Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Did the minerals yearbook claim that the only use for Iron Oxide was computer disk drives? The answer to the, again, rather asinine question of whether or not iron oxide is used in pigments and coatings is yes. The answer to the question of particle size can be found in the following texts available from your local university library:

Outlines of Paint Technology, Volume 1: Materials (1982) W. M. Morgans
Page 26 notes that particle size distributions for paints and pigments ranging from 100 nm to 300 nm. It also suggests methods for determining particle sizes in pigments.

Chemistry of Pigments and Fillers (1983) D. H. Solomon and D. G. Hawthorne
Page 301 shows the particle size range for a pigment known as "Pure Yellow Oxide". The accompanying micrograph (figure 7) shows the particle size range, which is also shown in the table above. The listed particle size range is 100 nm to 1.5 µm.


It's not surprising that various pigments use iron oxide in a range of sizes.
It's not surprising that some of those particles are as small as 100 nm.
But to expect the QC processes to produce a relative uniformity of particle sizes is impossible with a capital "I".

There simply is no requirement for pigment particles to be so uniform. It's expensive and unnecessary. It would be like sanding the frame of a house smooth before applying sheetrock. Very time-consuming (and therefore expensive) and totally unnecessary. That level of refinement far exceeds any practical purpose.

Now look at figure 8 and more clearly, figure 9 on page 15: these particles are clearly very close in size--about 100 nm. It is exceedingly unreasonable to theorize that the apparent uniformity of particles ONLY OCCURS IN THESE AREAS.

If this material were paint, we should expect to see a range of sizes of the iron oxide. We don't. Not in any of the images. Did they simply miss the variety of iron oxide particle sizes in all the samples? It's possible. But not likely. You will NEVER crack open a sample of paint and see a relative uniformity of iron oxide particles at 100 nm. Never.

And what of the other properties? Why is this material magnetic? Is there some paint that's magnetic when dried? (I'm asking this sincerely--not sarcastically.) Is there some paint that would produce a concentrated exothermic reaction at 430C? That's extremely unlikely. But not impossible. And what of the iron and silicate spheres produced from the reaction?

Taking all these properties into account, the paint theory leaks like a sieve.



The data I linked to earlier is an example of a pigment/industrial coating, made of iron oxide (among other materials) in a ceramic matrix comprised of alumina and silica. Jones has provided evidence of a pigment/industrial material, made of faceted iron oxide in a matrix of alumina and silica. Why should we not eliminate this material, said to coat the beams of every major structural element in the WTC, from consideration as the source material of the sample analyzed by Jones?


I think it's a fair consideration to compare the material. I do not advocate "hiding" an analysis of it--especially if it will provide a firm basis from which to eliminate a substantial amount of doubt. And if it's a match, then this whole debate is over, and I'm just wrong. So yea, I'd personally like to see this comparison done.


Plausibility cannot be ascertained by either party. The provenance of the sample is in doubt.


What do you mean "the provenance is in doubt"? I know you doubt the data. I know you doubt the conclusions of the researchers. Do you doubt that the material is from the WTC wreckage? Just want to clarify what it is you're doubting.


A better, and more interesting question, is, "What evidence does Jones bring to show that this material was a thermite coating applied to the steel in the WTC towers in order to heat the structure past the point of stability and cause the towers to collapse?" The answer, of course, is none.


First, that's not what the HJF crew is claiming. Second, it doesn't really affect the existence of the evidence to claim it could not have brought the towers down by itself. This kind of tertiary theorizing is fun, but it's not what this discussion is about.

The authors of the paper did propose that "it is indeed possible that such matches, [invented by Los Alamos National Lab], which are designed to be ignited by a simple electric pulse, could contain material similar to the red material we have found in the WTC dust."

But I don't see the point of trying to rule out the significance of the material based on a particular theory of its application if we cannot even agree that this substance is a nano-energetic composite or paint. This is a strange kind of "hedge" against the eventuality of accepting that this material is nanothermitic. If you don't accept that premise, what's the purpose of trying to rule it out based on usage?


I believe the above linked references and information will close the case.


Where have I heard that before?


.
 
Is there some paint that would produce a concentrated exothermic reaction at 430C?

Ummm what item produced a concentrated exothermic reaction? Nothing in the test produced any exothermic reaction. This "paper" had something combust in an oxygen rich environment. YOu cannot claim it was an "exothermic" reaction in an oxygen rich environment. No matter how you try to handwave it, unless you test it in an inert environment, you cannot make that claim.

I think it's a fair consideration to compare the material. I do not advocate "hiding" an analysis of it--especially if it will provide a firm basis from which to eliminate a substantial amount of doubt. And if it's a match, then this whole debate is over, and I'm just wrong. So yea, I'd personally like to see this comparison done.

Great. Then have jones et al do it again using PROPER methodology. While you are at it, denounce this craptacular pile o fail and ask them to send their samples to an independent lab and publish the results openly.

handwave noted.

What do you mean "the provenance is in doubt"? I know you doubt the data. I know you doubt the conclusions of the researchers.
NO, I don't doubt the data. No i don't doubt the researchers. The data, findings, conclusions and anything they have said are invalid due to their massive methodological errors, which you don't defend because you can't. Because their findings, data and conclusions are invalidated by the bad methodology, they need to do it AGAIN. properly.

Do you doubt that the material is from the WTC wreckage? Just want to clarify what it is you're doubting.
I have no idea if the material is from the wtc wreckage. It could be left over from the construction and was released during the collapse. It could be stuff from the collapse and destruction. It could be something released during the clean up when they were using thermic lances to cut debris.

IT could be any of those. Unless you can eliminate any of them, you cannot make claims about what it is from.

The authors of the paper did propose that "it is indeed possible that such matches, [invented by Los Alamos National Lab], which are designed to be ignited by a simple electric pulse, could contain material similar to the red material we have found in the WTC dust."
I have bolded the important part there. Possible and could contain. What does that say in plain english? We have no proof, we have no evidence so we are making **** up .

But I don't see the point of trying to rule out the significance of the material based on a particular theory of its application if we cannot even agree that this substance is a nano-energetic composite or paint.
because you and jones have failed to show that it is anything besides for paint.
bad controls, bad methodology, bad science and you want me to accept the data? What are you high on and why aren't you sharing?
 
You're obviously referring to the RJ Lee report. As you noted, that data from normal building dust was for structures that were standing prior to 9/11 and had therefore not collapsed. Now remember, after the towers fell there was a higher concentration of dust everywhere, definitely far higher than was present beforehand. Post collapse photos alone establishes this. There being a higher amount of microspheres due to this is a logical extention of that fact. The collapse produced orders of magnitude more dust, and given that microspheres were a normal component of the dust, there would obviously be more microspheres present too. So ruling out concrete and other sources due to pre-collapse measurements of their amounts is turning logic on it's head; the fact that the concentrations were less prior to collapse is a perfect indicator that they were liberated by the collapse of the towers, and therefore had come from the same sources that they did prior to collapse.

You have to compare the concentrations relative to this part of the dust which origin is the main building materials (such as concrete): the class A particles. Again, even renormalized in this way, the fraction of iron microspheres is 10 times higher than before the collapse.

0.04/2.57 = 0.0156 << 5.87/35.58 = 0.165

All other publications report several percent of iron in the dust (they all agree on that) but only the RJ Lee report stresses that this iron is often found as iron microspheres. The others seem to not pay much attention to this important discovery.
5% by weight of these spheres in the dust is huge! Means thousands of tons of iron melted. Notice also that the report give evidence that lead vaporized (hence 1800°C was reached) and redeposited on fiber wool.
 
Bump. I'd like to see an answer to this.

Microspheres in your wood ash?! certainly not originated from your wood.
According this study:
http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/pdf1993/misra93a.pdf
there is less than 0.5% of iron in wood ash (see table 4) and there is no fusion of this ash below 1400°C (as explained in the abstract).
We are speaking here of 5% iron microspheres in the WTC dust and the organic material that could burn at the WTC represent a negligible weight fraction of the main building material that we find in this dust.
On the other hand there are always everywhere small iron microspheres at a very low level in the soils thus everywhere in your house. Their origin is micrometeoritic activiy.

F
 
Means thousands of tons of iron melted.

Yet none of the beams showed such melting? How do you explain that? And the microspheres Jones found were supposedly from his "thermite" .....are you suggesting that thousands of tones of thermite were added to the building????:confused:
 
Yet none of the beams showed such melting? How do you explain that? And the microspheres Jones found were supposedly from his "thermite" .....are you suggesting that thousands of tones of thermite were added to the building????:confused:

the main source of all these iron microspheres may have nothing to do with thermite but certainly is related to the high energy weapons that destroyed the towers whatever these are.
 
Wait a minute. I thought Jones' findings were supposed to be thermite? Now they may be some kind of residue of a yet to be defined "high energy weapon"?
 
The "5% iron-rich microspheres" figure is highly suspect. Even if the sample(s) from which this figure was derived were genuine, uncontaminated, and correctly measured, I can think of several different physical processes, including preferential settling out of the dust plume and the action of air currents on standing dust, that would be very likely to significantly concentrate the heavier denser particles relative to other species in a surface-collected dust sample.

The main problem with thermitic origin of iron microspheres (besides the lack of any plausible scenario involving the use of any kind of thermite in the buildings on 9/11) is that no one has shown any mechanism by which particles of that shape and size distribution can be created from thermite reaction products nor from structural metal melted by thermite reaction products. Such sphere formation would be at the very least indicative of extremely poor heat transfer between the reaction product and the material it's supposed to have damaged, because it indicates that the reaction product underwent its liquid to solid phase transition at about 1500°C while out of contact with any other surface. Agitation of molten material during the collapse has been suggested, but that fails to explain the size distribution (specifically, the lack of larger droplets).

Production of such spheres from bulk steel by means of any form of transmitted energy has also not been demonstrated, nor any plausible physical mechanism even suggested.

While I don't have a conclusive finding yet, I'm looking into origination of iron-rich microspheres from the burning of wood and paper. Wood, like all living tissue, contains ferritin proteins. Each ferritin protein complex sequesters up to about 1200 iron atoms in the form of a tiny granule of ferrihydrate. Ferrihydrate is metastable, decomposing spontaneously into hematite in an exothermic reaction, especially when it is no longer in the wet oxidative environments in which it naturally forms (and free of the surface contaminants that abiotic mineral ferrihydrate deposits typically have). My hypothesis is that the ferrihydrate granules, in the hot reducing environment of a flame after being freed by the combusiton of the phytoferritin, condenses and reduces into the iron-rich droplets observed. Self melting of the droplets occurs in the process. No conventional vaporization of iron occurs, or is necessary, at any stage of the process, because the iron exists at the outset in a quasi "dissolved" form as nanoclusters bound within proteins.

It's a somewhat speculative hypothesis, but it has some significant advantages over competing hypotheses including (1) accounting for the upper limit of the microsphere size distribution (due to limited concentrations of iron in the burning wood and paper), and (2) requiring no silent invisible death beams.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Last edited:
It's not surprising that various pigments use iron oxide in a range of sizes.
It's very telling what you decided to quote from my response. Please consider, again, the following:
D. Patterson said:
Pigments: An Introduction to their Physical Chemistry (1967) D. Patterson (ed)
Page 100 identifies several variants of iron oxide pigments and notes "[...] iron oxides with particles of 0.1 µm or less are used as transparent colorants."
jay howard said:
It's not surprising that some of those particles are as small as 100 nm.
This is a significant retreat from your earlier positions that no pigments contained iron oxide and that no pigments contained iron oxide with 100 nm particles. However, this:
But to expect the QC processes to produce a relative uniformity of particle sizes is impossible with a capital "I".
Is an excellent example of the "Moving the Goalposts" tactic. Your original claim was that the iron oxide represented proof that the material is thermite. Now your argument appears to be that thermite (or nano-thermite) is composed of an entirely uniform 100 nm particle matrix. You also seem to believe that it is impossible to create uniform (that is, a sample of particle sizes representing a relative standard deviation of no more than, shall we say, 5% of the average particle diameter) particles. I can assure you, that is false.
There simply is no requirement for pigment particles to be so uniform. It's expensive and unnecessary. It would be like sanding the frame of a house smooth before applying sheetrock. Very time-consuming (and therefore expensive) and totally unnecessary. That level of refinement far exceeds any practical purpose.
Again, if you had read the entirety of my response, you would have noticed that I already addressed this claim:
The Almond said:
The top of page 100 in the Pigments book (see above) notes, "The hues of most of the colored inorganic pigments are determined not only by their molecular compositions, but also on particle size and crystalline form." Further down the page, it notes, "The color dependence on average particle size is illustrated by the dominant wavelength of magnetite, which changes from 600 nm to 635 nm as the particles increase [...]"

Interestingly, it appears that magnetite, along with other iron oxide pigments, appears to have a size dependency on fluoresced wavelength. So, it seems that, when iron oxides are used as a pigment, size control and separation are of paramount importance.
There is a size dependency for iron oxide particles. Larger particles produce different colors when the size range is extremely small. This particle size control is critical to consistent paint colorization.
Now look at figure 8 and more clearly, figure 9 on page 15: these particles are clearly very close in size--about 100 nm.
In order to establish uniformity, the authors would have needed to do quantitative particle sizing, which would have required the use of the a scale calibration artifact. They would have needed to image a random sampling of particles and determined the size distribution from the calibration information. Without such data, no quantitative information about the size or uniformity of the particles can be determined. I don't doubt that they look roughly uniform, or that their average particle size is probably 100 nm, but I point this out to note that, scientifically speaking, this point has not been proven robustly.

If this material were paint, we should expect to see a range of sizes of the iron oxide. We don't.
How do we know what the range and relative standard deviation of particle diameters are? The answer "It looks like it" doesn't fly in a scientific publication.
Not in any of the images. Did they simply miss the variety of iron oxide particle sizes in all the samples?
Their work indicates to me that the authors of the paper are incompetent. I would posit that they simply did not use the appropriate methodology to establish the veracity of their claims.
You will NEVER crack open a sample of paint and see a relative uniformity of iron oxide particles at 100 nm. Never.
In whose opinion?
And what of the other properties? Why is this material magnetic?
Is all thermite magnetic? Does that imply that all that which is magnetic is thermite?
Is there some paint that's magnetic when dried? (I'm asking this sincerely--not sarcastically.)
Any paint that uses hematite or magnetite in any significant concentration would be magnetic. A user's ability to "detect" magnetic fields using a magnet would depend on the strength of the magnet and the overall content of magnetic material. The magnetic properties of a material can be changed if the material is heated near the Curie point.
Is there some paint that would produce a concentrated exothermic reaction at 430C?
In an oxygen atmosphere, any material containing carbon will combust. Further, this material exhibited energy densities greater than those of thermite. Thermite is excluded on conservation of energy grounds.
That's extremely unlikely. But not impossible. And what of the iron and silicate spheres produced from the reaction?
Again, iron and silicate spheres are a common product of combustion. They are a common component of ash. Myriad has noted the production of magnetic particles from wood ash. These silica and alumina spheres are essentially a glass eutectic, the melting point of the combined material is lower than either of the pure materials. Interestingly, the NCSTAR 1-3C also notes that the pigment applied to the WTC structure contained diatomaceous silica and silica sand.

I think it's a fair consideration to compare the material. I do not advocate "hiding" an analysis of it--especially if it will provide a firm basis from which to eliminate a substantial amount of doubt. And if it's a match, then this whole debate is over, and I'm just wrong. So yea, I'd personally like to see this comparison done.
What I'm saying is that, given that the Sramek coating was applied to every structural member in both WTC 1 and 2, it's far more likely that Jones's material is just that. Jones needs to provide evidence that it's not that. His extraordinary claim, his evidence.

Then again, all Jones has to do is burn the samples in argon, and prove that the material will combust without oxygen. Why didn't he do that again?

What do you mean "the provenance is in doubt"? I know you doubt the data. I know you doubt the conclusions of the researchers. Do you doubt that the material is from the WTC wreckage? Just want to clarify what it is you're doubting.
Jones's stated purpose in his research is to find evidence that members of the US government were complicit in the destruction of the twin towers and WTC 7. To do that, we should only consider evidence whose chain of custody would be acceptable in court. It's worth noting that to even initiate a "grand jury" investigation, Jones would need to show an admissible form of evidence.

We're not looking at admissible evidence.

Despite Jones's insistence that the samples come from the WTC (and I'll admit that it's likely that they do), the method of collection and chain of custody issues would cause his evidence to be thrown out. What's further, Jones needs to establish the validity of his sampling method (that would have required a random sampling shortly after the collapse from clean sources) and the statistical relevance of his data (which would require comparison to a variety of standards including ashes from other high-rise fires). He's done none of that. The importance, relevance of the data and the origin of the samples need to be established in a robust, statistically valid way. That's provenance. That's what's missing.

First, that's not what the HJF crew is claiming. Second, it doesn't really affect the existence of the evidence to claim it could not have brought the towers down by itself. This kind of tertiary theorizing is fun, but it's not what this discussion is about.

The authors of the paper did propose that "it is indeed possible that such matches, [invented by Los Alamos National Lab], which are designed to be ignited by a simple electric pulse, could contain material similar to the red material we have found in the WTC dust."

But I don't see the point of trying to rule out the significance of the material based on a particular theory of its application if we cannot even agree that this substance is a nano-energetic composite or paint. This is a strange kind of "hedge" against the eventuality of accepting that this material is nanothermitic. If you don't accept that premise, what's the purpose of trying to rule it out based on usage?
Let's look at the idea that the material is nano-energetic. If it is, but it was not directly related to the collapse of the towers (as in the case of a thermite "match"), then its relevance is trivial. The material is nano-energetic, but it's use and reason for being there are left as questions. That throws the idea that it was planted there for nefarious purposes out the window. In other words, if it's a thermite match, why bother with it instead of a standard electrical pulse primer (and it's a match that has to be set off with an electric pulse!)?

If the material is thermite paint, applied directly to the columns in order to melt them and ensure collapse, the authors have to show why anyone would bother to do this. The thickness of the "nano energetic paint" is not sufficient, given the material as thermite, to heat the columns appreciably. So what are we left with?

It's up to the authors to show why their data are meaningful. Just throwing out data with no cause or link to relevancy is lazy, irresponsible science. It's not up to the reader to draw conclusions, it's up to the authors.

What's unfortunate is the way that the rest of the Truth movement has interpreted the results. Gage has happily added the "thermite found in dust" to his list of moronic reasons why the towers couldn't have collapsed on their own. It's already become a talking point, and that's precisely what the authors wanted. Without proving a single relevant fact, they want us to believe they've solved the mystery of the missing thermite.

Bull honkey.
 
I dont understand how the large concentration of iron rich microspheres at WTC could be correlated to the WTC fires because the fires at WTC could not reach the iron melting point.

Fred, how do you think that iron micropsheres form in fly ash in the first place?

if a normal fire can indeed produce iron microspheres as someone suggested in this thread, please explain to me how this can be ...

Fred

I imagine it would be through the same process by which those microspheres are formed in fly ash.
 
i forgot to make clear in my previous post that i can understand why the fly ash from a metal furnace has iron microspheres: just because the temperature of the burning coal there is over 1500°C the melting point of Fe. Whis was not the case in the WTC fires.


Oops, I didn’t’ read this part before I posted my response above.

Why do you think that a burning coal furnace can reach 1500C, but that the fires in the WTC towers did not?

Coal and jet fuel are essentially the both hydrocarbon fuels. There is no difference between a coal fired furnace with a natural draft chimney and the fire floors in the WTC where the smoke was exiting out the upper floors of the building.

Even a simple candle can generate temperatures of 1400C in the flame.
 
On the other hand i was ready to accept that these iron microspheres had their source in the fly ash used as a material in the production of concrete:
these would have been part of the concrete from the begining but the data from normal building dust and WTC dust before 911, clearly shows that their concentration from this source only should be very small, much smaller than observed! Right ?
Fred

Fred, I’m not sure where you are coming up with some of these assumptions.

1) I agree with you that it is very likely that fly ash was incorporated into the lightweight concrete used in the construction of the WTC towers. And yes, these would have been in the concrete from the beginning.

2) You wrote: “ the data from normal building dust and WTC dust before 911.” Where did you get a sample from WTC dust from BEFORE 9/11? Is this something new? I have not heard that anyone had such a thing before this. Can you provide any details on how this was obtained?

3) Even if we assume that the “normal” background dust was collected in a third party building which used the same lightweight concrete mix as the WTC towers, that would not mean that the “normal” background dust would have the same percentage of iron microspheres as did the WTC dust.

Since the concrete in the WTC towers was broken up and “dustified” (as Judy Woods would say) during the collapse, while the concrete in the third party building in which we collected the background dust sample was not, there is no reason to assume that the percentages of iron microspheres in both samples should be equal.
 
TruthersLie said:
Is there some paint that would produce a concentrated exothermic reaction at 430C?

Ummm what item produced a concentrated exothermic reaction? Nothing in the test produced any exothermic reaction. This "paper" had something combust in an oxygen rich environment. YOu cannot claim it was an "exothermic" reaction in an oxygen rich environment. No matter how you try to handwave it, unless you test it in an inert environment, you cannot make that claim.

To be fair to Jay, combustion in an oxygen-containing atmosphere is an exothermic reaction, albeit one that cannot proceed without the presence of oxygen. So, realistically, the answer to Jay's question is that any kind of paint with an organic binder will produce an exothermic reaction at somewhere around 430ºC. There really isn't anything even vaguely unexpected about paint catching fire.

Dave
 
To be fair to Jay, combustion in an oxygen-containing atmosphere is an exothermic reaction, albeit one that cannot proceed without the presence of oxygen. So, realistically, the answer to Jay's question is that any kind of paint with an organic binder will produce an exothermic reaction at somewhere around 430ºC. There really isn't anything even vaguely unexpected about paint catching fire.

Dave

Dave.

You are correct. It was late and I was reading exothermic as thermitic in my reply.

what they showed is that something combusted at 430 C in an oxygen rich environment with a higher energy density than thermite can produce.

Which is again a methodological error to try to prove it was thermite/nanothermite/godzilla poo they should have used an inert atmosphere.
 
Oops, I didn’t’ read this part before I posted my response above.

Why do you think that a burning coal furnace can reach 1500C, but that the fires in the WTC towers did not?

because the Nist reaches in its simulation the maximum for a fire in open air : 1100°C. this is already extreme!

Coal and jet fuel are essentially the both hydrocarbon fuels. There is no difference between a coal fired furnace with a natural draft chimney and the fire floors in the WTC where the smoke was exiting out the upper floors of the building.

Even a simple candle can generate temperatures of 1400C in the flame.

this is still far from the iron melting point. in a metal furnace the heat is "concentrated" in time and space and the oxygenation conditions are optimal. such that you can melt iron.

The worse is again that even if you could produce these microspheres in a fire you would be very very far from several percent in weight of the dust.
All flammable materials in the whole tower represent a negligible weight (not to mention that a small number of floors were actually on fire before collapse) as compared to 90000 tons of pulverized concrete.
 
Most interesting posts by F H-C et al.

I'd like to make the observation that Frédéric also seems confused by the various possibilities, and hasn't settled on any strong hypothesis yet.

1) He states that 'The chips are very thin but there are photos strongly suggesting that the thermite was applied in a multilayered red/grey/red/grey.... that could reach millimeters in total thickness.... so sorry again but i really see no problem with this scenario.'

but

2) 'the main source of all these iron microspheres may have nothing to do with thermite but certainly is related to the high energy weapons that destroyed the towers whatever these are.'

He seems to argue for Judy Wood -type DEW weapons here. This has nothing to do with thermite or nano-whateveritis

3) nanoparticles of elemental Alu dont exist in nature: Al is always oxydized in surface bery fast, and for a 40nm particle, this surface is very soon the whole particle itself exposed to oxygen of the air.

This is the only reason i see to really question the presence of a black ship among these truthers who may have falsified the data in order to decredibilize the whole study and i'm surprised that nobody has mentionned this issue here : how could elemental nanoAlu remain activate 7 years after 911: hardly possible without a very efficient coating according the studies i have read on the subject. Or storage in very dry and oxygen depleted conditions...

So Frédéric seems to argue variously for Truther fraud (Jones and co. presumably), DEW weapons and nanothermite paint.

I don't know how to make head or tails out of all that. Just wanted to point it out - I'm sure others have noticed the contradictions as well.

btw, F H-C wrote that temps couldn't have reached 1500°C based solely on the fact that
'Nist reaches in its simulation the maximum for a fire in open air : 1100°C. '

Isn't it just cherry-picking to seize on this, yet dismiss the other NIST findings? Besides, NIST is not the only source for valid arguments and data - why indeed couldn't the huge fires have produced temps high enough to create iron-rich microspheres?

There's lots of evidence of fires, but nothing for thermite (where's the melted steel?). Seems a reasonable hypothesis to me.
 
ALien;

I believe the problem is that it would take over 100 layers of this alleged thermitic paint, based on THEIR numbers, to raise the temperature of steel it is applied to any significant degree. For each "layer" it would have to be sprayed on, allowed to dry, then another layer applied (otherwise you would get a blend of primer and paint, not a layer of each followed by another layer of each).

This would have to be done a hundred times, and if that were the case (A) through what plausible scenario could this be done in the cases of those buildings, and (B) Explain to me how you could apply layer after layer and not have each layer REACT as it is applied, rather then build up.

This idea of "100 layers" of thermitic paint is just off the charts implausible, IMO.

TAM:)
 
Some of [the black areas in the image] is most definitely H. As I said earlier in response to this, they likely used a filter or just reduced the intensities to demonstrate separation and concentration of certain components.
Anyway, there should be something there. Something as in, not nothing. Remember the XEDS spectrum shown in fig. 14. It shows peaks for: C, O, Fe, Zn, Al, Si, S, Ca, Cr, plus Mg (present but not marked in fig. 14 and present and marked in fig. 17), and Na, Cl, and P (fig. 18) and (as noted by Sunstealer) K.

Are you claiming that *all of these* are contamination? My, that's a lot of contamination. Isn't it more likely that the black areas correspond to an element present in the spectrum but that we're not shown at all? Do you still maintain, looking at figs. 14 and 15, that the MEK-soaked chip has anything at all in common with samples 1-4, besides the color? (Remember that the authors admit that Zn and Cr are sometimes seen in the red layers; see caption of Fig. 14, but we're not shown the XEDS maps for Zn and Cr. We're not told what that "sometimes" means - "sometimes" as in, some chips have them and some others don't? That plainly means that the chips are different.)

And, even if you were right and the data were filtered to show concentration of certain components (which I doubt), what would be the basis to affirm that there's a substantial amount of Fe2O3 based on figure 15? Figure 15 shows that most of the O is correlated to Si and not to the Fe, so there's no basis to state that "Oxygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron in the red material even after soaking in MEK solvent (Fig. 15)" (sic) (p.19).


The matrix material is most definitely a hydrocarbon, so there should be C and O throughout all the maps.
Which burns in an oxygen-rich atmosphere, by the way. But that's not established for the MEK-soaked chip, which is of a different nature to that of samples 1-4. Remember, a magnet can attract lots of things; if you pick only red-grey ones, but you fail to make any effort to classify them and ensure that you're handling all of the same kind, as happens in the paper, then you can easily end up with a non-uniform mixture leading you to wrong conclusions, as happens in the paper.

Would you rationalize that the MEK caused the hydrocarbon matrix to break down chemically? An insignificant percentage may indeed have broken down, however, we should still expect to see C and O throughout the entire sample. But we don't. Why not? Because they are using XEDS as a qualitative technique to demonstrate relative concentrations of various elements.
A better explanation is that the MEK-soaked chip is fundamentally different from samples 1-4.

If you want to postulate the existence of elemental Fe, be my guest. I don't see how that gets you any closer to dismissing the significance of this material, but it's not inconceivable that it exists. Did the elemental Al disappear yet?
Yet once again: I don't claim there's elemental Fe, that's entirely your claim. Not oxidized does not mean elemental. Same with Al: not oxidized does not mean elemental, and you have no basis to claim that it's in elemental form, because you can't exclude other elements that could also be bound to Al. We're just not shown other elements present in the XEDS spectrum that could be bound to Fe and to Al. Using only the data given, there's no basis to claim that there's elemental Al. However, it's a fact that we lack XEDS maps for other elements present in that particular chip, that are not present in samples 1-4 as the XEDS spectra show. You only bring up incredulity to support that they should be the same thing. The data shows otherwise. The claim that there's elemental Al in samples 1-4 can't be sustained, as it's based in comparing things of a very different nature. It would be established if there were no other elements in that chip as in samples 1-4, and if the spectrum for that chip matched that of samples 1-4. But that's not the case; they show unoxidized aluminium in one chip and make two claims that aren't supported by their data: that the aluminium is elemental, and that the same applies to samples 1-4. There's strong evidence, presented by Sunstealer, that in samples 1-4 the aluminium is not free but in the form of an aluminosilicate, thus it's unsustainable that the aluminium is in elemental form in any of the samples.
 
The "5% iron-rich microspheres" figure is highly suspect. Even if the sample(s) from which this figure was derived were genuine, uncontaminated, and correctly measured, I can think of several different physical processes, including preferential settling out of the dust plume and the action of air currents on standing dust, that would be very likely to significantly concentrate the heavier denser particles relative to other species in a surface-collected dust sample.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that the use of a magnet would also have an influence in attracting little iron spheres already present in the dust. Which can explain a higher concentration of them than usual.
 
I am almost sure that fig. 25 is a pic. from cement/flyash and not from the post-DSC.
Fig. 27 is indeed a pic. of flyash.
In Denmark we use up to 30% flyash in cement.
So why the fuss about iron-rich spheres in the dust from WTC.(not the samples)
And why call them iron-rich, why not O,Si,Al,Ti,S,Mg C,K,Ca-rich.
These elements are found in flyash.
We need pic. af the DSC-residues.
The flame-test is a joke and the corrosponding pics. is an insult.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom