Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Are you claiming to know this from the XEDS graphs? I hope you're aware that XEDS can't give chemical compositions.
X-ray Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy provides elemental compositional information, but not information about bonding. X-ray Diffraction and X-ray Wavelength Dispersive Spectroscopy can provide such information, in addition to a variety of incident ion techniques.
A photo comparison and XEDS cannot "demonstrate" the presence of a particular chemical species.
It also can't demonstrate the absence of a particular compound. Remember that XEDS is a surface technique. The compositional information comes only from the first few microns at most, and in the case of oxygen and aluminum X-rays, the first few hundred nanometers. The particles and substances in question here are tens of microns thick, with matrix composition and heterogeneity which are largely invisible to the technique.
Given that the MEK-soaked chip positively demonstrated the existence of elemental Al, your response is that it must be yet another unidentified material from the red/gray chips...

Ok, you've been claiming this a lot, but there is no evidence to support Jones's assertion that there is too much aluminum in the spectrum than can be accounted for by bonding to oxygen. It should be noted that Jones bases his conclusion on the "common" quantification routine. The routine he's referring to is known as standardless quant, and it requires 3 assumptions to be true about the sample.
1) The sample must be flat, conductive and measured at vacuum.
2) The matrix must be completely visible (to the incident radiation), and be free from confounding radiation.
3) The sample must be homogeneous and isotropic in all 3 dimensions.

Why are we considering these assumptions? Because none of them are true of the chip in question. The chip is large, heterogeneous, rough and may contain hydrogen, lithium and beryllium. It fails all three fundamental assumptions. So, when Jones hits the "Quant" button, his results, in addition to being skewed by normalization to 100%, are significantly affected by topology, sample composition and a large, unknown matrix. What's sad is that Jones doesn't question the results because they fit his predetermined conclusion.

There are no conclusions that can be drawn from the quantification routine. It's making assumptions about the sample that aren't true and spitting out numbers. There may be elemental aluminum in the sample, but there is not sufficient data to draw that conclusion. It's far more likely that the numbers the routine spits out are just wrong.
Here's a clue: since H has only one proton, it's too light for XEDS to show--at least at the keV's they ran the electron beam at.
Hydrogen doesn't have the energy levels necessary to produce electromagnetic radiation in the IUPAC defined X-ray region. And it's electrons that produce X-rays, not protons.
That's what happens when you pretend that the original substance was kaolinite to begin with--it's OBVIOUSLY absurd. How then, do you account for Si-based microspheres as a by-product? Or would you like to propose that those too were in the matrix before they combusted?
The Si microspheres are not necessarily a by-product. In coal, silica, alumina and iron oxide are all present to begin with, the burning process simply concentrates them as products that are not easily burned.

What's further, the Si may be present in layers below the first few microns of the sample. If you'll remember, XEDS is a surface technique, and the bulk composition of the sample, which may have 100 different compounds in a dozen layers, has not been determined.
Do you NOW believe Si spheres were also already there since it's the only way you can dismiss this evidence? Or do you just want to say they're lying about everything? That they sprinkled the Fe and Si based spheres in the ashes of the chips and then "analyzed" them?

But there's another issue that we need to clarify: the Fe microspheres produced from the combustion of the chips. Are you saying they were present in the chips before combustion? Are you denying that Sunstealer agrees with the existence of faceted Fe particles in the matrix? Or just that they weren't reduced to Fe?
Please, try to understand this: Silica, alumina, iron, iron oxide, iron hydroxide, mica, and kaolinite are all UBIQUITOUS. They exist everywhere on earth. They exist on the ocean floor, in the walls of your house, on the top of Mount Everest. Every place you look, every ash sample, every dust sample will have these same elements. They are ubiquitous. They are everywhere. There are no conclusions that can be drawn from their presence if the source material is dust. None.
Really, you're just better off claiming they've lied about everything. Or you think 9 scientists would agree to "cherry pick" analyses that would clearly not further anyone's career.
I would never ascribe to malice what can be subscribed to ignorance. Jones's analysis is exactly what I'd expect from a person who had a cursory understanding of XEDS and complete ignorance of statistics, particle analysis, forensic investigation and basic experimental design. It's just wrong, and there's nothing beyond that.
 
X-ray Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy provides elemental compositional information, but not information about bonding. X-ray Diffraction and X-ray Wavelength Dispersive Spectroscopy can provide such information, in addition to a variety of incident ion techniques.

You're absolutely right on that. Poor word choice on my part: XEDS does indeed give elemental composition but cannot directly delineate chemical configurations.

It also can't demonstrate the absence of a particular compound. Remember that XEDS is a surface technique. The compositional information comes only from the first few microns at most, and in the case of oxygen and aluminum X-rays, the first few hundred nanometers. The particles and substances in question here are tens of microns thick, with matrix composition and heterogeneity which are largely invisible to the technique.

True. And if XEDS was the only analytical technique done, then it would be difficult to make knowledge claims about the composition of the material. But when a multitude of technical analyses corroborate a theory about the composition, it becomes difficult to deny the claims.

Ok, you've been claiming this a lot, but there is no evidence to support Jones's assertion that there is too much aluminum in the spectrum than can be accounted for by bonding to oxygen. It should be noted that Jones bases his conclusion on the "common" quantification routine. The routine he's referring to is known as standardless quant, and it requires 3 assumptions to be true about the sample.
1) The sample must be flat, conductive and measured at vacuum.
2) The matrix must be completely visible (to the incident radiation), and be free from confounding radiation.
3) The sample must be homogeneous and isotropic in all 3 dimensions.

Why are we considering these assumptions? Because none of them are true of the chip in question. The chip is large, heterogeneous, rough and may contain hydrogen, lithium and beryllium. It fails all three fundamental assumptions. So, when Jones hits the "Quant" button, his results, in addition to being skewed by normalization to 100%, are significantly affected by topology, sample composition and a large, unknown matrix. What's sad is that Jones doesn't question the results because they fit his predetermined conclusion.

This is yet another attempt to simply dismiss their technical data. And again, if they were only doing XEDS on the sample, I would have to agree, however, that's clearly not the case. Why is it so difficult to understand the notion of "corroborative data/evidence?" I don't think you have a hard time with the concept, which makes your entire case for throwing out the technical analysis seem purely obstructionist.

And it's not just the technical data that corroborates the theory that this material is thermitic. The fact that it produces iron and silicate microspheres upon combustion is difficult to dismiss as "normal" or "expected" if we were talking about dried paint or concrete components.

There may be elemental aluminum in the sample, but there is not sufficient data to draw that conclusion. It's far more likely that the numbers the routine spits out are just wrong.

In a composite material that is uniformly mixed at the nanometer scale, it's not a stretch of logic to say that a positively identified element exists throughout the sample. The Al was physically separated by the MEK, a section demonstrated beyond any doubt that elemental Al exists, the material exhibits a highly energetic reaction that cannot be accounted for solely by the hydrocarbon matrix, and it produces elemental iron and silicate microspheres as a by-product.

There is copious corroborative overlap to make the case that elemental Al exists and that this material is indeed thermitic. If the only available data was the XEDS spectragraphs, then it would be epistemologically careless to jump to the conclusion that this material was suspicious, however, as in any scientific theory, it is the confirmation of various tests that give the theory a solid foundation.

As for the XEDS data by themselves, if XEDS showed no Al peak greater than the O peak at any given point, then you would be on solid ground to claim there was no elemental Al. But they did indeed find Al peaks greater than O peaks and without Si peaks. That by itself doesn't rule out the possibility of other Al molecules, but Al2Si2O5(OH)4 is most certainly ruled out.

Given the SE microscopy showed a finely mixed, heterogeneous composition, it's a safe bet that surface composition of a freshly broken piece is indicative of the matrix throughout. So although you are correct that XEDS is only a surface analysis technique, when combined with BSE, SE, and various experiments on the material, the HFJ crew are making well-founded claims.

The Si microspheres are not necessarily a by-product. In coal, silica, alumina and iron oxide are all present to begin with, the burning process simply concentrates them as products that are not easily burned.

That's nice but irrelevant to the samples in question. This material is clearly not coal, nor concrete, nor paint. You have absolutely no evidence whatsoever indicating that the microspheres observed upon combustion were present in the uncombusted material. To assume the researchers chose to ignore them is to engage in calling them all "liars." If that's your professional analysis, then write a paper exposing them.

That's really the best argument against the paper: just call them liars and be done with it. There's no way they missed finding iron and silica microspheres in the material. They must be lying, right? Would you be willing to put your professional credentials next to that claim in a scientific publication?

Please, try to understand this: Silica, alumina, iron, iron oxide, iron hydroxide, mica, and kaolinite are all UBIQUITOUS. They exist everywhere on earth.

Are uniformly sized nanometer scale iron oxide particles ubiquitous in nature? Not by any stretch of the imagination. Is particulate elemental Al ubiquitous in nature? You know full well it's not. Are these materials found mixed together in any normal building materials? Nope.

And I'm not saying anything controversial here. Yes, the towers were made of a lot of aluminum and steel, but no amount of building destruction is going to accidentally form this material in question. It would be like trying to build a computer by putting a bunch of computer parts in your front seat then crashing into a wall at 70 mph. The real world doesn't work like that.

Again, you understand exactly what I'm saying. It is purely obstructionist to suggest that because the elemental components of this material are present, we should not be surprised at this particular combination of them. WRONG. This material cannot be explained away by citing the ubiquitous nature of the various elemental constituents.

Don't believe me? Mix up some C, H, N and O in a bag, shake it, warm it, and VIOLA! you're a DAD! Right? No, no human will form, despite the fact that those are our primary elemental components.

Your arguments are vacuous in the face of the plentiful corroborative data, and your attempts to conjure iron and silicate spheres in the material before combustion hinge entirely on evidence that doesn't exist. Pure argument from ignorance.
 
True. And if XEDS was the only analytical technique done, then it would be difficult to make knowledge claims about the composition of the material. But when a multitude of technical analyses corroborate a theory about the composition, it becomes difficult to deny the claims.

XEDS was the only technique done which provides elemental compositional information. Secondary electron imaging provides information about topology of the sample, and backscattered electron imaging provides information about the average atomic number of the sample. DSC is not a compositional technique.

This is yet another attempt to simply dismiss their technical data. And again, if they were only doing XEDS on the sample, I would have to agree, however, that's clearly not the case. Why is it so difficult to understand the notion of corroborative data/evidence? I don't think you have a hard time with the concept, which makes your entire case for throwing out the technical analysis seem purely obstructionist.
This is not dismissing technical data. It is dismissing meaningless data by pointing out precisely why it is meaningless. If you want to discuss the technical merits of my criticism, I would welcome it. This hand waving only proves that you have not understood my criticism.

And it's not just the technical data that corroborates the theory that this material is thermitic. The fact that it produces iron and silicate microspheres upon combustion is difficult to dismiss as "normal" or "expected" if we were talking about dried paint or concrete components.
There is no evidence that the reaction produces microspheres. There is evidence that the spheres exist after the reaction, but there is no evidence which ELIMINATES their presence beforehand. What I'm telling you is, if the source material is dust, iron oxide, silica and alumina spheres will have already contaminated the sample. The ashing process simply concentrates them.
In a composite material that is uniformly mixed at the nanometer scale,
There is no evidence to support this conclusion. The sample is heterogeneous. The X-ray images prove that they are heterogeneous.
it's not a stretch of logic to say that a positively identified element exists throughout the sample.
Yes, it is. It is a wildly illogical, completely unreasonable assumption to make without proof. There is no proof that the samples are homogeneous, isotropic, flat and conductive.
The Al was physically separated by the MEK
Incorrect. The quantification routine failed to correctly determine the oxygen concentration. Jones has assumed that this failure somehow supports the conclusion that elemental aluminum exists. He is wrong.
, a section demonstrated beyond any doubt that elemental Al exists,
This is your opinion. It has no bearing on this debate.
the material exhibits a highly energetic reaction that cannot be accounted for solely by the hydrocarbon matrix, and it produces elemental iron and silicate microspheres as a by-product.
This reaction was done in a reducing atmosphere. The results are meaningless in the presence of carbonaceous material.
There is copious corroborative overlap to make the case that elemental Al exists and that this material is indeed thermitic.
There is no evidence of elemental aluminum in the sample. The quantification routine is wrong. The results are meaningless.
If the only available data was the XEDS spectragraphs, then it would be epistemologically careless to jump to the conclusion that this material was suspicious, however, as in any scientific theory, it is the confirmation of various tests that give the theory a solid foundation.
Please tell me what you think the other data tell you about the spatially resolved elemental composition of the sample.
As for the XEDS data by themselves, if XEDS showed no Al peak greater than the O peak at any given point, then you would be on solid ground to claim there was no elemental Al. But they did indeed find Al peaks greater than O peaks and without Si peaks. That by itself doesn't rule out the possibility of other Al molecules, but Al2Si2O5(OH)4 is most certainly ruled out.
Please try to understand this: Quantification of XEDS spectra is not simply a matter of which peak is higher. To produce compositional information from spectral data, you need to account for morphology, topology, matrix, radiation and atomic number effects. These equations are not simple, and the results are often difficult to interpret.

Jones interpreted his data incorrectly. He used the wrong tool, got the wrong answer, but it supported his conclusion, so he went with it. Jones is wrong.
Given the SE microscopy showed a finely mixed, heterogeneous composition, it's a safe bet that surface composition of a freshly broken piece is indicative of the matrix throughout.
Incorrect. It is not an assumption that any reasonable researcher would make.
So although you are correct that XEDS is only a surface analysis technique, when combined with BSE, SE, and various experiments on the material, the HFJ crew are making well-founded claims.
Secondary electrons come only from the first 100 nanometers of the sample or less, and backscattered electrons come from approximately the same region as the X-rays. They are all surface techniques. They are all ONLY surface techniques.
That's nice but irrelevant to the samples in question. This material is clearly not coal, nor concrete, nor paint.
My point is that you could do X-ray analysis on coal and find no alumina or silica, but once you burned the coal, the alumina and silica would appear. It's not because burning coal produces these compounds, but rather, since you're removing the matrix, the non-combustible parts will concentrate.

These samples were coated in, in contact with and generally in the presence of dust, concrete and ash.
You have absolutely no evidence whatsoever indicating that the microspheres observed upon combustion were present in the uncombusted material.
The material was coated in, in contact with, and generally in the presence of dust, concrete and ash. These microspheres are common in all of these compounds. What's more important is that Jones has no proof that the microspheres were absent.
To assume the researchers chose to ignore them is to engage in calling them all "liars." If that's your professional analysis, then write a paper exposing them.
Writing a paper would be a complete waste of time, especially since the vast majority of Jones's paper is simply an exercise in ignorance. I would never ascribe to malice what can be ascribed to ignorance.
That's really the best argument against the paper: just call them liars and be done with it.
Your summary of my argument seems to indicate that you do not understand my objections. I have no evidence that Jones is lying, because no one has ever demonstrated his competence as a researcher to me. He is uninformed, uneducated and ignorant of many of the salient points of X-ray spectrometry, DSC, statistical analysis, particle sampling, forensics, microscopy, chemistry, and materials science.

My objections could be summarized this way: Jones is using the wrong techniques on the wrong samples, ignoring the conventions of research, experimental design, statistical relevance and microscopy in support of a pre-determined conclusion which stands in stark contrast to the vast majority of opposing, statistically relevant data and scientific research. His conclusions are inaccurate, his methods are nonsensical, and he's wasting time pointing at ash and calling it thermite.
There's no way they missed finding iron and silica microspheres in the material.
Yes, they did. They are incompetent. Their paper stinks of incompetence.
They must be lying, right? Would you be willing to put your professional credentials next to that claim in a scientific publication?
Only if Jones manages to get his work published in a relevant scientific publication. I would suggest Analytical Chemistry, Science, Nature, Physical Review Letters, Nano Environmental Health and Science, Nature Methods or Journal of the American Ceramic Society.

Are uniformly sized nanometer scale iron oxide particles ubiquitous in nature?
1) There is no evidence that the particles in question are uniformly sized.
2) There is no evidence that they're all nanometer sized
3) Iron oxide particles of all sizes are ubiquitous in nature. They are the product of 1,000,000 forest fires and volcanic ash eruptions that have existed for the last 3 billion years on earth. Their ashes have been carried by the wind, the waves and even the birds across the entirety of the earth.
Not by any stretch of the imagination. Is particulate elemental Al ubiquitous in nature? You know full well it's not. Are these materials found mixed together in any normal building materials? Nope.
There is no evidence for elemental aluminum.
[...]
Your arguments are vacuous in the face of the plentiful corroborative data, and your attempts to conjure iron and silicate spheres in the material before combustion hinge entirely on evidence that doesn't exist. Pure argument from ignorance.
Shall we keep our debate the the scientific merits of the paper, or shall we engage in endless polemics?
 
Last edited:
XEDS was the only technique done which provides elemental compositional information. Secondary electron imaging provides information about topology of the sample, and backscattered electron imaging provides information about the average atomic number of the sample. DSC is not a compositional technique.

This is not dismissing technical data. It is dismissing meaningless data by pointing out precisely why it is meaningless. If you want to discuss the technical merits of my criticism, I would welcome it. This hand waving only proves that you have not understood my criticism.

Who's hand waving data away? How is it you can look at the BSE images in figure 8 and say they do NOT demonstrate the presence of relatively dense, faceted particles that are nearly uniformly 100 nm? Or dismiss the relevance of finding the same morphology in all the samples?

Do you want to say this is paint? Concrete residues? Corrosion protection? You know it's not any of these. This material was manufactured--it didn't just form in the wreckage--you can at least agree with that, yea?

As for the rest of your argument, it boils down to a simple argument from incredulity, no matter what fancy dress you like to package it in. You must deny the relevance of the similarities in the material from the various samples. You must deny even the uncontroversial points such as the faceted particles are Fe2O3. You must dismiss the repeatable XEDS data (as if they could mimic Al peaks somehow). You must claim the existence of iron and silicon microspheres in the samples before combustion. You must completely ignore the MEK soaked chip and all the corresponding XEDS maps and graphs. And then you must deny that the red color is from Fe2O3.

I must say, you at least appear to agree that the implications of this material are massive to make so many claims of incredulity.

There is no evidence that the reaction produces microspheres. There is evidence that the spheres exist after the reaction, but there is no evidence which ELIMINATES their presence beforehand. What I'm telling you is, if the source material is dust, iron oxide, silica and alumina spheres will have already contaminated the sample. The ashing process simply concentrates them.

And here you have no problem whatsoever invoking a pure argument from ignorance to support this claim. You have no evidence to suggest the spheres were present before combustion, yet you deny the findings of the paper based on the fact that they are NOT found before combustion and they ARE found after combustion.

This is similar to denying the presence of elemental Al despite the fact that it was determined to be found in the MEK soaked chip. You may want to dispute the results, however, you cannot make a positive claim that elemental Al does NOT exist based on the fact that XEDS data confirmed its presence.

This is basic logic. You cannot make positive claims based on a lack of evidence. If you throw the evidence out (for whatever reasons) then you must still tangle with the possibility of the original claim. You've just reduced the debate to a question of verification.

There is no evidence to support this conclusion. The sample is heterogeneous. The X-ray images prove that they are heterogeneous.

That's why I'm calling it a "composite" material. This is a non-argument. They broke several samples to create an uncontaminated surface and found the same structures inside ALL of them. It is exceedingly less likely that they accidentally broke all the samples in precisely the right places to make it appear that they all shared the same morphology than that they simply shared the same morphology.

Again, the implications of these findings are such that incredulity knows no bounds. You'd rather accept astronomically minuscule probabilities over the much more likely, but psychologically dissonant probability that this substance is evidence of murder by forces within our own system.

Yes, it is. It is a wildly illogical, completely unreasonable assumption to make without proof. There is no proof that the samples are homogeneous, isotropic, flat and conductive.

There is ample evidence to support the theory that materials found on the surface of a freshly broken piece exist throughout the material. What would you need to convince you of this? Should the sample be ground into powder before performing XEDS on it? Why is breaking it and sampling the clean surface NOT a good indication of the contents? Is there ANY evidence that the material is not uniformly mixed?

Incorrect. The quantification routine failed to correctly determine the oxygen concentration. Jones has assumed that this failure somehow supports the conclusion that elemental aluminum exists. He is wrong.

You can confirm his analysis of the XEDS graphs by looking at the XEDS maps. Some of the Al is likely oxidized, however, some of it clearly is NOT. If it was all oxidized, the Al would be indistinguishable from the O. This is unmistakably NOT the case. Any argument to the contrary is essentially an accusation of data fabrication. If that's your ultimate defense, then why even bother giving criteria for a proper XEDS acquisition?

This is your opinion. It has no bearing on this debate.

We are entitled to our own opinions but not our own facts. Is it your opinion that the XEDS maps showed little overlap between the Si and the Al? Irrelevant. The fact is the XEDS maps showed little overlap between the Si and Al.

My point is that you could do X-ray analysis on coal and find no alumina or silica, but once you burned the coal, the alumina and silica would appear. It's not because burning coal produces these compounds, but rather, since you're removing the matrix, the non-combustible parts will concentrate.

This is a completely unfounded ad hoc theory that is just thrown out there in a desperate attempt to avoid piecing together the well-corroborated data that the chips in question produced iron and silica based microspheres when combusted. It is antirational and hinges on evidence you do not have in regard to the test chips.

Even if Jones is motivated to a particular conclusion, there is no way he would be able to produce such copious corroborative data AND get all 8 other scientists to agree to such a controversial interpretation of the data unless it was well founded.

What's more important is that Jones has no proof that the microspheres were absent.

So therefore they must have been present, right?

Writing a paper would be a complete waste of time, especially since the vast majority of Jones's paper is simply an exercise in ignorance. I would never ascribe to malice what can be ascribed to ignorance.

Right. Of course it is.

1) There is no evidence that the particles in question are uniformly sized.
2) There is no evidence that they're all nanometer sized
3) Iron oxide particles of all sizes are ubiquitous in nature.

This is the tell: you have to completely ignore the BSE images in figure 8 and the SE image in figure 9 in order to say this. If you were actually attempting to evaluate this info scientifically/skeptically, there would be no reason to deny the existence of these relatively uniform 100nm iron oxide particles in these images.

You would also be hard pressed to deny their rarity in anything other than highly manufactured materials--IF you were actually trying to be a legitimate skeptic of the HJF paper. But you're not. You're just a cheerleader for a particular political view. If you were doing science, I wouldn't have to point out how strange it would be to find iron oxide in this particular configuration with this particular regularity. It simply doesn't happen like that accidentally in a composite material that is combustible at 430C and also just happens to be in the wreckage of the major catastrophe of our time.

There is no way to deny this. But that won't stop you from denying it. It is the least controversial bit of evidence from this whole study, and it's backed up by a number of analytical techniques, and it is likely the reason the red material has its color, yet you cannot even admit that it exists for fear it will topple your pile of denial. But in denying that bit of uncontroversial data, you expose yourself as a political voice, not a scientific one. You aren't interested in the data under any circumstances--if it isn't the kind of data that supports the theory you oppose--despite what you may claim. Your denial of the evidence for Fe2O3 makes that clear.


.
 
Ryan, if you would like to have a real discussion about this, then we need to agree about basic premises.

Unless you found something wrong with the XEDS analysis of the post-MEK chip, then there is no way to claim that elemental Al was NOT found.


pg. 18 (my emphasis)

What have they done wrong that they cannot make this claim?

I'm responding for the last time with this post from earlier in the thread. You requested that we find something wrong with the EDS analysis. The following things are wrong with the microanalysis of the sample:
1) Quantitative analysis was done on a rough, heterogeneous sample without requisite standards.
2) The provenance of the samples was not established by appropriate, random sampling and statistical analysis.
3) The techniques used to analyze the composition of the particles were surface only techniques, and the results are capable of being skewed by material below the surface.
4) The source material for the samples is dust and ash, and the materials, morphology and composition of everything analyzed within the sample is consistent with dust and ash.
5) The chips analyzed were entirely consistent with the morphology, composition, color and size of already established and analyzed building materials in the WTC.

These 5 errors call into question the conclusion that the material is nano-thermite. Without addressing these problems, the authors don't have a leg to stand on. That's all. Please return when you have something substantive to add to the debate, or when their paper is published in Analytical Chemistry.
 
I'm responding for the last time with this post from earlier in the thread. You requested that we find something wrong with the EDS analysis. The following things are wrong with the microanalysis of the sample:
1) Quantitative analysis was done on a rough, heterogeneous sample without requisite standards.
2) The provenance of the samples was not established by appropriate, random sampling and statistical analysis.
3) The techniques used to analyze the composition of the particles were surface only techniques, and the results are capable of being skewed by material below the surface.
4) The source material for the samples is dust and ash, and the materials, morphology and composition of everything analyzed within the sample is consistent with dust and ash.

Ultimately, this is a simple argument from incredulity. What's the likelihood of accidentally producing aluminum peaks? Without knowing that, all skepticism of the graphs/maps doesn't mean much. What's the chance of that happening 4 times from 4 different samples? Likely? Not likely? Unless they are trying to fabricate the data (in which case, you're just accusing them of lying), what are the actual chances of getting 4 replicable results from 4 different samples that all coincide?

That's the value of corroborative data. If you did it just once, it would be more difficult to claim, but they've done multiple tests on multiple samples. The likelihood of reproducing the results 4 samples x 4 results is extremely low.

5) The chips analyzed were entirely consistent with the morphology, composition, color and size of already established and analyzed building materials in the WTC.

What materials? Please explain what materials you refer to that combust at 430C and leave a residue of iron and silicate microspheres (whether they are condensed dust or reaction by-products). I await a fair rationalization.


.
 
As you well know, the O is bound up with more than just the Fe. We know for a fact that the red matrix is a hydrocarbon, the silicon is likely bound as well and the Fe2O3--which is not really a controversial position. So there's plenty of O that doesn't overlap the Fe.
You're failing to address my argument, which was the opposite despite your effort to take it the wrong way: in figure 15, there's plenty of Fe that doesn't overlap the O, so that's unoxidized Fe.

The XEDS spectrographs then verify that the Al exists independently of Si AND that Fe does NOT exist without a corresponding O peak that is greater than the Fe peaks.
That may be true for samples 1-4 and figure 10, which you can take as reference for comparison. Figure 15 shows otherwise, proving that either the MEK solvent magically separated the Fe and the O, or that that chip is a totally different material which contains unoxidized Fe. You're welcome to offer an alternative explanation and why it wasn't addressed by the analysts.

And you're still failing to explain how this sentence follows from the data presented:

Oxygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron in the red material even after soaking in MEK solvent (Fig. 15)
​
(p.19). Since you seem to be confusing that every so often, let me explain that I'm not claiming they have fabricated the data here, I'm just claiming that the data leads to a different conclusion to the stated one, namely that the assertion that there's a significant amount of iron oxide IN THAT SAMPLE does not hold. You can claim things about improbability of it being different materials, but that's incredulity. I'm referring ONLY to the data, namely Fig. 15.

You can confirm his analysis of the XEDS graphs by looking at the XEDS maps. Some of the Al is likely oxidized, however, some of it clearly is NOT. If it was all oxidized, the Al would be indistinguishable from the O. This is unmistakably NOT the case. Any argument to the contrary is essentially an accusation of data fabrication.
Why are you failing to apply that exact same reasoning to the Fe vs O in fig. 15?

The Fe2O3 is what was identified as the faceted, relatively dense particles about 100 nm in diameter. It's also, (not controversially), what likely gives the substance its red appearance. Even the people who want to claim it's paint agree that there's Fe2O3 in there.
I agree there's Fe2O3 in samples 1-4. I don't agree there's (substantial amounts of) Fe2O3 in the MEK-soaked chip. I proved that we lack the XEDS maps for elements dominating vast zones in the sample, so we can't know what was the Fe bound to in that chip, and the same goes for the Al. Here's the proof, now explain the dark/black areas:

MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Al+Si+O+Fe+C.jpg
 
You're failing to address my argument, which was the opposite despite your effort to take it the wrong way: in figure 15, there's plenty of Fe that doesn't overlap the O, so that's unoxidized Fe.


That may be true for samples 1-4 and figure 10, which you can take as reference for comparison. Figure 15 shows otherwise, proving that either the MEK solvent magically separated the Fe and the O, or that that chip is a totally different material which contains unoxidized Fe. You're welcome to offer an alternative explanation and why it wasn't addressed by the analysts.

And you're still failing to explain how this sentence follows from the data presented:

Oxygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron in the red material even after soaking in MEK solvent (Fig. 15)
​
(p.19). Since you seem to be confusing that every so often, let me explain that I'm not claiming they have fabricated the data here, I'm just claiming that the data leads to a different conclusion to the stated one, namely that the assertion that there's a significant amount of iron oxide IN THAT SAMPLE does not hold. You can claim things about improbability of it being different materials, but that's incredulity. I'm referring ONLY to the data, namely Fig. 15.


Why are you failing to apply that exact same reasoning to the Fe vs O in fig. 15?


I agree there's Fe2O3 in samples 1-4. I don't agree there's (substantial amounts of) Fe2O3 in the MEK-soaked chip. I proved that we lack the XEDS maps for elements dominating vast zones in the sample, so we can't know what was the Fe bound to in that chip, and the same goes for the Al. Here's the proof, now explain the dark/black areas:

Some of it is most definitely H. As I said earlier in response to this, they likely used a filter or just reduced the intensities to demonstrate separation and concentration of certain components. The matrix material is most definitely a hydrocarbon, so there should be C and O throughout all the maps. Would you rationalize that the MEK caused the hydrocarbon matrix to break down chemically? An insignificant percentage may indeed have broken down, however, we should still expect to see C and O throughout the entire sample. But we don't. Why not? Because they are using XEDS as a qualitative technique to demonstrate relative concentrations of various elements.

If you want to postulate the existence of elemental Fe, be my guest. I don't see how that gets you any closer to dismissing the significance of this material, but it's not inconceivable that it exists. Did the elemental Al disappear yet?

As I tried to explain to Almond, if you had only the XEDS maps, or only the BSE images or only the DSC data, then it would be difficult to make claims as to the composition of the material or its properties. However, it is the corroborative nature of this data, that is, the confirmation of multiple tests that provides firm ground on which to make claims about the material. They are not making their case based on any ONE piece of data.


.
 
There is evidence that the iron microspheres are present after reaction
AND there is ALSO evidence that the microspheres were NOT present before reaction.

The Microspheres are indeed huge in Jones photographs : some have almost half the size of the red chip they originated from so the idea that the spheres were already there somehow hidden inside the chip is simply ridiculous.
So please look at the photos again and stop this endless debate.
 
There is evidence that the iron microspheres are present after reaction
AND there is ALSO evidence that the microspheres were NOT present before reaction.

The Microspheres are indeed huge in Jones photographs : some have almost half the size of the red chip they originated from so the idea that the spheres were already there somehow hidden inside the chip is simply ridiculous.
So please look at the photos again and stop this endless debate.

Please show me evidence, outside of Jones' word, that the microspheres were not present in the samples prior to the reaction.

TAM:)
 
There is NO debate.

That is the funny part.

With over 20 methodological errors, you cannot take anything from this "paper."

As almond has pointed out with 5 errors in the EDS data collection.

It is crap. File it in the circular bin and start over.

What is so hard to understand about that?
 
Energetics

Jones is trying to force a conclusion because he wants something that will get him noticed. His fans are non-scientists because they do not realize that the paper has no substance. I will not bother discussing the Jones team lack of a competent chemist when selecting MEK as a solvent for cured paint, the use of an unknown fresh paint to compare it to, a conductivity test [have meter = do test], or the inconsistent analyses of the EDAX data, but will get to the heart of it. Spheres or no spheres and oxy torches notwithstanding, he has yet to show thermitic reaction.
He claims thermitic reaction and compares his DSC with one published using an authentic sample from LLNL. The known sample was run in air, but Jones has no idea that he should run the sample under an inert atmosphere to prove thermite and eliminate combustion of the binder material. The DSC traces are quite different in shape, duration, and onset temperature, not a good sign for a nano-thermite. He also does not eliminate combustion.
This can be seen in his energetics calculations. Two of his highly engineered samples, those same deadly samples where he estimated ten tons lay unreacted in the dust [not a compelling argument for quality control], showed significantly more energy than the other two samples. As we consider figure 30, we see that the range of energy per unit mass of these samples varies over a factor of about four. We also see that chips 3 and 4 significantly exceed the theoretical value of thermite. So what must be doing this? Combustion of paint binder is most likely.
Jones suggests that he has found a super-thermite with an energetic binder. Consider the energy per unit mass for HMX as an example of an “energetic binder.” HMX is an extremely energetic material. It is not present in the paint chips but is a good example of an energetic material. Now, compare its energy to chips 3 and 4. It is slightly less than the energy for chip 4 and much less than the energy for chip 3. If something as energetic as HMX were used as the binder for the purported nanothermite, and half the mass of the chip was binder, the maximum theoretical energy output would be about 4.7kJ, still well below chips 3 and 4. The paint is putting out more energy per unit mass than super-thermite, HMX, TNT, TATB or any possible mixtures of them. The ONLY way that much energy per unit mass can come out of the chips is through combustion. Candle wax has about ten times the energy of thermite. Jones and crew can hand wave and obfuscate all they want, they can’t ignore the math and their own data.
Now we come to the rationale. Thin layers of thermite will only warm the steel. Burning paint would do better. Jones then suggests that it is fuse material; super-nano-thermite fuse material. He asks us to believe that he has discovered ten tons of paint-on fuse that didn't burn. What didn't it set off? There must be thousands of tons of active ordinance left in the debris.

Alternatively, given the skills of his team, he has simultaneously discovered red paint and celebrity, of sorts.
 
There is evidence that the iron microspheres are present after reaction
AND there is ALSO evidence that the microspheres were NOT present before reaction.

There's also ample evidence that iron-rich microspheres are a commonplace product of normal combustion, and that a thermite reaction is not a necessary condition for their formation.

Dave
 
AND there is ALSO evidence that the microspheres were NOT present before reaction.

Yet, in the SEM and BSE images in Fig (3) show a pair of uncharacterized spheroids in the lower left corner and another pair up along the right side of the image. This was a sample that, according to the authors was removed via magnet and was never even subject to a DSC test.

Were they iron spheriods? I have no idea; Harrit and Jones never characterized them. But again: They were extracted by magnet and did not undergo combustion. Now, you tell us what they were.
 
There's also ample evidence that iron-rich microspheres are a commonplace product of normal combustion, and that a thermite reaction is not a necessary condition for their formation.

Dave

Not combustion of an isolated micrometer particle that produces such a huge iron microsphere! so either you trust the authors when they say that they obtained these photographs on an isolated chip after heating at less than 500°c in their DSC and this alone is hard evidence or you dont trust them... i.e you suggest that they have completely invented these results and that is a major accusation...

This is why my approach was to tried to reproduce this single simple observation because in principle it only requires a small kiln and a magnet so anybody having some dust could check this at home.
I admit i did not succeed to obtain this reaction but its possible that all my chips in my sample was already reacted because even before heating them i could notice a myriad of small iron microspheres at their surface.
Thus, though i could not trigger the reaction myself, i consider that all these microspheres at the surface is a strong indication that these were involved in a high energy process, whatever it is.

F H-C
 
or they were there in the gypsum, or the fly ash from the concrete... or from the construction of the towers, or from the recovery period.

FHC, can you eliminate ANY of those possible sources of the microspheres?
 
Last edited:
Thus, though i could not trigger the reaction myself, i consider that all these microspheres at the surface is a strong indication that these were involved in a high energy process, whatever it is.

F H-C

The videos of airliners crashing into the buildings are are also strong indications of a high energy process.
 
This is my point. All along the big key, the alleged undebunkable point in that entire paper, despite its poor construction, poor form, poor adherence to scientific approach and protocol, has been this alleged production of iron microspheres simply by heating the chips to a certain temperature.

Yet Hency has a sample of the alleged dust and the alleged thermite, and yet can he produce said iron microspheres via the same process? No. If you ask me Henry, it is very weak, to say that the reason for this is that "all of your chips had already reacted". Seriously, does the scientist in you say that that is the most likely reason? really?

TAM:)
 
or they were there in the gypsum, or the fly ash from the concrete... or from the construction of the towers, or from the recovery period.

FHC, can you eliminate ANY of those possible sources of the microspheres?

Of course. The known abundance of iron in the dust is 2%. If you select iron with a magnet in the dust you find that 10% of it is in the form of iron (almost pure) microspheres. Hence these microspheres represent at least 0.2% in weight of the dust. This is HUGE: more than 100 tons of melted and pulverized iron (as indicated by the micron size) per tower. Many of them show the signature Aluminum+ Iron.

Thus i dont know where it comes from but the idea that this is fly ash from a normal fire (i mean not a fire in a métall furnace that can concentrate the heat) is simply ridiculous.

A crash plane is not a high density of energy (energy released per unit volume) process

F H-C
 
Henri.

Fly ash is not from a normal fire. It is used in making gypsum and concrete. It isn't "ash from a normal fire."

http://www.flyash.info/2005/200fan.pdf
http://www.tfhrc.gov/hnr20/recycle/waste/cfa51.htm
http://igs.indiana.edu/Geology/coalOilGas/flyAshProperties/index.cfm

So back to my question.

Can you ELIMINATE ANY OTHER SOURCE for these microspheres? yes or no?

As for your statement
A crash plane is not a high density of energy (energy released per unit volume) process

I just have this
Energy911.jpg


You are right... there is no high density of energy released... just a minimum of 1200 lbs of TNT being released... that isn't anythihg...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom