TruthersLie
This space for rent.
- Joined
- Jun 20, 2009
- Messages
- 3,715
again and again you just jump past the 20 methodological errors and then continue to try to argue the "evidence." That is SOMETHING YOU CAN'T DO. If the methodology is crap, then you cannot discuss the findings, results, experiments or the conclusions.So your reason to dismiss this as not real is that you sincerely believe that the HFJ team made or found this material and are simply claiming they found it in the dust?
It has NOTHING to do with the idea that "this as no real" or that "the HFJ team made or found this material."
It is the basic backbones of science. If you don't have the methodology, you don't have a paper. Throw this crap in the bin and start over.
What evidence do you have that they did not find this material in the dust? If your only reason to doubt that is that you don't like the conclusions, that's not good enough.
Again and again. I don't know what they found (and neither do they) because they had crap methdology. You are starting with an assumption (you do know that it makes an ASS out of U and MPTION right?) that is not backed up by any science.
Your lack of reading for comprehension is showing. When Jones was making the iron microspheres argument, people were asking him what ELSE MAKES/HAS microspheres in them. What else does? Come on twoof? Now can you eliminate ANY OF THOSE OTHER SOURCES OF MICROSPHERES? No. If you cannot eliminate them, then you cannot claim that the microsphres are from thermate, thermite, godzilla, pixie dust or anything else.When Jones was claiming the microspheres were evidence of thermite, everyone here was doubting that because they claimed there wasn't enough evidence to make that determination.
go back to school and take a simple experimental methods class. FAIL (yet again)
Where? Please point out any corroborative evidence. Pretty please with a cherry on top...... OHHHHHHH you mean this pile o fail that is the Bentham article. <snort> <snicker> <lol>Now here is strong corroborative evidence to support that claim and the best you can do is double down on your doubt without any supporting evidence.
again and again. Lets repeat.
1. If the methodology is crap (and there are 20 methodological errors in this "paper"), then the "paper" is invalid and you cannot take anything from it in any seriousness.
2. Now you claim that there is something in the dust, but you cannot eliminate ANY of the possible other sources of this materials.
You have demonstrated that there isn't anything more to talk about. Now make that phone call I suggested and educate yourself.If you don't think this stuff was in the dust, then just quit writing. There's nothing more to talk about.
.