Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

I am almost sure that fig. 25 is a pic. from cement/flyash and not from the post-DSC.
Fig. 27 is indeed a pic. of flyash.
In Denmark we use up to 30% flyash in cement.
So why the fuss about iron-rich spheres in the dust from WTC.(not the samples)
And why call them iron-rich, why not O,Si,Al,Ti,S,Mg C,K,Ca-rich.
These elements are found in flyash.
We need pic. af the DSC-residues.
The flame-test is a joke and the corrosponding pics. is an insult.
this article makes it sound like flyash was not used when the wtc towers were built. if you read about the new wtc being built, they are using flyash.

from the article:
TMS hot topic symposium examines WTC collapse and building engineering

"Additional barriers deal with building codes and the need to adhere to existing standards. Years of effort and very aggressive champions are always needed to get a new material into common use. As an example, Hooper discussed the difficulty in persuading building officials to accept fly-ash residue from coal burning as a component in concrete. Adding fly ash makes concrete a more environmentally friendly material, but required federal legislation to overcome skeptics."
 
this article makes it sound like flyash was not used when the wtc towers were built. if you read about the new wtc being built, they are using flyash.

from the article:
TMS hot topic symposium examines WTC collapse and building engineering

"Additional barriers deal with building codes and the need to adhere to existing standards. Years of effort and very aggressive champions are always needed to get a new material into common use. As an example, Hooper discussed the difficulty in persuading building officials to accept fly-ash residue from coal burning as a component in concrete. Adding fly ash makes concrete a more environmentally friendly material, but required federal legislation to overcome skeptics."


I think the enviromemtal issues in using it are new not its use.
 
this article makes it sound like flyash was not used when the wtc towers were built. if you read about the new wtc being built, they are using flyash. ...
Fly-ash was used in ancient Rome.

common knowledge? to cement experts...
Fly ash concrete was first used in the U.S. in 1929 for the Hoover Dam, where engineers found that it allowed for less total cement. It is now used across the country.

Who used fly-ash?
Long before modern power plants began producing coal fly ash, Roman builders turned to volcanic ash to harness the power of pozzolans.

In fact, the term “pozzolan” is derived from the name of an Italian city — Pozzuoli — that is regarded as the birthplace of ash concrete technologies. Famed Roman structures such as the Pantheon and Colosseum, as well as many roads and aqueducts, are still standing over 2,000 years after their construction — in part because of the durability of their ash-based concrete.
1Fly-AshPant.jpg
​

http://www.flyash.com/data/upimages/press/HWR_brochure_flyash.pdf



Would the event of massive office fires set with 10,000 gallons of jet fuel create some fly-ash? Yes? No? Maybe? Metal spheres?
 
Fly-ash was used in ancient Rome.

common knowledge? to cement experts...


Who used fly-ash?




Would the event of massive office fires set with 10,000 gallons of jet fuel create some fly-ash? Yes? No? Maybe? Metal spheres?


the romans were ahead of their time!!

the article implies that flyash was not used the construction of the old wtc buildings. the new wtc does incorporate flyash.

as henryco said "5% by weight of these spheres in the dust is huge! Means thousands of tons of iron melted."
 
i forgot to make clear in my previous post that i can understand why the fly ash from a metal furnace has iron microspheres: just because the temperature of the burning coal there is over 1500°C the melting point of Fe. Whis was not the case in the WTC fires.


why do you think the temp is over 1500C.
i found an article that states:
"For the combustion of mineral coal, the energy industry is
mainly using dry-bottom boilers which produce coal fly ash, bottom ash and FGD gypsum as by-products.
In dry-bottom boilers, the ash does not liquefy due to the
relatively low boiler temperature of about 1200°C."

that would not melt the iron content in the flyash.

i guess im wondering how one could distinguish between iron spheres from flyash and iron microspheres that were created during the wtc destruction.

this is from the article:
Extremely high temperatures during the WTC destruction

***There are other identifying features that characterize WTC dust compared with ordinary office dust; the RJ
Lee report concludes:
“Various metals (most notably iron and lead) were melted during the WTC Event, producing spherical metallic particles. Exposure of phases to high heat results in the formation of spherical particles due to surface tension…”

i wonder if there is anyway to distinguish between these "spherical particles due to surface tension" and the iron microspheres from flyash?
 
Oops, I didn’t’ read this part before I posted my response above.

Why do you think that a burning coal furnace can reach 1500C, but that the fires in the WTC towers did not?

because the Nist reaches in its simulation the maximum for a fire in open air : 1100°C. this is already extreme!

I find it extremely frustrating and annoying that most people fail to grasp the differences between heat and temperature.

The notion that a particular fuel can only burn at a particular temperature indicates a fundamental lack of understanding of basic science.

The NIST simulation was just that, a computer simulation that produced an average value for the temperature of an area. This is not the absolute maximum, it is an average of the maximum.

1100 C temperatures is not an extreme value for a typical structure fire. The fires in the WTC were far from typical, fed by jet fuel, they involved large amounts of fuel on multiple floors at once.
 
Coal and jet fuel are essentially the both hydrocarbon fuels. There is no difference between a coal fired furnace with a natural draft chimney and the fire floors in the WTC where the smoke was exiting out the upper floors of the building.

Even a simple candle can generate temperatures of 1400C in the flame.




this is still far from the iron melting point. in a metal furnace the heat is "concentrated" in time and space and the oxygenation conditions are optimal. such that you can melt iron. .

You seem to be of the impression that fly ash with metal spheres only forms in metal furnaces. This is not the case. The vast majority of fly ash is generated from coal power boilers. Do you think that these boilers operate at temperatures that will melt iron?




The worse is again that even if you could produce these microspheres in a fire you would be very very far from several percent in weight of the dust.

Do you have empirical data to support this claim?



All flammable materials in the whole tower represent a negligible weight (not to mention that a small number of floors were actually on fire before collapse) as compared to 90000 tons of pulverized concrete.

Which means what, exactly?
 
"All flammable materials in the whole tower represent a negligible weight (not to mention that a small number of floors were actually on fire before collapse) as compared to 90000 tons of pulverized concrete.

Look at pictures of the Windsor Tower fire, contents were quite enough to totally engulf the building for hours...........and at least 10 floors of the first WTC tower were on fire ......the photos from the Helicopter Cop show huge fires.
 
the romans were ahead of their time!!

the article implies that flyash was not used the construction of the old wtc buildings. the new wtc does incorporate flyash.

as henryco said "5% by weight of these spheres in the dust is huge! Means thousands of tons of iron melted."
No, the article does no imply fly-ash was not used in the old WTC, in fact the information on fly-ash makes it a great use in lightweight floors. But the there are studies ignored by Jones and company which imply fly-ash was a product of the WTC disaster. Care to comment on reality based studies 911 truth fails to research and discuss which refute their thermite based lies?

5 percent by weight of samples that have no chain of custody? This is not science it is Jones who made up thermite out of the blue 4 years after 911 and Jones had zero evidence. I have a copy of his first paper which he put out and then was fired for his conduct on 911 issues and his faulty nonexistent research which fueled his claims. I have his first paper, his letter which precipitated his retirement, being fired.

The paper by Jones has come and gone. It had to be paid to be published and has zero effect on the scientific community understanding of 911 and how the WTC collapsed.

I have seen lies of small fires in the WTC towers posted again, when the fires were the largest office fires started on multiple floors in history. Had 911 taken place at night, most of 911 truth would wonder how they survived so long to let most of the people evacuate. The only purpose of the paper in question is to satisfy some bias of Jones who now thinks the United States caused the earthquake in Haiti. The paper is nonsense and nothing will save it from being a failure in the world of science.

If you disagree with me, take the paper to a real journal which publishes similar topics and you find rejection of the paper for many reasons already pointed out. Take the paper and have it accepted by a real journal! Jones needs to step up and explain why his paper was not peer reviewed.

The good part is due to the failed test where the energy was not a match for thermite; it appears the samples were not planted, but just other substances not thermite. Since office contents have more heat energy than thermite, I find it complete nonsense thermite is proposed and then the lack of TONS of iron from thermite reactions at the WTC closes the thermite case.


the article implies that flyash was not used the construction of the old wtc buildings.
No the article does not come close to implying such. Do you need the study where fly-ash is discussed with respect to the WTC?
 
still no flyash??
Particle Atlas of World Trade Center Dust
http://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2005/1165/508OF05-1165.html#heading10

Concrete
Concrete is composed of aggregate, sand, and Portland cement (Chandra and Berntsson, 2003). The aggregate material in WTC concrete sample appears to be expanded shale. The sand is primarily quartz, but can contain feldspar, iron and titanium oxides, micas, and other rock-forming minerals. Portlandite (Ca(OH)2) and magnesium hydroxide are also present in minor to trace amounts. Portland cement hydrates to form a large variety of Ca-rich phases including calcium silicate hydrate, calcium aluminum hydrate, calcium aluminum iron hydrate, and Portlandite (Ca(OH)2) (Chandra and Berntsson, 2003). Portlandite is indistinguishable from lime (CaO) using qualitative EDS. Minor gypsum is added to control the set of the concrete.

Particles identifiable as concrete in WTC dust are those constituting the Portland cement component. Portland cement particles will usually have a high Ca peak accompanied by Si and/or Al, Mg, Fe. Most particles of Portland cement will be composed of several Ca-rich phases. These phases are generally extremely fine grained and often occur without distinct grain boundaries. These phases can usually be differentiated using backscattered electron imaging combined with EDS analysis.

A large proportion of the quartz in WTC dust is likely from disaggregated concrete, but has been grouped below with mineral material. Calcite (CaCO3) and dolomite (CaMg(CO3)2) are also components of concrete, but as with quartz, have been grouped with mineral material because they can be present from a variety of sources.
 
still no flyash??
Particle Atlas of World Trade Center Dust
http://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2005/1165/508OF05-1165.html#heading10

Concrete
Concrete is composed of aggregate, sand, and Portland cement (Chandra and Berntsson, 2003). The aggregate material in WTC concrete sample appears to be expanded shale. The sand is primarily quartz, but can contain feldspar, iron and titanium oxides, micas, and other rock-forming minerals. Portlandite (Ca(OH)2) and magnesium hydroxide are also present in minor to trace amounts. Portland cement hydrates to form a large variety of Ca-rich phases including calcium silicate hydrate, calcium aluminum hydrate, calcium aluminum iron hydrate, and Portlandite (Ca(OH)2) (Chandra and Berntsson, 2003). Portlandite is indistinguishable from lime (CaO) using qualitative EDS. Minor gypsum is added to control the set of the concrete.

Particles identifiable as concrete in WTC dust are those constituting the Portland cement component. Portland cement particles will usually have a high Ca peak accompanied by Si and/or Al, Mg, Fe. Most particles of Portland cement will be composed of several Ca-rich phases. These phases are generally extremely fine grained and often occur without distinct grain boundaries. These phases can usually be differentiated using backscattered electron imaging combined with EDS analysis.

A large proportion of the quartz in WTC dust is likely from disaggregated concrete, but has been grouped below with mineral material. Calcite (CaCO3) and dolomite (CaMg(CO3)2) are also components of concrete, but as with quartz, have been grouped with mineral material because they can be present from a variety of sources.

When fly ash is added to concrete, the siliceous and calciferous components undergo a pozzolanic reaction with the calcium hydroxide. The fly ash becomes largely indistinguishable from the CSH gel component.

Of course, the only thing that doesn't react or react well is the iron oxide spheres...
 
It's very telling what you decided to quote from my response. Please consider, again, the following:


This is a significant retreat from your earlier positions that no pigments contained iron oxide and that no pigments contained iron oxide with 100 nm particles. However, this:

Is an excellent example of the "Moving the Goalposts" tactic. Your original claim was that the iron oxide represented proof that the material is thermite. Now your argument appears to be that thermite (or nano-thermite) is composed of an entirely uniform 100 nm particle matrix.


Since we've been having this discussion, I've been clear about the fact that paint/pigments do not require this uniformity of particle size at 100 nm. I state this unequivocally back in post 460:
jay howard said:
Instead we see nanometer-sized iron, aluminum and silicon particles mixed very finely in a carbon-based matrix. The uniformity of these particles is startling, as most manufacturing processes on an industrial scale--paints, primers, corrosion protection coatings, etc., cannot afford to design these particles (most especially the aluminum) so precisely for use in products that do not require such specific size/mixture parameters. It would be an enormously wasteful endeavor to design paints or other common industrial coatings that don't require such fine particles. The mere prospect is laughable as there isn't a plant manager on the planet that would propose such an unnecessary move. It's not only a sure-fire way to get fired, it would ensure the company would eventually go out of business as well!

And here in post 562:
jay howard said:
Are uniformly sized nanometer scale iron oxide particles ubiquitous in nature? Not by any stretch of the imagination.

And again in post 564:
jay howard said:
How is it you can look at the BSE images in figure 8 and say they do NOT demonstrate the presence of relatively dense, faceted particles that are nearly uniformly 100 nm?... If you were actually attempting to evaluate this info scientifically/skeptically, there would be no reason to deny the existence of these relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles in these images.

Yet again in post 591:
jay howard said:
The SE microscopy clearly reveals fairly uniform nanoscale particles in a bi-layered matrix.... By "highly processed" I mean that the red material is composed of relatively uniform nanoscale particles that have been finely mixed.

And here again in post 631:
jay howard said:
Find some paint/coating that is composed of relatively uniform 100 nm iron oxide particles.

And again in 637:
jay howard said:
Not a word about construction materials or industrial paints or corrosion protection. And this is not surprising considering the difficulty involved in manufacturing uniform 100nm particles.

And this one in 649:
jay howard said:
The relative uniformity of the iron oxide suggests a use which takes advantage of the high surface area-to-mass properties afforded by such small particles.


So, to accuse me of "moving the goalposts"--a favorite accusation around here on both sides of these issues--requires a robust ignorance of reading comprehension. I think we've been having a productive conversation by and large, but this type of pre-refuted sophistry serves no purpose here. I've been clear about what would count as a counterexample to the red/gray chips being something that doesn't belong in a building: relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles in paint/pigment/primer/etc.

As I've also stated unequivocally before, if you find industrial paint that has relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles in it that combusts at 430C, then you have a very good contender for the material that the HFJ crew found. Until then, you'll have to stick with incredulity or claims of data fabrication.

You also seem to believe that it is impossible to create uniform (that is, a sample of particle sizes representing a relative standard deviation of no more than, shall we say, 5% of the average particle diameter) particles. I can assure you, that is false.


This is NOT what I'm saying at all, at all. I'm saying that the manufacture of relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles is very difficult and most likely more expensive than is required for the manufacture of pigments using iron oxide. Everything I've read and been pointed towards on this subject confirms this.

Paint manufacturers aren't going to process their pigments any further than necessary to make them work. Period. If they don't absolutely require uniform particle sizes, then you can guarantee they won't waste their time making them--unless they form naturally uniform sizes, they won't be in the mix. When, by several techniques, the particles appear strikingly uniform at 100nm, you can pretty much rest assured this wasn't an accident.

Like I said earlier, it's not surprising that the range of particle sizes in iron oxide pigments goes to 100nm. It would indeed be very surprising if ALL the particles in a pigment sample were 100nm. Clear?


.
 
Since we've been having this discussion, I've been clear about the fact that paint/pigments do not require this uniformity of particle size at 100 nm. I state this unequivocally back in post 460:

[...]

So, to accuse me of "moving the goalposts"--a favorite accusation around here on both sides of these issues--requires a robust ignorance of reading comprehension. I think we've been having a productive conversation by and large, but this type of pre-refuted sophistry serves no purpose here. I've been clear about what would count as a counterexample to the red/gray chips being something that doesn't belong in a building: relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles in paint/pigment/primer/etc.
Since I don't want to devolve into he said - she said sophistry either, I will concede that you have been consistent in your position.
As I've also stated unequivocally before, if you find industrial paint that has relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles in it that combusts at 430C, then you have a very good contender for the material that the HFJ crew found. Until then, you'll have to stick with incredulity or claims of data fabrication.
False choice fallacy. My argument is that there is more than sufficient provenance for this coating as the material in question. It was applied to every major structural member in the WTC, it has the same qualitative composition as Jones has listed, including the zinc and chromium (see figure 14) as very specifically noted in NCSTAR 1-3C, and it notes the use of iron oxide as pigment. That's a confounding variable, and it's up to Jones to eliminate it.

Of course, a great first step to prove that the material is thermite would be by showing that it combusts in an inert atmosphere. Why didn't Jones do that?

This is NOT what I'm saying at all, at all. I'm saying that the manufacture of relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles is very difficult and most likely more expensive than is required for the manufacture of pigments using iron oxide. Everything I've read and been pointed towards on this subject confirms this.
So because most manufacturers wouldn't bother to do it, all manufacturers don't do it? Or it's impossible? Again, your opinions on what is and is not in the best interest of the paint manufacturer are very interesting, but they have no relevancy on this debate.

A pigment used to make a protective, anti-corrosive paint for every major structural member in two of the tallest free-standing structures in the world most assuredly represents a special case. The manufacturer was given a series of specifications, and met them to the best of their ability.
Paint manufacturers aren't going to process their pigments any further than necessary to make them work. Period.
Please stop ignoring this:

The top of page 100 in the Pigments book (see above) notes, "The hues of most of the colored inorganic pigments are determined not only by their molecular compositions, but also on particle size and crystalline form." Further down the page, it notes, "The color dependence on average particle size is illustrated by the dominant wavelength of magnetite, which changes from 600 nm to 635 nm as the particles increase [...]"

Interestingly, it appears that magnetite, along with other iron oxide pigments, appears to have a size dependency on fluoresced wavelength. So, it seems that, when iron oxides are used as a pigment, size control and separation are of paramount importance.
If they don't absolutely require uniform particle sizes, then you can guarantee they won't waste their time making them
Are you a paint manufacturer? Do you feel like you can speak for all paint manufacturers in the world now and for the last 50 years?
--unless they form naturally uniform sizes, they won't be in the mix. When, by several techniques, the particles appear strikingly uniform at 100nm, you can pretty much rest assured this wasn't an accident.
I would love to see the particle size distribution done using the quantitative particle sizing methodology I described earlier. What page of the article was that on?
Like I said earlier, it's not surprising that the range of particle sizes in iron oxide pigments goes to 100nm. It would indeed be very surprising if ALL the particles in a pigment sample were 100nm. Clear?
There is no evidence that all of the particles are exactly 100 nm in diameter. "It looks like it" doesn't work in science. Particle sizing, random sampling, isolation and separation. That's what's required to prove this point scientifically.
 
"It looks like it" doesn't work in science.

This point can't be stressed enough....so many truther arguments rest on this....

"It looks like" squibs...

"It looks like" uniform particles...

"It looks like" freefall speed...

"It looks like" the top should have toppled like a tree...

"It looks like" molten iron...

"It looks like" it collapsed into its own footprint...

"It looks like" the sphericals are from molten iron produced from thermite...

"It looks like" the fires on 9/11 weren't really that bad...


This is all I ever hear from them....no evidence...just opinions and incredulity....the Jones paper is no exception.

Every test he does implies that it "looks like" some kind of thermite without ever conclusively showing that it is.
 
This point can't be stressed enough....so many truther arguments rest on this....

"It looks like" squibs...

"It looks like" uniform particles...

"It looks like" freefall speed...

"It looks like" the top should have toppled like a tree...

"It looks like" molten iron...

"It looks like" it collapsed into its own footprint...

"It looks like" the sphericals are from molten iron produced from thermite...

"It looks like" the fires on 9/11 weren't really that bad...


This is all I ever hear from them....no evidence...just opinions and incredulity....the Jones paper is no exception.

Every test he does implies that it "looks like" some kind of thermite without ever conclusively showing that it is.
More accurately, several of their tests clearly showed that it did not look like or behave like thermite.

That's why they speculated it was nanothermite, which was conveniently unavailable for comparison testing.
 
More accurately, several of their tests clearly showed that it did not look like or behave like thermite.

Of course....that is why I write "it looks like" using quotation marks....because in reality the phrase is not accurate when examined...

That's why they speculated it was nanothermite, which was conveniently unavailable for comparison testing.

Yep....once they realized that their little "energy" experiment proved that is WASN'T thermite they simply shifted to "nano" or "super" thermite in an attempt to save their position...

Unfortuantely for them it did not fool most people.
 
So because most manufacturers wouldn't bother to do it, all manufacturers don't do it? Or it's impossible? Again, your opinions on what is and is not in the best interest of the paint manufacturer are very interesting, but they have no relevancy on this debate.


This just doesn't seem like a very controversial statement. Have I contacted all the pigment/paint manufacturers? No. But this is just basic market economics. Paint/pigment makers aren't going to go through the trouble of overprocessing something beyond the necessities of its application because that cuts directly into profit margins. This isn't chemistry or materials engineering, this is basic economics.

Take a look at these prices for alpha-Fe2O3 at 20-40 nm. Not surprisingly, it's $76/100g. Sure, they probably painted all the towers in that stuff, right?

Here's a patent description for producing Fe2O3 particles at 50-100 nm. Not exactly the kind of technology we would expect to find at a paint manufacturing facility.

All the available info out there makes it very unlikely that industrial scale manufacturing processes would ever mess with uniform 100 nm iron oxide particles unless it was absolutely necessary. Again, this isn't a controversial point, and there is zero evidence to the contrary. Are you still in disagreement over this?


Please stop ignoring this:

The top of page 100 in the Pigments book (see above) notes, "The hues of most of the colored inorganic pigments are determined not only by their molecular compositions, but also on particle size and crystalline form." Further down the page, it notes, "The color dependence on average particle size is illustrated by the dominant wavelength of magnetite, which changes from 600 nm to 635 nm as the particles increase [...]"

Interestingly, it appears that magnetite, along with other iron oxide pigments, appears to have a size dependency on fluoresced wavelength. So, it seems that, when iron oxides are used as a pigment, size control and separation are of paramount importance.


Right. The reason I didn't respond to this is that the wavelengths that magnetite absorbs (or doesn't absorb) is absolutely irrelevant to a discussion about nanometer scale iron oxide particles. They're referencing "600 nm to 635 nm" as the wavelength that the material in question absorbs or reflects, thus changing its color. That's neato!

What's your point? You either don't understand what you're quoting or you have no interest in demonstrating your disagreement.


Are you a paint manufacturer? Do you feel like you can speak for all paint manufacturers in the world now and for the last 50 years?


No. Not a paint manufacturer. Yes. I can speak for all the paint manufacturers in the world for the last 50 years that unless they have a very specific and expensive need for relatively uniform 100 nm iron oxide particles, they will not waste their time and money making them. Nor will their manufacturing processes "accidentally" make them.


I would love to see the particle size distribution done using the quantitative particle sizing methodology I described earlier. What page of the article was that on?

There is no evidence that all of the particles are exactly 100 nm in diameter. "It looks like it" doesn't work in science. Particle sizing, random sampling, isolation and separation. That's what's required to prove this point scientifically.


The only evidence we have on this is what the HFJ crew has done in their paper. From all the pictures they took, the faceted, relatively dense, 100 nm particles are very likely iron oxide and there aren't any that appear much larger or smaller--as we would expect if this material were paint/pigment/corrosion protection/etc.

In all fairness, their hasn't been an analysis done specifically on the particle size of the iron oxide. And in all fairness, finding the same relatively uniform 100 nm particles in 4 different samples which were broken open for SE analysis makes the hypothesis that "they just missed the bigger particles" very slim.

And finally, can you show me any industrial paint/pigment/coating/etc. WHATSOEVER that is composed of relatively uniform 100 nm iron oxide particles? No? That's not surprising.

.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom