Since we've been having this discussion, I've been clear about the fact that paint/pigments do not require this uniformity of particle size at 100 nm. I state this unequivocally back in post 460:
[...]
So, to accuse me of "moving the goalposts"--a favorite accusation around here on both sides of these issues--requires a robust ignorance of reading comprehension. I think we've been having a productive conversation by and large, but this type of pre-refuted sophistry serves no purpose here. I've been clear about what would count as a counterexample to the red/gray chips being something that doesn't belong in a building: relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles in paint/pigment/primer/etc.
Since I don't want to devolve into he said - she said sophistry either, I will concede that you have been consistent in your position.
As I've also stated unequivocally before, if you find industrial paint that has relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles in it that combusts at 430C, then you have a very good contender for the material that the HFJ crew found. Until then, you'll have to stick with incredulity or claims of data fabrication.
False choice fallacy. My argument is that there is more than sufficient provenance for this coating as the material in question. It was applied to every major structural member in the WTC, it has the same qualitative composition as Jones has listed, including the zinc and chromium (see figure 14) as very specifically noted in NCSTAR 1-3C, and it notes the use of iron oxide as pigment. That's a confounding variable, and it's up to Jones to eliminate it.
Of course, a great first step to prove that the material is thermite would be by showing that it combusts in an inert atmosphere. Why didn't Jones do that?
This is NOT what I'm saying at all, at all. I'm saying that the manufacture of relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles is very difficult and most likely more expensive than is required for the manufacture of pigments using iron oxide. Everything I've read and been pointed towards on this subject confirms this.
So because most manufacturers wouldn't bother to do it, all manufacturers don't do it? Or it's impossible? Again, your opinions on what is and is not in the best interest of the paint manufacturer are very interesting, but they have no relevancy on this debate.
A pigment used to make a protective, anti-corrosive paint for every major structural member in two of the tallest free-standing structures in the world most assuredly represents a special case. The manufacturer was given a series of specifications, and met them to the best of their ability.
Paint manufacturers aren't going to process their pigments any further than necessary to make them work. Period.
Please stop ignoring this:
The top of page 100 in the
Pigments book (see above) notes, "The hues of most of the colored inorganic pigments are determined not only by their molecular compositions, but also on particle size and crystalline form." Further down the page, it notes, "The color dependence on average particle size is illustrated by the dominant wavelength of magnetite, which changes from 600 nm to 635 nm as the particles increase [...]"
Interestingly, it appears that magnetite, along with other iron oxide pigments, appears to have a size dependency on fluoresced wavelength. So, it seems that, when iron oxides are used as a pigment, size control and separation are of paramount importance.
If they don't absolutely require uniform particle sizes, then you can guarantee they won't waste their time making them
Are you a paint manufacturer? Do you feel like you can speak for all paint manufacturers in the world now and for the last 50 years?
--unless they form naturally uniform sizes, they won't be in the mix. When, by several techniques, the particles appear strikingly uniform at 100nm, you can pretty much rest assured this wasn't an accident.
I would love to see the particle size distribution done using the quantitative particle sizing methodology I described earlier. What page of the article was that on?
Like I said earlier, it's not surprising that the range of particle sizes in iron oxide pigments goes to 100nm. It would indeed be very surprising if ALL the particles in a pigment sample were 100nm. Clear?
There is no evidence that all of the particles are exactly 100 nm in diameter. "It looks like it" doesn't work in science. Particle sizing, random sampling, isolation and separation. That's what's required to prove this point scientifically.