Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Yea, I read that. Kaolinite has both Al and Si, however, they are bound. Are you suggesting that MEK caused a reaction that unbound the Al from the Si?


.
 
I like how the OP begins. Its literally like the continuation of a paragraph from a 6 month old thread.

Truthers are funny. They make me giggle.
 
So the very scientific, skeptical "debunkers" accept without any question that soaking something in MEK can actually separate aluminum silicates into elemental Al and a silicon compound? Seriously? This kind of non-reasoning counts as "skepticism" here at JREF?

Anyone want to buy some spoon bending DVD's? You can do it too! Only $17.99 plus shipping. Results may vary, and by "vary" i mean they may not happen at all, at all.


.
 
There was indeed elemental Al found in the samples. They didn't soak all the samples in MEK. Nor did they ignite all the samples. The sample that was soaked in MEK demonstrated that the Al migrated during the soaking period and the Si did not. They were not bound.
 
Jay might be on to something here.I just set fire to a piece of steel wool with an ordinary lighter and small blobs of red hot metal were formed.

Why would anybody make a skyscraper out of a material that ignites at such a low temperature.This conspiracy must go back to the construction !!.


;)
 
Last edited:
The ways this topic is treated demonstrate well the unscientific habits that debunkers here participate in.

Hey pot, it is the kettle... you are black. A truther talking about "unscientific habits" is rather ironic.

Over 20 methodological errors in this "paper." Those errors invalidate ALL of the findings and conclusions of said "paper." That isn't even going into the pay to publish vanity journal which is Bentham.

Try again, with some REAL science.

Why? If the material Harrit, Farrer, Jones, et. al. found is so much nonsense, then why can't it just be handled head-on, without resorting to pretended lacks of understanding, circumstantial ad hominems, and distractions?

Again let me repeat. Over 20 methodological errors in this "paper." It completely invalidates any findings or conclusions drawn. That is science. Try again.

You don't like the journal it's published in? Fine.

You are using a word that you do not understand. It isn't a journal. It is a vanity press, a pay to publish press. It wasn't peer reviewed, it wasn't sent to any type of REAL JOURNAL. Try again

You don't like other things the authors have written? So what?

What else have these authors written that has passed peer review in ANY real journal? Huh?

None of that changes what they found.

What did they find? With over 20 methodological errors in this "paper" it invalidates any findings or conclusions. Very simple. What paints did they use for a control? It isn't mentioned in the paper. We find out later it was BYU stadium paint by a DIFFERENT MANUFACTURER, a DIFFERENT COLOR. So the control is crap. Why was it tested in an oxygen rich envrionment? Thermite burns in a vaccuum. Those are freshman college experimental errors.

The little actual scientific debate of the merits of the research say basically that the chips were paint—DESPITE the fact that paint (especially in the WTC towers) could withstand temperatures of at least 800C.

let me repeat myself. Over 20 major methodological errors completely invalidates any findings or conclusions drawn from this "paper."

Why won't you all submit your samples to an independent lab? Can't afford the $100?

The thermitic chips in the WTC dust IGNITED at about 430C. Not only did they ignite, they formed iron microspheres. Imagine that.
AGain and again. Let me use little words. If you do bad science, you can't use it. Over 20 methodological errors in this "paper" completely invalidate their findings and conclusions. Try again

Does primer ignite at 430C? Can you show me a sample somewhere, anywhere, that ignites at 430C when dry?
I honestly don't know. But you are already making a massive methodological error. We are not talking about unreacted primer paint at 430 C. We are talking about paint chips which were baked in the fires after the collapse, possibly having been in and on fire. So you cannot compare unreacted primer paint with it. Try again.

It would help if you took even a basic science course... and experimental methods course would be better.

Much less a sample that produces metallic iron when ignited?

Oh back to the "iron rich microspheres?" Really? ROFLMAO.

We all know it doesn’t exist. What would be the point? To make a REALLY unsafe primer that ignites at a very achievable office fire temperatures and proceeds to increase BEYOND the melting point of iron?

What was the hindenberg painted in? Oops.
What does the paint chips match? Oh the composition of the primer paint. Doh.

Another standard response to this will no doubt be the uncontrollable urge to turn this into a debate over HOW the thermitic material could possibly have ended up in the towers. Now, that’s not a bad line of inquiry in itself IF it weren’t intended solely to be used as a means to reduce the premise to an absurdity and thus, dismiss it.

Not at all. First you need to prove it was thermitic materials, which you have completely FAILED to do. Why can't you do SIMPLE science? Yet again, over 20 methodological errors in this "paper." Try again. This time with 1. a real journal. 2. with real science. 3. maybe with people who are not working WAY outside of their fields. Better yet, send the samples to a truely INDEPENDENT LAB for analysis. It is like $100. Too much for you all?

I'd love to know how and why it's in the dust. But suggesting that because someone doesn't know exactly how it was used, we can therefore dismiss their scientific findings, is poor reasoning at best.

No. Not even getting that far. So far you all have failed to do competent science, and you are trying to pass of pseudo science to illiterate truthers... It won't pass muster here.

So go back and do real science. Then come back and lets talk. But don't bring up craptacular fail like this.
 
Jay might be on to something here.I just set fire to a piece of steel wool with an ordinary lighter and small blobs of red hot metal were formed.

Why would anybody make a skyscraper out of a material that ignites at such a low temperature.This conspiracy must go back to the construction !!.


;)

So you have some primer that ignites at 800F and produces molten iron? Wow! Sounds like you've got a really valuable lawsuit on your hands!


.
 

Exactly. There's no evidence of free (elemental) aluminum.

The reason the aluminum is in flat hexagonal plates is because that is a crystalline form of aluminum oxide, found in many, many, many minerals. Including those used in paint.

No elemental aluminum, no thermite, nano- or otherwise.

Please join me in ignoring Truthers. They've demonstrated that they either will not or cannot learn, and I don't know which is sadder.
 
So the very scientific, skeptical "debunkers" accept without any question that soaking something in MEK can actually separate aluminum silicates into elemental Al and a silicon compound? Seriously? This kind of non-reasoning counts as "skepticism" here at JREF?

Anyone want to buy some spoon bending DVD's? You can do it too! Only $17.99 plus shipping. Results may vary, and by "vary" i mean they may not happen at all, at all.


.
Thermite used to bring down the WTC is insanity. Is 911 Truth insane?

The red gray chips are fraud to support delusion from failed scientists who have paranoid nut case conspiracy theories; to prove me wrong get published in a real journal and expose your scenario; 99.99 percent of all scientists will pronounce your ideas on 911 as delusions; good for you.

What does not burn at 450 degrees?

Why would you use thermite when fuel has more energy, 10 TIMES more! lol

So paint does not burn? Where do you get this super paint?

What temp does paint burn at, and what are the products? Paper please;

When is your paper being published in a real journal?
 
Last edited:
Jay howard, you have been registered here since 2007. Yet while quickly browsing through all nine pages in the thread I linked to there is not a single post by you in that thread which started in April of 2009. Why not? Will you be posting in that or shall i ask the moderation team to merge this new thread with the one that has all the information in it you request? Or were you hoping we would forget that thread?

here it is again, just so YOU don't forget
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=140017
 
Last edited:
We are not talking about unreacted primer paint at 430 C. We are talking about paint chips which were baked in the fires after the collapse, possibly having been in and on fire. So you cannot compare unreacted primer paint with it. Try again..

I thought they said some woman collected it off her window or some guy found it on a railing or something far away from the collapse zone?
 
What paints did they use for a control? It isn't mentioned in the paper. We find out later it was BYU stadium paint by a DIFFERENT MANUFACTURER, a DIFFERENT COLOR. So the control is crap. Why was it tested in an oxygen rich envrionment? Thermite burns in a vaccuum. Those are freshman college experimental errors.

So you believe that if they just used the right manufacturer that the paint/primer would NOT dissolve in the MEK?

I honestly don't know.

That's refreshing. Really. We shouldn't be afraid to say it when it applies. I will do my best not to be afraid of not knowing either.

But you are already making a massive methodological error. We are not talking about unreacted primer paint at 430 C. We are talking about paint chips which were baked in the fires after the collapse, possibly having been in and on fire. So you cannot compare unreacted primer paint with it. Try again.

So you think the cracked paint they used to determine temperatures reached on the columns would react the same way? That'd be a good test in my opinion. If they did in fact dissolve or react like the paint in the test, would that be enough for you to believe that the authors did in fact find thermitic materials?

What was the hindenberg painted in? Oops.

Are you saying the Hindenberg was composed of material more like that in the WTC towers than primer from a stadium built in the last 20 years? Is that what they learned ya in your science classes?

Is that reasoning #SUCCESS?



.
 
Jay howard, you have been registered here since 2007. Yet while quickly browsing through all nine pages in the thread I linked to there is not a single post by you in that thread which started in April of 2009. Why not? Will you be posting in that or shall i ask the moderation team to merge this new thread with the one that has all the information in it you request? Or were you hoping we would forget that thread?

here it is again, just so YOU don't forget
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=140017

Started a new job. No time for beating my head against the wall at the time.



.
 
So you believe that if they just used the right manufacturer that the paint/primer would NOT dissolve in the MEK?
Bad science. What is it with you using bad science?

if your control is crap, your experiment is crap.

Again and again. I'll spell it out slowly and see if you get it this time.
if
you
use
bad
methodology
then
you
can't
use
the
results

Is that slow enough for you? Over 20 methodological ERRORS in this "paper." That completely invalidates ANY and ALL findings and conclusions. Try again, with a REAL paper.

That's refreshing. Really. We shouldn't be afraid to say it when it applies. I will do my best not to be afraid of not knowing either.
blah blah blah. Provide REAL science. Not crap. None of the findings are useful in a crap paper. Try again.

So you think the cracked paint they used to determine temperatures reached on the columns would react the same way? That'd be a good test in my opinion. If they did in fact dissolve or react like the paint in the test, would that be enough for you to believe that the authors did in fact find thermitic materials?

Are you blind? Do you have a reading impediment? OR is it just a lack of understanding on basic scientific method? Have you ever taken an experimental design course? If you can produce a REAL peer reviewed journal in which you don't have 20 methodological errors which invalidate any findings or conclusions, I'd love to read it. Unfortunately you are pointing to pseudo scientific claptrap designed to fool the scientifically illiterate. And you fell for it.

Are you saying the Hindenberg was composed of material more like that in the WTC towers than primer from a stadium built in the last 20 years? Is that what they learned ya in your science classes?

Lets see... it was a paint which reacted just like thermite... wow. But hey, engineers never make mistakes right? They never have things just go "oops, I didn't think of that."

How can you compare a stadium paint (which is a different manufacturer, different color, and different composition) to your sample? YOU CAN'T. It is a bad control. Bad control = bad science.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom