So despite their claims that the combustion of the chips produced iron and silicate spheres, you don't believe it. So what? When did incredulity become a solid foundation for making claims on JREF?
Incredulity nothing. I told you they didn't prove it, and furthermore cited a photo where spheres were visible in a sample
prior to combustion. Furthermore, you ignore all the other posts demonstrating 1. A lack of examination establishing that the DSC'd chips were indeed the same composition as the ones subjected to spectroscopy, and 2. A lack of proof that the spheres weren't there beforehand. Again,
you are the one swallowing that uncritically. I cited a photo, I refered to what Jones and his cohorts wrote.
The ONLY thing you've demonstrated beyond any reasonable doubt is your disbelief. Do you have any scientific papers that demonstrate that the chips are not in the dust? Or that they're kaolinite? Or that they do NOT produce iron and silicate spheres when combusted? No. You have nothing but a refusal to accept their findings. Congratulations.
Pfff... what we've all shown are the paper's failings. The problem here is that
you refuse to accept that they have not only failed to demonstrate the presence of "thermitic material", but in fact
contradicted it with their findings, namely the spectroscopic image Sunstealer used to demonstrate the presence of bound aluminum, as well as the totally contraindicative energy densities.
Their own data contradicts their claims. You simply refuse to accept that.
Um... You care. Sunstealer cares. I care. Pretty much everyone who has the slightest interest in the question of 911 involving non-muslims does.
Nice attempt to dodge. What I was pointing out was that whatever the material was, it couldn't have been "thermitic material" because the data contradicts that.
The chances of it being some sort of esoteric rust prevention coating are extremely small.
You provide no support for this claim, and it is also contradicted by what we've been saying for what, 4 pages now. Whether it was paint, some sort of
standard (why esoteric? So you can make your argument feel stronger?) rust prevention coating, or whatnot, the facts remain:
- Bound aluminum
- Kaolin identified
End of story. What matters is that the possibility of it being "thermitic material" has been
eliminated. And by Jones's and Harrit's own data too.
That's why we call their research sloppy: Their data contradicts their conclusions. And only suckers like you don't see that.
That fact, along with its other demonstrated properties (low ignition temp accompanied by a high-energy exothermic reaction, producing iron and silicon-based microspheres) make it difficult to deny that another energy source may have been available in the towers the day they fell.
How? Bazant has demonstrated that once the towers began their collapse, there was more than enough energy available to sever the floor connections and collapse all the way to the ground. No other energy source would even be needed.
Furthermore, you keep on thinking the properties discovered in the experiments only apply to thermite. No. The "high-energy exothermic reaction" they claim was from a thermite reaction completely misses the energy-density boat: It is
impossible for thermite to cause energy densities greater than the limit imposed by thermite's enthalpy of reaction. Combine
that with the fact that they burnt a chip alleged to be paint (and therefore rife with hydrocarbons) in an oxygen environment, and you have enough to conclude that their "high-energy exothermic reaction" (as if there's any such thing as an endothermic combustion

) was the hydrocarbon aspect of the chip (the stuff Jones handwaves as "sol gel") burning. Combine all
that with the lack of proof behind their claim of microspheres not being present beforehand, and an image in their own paper showing spheres of some nature afterwards, and what more do we need?
You are the one swallowing their party line uncritically.
You are the one refusing to think your way through this.
How many times can this be said? It doesn't matter what you want to call it, given it's properties, it points to another energy source in the towers. How is it you can deny that the by-products from the commercial thermite matched closely to the by-products from the red-gray chips? Again, it's just your incredulity, and it's weak.
How many times can
this be said: The aluminum was bound. The kaolin was present.
It doesn't matter what you want to call it, given it's properties, it points to the hydrocarbons burning. How is it that you can deny the contradictory energy density well beyond thermite's enthalpy of reaction?
And no, the "by-products from the commercial thermite" did
not match the by-products from the red-gray chips. Reread the paper. Aside from the microspheres which were not proven to have been there beforehand, name any other byproduct of his burning of the chips.
It's got a similar structure to kaolinite from those SE photos. Check. It's got similar chemical make-up. Check. Does kaolinite combust at 430C? Not even close. At what temp does the Si separate from the Al?
Above 925C according to Wikipedia. So, you can stop linking to Sunstealer's posts already. I read them before I posted anything about this.
We can categorically rule out kaolinite as the substance in the red/gray chips because it's not combustable at 430C.
Who said it was the
kaolin that burnt? Jones
himself tries to dodge the energy problems away by citing the burning of what he mistakenly thinks is the sol-gel. His own data shows the presence of carbon and oxygen, and
EDX spectroscopy does not show hydrogen. The point? Jones's own data shows the presence of hydrocarbons.
That was what burnt! No one
ever tried to claim it was the
kaolin that combusted!
You rule it out based on a mistake in logic. Kaolin is most certainly not ruled out, given that the combustible component of the chips was never alleged to have been kaolin to begin with, and given that other characteristics match it perfectly.
That is, unless you are proposing that the hydrocarbon matrix is responsible for heating the kaolinite above that temp sufficiently to cause the reduction to SiO2 AND reducing Fe2O3 into elemental Fe. Is that what you're claiming? That's in the realm of possibility--in the same sense that it's possible for all the oxygen in the room to suddenly shift to one side. Not likely.
Yes, the hydrocarbons is the only thing left that could have burned. And no, again: Look at figure 3 in his paper; spheres present in one sample
before combustion. Also: Find the section where Jones/Harrit
prove - not merely assert, but
prove - that the spheres were not present to begin with. You cannot claim that the spheres were created during the combustion, and in fact need to explain the photo indicating that they were present beforehand.
The bottom line is that you cannot back up the claim of microsphere
generation during the combustion with their data. Those researchers merely claim it, they do not demonstrate it. And one of their own pieces of data argues
against it.
You want to disprove that? Convince Jones and Harrit to replicate their findings, but in an anaerobic environment. Their findings regarding energies are meaningless when they provide a means for the hydrocarbons to burn.
But that's all you have to hang on to with the kaolinite argument: extremely low probabilities in the face of an alternate energy source in the towers.
Wrong. See above. Double check
Sunstealer's post as well, and yes, I
will continue to link them. Your attempts at refutation do not negate what he has demonstrated, and your argument still fails on what he has shown.
This is exactly where the whole idea of "skeptics" at JREF becomes inverted. You must accept unfathomably low probabilities that have yet to even be corroborated in order to deny the evidence that there was another energy source in the towers.
#SKEPTICFAIL
This is
exactly where the whole idea of "thermitic material" in your thesis fails. You must accept unsupported allegations, weak pattern matching (re: Temperatures), and overlook outright contradictions (re: energy densities above 3.9 kj/g,
spectroscopy demonstrating bound aluminum (Hey, look!
Another Sunstealer post that negates your claim!)) in order to forward your claim that there was some other energy source in the towers.
#TRUTHERFAIL
Until you confront the lack of proof that the spheres weren't present beforehand
and address the fact that a photo shows spheres prior to combustion, you will get nowhere. Until you confront the fact that kaolin was demonstrated to be present, and understand that your counterargument fails due to the mistaken belief that it was the kaolin that combusted, you will get nowhere. Until you confront the fact that their own energy densities exceeded 3.9 kj/g, thus contraindicating thermite, you will get nowhere.
To date, you've gotten nowhere. Time for you to give up the fantasy.