Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

You cannot prove the spheres weren't present beforehand. This is the extent of his Jones's observation:

​
And that's it. But the problem is, his own evidence seems to suggest otherwise; Figure 3 of his paper shows spherules that remain uncharacterized. And those images are from uncombusted chips. Huh... wonder why Jones failed to characterize those :rolleyes:.

No imagry, no proof, nothing but assertion... which you swallow uncritically.

Even if you presume the spheres were produced by the combustion, you cannot conclude they were produced by thermite. Temperature is off, and so are the energy density figures Jones himself gives in that paper. They're off by quite a bit. You're operating on faith, not established fact.

So despite their claims that the combustion of the chips produced iron and silicate spheres, you don't believe it. So what? When did incredulity become a solid foundation for making claims on JREF?

You are totally mistaken about this "whole ''inside job"" thing. We've demonstrated that.

The ONLY thing you've demonstrated beyond any reasonable doubt is your disbelief. Do you have any scientific papers that demonstrate that the chips are not in the dust? Or that they're kaolinite? Or that they do NOT produce iron and silicate spheres when combusted? No. You have nothing but a refusal to accept their findings. Congratulations.


Maybe the material is paint. Maybe it's some other sort of coating. Who cares?

Um... You care. Sunstealer cares. I care. Pretty much everyone who has the slightest interest in the question of 911 involving non-muslims does.

The chances of it being some sort of esoteric rust prevention coating are extremely small. That fact, along with its other demonstrated properties (low ignition temp accompanied by a high-energy exothermic reaction, producing iron and silicon-based microspheres) make it difficult to deny that another energy source may have been available in the towers the day they fell.

The point is that the material when ignited exhibited characteristics of something other than "thermitic material": It did not reach the temperatures necessary for thermite. It did not reach temperatures necessary for the melting of steel. If you presume that some sort of reaction besides pure combustion occurred, you don't get elemental iron, you get an iron-silicate spheroid. That is all from Jones's own data. How do you claim that it is "thermitic material" with those characteristics?

How many times can this be said? It doesn't matter what you want to call it, given it's properties, it points to another energy source in the towers. How is it you can deny that the by-products from the commercial thermite matched closely to the by-products from the red-gray chips? Again, it's just your incredulity, and it's weak.


Read the link. Sunsetaler matches both morphology and X-EDS spectra with kaolinite. You've yet to muster an argument against this.

It's got a similar structure to kaolinite from those SE photos. Check. It's got similar chemical make-up. Check. Does kaolinite combust at 430C? Not even close. At what temp does the Si separate from the Al? Above 925C according to Wikipedia. So, you can stop linking to Sunstealer's posts already. I read them before I posted anything about this. We can categorically rule out kaolinite as the substance in the red/gray chips because it's not combustable at 430C.

That is, unless you are proposing that the hydrocarbon matrix is responsible for heating the kaolinite above that temp sufficiently to cause the reduction to SiO2 AND reducing Fe2O3 into elemental Fe. Is that what you're claiming? That's in the realm of possibility--in the same sense that it's possible for all the oxygen in the room to suddenly shift to one side. Not likely.

But that's all you have to hang on to with the kaolinite argument: extremely low probabilities in the face of an alternate energy source in the towers. This is exactly where the whole idea of "skeptics" at JREF becomes inverted. You must accept unfathomably low probabilities that have yet to even be corroborated in order to deny the evidence that there was another energy source in the towers.

#SKEPTICFAIL
 
Does kaolinite combust at 430C?
#SKEPTICFAIL
Paper does with more energy.
Paint does with almost the same energy as the super-nano-thermite.

From the paper: If it was thermite, all the energies would be the same, they are not. Why not?
 
The material is not incendiary. It can burn, but that's not it's primary purpose.

Really? You've determined it's primary purpose? Was it paint? Paint that ignites at 430! Wow! That's great work, detective.

And given the presence of characteristics indicating paint - such as the undeniable presence of kaolin - then it should indeed be present.

It doesn't matter how much you want this stuff to be kaolinite. It doesn't change according to our will. Show me some dry paint that shares the same characteristics as this material and I'll renounce the whole "inside job" thing. Again, you can't. Because it doesn't exist. If it did, someone would've pointed it out by now.

Ps: You're not only failing to appreciate the difference between an "incendiary" and an "explosive" in your paragraph here, but you are also positing a specific about how the material was used.

Irrelevant. I've said it about 6 times in this thread already: I don't know how this material was used. You can ignore that and reinterpret that to mean something I didn't say, however, it doesn't change the fact that this material shouldn't be in the towers.

No one's saying "the material is not there".

Have you read anything T.A.M. wrote?

The message you're missing is that it is not "thermitic".

You make knowledge claims here on the wrong side of the evidence. The evidence demonstrates that there is indeed elemental Al and Fe2O3 present. It also produced by-product that is very similar to commercial thermite by-product as well as the microspheres in the WTC dust.

It's interesting that there are about 5 or 6 different theories about the sources of the microspheres--(my fav still being that it's boiled blood!)--yet, when presented with corroborative evidence on top of corroborative evidence, that their is strong reason to suspect that they have suspicious origins, the best anyone can do is deny the evidence.

Highly energetic material with a low ignition point covers many materials.

And of those, how many take the form of little red/gray chips? And of those, how many ignite at 430C and produce an intense exothermic reaction? Yea, none. It's not possible to hang on to any other materials as contenders when all the properties are factored in--that is, unless you want to simply deny evidence. Do you have any scientific papers that contradict the findings in the HFJ paper? No.

What's more disingenuous? What I wrote, or your attempt to define "agenda" as only being financially driven? I'm not the one commiting the fallacy of false choice by restricting the definition. Money has nothing to do with it.

So, you have absolutely no way to even formulate what my "agenda" is, but you are absolutely certain I have one. Very uncritical of you.

On top of that, military contractors make billions regardless of whether the towers fell or not. I don't recall the recent "Star Wars" laser platform being dependent on the narrative of 9/11, nor the next generation of fighter aircraft. Yet Jones and Gage only make their comparative pennies by pushing the lie. Does the magnitude of the difference change the fact that only one of them has any interest in continuing the conspiracy fantasy?

my emphasis

We are in the process of disambiguating who is involved in "conspiracy fantasy." The more science is done, the more it appears that there is indeed a strong urge to keep the conspiracy fantasy that boiling blood can produce iron microspheres or that kaolinite will combust at 430C or that iron microspheres must have been present all along in the red/gray chips.
 
So despite their claims that the combustion of the chips produced iron and silicate spheres, you don't believe it. So what? When did incredulity become a solid foundation for making claims on JREF?
It would help if they provided PROOF that they combusted. I"m sorry, but jones et al do not get a pass.

Their science is shoddy. Plain and simple. They haven't had any good controls and there are over 20 major methodological errors in this "paper." Throw it out and start over.

The ONLY thing you've demonstrated beyond any reasonable doubt is your disbelief. Do you have any scientific papers that demonstrate that the chips are not in the dust? Or that they're kaolinite? Or that they do NOT produce iron and silicate spheres when combusted? No. You have nothing but a refusal to accept their findings. Congratulations.

no, No, NO, NO. Bad truther. The burden of proof is on you, jones and others. They haven't provided proof, it hasn't passed peer review, and it hasn't appeared in any journal, nor in any convention.

Why can't you do that?

and yes. I do refuse to accept their findings. What part of 20 methodological errors INVALIDATES their findings and conclusions do you not understand?

Is it the
I? N? V? A? L? I? D? A? T? E? or the S? that you do not understand?


The chances of it being some sort of esoteric rust prevention coating are extremely small.

then prove it. do a REAL paper with REAL controls done by REAL scientists, passing REAL peer review and appearing in a REAL journal.


That fact, along with its other demonstrated properties (low ignition temp accompanied by a high-energy exothermic reaction, producing iron and silicon-based microspheres) make it difficult to deny that another energy source may have been available in the towers the day they fell.

No it doesn't. They have not eliminated ANY of the other possiblities, and by failing to test in an inert environment, they have failed to even open the door that it is exothermic in anyways.

How many times can this be said? It doesn't matter what you want to call it, given it's properties, it points to another energy source in the towers.
How many times can this be said? IF YOU HAVE MAJOR METHODOLOGICAL ERRORS IN YOUR PAPER, YOU CAN'T USE THE FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS OR EVEN THE DATA.
How is it you can deny that the by-products from the commercial thermite matched closely to the by-products from the red-gray chips? Again, it's just your incredulity, and it's weak.

because they match much closer to kaolinite. Because unless you can ELIMINATE ANY POSSIBLE OTHER SOURCES, you cannot CLAIM it is something. And this "paper" fails to do that.

It's got a similar structure to kaolinite from those SE photos. Check. It's got similar chemical make-up. Check. Does kaolinite combust at 430C? Not even close. At what temp does the Si separate from the Al? Above 925C according to Wikipedia. So, you can stop linking to Sunstealer's posts already. I read them before I posted anything about this. We can categorically rule out kaolinite as the substance in the red/gray chips because it's not combustable at 430C.

No you cannot. Due to the METHODOLOGICAL ERRORS you cannot use teh findings, conclusions or even the raw data.

And considering that this is in the dust, it has been cooked, cured, and then allowed to dry out over 5 years. That does change things... you know... like ignition points, chemical bonds etc...

scrap this crap and do it over.

But that's all you have to hang on to with the kaolinite argument: extremely low probabilities in the face of an alternate energy source in the towers. This is exactly where the whole idea of "skeptics" at JREF becomes inverted. You must accept unfathomably low probabilities that have yet to even be corroborated in order to deny the evidence that there was another energy source in the towers.

#SKEPTICFAIL

You have the FAIL part right. Now then, why don't you go and take a simple experimental design course, maybe some basic chemistry courses and a research methods course. Then you can find the 20 major methodological errors and UNDERSTAND why you can't use their findings, conclusions or even their data because they ****ED IT UP that badly.

try again.
 
You bend over backwards to argue the presence of a material that melts steel and has been cited by advocates of the "controlled demolition" narrative, but yet you profess to "not know how this stuff was used."? And in the very same post call it an "explosive"? :rolleyes: That's a 5-year-old's attempt at sophistry. You're citing the work of a person - Jones - on record as having claimed that thermite was used in the destruction of the Twin Towers, and you are advocating that he is correct in proposing that "thermitic material" was present. Furthermore, you characterize an incendiary as an explosive, further demonstrating what you believe the material was used for. When you say that you "do not know how this stuff was used", what fiction do you think you're passing on us? Unless you think that explosives have some purpose other than to explode, you come right out and say how you think it was used. See above.

Nice rant. I admit, I'm not expert in explosives. But it doesn't take a genius or a specialist to see that if you find a strange, abundant energy source in the dust whose by-products are also abundant in the dust, there might be reason to look further. Am I using those words incorrectly? That may be true. Given that the origins and properties of the material in question are still being analyzed by experts, it's unclear whether it's explosive or incendiary or both, however, it is undeniably an unusual and abundant energy source that shouldn't be in the WTC dust. And no amount of doubt will change that.

There's your lie right there. QED. You claim the presence of an incendiary material in a tower in the same context of accusing the US government of killing citizens in a collapse of a tower, and you cite evidence from a known advocate of the "controlled demolitions" proposal. No one's so dumb as to not see through that. Drop the pose; you're transparent as glass.

Quit trying to take attention away from your poor attempts at denying the evidence.




Wow. Picture comparisons. It reminds me of the DEW folks who keep pointing to grainy pics of dust clouds as "proof" of cosmic ray guns.

And what are the other contradictions? To start with: There's the proposition that something suspicious was planted in the towers; there wasn't.

We haven't determined that there wasn't. That's what this conversation is about.

And not a bit of the Jones paper speaks towards that.

Except the entire thing.

Also: There's the analysis of the very data Jones and Harrit provides demonstrating that there is kaolin present and that the aluminum was bound.

Repeating it doesn't make it any closer to true.

I've given you two direct links to posts discussing that above; you can search for the rest on your own. And that right there by itself negates Jones's and Harrit's conclusions...

Keep repeating it, maybe the laws of physics will change.

...what MEK did to one single chip out of the sample does not change the results of the spectroscopy of the rest of the chips.

Nor does it rule out the existence of elemental Al in the rest of the chips. That is the conclusion you would like to draw, isn't it? But demonstrating that elemental Al is in one chip does not make it less likely that the other chips also contain elemental Al. Welcome to the world of inductive reasoning.
 
[*]Confront the lack of melting on critical steel pieces. You dodged it by claiming that it "wasn't your theory" or somesuch. Irrelevant.

How much of the steel was examined? 1 PERCENT!! You don't disagree. And we should make sweeping knowledge claims about the other 99% in your opinion? That's being "critical?" "Skeptical?" I don't think you're really a "skeptic."

This isn't a tantrum. This is a lecture. It would be a conversation if you had demonstrated any ability to put aside your arrogance and recognize where your failures of comprehension are, but unfortunately, your rejection of fact and reality has forced this to be a one-way talk. I've provided links to what the refutations to your arguments are, and at all times you have failed to pay attention to them. You refuse to recognize truth. At some point, the lecture will turn into laughter at the extent of your oblivion. But feel free to keep on mistaking what you read. Let me know when you're ready to confront your inability to understand the flaws of the paper and the outright errors committed in the reasearch. At that point, maybe you'll be ready to conduct a productive conversation. But until then, all you're doing is pitching a snow job.

That whole paragraph basically says "I know you are but what am I?" Thanks for the "lecture."
 
So despite their claims that the combustion of the chips produced iron and silicate spheres, you don't believe it. So what? When did incredulity become a solid foundation for making claims on JREF?

Incredulity nothing. I told you they didn't prove it, and furthermore cited a photo where spheres were visible in a sample prior to combustion. Furthermore, you ignore all the other posts demonstrating 1. A lack of examination establishing that the DSC'd chips were indeed the same composition as the ones subjected to spectroscopy, and 2. A lack of proof that the spheres weren't there beforehand. Again, you are the one swallowing that uncritically. I cited a photo, I refered to what Jones and his cohorts wrote.

The ONLY thing you've demonstrated beyond any reasonable doubt is your disbelief. Do you have any scientific papers that demonstrate that the chips are not in the dust? Or that they're kaolinite? Or that they do NOT produce iron and silicate spheres when combusted? No. You have nothing but a refusal to accept their findings. Congratulations.

Pfff... what we've all shown are the paper's failings. The problem here is that you refuse to accept that they have not only failed to demonstrate the presence of "thermitic material", but in fact contradicted it with their findings, namely the spectroscopic image Sunstealer used to demonstrate the presence of bound aluminum, as well as the totally contraindicative energy densities.

Their own data contradicts their claims. You simply refuse to accept that.

Um... You care. Sunstealer cares. I care. Pretty much everyone who has the slightest interest in the question of 911 involving non-muslims does.

Nice attempt to dodge. What I was pointing out was that whatever the material was, it couldn't have been "thermitic material" because the data contradicts that.

The chances of it being some sort of esoteric rust prevention coating are extremely small.

You provide no support for this claim, and it is also contradicted by what we've been saying for what, 4 pages now. Whether it was paint, some sort of standard (why esoteric? So you can make your argument feel stronger?) rust prevention coating, or whatnot, the facts remain:
  1. Bound aluminum
  2. Kaolin identified
End of story. What matters is that the possibility of it being "thermitic material" has been eliminated. And by Jones's and Harrit's own data too. That's why we call their research sloppy: Their data contradicts their conclusions. And only suckers like you don't see that.

That fact, along with its other demonstrated properties (low ignition temp accompanied by a high-energy exothermic reaction, producing iron and silicon-based microspheres) make it difficult to deny that another energy source may have been available in the towers the day they fell.

How? Bazant has demonstrated that once the towers began their collapse, there was more than enough energy available to sever the floor connections and collapse all the way to the ground. No other energy source would even be needed.

Furthermore, you keep on thinking the properties discovered in the experiments only apply to thermite. No. The "high-energy exothermic reaction" they claim was from a thermite reaction completely misses the energy-density boat: It is impossible for thermite to cause energy densities greater than the limit imposed by thermite's enthalpy of reaction. Combine that with the fact that they burnt a chip alleged to be paint (and therefore rife with hydrocarbons) in an oxygen environment, and you have enough to conclude that their "high-energy exothermic reaction" (as if there's any such thing as an endothermic combustion :rolleyes:) was the hydrocarbon aspect of the chip (the stuff Jones handwaves as "sol gel") burning. Combine all that with the lack of proof behind their claim of microspheres not being present beforehand, and an image in their own paper showing spheres of some nature afterwards, and what more do we need? You are the one swallowing their party line uncritically. You are the one refusing to think your way through this.


How many times can this be said? It doesn't matter what you want to call it, given it's properties, it points to another energy source in the towers. How is it you can deny that the by-products from the commercial thermite matched closely to the by-products from the red-gray chips? Again, it's just your incredulity, and it's weak.

How many times can this be said: The aluminum was bound. The kaolin was present. It doesn't matter what you want to call it, given it's properties, it points to the hydrocarbons burning. How is it that you can deny the contradictory energy density well beyond thermite's enthalpy of reaction?

And no, the "by-products from the commercial thermite" did not match the by-products from the red-gray chips. Reread the paper. Aside from the microspheres which were not proven to have been there beforehand, name any other byproduct of his burning of the chips.

It's got a similar structure to kaolinite from those SE photos. Check. It's got similar chemical make-up. Check. Does kaolinite combust at 430C? Not even close. At what temp does the Si separate from the Al? Above 925C according to Wikipedia. So, you can stop linking to Sunstealer's posts already. I read them before I posted anything about this. We can categorically rule out kaolinite as the substance in the red/gray chips because it's not combustable at 430C.

Who said it was the kaolin that burnt? Jones himself tries to dodge the energy problems away by citing the burning of what he mistakenly thinks is the sol-gel. His own data shows the presence of carbon and oxygen, and EDX spectroscopy does not show hydrogen. The point? Jones's own data shows the presence of hydrocarbons. That was what burnt! No one ever tried to claim it was the kaolin that combusted!

You rule it out based on a mistake in logic. Kaolin is most certainly not ruled out, given that the combustible component of the chips was never alleged to have been kaolin to begin with, and given that other characteristics match it perfectly.

That is, unless you are proposing that the hydrocarbon matrix is responsible for heating the kaolinite above that temp sufficiently to cause the reduction to SiO2 AND reducing Fe2O3 into elemental Fe. Is that what you're claiming? That's in the realm of possibility--in the same sense that it's possible for all the oxygen in the room to suddenly shift to one side. Not likely.

Yes, the hydrocarbons is the only thing left that could have burned. And no, again: Look at figure 3 in his paper; spheres present in one sample before combustion. Also: Find the section where Jones/Harrit prove - not merely assert, but prove - that the spheres were not present to begin with. You cannot claim that the spheres were created during the combustion, and in fact need to explain the photo indicating that they were present beforehand.

The bottom line is that you cannot back up the claim of microsphere generation during the combustion with their data. Those researchers merely claim it, they do not demonstrate it. And one of their own pieces of data argues against it.

You want to disprove that? Convince Jones and Harrit to replicate their findings, but in an anaerobic environment. Their findings regarding energies are meaningless when they provide a means for the hydrocarbons to burn.

But that's all you have to hang on to with the kaolinite argument: extremely low probabilities in the face of an alternate energy source in the towers.

Wrong. See above. Double check Sunstealer's post as well, and yes, I will continue to link them. Your attempts at refutation do not negate what he has demonstrated, and your argument still fails on what he has shown.

This is exactly where the whole idea of "skeptics" at JREF becomes inverted. You must accept unfathomably low probabilities that have yet to even be corroborated in order to deny the evidence that there was another energy source in the towers.

#SKEPTICFAIL

This is exactly where the whole idea of "thermitic material" in your thesis fails. You must accept unsupported allegations, weak pattern matching (re: Temperatures), and overlook outright contradictions (re: energy densities above 3.9 kj/g, spectroscopy demonstrating bound aluminum (Hey, look! Another Sunstealer post that negates your claim!)) in order to forward your claim that there was some other energy source in the towers.

#TRUTHERFAIL

Until you confront the lack of proof that the spheres weren't present beforehand and address the fact that a photo shows spheres prior to combustion, you will get nowhere. Until you confront the fact that kaolin was demonstrated to be present, and understand that your counterargument fails due to the mistaken belief that it was the kaolin that combusted, you will get nowhere. Until you confront the fact that their own energy densities exceeded 3.9 kj/g, thus contraindicating thermite, you will get nowhere.

To date, you've gotten nowhere. Time for you to give up the fantasy.
 
There is a simple solution, but Jones et al would not dare engage in it, because it would expose their sham...

1. Provide the names etc... of the suppliers of the original samples Jones used.
2. Have a truly independent lab collect those samples, and collect samples from other sources with well known, reliable chains of custody.
3. Have said lab conduct appropriate studies to determine if their is any evidence of exotic explosives/incindiaries in the dust, and if so, in which samples.

NOT GOING TO HAPPEN!

TAM:)
 
How? Bazant has demonstrated that once the towers began their collapse, there was more than enough energy available to sever the floor connections and collapse all the way to the ground. No other energy source would even be needed.



Furthermore, you keep on thinking the properties discovered in the experiments only apply to thermite. No. The "high-energy exothermic reaction" they claim was from a thermite reaction completely misses the energy-density boat: It is impossible for thermite to cause energy densities greater than the limit imposed by thermite's enthalpy of reaction.

Is it possible for hydrocarbons at those amounts (i.e. less than a gram) to reduce Iron (iii) Oxide to elemental Fe?

(hint: no way) If you don't believe me, try roasting some rust with a bic lighter and see if it turns to Fe before it runs out of gas.

Conclusion: something other than hydrocarbon material is heating the contents enough to cause high-temperature reactions thereby producing elemental Fe and silicate spheres. You want to call it something other than "thermitic?" Be my guest.

Combine that with the fact that they burnt a chip alleged to be paint (and therefore rife with hydrocarbons) in an oxygen environment...

The only ones alleging it's paint are here. The authors of the paper make a very good case that it cannot be paint. For the 3rd or 4th time, if you can show me some dried paint that exhibits the same characteristics when heated, I will bow out of this entire stream of thought. Not holding my breath.

How many times can this be said: The aluminum was bound. The kaolin was present.

Are you claiming to know this from the XEDS graphs? I hope you're aware that XEDS can't give chemical compositions. A photo comparison and XEDS cannot "demonstrate" the presence of a particular chemical species. You're not the only one around here that wants to speak in a condescending manner, yet it appears you have little grasp on how to make sense of the available data or even have much of a grasp on basic chemistry.

Given that the MEK-soaked chip positively demonstrated the existence of elemental Al, your response is that it must be yet another unidentified material from the red/gray chips...

Sure. Because lots of paint has elemental aluminum in it, yea? And has red/gray layers? Yea? That's better than knowing everything you've been lead by the nose to believe by the very people you've put your trust in has all been a giant, blatant lie.

Who said it was the kaolin that burnt? Jones himself tries to dodge the energy problems away by citing the burning of what he mistakenly thinks is the sol-gel. His own data shows the presence of carbon and oxygen, and EDX spectroscopy does not show hydrogen.

Here's a clue: since H has only one proton, it's too light for XEDS to show--at least at the keV's they ran the electron beam at.

The point? Jones's own data shows the presence of hydrocarbons. That was what burnt! No one ever tried to claim it was the kaolin that combusted!

That's what happens when you pretend that the original substance was kaolinite to begin with--it's OBVIOUSLY absurd. How then, do you account for Si-based microspheres as a by-product? Or would you like to propose that those too were in the matrix before they combusted?

Do you NOW believe Si spheres were also already there since it's the only way you can dismiss this evidence? Or do you just want to say they're lying about everything? That they sprinkled the Fe and Si based spheres in the ashes of the chips and then "analyzed" them?

But there's another issue that we need to clarify: the Fe microspheres produced from the combustion of the chips. Are you saying they were present in the chips before combustion? Are you denying that Sunstealer agrees with the existence of faceted Fe particles in the matrix? Or just that they weren't reduced to Fe?

Why is it difficult to imagine that since these chips appear to be pieces that did not completely combust that they would therefore have partially combusted by-product on the edges of them? That certainly doesn't seem far fetched if those substances are the natural by-products and we're looking at partially-combusted specimens.

Really, you're just better off claiming they've lied about everything. Or you think 9 scientists would agree to "cherry pick" analyses that would clearly not further anyone's career.

This is the point at which claims to the contrary are WAY more ridiculous than just accepting the science in front of us. No one said the truth would be pretty.
 
The evidence demonstrates that there is indeed elemental Al and Fe2O3 present.
There's no evidence in the paper for what you're claiming there is. There's a clearly false statement about what Fig. 15 indicates with respect to the Fe and O. There's also information hiding because in the MEK chip the XEDS spectrum prior to the soaking shows a lot of elements present, but the XEDS maps for these elements are not shown. There are clearly large areas for which no element of those for which we have the maps appears at all:

MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Al+Si+O+Fe+C.jpg


So there's no proof that the Al is not bound to anything else, because we are being hidden some of the elements present in the MEK chip.

Also, there's a lot of unoxidized Fe, something totally inconsistent with any kind of 'thermitic' material (or are you claiming that the MEK solvent separates the oxygen from the Fe?) Yellow=Fe without O, Brown=Fe with O

MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Fe-O-Si.jpg


Unless you address these points, you should stop claiming that the material is 'thermitic' because the 'proof' you're using is bogus. You have failed to address any of these points so far, and have dismissed them as being 'incredulity', which they aren't.

Given that the MEK-soaked chip positively demonstrated the existence of elemental Al, [...]
No it didn't. The MEK chip is shown by its spectrum to be substantially different to the rest, yet they dismiss the many extra elements as 'contamination' without proof. They show the XEDS map of Al but they don't prove it was not bound to anything else because they lack lots of elements. That's not a positive demonstration AT ALL.

You're taking the paper as if it were wirtten by unbiased people with expertise in the field who used a proper methodology, publishing it in a reputed journal passing a decent review process. None of these assumptions holds and thus there is no reason to take any authority from that paper, so it doesn't have any more weight than Sunstealer's arguments, which you're dismissing merely on the basis of the same incredulity you're accusing others to have, despite his expertise in a field where none of the authors were authorities, and neither are you, who are using your arrogance to dismiss his proof.

There's no 'extraordinary proof' in the paper that matches the extraordinary claims. On the contrary, the proof presented by them contradicts their claims.
 
There's no evidence in the paper for what you're claiming there is. There's a clearly false statement about what Fig. 15 indicates with respect to the Fe and O. There's also information hiding because in the MEK chip the XEDS spectrum prior to the soaking shows a lot of elements present, but the XEDS maps for these elements are not shown. There are clearly large areas for which no element of those for which we have the maps appears at all:

[qimg]http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/11-s/MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Al+Si+O+Fe+C.jpg[/qimg]

So there's no proof that the Al is not bound to anything else, because we are being hidden some of the elements present in the MEK chip.

Also, there's a lot of unoxidized Fe, something totally inconsistent with any kind of 'thermitic' material (or are you claiming that the MEK solvent separates the oxygen from the Fe?) Yellow=Fe without O, Brown=Fe with O

[qimg]http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/11-s/MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Fe-O-Si.jpg[/qimg]

Unless you address these points, you should stop claiming that the material is 'thermitic' because the 'proof' you're using is bogus. You have failed to address any of these points so far, and have dismissed them as being 'incredulity', which they aren't.


No it didn't. The MEK chip is shown by its spectrum to be substantially different to the rest, yet they dismiss the many extra elements as 'contamination' without proof. They show the XEDS map of Al but they don't prove it was not bound to anything else because they lack lots of elements. That's not a positive demonstration AT ALL.

You're taking the paper as if it were wirtten by unbiased people with expertise in the field who used a proper methodology, publishing it in a reputed journal passing a decent review process. None of these assumptions holds and thus there is no reason to take any authority from that paper, so it doesn't have any more weight than Sunstealer's arguments, which you're dismissing merely on the basis of the same incredulity you're accusing others to have, despite his expertise in a field where none of the authors were authorities, and neither are you, who are using your arrogance to dismiss his proof.

There's no 'extraordinary proof' in the paper that matches the extraordinary claims. On the contrary, the proof presented by them contradicts their claims.


So you're no longer claiming that the MEK-soaked chip was a different substance, but they are simply altering their data to make it appear as though there's elemental Al in it? O.k. Does this mean you still think the material is some kind of paint or corrosion protection? What do you think the chances are you could find some, dry it, bake it, run some tests on it and get a paper published with results that confirm your theory?

And even if you want to say there's elemental Fe in the matrix, it's clearly not in microsphere form until after combustion of the chips. How do you account for that?
 
So we have a "paper" with over 20 methodological errors, a group of "researchers" who are outside of their area of expertise and education who have a known bias and they don't use independent labs for analysis... wowsers. Call the press!!!!

I'm aware of several of the errors having read through the paper several times and looking at some of the threads on this issue....

Is there a consolidated list of the 20 errors somewhere?
 
So you're no longer claiming that the MEK-soaked chip was a different substance, but they are simply altering their data to make it appear as though there's elemental Al in it?
No, I am claiming that because it's a different substance, they obtain wrong conclusions unrelated to the previous chips they analyze. I can't see any proof about elemental Al in their data despite their claims. I have insisted that we lack XEDS maps of other elements present, so there's no proof that the Al is free. For example there could be aluminium sulfide, but since we're not shown the XEDS map for S that the XEDS spectrum shows, we'd never know.

O.k. Does this mean you still think the material is some kind of paint or corrosion protection? What do you think the chances are you could find some, dry it, bake it, run some tests on it and get a paper published with results that confirm your theory?
I'm not claiming they dried and baked it. I'm saying the chips were probably in the dust. Remember the chips were separated with a magnet, so at least Fe was almost guaranteed. Many different things of very different nature can be attracted to a magnet, then selected for 'red-gray nature' of some kind, and that's where Sunstealer's table of chips comes handy in distinguishing them. Remember fig. 31, it's totally different from anything else and it's just part of what the magnet attracted.

And even if you want to say there's elemental Fe in the matrix, it's clearly not in microsphere form until after combustion of the chips. How do you account for that?
You get my claims wrong every time. I haven't claimed there's elemental Fe; I insist that we lack XEDS maps of other elements present, so the Fe might not be free; for example there might be iron sulfide, but since we're not shown the XEDS map for S we'd never know. I have claimed instead that there's a lot of unoxidized Fe. I haven't seen any microspheres whatsoever in the MEK chip, and I haven't seen any indication that it was ever put through DSC so the claim that it would have produced microspheres is all yours, even if you've been shown by others in this thread that the microspheres in the other chips were already there. Can you prove your claim with respect to this, totally different MEK chip?

And can you now please explain how figure 15 shows that...

Oxygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron in the red material even after soaking in MEK solvent​

(p.19)?
 
Are you claiming to know this from the XEDS graphs? I hope you're aware that XEDS can't give chemical compositions.
Let's be clear here: XEDS done with a solid state X-ray detector gives elemental compositional information. It does not give bonding information or information about elements below atomic number 3 (Li).
A photo comparison and XEDS cannot demonstrat the presence of a particular chemical species.
It also can't demonstrate the absence of a particular species. Remember that XEDS is a surface analysis technique. Looking at samples other than 1 micron cubes requires the admission that X-rays generated deeper than a few microns into the sample are absorbed by the matrix, and thus, not detected. It is impossible to say, for a bulk sample, that the composition of the surface is homogeneous throughout, given the composition of the surface.
Given that the MEK-soaked chip positively demonstrated the existence of elemental Al, your response is that it must be yet another unidentified material from the red/gray chips
I've been seeing this a lot, so let's take the opportunity to correct an enormous misconception about Jones's analysis. In the Figure 17 spectrum, supposedly taken from the "high aluminum" region of the red chip, Jones claims that a "conventional" quantification routine showed an abundance of aluminum, beyond which the attachment to oxygen would predict. From this, Jones draws the wildly inaccurate conclusion that elemental aluminum must be present. First, the quantification routine Jones is using is known as standardless quant. In order to quantify (that is, derive the elemental composition from net peak intensities acquired in the spectrum) the spectrum, you need to make 3 fundamental assumptions about the sample: 1) The sample is homogeneous and isotropic in all 3 dimensions 2) All of the possible elements present will produce non-confounding, measurable X-rays. 3) The sample is flat, conducting and measured at high, constant vacuum. Looking at the first assumption, we know that the chip is not homogeneous. The XEDS images prove that beyond a reasonable doubt. Looking at the second assumption, we have to understand that quantitative XEDS requires an awful lot of a priori knowledge about the sample. Analyzing a pure glass sample, for instance, does require the assumption that there is no hydrogen or lithium present (lack of helium is usually assumed), or that it is present in extremely well known forms, such as water or lithium tetraborate. Now looking at the 3rd assumption, we clearly don't have a polished sample. So what? Well, X-rays need to travel in a straight line path to the detector. Lighter elements whose ionization cross section is only a few hundred nanometers (such as aluminum and oxygen) are heavily influenced by morphological changes in the sample. Why are we looking at these assumptions? Because they influence the accuracy of the numbers reported by the quantification routine, and none of them are true of the sample Jones is analyzing. When incorrectly assumed to be true, the three assumptions combined will often give spurious and nonsensical results. That's exactly what's happened here. And, perhaps more egregiously, Jones doesn't question the validity of the results because they support his predetermined conclusion. The issues are further compounded by the fact that such quantification routines always normalize to 100%, meaning that the values, which may have been correct before normalization, now only represent an idealized specimen. This idea that "elemental aluminum" exists is specious at best, given the evidence, and more likely to be unprovable. It may be true, but the data presented are not sufficient to support this conclusion.
Here's a clue: since H has only one proton, it's too light for XEDS to show--at least at the keV's they ran the electron beam at.
For your own edification, electrons produce X-rays, not protons. Hydrogen does not have sufficient energy levels to allow photoelectric absorption or inner shell ionization in the commonly defined X-ray range.
That's what happens when you pretend that the original substance was kaolinite to begin with--it's OBVIOUSLY absurd. How then, do you account for Si-based microspheres as a by-product? Or would you like to propose that those too were in the matrix before they combusted?
This is an entirely valid conclusion, given the evidence presented. The heterogeneous particles may have been concealing Si spheres (which are ubiquitous in dust and ash). The process of soaking and ashing may have simply brought them to the surface. Again, you're operating under the wildly inaccurate assumption that the XEDS techniques employed here tell you about anything more than the first micron of the surface. The chips analyzed are quite sizeable, and the Si K-alpha X-rays at 1.74 keV are only traveling through perhaps 1 micron of material. That means the matrix beyond the ionization cross section is largely invisible to this technique.
Do you NOW believe Si spheres were also already there since it's the only way you can dismiss this evidence?
Though I don't want to make the answer for my fellow JREFers, I think we agree that the answer is: There is no way to eliminate this possible confounding variable from the experimental matrix. Therefore, the conclusion is questionable.
But there's another issue that we need to clarify: the Fe microspheres produced from the combustion of the chips. Are you saying they were present in the chips before combustion?
Yes, a thousand times, yes. Iron, iron microspheres, iron bearing minerals, iron oxides, iron hydroxides, iron squiddiliddilidoos and others are all ubiquitous in nature. Their presence signifies nothing.
Really, you're just better off claiming they've lied about everything. Or you think 9 scientists would agree to cherry pick; analyses that would clearly not further anyone's career.
It is not unheard of that scientists would lie and misrepresent data in order to further their careers. It's also not unheard of to simply be ignorant and draw inaccurate, nonsensical conclusions from data.
 
I'm aware of several of the errors having read through the paper several times and looking at some of the threads on this issue....

Is there a consolidated list of the 20 errors somewhere?

Unfortunately I have not consolidated the list.

So no. I know that there are about 20 and if you want to find them, start with the original thread that this on was split from (all 60+ pages) and now all 15+ pages here.

Sorry.

Off the top of my head I can think of 2 or 3 of the main ones.
1. the issue with the control (which is huge and takes 3 or for of the 20 methodological errors). That would be a. the lack of telling us what the control was b. using a control that is in NO way similar to the paint or rust proofing that was in the towers. C. using paint from the byu stadium (different color, different manufacturer, etc...)
2. The lack of testing any of the combustion experiments in an inert environment.
3. the lack of removing "contamination" for which they handwave away differences.
4. the lack of testing any "nanothermite" for comparision

and there are lots more...When I read the main thread, I came up with 20.. but I don't have the comprehensive list.

but notice that Jay had completely decided to ignore all of the methodological errors as he can't explain ANY of them away... so it doesn't really matter for this discussion.
 
Also, there's a lot of unoxidized Fe, something totally inconsistent with any kind of 'thermitic' material (or are you claiming that the MEK solvent separates the oxygen from the Fe?) Yellow=Fe without O, Brown=Fe with O

As you well know, the O is bound up with more than just the Fe. We know for a fact that the red matrix is a hydrocarbon, the silicon is likely bound as well and the Fe2O3--which is not really a controversial position. So there's plenty of O that doesn't overlap the Fe. Keep in mind these maps are qualitative in nature--they can show groupings of elements, but to expect isomorphic overlap on an atomic scale is unrealistic. They may have adjusted the intensities of the maps to highlight the areas of greatest concentrations to make clear that there were indeed areas with Si but not Al. The XEDS spectrographs then verify that the Al exists independently of Si AND that Fe does NOT exist without a corresponding O peak that is greater than the Fe peaks.

The Fe2O3 is what was identified as the faceted, relatively dense particles about 100 nm in diameter. It's also, (not controversially), what likely gives the substance its red appearance. Even the people who want to claim it's paint agree that there's Fe2O3 in there.

This argument is a non-starter.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom