Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

So your reason to dismiss this as not real is that you sincerely believe that the HFJ team made or found this material and are simply claiming they found it in the dust?
again and again you just jump past the 20 methodological errors and then continue to try to argue the "evidence." That is SOMETHING YOU CAN'T DO. If the methodology is crap, then you cannot discuss the findings, results, experiments or the conclusions.

It has NOTHING to do with the idea that "this as no real" or that "the HFJ team made or found this material."

It is the basic backbones of science. If you don't have the methodology, you don't have a paper. Throw this crap in the bin and start over.

What evidence do you have that they did not find this material in the dust? If your only reason to doubt that is that you don't like the conclusions, that's not good enough.

Again and again. I don't know what they found (and neither do they) because they had crap methdology. You are starting with an assumption (you do know that it makes an ASS out of U and MPTION right?) that is not backed up by any science.

When Jones was claiming the microspheres were evidence of thermite, everyone here was doubting that because they claimed there wasn't enough evidence to make that determination.
Your lack of reading for comprehension is showing. When Jones was making the iron microspheres argument, people were asking him what ELSE MAKES/HAS microspheres in them. What else does? Come on twoof? Now can you eliminate ANY OF THOSE OTHER SOURCES OF MICROSPHERES? No. If you cannot eliminate them, then you cannot claim that the microsphres are from thermate, thermite, godzilla, pixie dust or anything else.

go back to school and take a simple experimental methods class. FAIL (yet again)

Now here is strong corroborative evidence to support that claim and the best you can do is double down on your doubt without any supporting evidence.
Where? Please point out any corroborative evidence. Pretty please with a cherry on top...... OHHHHHHH you mean this pile o fail that is the Bentham article. <snort> <snicker> <lol>

again and again. Lets repeat.
1. If the methodology is crap (and there are 20 methodological errors in this "paper"), then the "paper" is invalid and you cannot take anything from it in any seriousness.
2. Now you claim that there is something in the dust, but you cannot eliminate ANY of the possible other sources of this materials.

If you don't think this stuff was in the dust, then just quit writing. There's nothing more to talk about.
.
You have demonstrated that there isn't anything more to talk about. Now make that phone call I suggested and educate yourself.
 
We can't even start speculating about the possibilities of how this stuff was used until we can all agree that this stuff was in fact in the WTC dust.

Can we agree on that?

I would go one step further and say we can't start speculating whether the stuff was 'used' until we can all agree that it was in the WTC dust. You're assuming your conclusion by asking 'how this stuff was used'.

We can be certain about some aspects of how this stuff was not used. It was not used to initiate the collapse, as the collapse initiation took place in a region where temperatures were high enough for this stuff to have ignited long before initiation. It was not used for melting steel structural members, as the thickness of the material is too small to have given any significant temperature increase. It was not used for igniting explosives in connection with the collapses, as the collapses are known not to have been assisted by explosives. It seems to me that, on the basis of these fairly simple and irrefutable conclusions, we can exclude the possibility that this stuff had any role in the initiation or propagation of the collapses. And that, alone, renders its analysis more or less irrelevant to any study of the collapse mechanisms. It is simply too insignificant to have played an identifiable role.

And: No, we can't agree that it has even been proven to originate from the WTC. That's the whole point of the chain of custody argument. Harrit et al not only haven't proven anything, they haven't even reached the starting point for a proof.

Dave
 
So your reason to dismiss this as not real is that you sincerely believe that the HFJ team made or found this material and are simply claiming they found it in the dust?

What evidence do you have that they did not find this material in the dust? If your only reason to doubt that is that you don't like the conclusions, that's not good enough.

From Carl Sagan's baloney detection kit (paraphrasing): If an idea depends on a chain of reasoning, then a single broken link in the chain invalidates it.

The chain of reasoning that led to the HFJ team's conclusions is FULL of broken links. It's not even worth trying to repair them all. If they want to be taken seriously in the scientific or academic communities, then they need to start over.

They will discover, of course, that there is nothing to find. As is usually the case when proper scientific methodology is applied to wooish ideas.
 
So your reason to dismiss this as not real is that you sincerely believe that the HFJ team made or found this material and are simply claiming they found it in the dust?

What evidence do you have that they did not find this material in the dust? If your only reason to doubt that is that you don't like the conclusions, that's not good enough.

When Jones was claiming the microspheres were evidence of thermite, everyone here was doubting that because they claimed there wasn't enough evidence to make that determination. Now here is strong corroborative evidence to support that claim and the best you can do is double down on your doubt without any supporting evidence.

If you don't think this stuff was in the dust, then just quit writing. There's nothing more to talk about.



.

I believe they found something in the dust, but it is not what they think it is, or what they are claiming it is. I think that is why none of the other independent analysis found "exotic incidiaries" in the dust...there are none. What they found are paint chips +/- corrosion.

I also believe that their analysis, and approach in general, is so unscientific, so full of methodological errors, as to render their results null and void, as many many people here have already pointed out to you.

TAM:)
 
Hey Jay,

I'm feeling neglected.

In your reply, you completely ignored every single point that I made. That's not very sporting of you.

Would you care to actually, you know, "address" my points ...?

BTW, with regard to your (shades of 2006) "iron microspheres"...

Ever heard of "fly ash"?

What is the probability that any tiny chunk of iron, if melted by any method at all, will coalesce into a sphere? What causes it to do that?

How much energy do you think that it takes to melt a (big hint here) MICROsphere of iron.

What sort of other processes do you think might get hot enough & have enough energy to melt a MICROsphere's worth of iron?

How hot do you think electrical arcs are? You know, the types that leap from DC motor armatures to brushes. From electrical contacts in, oh say, trains when they make & break contact to the power rails. Did you ever see the opening of that old cop series "NYPD Blue". With the drums & the trains?

Dr. Jones has asserted that iron microspheres in NYC was a big deal back in 2006 / 2007. Did you notice his checking Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, etc for "iron microspheres". Just to make sure that it was, in fact, a big deal? And not a common occurrence in a city.

I haven't heard him make that claim in about 2+ years. Any thoughts as to why that might be?


Tom
 
Dr. Jones has asserted that iron microspheres in NYC was a big deal back in 2006 / 2007. Did you notice his checking Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, etc for "iron microspheres". Just to make sure that it was, in fact, a big deal? And not a common occurrence in a city.

I haven't heard him make that claim in about 2+ years. Any thoughts as to why that might be?

I don't know about Jones but Gage still talks about it. In the recent debate with Ron Craig he made a big deal about it, for example
 
This will surely not be the last time I need to spell this out, as no one here seems capable of reading this sentence: I don't know how the stuff was used. Do you understand me?

I understand you perfectly. What I'm saying is that you're wrong on multiple counts.
  1. It was not present.
  2. It was not used.
  3. Had it even been present, existing evidence proves it failed because it had zero effect on the steel.
You are the one having difficulties grasping concepts.

You are implying that if this material was used, then it was necessarily used in the collapse region and it was the only substance used. Neither of those necessarily follow.

Absolutely, postively wrong. Why do you think I invoked Bazant? It either was used to start the collapse, or its presence wouldn't have mattered at all. Why is that so? Again: Read Bazant's work.

All the rest of your post I omitted is just a restatement of this basic misunderstanding (pretend or real) of what I'm saying. Until you understand what I'm saying, you're just arguing at cross-purposes.
Whatever. At this point, you're refusing to even try to comprehend .
  1. "Thermitic material" was not present.
  2. Even if it were, it did not have any effect.
You have demonstrated that you intend to ignore logic and evidence.

We can't even start speculating about the possibilities of how this stuff was used until we can all agree that this stuff was in fact in the WTC dust.

I cannot agree to a falsehood, save for the sake of argument. Which I've been doing when I said that even if it were present, it failed. Regardless, no, we do not need to agree "that this stuff was in fact in the WTC dust", because it wasn't. You have failed to prove that point, and it has been refuted in the past. Read the refutation, but this time for comprehension.

Can we agree on that

No. You have failed to support your argument. You refuse to accept evidence, and you refuse to draw the proper conclusions from the evidence that exists.

Back with the kaolinite again... Kaolinite was never "demonstrated to be present." It was demonstrated that kaolinite has a similar morphology to the plate-like structures in the red part of the WTC dust chips. Until it has been demonstrated that MEK causes a chemical reaction in aluminosilicates that causes the aluminum to become unbound from the silicon, the only thing being demonstrated is an inability to understand basic chemistry.

This in incorrect. First of all, the aluminum in the red layer was demonstrated to not be unbound in Jones's and Harrit's own spectroscopy. Any assertion that aluminum is not bound to the silicate is contradicted by the very evidence they present. Second of all, the morphology is that of kaolin. You're misstaking by saying that kaoline has "similar" morphology. No, it has the same.

Instead of parroting Jones's own claim that the aluminum migrated out from the red layer in elemental form, why don't you actually ask him to prove it? He merely asserts this; his paper doesn't establish this. As has been pointed out, the MEK soaked chip was not established to be the same composition as the DSC tested ones, which is a damning failure.
 
This in incorrect. First of all, the aluminum in the red layer was demonstrated to not be unbound in Jones's and Harrit's own spectroscopy. Any assertion that aluminum is not bound to the silicate is contradicted by the very evidence they present. Second of all, the morphology is that of kaolin. You're misstaking by saying that kaoline has "similar" morphology. No, it has the same.

Interesting. My first impression was that the alumina and silica bound, due to its rather weak binding, had in the given material experiences dissolution; e.g kaolin dissolution. It's perfectly conceivable that the material in question had experienced enough pressure prior to the 55-hour lay-in-solvent that parts might've dispersed.
 
What is the probability that any tiny chunk of iron, if melted by any method at all, will coalesce into a sphere? What causes it to do that?

That sounds like a good idea for an experiment: Scrape a piece of metal against a sidewalk so that sparks fly, then try to pick up tiny metal fragments with a magnet and examine the results under a microscope.
 
How much energy do you think that it takes to melt a (big hint here) MICROsphere of iron.



Whatever melted them got to at least 1538C for some amount of time, and it did it enough that in a random dust sample collected and studied by the RJ Lee group, they composed 5.7% of the mass.

How did fire get that hot? We know they didn't. So it was electrical? The electrical system was blasting the steel members so hot it decarburated the steel and turned them into iron, aluminum and silica-based spheres? You've seen some evidence of this? That's a "better" theory?

No. It's not a better theory by any stretch of the imagination. It's grasping at straws in the face of the narrowing plausibility of the fire and wreckage-induced collapse theory.

.
 
The first objection that should be dealt with is the issue of sample authenticity. Is this dust from the WTC wreckage? The scenario proposed is that the 4 samples were given to the research team via different channels originally for a different paper, from residents of NYC on or near 9/11/01.

If you don't buy this, then there is no point discussing this further. We really need to get past that first premise if there is to be any real discussion. These are the 3 basic positions at this point:

One. They planted the chips. (contamination)

Two. The substance is in the dust but benign and expected. (Kaolinite)

Three. The substance was planted AND it’s normal building material. (confused)

Those who take the contamination position have a difficult hill to climb with little more than some speculation. This is the time to show any evidence (beyond incredulity) for consideration of this stance or accept that the substance was in the dust and these samples are representative. Or opt into the world of ignore.

The Kaolinites would have us believe this is nothing more than a flammable industrial material painted on the columns that has been baked to a rusted surface, that ignites at 430C and forms iron and silicon-based microspheres during ignition. And just like the molten aluminum theory, if you can replicate those phenomena with some of the paint from the towers, you win. I go home with my tail between my legs. No conspiracy.

The confused apologist takes the unusual stance that the dust is BOTH benign AND planted. This is just a tell that you’re drive is to make this conversation end ASAP. It seems like you're heading off resistance from all directions, but in reality, the argument only demonstrates an unwillingness to talk about this subject at all--as in reality, the dust is either authentic or it's planted. It's either regular building material or it's not supposed to be there. If it's planted, then it better be damningly suspicious. If it's totally benign, then it definitely NOT planted.

It's not both planted AND JUST IN CASE I CAN'T MAKE THAT ARGUMENT WORK, it's also benign. So move your bowels or go on your way, because it can't be both when they are mutually exclusive.

How was this stuff used in the towers? That’s a good question. I don’t know. Did the evidence disappear yet? Nope. All the speculation in the world will not change the fact that these chips ignited at 430C and formed molten iron and silicate spheroids.



.
 
Those who take the contamination position have a difficult hill to climb with little more than some speculation. This is the time to show any evidence (beyond incredulity) for consideration of this stance or accept that the substance was in the dust and these samples are representative. Or opt into the world of ignore.

.

Are you kidding? The burden of proof is on the experimenter to show that a sample is genuine and uncontaminated. These experimenters were unable to do this.

Remember the meteorite found in Antarctica that showed possible signs of life on Mars? The problem was that there was no way to show that the meteorite hadn't been contaminated by terrestrial material. Do you think it is reasonable to conclude that the artifacts found in the sample were signs of Martian life unless someone else proved otherwise?

I'll give you a hint: It isn't. That's how science works.
 
Whatever melted them got to at least 1538C for some amount of time, and it did it enough that in a random dust sample collected and studied by the RJ Lee group, they composed 5.7% of the mass.

How did fire get that hot? We know they didn't. So it was electrical? The electrical system was blasting the steel members so hot it decarburated the steel and turned them into iron, aluminum and silica-based spheres? You've seen some evidence of this? That's a "better" theory?

No. It's not a better theory by any stretch of the imagination. It's grasping at straws in the face of the narrowing plausibility of the fire and wreckage-induced collapse theory.

.

again and again and again...

Before you can make any claims about what was found, first you need to ELIMINATE EVERY OTHER POSSIBLE CAUSE. Here let me state it again.

Before you can make any claims about what was found, first you need to ELIMINATE EVERY OTHER POSSIBLE CAUSE. Here let me hilite it for you

Before you can make any claims about what was found, first you need to ELIMINATE EVERY OTHER POSSIBLE CAUSE.
Will that get through to you? Of course not.

<off topic> The RJ Lee samples were gathered 8 months and 13 months after the attack. WE HAVE NO IDEA when those microspheres got there.

Could they be there from the recovery period when they were using oxy torches and thermic lances to cut steel? (which would create microspheres) Yes.

Could they be there from any upgrades or changes during the ORIGINAL CONSTRUCTION of the towers? Yes.

Could they be there from being released from Fly ASH? Yes.

Could they be from the gypsum and concrete? Yes.

Could they be from thermite/thermate/nanothermite? Yes. (except we know it wasn't because there is no evidence).

Now, since RJ Lee state explicitly that the microspheres were FULLY EXPECTED to be found, why? How would they expect to find them? Maybe you should ask them.

Can you ELIMINATE ANY OF THE OTHER POSSIBILITIES? What? Speak up. I can't hear you. Huh? No you can't.

try again
</off topic>
 
Whatever melted them got to at least 1538C for some amount of time, and it did it enough that in a random dust sample collected and studied by the RJ Lee group, they composed 5.7% of the mass.

How did fire get that hot? We know they didn't. So it was electrical? The electrical system was blasting the steel members so hot it decarburated the steel and turned them into iron, aluminum and silica-based spheres? You've seen some evidence of this? That's a "better" theory?

No. It's not a better theory by any stretch of the imagination. It's grasping at straws in the face of the narrowing plausibility of the fire and wreckage-induced collapse theory.

It is a mistake to presume that the microspheres found in the RJ Lee survey were produced by the fire. That was nothing more than their working presumption, and recall that they made it before the NIST report came out and laid out what happened inside the towers prior to collapse. They were working with the same presumptions regarding the fires that were made in the initial FEMA report, and those have been shows through later research to have been incorrect.

There are multiple possible sources for the microspheres found in the RJ Lee survey that are mundane and far from conspiratorial. For example, if you presume they were there well before 9/11 - which is not only entirely possible, but quite likely, since nothing about their formation dictates that they were formed during 9/11 - then they could have easily come from welding during construction, or the fly ash ingredient of concrete - or both - and have been exposed by the collapses from areas in the buildings where they were previously contained (this explains the higher-than-background concentration RJ Lee noted). If you also keep in mind that, as Ryan Mackey pointed out, their survey was done 9 months after the towers fell, then suddenly you have another source that's not merely likely, but is impossible to ignore: Salvage operations.

Bottom line: You commit an error by presuming the spheres RJ Lee identified were created by the 9/11 events. You have no basis for that presumption.

Furthermore: The implications of the RJ Lee report have been discussed before. You apparently missed those threads. Here's a small sample:
Invoking the RJ Lee report to support conspiratorial fantasies is a mistake. Those spheres have other sources. Your "thermitic material" is ruled out for other reasons, and could not have possibly been the generator of the spheres noted by the RJ Lee group.

How was this stuff used in the towers? That’s a good question. I don’t know. Did the evidence disappear yet? Nope. All the speculation in the world will not change the fact that these chips ignited at 430C and formed molten iron and silicate spheroids.

Too bad 430oC happened in far too small a sample to have any meaning: Temperatures generated at that level are not indicative of bulk properties. Too bad also that the spheres were shown in Jones and Harrit's own work to not be homogenous, which directly impacts the melting point argument (a compound will not exhibit the same characteristics of an element, and often, melting points are lowered. This is seen in many simple iron-other element compounds - take iron sulfide as an example: It has a lower melting point (~1194oC) than straight iron (1538oC) or various steels (~1510oC, depending on the carbon content and other elements present). But what brings the ultimate sadness is that the characteristics Jones's group describes match that of paint and contradict that of thermite (or whatever you want to call it... "thermitic material" or some such euphamism), yet folks like you insist on beating the square "thermitic material" peg in the round "it's anything but" hole.

Lots of these issues are covered in the first few pages of this very thread. You really should read them.
 
Look Jay, you can BS all you want, but this is the way PROPER SCIENCE works.

1. You find substance A. You hypothesize what it might be based on tests done, you must then prove that the substance is what you hypothesize, and you do that by eliminating ALL OTHER REASONABLE POSSIBILITIES.

THEY have not done this, so they fail...plain and simple.

2. So the alleged chain of custody for ALL of the sample they used, is that they came from a common source 5 years later from the time that that source collected them for a different paper...thats it? That is suppose to be a good chain of custody? Perhaps for a grade 1 science paper, but not for a real world grown up paper, and CERTAINLY not for any type of forensic analysis. Now you can whine about how we are being unreasonable, or unfair, but that is THE WAY SCIENCE WORKS.

3. WHy don't you just be honest (you have shown glimmers of being of legitimate inquiry) and admit they did a piss poor, totally bias, totally unscientific JOB of it, and that they should start over.

DO YOU NOT FIND IT SUSPICIOUS that (A) they have not provided their samples for TRULY INDEPENDENT ANALYSIS, and (B) Those other analysis of WTC dust have not come up with any material they consider unexpected or out of the ordinary????

Your answer to this will truly tell me if you are being honest about your inquiry, or simply playing along, trying to convince people.

TAM:)
 
The first objection that should be dealt with is the issue of sample authenticity. Is this dust from the WTC wreckage? The scenario proposed is that the 4 samples were given to the research team via different channels originally for a different paper, from residents of NYC on or near 9/11/01.

If you don't buy this, then there is no point discussing this further.

That, in fact, is the first problem. There is no established chain of custody to verify that the dust samples originated from the WTC debris. That, alone, renders any speculation on the further analysis moot.


These are the 3 basic positions at this point:

One. They planted the chips. (contamination)

Two. The substance is in the dust but benign and expected. (Kaolinite)

Three. The substance was planted AND it’s normal building material. (confused)

Four. The samples are a mixture of dust from various sources, including unintentional contamination from environmental dust sources.

Those who take the contamination position have a difficult hill to climb with little more than some speculation. This is the time to show any evidence (beyond incredulity) for consideration of this stance or accept that the substance was in the dust and these samples are representative. Or opt into the world of ignore.

The problem, for you, is that you are trying to evangelise. Putting people on ignore is, for you, as much of a failure as people putting you on ignore. By leaving the debate, you are conceding defeat, because if you simply claim that your point of view has not been disproven and no more then you are accepting the status quo, and the status quo is a general understanding that 9/11 was perpetrated by al-Qaeda and that the Twin Towers collapsed as a direct result of impact and fire damage. The burden of proof rests entirely on you.

The confused apologist takes the unusual stance that the dust is BOTH benign AND planted. This is just a tell that you’re drive is to make this conversation end ASAP. It seems like you're heading off resistance from all directions, but in reality, the argument only demonstrates an unwillingness to talk about this subject at all--as in reality, the dust is either authentic or it's planted. It's either regular building material or it's not supposed to be there. If it's planted, then it better be damningly suspicious. If it's totally benign, then it definitely NOT planted.

You're omitting the possibility that we think it was planted by somebody stupid. It's quite feasible - though, in fact, I don't think this is the case - that the dust samples were deliberately doctored to contain a substance that is nevertheless incapable of creating the effect the forger wanted to suggest, because the forger is too stupid to work out the ramifications of his own conspiracy theory.

How was this stuff used in the towers? That’s a good question. I don’t know. Did the evidence disappear yet? Nope. All the speculation in the world will not change the fact that these chips ignited at 430C and formed molten iron and silicate spheroids.

Thus demonstrating that (a) they would have been ignited by the jet fuel fires immediately following the impacts and could not therefore have been responsible for the collapses, and (b) either it is possible to form iron spheroids without producing temperatures high enough to melt steel over significant areas (assuming Dr. Harrit's equipment survived the experiments) or the spheroids are not, in fact, pure iron.

I suggest you consider that second point very, very carefully. Conspiracy theorists are using spheroids produced in a reaction that did not generate temperatures in excess of 1500ºC over macroscopic regions as proof that temperatures in excess of 1500ºC were produced over macroscopic regions. The fact that they were able to produce these spheres without destroying their own equipment is simple refutation of their claim.

Dave
 
how much energy will melt a MICROsphere of iron?

Whatever melted them got to at least 1538C for some amount of time, and it did it enough that in a random dust sample collected and studied by the RJ Lee group, they composed 5.7% of the mass.

How did fire get that hot? We know they didn't. So it was electrical? The electrical system was blasting the steel members so hot it decarburated the steel and turned them into iron, aluminum and silica-based spheres? You've seen some evidence of this? That's a "better" theory?

No. It's not a better theory by any stretch of the imagination. It's grasping at straws in the face of the narrowing plausibility of the fire and wreckage-induced collapse theory.

.
jay howard, do you think that what you wrote above answers this question that you quoted? Because it doesn't. The answer should be a number of joules. Please try again.

tfk said:
How much energy do you think that it takes to melt a (big hint here) MICROsphere of iron.


jay howard, please insert number of joules here __________________
 
Microspheres ??? Again??? Is it 2008 all over again? Have you been hibernating in a cave like a bear for 2 years Jay Howard? Time to get up to speed on what could have formed Microspheres.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=114717

Brake pads on heavy equipment, especially cranes, and excavators produce micro spheres with silicon, Concrete cut off saws with Aluminum oxide and silicon binder do the same. Clutches and big truck brakes also. As well as some sand papers using silicon binders with aluminum oxide.
Iron fibers and Diatomaceous Earth are used in brake pads, on equipment and vehicles.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatomaceous_earth

http://www.patentstorm.us/patents/5042991/description.html

Until site contamination is resolved the work of Dr. Steven E Jones and the other Scholars on the micro spheres is garbage Pseudo Science.

They believe solely because micro spheres are present that they indicate high temperatures, that is a false leap based solely on assumption in conditions which are not and can never be controlled to rule out possible contamination from multiple sources.

The Micro spheres might even be from the renovation following the 1993 bombing from steel cutting and hauling or from equipment operations and steel and concrete cutting during the clean up in 2001.

The micro spheres are not important unless they point to a specific source that can not be mistaken for back ground contamination, from other sources.

I would like to see more evidence of work on the micro spheres, and samples provided, however I do not expect that from the Scholars for truth at this moment.

Many micro spheres are the result of abrasive Mechanical friction on steel and not the result of the fires, that was a false assumption, which I thought I should clear up.

I thought I read somewhere (not here) that diesel engine combustion produces a small amount of such, especially on less well maintained engines. Do you know anything about this? I'm unable to find much about it, but I haven't tried searching beyond the internet yet.

If that's correct - if - then sheer exposure from the number of buses, delivery trucks, etc. would be immense. But again, that's if.

Yes diesel engine exhaust does contain micro spheres, as well as the fluids contained in the engine contain them, from cavitational corrosion of the cylinder liners.

Car engines also can produce micro spheres there is no perfect system of lubrication as the piston rings wear in a car engine and carbon builds up it increases cylinder wear.
Cast steel engines and Cylinder liners are high silicon for greater hardness and less wear as well as greater heat dissipation.

The brakes on a car can though mechanical friction produce micro spheres if the car is traveling fast enough to reach the critical energy necessary when the brakes are applied.

Anything that cuts or brakes using iron and aluminum silicates or aluminum oxide and silicates, can form micro-spheres the greater the live load stopped by the breaking material the more micro-spheres produced.
Large overloaded trucks and Cranes would be a huge source of them.
There are certain characteristics of microspheres that would point to thermite as being the most likely source. So far Steven Jones has failed to provide X-ray spectra showing the characteristics I am refering to. (I will not say what these characteristics are - to keep Jones honest - but I have plenty of data to back-up my claim.)

Chainsaw and other posters are correct about the multiple sources of "iron-rich microspheres". They are myriad! I have also reviewed published data on airborne particulate for New York City going back to the 1970s and the years when the Twin Towers were under construction! The deposition rate for Fe onto NYC is about 400 mg/m^2/year. Jones needs to consider this dry deposition flux before he goes off claiming all sorts of things about his samples.

Until Jones is willing to provide a complete set of analytical data for a statistically significant set of WTC microspheres, he is not going to convince a jury of his peers of anything!
 
Here is a photograph showing iron-rich microspheres being produced:


Can you spot the iron-rich microspheres in the photo? It's easier than you might think!

Where was Grinder Girl on 9/11/2001? We'll need a new investigation with subpoena power to find out!

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom