Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

I don't remember anyone claim that samples 1-4 are contaminated, and there's no proof of free aluminium in them. Unoxidized aluminium was only present in the MEK-soaked chip, which is of a different nature, so there's no basis to affirm that the material in samples 1-4 is 'thermitic' or 'explosive'.

So, are you proposing that there is another[/] substance in the dust that was also magnetically separated and is composed of red/gray layers?
 
All we have is evidence and probability.

To write the results off as contamination of 4 different samples with the same material is wildly less probable than the probability of that material simply being in the dust.
Are you really going to show a full lack of understanding of probability and the scientific method? Really?

<facepalm>

We already know there are over 20 methodological errors in this "paper." That alone invalidates ANY of their findings, conclusions or data.

But you decide to shift away from that (you keep on shifting) and now you try to bring in probablity?

Great.

What is the probability that of ALL the labs which have examined the dust, the only one to find anything is a group of "scientists" who are way outside of their specialities, education and knowledge base?

What is that probability that those labs would be wrong? Huh? Hmmm?

Your failing to understand research methods, experimental design and now probability.

Thank you for playing.

If you want to claim the samples were seeded by the Harrit/Farrer/Jones crew, that's nice but there isn't any good reason to accept that over the acquisition process they claim.

I actually don't say that. I say that they are wrong about what they are. I'm saying that with the craptacular "science" they have tried to pass off, it is impossible to claim with a straight face that it is anything. Why do you keep trying?

Do you think it's more reasonable to accept that the samples are contaminated because they appear to have explosive chips in them? or would you be all up in arms about the samples even if they found nothing suspicious?

I just wonder why NO ONE ELSE (you know real experts) have found this, or thought it wasn't paint.

So we have a "paper" with over 20 methodological errors, a group of "researchers" who are outside of their area of expertise and education who have a known bias and they don't use independent labs for analysis... wowsers. Call the press!!!!
 
Those who take the contamination position have a difficult hill to climb with little more than some speculation. This is the time to show any evidence (beyond incredulity) for consideration of this stance or accept that the substance was in the dust and these samples are representative. Or opt into the world of ignore.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Jones get some samples used from Janette MacKinlay (another 9/11 Truth Movement member) who had put some dust found in her apartment(debris-dust that reportedly got there) and mailed it to him... nine days after 9/11??
If this is true and Jones used, in part, samples thereof, it had to have been exposed to possible influx and contamination during those nine days.
Furthermore, Janette's boyfried was a sculptor who reportedly used welding tools and metals in his artistic sculpturing.
How do we know none of the samples in the dust collected came from his stuff?
 
I am affirming that there was. See fig. 31.

So the 2nd material was also magnetically separated from the dust, was composed of a red/gray layered compound, but was unlike the other chips (how you could know this is unclear) because it demonstrated the presence of elemental Al after the MEK soak. And you maintain that claim based on the claim that you've identified a 3rd kind of material from a photograph, which was also magnetically separated from the dust, but instead of being a red/gray chip, it's a red/gray/red chip. That's your best argument?

Do you know what kind of shreds a "truther" would be ripped to if he came here with that kind of an argument? You've got to do better than that.
 
So the 2nd material was also magnetically separated from the dust, was composed of a red/gray layered compound, but was unlike the other chips (how you could know this is unclear) because it demonstrated the presence of elemental Al after the MEK soak. And you maintain that claim based on the claim that you've identified a 3rd kind of material from a photograph, which was also magnetically separated from the dust, but instead of being a red/gray chip, it's a red/gray/red chip. That's your best argument?
My argument, which you apparently ignored, is in message #466 with a correction in message #468.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Jones get some samples used from Janette MacKinlay (another 9/11 Truth Movement member) who had put some dust found in her apartment(debris-dust that reportedly got there) and mailed it to him... nine days after 9/11??
If this is true and Jones used, in part, samples thereof, it had to have been exposed to possible influx and contamination during those nine days.
Furthermore, Janette's boyfried was a sculptor who reportedly used welding tools and metals in his artistic sculpturing.
How do we know none of the samples in the dust collected came from his stuff?

If it's from welding materials from Mckinley's apt, how did it get in the other 3 samples? One of them was collected 10 minutes after the collapse of building 1.

Your criticism holds no water the moment the material is found in another sample--unless you want to claim that the HFJ guys are making all this up. Is that your next claim?


.
 
That doesn't help make sense of the ignition products of the red/gray chips. Are you suggesting they are made of coal?


.

Sure it does.

The ignition process of the red/gray chips is unknown. Because it was tested in an OXYGEN RICH ENVIRONMENT, you have something that burns in the presence of air.

Wow... Just like COAL.

Unless they have tested it in an INERT environment... did they do that while I wasn't looking?

So unless you have some form of a test in an inert environment, you have no proof that it is an exothermic reaction. What you do have is something burning in AIR. Doh!
 
If it's from welding materials from Mckinley's apt, how did it get in the other 3 samples? One of them was collected 10 minutes after the collapse of building 1.

Your criticism holds no water the moment the material is found in another sample--unless you want to claim that the HFJ guys are making all this up. Is that your next claim?


.

YOur claims "holds no water the moment" that this "paper" has complete and utter crapola for controls and over 20 methodological errors. Once you look at those, this becomes the fail boat and you keep on speeding up into those icebergs ahead.

If you want to do anything, scrap this piece of crap, and do it again. Send your materails to outside, INDEPENDENT LABS and have them tell you what is in it.

Why is it that Henri C coudln't find any red/gray chips in his samples?

Until you can a. do the science correctly, b. get independent lab confirmation and c. get it replicated this is nothing more than psuedo scientific babble.

Try again.
 
That doesn't help make sense of the ignition products of the red/gray chips. Are you suggesting they are made of coal?

No, I was answering your question. The point is, though, that truthers have created a mystic air of voodoo about the presence of iron-rich microspheres in the combustion products and the WTC dust, to give the deliberately misleading impression that such things can only possibly be created by a thermite reaction. In fact, this is a complete, deliberate and carefully calculated lie, and iron-rich microspheres are a fairly common product of mundane and commonplace combustion reactions.

Dave
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Jones get some samples used from Janette MacKinlay (another 9/11 Truth Movement member) who had put some dust found in her apartment(debris-dust that reportedly got there) and mailed it to him... nine days after 9/11??
If this is true and Jones used, in part, samples thereof, it had to have been exposed to possible influx and contamination during those nine days.
Furthermore, Janette's boyfried was a sculptor who reportedly used welding tools and metals in his artistic sculpturing.
How do we know none of the samples in the dust collected came from his stuff?

Exactly. Hence my (and others) point that without a reliable and known chain of custody, the samples and hence the whole paper are useless. Prime example.

Of course Jay will make the argument that the same chips showed up in all 4 samples and that makes intentional contamination/fabrication unlikely. He is correct, in the sense that it makes such unlikely by the separate entities that supplied the samples, but beyond that...who knows.

TAM:)
 
If it's from welding materials from Mckinley's apt, how did it get in the other 3 samples? One of them was collected 10 minutes after the collapse of building 1.

Your criticism holds no water the moment the material is found in another sample--unless you want to claim that the HFJ guys are making all this up. Is that your next claim?

Well let's not run with the absolutes like so. First of all, the criticism implied for, if it is as Jones said quite some time ago, concerning the samples from Mckinley's apartment, the samples (plural) collected thereof? Did he use several samples thereof (he took many samples from the apartment)? Did they put the samples together?
In any case, that/those samples should be identified and automatically excluded. You can't possibly disagree with that can you?

And which sample was the one collected 10 minutes after the collapse?
I assume you are referring to Delessio who just stood still while he got consumed by the dust clouds of the North Tower, swept his hand on and over the railing and then went straight his friend with the dust in his hand, where they put it in a plastic bag and later send it to Jones??

McKinley's sample, according to Jones, was sample nr:1.
Delessio's was nr:2. Intermont's (collected from Hudson Street by him) was number 3 and Stephen White's (from his own apartment) got to be number 4.

Furthermore, it's not clear that the dust samples weren't partly affected by potential compounds from within the WTC's, like transistors, generators, batteries in smitherines potentially gone through explosive pressure/events et al. If it was in the dust that blew from the collapses, any given pre-mid-post construction material could very well have been present in the mix of the dust now couldn't it? Actually, it would expectadly be mixed therein.
Not to mention other potential sources of contamination at the scene from where the people collected these samples. As with McKinley, I just happend to find out that she shared apartment with a welder/sculptor.

Add this with what I've told you before, the least given explaination is that the very different samples being "nano-thermite", let alone one of them.
Use Occam's Razor on that one.
 
Your criticism holds no water the moment the material is found in another sample--unless you want to claim that the HFJ guys are making all this up. Is that your next claim?


.

If they were true frauds, then yes, they would just make stuff up. However, I think it is more likely they are self-deluded, so they follow the path that all self-deluded scientists do: Sloppy methodology and confirmation bias. That's a potent combination that can lead to whatever results you want, while creating the impression that you're a real scientist.
 
Here is a simple question. These samples were all collected in 2001. Now, unless they were stored in a severely dehumidified environment, would not the effects of corrosion set in over the course of the 5-6 years that followed, before Jones evaluated them?

TAM:)
 
Except the production of iron and silicate microspheres. Can you think of another exothermic reaction that can do this? Does it matter to the existence of the evidence what you call this material? It doesn't make the evidence go away.

You cannot prove the spheres weren't present beforehand. This is the extent of his Jones's observation:
The abundant iron-rich spheres are of particular interest in this study; none were observed in these particular chips prior to DSC-heating...
And that's it. But the problem is, his own evidence seems to suggest otherwise; Figure 3 of his paper shows spherules that remain uncharacterized. And those images are from uncombusted chips. Huh... wonder why Jones failed to characterize those :rolleyes:.

No imagry, no proof, nothing but assertion... which you swallow uncritically.

Even if you presume the spheres were produced by the combustion, you cannot conclude they were produced by thermite. Temperature is off, and so are the energy density figures Jones himself gives in that paper. They're off by quite a bit. You're operating on faith, not established fact.

Like paint? Really? You have absolutely no evidence of that whatsoever. If you can show me some paint from the towers that ignites at 430C and creates iron and silicate spheres, I will concede that I've been TOTALLY MISTAKEN by this whole "inside job" thing.

You are totally mistaken about this "whole ''inside job"" thing. We've demonstrated that.

Maybe the material is paint. Maybe it's some other sort of coating. Who cares? The point is that the material when ignited exhibited characteristics of something other than "thermitic material": It did not reach the temperatures necessary for thermite. It did not reach temperatures necessary for the melting of steel. If you presume that some sort of reaction besides pure combustion occurred, you don't get elemental iron, you get an iron-silicate spheroid. That is all from Jones's own data. How do you claim that it is "thermitic material" with those characteristics?

Read the link. Sunsetaler matches both morphology and X-EDS spectra with kaolinite. You've yet to muster an argument against this.

Let me clarify my position for you: This material is incendiary. It shouldn't be in the dust. It is proof positive that someone put explosive material in the towers. How was this stuff used? I still don't know. Was it used in conjunction with something else? Was any of the material used to take down the buildings "conventional" or was it all highly tailored and unusual? I don't know that either.

Material combusting and being "incendiary" are two different things. Paper combusts, but no one considers it an "incendiary" except in the most loose sense of being susceptible to burning. The fact that it burned in the calorimeter test doesn't mean anything in regards to it being an "incendiary". You can burn pig fat. In conjunction with other observations you may have something, but that's the problem: Those other observations have been demonstrated to be incorrect as well.

The material is not incendiary. It can burn, but that's not it's primary purpose. And given the presence of characteristics indicating paint - such as the undeniable presence of kaolin - then it should indeed be present.

Ps: You're not only failing to appreciate the difference between an "incendiary" and an "explosive" in your paragraph here, but you are also positing a specific about how the material was used. See below...

Has the material disappeared yet? Not yet?

No one's saying "the material is not there". The message you're missing is that it is not "thermitic". You're claiming it's something suspicious by mistakenly attributing incendiary and "thermitic" characteristics to it, despite the errors we've shown you in doing so.

Yes. My agenda.

My "agenda" is to read and understand the evidence.

You failed.

It clearly shows an unusual and highly energetic material with a low ignition point in the WTC dust. Unless you think it's more probable that the HFJ crew contaminated the dust themselves and tried to push this off as "real science" in a journal that everyone on the planet has free access to...

Highly energetic material with a low ignition point covers many materials. Given that the morphology of the material on a microscopic level matches kaoline, the spectroscopy shows that the aluminum is in fact not unbound, and that you and Jones only claims and cannot prove that the spheres were indeed caused by the combustion, "thermitic material" is the last thing you should consider including, and is the first thing that the evidence dictates be excluded.

It is disingenuous, at least, to accuse me of having an "agenda" when there is no way I'm making any money or somehow becoming influential in any way whatsoever by following the trail of evidence. The insinuation that I have anything to gain from this is laughable in light of the amount of money that is contingent on keeping people in fear.

Who makes more money (by any standard): various 911 groups combined with all the media sales on the subject, OR any individual security contract (from a vast multitude) awarded as a result of the catastrophe from which all of this sprang?
(Hint: all the profits from all the 911 book/dvd/convention sales combined are a drop in the bucket compared to the individual profits made by military contractors.)

What's more disingenuous? What I wrote, or your attempt to define "agenda" as only being financially driven? I'm not the one commiting the fallacy of false choice by restricting the definition. Money has nothing to do with it. Lots of people push agendas for zero financial gain; you're a prime example. You're parroting Jones's work uncritically, and you are blatantly ignoring the contradictions and errors that have been pointed out to you.

On top of that, military contractors make billions regardless of whether the towers fell or not. I don't recall the recent "Star Wars" laser platform being dependent on the narrative of 9/11, nor the next generation of fighter aircraft. Yet Jones and Gage only make their comparative pennies by pushing the lie. Does the magnitude of the difference change the fact that only one of them has any interest in continuing the conspiracy fantasy?

If you doubt this at all, at all, you should be put in D-hall by your teacher for being irresponsibly gullible.

From a guy who parrots disproven research without critically thinking about it, that's rich.

That's a bold accusation. If you want to call me a liar you'd better have some real substance behind that. I don't have, nor have ever claimed to have a complete theory about what happened. Not having a complete theory is not equivalent to lying. You need to retract that or back it up.

I did provide real substance. It has already been backed up. Here are your own words:
Forces within our own government are complicit in the deaths of 3000 Americans. The HFJ paper makes this an air-tight conclusion. There is no other explanation.
...I've said several times I do not know how this stuff was used.
You bend over backwards to argue the presence of a material that melts steel and has been cited by advocates of the "controlled demolition" narrative, but yet you profess to "not know how this stuff was used."? And in the very same post call it an "explosive"? :rolleyes: That's a 5-year-old's attempt at sophistry. You're citing the work of a person - Jones - on record as having claimed that thermite was used in the destruction of the Twin Towers, and you are advocating that he is correct in proposing that "thermitic material" was present. Furthermore, you characterize an incendiary as an explosive, further demonstrating what you believe the material was used for. When you say that you "do not know how this stuff was used", what fiction do you think you're passing on us? Unless you think that explosives have some purpose other than to explode, you come right out and say how you think it was used. See above.

There's your lie right there. QED. You claim the presence of an incendiary material in a tower in the same context of accusing the US government of killing citizens in a collapse of a tower, and you cite evidence from a known advocate of the "controlled demolitions" proposal. No one's so dumb as to not see through that. Drop the pose; you're transparent as glass.

What are those? That you don't accept the chain of custody or you think MEK can chemically alter aluminosilicates? Or that it's kaolinite? Do you have a peer-reviewed paper that demonstrates your claims? Or is a photo comparison strong enough evidence for you?

You want a photo comparison?
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4659658#post4659658

And what are the other contradictions? To start with: There's the proposition that something suspicious was planted in the towers; there wasn't. And not a bit of the Jones paper speaks towards that. Also: There's the analysis of the very data Jones and Harrit provides demonstrating that there is kaolin present and that the aluminum was bound. I've given you two direct links to posts discussing that above; you can search for the rest on your own. And that right there by itself negates Jones's and Harrit's conclusions; what MEK did to one single chip out of the sample does not change the results of the spectroscopy of the rest of the chips.

Furthermore, Jones chips are not all identical, and have shown characteristics indicating they are in fact different materials. You cannot combine characteristics of the butanone-soaked chip to inform conclusions about the XEDS-scoped chips; Jones and his cohorts certainly never gave us any SEM photos of the soaked sample, or any reason to believe that it in fact carried the same characteristics as the others. You cannot presume the soaked and the spectroscopically examined chips are linked when you provide no proof that they are, and that's the error Jones commits. Add that to what Sunstealer observed, and you have an open error.

To continue, there's that Jones et. al.'s conclusions deriving from the energy densities preclude the whole notion of "thermitic material". They've commited a serious abuse of logic by positing the existence of contradictory data as conformation. Read here. The enthalpy of reaction of thermite dictates an absolute limit, and that is the chemical bond energy. Their experiments gave figures that wildly exceeded these. And no, that is not proof of "super thermite"; enthalpy of reaction for iron oxide - aluminum redox reactions is set by nature. When you go beyond that, you're no longer talking anything thermite based. Energy density eliminates anything "thermitic" from the argument. Either that, or if you are desperate to salvage the argument, then you say that the "sol-gel" was what burned. Given that sol gels tend to be composed of hydrocarbons, then yes, you can claim that the figures do indeed encompass that. But then, you're also admitting that you don't have a thermite redox occurring, which begs the question of why those figures are cited to begin with. Either way, the energy density figures given either negates the argument or proves that the calorimeter data is unapplicable.

I can go on... or I can do what I've done before, and that's to tell you to read the first pages of this very thread as well as the parent thread. Why you show zero interest in doing this, I don't understand.


I make a leap. And it has much corroborative evidence, but don't get distracted. If you want to have a discussion about the totality of evidence, start a new thread. The strength of that theory rests largely with the HFJ paper. That's the strongest evidence there is, and it's very strong. And the best arguments against it here hold no water whatsoever as has been pointed out time and again in the last couple of pages.

Yes, you made a leap, no it wasn't warranted, and I don't need to start a new thread to point out that the totality of the evidence negates anything you draw from Jones's paper. Pointing out that thermite obviously had no effect on critical steel pieces is pointing out that Jones's conclusions are incorrect. The best arguments sunk the paper you're trying to defend a long time ago.

I'm not here to convince you. I have no misconceptions that you'll change your mind about anything, but it's very illuminating to the spectators how the argument progresses. The people who resort to lashing out and who get personal generally do so out of desperation.


Then don't lash out. Instead:
  • Confront Sunstealers' posts regarding the identification of kaolin and bound aluminum. No, the butanone soak doesn't cut it; that's only one chip, not the spectroscoped ones, and furthermore can have a range of explanations. I gave a possible one above.
  • Stop dodging the methodological errors. It's worth noting that one other resident truther tried to put it in front of other members in the Science forum who were unfamiliar with 9/11 conspiracy fantasy, and errors in methodology was the second problem identified, after the choice of publishers.
  • Confront the lack of melting on critical steel pieces. You dodged it by claiming that it "wasn't your theory" or somesuch. Irrelevant. Damage to the steel components is the logical conclusion of your theory. You openly point towards it when you cite "thermitic material". The problem is, you cannot collapse the towers without somehow damaging the steel. And Bazant's calculations also limit which steel components are to be damaged (the ones in the collapse initiation zone, since nothing stops the collapse once it starts). Those components were recovered and documented. They show no signs of "thermite" or explosives being used. This is inescapable. If you do not confront this, you are not confronting 9/11.
  • Deal with the energy errors. I pointed that out above.
You ignore so much evidence in order to do this, subtract so much context...
Project much?

Described accurately. You're the one trying to dodge context by blowing off the methodological errors. You're the one trying to subtract context and ignore evidence by refusing to confront the lack of molten steel from the collapse initiation zones. That's a description of you.

Again with the lies. The only thing I can make out is you're calling me a liar. What does "the pose amounts to a lie" mean anyway? Would you like to say I'm asking loaded questions? Can you back anything up?

Your pose is that you ignore evidence. Your pose is further that the only conclusions that are valid are yours. Yes, your pose is a component of a compound lie about 9/11. Ergo, that makes you a liar. Again: We've demonstrated that the material was not "thermitic". See above. We've demonstrated that it's characteristics contradict thermite. See above. We've demonstrated that there are huge flaws in the study. See above. All this you ignore in order to push an agenda that this is honest research with a proper conclusion. You may be fooling yourself into thinking it's the truth, but no research with such fundamental flaws can remotely approach being the truth except by accident.

You cannot claim to be working towards truth when you blatantly ignore truth.
[/quote]

Let me know when you're done throwing a tantrum.

This isn't a tantrum. This is a lecture. It would be a conversation if you had demonstrated any ability to put aside your arrogance and recognize where your failures of comprehension are, but unfortunately, your rejection of fact and reality has forced this to be a one-way talk. I've provided links to what the refutations to your arguments are, and at all times you have failed to pay attention to them. You refuse to recognize truth. At some point, the lecture will turn into laughter at the extent of your oblivion. But feel free to keep on mistaking what you read. Let me know when you're ready to confront your inability to understand the flaws of the paper and the outright errors committed in the reasearch. At that point, maybe you'll be ready to conduct a productive conversation. But until then, all you're doing is pitching a snow job.

Reread the first few pages of this thread, and the one that spawned it. You are in bad need of information.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom