sheeplesnshills
Illuminator
- Joined
- Mar 5, 2010
- Messages
- 3,706
How MEK may have affected the results of Jones Test
I did some more reading of the patent. I am a mechanical engineer so its a little outside my field but even high school chemistry is enough to get an idea what is happening when you soak aluminium or perhaps even just Al oxide in MEK
It appears that when creating the aluminium powder (the patent is dated 1972 and the powder is created with a milling machine so this is not sooper dooper nano anything) that an oxide layer immediately forms on it even if the machining is done in hexane. The addition of MEK changes the oxide layer so that it no longer protects the aluminium as effectively thus allowing immediate reaction in acid or if ignited. That indicates the oxide layer itself has be made reactive by the MEK
In the Jones et al Paper, they soak the chips which are known to contain aluminium or aluminium oxides for 5 days which may activate the entire mass of oxide and remove any protection from any elemental Al. that may be present.
When the activated aluminium oxide is then burned in air the reaction would be much more vigorous than that of the an unsoaked example.
MEK would also have plenty of time to soak into any binder material used in the sample and as MEK is highly flammable this may also add to the reactivity of the sample is the time allowed the dry the material was insufficient to allow all MEK to evaporate.
I believe that, at the very least, the possibility of the above interaction of MEK with any sample chips renders any further tests null and void and they should be redone without any soaking in MEK. Further it is hard to see how Jones et al could have missed the above Patent during their Patent search (we know they carried out one as they found the much heralded Patents on Nano thermite.) If they then used MEK it is hard to avoid the conclusion that they are either grossly incompetent or deliberately fraudulent.
If I have made any errors in the above assessment please let me know.
I did some more reading of the patent. I am a mechanical engineer so its a little outside my field but even high school chemistry is enough to get an idea what is happening when you soak aluminium or perhaps even just Al oxide in MEK
The following examples are illustrative of the invention.
EXAMPLE 1
Two samples of atomized aluminum powder milled under substantially identical conditions in hexane, one in the presence of milling aid and the other not, were compared to illustrate the improved reactivity brought about by using milling aids according to the invention. The powder milled in the absence of a milling aid (here, methyl ethyl ketone) did not react immediately in 0.7N nitric acid but required several hours for penetration of the acid to the surfaces of the aluminum particles, the reaction even then being very difficult to detect, only a few bubbles of hydrogen being evolved. On the other hand, powder milled in hexane containing 0.0085 mole methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) per mole aluminum when immersed in distilled water, resulted in an immediate reaction between the water and the aluminum particles, visually observed in the generation of hydrogen bubbles at the surfaces. The powder milled in the presence of MEK also reacted vigorously in the 0.7N nitric acid. beginning immediately upon contact, thereby confirming the activity created by use of the milling aid, here methyl ethyl ketone.
It appears that when creating the aluminium powder (the patent is dated 1972 and the powder is created with a milling machine so this is not sooper dooper nano anything) that an oxide layer immediately forms on it even if the machining is done in hexane. The addition of MEK changes the oxide layer so that it no longer protects the aluminium as effectively thus allowing immediate reaction in acid or if ignited. That indicates the oxide layer itself has be made reactive by the MEK
In the Jones et al Paper, they soak the chips which are known to contain aluminium or aluminium oxides for 5 days which may activate the entire mass of oxide and remove any protection from any elemental Al. that may be present.
When the activated aluminium oxide is then burned in air the reaction would be much more vigorous than that of the an unsoaked example.
MEK would also have plenty of time to soak into any binder material used in the sample and as MEK is highly flammable this may also add to the reactivity of the sample is the time allowed the dry the material was insufficient to allow all MEK to evaporate.
I believe that, at the very least, the possibility of the above interaction of MEK with any sample chips renders any further tests null and void and they should be redone without any soaking in MEK. Further it is hard to see how Jones et al could have missed the above Patent during their Patent search (we know they carried out one as they found the much heralded Patents on Nano thermite.) If they then used MEK it is hard to avoid the conclusion that they are either grossly incompetent or deliberately fraudulent.

If I have made any errors in the above assessment please let me know.