of elemental Alu dont exist in nature: Al is always oxydized in surface bery fast, and for a 40nm particle, this surface is very soon the whole particle itself exposed to oxygen of the air
This is the only reason i see to really question the presence of a black ship among these truthers who may have falsified the data in order to decredibilize the whole study and i'm surprised that nobody has mentionned this issue here : how could elemental nanoAlu remain activate 7 years after 911: hardly possible without a very efficient coating according the studies i have read on the subject. Or storage in very dry and oxygen depleted conditions...
Neither of which can have happened for these samples. As you say, hardly possible.
This is where you are completely wrong for the obvious reasons i have just recalled
It is physically impossible for this conclusion to be wrong. The simple fact that the energy density is many times too great for a nanothermite reaction means that atmospheric combustion is the only possible source for at least the majority of the energy releaased.
several millimeters of thermite could heat any column by hundreds of degrees because the reaction is fast : so there is not enough time for the heat to escape, and the reaction is fast just because it does not need a huge volume of air around like a combustion.
Now that's just ridiculous. The law of conservation of energy doesn't have any loopholes. The energy output is the energy output; the only thing the speed of reaction can influence is the efficiency of the heat transfer, and that can't exceed 100%. For Harrit et al's chips to have had any significant effect, orders of magnitude more energy was needed. There's no source for that energy. And let's remember, we're not even talking about several millimeters - these chips are sub-millimeter in thickness. There is simply not enough energy, by orders of magnitude, and the speed of release won't change that.
1200 lbs of TNT divided by the volume of the fireball in the plane crash is still a ridiculous energy density as compared to xhat is needed to melt iron.
please learn what a density is!
Again, that's just ridiculous. A certain amount of steel has to be melted, in Jones's proto-hypothesis. Density is a secondary consideration; the absolute energy required for melting enough steel simply is not available.
Again sorry but i cannot find any way to avoid a thermitic reaction just from the evidence of molten iron spheroid production as shown in their photographs. This is crucial and conclusive even if all the rest of the article were not conclusive. And this is why , when i couldnt obtain the same reaction my first conclusion had to be that it is my chips that deactivated by heat or humidity or aging...because the only other way out of this would be to accuse the authors of complete falsification of their data!
The just follow your own lines of reasoning. You have two possibilities: either a thermite reaction occurred, or the data was falsified. You have failed to reproduce the evidence of a thermite reaction having occurred. Your reasoning suggests that a thermite reaction cannot have occurred, because the native oxide formation on aluminium nanoparticles would neutralise the reducing agent. Heat, humidity and ageing - be reasonable, these samples are supposed to have been still reactive after over eight years' storage in essentially uncontrolled conditions; any ageing that was going to occur has already occurred. Which is left as the more likely explanation?
Dave