Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Did Jones and company ever try to ignite it in an inert gas environment. I know there was talk of this. Seems to me this would be test number one for this type of stuff.

Jay Howard. do you know?

Nope, I sure don't.


.
 
Well now there is something.

Perhaps it was their failure to obtain the exact paints used in the WTC, paint them on steel columns, leave them or age them for corrosion and other natural effects, then super heat them, then take chips and compare those to their "mystery" chips. Given that is MUCH MORE PLAUSIBLE as a source of their chips, would that not seem like the most scientific thing to do? the most intellectually HONEST thing to do?

Fair enough. So if this comparison showed conclusively that the red/gray chips were indeed different from the paint chips, would that be enough to concede that whatever these chips were, they were not likely paint chips?

Perhaps it was their almost negligible attempt to eliminate anything else as the source of their chips, but rather, spend most of their time and investigation TRY TO PROVE the chips WERE THERMITE.

Does matter to the spectroscopy instrument what conclusion they were looking for? Does it matter to the calorimeter? Like I said earlier, if you think they are simply making stuff up, then there is certainly no need to talk further. However, if you think they aren't lying, and the analysis in the paper is indeed about these questionable chips in the dust, then the question remains: why is it unacceptable? Why is their analysis unscientific?

Sure, I agree they should have tried to examine known paint chips from the WTC wreckage, and they should have soaked that paint, among others, in the MEK for comparison. However, it is unclear to me how that consideration can invalidate XEDS spectrograms or maps or the DSC data.

Perhaps it was their failure to insure any kind of reasonable CHAIN OF CUSTODY. Perhaps you can ask henryco here on this forum, while his subsequent investigations of dust samples failed to produce the Jones results...

They go into a fair amount of detail regarding when, where, how and who gathered the samples. They even excluded a sample because the holder did not agree to have his/her name released for verification. What then, is the issue with the chain of custody of the samples?

So much wrong with the paper, with the investigation. I am but a laymen with this stuff, and even I can see the faults within it. Sunstealer and Mackey can and have torn it to shreds.

You are not bringing anything new to the table, so what is there to address?

TAM:)

I have yet to read a coherent reason for dismissing the data in the paper. Yes, I've read Sunstealer's analysis. SS must dismiss the data gathered from the MEK-soaked chip in order to claim that the material is in a kaolinite matrix. That is, unless SS is claiming that the MEK caused a reaction by which the Al became unbound, elemental Al. Is that how you read his analysis?


.
 
I'm pointing out that no one can or should take this claim seriously. It is not a scientific claim. No one with any scientific expertise with thermite has ever commented on it. It holds the same status as claims about Sasquatch or the Loch Ness monster - maybe less.

What is your definition (not just example) of a "scientific claim"? The standard one is something like this: "a scientific claim is a testable claim." Which is exactly why claims about sasquatch and Directed Energy Weapons are not scientific.

If a person makes a claim that nuclear weapons brought down the WTC towers, then one can test that claim by doing some analysis on the background radiation levels. Hence, that is a scientific claim. It is an incorrect scientific claim. And it is unmistakeably demonstrated to be wrong with some fairly simple tests.

What's interesting about this paper is that it makes somewhat risky predictions about the substance at hand. For the material in question to be considered "thermitic" it should have a couple of very well known properties and contents. The researchers demonstrate that it contains Fe2O3, elemental Al and it is highly energetic at unexpectedly low temperatures.

What's more interesting and unexpected is that the reaction results in iron and silicon-based microspheres. This adds weight to the earlier work done by Jones and corroborated by RJ Lee and the USGS on the iron-based microspheres which everyone here thought was pointless at the time. (Some here even tried to rationalize the existence of the microspheres as heat-reduced blood!)

Theories that make trivial predictions are trivial theories: i.e., "you will breath in the next 4 minutes." However, theories that make risky predictions, i.e., "there should be explosive residues in the WTC dust," are much more powerful theories.


.
 
It fully follows. When you use BAD sampling, BAD controls, and have over 20 methodological errors, can you in all honesty state that you can take any of their findings or conclusions at face value? Of course not.

In a "paper" riddled with methodological errors like this one, how can you honestly with a straight face try to take ANY of their conclusions at face value? If they botch it that badly, what is to say they didn't botch other parts or fudge the data? Absolutely NOTHING.

In papers riddled with methodological errors, the best thing, the ONLY thing to do is scrap the paper and do it again.



Again and again you want to try to equate this piss poor scientifically invalid "paper" with real science. Do it again. Get it done at independent labs or do it right. But realize that this is a craptacular fail and stop trying to use it for the basis of any argument. Go back to school and take just one decent experimental design course. Try again.



Again and again. With bad controls, bad samples, and over 20 methodological errors you cannot draw ANY conclusions from this "paper." What part of that is sooooo difficult to understand?

This isn't a "Yes the science is crap, but look at page 2 they say this..." because the first part invalidates the rest.

Right. 20 methodological errors. But you never answered my question: Does the XEDS analysis care if they used a poor control paint in the MEK soak? Do the x-rays somehow know it's poor methodology and therefore refuse to produce accurate spectrum data?



.
 
It may be best to keep your claims of "no explosions heard" to another thread as they are neither true nor relevant to the substances in question as examined in the Harrit/Farrer/Jones paper.

Oh, they're relevant all right.

What you here are two sides, one of which has what you call the "Official Theory", which is in fact the ONLY theory about what happened on 9/11. On the other side you've got what we call in the software development business a "Big Ball of Mud".

This ragtag collection of misfit hypotheses, of which Jones' "theory" about thermite is one, is made of of ideas that have zero utility in the real world. That is, they don't explain anything about anything...they just provide the hope that, if true, they will somehow point to the "official theory" (the ONLY theory, remember) as being somehow wrong, and by default, the nonsensical jumble of null-hypotheses being correct.

This reveals the themite story, and the Silverstein insurance scam story, and the NORAD stand-down story, and all the other idiotic truther notions to be products of a bass-ackward process in which the fervant hope that the US government is somehow responsible comes first, and whatever cognitive process truthers use comes second.

So, yeah, they're relevant. And true, too.
 
What is your definition (not just example) of a "scientific claim"? The standard one is something like this: "a scientific claim is a testable claim." Which is exactly why claims about sasquatch and Directed Energy Weapons are not scientific.

If a person makes a claim that nuclear weapons brought down the WTC towers, then one can test that claim by doing some analysis on the background radiation levels. Hence, that is a scientific claim. It is an incorrect scientific claim. And it is unmistakeably demonstrated to be wrong with some fairly simple tests.

What's interesting about this paper is that it makes somewhat risky predictions about the substance at hand. For the material in question to be considered "thermitic" it should have a couple of very well known properties and contents. The researchers demonstrate that it contains Fe2O3, elemental Al and it is highly energetic at unexpectedly low temperatures.

What's more interesting and unexpected is that the reaction results in iron and silicon-based microspheres. This adds weight to the earlier work done by Jones and corroborated by RJ Lee and the USGS on the iron-based microspheres which everyone here thought was pointless at the time. (Some here even tried to rationalize the existence of the microspheres as heat-reduced blood!)

Theories that make trivial predictions are trivial theories: i.e., "you will breath in the next 4 minutes." However, theories that make risky predictions, i.e., "there should be explosive residues in the WTC dust," are much more powerful theories..

"it is highly energetic at unexpectedly low temperatures." Did you pull that out of Jones cold fusion paper, because it makes about enough sense here as it did there.

You yourself said "For the material in question to be considered "thermitic" it should have a couple of very well known properties and contents." One of those properties is that it should not release more energy than thermite could theoretically release. And Jonesy and the boys proved that it did so. Science conclusion: Not thermite. Jones conclusion: super magic thermite. What a joke.

And I’ll ask you to keep your comments about what you think is "relevant" to yourself, sport. Last time I checked, I posted this thread, and you can be damn sure that I think Jones backing off his claim of the amount and use of the "super thermite" is relevant.
 
jay howard said:
pgimeno said:
In all, the only proof that the Al is not bound to the Si appears in a chip not thoroughly analyzed nor cleaned whose nature we don't know. They shouldn't extrapolate the conclusion that Al is not bound to Si to the other chips. By their logic, in figure 15 the O is bound to the Si and the Fe is free, so there's silicon oxide but no iron oxide, thus no thermite.
How do you get that from their logic? The XEDS data from silicon-rich areas show more Si than O (fig. 16). It's certainly not SiO2. What are you claiming it is?

I should clarify that it is possible that the matrix in question (the post-MEK soaked chip) does contain SiO2, as the XEDS maps are qualitative in nature. The Fe and O maps also overlap considerably. Without doubt, and more importantly, there is elemental Al in the post-MEK sample, and unless someone is speculating that the MEK caused a reaction whereby the Al separated from the Si. If not, then there is no reason to doubt the existence of elemental Al in the other samples.

.
 
Oh, they're relevant all right.

What you here are two sides, one of which has what you call the "Official Theory", which is in fact the ONLY theory about what happened on 9/11. On the other side you've got what we call in the software development business a "Big Ball of Mud".

This ragtag collection of misfit hypotheses, of which Jones' "theory" about thermite is one, is made of of ideas that have zero utility in the real world. That is, they don't explain anything about anything...they just provide the hope that, if true, they will somehow point to the "official theory" (the ONLY theory, remember) as being somehow wrong, and by default, the nonsensical jumble of null-hypotheses being correct.

This reveals the themite story, and the Silverstein insurance scam story, and the NORAD stand-down story, and all the other idiotic truther notions to be products of a bass-ackward process in which the fervant hope that the US government is somehow responsible comes first, and whatever cognitive process truthers use comes second.

So, yeah, they're relevant. And true, too.


Well, that sounds like a real interesting conversation, but it's not what this thread is about--at least not what I'm going to entertain. So have fun.


.
 
So, except samples 1, 2, 3, and 4, all the samples are different... Did you read this paper? Did you even skim it? In that time did you notice that there are only 4 samples of dust? Did you see the corresponding XEDS spectrum data that show the similarities in elemental composition by weight? Then the corresponding SE and BSE images to compare the morphology?

Please explain on what grounds you make the claim that all the chips are different? Or why you think the MEK soaked chip is different--other than the red layer expands during the 55 hour soak.
The MEK-soaked chip is not one of samples 1, 2, 3 or 4:

The chip that was used for this experiment was extracted from dust sample 2 and is shown in the images below.
The pre-soaking XEDS spectrum in figure 14 shows different elements to the ones found in fig 7 and in different proportions. They claim surface contamination from the chip because they didn't cut it, but that doesn't explain all of the elements found, plus they can't reach proper conclusions with a dirty chip, plus they don't show the contamination.

The chip in figure 31 is different too. Sunstealer made a classification of the data in the paper here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4687714&postcount=221 - I recommend you to read and understand it. A couple excerpts:

How many people realise that there are atleast 10 samples discussed in the paper? Many of these samples are different in character.

Red layer MEK chip ≠ a, b, c, d.

We know that the MEK chip was looked at in the SEM. We know the composition of the red layer is vastly different. So why are we not shown a detailed SEM image that shows that this red layer is exactly the same as for chips a,b,c,d? They claim contamination, but provide no proof of contamination. This is not professional. We could easily rule out Tnemec paint as the source because this MEK chip would not contain talc or ZnCrO4. We are not shown a detailed SEM image of this MEK chip's red layer, instead they claim it to be the same and wave anything else away as contamination. That's unprofessional. Show us the contamination with a SEM image.


Except the pre-soak XEDS spectrogram in fig. 14, the before/after SE image in fig. 12, the BSE and XEDS maps of the chip post-soak in fig. 15, and the spectrograms of the particular element-rich areas in figs. 16, 17 and 18, and accompanying analysis demonstrating the presence of elemental Al as well as Fe2O3. Except that, you're right.
Sorry, I meant *prior* to the MEK soaking: something that proves that the chip is similar to those previously analyzed. There's just the SE images in fig. 12 and the XEDS spectrum in figure 14. No serious reason to think they are the same thing, notably given fig 14 vs fig 7. The lack of a previous characterization of all the samples used is a serious issue.

As for the Fe2O3, they claim:

Oxygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron in the red material even after soaking in MEK solvent (Fig. 15), and in Fig. (18) an abundance of oxygen is found relative to iron.
Yet figure 15 shows no apparent correlation between Fe and O as compared to e.g. Si and O. Even Al and O are more correlated in figure 15 than Fe and O. That makes one wonder if figure 18 has been cherry-picked.

So, are you claiming that MEK produces a chemical reaction that releases the Al from the Si? Or are you claiming that since the MEK-soaked chip definitely had elemental Al in it, that it must therefore be different from the other samples?
I am claiming that the chip taken for MEK soaking can perfectly come from a different source and they don't prove it comes from the same source. Fig. 31 proves that there are chips of a very different nature among their samples, so the lack of prior in-depth examination of the MEK-soaked chip or even the failure to use one of the samples 1-4 for MEK soaking is sloppy at best. The XEDS spectrum of that chip has clear differences to those in samples 1-4, pointing to a strong difference in nature.

How do you get that from their logic? The XEDS data from silicon-rich areas show more Si than O (fig. 16). It's certainly not SiO2. What are you claiming it is?
I'm not sure what it IS, probably a compound with silicon and oxygen or other oxidized compounds not shown and free silicon, you can't really tell with so little data. I care what it is NOT though. That's definitely not iron oxide. Definitely not the same as in chips 1-4. Sunstealer in that post points that there is some hint of zinc chromate in the XEDS spectrum, which could explain a significant part of the oxygen. Too many possibilities to enumerate them all with that little data.
 
jay, instead of taking your ball and going home again, why don't you reply to tfk's rather substantive post? :)
 
Gee Jay,

I'm feeling neglected.

You answered everyone else except me.

Any reason for that?

Tom
 
What is your definition (not just example) of a "scientific claim"? The standard one is something like this: "a scientific claim is a testable claim." Which is exactly why claims about sasquatch and Directed Energy Weapons are not scientific.

If a person makes a claim that nuclear weapons brought down the WTC towers, then one can test that claim by doing some analysis on the background radiation levels. Hence, that is a scientific claim. It is an incorrect scientific claim. And it is unmistakeably demonstrated to be wrong with some fairly simple tests.

What's interesting about this paper is that it makes somewhat risky predictions about the substance at hand. For the material in question to be considered "thermitic" it should have a couple of very well known properties and contents. The researchers demonstrate that it contains Fe2O3, elemental Al and it is highly energetic at unexpectedly low temperatures.

What's more interesting and unexpected is that the reaction results in iron and silicon-based microspheres. This adds weight to the earlier work done by Jones and corroborated by RJ Lee and the USGS on the iron-based microspheres which everyone here thought was pointless at the time. (Some here even tried to rationalize the existence of the microspheres as heat-reduced blood!)

Theories that make trivial predictions are trivial theories: i.e., "you will breath in the next 4 minutes." However, theories that make risky predictions, i.e., "there should be explosive residues in the WTC dust," are much more powerful theories.
.

I suggest you read a little bit more widely about the nature of science. For example, the definition for science that you present is the one proposed by Karl Popper and while widely used and probably necessary for any 'scientific' claims, is hardly a sufficient definition. If this is the sufficient definition for science you're working from, I can understand why you come across as confused. A more important aspect of science in our case is whether or not you expect to be taken seriously. I guess neither you nor any making claims of thermite at the WTC care about this.

You're right. There's probably not much more we can talk about. Good luck with your hobby.
 
Right. 20 methodological errors. But you never answered my question: Does the XEDS analysis care if they used a poor control paint in the MEK soak? Do the x-rays somehow know it's poor methodology and therefore refuse to produce accurate spectrum data?
.

Right.

Thank you for agreeing that there are 20 methodologial errors in this "paper."

Now with REAL science, you scrap the JUNK and start again.

Your question is attempting to argue the details of a FLAWED "PAPER." As such any answer is not valid.

Start OVER. Throw the JUNK in the circular bin and do REAL science.

The POOR methodology combined with people who are OUTSIDE of their area of expertise and education call into question ALL of their tests. Try again.

My theory that MOTHRA did it has just as much science backing it up and superduper clean your room make your lunch nanothermite.
 
I should clarify that it is possible that the matrix in question (the post-MEK soaked chip) does contain SiO2, as the XEDS maps are qualitative in nature. The Fe and O maps also overlap considerably. Without doubt, and more importantly, there is elemental Al in the post-MEK sample, and unless someone is speculating that the MEK caused a reaction whereby the Al separated from the Si. If not, then there is no reason to doubt the existence of elemental Al in the other samples.

.

What does any of this matter? Ignoring the fact that Jones and Harrit's methodologies are so sloppy that they do not support their conclusions, and ignoring the fact that they were not able to get mainstream journal publication, what does any of what you're pointing out matter? The fact remains that, even if they were correct, even if thermite was indeed at Ground Zero, it had no effect. How do we know this? NCSTAR 1-3C. It contains an inventory and description of the recovered steel. Take a look at core column # 603 (C-80) from WTC 1. It was identified as having been within the zone where the collapse initiated; it spanned from the 92nd to the 95th floor. There are even pictures of it on page 201. Find the thermite induced melting on that column. It was in the collapse initiation zone, after all. Ditto column 605 (HH): It, too was from within the collapse initiation zone, it too is photographed. Find the melting. How about column 801 (C-88a) from WTC-2's collapse initiation zone? These are failed columns that were key to the collapses because they were the ones in the areas where the collapses started. And none of them show any signs of thermite use on them.

And that's just the core columns. Other steel structural pieces were recovered.

So tell me: Why am I supposed to believe that thermite was actually used when recovered failed columns show no signs of their use? Those columns were involved in the start of the collapse, yet all they show are signs of mechanical forcing, not incendiary-caused melting. So what do the point issues of the Jones and Harrit paper matter when it's patently obvious that the actual structural elements they were supposedly used on show no signs of thermite melting whatsoever? Even if we conceded the ridiculous position that thermite was indeed present, it quite obviously had zero effect, because the first columns that failed in the towers collapses do not show signs of thermite melting at all. Your points about Jones, Harrit, et. al. are nothing more than miniscule issues about those researchers writings; they had zero impact on how the towers actually collapsed.
 
Jay;

in the end, you seem to be claiming that while we have validly pointed out MANY flaws within the paper, from a scientific pov, from a methods pov, that the essence of the paper is the collection of Spectroscopy outputs and calorimeter outputs.

The problem is those outputs are completely useless with such poor science and scientific method surrounding them. Without a proper chain of custody, detailing where the samples were, how they were handled/stored, and by who for every step of the way, the samples are useless, as they could have been tampered with and/or spoiled.

Without a thorough attempt to rule out other sources of the chips, many of which are MORE LIKELY sources of said chips, they have clearly shown (A) their lack of respect for, and (B) their lack of desire for, the scientific method, and forensic investigation in general.

Without providing their samples, with a valid and thorough account of chain of custody, to an independent (truly independent, not their associates, not someone they discussed the topic with online, and not with someone who KNOWS WHAT THEY ARE LOOKING FOR IN THE DUST) lab for analysis, their results are NOT REPEATABLE, which throws out the window yet another fundamental of scientific research.

SO you see, those spectroscopy outputs you find so fascinating, are useless without the rest. I could provide you with similar spectroscopy outputs and you would never know where I got them, or how, or anything else about them, yet they would be JUST AS INTERESTING standing on their own, if I simply said, I GOT THEM FROM A SAMPLE OF WTC dust.

Sorry, but I am gonna have to go with the dozens of other WTC dust Analysis that found fiber, gypsum, organics, and paint, but NO THERMITE, done by professional labs unaffiliated with each other, and without agenda.

oh and by the way, IIRC, one of the reasons why Jones eventually had to admit that the only way his "thermite chips" theory was plausible was if the thermite was used as FUSES for conventional explosives, is because Dr. Greening, Mackey, and others, proved to him that it would require over 100 layers of his alleged spray on thermite (based on the thickness of the "exothermic layer" of his chips) to bring the steel to a temperature anywhere close to softening it.

TAM:)
 
What is your definition (not just example) of a "scientific claim"? The standard one is something like this: "a scientific claim is a testable claim." Which is exactly why claims about sasquatch and Directed Energy Weapons are not scientific.

Just to clarify: for a testable claim to exist, there must first be a claim. Harrit and Jones have not articulated a coherent claim that makes even superficial sense. They have not proposed a realistic mechanism by which a very thin coating of thermite on structural members could produce a failure corresponding to the observations made of the collapses of the Twin Towers; in fact, it seems they cannot even agree on the fundamentals of the claim.

And, to return to the original premise of the more recent part of this thread, it's irrelevant to the validity of Harrit et al's conclusions whether the material is paint. What it is not, is a substance which could withstand the temperatures produced by the jet fuel deflagration and contents fire, and then produce the observed failures of the Twin Towers. The authors' own data makes this quite clear. Therefore, it is irrelevant to the cause of the collapses.

Dave
 
The thermitic chips in the WTC dust IGNITED at about 430C.

No, something ignited at about 430 oC.

For the millionth time, since the experiement was executed in an atmosphere with oxygen present this is in no way an indication of thermite. Thermite can react in absence of oxygen and if Jones et al were loooking for thermite they should have done it in a nitrogen- or argon-atmosphere. Perhaps an honest mistake, but a stupid one and it clearly shows that the authors are incompetent at this kind of analysis.

Another thing that has not been mentioned often is that they used a heating rate that is way too fast. 10 oC/min is a rate you use when you are dealing with samples of known material and in circumstances where you use it as a quality control and don't have time for a slower rate.
When dealing with an unknown compound you should probably go as low as 0.5 oC/min.
When the heating rate is too fast the result may be that the recorded ignition temperature is too high.

But don't take my word for it. Contact R&D Carbon in Switzerland and ask them why they sell their air-reactivity apparatuses (basically specialized calorimeters) with two different heating rates pre-programmed (10 oC/min and 0.5 oC/min.)
http://www.rd-carbon.com/contact.html
 
Well, that sounds like a real interesting conversation, but it's not what this thread is about--at least not what I'm going to entertain. So have fun.


.

If you don't see the relevance, then obviously I haven't made myself clear. Fair enough.

The posts that YOU have made in this thread are an attempt to prove the presence of thermite at the WTC on 9/11. Correct?

What I'm saying is that even if you have proven this (you haven't), it amounts to precisely nothing.

That's because you have no idea how to get from "thermite was there" to "inside job".

Supposing you proved beyond the shadow of a doubt that magic lollipops were present on 9/11. What does that mean?

You have no idea. You have no theory about what happened on 9/11.

If you proved beyond the shadow of a doubt that thermite was present on 9/11, what does that mean?

You have no idea. YOU HAVE NO THEORY ABOUT 9/11.

Neither you nor the brightest minds in the truth movement, towering intellects such as Jones and Fetzer and Griffin, have been able to come up with a coherent narrative that is consistent with the "mountain of evidence" they claim to have produced.

Is it clear now?
 
"it is highly energetic at unexpectedly low temperatures." Did you pull that out of Jones cold fusion paper, because it makes about enough sense here as it did there.

You yourself said "For the material in question to be considered "thermitic" it should have a couple of very well known properties and contents." One of those properties is that it should not release more energy than thermite could theoretically release. And Jonesy and the boys proved that it did so. Science conclusion: Not thermite. Jones conclusion: super magic thermite. What a joke.

And I’ll ask you to keep your comments about what you think is "relevant" to yourself, sport. Last time I checked, I posted this thread, and you can be damn sure that I think Jones backing off his claim of the amount and use of the "super thermite" is relevant.


So Harrit/Farrer/Jones have come across a material that is undoubtedly highly energetic and which is undergoing a kind of aluminothermic reaction, but because it's more energetic than typical thermite, they are thus refuted.

It's too explosive to be thermite.

Therefore there's no need to look any further. We can discard their research as pointless and "conspiratorial."

Just want to make sure I'm following you.



.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom