Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Jay I applaud your attempt (at least very recently) to maintain a sense of skeptic necessity around this paper. That said, if you are honest in this, you must, MUST admit that the numerous methodological errors in the study, combined with insufficient documentation (from a forensic pov) on chain of custody, and the inadequate testing in an O2 free environment, makes the results of the analysis (outside of a passing "hmmm that is interesting") unusable.

If anything, you should (if you truly believe they are ON TO SOMETHING) be leading the way in calling for them to fix all the errors, submit their samples for independent testing, and make the appropriate adjustments...so, are you???

TAM:)


That's appreciated. I get a little snippy like everyone else, but mostly try to keep it focused on the issue.

There are most certainly a couple of problems with the paper. I agree they should've used a more relevant paint sample for comparison. There are some here who dispute the XEDS data because they say it wasn't done in the right circumstances to rule out a misinterpretation of the peaks. This is certainly possible, however, it must be weighed against the probability of a false negative for these particular peaks and against the likelihood of producing iron and silicate spheres as a by-product.

As for the chain of custody, we've been through this before: these samples had to come from someone. These people have provided the samples gave their names for this paper. And like the other problems with the evidence, the morphological comparison appears to make any problems in the chain of custody moot because they show, by several methods, the same substance in all the samples.

Unless the HFJ crew is simply lying, the comparative analysis leaves little doubt that these chips were indeed found in the WTC dust.

And yes, I do believe they need to look further and harder and use different solvents and different paint samples for comparison. Dr. Jones said recently that they sent off samples to 3 labs for XRF analysis. One lab couldn't do it because the chips were too small but they're waiting on the other two. Dr. Farrer has apparently done TEM analysis on the iron particles and determined from the electron diffraction patterns that they are definitely Fe2O3. So this is a work in progress. They believe they are on to something significant. I believe this evidence is strong and getting stronger the more work is done on it. Time and effort will tell, but at this point, there is little reason NOT to look further and harder.

.
 
Cement/Concrete

In Denmark and the US flyash has been and is used as a filler in cement/concrete. In US for more than 50 years. In Denmark since 1978.
Up to 30% in the cement.
Varies in size from 1-20 micron
It contains all the elements Harrit has found.

Here is a SEM-image og flyash.
That should set you mind in gear.

The big question is: Did they use flyash as a filler in paint as the primer used on WTC in the 70's.?

Today they use it in paint.

The binder is resin and turbentine. 85 % of the turbentine evaporates in a few hours.


I am not allowed to use URLs so

Google SEM flyash and then choose pictures.

Here is Harrits iron-rich spheres.
 
Elemental Al

Does not exist outside a lab

Elemental Al exposed in air/oxygen forms a passivation layer in 100 picoseconds

Aluminium Oxide: melting point 2072 degrees C.

React at 430 deg. C.: No way!

It takes Magnesium to start a reaction.
 
At what point should one say "hhmmm... this stuff is a little bit strange. Maybe not evidence of an inside job, but strange nonetheless. We should investigate further."?

At the point where either (a) there is at least the vaguest possibility that further investigation may lead to useful knowledge or (b) there is nothing else worth doing with one's time and money. At the moment, the status quo is that, among the vast miscellany of debris collected from the collapse of a large building with almost unimaginably diverse contents, someone has managed to isolate a trivially small amount of material whose precise identity appears to be in some minor doubt. Nobody has proposed, or been able despite considerable effort to propose, a hypothesis in which this material does not fall short by several orders of magnitude of being in any way significant to anything. There is, as you suggest, a threshold for taking a vague interest in any anomalies. The material identified falls so far short of this threshold that any serious scientist in a relevant field would be wasting their time doing anything beyond pointing out the appalling level of incompetence shown by the authors of the paper.

Dave
 
There are most certainly a couple of problems with the paper.

Admit it, there are many many problems with the paper.


I agree they should've used a more relevant paint sample for comparison.

They should have looked at multiple other possibilities, they only looked at one, the paint from the BYU LaVell Edwards Stadium. We don't even know the make of the paint in question or when it was applied.

There are some here who dispute the XEDS data because they say it wasn't done in the right circumstances to rule out a misinterpretation of the peaks. This is certainly possible, however, it must be weighed against the probability of a false negative for these particular peaks and against the likelihood of producing iron and silicate spheres as a by-product.

So either way it was inconclusive.

As for the chain of custody, we've been through this before: these samples had to come from someone. These people have provided the samples gave their names for this paper. And like the other problems with the evidence, the morphological comparison appears to make any problems in the chain of custody moot because they show, by several methods, the same substance in all the samples.

They all passed through Jones hands, a known 911 CTer so they have no provenance. he could have added anything he liked to them and nobody would know. He will not let anyone outside the Truthers have samples and will not have them independently tested. Jones testing for Thermite was like having a priest investigate child abuse in the RC Church.

Unless the HFJ crew is simply lying, the comparative analysis leaves little doubt that these chips were indeed found in the WTC dust.

Only Jones has to be lying as he did the testing and he had access to the samples. Most of the rest just put their names on the paper as they are unqualified to do anything else. The alternative is that thousands of people are lying about 911 and the death of thousands. Jones could just be lying to make money and a name for himself after a pathetic wasted career. Which do you consider more likely?

And yes, I do believe they need to look further and harder and use different solvents and different paint samples for comparison. Dr. Jones said recently that they sent off samples to 3 labs for XRF analysis. One lab couldn't do it because the chips were too small but they're waiting on the other two.

I'm not holding my breath :D

Dr. Farrer has apparently done TEM analysis on the iron particles and determined from the electron diffraction patterns that they are definitely Fe2O3.

ie rust :eek::jaw-dropp:rolleyes::boggled::eye-poppi:covereyes:shocked::yikes::gasp:

So this is a work in progress. They believe they are on to something significant. I believe this evidence is strong and getting stronger the more work is done on it. Time and effort will tell, but at this point, there is little reason NOT to look further and harder.

You are in complete denial! THERE IS NO EVIDENCE at all let alone strong evidence of anything other than gross incompetence and/or Fraud.

They should retract the paper (can you do that from a vanity journal?:)) and arrange for competent independent tests on samples of good provenance. Nothing else would be acceptable as proof in any court of law.

I'm not a betting man but I think its a fairly safe bet that they will never do that.
 
tsig

Elemental Al becomes Al2O3 instantly when exposed to air.
Soaking it in MEK-solution: Nothing happens, not even when heated.

So the italian is wrong when he says it can react more or less violent.

MEK (acetone) did not dissolve anything because the binder is resin and turpentine. (I think)

Resin (solid) is dissolved by alcohol:cool:
 
Yes, Dave. I'm well aware of using iron oxide as the active layer in memory devices. And I share your suspicions that the chips may be too abundant to be accounted for as computer components. Not only that, but they do not appear to be any kind of electronics component whatsoever.

At what point should one say "hhmmm... this stuff is a little bit strange. Maybe not evidence of an inside job, but strange nonetheless. We should investigate further."?

.

good question.

AT what point should one say "hhmmmm.... this paper is riddled with methodological errors, has bad controls and makes wildly unfounded claims. Maybe we should throw it out and start over?"

Huh?
 
There are most certainly a couple of problems with the paper.
.

wow.

It only took you 10 pages and about 2 months to finally agree with this.

Now lets take it one step further.

Will you agree that this "paper" is riddled with methodological errors? Not differences in intepretation, but actual ERRORS. Yes or no?

So either you have answered
A. Yes
or
B. No.

If A then read
Kothari, C.R. Research Methodology: Methods and Techniques
(WileyEastern,NewDelhi,1985).

Saravanavel P. Research Methodology
(KitabMa-hal,Allahabad,1987).

Both are excellent and show why you need proper methodology.

If B then please explain away the 20 methodological errors that have been pointed out in this thread and in the parent thread and explain how those are not "errors."
 
Elemental Al becomes Al2O3 instantly when exposed to air.
Soaking it in MEK-solution: Nothing happens, not even when heated.

So the italian is wrong when he says it can react more or less violent.

MEK (acetone) did not dissolve anything because the binder is resin and turpentine. (I think)

Resin (solid) is dissolved by alcohol:cool:

I hate to say this, but: MEK (otherwise known as butanone) is not acetone. They're both ketones, but acetone is (CH3)2CO, whereas butanone is CH3C(O)CH2CH3.

On top of that, butanone does work as a solvent for some resins.

That said, I've always felt that the MEK "test" that led them to claim it wasn't paint was weak. Butanone is indeed a component of many paint removers, but it's hardly a universal one. I'd have to hit the search function to find that old post, but there's a whole class of paints that would not dissolve in butanone.
 
It is unfortunate that you see the debate that way. Please allow me to remind you what you said:

The answer to this rather asinine question is, yes. Your attempt to move the debate from the relevant to the irrelevant by not addressing my comments directly has not furthered your argument.

More importantly, iron oxide spheres are used in a variety of lubricants and coatings and they are a common component of a dozen different building materials, including concrete, fly ash and inks, paints, stains and dyes. The point is that you, along with Steven Jones and everyone else who believes this nonsense, seem to think that there's something amazing about finding iron oxide in dust and ash. The detritus of a flaming, collapsing building was blown into a residential area and collected haphazardly with no deference to cross contamination issues. The source material is dust and ash, the chips and question are far more likely to be a coating applied to the structural steel in the towers.


So you believe this material is paint or some coating? Then it shouldn't be very hard to track down this coating for comparison. Put your skepticism to a real test: find some paint/protective coating that when dried and and heated, will ignite at 430C and produce iron and silicate spheres.

Find some paint/coating that is composed of relatively uniform 100 nm iron oxide particles. Demonstrate this "condensing of dust" into iron and silicate microspheres that you spoke of earlier. If you're really sticking that out there as a plausible explanation, then this can be confirmed or falsified--not just taken as a given.

I take it as a given that in industrial furnaces, particles can liquefy and condense into microspheres, but it is most certainly NOT a given that this is common or expected for the WTC dust under relatively much cooler temperatures.

Again, if you're relying on that claim in order to posit that the microspheres observed after heating of the chips was NOT a product of the chips, then you should be able to produce something other than your word or making reference to fly ash to support that.

.
 
So you believe this material is paint or some coating? Then it shouldn't be very hard to track down this coating for comparison.
no, No, NO, NO. Bad truther. It is called Burden of proof. The common narrative says that 19 hijackers took over four jets and crashed three into buildings and a field in pennslyvania. The towers burned and collapsed, the burning towers damaged wtc7 and caused fires to start which ultimately led to wtc7's collapse.

Now, you are the one making the extraordinary claims of explosives, nanothermite, thermite, government conspiracies. YOu need to PROVE that what you claim is NOT paint, coating, disk drive parts.

In order to do that you need to ELIMINATE any possible other source. Have you done that? Nope. Try again.


Put your skepticism to a real test: find some paint/protective coating that when dried and and heated, will ignite at 430C and produce iron and silicate spheres.

Nope. Not my burden. Since this "paper" failed to have proper controls and is riddle with methodological errors, anything and everything in it is invalid. Please try again with proper methodology and controls.

Find some paint/coating that is composed of relatively uniform 100 nm iron oxide particles. Demonstrate this "condensing of dust" into iron and silicate microspheres that you spoke of earlier. If you're really sticking that out there as a plausible explanation, then this can be confirmed or falsified--not just taken as a given.

Not my job. I"m not making the extraordinary claims. So admit this is junk (I know how heavily you have invested in it... but it is crap. so hvae them scrap it and start over. Do it right)

I take it as a given that in industrial furnaces, particles can liquefy and condense into microspheres, but it is most certainly NOT a given that this is common or expected for the WTC dust under relatively much cooler temperatures.

Again, if you're relying on that claim in order to posit that the microspheres observed after heating of the chips was NOT a product of the chips, then you should be able to produce something other than your word or making reference to fly ash to support that.

.
blah blah blah.

What part of bad methodology invalidates any findings do you not understand?
 
Elemental Al becomes Al2O3 instantly when exposed to air.
Soaking it in MEK-solution: Nothing happens, not even when heated.

This patent says otherwise.
http://www.freepatentsonline.com/3890166.html

As stated I'm not a Chem Eng but the MEK did have a lasting affect on the milled Al. or the oxide coating that forms on it that just milling in Hexane did not.

So the italian is wrong when he says it can react more or less violent.

The Patent says otherwise.

MEK (acetone) did not dissolve anything because the binder is resin and turpentine. (I think)

Resin (solid) is dissolved by alcohol:cool:

The choice of trying only one solvent always struck me as strange and but perhaps it was just incompetence and chance that made that one choice MEK.
 
There are most certainly a couple of problems with the paper. .

And do you know what the biggest problem is? The entire enterprise is an attempt to rationalize a pre-conceived belief. Personally, I see it as just another truther stalling tactic. If they can get people to focus long enough on this one piece of the puzzle, then they can (for a while, at least) make people forget that they only have ten ragged, bent, and broken pieces in a 1000-piece set.

Meanwhile the puzzle representing the so-called "official story" was completed eight years ago. It helps when you use actual pieces and not imaginary ones.
 
So you believe this material is paint or some coating?
My beliefs are irrelevant. I have correctly pointed out that there are insufficient data to eliminate any one of the hundreds (if not thousands) of paints, coatings, inks, stains, pigments, dyes or building materials present in the WTC on 9/11.

That's the problem with science. If you want to eliminate a confounding variable from the results, you have to show evidence. The burden of proof is on the claimant, not the critic.
Then it shouldn't be very hard to track down this coating for comparison. Put your skepticism to a real test: find some paint/protective coating that when dried and and heated, will ignite at 430C and produce iron and silicate spheres.
Done
See page 442. Look familiar? Read page 433. It identifies the paint applied to the steel beams as essentially a ceramic in an organic matrix. The pigment was iron oxide and other oxides added for color.
Case closed.

Find some paint/coating that is composed of relatively uniform 100 nm iron oxide particles.
McCrone Particle Atlas
Done.
Don't have access to the McCrone particle atlas? It costs about $600 per year, and is invaluable as a research tool for people serious about doing analysis of dust, ash and particles in general.
 
The choice of trying only one solvent always struck me as strange and but perhaps it was just incompetence and chance that made that one choice MEK.

It's liquid model airplane glue. Maybe that was the only solvent they could find. It would be in keeping with the general level of competence displayed.

Dave
 
My beliefs are irrelevant. I have correctly pointed out that there are insufficient data to eliminate any one of the hundreds (if not thousands) of paints, coatings, inks, stains, pigments, dyes or building materials present in the WTC on 9/11.


You remember when you linked to the USGS Iron Oxide Pigments Statistics and Information as if it provided a definitive answer to the question "is paint composed of 100 nm iron oxide particles?" Your link was supposed to be the case closer--verifying for God and everyone that these particles were indeed, not unusual for building materials. But here's what the 2008 USGS Minerals Yearbook for Iron Oxide actually said:
USGS Iron Oxide Pigments Statistics and Information said:
Potential uses for nanosized (less than 0.1 micron or 100 nanometers) iron oxide particles include catalysts and
ferrofluids. Uses for ferrofluids include computer disk drives and high-performance loud speakers; other applications are in biology and medicine, including nuclear magnetic resonance imaging (Vollath, 2008, p. 2, 5).


Not a word about construction materials or industrial paints or corrosion protection. And this is not surprising considering the difficulty involved in manufacturing uniform 100nm particles. When this is pointed out, Dave replies that "yes, it's a possibility that the red/grey chips are fragments of computer disc drives, but I suspect they're a little too abundant in the dust samples."

And a little too flammable too, I suspect. But I don't suppose the lack of substance behind your "certainty" will stop you from claiming it once again.


That's the problem with science. If you want to eliminate a confounding variable from the results, you have to show evidence. The burden of proof is on the claimant, not the critic.


True. And all we ever have is the evidence. And the evidence is clear that this material is NOT paint nor some industrial building material nor is it computer parts and we can pretty much rule out nuclear magnetic resonance imaging contrast.

So, if you are making the claim that this stuff is paint, YOU are now the one in the position to back that claim up with evidence. Let's see how that goes:


Done
See page 442. Look familiar? Read page 433. It identifies the paint applied to the steel beams as essentially a ceramic in an organic matrix. The pigment was iron oxide and other oxides added for color.
Case closed.


Really!? You don't accept mutually corroborative BSE, SE, photomicrograph images, XEDS graphs and corresponding maps, but you can look at a photograph of peeling paint, read a description and that's "case closed" for you?!

Your standards of evidence are, well... exceptional. And I mean that. You make strange and inconsistent exceptions as to what does and does not count as evidence.


McCrone Particle Atlas
Done.
Don't have access to the McCrone particle atlas? It costs about $600 per year, and is invaluable as a research tool for people serious about doing analysis of dust, ash and particles in general.

And again, you assume a "confident manner" by linking to something that makes reference to iron oxide particles used in pigments. Do you have some info that shows Fe2O3 particle sizes in paint pigments are 100nm? No, but that doesn't stop you from claiming certainty on that question.

Not only have you and everyone else failed to bring any evidence whatsoever to bear on the plausibility that this substance is some building material, the publication you cite references several uses of nanoscale iron oxide, none of which include any construction materials.

The SE image you cite in the McCrone Atlas has a 1 um reference bar at the bottom, so clearly, that doesn't even come close to the scale of iron oxide particles in the red/gray chips. And yet, you cite it as if it "finally shut down this silly conversation." It's just not necessary to get the particles so small and uniform in pigment applications.

Will you please read what you're citing before you link to it? Or do you just like to pretend you've "closed the case" on all this business?

.
 
You remember when you linked to the USGS Iron Oxide Pigments Statistics and Information as if it provided a definitive answer to the question "is paint composed of 100 nm iron oxide particles?" Your link was supposed to be the case closer--verifying for God and everyone that these particles were indeed, not unusual for building materials. But here's what the 2008 USGS Minerals Yearbook for Iron Oxide actually said:


Not a word about construction materials or industrial paints or corrosion protection. And this is not surprising considering the difficulty involved in manufacturing uniform 100nm particles. When this is pointed out, Dave replies that "yes, it's a possibility that the red/grey chips are fragments of computer disc drives, but I suspect they're a little too abundant in the dust samples."

Too abundant. We don't have reliable eviudence that they are there at all!
You are making the mistake again that Jones report can be used as evidence. It cannot. Period.

And a little too flammable too, I suspect. But I don't suppose the lack of substance behind your "certainty" will stop you from claiming it once again.

Again you are making the mistake that just beacuse somethinf does not have a commercial use that it would not be present. Fly ash contains the particals in question. Do you have evidence that they are not routinely that small




True. And all we ever have is the evidence. And the evidence is clear that this material is NOT paint nor some industrial building material nor is it computer parts and we can pretty much rule out nuclear magnetic resonance imaging contrast.

Again you do not have any evidence they exist at all!

So, if you are making the claim that this stuff is paint, YOU are now the one in the position to back that claim up with evidence. Let's see how that goes:

What stuff? Jones stuff has no provenance and his testing fails to meet any acceptable scientific standards. We know that the dust will contain vast quantities of paint because the WTC towers steel was painted, thats a given.





Your standards of evidence are, well... exceptional. And I mean that. You make strange and inconsistent exceptions as to what does and does not count as evidence.

And yours are extraordinarily loose.



Will you please read what you're citing before you link to it? Or do you just like to pretend you've "closed the case" on all this business?

You have no "case" to start with.
 
And a little too flammable too, I suspect.

Your confirmation bias is showing. We're discussing the presence of a substance which is known to combust in a standard atmosphere at 430ºC, so we know the stuff is flammable. You can't reject candidates for the identity of a flammable substance because they're flammable.

And you also can't reject candidates because they're not used in construction, industrial paints or corrosion protection. Anything used in IT is likely to have been present in the towers in significant quantities, and you also have to consider anything else that might be present in an office building. We are not talking about large quantities of material here.

I think you're trying too hard to ignore any possibilities you don't like.

Dave
 
To be honest, I think they're a bunch of lying, stinking weasels who would frame their own grandmothers if they thought it would make them look clever. However, that's beside the point. Are you suggesting that the microsphere produced was much bigger than the material that reacted to produce it? If not, then you need to work on expressing concepts more clearly.

When you put a chip in the DSC, it's because you have selected this chip in the iron rich dust with a needle as i did so many times. And you select it by inspecting the particles with a microscope. So each chip that you isolate and
put in you DSC has been inspected: this is obvious! A chip is always thin! so you can imagine there are very small microspheres embedded in the chip material, some of them visible at the surface, some others invisible , completely hidden in the chip but these must have a typical size smaller than the thickness of the chips.
I'have seen plenty of these very small microspheres, some of them even ejected from the chips at high temperature and it is impossible to make such mistake as to say for sure that these microspheres were produced by molten iron due to the reaction of the chips: at the very least there is no evidence for that. And this is why i do not say that my chips reacted.
But in case of the photographs shown by Jones and co there is absolutely no ambiguity because the diameter of the spheroid is huge compared to the thickness of the chip so you could not have missed them at microscopy inspection before putting them in the DSC .
So i'm sorry to repeat again that their evidence is very strong (and i can see no possibility to ignore this) that it is indeed a reaction that melted iron and produced the microspheres.

If so, then you need to look into the law of conservation of mass-energy.

I think it's possible that some substance in the chip reacted with atmospheric oxygen and produced a spherical particle with a significant iron content.


Impossible for a combustion with air oxygen of a micron sized particle to concentrate enough heat on it to melt iron.
indeed each volume V of combustible needs thousands V of air to react completely thus the heat is released in those thousands V of air instead of V of the chip: hence the density of energy is thousand times less than a thermitic reaction where all the reactives are together already inside the chip. Only the latter allows the concentration of the heat to melt iron!
ANother possibility is to accumulate heat in time and concentrate it in a given volume as in a coal burning furnace that produces fly ash where indeed iron can fuse (over 1500°C). But this is not the condition inside of a DSC if a microscopic particle burns : the energy does not accumulate but the dissipative effects are instead very fast in the surrounding air and the energy is not concentrated.

I think it's even possible that some combination of chemicals in the debris may have reacted in some thermite-like reaction.
In your dreams!! iron oxyde and Aluminum react in this way if Alu is elemental, and nanoparticles of elemental Alu dont exist in nature: Al is always oxydized in surface bery fast, and for a 40nm particle, this surface is very soon the whole particle itself exposed to oxygen of the air.

This is the only reason i see to really question the presence of a black ship among these truthers who may have falsified the data in order to decredibilize the whole study and i'm surprised that nobody has mentionned this issue here : how could elemental nanoAlu remain activate 7 years after 911: hardly possible without a very efficient coating according the studies i have read on the subject. Or storage in very dry and oxygen depleted conditions...

I think it completely impossible that the reaction observed by Harrit et al was not primarily combustion in atmospheric oxygen, and neither can anyone else who is rational and possessed of at least minimal expertise.
This is where you are completely wrong for the obvious reasons i have just recalled

And I think it completely impossible that any such reaction was in any way even a partial cause of the collapse of the Twin Towers, with the same dependent clause.
Dave

several millimeters of thermite could heat any column by hundreds of degrees because the reaction is fast : so there is not enough time for the heat to escape, and the reaction is fast just because it does not need a huge volume of air around like a combustion.

1200 lbs of TNT divided by the volume of the fireball in the plane crash is still a ridiculous energy density as compared to xhat is needed to melt iron.
please learn what a density is!

Again sorry but i cannot find any way to avoid a thermitic reaction just from the evidence of molten iron spheroid production as shown in their photographs. This is crucial and conclusive even if all the rest of the article were not conclusive. And this is why , when i couldnt obtain the same reaction my first conclusion had to be that it is my chips that deactivated by heat or humidity or aging...because the only other way out of this would be to accuse the authors of complete falsification of their data!


I admit i did not know that fly ash could be a large source of iron microspheres. But now i see another issue: a very significant fraction of these microspheres are essentially Fer + Al + O microspheres (i have checked this myself). Why so many of them have this signature ? And how this Al + O alloy could have formed ? you have to reach the Alumine fusion T which
is 2050°C when you burn your coal for that: significantly higher than 1500°C
to fuse iron. If not, a piece of alumina will remain at the surface of the iron liquid particle and you will not get a smooth spheroid.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom