The Almond
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Nov 7, 2006
- Messages
- 1,015
X-ray Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy provides elemental compositional information, but not information about bonding. X-ray Diffraction and X-ray Wavelength Dispersive Spectroscopy can provide such information, in addition to a variety of incident ion techniques.Are you claiming to know this from the XEDS graphs? I hope you're aware that XEDS can't give chemical compositions.
It also can't demonstrate the absence of a particular compound. Remember that XEDS is a surface technique. The compositional information comes only from the first few microns at most, and in the case of oxygen and aluminum X-rays, the first few hundred nanometers. The particles and substances in question here are tens of microns thick, with matrix composition and heterogeneity which are largely invisible to the technique.A photo comparison and XEDS cannot "demonstrate" the presence of a particular chemical species.
Given that the MEK-soaked chip positively demonstrated the existence of elemental Al, your response is that it must be yet another unidentified material from the red/gray chips...
Ok, you've been claiming this a lot, but there is no evidence to support Jones's assertion that there is too much aluminum in the spectrum than can be accounted for by bonding to oxygen. It should be noted that Jones bases his conclusion on the "common" quantification routine. The routine he's referring to is known as standardless quant, and it requires 3 assumptions to be true about the sample.
1) The sample must be flat, conductive and measured at vacuum.
2) The matrix must be completely visible (to the incident radiation), and be free from confounding radiation.
3) The sample must be homogeneous and isotropic in all 3 dimensions.
Why are we considering these assumptions? Because none of them are true of the chip in question. The chip is large, heterogeneous, rough and may contain hydrogen, lithium and beryllium. It fails all three fundamental assumptions. So, when Jones hits the "Quant" button, his results, in addition to being skewed by normalization to 100%, are significantly affected by topology, sample composition and a large, unknown matrix. What's sad is that Jones doesn't question the results because they fit his predetermined conclusion.
There are no conclusions that can be drawn from the quantification routine. It's making assumptions about the sample that aren't true and spitting out numbers. There may be elemental aluminum in the sample, but there is not sufficient data to draw that conclusion. It's far more likely that the numbers the routine spits out are just wrong.
Hydrogen doesn't have the energy levels necessary to produce electromagnetic radiation in the IUPAC defined X-ray region. And it's electrons that produce X-rays, not protons.Here's a clue: since H has only one proton, it's too light for XEDS to show--at least at the keV's they ran the electron beam at.
The Si microspheres are not necessarily a by-product. In coal, silica, alumina and iron oxide are all present to begin with, the burning process simply concentrates them as products that are not easily burned.That's what happens when you pretend that the original substance was kaolinite to begin with--it's OBVIOUSLY absurd. How then, do you account for Si-based microspheres as a by-product? Or would you like to propose that those too were in the matrix before they combusted?
What's further, the Si may be present in layers below the first few microns of the sample. If you'll remember, XEDS is a surface technique, and the bulk composition of the sample, which may have 100 different compounds in a dozen layers, has not been determined.
Please, try to understand this: Silica, alumina, iron, iron oxide, iron hydroxide, mica, and kaolinite are all UBIQUITOUS. They exist everywhere on earth. They exist on the ocean floor, in the walls of your house, on the top of Mount Everest. Every place you look, every ash sample, every dust sample will have these same elements. They are ubiquitous. They are everywhere. There are no conclusions that can be drawn from their presence if the source material is dust. None.Do you NOW believe Si spheres were also already there since it's the only way you can dismiss this evidence? Or do you just want to say they're lying about everything? That they sprinkled the Fe and Si based spheres in the ashes of the chips and then "analyzed" them?
But there's another issue that we need to clarify: the Fe microspheres produced from the combustion of the chips. Are you saying they were present in the chips before combustion? Are you denying that Sunstealer agrees with the existence of faceted Fe particles in the matrix? Or just that they weren't reduced to Fe?
I would never ascribe to malice what can be subscribed to ignorance. Jones's analysis is exactly what I'd expect from a person who had a cursory understanding of XEDS and complete ignorance of statistics, particle analysis, forensic investigation and basic experimental design. It's just wrong, and there's nothing beyond that.Really, you're just better off claiming they've lied about everything. Or you think 9 scientists would agree to "cherry pick" analyses that would clearly not further anyone's career.