Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Not combustion of an isolated micrometer particle that produces such a huge iron microsphere! so either you trust the authors when they say that they obtained these photographs on an isolated chip after heating at less than 500°c in their DSC and this alone is hard evidence or you dont trust them... i.e you suggest that they have completely invented these results and that is a major accusation...

To be honest, I think they're a bunch of lying, stinking weasels who would frame their own grandmothers if they thought it would make them look clever. However, that's beside the point. Are you suggesting that the microsphere produced was much bigger than the material that reacted to produce it? If not, then you need to work on expressing concepts more clearly. If so, then you need to look into the law of conservation of mass-energy.

I think it's possible that some substance in the chip reacted with atmospheric oxygen and produced a spherical particle with a significant iron content. I think it's even possible that some combination of chemicals in the debris may have reacted in some thermite-like reaction. I think it completely impossible that the reaction observed by Harrit et al was not primarily combustion in atmospheric oxygen, and neither can anyone else who is rational and possessed of at least minimal expertise. And I think it completely impossible that any such reaction was in any way even a partial cause of the collapse of the Twin Towers, with the same dependent clause.

Dave
 
Jones is trying to force a conclusion because he wants something that will get him noticed. His fans are non-scientists because they do not realize that the paper has no substance. I will not bother discussing the Jones team lack of a competent chemist when selecting MEK as a solvent for cured paint,

Just finished reading right through this thread to see if anyone else had posted about something interesting I found. It took a few days but it appears no one has.

The use of MEK struck me as curious as if the particle were thermite then why treat them with anything other than perhaps a quick wash before testing to see if they were indeed thermitic so I did a little google searching for "MEK" and "Thermite" and came across a very illuminating Patent here:

www(dot)freepatentsonline(dot)com/3890166(dot)html

Sorry not enough posts yet to post the URL, basically its US patent 3890166

scroll down the page a bit and you can download a pdf of the actual patent and the text is online too

The patent is outlining methods for "activating" aluminium, ie make it more reactive, for use in Thermite and claim 14 specifically mentions, and first on their list is, MEK.
Now its possible Jones et al did not know of this work and inadvertently used MEK on the samples which merely makes them grossly incompetent. A less generous view would be that they deliberately used MEK on the sample so that any aluminium in them would react more vigorously.

Jones et al were not testing for thermitic material........they were making it.
 
Of course. The known abundance of iron in the dust is 2%. If you select iron with a magnet in the dust you find that 10% of it is in the form of iron (almost pure) microspheres. Hence these microspheres represent at least 0.2% in weight of the dust. This is HUGE: more than 100 tons of melted and pulverized iron (as indicated by the micron size) per tower. Many of them show the signature Aluminum+ Iron.

Thus i dont know where it comes from but the idea that this is fly ash from a normal fire (i mean not a fire in a métall furnace that can concentrate the heat) is simply ridiculous.

A crash plane is not a high density of energy (energy released per unit volume) process

F H-C

Just to get the proper perspective, what do you think happened on 9/11?
 
Alternatively, given the skills of his team, he has simultaneously discovered red paint and celebrity, of sorts.

Still waiting to see if anyone can produce some paint that has the same properties as the red chip material.

The substance of your post rehashes much of what we've already discussed: you don't agree with the methods of the HJF crew, therefore you reject their findings. Or, you think they're just liars in search of temporary fame. Fine. That may be psychologically satisfying, but it doesn't make the significance of this substance disappear. It doesn't make this substance turn into paint or corrosion protection. Calling someone a "liar" is sometimes justified. Sometimes they are simply lying. But when the accused can produce multiple corroborative tests of multiple samples of material, especially when this material appears to be highly processed, accusations of mendacity are nothing more than arguments from incredulity.

Is that now a good argument?

.
 
"Still waiting to see if anyone can produce some paint that has the same properties as the red chip material."

What properties other than burning in air? And why just paint?

That may be psychologically satisfying, but it doesn't make the significance of this substance disappear.

What significance?.........the tests are not scientifically valid so the results have zero significance

But when the accused can produce multiple corroborative tests of multiple samples of material, especially when this material appears to be highly processed

Since we neither have multiple valid tests and since paint (and a million other man made materials) is "highly processed" they are evidence of nothing.
Why won't they do proper testing?


Is that now a good argument?

no. they make extraordinary claims but provide no evidence (in legal or scientific terms) to back them up.
 
Still waiting to see if anyone can produce some paint that has the same properties as the red chip material.

Spare us.....

The red chips didnt have any magical properties....this has already been discussed at length in this (and other) threads...

Nothing about the red chips is out of the ordinary.

The substance of your post rehashes much of what we've already discussed: you don't agree with the methods of the HJF crew, therefore you reject their findings. Or, you think they're just liars in search of temporary fame. Fine. That may be psychologically satisfying, but it doesn't make the significance of this substance disappear. It doesn't make this substance turn into paint or corrosion protection. Calling someone a "liar" is sometimes justified. Sometimes they are simply lying. But when the accused can produce multiple corroborative tests of multiple samples of material, especially when this material appears to be highly processed, accusations of mendacity are nothing more than arguments from incredulity.

Their "mulitple corroborative" tests didnt corroborate anything.

They did several tests...some of which were handled very poorly...and found different materials.

There tests don't even prove what they are trying to prove....what was the point of the resistence test?

What paint sample did they use as a control?

Most of their evidence is too subjective to be useful and isn't thorough enough to be useful. This has all been discussed AT LENGTH in this thread and other threads.

This is why this paper gets NO NOTICE OR CONSIDERATION from the engineering and scientific community...we aren't impressed by the paper.

Try again.
 
Still waiting to see if anyone can produce some paint that has the same properties as the red chip material.

Still waiting to see if anyone can produce a viable scenario in which it's possible to sever columns by heating them by 4ºC. Still waiting to see if anyone can produce a viable scenario in which it's possible to sever large structural columns in any way whatsoever using any variant whatsoever of thermite. Still waiting to see if any truthers can spot the contradiction between the assertions that split-second timing was needed to initiate and propagate the collapses, and that the columns were melted by a thermite reaction. Still waiting for any signs of critical self-analysis from any part of the truth movement.

Dave
 
Still waiting to see if anyone can produce some paint that has the same properties as the red chip material.

Why? I don't need to.

As far as the rest of the world is concerned, it is an interesting thingee in the dust.

AS far as sunstealer showed, it could be paint.

You (Jones, et al.) are the one making the claims, then they need to eliminate that it could be paint.

Which they haven't done.

From using a bad control
to testing in an oxygen rich environment
to using MEK which makes aluminum more reactive
through the list of 20 methdological errors.

Until you all can do real science, and get it in an real journal it is nothing more than a vanity paper.


The substance of your post rehashes much of what we've already discussed: you don't agree with the methods of the HJF crew, therefore you reject their findings.

It isn't that I don't agree with there methods. Their methodology is so ****ed up it invalidates any findings.

it isn't about having different methods to get to the conclusions. Their methods are bad, so their findings, data and conclusions are invaliated.

What part of that do you not understand?

Or, you think they're just liars in search of temporary fame.

Not at all. I think they all have a serious form of confirmation bias which is skewing any and all tests into "da guvmint did it."

look at FHC. He had dust samples. He couldn't find any of these chips. Instead of saying the logical thing (maybe they aren't that representative, maybe my sample doesn't have them) he jumps to the possibility that his samples were tampered with BEFORE HE GOT THEM. Huh? Say what?

Fine. That may be psychologically satisfying, but it doesn't make the significance of this substance disappear.

It is psychologically satisfying watching people who are incompetend fail, and then try to pass off their results to ignorant individuals.

YOu still haven't shown what this substance is. It is much closer to K and paint than to thermite/nanothermite/godzilla poo.

It doesn't make this substance turn into paint or corrosion protection. Calling someone a "liar" is sometimes justified. Sometimes they are simply lying.

when you can show proper methodology that any exothermic reaction occured, great. I'll cheer you on. Until then you have nothing.

Send any samples to independent labs... is that soooo freaking hard?

But when the accused can produce multiple corroborative tests of multiple samples of material, especially when this material appears to be highly processed, accusations of mendacity are nothing more than arguments from incredulity.

when the accused produce multiple tests which have different energy densities, different results and are all over the place in ONE PAPER which has yet to be replicated, then it is bogus and junk.
 
But when the accused can produce multiple corroborative tests of multiple samples of material, especially when this material appears to be highly processed, accusations of mendacity are nothing more than arguments from incredulity.

What you usually want is to replicate results independently, not simply have the original experimenters do the same thing again and say that the findings are "corroborated".

However, in this case, I don't think anyone will attempt to replicate the findings, because to do so would mean following the methodology described in the paper. If the methodology is flawed, then replicating the results doesn't necessarily mean anything.

You may argue that the methodology is sound, but let's allow the scientific community to decide that. We'll see how many reputable scientists think it's worth their time to attempt to replicate the results.
 
Just finished reading right through this thread to see if anyone else had posted about something interesting I found. It took a few days but it appears no one has.

The use of MEK struck me as curious as if the particle were thermite then why treat them with anything other than perhaps a quick wash before testing to see if they were indeed thermitic so I did a little google searching for "MEK" and "Thermite" and came across a very illuminating Patent here:

www(dot)freepatentsonline(dot)com/3890166(dot)html

Sorry not enough posts yet to post the URL, basically its US patent 3890166

scroll down the page a bit and you can download a pdf of the actual patent and the text is online too

The patent is outlining methods for "activating" aluminium, ie make it more reactive, for use in Thermite and claim 14 specifically mentions, and first on their list is, MEK.
Now its possible Jones et al did not know of this work and inadvertently used MEK on the samples which merely makes them grossly incompetent. A less generous view would be that they deliberately used MEK on the sample so that any aluminium in them would react more vigorously.

Jones et al were not testing for thermitic material........they were making it.

I always wondered why the MEK.
 
What properties other than burning in air? And why just paint?

The SE microscopy clearly reveals fairly uniform nanoscale particles in a bi-layered matrix. When heated to 430C the material forms iron and silicate microspheres. That seems like an unusual property for a building material.

I cited paint because pteridine made reference to it. Include other building materials in the scope of other possible materials if you like. I don't think that will get you any closer to finding a match.

What significance?.........the tests are not scientifically valid so the results have zero significance

The significance that this material is NOT a normal building material. What is it? Why is it there? If it is indeed something normal and expected, why can't someone just say "hey, this dried _________ coating does the exact same thing as the red/gray chips..." and show a BSE image with the same morphology? If it's normal building material, this should be a piece of cake.

Since we neither have multiple valid tests and since paint (and a million other man made materials) is "highly processed" they are evidence of nothing.
Why won't they do proper testing?

What do you mean "valid"? By "highly processed" I mean that the red material is composed of relatively uniform nanoscale particles that have been finely mixed. Is paint composed of 100 nm iron oxide particles? Other building materials? Paint is processed, however, it doesn't need to be made in a lab.

Again, if you want to throw out all the evidence because it's not up to your standards, you must still contend with the original claim. Throwing out evidence doesn't refute the issue in question, it just puts it in the "unknown" category. But it doesn't make sense that you'd throw out the BSE images or the DSC data or the fact that iron and silicate microspheres were produced when the chips were heated or the comparative XEDS data and morphology of the samples.

Are you dismissing that data because you don't like the MEK soaking data or because you don't think the XEDS data was done under the right conditions? Do you know what the likelihood of accidentally producing Al peaks is? Are you postulating that the MEK soaked chip was another material entirely?

It would help tremendously if you told me what you DO believe about the chips in question as there are many ad hoc theories whose only purpose is to deny the reality of the material. Do you believe the 4 samples contain the same kind of material? Is the material composed of nanoscale particles? etc.

.
 
So outside of ALL of the other errors in method, analysis, and general approach, we now find out (if sheeplesnshills info is accurate and correctly interpreted) that they used a WASH that has been shown to make Aluminum MORE REACTIVE? Lord JHC.

TAM:)
 
Is paint composed of 100 nm iron oxide particles?
Yes.

Are you dismissing that data because you don't like the MEK soaking data or because you don't think the XEDS data was done under the right conditions?
The XEDS data were incorrectly processed, collected, analyzed and reported. See above for details.
Do you know what the likelihood of accidentally producing Al peaks is?
In the presence of bromine or thulium, the likelihood is 100%. Then again, the likelihood of incompetent researchers pushing the Quant button and misinterpreting the results is also 100%.
[/quote]
 
=jay howard;5705325]The SE microscopy clearly reveals fairly uniform nanoscale particles in a bi-layered matrix. When heated to 430C the material forms iron and silicate microspheres. That seems like an unusual property for a building material.

The paper does not show that it is an unusual property for a building material, they only test paint of unknown manuafacture. It might seem like an unusual property but they have not shown that it is.

I cited paint because pteridine made reference to it. Include other building materials in the scope of other possible materials if you like. I don't think that will get you any closer to finding a match.

Its not my paper, I don't have to find anything. Jones et al have to show that there is no match. They do not even try to do that.

The significance that this material is NOT a normal building material. What is it? Why is it there? If it is indeed something normal and expected, why can't someone just say "hey, this dried _________ coating does the exact same thing as the red/gray chips..." and show a BSE image with the same morphology? If it's normal building material, this should be a piece of cake.

Again, show that it is not a normal building material!

What do you mean "valid"? By "highly processed" I mean that the red material is composed of relatively uniform nanoscale particles that have been finely mixed. Is paint composed of 100 nm iron oxide particles? Other building materials? Paint is processed, however, it doesn't need to be made in a lab.

No evidence is presented that the material Jones claims to have found had to have been made in a lab either......

Again, if you want to throw out all the evidence because it's not up to your standards, you must still contend with the original claim. Throwing out evidence doesn't refute the issue in question, it just puts it in the "unknown" category. But it doesn't make sense that you'd throw out the BSE images or the DSC data or the fact that iron and silicate microspheres were produced when the chips were heated or the comparative XEDS data and morphology of the samples.

Without documented control samples the results are absolutely meaningless, doubly so because MEK is a documented activator of Al.

Are you dismissing that data because you don't like the MEK soaking data or because you don't think the XEDS data was done under the right conditions? Do you know what the likelihood of accidentally producing Al peaks is? Are you postulating that the MEK soaked chip was another material entirely?

I have no idea what it was and neither do Jones et al as they never bothered to find out and I don't think them soaking it in MEK was an accident.

It would help tremendously if you told me what you DO believe about the chips in question as there are many ad hoc theories whose only purpose is to deny the reality of the material. Do you believe the 4 samples contain the same kind of material? Is the material composed of nanoscale particles? etc.


How would that help? I have never seen or examined the chips and the Jones paper does not provide a reliable source of any data so I could make an informed guess. However if I HAD to hazard a guess I'd say its a chip of paint containing iron and AL oxides and possibly Al particles.
 

The only thing I've found about nano sized Fe2O3 particles from that link is quite interesting:
USGS said:
Potential uses for nanosized (less than 0.1 micron or 100 nanometers) iron oxide particles include catalysts and ferrofluids. Uses for ferrofluids include computer disk drives and high-performance loud speakers; other applications are in biology and medicine, including nuclear magnetic resonance imaging (Vollath, 2008, p. 2, 5).


Were they manufacturing high-performance speakers or some other type of high-end manufacturing in the WTC buildings? That's your "case closed" argument?


The XEDS data were incorrectly processed, collected, analyzed and reported. See above for details.

In the presence of bromine or thulium, the likelihood is 100%. Then again, the likelihood of incompetent researchers pushing the Quant button and misinterpreting the results is also 100%.

Again, if you want to throw the evidence out, you haven't refuted anything. You've just reduced the debate to a question of verification. Do you think it's likely that the material contains bromine or thulium?

(Common uses for thulium: lasers and power for portable x-ray machines)
(Common uses for bromine: Gasoline antiknock mixtures, Fumigants, Poisons, Dyes, Photographic chemicals, Medicinals, Brominated vegetable oil)

Or is it more likely that the material simply contains Al?

.
 
This paper was published in April 2009 wasn't it?

Why is it that further tests have not been breathlessly published for the public? I would guess that the results have been disappointing, so the Jones boys are not going to push any further, except with their rhetoric.

I note that not even FH-C was able to reproduce the results given a valid sample of the dust. He seems to be enthusiastic about the theory, so there's no reason to suspect he isn't honest about his results.
This does not bode well for the nanothermite theory at all.

I'm tempted to think that it's fast becoming a dead issue in terms of real science. As it should.
 
Were they manufacturing high-performance speakers or some other type of high-end manufacturing in the WTC buildings? That's your "case closed" argument?

LOL, something can be present without there being a commercial use for it.


Again, if you want to throw the evidence out, you haven't refuted anything.

What evidence???? You have been repeatedly shown that NO evidence results from this paper. The errors in methodology negate all data derived.
Let them test the material again without errors and get the paper into a real peer reviewed journal then we can talk about evidence.
You've just reduced the debate to a question of verification.

Reduced? Verification is a critical part of the scientific method. If results cannot be verified then they are worthless.

Do you think it's likely that the material contains bromine or thulium?
Who cares if they contain unobtainium? They have no provenance and the experiments were incorrectly carried out so what they say they contained is completely meaningless. I could say that U235 was in the dust with equal validity.


Or is it more likely that the material simply contains Al?

It may well do in some form, which makes it crystal clear why they choose MEK to soak it in......
 
The only thing I've found about nano sized Fe2O3 particles from that link is quite interesting:


Were they manufacturing high-performance speakers or some other type of high-end manufacturing in the WTC buildings? That's your "case closed" argument?

Wait a second....I thought that any and all nano sized iron MUST be from molten iron via a thermite reaction?

And now you tell me that nano sized Fe2O3 is found in something ELSE?

Say it ain't so..........
 
Were they manufacturing high-performance speakers or some other type of high-end manufacturing in the WTC buildings? That's your "case closed" argument?

Would you care to try a little harder to confuse the issue? I think one or two people may have failed to notice that you deliberately missed out "computer disc drives". But, hey, it was a 21st century office building; why would it have anything like that in it?

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom