Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

But in case of the photographs shown by Jones and co there is absolutely no ambiguity because the diameter of the spheroid is huge compared to the thickness of the chip so you could not have missed them at microscopy inspection before putting them in the DSC .
So i'm sorry to repeat again that their evidence is very strong (and i can see no possibility to ignore this) that it is indeed a reaction that melted iron and produced the microspheres.

The principal reason to ignore it is that you have tried and failed to replicate this specific result. What you're saying is that your samples, after reaction, contain microspheres that could have been present before reaction, and it's only Harrit et al's samples that contain microspheres that could not have. That's not a reason to believe Harrit et al's results, it's a reason to doubt them.

Impossible for a combustion with air oxygen of a micron sized particle to concentrate enough heat on it to melt iron.

And unnecessary. As you point out below, the microspheres are not pure iron, they contain oxygen. Have you quantified how much? Is there reason to suspect the presence of any free iron?

In your dreams!! iron oxyde and Aluminum react in this way if Alu is elemental, and nanoparticles of elemental Alu dont exist in nature: Al is always oxydized in surface bery fast, and for a 40nm particle, this surface is very soon the whole particle itself exposed to oxygen of the air

This is the only reason i see to really question the presence of a black ship among these truthers who may have falsified the data in order to decredibilize the whole study and i'm surprised that nobody has mentionned this issue here : how could elemental nanoAlu remain activate 7 years after 911: hardly possible without a very efficient coating according the studies i have read on the subject. Or storage in very dry and oxygen depleted conditions...

Neither of which can have happened for these samples. As you say, hardly possible.

This is where you are completely wrong for the obvious reasons i have just recalled

It is physically impossible for this conclusion to be wrong. The simple fact that the energy density is many times too great for a nanothermite reaction means that atmospheric combustion is the only possible source for at least the majority of the energy releaased.

several millimeters of thermite could heat any column by hundreds of degrees because the reaction is fast : so there is not enough time for the heat to escape, and the reaction is fast just because it does not need a huge volume of air around like a combustion.

Now that's just ridiculous. The law of conservation of energy doesn't have any loopholes. The energy output is the energy output; the only thing the speed of reaction can influence is the efficiency of the heat transfer, and that can't exceed 100%. For Harrit et al's chips to have had any significant effect, orders of magnitude more energy was needed. There's no source for that energy. And let's remember, we're not even talking about several millimeters - these chips are sub-millimeter in thickness. There is simply not enough energy, by orders of magnitude, and the speed of release won't change that.

1200 lbs of TNT divided by the volume of the fireball in the plane crash is still a ridiculous energy density as compared to xhat is needed to melt iron.
please learn what a density is!

Again, that's just ridiculous. A certain amount of steel has to be melted, in Jones's proto-hypothesis. Density is a secondary consideration; the absolute energy required for melting enough steel simply is not available.

Again sorry but i cannot find any way to avoid a thermitic reaction just from the evidence of molten iron spheroid production as shown in their photographs. This is crucial and conclusive even if all the rest of the article were not conclusive. And this is why , when i couldnt obtain the same reaction my first conclusion had to be that it is my chips that deactivated by heat or humidity or aging...because the only other way out of this would be to accuse the authors of complete falsification of their data!

The just follow your own lines of reasoning. You have two possibilities: either a thermite reaction occurred, or the data was falsified. You have failed to reproduce the evidence of a thermite reaction having occurred. Your reasoning suggests that a thermite reaction cannot have occurred, because the native oxide formation on aluminium nanoparticles would neutralise the reducing agent. Heat, humidity and ageing - be reasonable, these samples are supposed to have been still reactive after over eight years' storage in essentially uncontrolled conditions; any ageing that was going to occur has already occurred. Which is left as the more likely explanation?

Dave
 
The principal reason to ignore it is that you have tried and failed to replicate this specific result.
It's impossible to ignore because it's a clean result that is claimed with photos
to support it and there is no other way to explain this observation. On the other hand there are plenty of reasons that could explain why i failed,
for instance that my sample were collected two days after 9/11 and it rained in between.

And unnecessary. As you point out below, the microspheres are not pure iron, they contain oxygen. Have you quantified how much? Is there reason to suspect the presence of any free iron?
I found pure iron microspheres in my sample! and i have shown their spectra!
http://www.darksideofgravity.com/marseille_gb.pdf
Notice that even when a pure iron microsphere is produced it must reoxydize very fast at high temperature before it is completely cooled if it is not in an oxygen depleted environment! so my own observations support that not only pure iron microspheres were generated but also that they appeared in an oxygen depleted air (thermobarics can consume all the oxygen for instance) where they could cool and remain pure iron.

Now that's just ridiculous. The law of conservation of energy doesn't have any loopholes. The energy output is the energy output; the only thing the speed of reaction can influence is the efficiency of the heat transfer, and that can't exceed 100%. For Harrit et al's chips to have had any significant effect, orders of magnitude more energy was needed. There's no source for that energy. And let's remember, we're not even talking about several millimeters - these chips are sub-millimeter in thickness. There is simply not enough energy, by orders of magnitude, and the speed of release won't change that.
Density is a secondary consideration; the absolute energy required for melting enough steel simply is not available.
Dave

Did you perform the computation? i did it a long time ago

At 100% efficiency:

- The reaction of a volume V of coil (carbon) produces the energy to heat and melt ~ 10V of iron (79kJ/cc released. 7.8kJ/cc needed to heat and melt the iron: (470 J/(°C.kg) x 1500°C + 270000J/kg) x 8000/1O^6 kg/cc)

But each C atom requires one O2 from the air hence a volume V of Carbon needs
32/12 (molar masses ratio ) times 2267/1.43 (density ratio) times 5 (20% oxygen in the air) = ~ 20000 V of air.

Hence when a small organic particle burns in the air the energy is released slowly in a huge volume hence a small particle of iron in its vicinity (volume V also) can only receive a ridiculous fraction of this heat energy ~ 1/20000. Impossible to reach the melting point with that.

- The reaction of a volume V of Thermite produces enough energy to melt ~ 2V of Iron. 16kJ/cc for thermite ~ 5x less than carbon...
BUT this heat is released entirely and fastly in the small volume V. This is why a micron size particle of thermite could melt iron in contact with it and nothing burning in the air in the DSC could do that!

Actually at the WTC, thermite was only needed to insure the heating effect that the jet fuel fires couldnt produce: soften the steel columns at the floors of the impact, not necessarily melt them!

One volume V of Thermite can heat 8V of steel by 500°C at 100% efficiency.
and 4V of steel at a more reasonable efficiency of 50%. So you just need to apply a thermite layer which has approximately 1/4 the steel thickness of any column to do the job. Thus 2 millimeters would be enough for all steel columns at the impacted floors.

The chips are very thin but there are photos strongly suggesting that the thermite was applied in a multilayered red/grey/red/grey.... that could reach millimeters in total thickness.... so sorry again but i really see no problem with this scenario.

F H-C
 
As for the iron rich microspheres and the idea that it could be due to fly ash:
The articles

http://www.flyash.info/2005/200fan.pdf
http://www.tfhrc.gov/hnr20/recycle/waste/cfa51.htm
http://igs.indiana.edu/Geology/coalOilGas/flyAshProperties/index.cfm


describe hollow iron oxide spheres.

In the RJ Lee group report from 2003,

http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q...3tOv6p&sig=AHIEtbTkaw08t-NYMaqCj9FdpiLnHUXQ0A

they found 5.87 % solid iron spheres (see XEDS) in the WTC dust, while 0.04 is what you expect in "normal" buildings (Table 3).

This confirms what i also observed: the fraction of these microspheres is huge!!
and the report concludes: WTC dust and normal background dust have different sources.
 
henryco:

As David said, henry, the fact that you COULD NOT reproduce their results, should be reason to doubt the validity of THEIR RESULTS, not make the ridiculous and much less likely assumption that of the sample you received, ALL OF THE CHIPS had already reacted.

To do so is not only bizarre and unscientific, but seriously makes me question whether you allowing your views on the 9/11 attacks cloud your judgement.

TAM:)
 
As for the iron rich microspheres and the idea that it could be due to fly ash:
The articles

http://www.flyash.info/2005/200fan.pdf
http://www.tfhrc.gov/hnr20/recycle/waste/cfa51.htm
http://igs.indiana.edu/Geology/coalOilGas/flyAshProperties/index.cfm


describe hollow iron oxide spheres.
Only the first article describes hollow iron oxide spheres, with very little data to back it up. I don't doubt that, given the way that the materials are formed, some of the spheres will trap air. However, the idea that fly ash is composed of only hollow iron oxide spheres is preposterous. It's worth remembering also:
1) If the sphere shell is sufficiently thick, backscattered electron imaging and secondary electron imaging alone are not enough to determine if it's hollow.
2) Optical methods for particle sizing and morphology (including petrographic methods) aren't able to determine if the particles are hollow.
In the RJ Lee group report from 2003,

http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q...3tOv6p&sig=AHIEtbTkaw08t-NYMaqCj9FdpiLnHUXQ0A

they found 5.87 % solid iron spheres (see XEDS) in the WTC dust,
It would be incredibly difficult to determine from XEDS if a particle is hollow (unless the shell is only a few nanometers thick) or solid. RJ Lee group is likely making an assumption, and given their vast experience with particle analysis, I'd be more likely to trust their analysis.
while 0.04 is what you expect in "normal" buildings (Table 3).

This confirms what i also observed: the fraction of these microspheres is huge!!
You do understand that the difference between a normal building and the WTC towers is that the WTC towers were on fire, right? The dust Jones tested is actually a combination of dust and ash, and, as the RJ Lee report notes, iron oxide spheres are a component of common dust. Ash, on the other hand, has a significantly higher concentration of iron because iron bearing compounds don't combust easily.
[/quote]
and the report concludes: WTC dust and normal background dust have different sources.[/quote]
Yes, and the plume that carried the material to Jones's source mixed the two together.
 
they found 5.87 % solid iron spheres (see XEDS) in the WTC dust, while 0.04 is what you expect in "normal" buildings (Table 3).

This confirms what i also observed: the fraction of these microspheres is huge!!
and the report concludes: WTC dust and normal background dust have different sources.

So?

What is your point? Of course the WTC dust is different from regular background dust.

What is your claim as to the significance of this?
 
This confirms what i also observed: the fraction of these microspheres is huge!!
and the report concludes: WTC dust and normal background dust have different sources.


Just to add:

You seem to be making that comparison of the fraction of fly ash in the WTC dust to the fraction in background dust to claim that the fraction in the WTC dust is not “normal.”

This is just silly. Of course the fraction of fly ash in the WTC dust is higher that normal dust. The WTC dust resulted from huge fires and the building collapses. These are not “normal” conditions at all. The whole reason for the comparison in the report was to categorize the signature components of WTC dust. The fact that these components differ from normal dust don’t signify anything other than the WTC dust was generated by huge fires and building collapses.
 
they found 5.87 % solid iron spheres (see XEDS) in the WTC dust, while 0.04 is what you expect in "normal" buildings (Table 3).


What was "normal" about the WTC Towers and the way they were destroyed?:confused:
 
Your confirmation bias is showing. We're discussing the presence of a substance which is known to combust in a standard atmosphere at 430ºC, so we know the stuff is flammable. You can't reject candidates for the identity of a flammable substance because they're flammable.

I get your point, Dave. Fair enough. The uncontroversial point I'm getting at is that given what we know about this substance, (its characteristics and abundance in the WTC dust), it's just not likely some electronics parts.

If you recall, your original claim was in response to the USGS particulate info and stats yearbook about ferrofluids being used to make computer disk drives. This stuff is clearly NOT from a computer disk drive. Have we ruled out all the possibilities in electronics? No. Have we narrowed down the probability that it's computer parts? Yes. How? Abundance and characteristics.

And you also can't reject candidates because they're not used in construction, industrial paints or corrosion protection.

Can we rule out nuclear magnetic resonance imaging contrast media? I think so. What about manufacturing processes that use ferrofluids? Yes. What about end products of ferrofluids? Not impossible, but not very likely.

What about the other main use cited in that USGS report: CATALYSTS. Could this substance be a puropsefully-designed reactive material? Yes, it's possible. The relative uniformity of the iron oxide suggests a use which takes advantage of the high surface area-to-mass properties afforded by such small particles.

When compared with Xerogel, (fig. 29, pg. 25), the fast reaction is remarkable--even in comparison to a known nano-energetic composite. That characteristic is enough to cement the theory that this stuff is indeed some kind of highly processed incendiary/explosive. If you give up the ludicrous idea that heating these chips is condensing dust into iron and silicate microspheres, then it becomes very likely that this stuff is evidence of pre-planted explosives in the WTC buildings.

Anything used in IT is likely to have been present in the towers in significant quantities, and you also have to consider anything else that might be present in an office building. We are not talking about large quantities of material here.

How are you claiming we aren't talking about large quantities of material here? It's been found in 4 different samples from 4 different locations. Apparently, there is a lot of this material in the dust.

I think you're trying too hard to ignore any possibilities you don't like.

Dave

And I think you are eager to consider the lower probability theories over higher probability theories as long as they don't infer the possibility of incendiary or explosive materials in the WTC dust.

All we ever have is evidence and probability. I don't "like" the IT parts theory because at this point in time, there isn't a good contender material in electronics that has the properties of the red/gray chips. If you can think of any, let's compare it.

In the meantime, the best theory is the one that explains the most evidence and doesn't have to ignore any phenomena. Right now, that theoy is that the red/gray chips are some kind of nano-energetic composite material.

.
 
You remember when you linked to the USGS Iron Oxide Pigments Statistics and Information as if it provided a definitive answer to the question "is paint composed of 100 nm iron oxide particles?" Your link was supposed to be the case closer--verifying for God and everyone that these particles were indeed, not unusual for building materials. But here's what the 2008 USGS Minerals Yearbook for Iron Oxide actually said:
Did the minerals yearbook claim that the only use for Iron Oxide was computer disk drives? The answer to the, again, rather asinine question of whether or not iron oxide is used in pigments and coatings is yes. The answer to the question of particle size can be found in the following texts available from your local university library:

Outlines of Paint Technology, Volume 1: Materials (1982) W. M. Morgans
Page 26 notes that particle size distributions for paints and pigments ranging from 100 nm to 300 nm. It also suggests methods for determining particle sizes in pigments.

Chemistry of Pigments and Fillers (1983) D. H. Solomon and D. G. Hawthorne
Page 301 shows the particle size range for a pigment known as "Pure Yellow Oxide". The accompanying micrograph (figure 7) shows the particle size range, which is also shown in the table above. The listed particle size range is 100 nm to 1.5 µm.

Pigments: An Introduction to their Physical Chemistry (1967) D. Patterson (ed)
Page 100 identifies several variants of iron oxide pigments and notes "[...] iron oxides with particles of 0.1 µm or less are used as transparent colorants."
Not a word about construction materials
Concrete Admixtures Handbook: Properties, Science and Technology (1984) V.S. Ramachandran (ed)
Page 316, in the section on fly ash notes, as point (iii), "Magnetite and hematite occur as opaque spheres in high-iron fly ashes." Further, the author of the section sites G.L. Fisher et al in Environmental Science and Technology (1978). Fisher's paper notes that the smaller particles tend to be opaque and spherical according to light microscopy.
or industrial paints or corrosion protection. And this is not surprising considering the difficulty involved in manufacturing uniform 100nm particles.
The above references should show, beyond any reasonable doubt, that not only were such technologies available in the late 1960's, but that the use and manufacture of iron oxide particles for use as pigments has been common in industry for the last 50 years.
True. And all we ever have is the evidence. And the evidence is clear that this material is NOT paint nor some industrial building material nor is it computer parts and we can pretty much rule out nuclear magnetic resonance imaging contrast.
The references above will show this claim false.
So, if you are making the claim that this stuff is paint
Pigment.
, YOU are now the one in the position to back that claim up with evidence. Let's see how that goes:
We need only to look at the authorship of the paper to determine who the claimant is. It is up to the author to reduce or eliminate through evidence and robust statistical analysis any possible confounding variables, however trivial they may seem.
Really!? You don't accept mutually corroborative BSE, SE, photomicrograph images, XEDS graphs and corresponding maps, but you can look at a photograph of peeling paint, read a description and that's "case closed" for you?!
The data I linked to earlier is an example of a pigment/industrial coating, made of iron oxide (among other materials) in a ceramic matrix comprised of alumina and silica. Jones has provided evidence of a pigment/industrial material, made of faceted iron oxide in a matrix of alumina and silica. Why should we not eliminate this material, said to coat the beams of every major structural element in the WTC, from consideration as the source material of the sample analyzed by Jones?
And again, you assume a "confident manner" by linking to something that makes reference to iron oxide particles used in pigments. Do you have some info that shows Fe2O3 particle sizes in paint pigments are 100nm? No, but that doesn't stop you from claiming certainty on that question.
McCrone's particle atlas does have such data, but it is unfair to demand that you purchase a $600 license in order to confirm that I am correct. The references I have listed should be available at your nearest university library free of cost.
Not only have you and everyone else failed to bring any evidence whatsoever to bear on the plausibility that this substance is some building material, the publication you cite references several uses of nanoscale iron oxide,[...]
Plausibility cannot be ascertained by either party. The provenance of the sample is in doubt. A better, and more interesting question, is, "What evidence does Jones bring to show that this material was a thermite coating applied to the steel in the WTC towers in order to heat the structure past the point of stability and cause the towers to collapse?" The answer, of course, is none.
The SE image you cite in the McCrone Atlas has a 1 um reference bar at the bottom, so clearly, that doesn't even come close to the scale of iron oxide particles in the red/gray chips. And yet, you cite it as if it "finally shut down this silly conversation." It's just not necessary to get the particles so small and uniform in pigment applications.
The top of page 100 in the Pigments book (see above) notes, "The hues of most of the colored inorganic pigments are determined not only by their molecular compositions, but also on particle size and crystalline form." Further down the page, it notes, "The color dependence on average particle size is illustrated by the dominant wavelength of magnetite, which changes from 600 nm to 635 nm as the particles increase [...]"

Interestingly, it appears that magnetite, along with other iron oxide pigments, appears to have a size dependency on fluoresced wavelength. So, it seems that, when iron oxides are used as a pigment, size control and separation are of paramount importance.

Will you please read what you're citing before you link to it? Or do you just like to pretend you've "closed the case" on all this business?

.
I believe the above linked references and information will close the case.
 
Out of curiosity, I just stirred a magnet through the ashes of my wood fireplace, left over from a wood fire 72 hours ago. Can anyone tell me what all the shiny round ferromagnetic particles about 10-50 microns in diameter I'm finding are, and where they came from? (I live in a wood-framed house, and to my knowledge neither welding nor thermite reactions have ever occurred therein.)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Just to add:

You seem to be making that comparison of the fraction of fly ash in the WTC dust to the fraction in background dust to claim that the fraction in the WTC dust is not “normal.”

This is just silly. Of course the fraction of fly ash in the WTC dust is higher that normal dust. The WTC dust resulted from huge fires and the building collapses. These are not “normal” conditions at all. The whole reason for the comparison in the report was to categorize the signature components of WTC dust. The fact that these components differ from normal dust don’t signify anything other than the WTC dust was generated by huge fires and building collapses.

I dont understand how the large concentration of iron rich microspheres at WTC could be correlated to the WTC fires because the fires at WTC could not reach the iron melting point.

On the other hand i was ready to accept that these iron microspheres had their source in the fly ash used as a material in the production of concrete:
these would have been part of the concrete from the begining but the data from normal building dust and WTC dust before 911, clearly shows that their concentration from this source only should be very small, much smaller than observed! Right ?

if a normal fire can indeed produce iron microspheres as someone suggested in this thread, please explain to me how this can be ...

Fred
 
i forgot to make clear in my previous post that i can understand why the fly ash from a metal furnace has iron microspheres: just because the temperature of the burning coal there is over 1500°C the melting point of Fe. Whis was not the case in the WTC fires.
 
If you recall, your original claim was in response to the USGS particulate info and stats yearbook about ferrofluids being used to make computer disk drives. This stuff is clearly NOT from a computer disk drive. Have we ruled out all the possibilities in electronics? No. Have we narrowed down the probability that it's computer parts? Yes. How? Abundance and characteristics.



Can we rule out nuclear magnetic resonance imaging contrast media? I think so. What about manufacturing processes that use ferrofluids? Yes.

I'm just going to focus on this particular point, because you're still working from an unsourced assumption. The original quote was that one use of ferrofluids was in computer magnetic disc media. At no point was it suggested that ferrofluids are only used in the manufacture of computer discs and that no part of the ferrofluid remains in the final product; this is entirely your interpretation, and is not backed up by any source that anyone has produced. Since small magnetic iron oxide particles are well known to be used in magnetic recording media, your insistence that small magnetic iron oxide particles cannot possibly be found in magnetic recording media, based on a source that gives magnetic recording media as a major use for ferrofluids that contain iron oxide nanoparticles, is completely indefensible.

Let me remind you that the relevant part of the original quote was, "Uses for ferrofluids include computer disc drives". Computer disc drives are, rather obviously, an application where particle size control is important, so we could expect well-controlled particle size, magnetic iron oxide in them. Therefore,without more data on absolute abundance in the debris, this is a source we cannot eliminate.

Dave
 
Eventually, even the samples that was collected hundred meters away from the WTC soon after the destruction, show this huge amount of iron microspheres, whereas the fires only affected a small number of floors before collapse and i would not expect even the total weight of sue to be in any way comparable to the total weight of concrete and gypsum that was pulverised in the "collapse". So the ~ percent in weight of iron microspheres in the WTC dust we all find in our samples is incredible ! not at all related to the quantity the fires could release even if their temp had been over 1500°C.
 
i forgot to make clear in my previous post that i can understand why the fly ash from a metal furnace has iron microspheres: just because the temperature of the burning coal there is over 1500°C the melting point of Fe. Whis was not the case in the WTC fires.

Concrete often contains fly ash so the temp at the WTC fire is quite possibly irrelevant as to whether or not it is in the WTC dust.
Then again you do not know for certain that what you had even was WTC dust.
Its just something Jones et al sent you.
 
Eventually, even the samples that was collected hundred meters away from the WTC soon after the destruction, show this huge amount of iron microspheres, whereas the fires only affected a small number of floors before collapse and i would not expect even the total weight of sue to be in any way comparable to the total weight of concrete and gypsum that was pulverised in the "collapse". So the ~ percent in weight of iron microspheres in the WTC dust we all find in our samples is incredible ! not at all related to the quantity the fires could release even if their temp had been over 1500°C.

Have you contacted these people (John K McGee, Lung Chi Chen, Mitchell D Cohen, Glen R Chee, Colette M Prophete, Najwa Haykal-Coates, Shirley J Wasson, Teri L Conner, Daniel L Costa, and Stephen H Gavett), who are LEGITIMATE SCIENTISTS in the field, who also conducted analysis of WTC dust, to see (A) what they think of your conclusions, (B) what they make of the microspheres, and (C) what their results were?

For C, you can go read their paper here,

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1241534/pdf/ehp0111-000972.pdf

WARNING, above is a PDF.

I see nothing in their conclusions that idicates surprise at iron content, or anything suspicious...care to comment?

TAM:)
 
On the other hand i was ready to accept that these iron microspheres had their source in the fly ash used as a material in the production of concrete:
these would have been part of the concrete from the begining but the data from normal building dust and WTC dust before 911, clearly shows that their concentration from this source only should be very small, much smaller than observed! Right ?

You're obviously referring to the RJ Lee report. As you noted, that data from normal building dust was for structures that were standing prior to 9/11 and had therefore not collapsed. Now remember, after the towers fell there was a higher concentration of dust everywhere, definitely far higher than was present beforehand. Post collapse photos alone establishes this. There being a higher amount of microspheres due to this is a logical extention of that fact. The collapse produced orders of magnitude more dust, and given that microspheres were a normal component of the dust, there would obviously be more microspheres present too. So ruling out concrete and other sources due to pre-collapse measurements of their amounts is turning logic on it's head; the fact that the concentrations were less prior to collapse is a perfect indicator that they were liberated by the collapse of the towers, and therefore had come from the same sources that they did prior to collapse.
 
Bump. I'd like to see an answer to this.

Out of curiosity, I just stirred a magnet through the ashes of my wood fireplace, left over from a wood fire 72 hours ago. Can anyone tell me what all the shiny round ferromagnetic particles about 10-50 microns in diameter I'm finding are, and where they came from? (I live in a wood-framed house, and to my knowledge neither welding nor thermite reactions have ever occurred therein.)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Bump. I'd like to see an answer to this.

Might try a log fire this weekend and try that experiment myself:). How much wood was there in the WTC towers, were walls, metal or wood studs for example? All those wall street executive wood desks alone........:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom