O.k. So because they don't have a coherent theory about how the stuff was used, then you feel good about consigning it to the wacko bin and moving on. That's nice but irrelevant to the actual material at hand.
This has been discussed to death both in this thread, and others on this forum, as well as other forums on the net. I am far from the only one to declare their science poor.
If you just want to say they made up the data, that's your prerogative. But if you accept that they actually found the stuff in the dust, then it must be dealt with.
We have taken that approach here, assuming that they did find red and red grey chips of "something" in the dust. As I said above, it has been discussed here to the nth degree.
It's ironic that you would go so far in your defense of the official theory as to claim a fairly complex conspiracy has been brewing by the Jones crew. They had to seed their dust (at first) with iron-based microspheres, then years later invest a considerable amount of money into making an as-yet unheard of explosive material that, surprise surprise, produces iron microspheres when ignited!
1. I do not DEFEND the "official theory". I have not had ANYONE present me with any worthy evidence that contradicts it, including Jones et al, so I believe what most people (many smarter then you and I) in the world believe, and what I have been presented with mountains of evidence for...that which most normal people call "what happened on 9/11", but what you feel COMPELLED to call the "official theory", which clearly is done to try to bring it down, way down, to an equal playing field with the ridiculous CTs that eminate from the truth movement.
2. Once again, the presence of the iron microspheres has been done on this forum MANY TIMES, and many non-conspiratorial reasons can explain them. Search and read, find issues, and bring the issues, not the entire ridiculous theory.
Are they also complicit in seeding the RJ Lee samples with iron-based microspheres as well as the USGS samples?
Where did I say they "Seeded" anything, I said it would not surprise me to find out that they manipulated or fabricated DATA. I said nothing directly related to the samples themselves in that regard, although others could have easily done so prior to giving Jones the sample, given the chain of custody issue.
Or can we simply cut Plato's beard here and say they did indeed find some strange material in the dust samples? It's most certainly more believable that these academics found the stuff they claim to have found.
You can cut my beard for all I care. Amazing is it not, that of all the samples taken from the WTC, and all the analysis done, ONLY THEIRS considers the contents of the dust, red chips or not, to be "strange" or "devious". Amazing indeed. Geniuses they are.
Again, I don't claim to know how this stuff was used in the towers, but don't you think it deserves a good examination?
I think that there has been a huge amount of "good examination" done on the contents of WTC dust, and NONE OF THOSE EXAMINATIONS found "thermite", but a number of them found PAINT within the dust. Amazing.
Or maybe you're just claiming that their analysis of the material is faulty--not that they designed and seeded it in the dust samples. If so, where did they fall off the tracks?
Well now there is something.
Perhaps it was their failure to obtain the exact paints used in the WTC, paint them on steel columns, leave them or age them for corrosion and other natural effects, then super heat them, then take chips and compare those to their "mystery" chips. Given that is MUCH MORE PLAUSIBLE as a source of their chips, would that not seem like the most scientific thing to do? the most intellectually HONEST thing to do?
Perhaps it was their almost negligible attempt to eliminate anything else as the source of their chips, but rather, spend most of their time and investigation TRY TO PROVE the chips WERE THERMITE.
Perhaps it was their failure to insure any kind of reasonable CHAIN OF CUSTODY. Perhaps you can ask henryco here on this forum, while his subsequent investigations of dust samples failed to produce the Jones results...
So much wrong with the paper, with the investigation. I am but a laymen with this stuff, and even I can see the faults within it. Sunstealer and Mackey can and have torn it to shreds.
You are not bringing anything new to the table, so what is there to address?
TAM
