Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

So you too are a believer that MEK can cause a chemical reaction that can reduce aluminosilicates to Al and a Si compound?

Please, give me a science lesson that doesn't involve linking to a paper you've never read.


.



OK, back up a bit here.

I'm not going to dig back through this thread, so humor me here.

are you stating that this:

The next XEDS spectrum (Fig. 17) was acquired from a region that showed a high concentration of aluminum. Using a conventional quantification routine, it was found that the aluminum significantly exceeded the oxygen present (approximately a 3:1 ratio). Thus, while some of the aluminum may be oxidized, there is insufficient oxygen present to account for all of the aluminum; some aluminum must therefore exist in elemental form in the red material.

proves that there was elemental aluminum because MEK can not disolve aluminosilicates?
 
OK, back up a bit here.

I'm not going to dig back through this thread, so humor me here.

are you stating that this:



proves that there was elemental aluminum because MEK can not disolve aluminosilicates?

No. I'm saying MEK cannot cause the Al in aluminosilicates to unbind from the Si. Are you saying it can?


.
 
According to Jones himself, the Thermite was most likely just used in the detonation fuses for more traditional explosives (See several threads on this suggestion he made on another forum as provided by email exchanges between Jones and Dr. Frank Greening about 1 year ago).

That said, given their obsession verging on insanity with this issue, given the investment in what little reputation the authors have in this, I would not doubt for a moment that they are capable not only of MANIPULATING the data, but actually FORGING/MANUFACTURING data to suite their hypothesis. At the very least the authors are guilty of (A) poor science, and (B) Severe (near blinding) bias.

TAM:)


O.k. So because they don't have a coherent theory about how the stuff was used, then you feel good about consigning it to the wacko bin and moving on. That's nice but irrelevant to the actual material at hand.

If you just want to say they made up the data, that's your prerogative. But if you accept that they actually found the stuff in the dust, then it must be dealt with.

It's ironic that you would go so far in your defense of the official theory as to claim a fairly complex conspiracy has been brewing by the Jones crew. They had to seed their dust (at first) with iron-based microspheres, then years later invest a considerable amount of money into making an as-yet unheard of explosive material that, surprise surprise, produces iron microspheres when ignited!

Are they also complicit in seeding the RJ Lee samples with iron-based microspheres as well as the USGS samples?

Or can we simply cut Plato's beard here and say they did indeed find some strange material in the dust samples? It's most certainly more believable that these academics found the stuff they claim to have found.

Again, I don't claim to know how this stuff was used in the towers, but don't you think it deserves a good examination?

Or maybe you're just claiming that their analysis of the material is faulty--not that they designed and seeded it in the dust samples. If so, where did they fall off the tracks?



.
 
Let me see, we have the following,

Buildings full of painted columns etc...collapses into huge pile. Thousands of people witness the jet airliners strike the buildings an hour or so prior to collapse. Years later, samples of alleged dust from GZ are submitted to the authors with a weak chain of custody record, at best, for analysis.

Now what do you think should be the focus of such an analysis?

(A) an unbias, scientific analysis of the dust contents, with ALL POSSIBLE contents ruled in or out,

OR

(B) a hunt for thermite?

You wanna talk unscientific, truther "scientists" wrote the book on that.

Funny how numerous other studies and analysis of the WTC dust have been done, and paint is mentioned as a component in many of them, yet never a mention of "thermite" or some "exothermic explosive/incidiary" or the like. Funny that.

TAM;)

Again, you can relegate the entire paper to the dustbin, however, your implication is that Farrer, Harrit, Jones, et. al. are participating in a fairly complex lie without much promise of fame or fortune just so they can make enemies out of the most powerful people in the country. Is that realistic? Am I taking you out of context?

If your hesitation is based on methodology, please expand on that.


.
 
what proof do you have that the AL was not bound to the Si?

The next XEDS spectrum (Fig. 17) was acquired from a region that showed a high concentration of aluminum. Using a conventional quantification routine, it was found that the aluminum significantly exceeded the oxygen present (approximately a 3:1 ratio). Thus, while some of the aluminum may be oxidized, there is insufficient oxygen present to account for all of the aluminum; some aluminum must therefore exist in elemental form in the red material.
P. 18

My emphasis
 
Or maybe you're just claiming that their analysis of the material is faulty--not that they designed and seeded it in the dust samples. If so, where did they fall off the tracks?
.

Well their truther buddy tested it and found nothing.

But more to the point their analysis of the material was not just faulty, it was a complete joke. Hey lets compare the sample with whatever old paint sample we have sitting around here in Utah. Lets also burn the sample in the air! Hey, lets do some science!

Hey, lets claim that the results which prove that it cannot be thermite means that it is some kind of super thermite! And rather than invest the time it takes to properly obtain “super thermite,” why don't some of you folks try to get some under false pretences?

Look out world, here comes science!
 
Hey, lets claim that the results which prove that it cannot be thermite means that it is some kind of super thermite! And rather than invest the time it takes to properly obtain “super thermite,” why don't some of you folks try to get some under false pretences?

Look out world, here comes science!

And don't forget that the thermite is necessary because there were no explosions heard, except that even Jones had to admit that there couldn't have been enough thermite to bring the buildings down, so it was used as a detonater for conventional explosives, which weren't heard, but that's OK, because there was thermite, which is necessary because....

It helps if you don't think about it too much.
 
But more to the point their analysis of the material was not just faulty, it was a complete joke. Hey lets compare the sample with whatever old paint sample we have sitting around here in Utah. Lets also burn the sample in the air! Hey, lets do some science!

Did Jones and company ever try to ignite it in an inert gas environment. I know there was talk of this. Seems to me this would be test number one for this type of stuff.

Jay Howard. do you know?
 
O.k. So because they don't have a coherent theory about how the stuff was used, then you feel good about consigning it to the wacko bin and moving on. That's nice but irrelevant to the actual material at hand.

This has been discussed to death both in this thread, and others on this forum, as well as other forums on the net. I am far from the only one to declare their science poor.

If you just want to say they made up the data, that's your prerogative. But if you accept that they actually found the stuff in the dust, then it must be dealt with.

We have taken that approach here, assuming that they did find red and red grey chips of "something" in the dust. As I said above, it has been discussed here to the nth degree.

It's ironic that you would go so far in your defense of the official theory as to claim a fairly complex conspiracy has been brewing by the Jones crew. They had to seed their dust (at first) with iron-based microspheres, then years later invest a considerable amount of money into making an as-yet unheard of explosive material that, surprise surprise, produces iron microspheres when ignited!

1. I do not DEFEND the "official theory". I have not had ANYONE present me with any worthy evidence that contradicts it, including Jones et al, so I believe what most people (many smarter then you and I) in the world believe, and what I have been presented with mountains of evidence for...that which most normal people call "what happened on 9/11", but what you feel COMPELLED to call the "official theory", which clearly is done to try to bring it down, way down, to an equal playing field with the ridiculous CTs that eminate from the truth movement.

2. Once again, the presence of the iron microspheres has been done on this forum MANY TIMES, and many non-conspiratorial reasons can explain them. Search and read, find issues, and bring the issues, not the entire ridiculous theory.

Are they also complicit in seeding the RJ Lee samples with iron-based microspheres as well as the USGS samples?

Where did I say they "Seeded" anything, I said it would not surprise me to find out that they manipulated or fabricated DATA. I said nothing directly related to the samples themselves in that regard, although others could have easily done so prior to giving Jones the sample, given the chain of custody issue.

Or can we simply cut Plato's beard here and say they did indeed find some strange material in the dust samples? It's most certainly more believable that these academics found the stuff they claim to have found.

You can cut my beard for all I care. Amazing is it not, that of all the samples taken from the WTC, and all the analysis done, ONLY THEIRS considers the contents of the dust, red chips or not, to be "strange" or "devious". Amazing indeed. Geniuses they are.

Again, I don't claim to know how this stuff was used in the towers, but don't you think it deserves a good examination?

I think that there has been a huge amount of "good examination" done on the contents of WTC dust, and NONE OF THOSE EXAMINATIONS found "thermite", but a number of them found PAINT within the dust. Amazing.

Or maybe you're just claiming that their analysis of the material is faulty--not that they designed and seeded it in the dust samples. If so, where did they fall off the tracks?

Well now there is something.

Perhaps it was their failure to obtain the exact paints used in the WTC, paint them on steel columns, leave them or age them for corrosion and other natural effects, then super heat them, then take chips and compare those to their "mystery" chips. Given that is MUCH MORE PLAUSIBLE as a source of their chips, would that not seem like the most scientific thing to do? the most intellectually HONEST thing to do?

Perhaps it was their almost negligible attempt to eliminate anything else as the source of their chips, but rather, spend most of their time and investigation TRY TO PROVE the chips WERE THERMITE.

Perhaps it was their failure to insure any kind of reasonable CHAIN OF CUSTODY. Perhaps you can ask henryco here on this forum, while his subsequent investigations of dust samples failed to produce the Jones results...

So much wrong with the paper, with the investigation. I am but a laymen with this stuff, and even I can see the faults within it. Sunstealer and Mackey can and have torn it to shreds.

You are not bringing anything new to the table, so what is there to address?

TAM:)
 
what proof do you have that the AL was not bound to the Si?
The next XEDS spectrum (Fig. 17) was acquired from a region that showed a high concentration of aluminum. Using a conventional quantification routine, it was found that the aluminum significantly exceeded the oxygen present (approximately a 3:1 ratio). Thus, while some of the aluminum may be oxidized, there is insufficient oxygen present to account for all of the aluminum; some aluminum must therefore exist in elemental form in the red material.

P. 18

My emphasis
Look at figure 7. Pay attention to the relative heights of Al and Si, and note that they are fairly comparable to O.

Now see figure 14. Does it look like the same thing at all?

The MEK-soaked chip was from a completely different nature to the rest. There's no characterization of the chips. They are all different, except maybe samples 1-4 in the beginning which seem of the same nature. The conclusions don't follow from the data. There's no in-depth analysis of the MEK-soaked chip. In figure 10 the Al appears bound to the Si and the O. The platelets they form correspond to kaolinite, as some people have shown repeatedly here.

In all, the only proof that the Al is not bound to the Si appears in a chip not thoroughly analyzed nor cleaned whose nature we don't know. They shouldn't extrapolate the conclusion that Al is not bound to Si to the other chips. By their logic, in figure 15 the O is bound to the Si and the Fe is free, so there's silicon oxide but no iron oxide, thus no thermite.

Just another sloppiness of many. Happens when you have decided a conclusion and are blind to indications that point in a different direction. That's the best conclusion about the paper when presuming good faith, something that coming from some of the signers of the paper is a bit too forced.
 
If you don't want to have this discussion, then by all means, don't have it. But encouraging others not[/n] to have it because we're not experts in nano-energetic materials is ridiculous and pointless.

I find it amusing that this sub-forum has become a lightening rod for debunkers, yet suddenly the topic is no longer appropriate for JREF because we lack expertise? There's certainly a lot of bull that passes for science on both sides of this debate, however, Farrer, Harrit, Jones, et. al. have written this paper in an accessible way. If you think their paper contains unfounded conclusions, then this is your chance to demonstrate that.
.


I'm pointing out that no one can or should take this claim seriously. It is not a scientific claim. No one with any scientific expertise with thermite has ever commented on it. It holds the same status as claims about Sasquatch or the Loch Ness monster - maybe less. As such, you can make whatever statement you want about the implications of thermite at the WTC, but it's about as meaningful as making claims about human evolution based on the existance of the Sasquatch. This may be fun, but it has no bearing at all on science or politics.
 
It's not that im ignoring you, it's that your claim that because there are errors you can dismiss all the findings in the paper, does not follow.

It fully follows. When you use BAD sampling, BAD controls, and have over 20 methodological errors, can you in all honesty state that you can take any of their findings or conclusions at face value? Of course not.

In a "paper" riddled with methodological errors like this one, how can you honestly with a straight face try to take ANY of their conclusions at face value? If they botch it that badly, what is to say they didn't botch other parts or fudge the data? Absolutely NOTHING.

In papers riddled with methodological errors, the best thing, the ONLY thing to do is scrap the paper and do it again.

It's a good point that they didn't use the same paint as was in the towers. As I asked above, do you think the paint from the towers would NOT dissolve or become soft? Does the XEDS analysis care if they used a poor control paint in the MEK soak? Do the x-rays somehow know it's poor methodology and therefore refuse to produce accurate spectrum data?

Again and again you want to try to equate this piss poor scientifically invalid "paper" with real science. Do it again. Get it done at independent labs or do it right. But realize that this is a craptacular fail and stop trying to use it for the basis of any argument. Go back to school and take just one decent experimental design course. Try again.

Did you find something wrong with the acquisition or analysis of the spectrum data?
.

Again and again. With bad controls, bad samples, and over 20 methodological errors you cannot draw ANY conclusions from this "paper." What part of that is sooooo difficult to understand?

This isn't a "Yes the science is crap, but look at page 2 they say this..." because the first part invalidates the rest.
 
There's certainly a lot of bull that passes for science on both sides of this debate, however, Farrer, Harrit, Jones, et. al. have written this paper in an accessible way. If you think their paper contains unfounded conclusions, then this is your chance to demonstrate that.


.

that has already been demonstrated. Over 20 methodological errors invalidates the "paper."

The lack of publishing it in anything beyond a vanity pay to publish journal invalidates the "paper."

the fact that ALL of them are WAY OUTSIDE of their fields of expertise also brings up serious questions about their science.

TRY AGAIN. Sunstealer has already demolished this "paper."
 
This is another attempt to say that since no one can explain how it was used, we can dismiss it.

What's interesting about this attempt this line of reasoning is that we all agree the WTC fell because of arson. No one here can meaningfully say that wasn't a case of arson. The only debate is the sources of energy involved.

You might want to look up the word ARSON. It was an act of terrorism. You know... those HUGE JETS striking the building may have had something to do with it.

Now that some very unusual highly energetic material was found, why should anyone interested not want to look into it?

What was found? Provide me with a single peer reviewed engineering/thermitic or other journal article which documents any "unusual highly energetic material" which was found.

Oh, you are talking about the same boat load of fail we have already been discussing.

AGain, let me repeat. This "paper" which you seem to want to tout is riddled with methodological errors. As such, any and all conclusions and findings are in doubt. It is bad science. Try again, this time actually do the science and eliminate the methodological errors. Once you have done that (and it has passed real peer review) come on back and I'd love to discuss it with you.

What could be gained from not looking into it?

Why would someone even entertain that idea?

I don't know how the stuff was used. The authors of the paper don't know how it was used. That doesn't make it go away.
You keep using that word. Do you know what it means? "Paper" I mean. What you keep touting isn't a scientific "paper." It is psuedo science that is riddled with methodological errors. Try again.
 
O.k. So because they don't have a coherent theory about how the stuff was used, then you feel good about consigning it to the wacko bin and moving on. That's nice but irrelevant to the actual material at hand.

It is NOT irrelevant to the actual material at hand. The actual material at hand has been shown in numerous REAL peer reviewed scientific papers to be paint.

It is only in a pay to publish vanity journal, with people working WAY OUTSIDE OF THEIR FIELDS with 20 methodological errors that you have anyone claiming that there is "nanothermite" there.

So fix the errors, get the "paper" validly and truely peer reviewed and published, then it will become a paper with validity.

If you just want to say they made up the data, that's your prerogative.

I call into question ALL of their data, ALL of their findings and ALL of their conclusions. How can you NOT? You have over 20 methodological errors in this "paper." One or two I can understand, as none of the authors of this "paper" are materials scientists. I can understand a few minor errors because they are working outside of their field of expertise and education. But 20 of them, some of them MASSIVELY GLARING errors? REally? That is like having a high school student produce a "paper" disproving relativity.

With the errors and the level of the errors, I cannot in any honesty take ANYTHING they have written with ANY type of reliability, validity or scientific honesty.

But if you accept that they actually found the stuff in the dust, then it must be dealt with.

Wishful thinking, and an "What if" atttitude. FIRST you must show that the materials you claim are there are in fact there. In this "paper" with 20 methodological errors you cannot show that.

Why won't truthers send their materials off to truely independent labs? Huh?

Why has S. Jones changed his story from super nanothermite cutting columns to now being used for fuses for conventional explosives (which are disproven as there is NO evidence for it?)

It's ironic that you would go so far in your defense of the official theory as to claim a fairly complex conspiracy has been brewing by the Jones crew.

1. what official theory? Which governmental agency has told the complete story of 9/11? I don't know of one. Who is part of this "official theory?"
2. This isn't a "complex conspiracy" for jones and crew. They are known truthers who have confirmation bias. It is rather simple.

They had to seed their dust (at first) with iron-based microspheres, then years later invest a considerable amount of money into making an as-yet unheard of explosive material that, surprise surprise, produces iron microspheres when ignited!
<facepalm>
BAck to the iron microspheres? Really? Truely? Are you that desperate? ROFLMAO.

Are they also complicit in seeding the RJ Lee samples with iron-based microspheres as well as the USGS samples?

Since you bring up RJ LEE (which is a derail btw) can you explain how RJ Lee was expecting to find these microspheres? They state directly that they were expected by products of the collapse. Does RJ Lee know it was CD? Did they know it was "nanothermite?"

Or can we simply cut Plato's beard here and say they did indeed find some strange material in the dust samples?

I do not know what they "found." I do know that they used bad science. Will you admit that this "paper" is riddled with methodologial errors? Yes or no?

It's most certainly more believable that these academics found the stuff they claim to have found.
So really your entire argument comes down to personal ignorance and personal incredulity? Is that correct?

These "academics" are working outside of their field of expertise. Yes or no?
These "academics" are working outside of their field of educaiton. Yes or no?
These "academics" created a "paper" which is filled with psuedo science and methodological errors. Yes or no?

Again, I don't claim to know how this stuff was used in the towers, but don't you think it deserves a good examination?

Neither you nor I can claim to know what this "stuff" was. That would be because this "paper" is riddled with methodological errors which call into question all of their findings and conclusions.

again and again, why won't you truthers send some of your "evidence" to any state of the art lab with a check for $100 to find out what the samples are?

Heck, PM me and I'll pay for it myself.

Or maybe you're just claiming that their analysis of the material is faulty--not that they designed and seeded it in the dust samples. If so, where did they fall off the tracks?

As has been pointed out REPEATEDLY. They have over 20 methodological errors in this "paper." Try to keep up.

I have given you three simple ones. Three easy ones. See if you can find the other 17.
 
My point is that they're not academic papers. They have the same status as blog posts. This doesn't necessarily mean they represent bad research, but in their current state, no one can possibly know.

We can all have fun here on JREF talking about what we think, but don't pretend for a second this has any bearing on science. If these papers continue to be ignored by politicans and policy makers, it's because Jones and his crew refuse to have them reviewed by legitimate experts. Sure it's all fun and games, but that's my point - who could possibly take it seriously? It seems not even Dr. Jones and our 911 Truth friends.
 
Can anyone back up the claim that the chips were just paint?

You don't understand how this whole process works.

Nobody in the entire world is required to back up the claim that the chips are just paint. Farrer, Harrit, Jones, et al, ARE required to back up their claim that they are thermite. Or nanothermite. Or Sooooperthermite.

I have just completed my hair-brained analysis and concluded that they are "Unicorn dandruff". (Has as much reality as nanothermite to FHJ etc.)

Are the world's serious scientists now required to drop their serious work & jump to reanalyze dust samples? Are they required to debunk my paper? Or do they just go on doing serious work?

O.k. So because they don't have a coherent theory about how the stuff was used, then you feel good about consigning it to the wacko bin and moving on.
...

Or maybe you're just claiming that their analysis of the material is faulty--not that they designed and seeded it in the dust samples. If so, where did they fall off the tracks?

Yes, their analysis is completely faulty. I'm not even a chemist, and I know FOR CERTAIN that their analysis is amateurish & faulty.

Because none of them have ever done this specific analysis before. Which, by definition, makes them amateurs at this analysis.

As a result, their analysis is completely inconclusive. They report SUGGESTIONS of a substance that they've NEVER SEEN.

Here's their primary screw-up.

THINK ABOUT IT: why would they try to invent their own tests, when arson investigators - REAL experts - are often called upon to determine whether or not thermite has been used in a fire?

Is there a DEFINITIVE test for thermite? Not aluminum-oxide & iron. But thermite, pre & post ignition.

I found out in about 1/2 hour that the answer is "Yes". There is a test, X-ray diffraction test, that can be done at contract chem labs around the country that will tell you FOR CERTAIN whether this stuff is the COMPOUND thermite, or just some compound that includes iron, aluminum & oxygen, etc.

The test cost about $130 ea. if you prepare your own samples (i.e., grind them into powder). Or about $170 ea if the lab does it for you.

And you are allegedly looking for a specific compound that was used for a specific task: "blowing up" or compromising the columns of the towers. You don't go searching in "dust" that was spread all over Manhattan. Your chances of finding the tiny amounts (compared to the millions of tons of rubble) are absurdly small. You go to the SOURCE: the ends of the columns that are still stored at JFK.

[Of course, there is nothing that looks anything like a thermite cut on any of those beams. Or - from detailed photos available today - on any beam that was in the rubble pile. But don't let that annoying little fact slow down the stupid.]

You could test 50 samples from many columns, at 2 independent labs, for less than $20K. And in about 30 days.

And when you are done, you have a definitive, conclusive answer. Rather than a pile of amateur innuendo.

How's that for "falling off the tracks"?

Tom
 
Look at figure 7. Pay attention to the relative heights of Al and Si, and note that they are fairly comparable to O.

Now see figure 14. Does it look like the same thing at all?

The MEK-soaked chip was from a completely different nature to the rest. There's no characterization of the chips. They are all different, except maybe samples 1-4 in the beginning which seem of the same nature.

So, except samples 1, 2, 3, and 4, all the samples are different... Did you read this paper? Did you even skim it? In that time did you notice that there are only 4 samples of dust? Did you see the corresponding XEDS spectrum data that show the similarities in elemental composition by weight? Then the corresponding SE and BSE images to compare the morphology?

Please explain on what grounds you make the claim that all the chips are different? Or why you think the MEK soaked chip is different--other than the red layer expands during the 55 hour soak.

The conclusions don't follow from the data. There's no in-depth analysis of the MEK-soaked chip.

Except the pre-soak XEDS spectrogram in fig. 14, the before/after SE image in fig. 12, the BSE and XEDS maps of the chip post-soak in fig. 15, and the spectrograms of the particular element-rich areas in figs. 16, 17 and 18, and accompanying analysis demonstrating the presence of elemental Al as well as Fe2O3. Except that, you're right.

In figure 10 the Al appears bound to the Si and the O. The platelets they form correspond to kaolinite, as some people have shown repeatedly here.

So, are you claiming that MEK produces a chemical reaction that releases the Al from the Si? Or are you claiming that since the MEK-soaked chip definitely had elemental Al in it, that it must therefore be different from the other samples?

In all, the only proof that the Al is not bound to the Si appears in a chip not thoroughly analyzed nor cleaned whose nature we don't know. They shouldn't extrapolate the conclusion that Al is not bound to Si to the other chips. By their logic, in figure 15 the O is bound to the Si and the Fe is free, so there's silicon oxide but no iron oxide, thus no thermite.

How do you get that from their logic? The XEDS data from silicon-rich areas show more Si than O (fig. 16). It's certainly not SiO2. What are you claiming it is?

Just another sloppiness of many. Happens when you have decided a conclusion and are blind to indications that point in a different direction.

Hello Mr. Pot... Have you met Mr. Kettle?


.
 
And don't forget that the thermite is necessary because there were no explosions heard, except that even Jones had to admit that there couldn't have been enough thermite to bring the buildings down, so it was used as a detonater for conventional explosives, which weren't heard, but that's OK, because there was thermite, which is necessary because....

It helps if you don't think about it too much.



It may be best to keep your claims of "no explosions heard" to another thread as they are neither true nor relevant to the substances in question as examined in the Harrit/Farrer/Jones paper.

Do you want to discuss the paper or do you want to speculate about logistical concerns? Either way, the substance in question does not go away.


.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom