Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

How MEK may have affected the results of Jones Test


I did some more reading of the patent. I am a mechanical engineer so its a little outside my field but even high school chemistry is enough to get an idea what is happening when you soak aluminium or perhaps even just Al oxide in MEK

The following examples are illustrative of the invention.

EXAMPLE 1
Two samples of atomized aluminum powder milled under substantially identical conditions in hexane, one in the presence of milling aid and the other not, were compared to illustrate the improved reactivity brought about by using milling aids according to the invention. The powder milled in the absence of a milling aid (here, methyl ethyl ketone) did not react immediately in 0.7N nitric acid but required several hours for penetration of the acid to the surfaces of the aluminum particles, the reaction even then being very difficult to detect, only a few bubbles of hydrogen being evolved. On the other hand, powder milled in hexane containing 0.0085 mole methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) per mole aluminum when immersed in distilled water, resulted in an immediate reaction between the water and the aluminum particles, visually observed in the generation of hydrogen bubbles at the surfaces. The powder milled in the presence of MEK also reacted vigorously in the 0.7N nitric acid. beginning immediately upon contact, thereby confirming the activity created by use of the milling aid, here methyl ethyl ketone.


It appears that when creating the aluminium powder (the patent is dated 1972 and the powder is created with a milling machine so this is not sooper dooper nano anything) that an oxide layer immediately forms on it even if the machining is done in hexane. The addition of MEK changes the oxide layer so that it no longer protects the aluminium as effectively thus allowing immediate reaction in acid or if ignited. That indicates the oxide layer itself has be made reactive by the MEK

In the Jones et al Paper, they soak the chips which are known to contain aluminium or aluminium oxides for 5 days which may activate the entire mass of oxide and remove any protection from any elemental Al. that may be present.

When the activated aluminium oxide is then burned in air the reaction would be much more vigorous than that of the an unsoaked example.

MEK would also have plenty of time to soak into any binder material used in the sample and as MEK is highly flammable this may also add to the reactivity of the sample is the time allowed the dry the material was insufficient to allow all MEK to evaporate.

I believe that, at the very least, the possibility of the above interaction of MEK with any sample chips renders any further tests null and void and they should be redone without any soaking in MEK. Further it is hard to see how Jones et al could have missed the above Patent during their Patent search (we know they carried out one as they found the much heralded Patents on Nano thermite.) If they then used MEK it is hard to avoid the conclusion that they are either grossly incompetent or deliberately fraudulent.:boggled:

If I have made any errors in the above assessment please let me know.
 
Would you care to try a little harder to confuse the issue? I think one or two people may have failed to notice that you deliberately missed out "computer disc drives". But, hey, it was a 21st century office building; why would it have anything like that in it?

Dave

Dave, they mean that ferrofluids are used in the manufacture of computer disc drives. Are you trying to postulate that the red/gray chips are computer disc drive components?

The ad hoc attempts to make this evidence disappear are as continuous as they are weak.
 
At the very LEAST, the following should be done in a new paper, if they are to have any chance of having their results considered valid.

1. Well defined and complete chain of custody for all samples.
2. Comparative samples from other labs who conducted analysis, with said chain of custody.
3. Provision of samples to an independent lab for repeatability of tests performed and results obtained.
4. Tests to be performed in an O2 Free environment.
5. MEK to NOT BE USED as a wash.

Without the above, their results are null and void, as much as truthers may want to say otherwise.

TAM:)
 
jay howard;5708069]Dave, they mean that ferrofluids are used in the manufacture of computer disc drives. Are you trying to postulate that the red/gray chips are computer disc drive components?

Its more likely than thermite and could easily have been ruled out with some controls tests. Oh I forgot Jones did no control tests other than on paint scraped from the BYU stadium.

The ad hoc attempts to make this evidence disappear are as continuous as they are weak.

There is no evidence to make disappear. How do not grasp this? :confused:
Jones et al have shown themselves to have been either incompetent or fraudulent or both (do you still dispute that?) so any results they obtained are worthless as evidence.
The dust they have might be regarded as evidence if we can show a chain of custody for it (I think we need to go back to the original suppliers of that dust to get new samples that cannot have been tampered with by Jones at least), get samples from other known sources and have them independently tested and see what they find. Similar tests can then be done on likely controls such as WTC paints etc etc.

Then get the results published in a reputable peer reviewed journal and the and only then will we start to think you might have something.
 
If I have made any errors in the above assessment please let me know.


The primary error is in believing that the MEK soaked chip was heated in the DSC. This does not appear to be the case. Did you read this paper or are you getting all your info from the thread?

In theorizing an increase in reactivity of the Al in the chip, you are at least acknowledging the existence of elemental Al. That's a start. Or are you going to retract that now that you know the MEK chip wasn't ignited?


.
 
Dave, they mean that ferrofluids are used in the manufacture of computer disc drives. Are you trying to postulate that the red/gray chips are computer disc drive components?

"Uses for ferrofluids include computer disk drives and high-performance loud speakers", was the original quote. If you think it means that ferrofluids are used as a piece of manufacturing machinery, or some intermediate reagent, or something similar, and are not present in the final product, a citation would be nice; however, I think it's fairly common knowledge that computer discs use magnetic iron oxide as the recording medium. Are you trying to postulate otherwise?

And, yes, it's a possibility that the red/grey chips are fragments of computer disc drives, but I suspect they're a little too abundant in the dust samples. However, there would certainly have been a lot of computers in the World Trade Centre in 2001.

Dave
 
I did some more reading of the patent. I am a mechanical engineer so its a little outside my field but even high school chemistry is enough to get an idea what is happening when you soak aluminium or perhaps even just Al oxide in MEK

It appears that when creating the aluminium powder (the patent is dated 1972 and the powder is created with a milling machine so this is not sooper dooper nano anything) that an oxide layer immediately forms on it even if the machining is done in hexane. The addition of MEK changes the oxide layer so that it no longer protects the aluminium as effectively thus allowing immediate reaction in acid or if ignited. That indicates the oxide layer itself has be made reactive by the MEK

In the Jones et al Paper, they soak the chips which are known to contain aluminium or aluminium oxides for 5 days which may activate the entire mass of oxide and remove any protection from any elemental Al. that may be present.

When the activated aluminium oxide is then burned in air the reaction would be much more vigorous than that of the an unsoaked example.

MEK would also have plenty of time to soak into any binder material used in the sample and as MEK is highly flammable this may also add to the reactivity of the sample is the time allowed the dry the material was insufficient to allow all MEK to evaporate.

I believe that, at the very least, the possibility of the above interaction of MEK with any sample chips renders any further tests null and void and they should be redone without any soaking in MEK. Further it is hard to see how Jones et al could have missed the above Patent during their Patent search (we know they carried out one as they found the much heralded Patents on Nano thermite.) If they then used MEK it is hard to avoid the conclusion that they are either grossly incompetent or deliberately fraudulent.:boggled:

If I have made any errors in the above assessment please let me know.


I think you might be misinterpreting the source material a bit. It appears to be saying that the presence of MEK prevents or alters the formation of the normal oxide layer on freshly exposed surfaces (i.e. during milling). It does not appear to claim that exposure to MEK can remove or alter already existing oxide layers on surfaces already exposed to air.

In any event, nothing done to the aluminum oxide layer could increase the energy derivable from a thermite reaction beyond its stoichiometric maximum. And the calorimeter tests in air showed energy releases significantly above that. Which still means some other "highly energetic" reaction is occurring, most likely ordinary combustion of the organic binder material.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
The primary error is in believing that the MEK soaked chip was heated in the DSC. This does not appear to be the case. Did you read this paper or are you getting all your info from the thread?

In theorizing an increase in reactivity of the Al in the chip, you are at least acknowledging the existence of elemental Al. That's a start. Or are you going to retract that now that you know the MEK chip wasn't ignited?


.

This thread has been going for almost a year.

Even if you are completely vindicated, and it turns out that the paper represents a valid and well-designed experiment, that's one piece of the puzzle.

I calculate that, at the current rate, it will take you 1,000,000 years to prove that 9/11 was an inside job.
 
I did some more reading of the patent. I am a mechanical engineer so its a little outside my field but even high school chemistry is enough to get an idea what is happening when you soak aluminium or perhaps even just Al oxide in MEK





It appears that when creating the aluminium powder (the patent is dated 1972 and the powder is created with a milling machine so this is not sooper dooper nano anything) that an oxide layer immediately forms on it even if the machining is done in hexane. The addition of MEK changes the oxide layer so that it no longer protects the aluminium as effectively thus allowing immediate reaction in acid or if ignited. That indicates the oxide layer itself has be made reactive by the MEK

In the Jones et al Paper, they soak the chips which are known to contain aluminium or aluminium oxides for 5 days which may activate the entire mass of oxide and remove any protection from any elemental Al. that may be present.

When the activated aluminium oxide is then burned in air the reaction would be much more vigorous than that of the an unsoaked example.

MEK would also have plenty of time to soak into any binder material used in the sample and as MEK is highly flammable this may also add to the reactivity of the sample is the time allowed the dry the material was insufficient to allow all MEK to evaporate.

I believe that, at the very least, the possibility of the above interaction of MEK with any sample chips renders any further tests null and void and they should be redone without any soaking in MEK. Further it is hard to see how Jones et al could have missed the above Patent during their Patent search (we know they carried out one as they found the much heralded Patents on Nano thermite.) If they then used MEK it is hard to avoid the conclusion that they are either grossly incompetent or deliberately fraudulent.:boggled:

If I have made any errors in the above assessment please let me know.

As I understand things, the butanone soaked chips were never combusted in the calorimeter; it was a different set of samples. This is one of the more nuanced critiques, and I confess, I missed it the first couple of spins I took around the paper; Sunstealer first suspected that here, then made it his conclusion here. He started from the observation that there's no continuity of characteristics between the various samples, then noticed that the other samples given the full gamut of spectroscopy and calorimeter testing were different. Given that, I don't think butanone would be the source of the combustion in the calorimeter. As Myriad said, the organic material is quite enough to explain what was observed.
 
jay howard;5708616]The primary error is in believing that the MEK soaked chip was heated in the DSC. This does not appear to be the case. Did you read this paper or are you getting all your info from the thread?

Of course I have read the paper. And I did make an error when I said 5 days soak in MEK it was in fact 55 hours. Mea Culpa.
However Jones makes no indication whether or not its the MEK soaked chips that he burns and that section is immediately after the part where he does examine the soaked chips so its not at all unreasonable to assume that it is.
If it was not then the paper need to be revised to clarify that point. Given Jones incompetence to that point I am not inclined to give him the benefit of any doubt.

In theorizing an increase in reactivity of the Al in the chip, you are at least acknowledging the existence of elemental Al. That's a start. Or are you going to retract that now that you know the MEK chip wasn't ignited?

Where did I say that? I said it probably actifies the Al Oxides and any Al that may have been present. Jones did not prove the absence or presence of elemental Al he merely incorrectly infers it from the Oxygen levels. Since he fails to show that elemental AL is present let alone that its in sooperdooper nano form we do not now if it was there or not. Huge amounts of Al were used in the building (the cladding) so its not impossible that the chips were contaminated with Al. or that non nano particles were included in some paint finishes or other materials used.


We do not KNOW that a MEK chip was not ignited, Jones does not specify which chips he ignites. he merely says they were red/gray chips. We already have shown that we cannot rely on Jones methodology.

3. Thermal Analysis using Differential Scanning
Calorimetry
Red/gray chips were subjected to heating using a differential
scanning calorimeter (DSC). The data shown in Fig.
(19) demonstrate that the red/gray chips from different WTC
samples all ignited in the range 415-435 °C. The energy release
for each exotherm can be estimated by integrating with
respect to time under the narrow peak. Proceeding from the
smallest to largest peaks, the yields are estimated to be approximately
1.5, 3, 6 and 7.5 kJ/g respectively. Variations in
peak height as well as yield estimates are not surprising,
since the mass used to determine the scale of the signal,
shown in the DSC traces, included the mass of the gray
layer. The gray layer was found to consist mostly of iron
oxide so that it probably does not contribute to the exotherm,
and yet this layer varies greatly in mass from chip to chip.
 
Myriad;5708861]I think you might be misinterpreting the source material a bit. It appears to be saying that the presence of MEK prevents or alters the formation of the normal oxide layer on freshly exposed surfaces (i.e. during milling). It does not appear to claim that exposure to MEK can remove or alter already existing oxide layers on surfaces already exposed to air.

I considered that possibility but the MEK does seem to do something other than simply prevent the oxide layer forming. The MEK would quickly evaporate and and preventative effect would disappear with the MEK.
however that does not appear to be the case as the MEK removes the effectiveness of the oxide layer allowing the Al underneath to react with acid or burn more vigorously. The Author does not speculate on the chemical process involved merely its effects.

I
n any event, nothing done to the aluminum oxide layer could increase the energy derivable from a thermite reaction beyond its stoichiometric maximum. And the calorimeter tests in air showed energy releases significantly above that. Which still means some other "highly energetic" reaction is occurring, most likely ordinary combustion of the organic binder material.

Indeed, but it could account for the supposed high rate of the reaction. No more energy is released but it is released at a higher rate and likely higher temp but for a shorter period.
 
lMondoHummus;5708963]As I understand things, the butanone soaked chips were never combusted in the calorimeter; it was a different set of samples.

Perhaps but since Jones does not say so or properly segregate the chips into organized set of samples we simply do not know. With chips in short supply he may simply have used the dried MEK chips in the Calorimeter.


Given that, I don't think butanone would be the source of the combustion in the calorimeter. As Myriad said, the organic material is quite enough to explain what was observed.

Agreed, the reaction already gives out too much energy but it was just a possibility I wanted to mention. If the chips were allowed to dry for two days as reported, little MEK might be left in them to add to the resultant energy.
 
It appears that we've entered the point of the debate where unofficial conspiracy skeptics are mad-googling anything that makes reference to nanoscale iron oxide and aluminium or some other aspect of the evidence or methods while introducing any theory--many of them mutually exclusive--in an attempt to diminish the evidence in this paper as unreal.

As a skeptic myself, I applaud the effort. It is indeed worthwhile to try to poke holes in this paper as much as possible. If the evidence is sturdy, it should be able to stand the scrutiny of a skeptical perspective.

But it doesn't help the effort (either to refute the findings in this paper or to bolster them) to be overzealous in this. What I mean is, citing a flood of papers simply because they mention something related to this subject only demonstrates a desperation to block out uncomfortable information. If a paper makes a relevant point about the material or the methods, then by all means, proceed. But data dumping is just a distraction from a real discussion.

The WTC towers may have indeed fallen because of the plane impacts and the ensuing fires. They may not have. There appears to be some incendiary/explosive material in the dust. Up until this paper came out, it was a given here on JREF that incredulity is a worthless stance. Likewise, it was a given that when multiple, contradictory ad hoc theories were postulated in an attempt to overcome objections, that was a pretty good indication (though not demonstrative proof) that they were grasping at straws to support a particular claim.

But that doesn't stop anyone from employing those methods when the evidence at hand appears to support the "inside job" theory. All I'm asking for is that before you cite a paper as a source of a relevant counterargument, read it and make sure it makes some kind of sense first.


.
 
It appears that we've entered the point of the debate where unofficial conspiracy skeptics are mad-googling anything that makes reference to nanoscale iron oxide and aluminium or some other aspect of the evidence or methods while introducing any theory--many of them mutually exclusive--in an attempt to diminish the evidence in this paper as unreal.

As a skeptic myself, I applaud the effort. It is indeed worthwhile to try to poke holes in this paper as much as possible. If the evidence is sturdy, it should be able to stand the scrutiny of a skeptical perspective.

But it doesn't help the effort (either to refute the findings in this paper or to bolster them) to be overzealous in this. What I mean is, citing a flood of papers simply because they mention something related to this subject only demonstrates a desperation to block out uncomfortable information. If a paper makes a relevant point about the material or the methods, then by all means, proceed. But data dumping is just a distraction from a real discussion.

The WTC towers may have indeed fallen because of the plane impacts and the ensuing fires. They may not have. There appears to be some incendiary/explosive material in the dust. Up until this paper came out, it was a given here on JREF that incredulity is a worthless stance. Likewise, it was a given that when multiple, contradictory ad hoc theories were postulated in an attempt to overcome objections, that was a pretty good indication (though not demonstrative proof) that they were grasping at straws to support a particular claim.

But that doesn't stop anyone from employing those methods when the evidence at hand appears to support the "inside job" theory. All I'm asking for is that before you cite a paper as a source of a relevant counterargument, read it and make sure it makes some kind of sense first.


.

Jay I applaud your attempt (at least very recently) to maintain a sense of skeptic necessity around this paper. That said, if you are honest in this, you must, MUST admit that the numerous methodological errors in the study, combined with insufficient documentation (from a forensic pov) on chain of custody, and the inadequate testing in an O2 free environment, makes the results of the analysis (outside of a passing "hmmm that is interesting") unusable.

If anything, you should (if you truly believe they are ON TO SOMETHING) be leading the way in calling for them to fix all the errors, submit their samples for independent testing, and make the appropriate adjustments...so, are you???

TAM:)
 
"Uses for ferrofluids include computer disk drives and high-performance loud speakers", was the original quote. If you think it means that ferrofluids are used as a piece of manufacturing machinery, or some intermediate reagent, or something similar, and are not present in the final product, a citation would be nice; however, I think it's fairly common knowledge that computer discs use magnetic iron oxide as the recording medium. Are you trying to postulate otherwise?

And, yes, it's a possibility that the red/grey chips are fragments of computer disc drives, but I suspect they're a little too abundant in the dust samples. However, there would certainly have been a lot of computers in the World Trade Centre in 2001.

Dave

Yes, Dave. I'm well aware of using iron oxide as the active layer in memory devices. And I share your suspicions that the chips may be too abundant to be accounted for as computer components. Not only that, but they do not appear to be any kind of electronics component whatsoever.

At what point should one say "hhmmm... this stuff is a little bit strange. Maybe not evidence of an inside job, but strange nonetheless. We should investigate further."?

.
 
I did some more reading of the patent. I am a mechanical engineer so its a little outside my field but even high school chemistry is enough to get an idea what is happening when you soak aluminium or perhaps even just Al oxide in MEK





It appears that when creating the aluminium powder (the patent is dated 1972 and the powder is created with a milling machine so this is not sooper dooper nano anything) that an oxide layer immediately forms on it even if the machining is done in hexane. The addition of MEK changes the oxide layer so that it no longer protects the aluminium as effectively thus allowing immediate reaction in acid or if ignited. That indicates the oxide layer itself has be made reactive by the MEK

In the Jones et al Paper, they soak the chips which are known to contain aluminium or aluminium oxides for 5 days which may activate the entire mass of oxide and remove any protection from any elemental Al. that may be present.

When the activated aluminium oxide is then burned in air the reaction would be much more vigorous than that of the an unsoaked example.

MEK would also have plenty of time to soak into any binder material used in the sample and as MEK is highly flammable this may also add to the reactivity of the sample is the time allowed the dry the material was insufficient to allow all MEK to evaporate.

I believe that, at the very least, the possibility of the above interaction of MEK with any sample chips renders any further tests null and void and they should be redone without any soaking in MEK. Further it is hard to see how Jones et al could have missed the above Patent during their Patent search (we know they carried out one as they found the much heralded Patents on Nano thermite.) If they then used MEK it is hard to avoid the conclusion that they are either grossly incompetent or deliberately fraudulent.:boggled:

If I have made any errors in the above assessment please let me know.

So he proved that if you soak paint chips containing aluminum oxide in MEK for a week they will burn.
 
If a paper makes a relevant point about the material or the methods, then by all means, proceed. But data dumping is just a distraction from a real discussion.

One of my replies to you noted on a relevant one.
Here's a summary:
--------------------------------------------------------------------

My first impression was that the alumina and silica bound, due to its rather weak binding, had in the given material experienced dissolution; e.g kaolin dissolution. It's perfectly conceivable that the material in question had experienced enough pressure prior to the 55-hour lay-in-solvent that parts might've dispersed.

You might find this relevant to read, perhaps; a critical analysis of Jones paper on the active material:
*Active Thermitic Material" Claimed in Ground Zero Dust May Not Be Thermitic At All
 
But it doesn't help the effort (either to refute the findings in this paper or to bolster them) to be overzealous in this. What I mean is, citing a flood of papers simply because they mention something related to this subject only demonstrates a desperation to block out uncomfortable information. If a paper makes a relevant point about the material or the methods, then by all means, proceed. But data dumping is just a distraction from a real discussion.

I only googled two words to get that patent on MEK being used to help make thermite. Jones used it without any particularly good reason cited and I was curious why. And to complain about me doing it is by default also condemning Jones as he does exactly the same to get his info on Nano thermite. He has none of this material and has tested none. His only proof that it exists at all is in the Patents. Jones paper is the distraction not my or anyone else's refutation.

The WTC towers may have indeed fallen because of the plane impacts and the ensuing fires. They may not have. There appears to be some incendiary/explosive material in the dust.

What evidence other than the paper is there for that assertion?

But that doesn't stop anyone from employing those methods when the evidence at hand appears to support the "inside job" theory. All I'm asking for is that before you cite a paper as a source of a relevant counterargument, read it and make sure it makes some kind of sense first.
I did and I think it does. If nothing else it shows that Jones was further incompetent by not making clear which chips he was testing. If it was the MEK ones then he needs to go back and redo the tests as even the possibility of the MEK affecting any Al oxide or Elemental Al makes the results invalid...... and if it was not then he needs to clearly state that in the paper.

Forgive me if I seem a little harsh on Jones et al but they are making extraordinary claims based on this shoddy little paper and its long past the point he should retract what he said and either repeat the experiments in a proper scientific manner or quietly go away. Somehow I doubt he will do neither. The very fact that he does not just lends credence to the notion that his paper never was about the truth and solely as a vehicle for his self promotion. Thousands died on 911 and it triggered wars in which thousands more have died.....for him to be making money and living it up on all those corpses is sickening and now with the Pentagon gunman the lies are costing lifes as well.:mad:
 
It appears that we've entered the point of the debate where unofficial conspiracy skeptics are mad-googling anything that makes reference to nanoscale iron oxide and aluminium or some other aspect of the evidence or methods while introducing any theory--many of them mutually exclusive--in an attempt to diminish the evidence in this paper as unreal.
It is unfortunate that you see the debate that way. Please allow me to remind you what you said:
Is paint composed of 100 nm iron oxide particles?
The answer to this rather asinine question is, yes. Your attempt to move the debate from the relevant to the irrelevant by not addressing my comments directly has not furthered your argument.

More importantly, iron oxide spheres are used in a variety of lubricants and coatings and they are a common component of a dozen different building materials, including concrete, fly ash and inks, paints, stains and dyes. The point is that you, along with Steven Jones and everyone else who believes this nonsense, seem to think that there's something amazing about finding iron oxide in dust and ash. The detritus of a flaming, collapsing building was blown into a residential area and collected haphazardly with no deference to cross contamination issues. The source material is dust and ash, the chips and question are far more likely to be a coating applied to the structural steel in the towers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom