Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Microspheres ??? Again??? Is it 2008 all over again? Have you been hibernating in a cave like a bear for 2 years Jay Howard? Time to get up to speed on what could have formed Microspheres...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=114717


...
I thought I read somewhere (not here) that diesel engine combustion produces a small amount of such, especially on less well maintained engines. Do you know anything about this? I'm unable to find much about it, but I haven't tried searching beyond the internet yet.

If that's correct - if - then sheer exposure from the number of buses, delivery trucks, etc. would be immense. But again, that's if.
...

FYI: I've since formed the opinion that the amount of microspheres contributed by external pollutants would be small compared to the number donated by/created from
  1. Fly ash
  2. Welding during the construction
  3. Steel cutting after the collapses.
So the proposition I made back then (quoted above) should not be taken too seriously anymore.

Now, given the low oxygenation of the spheres Jones found, he makes an acceptible argument that steel cutting doesn't account for those (whether they account for none at all is an entirely separate question; I would have to say "No", that Jones simply found a sample among many that would've not been produced by cutting. I'll reread the RJ Lee report later and see what if anything it has to say about oxygenation). But, the amount of spheres produced via welding during construction would have been far from trivial, and the welding methods used then could indeed have produced such spheres.

I'd positively have to cite fly ash as the #1 source of microsphere production. Again, for those who don't know, fly ash is a component of many concretes. It makes sense as it's a potential source especially considering that it would help explain why microsphere concentrations prior to the collapses differed from concentrations afterwards: They would've been released from the concrete structures being disintegrated. But welding/cutting would have been a very nontrivial source. Pollution comes in well behind those. And obviously, thermite is ruled out and therefore not worth discussing seriously.
 
I'd positively have to cite fly ash as the #1 source of microsphere production. Again, for those who don't know, fly ash is a component of many concretes. It makes sense as it's a potential source especially considering that it would help explain why microsphere concentrations prior to the collapses differed from concentrations afterwards: They would've been released from the concrete structures being disintegrated. But welding/cutting would have been a very nontrivial source. Pollution comes in well behind those. And obviously, thermite is ruled out and therefore not worth discussing seriously.

It bears repeating as many times as it takes for Jones et al to understand this. Iron microspheres are ubiquitous in the environment. I just completed a study on dust in condemned buildings and found thousands of iron microspheres despite the fact that the building had never been on fire.

Iron microspheres usually account for 1% of fly ash (other iron is mixed in glassy phases with silicon, aluminum, potassium and oxygen), and they're almost totally unreactive in concrete. It's not crazy to think that broken, crumbling concrete would release the microspheres into the environment.
 
It bears repeating as many times as it takes for Jones et al to understand this. Iron microspheres are ubiquitous in the environment. I just completed a study on dust in condemned buildings and found thousands of iron microspheres despite the fact that the building had never been on fire.

Iron microspheres usually account for 1% of fly ash (other iron is mixed in glassy phases with silicon, aluminum, potassium and oxygen), and they're almost totally unreactive in concrete. It's not crazy to think that broken, crumbling concrete would release the microspheres into the environment.

Is yours an academically published study? If so, mind PM'ing me a cite? I should be able to view it through my local university's online resources.
 
That, in fact, is the first problem. There is no established chain of custody to verify that the dust samples originated from the WTC debris. That, alone, renders any speculation on the further analysis moot.


There most certainly is an established chain of custody. There is absolutely no reason to doubt the chain of custody other than people here don't like the conclusions of the paper. But, as mentioned by smarter people than me, incredulity is a poor foundation for argument.

If anyone had real evidence to explain why the chain of custody is not "good enough" then they would have posted it already. So far, the only thing people have brought up is the amount of time it was held. Apparently, someone cooked up some nano-particles and made them magnetic so the investigators would find them with a magnet.

Put it this way, if there were a group of academics out there who where falsifying information for the purpose of indicting high-level politicos, they would be tried and convicted of treason. Full stop.

Four. The samples are a mixture of dust from various sources, including unintentional contamination from environmental dust sources.

Right. I just decided that was so ridiculous we wouldn't need to include it. Apparently not. Apparently it's more likely to you that 4 different samples were contaminated with the SAME material, and they all ended up in Jones' hands. And I'm the one with the crazy theory.

The problem, for you, is that you are trying to evangelise.

That's rich.

Putting people on ignore is, for you, as much of a failure as people putting you on ignore.

Your opinion is noted.

By leaving the debate, you are conceding defeat, because if you simply claim that your point of view has not been disproven and no more then you are accepting the status quo, and the status quo is a general understanding that 9/11 was perpetrated by al-Qaeda and that the Twin Towers collapsed as a direct result of impact and fire damage. The burden of proof rests entirely on you.

You accuse me of evangelizing and then tout this debate as a popularity contest? The contents of the WTC dust don't care about the status quo. Strange explosive material was found in the dust that ignited at 430C and formed molten iron and silicon-based spheres. That doesn't change. Nothing you say can make that reality disappear. And the implications of that material are clear to the world.

Forces within our own government are complicit in the deaths of 3000 Americans. The HFJ paper makes this an air-tight conclusion. There is no other explanation.


You're omitting the possibility that we think it was planted by somebody stupid. It's quite feasible - though, in fact, I don't think this is the case - that the dust samples were deliberately doctored to contain a substance that is nevertheless incapable of creating the effect the forger wanted to suggest, because the forger is too stupid to work out the ramifications of his own conspiracy theory.

So, you do or do not believe this? You say you don't, however, you follow up your shallow disbelief with the same argument that's been flagged for being pure propaganda: they planted it... AND it's benign.

Have you worked out the ramifications of your "quadruple contamination" conspiracy theory?

Thus demonstrating that (a) they would have been ignited by the jet fuel fires immediately following the impacts and could not therefore have been responsible for the collapses, and (b) either it is possible to form iron spheroids without producing temperatures high enough to melt steel over significant areas (assuming Dr. Harrit's equipment survived the experiments) or the spheroids are not, in fact, pure iron.

Why don't you just read the paper? It clearly demonstrates that this stuff ignites at about 430C and gets hot enough to reduce iron oxide to molten iron and produce silicon spheres.


I suggest you consider that second point very, very carefully. Conspiracy theorists are using spheroids produced in a reaction that did not generate temperatures in excess of 1500ºC over macroscopic regions as proof that temperatures in excess of 1500ºC were produced over macroscopic regions. The fact that they were able to produce these spheres without destroying their own equipment is simple refutation of their claim.

So because a little chip weighing less than a gram didn't destroy their machinery, they can't be right? That's your argument? Wow, the attempts at refutation here are getting weaker and weaker, to put it mildly. Face it, this paper isn't perfect, but it's absolutely clear that these are not samples of paint or corrosion protective material. This stuff is incendiary and is crystal clear evidence of foul play.


.
 
“There most certainly is an established chain of custody. There is absolutely no reason to doubt the chain of custody other than people here don't like the conclusions of the paper. But, as mentioned by smarter people than me, incredulity is a poor foundation for argument.”

Huh, anonymous people send to person with obvious motive and a penchant for dishonesty a bag of “dust’ from locations unknown. That is a chain of custody?

Same person with obvious motive and a penchant for dishonesty and now a bag of “dust’ from locations unknown refuses to send sample to independent lab. Instead sends sample to truther buddy in Europe who reports that he cannot duplicate Jones’ results.

Makes ya go: Hmmmm.
 
If anyone had real evidence to explain why the chain of custody is not "good enough" then they would have posted it already.

Not good enough.

Proof of a chain of custody is required when the evidence that is sought to be introduced at trial is not unique or where the relevance of the evidence depends on its analysis after seizure. A proper chain of custody requires three types of testimony: (1) testimony that a piece of evidence is what it purports to be (for example, a litigant's blood sample); (2) testimony of continuous possession by each individual who has had possession of the evidence from the time it is seized until the time it is presented in court; and (3) testimony by each person who has had possession that the particular piece of evidence remained in substantially the same condition from the moment one person took possession until the moment that person released the evidence into the custody of another (for example, testimony that the evidence was stored in a secure location where no one but the person in custody had access to it).

We don't know who collected it or what the collection method was. We don't know who stored it or where and how it was stored. This dust and any evidence that came from it would get thrown out of a court of law.
 
There most certainly is an established chain of custody. There is absolutely no reason to doubt the chain of custody other than people here don't like the conclusions of the paper. But, as mentioned by smarter people than me, incredulity is a poor foundation for argument.

If anyone had real evidence to explain why the chain of custody is not "good enough" then they would have posted it already. So far, the only thing people have brought up is the amount of time it was held. Apparently, someone cooked up some nano-particles and made them magnetic so the investigators would find them with a magnet.

Put it this way, if there were a group of academics out there who where falsifying information for the purpose of indicting high-level politicos, they would be tried and convicted of treason. Full stop.



Right. I just decided that was so ridiculous we wouldn't need to include it. Apparently not. Apparently it's more likely to you that 4 different samples were contaminated with the SAME material, and they all ended up in Jones' hands. And I'm the one with the crazy theory.



That's rich.



Your opinion is noted.



You accuse me of evangelizing and then tout this debate as a popularity contest? The contents of the WTC dust don't care about the status quo. Strange explosive material was found in the dust that ignited at 430C and formed molten iron and silicon-based spheres. That doesn't change. Nothing you say can make that reality disappear. And the implications of that material are clear to the world.

Forces within our own government are complicit in the deaths of 3000 Americans. The HFJ paper makes this an air-tight conclusion. There is no other explanation.




So, you do or do not believe this? You say you don't, however, you follow up your shallow disbelief with the same argument that's been flagged for being pure propaganda: they planted it... AND it's benign.

Have you worked out the ramifications of your "quadruple contamination" conspiracy theory?



Why don't you just read the paper? It clearly demonstrates that this stuff ignites at about 430C and gets hot enough to reduce iron oxide to molten iron and produce silicon spheres.




So because a little chip weighing less than a gram didn't destroy their machinery, they can't be right? That's your argument? Wow, the attempts at refutation here are getting weaker and weaker, to put it mildly. Face it, this paper isn't perfect, but it's absolutely clear that these are not samples of paint or corrosion protective material. This stuff is incendiary and is crystal clear evidence of foul play.


.

Absolutely clear? based on what? That is our whole point, and you haven't refuted it in the slightest. You are no scientist, nor do you seem to believe in the scientific method. After all of these posts you resort, unfortunately as expected, to the same old truther lines and MO. Well I wish you had declared the idiocy above well before now...

Welcome to ignore jay.

TAM:boggled:
 
Forces within our own government are complicit in the deaths of 3000 Americans. The HFJ paper makes this an air-tight conclusion. There is no other explanation.

So, you aren't evangelizing?


I'm into this conversation late but is there a paper trail establishing the chain of custody of the materials and how/where they were stored? If not then there is NOT an established chain of custody, plain and simple. Taking someone's word that they had it stored properly and for how long is simply not good enough for a real scientific paper.

I can make microspheres in my basement with the hand driven grinder I have there. In fact it was a 'neat' thing for my brother and I when we were 9/10 years old to use that very grinder wheel and touch steel nails to it to watch the sparks fly.

In that case Jay, we had raised the temperature of small particles of steel by adding energy(heat) to them such that they were molten.
A 9 year old had the muscle power to cause iron microspheres to be produced Jay!

Now the dust was collected from an area where thousands of tons of steel had bashed and scraped against itself and a large amount of concrete. It was in a very large city where there are multiple possible sources of such microspheres and the paper does not make any effort to eliminate the possibility of other sources. It is from an area in which very quickly following the collapses all manner of saws, grinders and high temperature torches were utilised which would seem to make it unusual if there were no iron microspheres.

You then attempt to sell this as evidence towards an "air tight conclusion"?

I have seen better arguements for creationism.
 
Forces within our own government are complicit in the deaths of 3000 Americans. The HFJ paper makes this an air-tight conclusion. There is no other explanation.
You have failed to support this
Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for civility (Moderated thread.)


Whatever melted them got to at least 1538C for some amount of time, and it did it enough that in a random dust sample collected and studied by the RJ Lee group, they composed 5.7% of the mass.

How did fire get that hot? We know they didn't. So it was electrical? The electrical system was blasting the steel members so hot it decarburated the steel and turned them into iron, aluminum and silica-based spheres? You've seen some evidence of this? That's a "better" theory?

No. It's not a better theory by any stretch of the imagination. It's grasping at straws in the face of the narrowing plausibility of the fire and wreckage-induced collapse theory.

.

So because a little chip weighing less than a gram didn't destroy their machinery, they can't be right? That's your argument? Wow, the attempts at refutation here are getting weaker and weaker, to put it mildly. Face it, this paper isn't perfect, but it's absolutely clear that these are not samples of paint or corrosion protective material. This stuff is incendiary and is crystal clear evidence of foul play.
You tripped up Jay, See the holding in red? You contradict yourself. You assert that whatever caused your micro-spheres HAD to encounter temps of 1538 degrees C, Then claim it didn't need to reach that temperature in Jones "laboratory". You also breezed right past post 499 where i show you what else can commonly cause micro-spheres, Do you see the quote attributed to Apolo20? That's Frank Greening, And he agrees there are many common sources of micro-spheres. Take it up with him and get back to us.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You accuse me of evangelizing and then tout this debate as a popularity contest? The contents of the WTC dust don't care about the status quo. Strange explosive material was found in the dust that ignited at 430C and formed molten iron and silicon-based spheres. That doesn't change. Nothing you say can make that reality disappear. And the implications of that material are clear to the world.

Therein lies your problem: You've fallen for an act of fraud. Willingly so. We've amply demonstrated that the material is in fact not suspicious, nor "thermitic". We've even gone so far as to demonstrate that Jones own data contradicts the notion that the material is "thermitic"; more than once, in fact. On top of that, I've demonstrated that even if it was what you allege, it failed to work. Your problem is that you are actively ignoring all this in a futile desire to make stick a false, well disproven conspiracy proposal that doesn't even contain internal consistency, much less provide enough impetus to make the rational segment of society want to revisit the events of 9/11.

The reality is that it was not explosive material, did not evolve iron spheres via a thermite reaction, and did not demonstrate any characteristics of an iron oxide - aluminum redox reaction. Instead, the material when ignited exhibited characteristics of something other than "thermitic material". You've been shown this; the links and quotes have been provided repeatedly (heck, this last link is a repeat of one just a single paragraph above... maybe one of these days you'll actually read it). It's your own failure that you refuse to accept the reality the evidence leads to.

Forces within our own government are complicit in the deaths of 3000 Americans. The HFJ paper makes this an air-tight conclusion. There is no other explanation.

Funny you should say this now, when just a page or two ago, you said:
...I've said several times I do not know how this stuff was used.
You don't know how it was used... yet you posit that it was used to bring down the twin towers. Thermite affects steel through high temperatures, you accuse the government of killing 3000 citizens, yet you try to strike a "just asking questions" pose when you said "I do not know how this stuff was used".
Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for civility. (Moderated thread)
You try to project a demeanor of honest inquisition, but in reality you were driving towards an agenda. You believed that you knew how it was used, but you try to claim that you don't, that you're merely following where the evidence supposedly leads.

Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for civility. (Moderated thread)


But you know, in a funny way, you are right about one thing: You truly don't know how "thermitic material" can be used. "Can", not "was", because it wasn't. We've demonstrated that conclusively; see links above, plus read the first pages of this thread. You truly don't know how such material can be used, you can't even properly identify from the evidence what the material is, and instead you parrot conclusions that are unsupported and in fact actively contradicted by the data itself. So you lied, but you revealed a truth in doing so: You revealed that you know no more than what the conspiracy leaders tell you to believe. You reveal that by hewing strongly to their disproven arguments, even when shown what the contradictions and refuations are. Very cultish of you. Very brainwashed.

You were willing to leap to conspiratorial conclusions in spite of evidence contradicting your fantasy, and you continue to try to build from a base of refuted arguments. You've lept from "I do not know how this stuff was used" to "Forces within our own government are complicit in the deaths of 3000 Americans. The HFJ paper makes this an air-tight conclusion" when the Harrit paper doesn't identify these "forces", doesn't identify any links between the material Jones was given and the government, and did not ever show you "how this stuff was used". You leap. With no evidence or reason to. What about the 430oC ignition point tells you that the government was involved? What about the evolution of spheroids tells you that these shadowy forces put the material there? You see, even if we pretend that the material is indeed suspicious, you still have nothing but leaps of faith about how it got there. And yet you argue this anyway? You think we're stupid enough to buy this argument?

You see, this is why I call people like you "conspiracy fantasists". You don't have a theory, you have a disproven narrative. You spin a fiction. A Fantasy. A fantasy that centralizes around a fictional conspiracy. And you try to peddle it as truth. You ignore so much evidence in order to do this, subtract so much context to make your questions appear to have validity that no one can evaluate the questions honestly as ones about 9/11, and bend so much truth to present those questions as honestly arrived at that the pose amounts to a lie. The questions are not honest ones. The points are at best misinterpretations, at worst open lies. And you conspiracy peddlers? Well, now... "impotent" is the kindest word I can come up with, seeing as how you supposedly have evidence of some grand conspiracy involving the murder of 3000 US citizens, yet all you can do is serial post mistaken point after mistaken point on some internet discussion board. That says a lot about you conspiracy fantasists. And none of it is good. None of it at all.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There most certainly is an established chain of custody. There is absolutely no reason to doubt the chain of custody other than people here don't like the conclusions of the paper. But, as mentioned by smarter people than me, incredulity is a poor foundation for argument.

If anyone had real evidence to explain why the chain of custody is not "good enough" then they would have posted it already.

Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for civility. (Moderated thread)


So far, the only thing people have brought up is the amount of time it was held. Apparently, someone cooked up some nano-particles and made them magnetic so the investigators would find them with a magnet.

Since the person who "found" these particles is a known fraud, the "paper" is riddled with methodological errors, no proof that they are "cooked up some nano particles" and NO ONE ELSE HAS FOUND THIS SUBSTANCE... I really don't know what it is, and more to the point neither does anyone else.

Put it this way, if there were a group of academics out there who where falsifying information for the purpose of indicting high-level politicos, they would be tried and convicted of treason. Full stop.

Your ignorance of US law is just as bad as your ignorance of the basic experimental design. "if there were such a group" they wouldn't be tried and convicted for treason. Sorry. Again argument from ignorance. AT best they would be tried for LIBEL and SLANDER, be disbarred from their profession and forced to pay restitution.

The accusation of individuals in high level politics of misdoing, murder etc are NOT TREASON. Full stop.

Right. I just decided that was so ridiculous we wouldn't need to include it. Apparently not. Apparently it's more likely to you that 4 different samples were contaminated with the SAME material, and they all ended up in Jones' hands. And I'm the one with the crazy theory.

So how do you nano engineer something to tailor its properties, yet when these samples aer tested you have 4 VASTLY DIFFERENT reactions between them? Don't you nano engineer something to make sure it reacts the same way every time? (yet more proof that it isn't something nano engineered)


You accuse me of evangelizing and then tout this debate as a popularity contest? The contents of the WTC dust don't care about the status quo.

You are right, the contents of the dust doesn't care about anything. It is dust.

Strange explosive material

You use a word there that doesn't mean what you think it means... "explosive" You should look that up. Combustible.. ok. explosive? hasn't been proven. try again.

Again and again, where is the methodology which eliminate ANY OTHER THING which would combust?

was found in the dust that ignited at 430C and formed molten iron and silicon-based spheres.

Again back to those methodological errors you are ignoring.
it ignited at 430 c in an oxygen rich atmosphere. Lots of things will ignite at that temperature.. including dried paint. oops.

That doesn't change. Nothing you say can make that reality disappear. And the implications of that material are clear to the world.

The outright implicaitons are that harrit, jones, et al are extremely outside of their fields of education and experience. The rest of those implications are that they do shoddy science and that you don't have a clue as to basic scientific principles.

Did you have other implications?

Forces within our own government are complicit in the deaths of 3000 Americans. The HFJ paper makes this an air-tight conclusion. There is no other explanation.

Conclusions that are not supported by this "paper." The lack of evidence, the horrendous methodological errors, the necessicity of publishing in a vanity journal and even JONES backing from the nanothermite claim (now he claims it was used in fuses for conventional explosives) all destroy this BS claim. You should get on the mailing list to make sure you have the new twoof talking points.

Why don't you just read the paper? It clearly demonstrates that this stuff ignites at about 430C and gets hot enough to reduce iron oxide to molten iron and produce silicon spheres.

I have read this "paper" numerous times. And I can't get beyond the 20 methodological errors... and that isn't counting the outrageous conclusions or the vanity journal publication.

Face it, this paper isn't perfect, but it's absolutely clear that these are not samples of paint or corrosion protective material.

Ummm "this paper isn't perfect" is an extreme understatement. This "paper" is riddled with methodological errors which completely and utterly invalidate ANY findings or conclusions of this "paper."

File it in the circular bin and start over.

This paper didn't rule out paint or corrosion protective materials. How could they? They used a bad control and didn't make any attempt to get proper control.

We have NO idea what they found and more importantly neither do they.

This stuff is incendiary and is crystal clear evidence of foul play.

Ummm... NO. This stuff combusts in an oxygen rich environment. There are literally thousands of things which do so. NONE of them were eliminated. How can you possibly make any claims as to what something is when you don't eliminate anything? Huh?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There most certainly is an established chain of custody. There is absolutely no reason to doubt the chain of custody other than people here don't like the conclusions of the paper.

You've had this explained to you many times, and decided to ignore the explanation.

Put it this way, if there were a group of academics out there who where falsifying information for the purpose of indicting high-level politicos, they would be tried and convicted of treason. Full stop.

Why? Nobody cares what they're doing. Since they have no relevance, why bother?


You accuse me of evangelizing and then tout this debate as a popularity contest? The contents of the WTC dust don't care about the status quo. Strange explosive material was found in the dust that ignited at 430C and formed molten iron and silicon-based spheres. That doesn't change. Nothing you say can make that reality disappear. And the implications of that material are clear to the world.

It's not an accusation, it's a statement of fact. You're seeking to convince the world that reality is something other than what they believe it to be. Taking your ball and going home is a failure. You have to keep arguing, or concede. And, no, no explosive material was found in the dust, no molten iron was observed, and the spheres are not iron, they're iron-rich. Reality is not what you want it to be.

Why don't you just read the paper? It clearly demonstrates that this stuff ignites at about 430C and gets hot enough to reduce iron oxide to molten iron and produce silicon spheres.

No, it doesn't. It simply pretends to demonstrate that.

So because a little chip weighing less than a gram didn't destroy their machinery, they can't be right? That's your argument? Wow, the attempts at refutation here are getting weaker and weaker, to put it mildly.

Just because you choose not to understand the argument, that doesn't invalidate it. Let's break it down into premises and conclusions.

(P1) An experiment demonstrates that heating a substance claimed to be found in the WTC to 430ºC causes that substance to combust.
(P2) This combustion produces iron-rich microspheres in microscopic regions, without producing sufficiently high temperatures to melt iron over macroscopic regions.
(P3) Iron-rich microspheres cannot be produced without the creation of sufficiently high temperatures to melt iron over macroscopic regions.
(C) Therefore, macroscopic regions of the WTC were exposed to temperatures sufficiently high to melt iron.

Either you can see that premise 2 contradicts premise 3, or you're blinded by your own idealogy, or you're incapable of understanding a line of reasoning.

Dave
 
There most certainly is an established chain of custody. There is absolutely no reason to doubt the chain of custody other than people here don't like the conclusions of the paper. But, as mentioned by smarter people than me, incredulity is a poor foundation for argument.

If anyone had real evidence to explain why the chain of custody is not "good enough" then they would have posted it already. So far, the only thing people have brought up is the amount of time it was held. Apparently, someone cooked up some nano-particles and made them magnetic so the investigators would find them with a magnet.

Could you imagine a murder case where the police would enlist the help of the public to send in evidence they may have picked up from the crime scene? Do you REALLY think that would hold up in court?

The standards of evidence in science are HIGHER than the standards of evidence in court. That should give you a hint right there.

Put it this way, if there were a group of academics out there who where falsifying information for the purpose of indicting high-level politicos, they would be tried and convicted of treason. Full stop.

In what country? Not in the United States. Treason is very specifically defined in the US Constitution.
 
First post. Longtime lurker.

It has been said many times already but bears repeating that these authors were already fully signed up to the inside jobby job theory from early days post 911.
Therefore, their objectivity and reliability is questionable to say the least. Any reasonable person would therefore expect THEM to go the extra mile to establish the chain of custody for the dust samples, to conduct independent tests to verify their findings etc
Assuming of course that the exercise was not just to impress those already committed to the inside jobby job theory but rather to raise the issue with their peers (well Jones' and Harrit's anyway) in the relevant scientific disciplines.

One small mystery for me is this. Jones et all claimed that when he/they saw the collapses on television it was obvious to him/them that these were the result of some kind of demolition.
Why on earth did he/they wait years to be given some dust samples, surely, if he/they is/are genuine, he/they would have headed straight to ground zero, volunteered for the clean up, and gathered a wealth of 'incriminating' evidence ?
 
Not good enough.



We don't know who collected it or what the collection method was. We don't know who stored it or where and how it was stored. This dust and any evidence that came from it would get thrown out of a court of law.


All we have is evidence and probability.

To write the results off as contamination of 4 different samples with the same material is wildly less probable than the probability of that material simply being in the dust.

If you want to claim the samples were seeded by the Harrit/Farrer/Jones crew, that's nice but there isn't any good reason to accept that over the acquisition process they claim.

Do you think it's more reasonable to accept that the samples are contaminated because they appear to have explosive chips in them? or would you be all up in arms about the samples even if they found nothing suspicious?

[transparent][/transparent]


.
 
Any reasonable person would therefore expect THEM to go the extra mile to establish the chain of custody for the dust samples, to conduct independent tests to verify their findings etc

Jones seems to have established a second career preaching to the choir. He only has to convince his followers, who are easily convinced of things they already believe without question.

One small mystery for me is this. Jones et all claimed that when he/they saw the collapses on television it was obvious to him/them that these were the result of some kind of demolition.

Unfortunately, the truthiness movement is full of small mysteries.
 
Absolutely clear? based on what? That is our whole point, and you haven't refuted it in the slightest.

Sure. Don't let the inability of MEK to reduce aluminosilicates to elemental Al and a Si compound get in the way of your disbelief. Nor the production of iron and silicon-based microspheres from an intimately mixed material found in the WTC dust that ignites at 430C.

Strong claims require strong evidence. And it has been presented for free for anyone to attempt to refute. And the best attempts here have fallen far short of refutation. You have imparted your doubt with utmost clarity, however, that is in no way equivalent to a refutation.

You are no scientist, nor do you seem to believe in the scientific method. After all of these posts you resort, unfortunately as expected, to the same old truther lines and MO. Well I wish you had declared the idiocy above well before now...

Welcome to ignore jay.

TAM:boggled:

Why are "debunkers" unable to put someone on ignore without announcing it to that person? If you really want to ignore someone, just ignore them. No need for a ceremony.


.
 
To write the results off as contamination of 4 different samples with the same material is wildly less probable than the probability of that material simply being in the dust.
I don't remember anyone claim that samples 1-4 are contaminated, and there's no proof of free aluminium in them. Unoxidized aluminium was only present in the MEK-soaked chip, which is of a different nature, so there's no basis to affirm that the material in samples 1-4 is 'thermitic' or 'explosive'.
 
All we have is evidence and probability.
No you do not, You have evidence of something that cannot possibly be thermite or an incendiary sufficient to damage steel
To write the results off as contamination of 4 different samples with the same material is wildly less probable than the probability of that material simply being in the dust.
Yet, you claim to have four random samples that you "coincidentally" claim are evidence of an incendiary.
If you want to claim the samples were seeded by the Harrit/Farrer/Jones crew, that's nice but there isn't any good reason to accept that over the acquisition process they claim.
His refusal to release those samples for independent impartial analysis shows there is a problem he would rather not have revealed to the public.
Do you think it's more reasonable to accept that the samples are contaminated because they appear to have explosive chips in them? or would you be all up in arms about the samples even if they found nothing suspicious?
.
They do not appear to have explosive chips in them. Let us know if the chips combust in an inert atmosphere. Mkay?
 
Therein lies your problem: You've fallen for an act of fraud. Willingly so. We've amply demonstrated that the material is in fact not suspicious, nor "thermitic". We've even gone so far as to demonstrate that Jones own data contradicts the notion that the material is "thermitic"; more than once, in fact. On top of that, I've demonstrated that even if it was what you allege, it failed to work. Your problem is that you are actively ignoring all this in a futile desire to make stick a false, well disproven conspiracy proposal that doesn't even
contain internal consistency, much less provide enough impetus to make the rational segment of society want to revisit the events of 9/11.

The reality is that it was not explosive material, did not evolve iron spheres via a thermite reaction, and did not demonstrate any characteristics of an iron oxide - aluminum redox reaction.

Except the production of iron and silicate microspheres. Can you think of another exothermic reaction that can do this? Does it matter to the existence of the evidence what you call this material? It doesn't make the evidence go away.


Like paint? Really? You have absolutely no evidence of that whatsoever. If you can show me some paint from the towers that ignites at 430C and creates iron and silicate spheres, I will concede that I've been TOTALLY MISTAKEN by this whole "inside job" thing.

I'm not holding my breath.

Funny you should say this now, when just a page or two ago, you said:

​
You don't know how it was used... yet you posit that it was used to bring down the twin towers.

Let me clarify my position for you: This material is incendiary. It shouldn't be in the dust. It is proof positive that someone put explosive material in the towers. How was this stuff used? I still don't know. Was it used in conjunction with something else? Was any of the material used to take down the buildings "conventional" or was it all highly tailored and unusual? I don't know that either.

Has the material disappeared yet? Not yet?

Thermite affects steel through high temperatures, you accuse the government of killing 3000 citizens, yet you try to strike a "just asking questions" pose when you said "I do not know how this stuff was used".
Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for civility. (Moderated thread)
You try to project a demeanor of honest inquisition, but in reality you were driving towards an agenda. You believed that you knew how it was used, but you try to claim that you don't, that you're merely following where the evidence supposedly leads.

Yes. My agenda.

My "agenda" is to read and understand the evidence. It clearly shows an unusual and highly energetic material with a low ignition point in the WTC dust. Unless you think it's more probable that the HFJ crew contaminated the dust themselves and tried to push this off as "real science" in a journal that everyone on the planet has free access to...

It is disingenuous, at least, to accuse me of having an "agenda" when there is no way I'm making any money or somehow becoming influential in any way whatsoever by following the trail of evidence. The insinuation that I have anything to gain from this is laughable in light of the amount of money that is contingent on keeping people in fear.

Who makes more money (by any standard): various 911 groups combined with all the media sales on the subject, OR any individual security contract (from a vast multitude) awarded as a result of the catastrophe from which all of this sprang?

(Hint: all the profits from all the 911 book/dvd/convention sales combined are a drop in the bucket compared to the individual profits made by military contractors.)

If you doubt this at all, at all, you should be put in D-hall by your teacher for being irresponsibly gullible.


Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for civility. (Moderated thread)


But you know, in a funny way, you are right about one thing: You truly don't know how "thermitic material" can be used. "Can", not "was", because it wasn't. We've demonstrated that conclusively; see links above, plus read the first pages of this thread. You truly don't know how such material can be used, you can't even properly identify from the evidence what the material is, and instead you parrot conclusions that are unsupported and in fact actively contradicted by the data itself. So you lied...

That's a bold accusation. If you want to call me a liar you'd better have some real substance behind that. I don't have, nor have ever claimed to have a complete theory about what happened. Not having a complete theory is not equivalent to lying. You need to retract that or back it up.

...but you revealed a truth in doing so: You revealed that you know no more than what the conspiracy leaders tell you to believe. You reveal that by hewing strongly to their disproven arguments, even when shown what the contradictions and refuations are.

What are those? That you don't accept the chain of custody or you think MEK can chemically alter aluminosilicates? Or that it's kaolinite? Do you have a peer-reviewed paper that demonstrates your claims? Or is a photo comparison strong enough evidence for you?

Very cultish of you. Very brainwashed.

Everyone else's magic is black magic.

You've lept from "I do not know how this stuff was used" to "Forces within our own government are complicit in the deaths of 3000 Americans.[//quot The HFJ paper makes this an air-tight conclusion" when the Harrit paper doesn't identify these "forces", doesn't identify any links between the material Jones was given and the government, and did not ever show you "how this stuff was used". You leap. With no evidence or reason to.

I make a leap. And it has much corroborative evidence, but don't get distracted. If you want to have a discussion about the totality of evidence, start a new thread. The strength of that theory rests largely with the HFJ paper. That's the strongest evidence there is, and it's very strong. And the best arguments against it here hold no water whatsoever as has been pointed out time and again in the last couple of pages.

What about the 430oC ignition point tells you that the government was involved? What about the evolution of spheroids tells you that these shadowy forces put the material there? You see, even if we pretend that the material is indeed suspicious, you still have nothing but leaps of faith about how it got there. And yet you argue this
anyway? You think we're stupid enough to buy this argument?

I'm not here to convince you. I have no misconceptions that you'll change your mind about anything, but it's very illuminating to the spectators how the argument progresses. The people who resort to lashing out and who get personal generally do so out of desperation.

You ignore so much evidence in order to do this, subtract so much context...

Project much?

...to make your questions appear to have validity that no one can evaluate the questions honestly as ones about 9/11,

What? I make my "questions appear to have validity that no one can evaluate the questions honestly as ones about 911?" What does that even mean?

...and bend so much truth to present those questions as honestly arrived at that the pose amounts to a lie. The questions are not honest ones. The points are at best misinterpretations, at worst open lies.

Again with the lies. The only thing I can make out is you're calling me a liar. What does "the pose amounts to a lie" mean anyway? Would you like to say I'm asking loaded questions? Can you back anything up?

And you conspiracy peddlers? Well, now... "impotent" is the kindest word I can come up with, seeing as how you supposedly have evidence of some grand conspiracy involving the murder of 3000 US citizens, yet all you can do is serial post mistaken point after mistaken point on some internet
discussion board. That says a lot about you conspiracy fantasists. And none of it is good. None of it at all.

Let me know when you're done throwing a tantrum.


.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom