Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Exactly. There's no evidence of free (elemental) aluminum.

The reason the aluminum is in flat hexagonal plates is because that is a crystalline form of aluminum oxide, found in many, many, many minerals. Including those used in paint.

No elemental aluminum, no thermite, nano- or otherwise.

Please join me in ignoring Truthers. They've demonstrated that they either will not or cannot learn, and I don't know which is sadder.


Ryan, if you would like to have a real discussion about this, then we need to agree about basic premises.

Unless you found something wrong with the XEDS analysis of the post-MEK chip, then there is no way to claim that elemental Al was NOT found.


The next XEDS spectrum (Fig. 17) was acquired from a region that showed a high concentration of aluminum. Using a conventional quantification routine, it was found that the aluminum significantly exceeded the oxygen present (approximately a 3:1 ratio). Thus, while some of the aluminum may be oxidized, there is insufficient oxygen present to account for all of the aluminum; some aluminum must therefore exist in elemental form in the red material.
pg. 18 (my emphasis)

What have they done wrong that they cannot make this claim?


.
.
 
I don't want to have a real discussion about this. I already had one. Your side didn't understand it, and further discussion is futile. Your nonsense reply above only bolsters this impression. That's why I am Ignoring you.

I'm breaking cover just this once to clear that up for you, but that's it. Don't bother replying to me again, not here, not ever.
 
Ryan, if you would like to have a real discussion about this, then we need to agree about basic premises.

Unless you found something wrong with the XEDS analysis of the post-MEK chip, then there is no way to claim that elemental Al was NOT found.


pg. 18 (my emphasis)

What have they done wrong that they cannot make this claim?


.
.

YOu have already been linked to Sunstealers excellent debunking of this bs claim. Try to read for comprehension.

AGain and again. The simple answer is that there are over 20 methodological ERRORS in this "paper." As such, none of the findings or conclusions are valid. The entire "paper" is crap. So why don't you start over, with a new paper from scratch and do the science. It should only take a few months. You've had the time. Try again.
 
Is that a yes or a no: you believe that if they just used the right manufacturer that the paint/primer would NOT dissolve in the MEK?


How can you compare a stadium paint (which is a different manufacturer, different color, and different composition) to your sample? YOU CAN'T. It is a bad control. Bad control = bad science.


Right. But you can compare the Hindenberg and there's no problem there, huh?
 
I don't want to have a real discussion about this. I already had one. Your side didn't understand it, and further discussion is futile. Your nonsense reply above only bolsters this impression. That's why I am Ignoring you.

I'm breaking cover just this once to clear that up for you, but that's it. Don't bother replying to me again, not here, not ever.



Why do you always announce that you're going to ignore someone. Just ignore me, please.


.
 
YOu have already been linked to Sunstealers excellent debunking of this bs claim. Try to read for comprehension.

AGain and again. The simple answer is that there are over 20 methodological ERRORS in this "paper." As such, none of the findings or conclusions are valid. The entire "paper" is crap. So why don't you start over, with a new paper from scratch and do the science. It should only take a few months. You've had the time. Try again.



So you too are a believer that MEK can cause a chemical reaction that can reduce aluminosilicates to Al and a Si compound?

Please, give me a science lesson that doesn't involve linking to a paper you've never read.


.
 
Reading for comprehension is not your strong suit eh?

Is that a yes or a no: you believe that if they just used the right manufacturer that the paint/primer would NOT dissolve in the MEK?

that is a "do the science right and we can have this discussion." If you use a bad control, you invalidate all of your findings.

what part of that do you NOT understand? is it the, if? you? use? a? bad? control? you? invalidate? all? of? your? findings?

What part of that is soooo hard that you must try to dodge around and try to make this pseudo scientific claptrap somewhat legitimate? It isn't and we both know it.

Right. But you can compare the Hindenberg and there's no problem there, huh?

Go back and read where the hindenberg comment comes from. Reading for comprehension isn't your strong suit is it? It is called the law of unintended consequences.... Look it up and try to read for comprehension.
 
So you too are a believer that MEK can cause a chemical reaction that can reduce aluminosilicates to Al and a Si compound?

Please, give me a science lesson that doesn't involve linking to a paper you've never read.


.

I've read the "paper" repeatedly. And I keep getting tripped up on those 20 methodological errors which completely invalidate any findings.

What part of that do you not understand?

Do it again and remove those methodological errors, and we can talk. Why do you insist on dodging those methodological errors?
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4628585&postcount=86
Why the Silicon and any other element (except O)? Engineered aluminium nanoparticles are 99% pure (commercial pure) so why do we have all the junk in it? Secondly that EDS and the SEM photos clearly show that the platelets are comprised of an aluminosilicate. Can't be anything else. They try to get around this by soaking a completely different sample in MEK and say they found "elemental Al" but they don't show any detailed SEM images of the red layer for that chip. So where are the Al particles? They just aren't there. Their own data shows that.
 
It goes completely unsaid in all of this there is an entire thermite research community in the United States and the World. Strangely, there is not only a failure to consult them, there existance in this debate has gone completely ignored. There are entire journals dedicated to related matters, such as the journal
Combustion Science and Technology
Combustion Theory and Modelling
These are a Francis & Taylor journals and are very high status. Publication in such a venue would not be questioned.

From a purely academic point of view, if I were Steven Jones or any of his lackies, I would submit a paper to the kind of conferences where research on thermite is discussed. I can suggest some names, if jay howard finds this helpful.

I can list many more journals and conferences that are far more appropriate venues to settle this problem than the James Randi Forum which has no status whatsoever as a scientific venue. In fact, I would go so far as to say that discussion about this are a complete waste of time and show that the people involved are not really interested in an answer. Of course that is the case for the regular crowd who post here only a hobby. If Dr. Jones and his crew believe this is a serious topic they should take the discussion elsewhere, otherwise an observer would be left to conclude that for them it is also only a hobby.
 
Last edited:
Can anyone back up the claim that the chips were just paint?

Since nobody can back up the claim that they were nanothermite, since it's been shown that they couldn't have had any significant effect if they had been nanothermite, and since the simple fact that they ignited at 430ºC is irrefutable proof that they cannot have remained unignited by the fires in the regions where the collapse initiated, asking for proof they were paint is the logical fallacy known as "shifting the burden of proof". It doesn't really matter what they were; they cannot possibly have played any significant part in the collapses of the Twin Towers, therefore they are irrelevant to any discussion of the causes of those collapses.

Dave
 
I've read the "paper" repeatedly. And I keep getting tripped up on those 20 methodological errors which completely invalidate any findings.

What part of that do you not understand?

Do it again and remove those methodological errors, and we can talk. Why do you insist on dodging those methodological errors?

It's not that im ignoring you, it's that your claim that because there are errors you can dismiss all the findings in the paper, does not follow.

It's a good point that they didn't use the same paint as was in the towers. As I asked above, do you think the paint from the towers would NOT dissolve or become soft? Does the XEDS analysis care if they used a poor control paint in the MEK soak? Do the x-rays somehow know it's poor methodology and therefore refuse to produce accurate spectrum data?

Did you find something wrong with the acquisition or analysis of the spectrum data?


.
 
It goes completely unsaid in all of this there is an entire thermite research community in the United States and the World. Strangely, there is not only a failure to consult them, there existance in this debate has gone completely ignored. There are entire journals dedicated to related matters, such as the journal
Combustion Science and Technology
Combustion Theory and Modelling
These are a Francis & Taylor journals and are very high status. Publication in such a venue would not be questioned.

From a purely academic point of view, if I were Steven Jones or any of his lackies, I would submit a paper to the kind of conferences where research on thermite is discussed. I can suggest some names, if jay howard finds this helpful.

I can list many more journals and conferences that are far more appropriate venues to settle this problem than the James Randi Forum which has no status whatsoever as a scientific venue. In fact, I would go so far as to say that discussion about this are a complete waste of time and show that the people involved are not really interested in an answer. Of course that is the case for the regular crowd who post here only a hobby. If Dr. Jones and his crew believe this is a serious topic they should take the discussion elsewhere, otherwise an observer would be left to conclude that for them it is also only a hobby.

If you don't want to have this discussion, then by all means, don't have it. But encouraging others not[/n] to have it because we're not experts in nano-energetic materials is ridiculous and pointless.

I find it amusing that this sub-forum has become a lightening rod for debunkers, yet suddenly the topic is no longer appropriate for JREF because we lack expertise? There's certainly a lot of bull that passes for science on both sides of this debate, however, Farrer, Harrit, Jones, et. al. have written this paper in an accessible way. If you think their paper contains unfounded conclusions, then this is your chance to demonstrate that.


.
 
Since nobody can back up the claim that they were nanothermite, since it's been shown that they couldn't have had any significant effect if they had been nanothermite, and since the simple fact that they ignited at 430ºC is irrefutable proof that they cannot have remained unignited by the fires in the regions where the collapse initiated, asking for proof they were paint is the logical fallacy known as "shifting the burden of proof". It doesn't really matter what they were; they cannot possibly have played any significant part in the collapses of the Twin Towers, therefore they are irrelevant to any discussion of the causes of those collapses.

Dave

This is another attempt to say that since no one can explain how it was used, we can dismiss it.

What's interesting about this attempt this line of reasoning is that we all agree the WTC fell because of arson. No one here can meaningfully say that wasn't a case of arson. The only debate is the sources of energy involved.

Now that some very unusual highly energetic material was found, why should anyone interested not want to look into it?

What could be gained from not looking into it?

Why would someone even entertain that idea?

I don't know how the stuff was used. The authors of the paper don't know how it was used. That doesn't make it go away.


.
 
Let me see, we have the following,

Buildings full of painted columns etc...collapses into huge pile. Thousands of people witness the jet airliners strike the buildings an hour or so prior to collapse. Years later, samples of alleged dust from GZ are submitted to the authors with a weak chain of custody record, at best, for analysis.

Now what do you think should be the focus of such an analysis?

(A) an unbias, scientific analysis of the dust contents, with ALL POSSIBLE contents ruled in or out,

OR

(B) a hunt for thermite?

You wanna talk unscientific, truther "scientists" wrote the book on that.

Funny how numerous other studies and analysis of the WTC dust have been done, and paint is mentioned as a component in many of them, yet never a mention of "thermite" or some "exothermic explosive/incidiary" or the like. Funny that.

TAM;)
 
Ryan, if you would like to have a real discussion about this, then we need to agree about basic premises.

Unless you found something wrong with the XEDS analysis of the post-MEK chip, then there is no way to claim that elemental Al was NOT found.


pg. 18 (my emphasis)

What have they done wrong that they cannot make this claim?


.
.
See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4682006&postcount=188

In short:

Given that we don't know anything about this chip prior to it's soaking in MEK then i don't know why it's in the paper.
 
So you too are a believer that MEK can cause a chemical reaction that can reduce aluminosilicates to Al and a Si compound?

Please, give me a science lesson that doesn't involve linking to a paper you've never read.


.

Even if you are somehow correct, and the paint chips are indeed thermite, you still have no convergence of evidence. All you have is a curiosity that doesn't fit into any coherent theory.

Unless you'd like to offer one. No? I didn't think so.
 
Even if you are somehow correct, and the paint chips are indeed thermite, you still have no convergence of evidence. All you have is a curiosity that doesn't fit into any coherent theory.

Unless you'd like to offer one. No? I didn't think so.

According to Jones himself, the Thermite was most likely just used in the detonation fuses for more traditional explosives (See several threads on this suggestion he made on another forum as provided by email exchanges between Jones and Dr. Frank Greening about 1 year ago).

That said, given their obsession verging on insanity with this issue, given the investment in what little reputation the authors have in this, I would not doubt for a moment that they are capable not only of MANIPULATING the data, but actually FORGING/MANUFACTURING data to suite their hypothesis. At the very least the authors are guilty of (A) poor science, and (B) Severe (near blinding) bias.

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom