Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

So Harrit/Farrer/Jones have come across a material that is undoubtedly highly energetic and which is undergoing a kind of aluminothermic reaction, but because it's more energetic than typical thermite, they are thus refuted.

It's too explosive to be thermite.

Therefore there's no need to look any further. We can discard their research as pointless and "conspiratorial."

Just want to make sure I'm following you..

well obviously not, what in god's name are you talking about "explosive"?" And what are you talking about "highly energetic"? Do you have the first clue? Highly energetic compared to the theoretical maximum for any kind of thermite? Hell yes. Highly energetic compared to a cookie? Hell no.

Your heroes have let you down and you don't even know it.
 
So Harrit/Farrer/Jones have come across a material that is undoubtedly highly energetic and which is undergoing a kind of aluminothermic reaction, but because it's more energetic than typical thermite, they are thus refuted.

Ummm no. They have NOT come across a material that is "undoubtely highly energetic..." We don't know what they came across as their paper is riddled with so many errors in methodology that it is impossible to determine what it is.

Though it is rather amusing that you keep pointing to their reactions, which have 4 different reaction levels, from below thermite to above thermite... For something "nano engineered" it really is all over the ****ing scale.

It's too explosive to be thermite.

So is paper, chocolate and gasoline.

Therefore there's no need to look any further. We can discard their research as pointless and "conspiratorial."

not at all. We can disgard their "research" because their methodologies are crap which invalidates any and all of their findings and conclusions. IT is called basic science mate, look it up. Maybe take a class or two.
 
So, are you claiming that MEK produces a chemical reaction that releases the Al from the Si? Or are you claiming that since the MEK-soaked chip definitely had elemental Al in it, that it must therefore be different from the other samples?

Hmm, well if we assume kaolinite then the binding inbetween the two tends to be quite weak, perhaps the reaction was a dissolution of sorts? Just wondering.

Edit: You might find this relevant to read, perhaps; a critical analysis of Jones paper on the active material:
*Active Thermitic Material" Claimed in Ground Zero Dust May Not Be Thermitic At All
 
Last edited:
So Harrit/Farrer/Jones have come across a material that is undoubtedly highly energetic and which is undergoing a kind of aluminothermic reaction, but because it's more energetic than typical thermite, they are thus refuted.

It's too explosive to be thermite.

Therefore there's no need to look any further. We can discard their research as pointless and "conspiratorial."
.

Harrit/Farrer/Jones are welcome to search further. Let them test the energy of their sample in an oxygen-free atmosphere. If the sample doesn't burn, it isn't thermite.

Why don't they do this test and report the results?
 
Hmm, well if we assume kaolinite then the binding inbetween the two tends to be quite weak, perhaps the reaction was a dissolution of sorts? Just wondering.

Edit: You might find this relevant to read, perhaps; a critical analysis of Jones paper on the active material:
*Active Thermitic Material" Claimed in Ground Zero Dust May Not Be Thermitic At All

Jones and Co. get taken to school here. Which is good, because the schools they originally went to have evidently failed them.
 
What does any of this matter? Ignoring the fact that Jones and Harrit's methodologies are so sloppy that they do not support their conclusions, and ignoring the fact that they were not able to get mainstream journal publication, what does any of what you're pointing out matter? The fact remains that, even if they were correct, even if thermite was indeed at Ground Zero, it had no effect. How do we know this? NCSTAR 1-3C. It contains an inventory and description of the recovered steel. Take a look at core column # 603 (C-80) from WTC 1. It was identified as having been within the zone where the collapse initiated; it spanned from the 92nd to the 95th floor. There are even pictures of it on page 201. Find the thermite induced melting on that column. It was in the collapse initiation zone, after all. Ditto column 605 (HH): It, too was from within the collapse initiation zone, it too is photographed. Find the melting. How about column 801 (C-88a) from WTC-2's collapse initiation zone? These are failed columns that were key to the collapses because they were the ones in the areas where the collapses started. And none of them show any signs of thermite use on them.

And that's just the core columns. Other steel structural pieces were recovered.

So tell me: Why am I supposed to believe that thermite was actually used when recovered failed columns show no signs of their use? Those columns were involved in the start of the collapse, yet all they show are signs of mechanical forcing, not incendiary-caused melting. So what do the point issues of the Jones and Harrit paper matter when it's patently obvious that the actual structural elements they were supposedly used on show no signs of thermite melting whatsoever? Even if we conceded the ridiculous position that thermite was indeed present, it quite obviously had zero effect, because the first columns that failed in the towers collapses do not show signs of thermite melting at all. Your points about Jones, Harrit, et. al. are nothing more than miniscule issues about those researchers writings; they had zero impact on how the towers actually collapsed.



It's premature at minimum to insist that unexploded aluminothermic material found in the WTC dust had "zero impact on how the towers actually collapsed." At least you've come to terms with the existence of the material. That's a first step.


.
 
You don't understand how this whole process works.

Nobody in the entire world is required to back up the claim that the chips are just paint. Farrer, Harrit, Jones, et al, ARE required to back up their claim that they are thermite. Or nanothermite. Or Sooooperthermite.

Their paper demonstrates beyond any reasonable doubt that they have identified a highly energetic material in the WTC dust. They claim it is thermitic--as opposed to calling it thermite. Do you understand why they make that distinction? If you don't, then your entire line of reasoning is misplaced.


.
 
The MEK-soaked chip is not one of samples 1, 2, 3 or 4:

So you're claiming that it's more likely they pulled several different materials from the WTC dust that were 1. magnetic, 2. layered red/gray and 3. showed very similar elemental compositions?

I admit, it's possible, but not likely. But that doesn't increase the reaction temperature of the chips in the DSC. Nor does it make the iron-based and silicon-based microspheres vanish. Even if you want to claim that the MEK chip is not the same as the others, there is clearly a highly energetic reaction taking place by which molten iron and silicon are being produced.

The problem with your analysis is that you must ignore the corroboration of data (that an aluminothermic reaction is taking place) by denying that the components of aluminothermic material are present. Your analysis does more to obfuscate the problem than it does to "set the record straight."

We can all agree the HFJ team went into this looking for something suspicious. But unless you think they manufactured and seeded this material in the dust, then there's no denying they found something suspicious.

It matters not a wit to the instruments what their intentions were. Unless you think they are wholesale lying, there is no way around the fact that they found unexploded ordinance in the WTC dust. If you think they're just totally making up evidence, then there's no need to discuss this any further. Go and make a case for that conspiracy. Then write a paper about it and get it published.

The pre-soaking XEDS spectrum in figure 14 shows different elements to the ones found in fig 7 and in different proportions. They claim surface contamination from the chip because they didn't cut it, but that doesn't explain all of the elements found, plus they can't reach proper conclusions with a dirty chip, plus they don't show the contamination.

The XEDS graph DOES show the contamination.

The chip in figure 31 is different too. Sunstealer made a classification of the data in the paper here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4687714&postcount=221 - I recommend you to read and understand it. A couple excerpts:

Yea, I read that too. All that does is point to the hypothesis that these materials were originally layered. Big deal. Does nothing to invalidate their conclusions.


As for the Fe2O3, they claim:


Yet figure 15 shows no apparent correlation between Fe and O as compared to e.g. Si and O. Even Al and O are more correlated in figure 15 than Fe and O. That makes one wonder if figure 18 has been cherry-picked.

If you think they are manipulating the data, then there's no point having this discussion. You still can't dismiss their conclusions based on your feeling about their methods. And they go to lengths to avoid being accused of doing anything tricky. For instance, they took a known source of Fe2O3 and tested its elemental composition for comparison to their calculations in the determination of the presence of Fe2O3 in the sample:
To check the quantification method, tests were performed with the known chemical, iron (III) oxide, and the elemental quantification was found to yield consistent and repeatable results for iron and oxygen. In particular we made eight 50- second measurements on Fe2O3 samples and found consistency for iron (± 6.2%, 1 sigma) and for oxygen (± 3.4%, 1 sigma) with the O/Fe ratio consistently near 1.5 as expected.
pg. 19



That's definitely not iron oxide.

How are you making this determination? Because of the XEDS maps of fig. 15? The Fe and O portions are not isomorphic, but there is unarguably overlap between the two. Why are you then discounting the XEDS graphs that accompany the maps? They need only show the existence of some Fe2O3 to claim the sample contains it. Same with elemental Al, which they do. What's the problem?



.
 
Jay;

in the end, you seem to be claiming that while we have validly pointed out MANY flaws within the paper, from a scientific pov, from a methods pov, that the essence of the paper is the collection of Spectroscopy outputs and calorimeter outputs.

I think its a valid criticism that they didn't test known paint chips from the WTC wreckage. Beyond that, the data they collect is quite solid. The consideration of a better control paint for the MEK soak does not militate against their conclusions because there is so much corroboration of data that the only way to dismiss the entirety is to accuse them of pure data fabrication.

It's extremely difficult to make a lie (or even faulty data collection) work on a forensic investigation when so many different methods are brought to bear on the samples--unless you think they totally made the data up.

The problem is those outputs are completely useless with such poor science and scientific method surrounding them. Without a proper chain of custody, detailing where the samples were, how they were handled/stored, and by who for every step of the way, the samples are useless, as they could have been tampered with and/or spoiled.

Again, what exactly is wrong with the chain of custody?

Without a thorough attempt to rule out other sources of the chips, many of which are MORE LIKELY sources of said chips, they have clearly shown (A) their lack of respect for, and (B) their lack of desire for, the scientific method, and forensic investigation in general.

Without providing their samples, with a valid and thorough account of chain of custody, to an independent (truly independent, not their associates, not someone they discussed the topic with online, and not with someone who KNOWS WHAT THEY ARE LOOKING FOR IN THE DUST) lab for analysis, their results are NOT REPEATABLE, which throws out the window yet another fundamental of scientific research.

So you think it's more likely that 4 people known publicly to have some dust samples all had them contaminated with the same, highly energetic substance? You seem to be tip toeing around these accusations without actually making them, but if they ever get verbalized, they sound instantly ridiculous.

The probability of what you appear to be implying is far less than there actually being this strange material in the samples. Amazing claims require amazing evidence--this goes in all directions.

SO you see, those spectroscopy outputs you find so fascinating, are useless without the rest. I could provide you with similar spectroscopy outputs and you would never know where I got them, or how, or anything else about them, yet they would be JUST AS INTERESTING standing on their own, if I simply said, I GOT THEM FROM A SAMPLE OF WTC dust.

If you gave the names of the people who collected them, times, and locations, then I would be hard pressed to doubt them. Seeing as how the authors provide all this info, what room is there to doubt? Is there reason to doubt other than the results of the analysis?

Sorry, but I am gonna have to go with the dozens of other WTC dust Analysis that found fiber, gypsum, organics, and paint, but NO THERMITE, done by professional labs unaffiliated with each other, and without agenda.

And if they don't look for something, they're definitely not going to find it.

oh and by the way, IIRC, one of the reasons why Jones eventually had to admit that the only way his "thermite chips" theory was plausible was if the thermite was used as FUSES for conventional explosives, is because Dr. Greening, Mackey, and others, proved to him that it would require over 100 layers of his alleged spray on thermite (based on the thickness of the "exothermic layer" of his chips) to bring the steel to a temperature anywhere close to softening it.

TAM:)


I care not how it was used. I'm still trying to understand how the results of this research can be in doubt. But it is telling that the common defense for finding unreacted explosive material is to point out that it couldn't have brought down the towers anyway.


.
 
So Harrit/Farrer/Jones have come across a material that is undoubtedly highly energetic and which is undergoing a kind of aluminothermic reaction, but because it's more energetic than typical thermite, they are thus refuted.

It's too explosive to be thermite.

Therefore there's no need to look any further. We can discard their research as pointless and "conspiratorial."

Just want to make sure I'm following you.

No, you're not following.

Harrit, Farrer and Jones have found a material that produces a similar amount of energy, when burned in oxygen, to a typical mixture of hydrocarbons and inert material. It produces more energy than the theoretical maximum energy that can possibly be produced by a thermite reaction; however, thermite actually produces a relatively small amount of energy compared to - for example - paper or wood (see appendix). This is extremely well known to science.

Since the reaction observed produces more energy than thermite, we can be absolutely, 100% certain that at least some of the energy is being produced by simple combustion of hydrocarbons in atmospheric oxygen. Since Harrit et al did their experiments in an oxygen-containing atmosphere, there is no way we can be certain that any of the energy came from a thermite reaction, and it is perfectly plausible that none of it did, as there is ample theoretical energy content in hydrocarbons to account for all the measured energy release. Therefore, Harrit et al have not in fact proven that any aluminothermic reaction is taking place. We can therefore dismiss their claim to have done so as unfounded speculation; the evidence does not support it.

Your comment that 'it's too explosive to be thermite' is a curious piece of hyperbole; if you honestly believe that to be our position, then you are working under the handicap of a very basic misunderstanding of the definition of the word 'explosive'. A high energy density is not the signature of an explosive; most high explosives have, again, a lower energy density than burning paper. The signature of an explosive is rapid release of evolved gases. By this definition, no variety of thermite is explosive at all, because the thermite reaction does not release any gases. Therefore, it's perfectly possible for something to be 'too explosive to be thermite'; if it's explosive at all, it isn't thermite. However, this is not the argument we are making.

Finally, we do not dismiss Harrit, Farrer and Jones's research as 'conspiratorial'. We dismiss it because its methodology is fatally flawed and its results do not support the conclusions the authors draw from them. This is not a dismissal on grounds of motivation, or of the intrinsic value of studying the subject matter, as you suggest, but on the grounds that it is a shockingly incompetent piece of work.

Dave

Appendix: A few useful energy densities (from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density):

Thermite 4.0MJ/kg
Nitroglycerin 6.38MJ/kg
Wood 18Mj/kg
Jet A aviation fuel 42.8MJ/kg

These assume the presence of sufficient oxygen for full combustion, where necessary (i.e. the experimental conditions used by Harrit, Farrer and Jones).
 
It matters not a wit to the instruments what their intentions were. Unless you think they are wholesale lying, there is no way around the fact that they found unexploded ordinance in the WTC dust. If you think they're just totally making up evidence, then there's no need to discuss this any further. Go and make a case for that conspiracy. Then write a paper about it and get it published.

As has been explained in detail many, many times on this thread, the bolded sentence is simply wrong. Harrit et al found a combustible substance in the WTC dust, which released somewhat less energy on combustion than an equal quantity of paper but somewhat more than an equal quantity of thermite. It has nothing in common with any form of explosive ordnance, so it's utterly fatuous to describe it as 'unexploded ordinance'; since it doesn't conform to any known ordnance of any sort, it's also factually incorrect. And, finally, Harrit et al are stating conclusions that their data does not support; so, while nobody's accusing them of faking their results, we're pointing out that they do not mean what you (and they) pretend they mean.

I care not how it was used. I'm still trying to understand how the results of this research can be in doubt. But it is telling that the common defense for finding unreacted explosive material is to point out that it couldn't have brought down the towers anyway.

The fact that you can't understand something is hardly a refutation of it. I, personally, find it difficult to understand how anyone, having seen the refutations of Harrit et al's reasoning, can fail to understand that at the very least there is a solid case against it, unless that person is deliberately deluding themself. But it is telling, in reply, that not only was there no unreacted explosive material found, but that the authors cannot even begin to construct the bare bones of a scenario in which the material they have found is in any way significant.

Dave
 
I think its a valid criticism that they didn't test known paint chips from the WTC wreckage. Beyond that, the data they collect is quite solid. The consideration of a better control paint for the MEK soak does not militate against their conclusions because there is so much corroboration of data that the only way to dismiss the entirety is to accuse them of pure data fabrication.

It's extremely difficult to make a lie (or even faulty data collection) work on a forensic investigation when so many different methods are brought to bear on the samples--unless you think they totally made the data up.

Ignoring or refusing to eliminate WTC paint/primer + corrosion as a source, is like observing a white liquid spilled near the fridge, and refusing to determine if it was milk, but rather declaring it was propofol. You have admitted it was a valid criticism, which is a start, but I would say it is an error, an INTENTIONAL ONE, that is of such significance as to render the rest of the study essentially useless.

Again, what exactly is wrong with the chain of custody?

It has been a while since I read the paper, but IIRC, they solicited the samples through an open request from the public.

They obtained said samples from people YEARS AFTER THE EVENT. So we don't know (A) How it was stored for those years leading up to them getting the sample, (B) was it ever taken out and played with. Did the people open up their little bag of dust and play with/contaminate it?

The details on the COLLECTION of said material, in the first place, is INCOMPLETE. He gives some detail for some samples, and no detail on others.

As well, you are getting samples from anonymous people, whose motives you may or may not know. I mean the list of problems with the Chain of Custody goes on and on...it was FAR, FAR, FAR, from a proper forensic collection and storage of material for analysis.

So you think it's more likely that 4 people known publicly to have some dust samples all had them contaminated with the same, highly energetic substance? You seem to be tip toeing around these accusations without actually making them, but if they ever get verbalized, they sound instantly ridiculous.

I am not tiptoeing around anything. You asked me about problems with the chain of custody. You can insinuate what ever you like. I am a clinician and scientist, and we are discussing methodological errors with their analysis/paper. You wanna start talking what I think these lunatic truthers are CAPABLE of, well that is another thread.

However, you are tiptoeing (or ignoring) the fundamental flaw that this group of "scientists" has refused to provide their samples to a truly independent lab for analysis, and hence have no unbias means of repeatability.

The probability of what you appear to be implying is far less than there actually being this strange material in the samples. Amazing claims require amazing evidence--this goes in all directions.

As I said, I am not implying anything...I am merely showing how the flaws in the chain of custody allow for such things, and that is why a proper chain of custody is essential.

If you gave the names of the people who collected them, times, and locations, then I would be hard pressed to doubt them. Seeing as how the authors provide all this info, what room is there to doubt? Is there reason to doubt other than the results of the analysis.

And if they don't look for something, they're definitely not going to find it.

Yes, that is true, but you take the facts, the existing evidence, and then you try to do an honest scientific analysis, not a witch hunt or goose chase. If you find a material that fits your hypothesis, then you are REQUIRED to eliminate other possible sources before you declare a positive conclusion. S. Jones, while bias and a true paranoiac, is not dumb, and he knows this...HE CHOSE NOT TO!!!!

TAM:)
 
jay howard?

Hi jay howard. You appear to be ignoring Tom's post here, so I'm quoting it for you. If you could respond, that would be super. Thanks. :)
You don't understand how this whole process works.

Nobody in the entire world is required to back up the claim that the chips are just paint. Farrer, Harrit, Jones, et al, ARE required to back up their claim that they are thermite. Or nanothermite. Or Sooooperthermite.

I have just completed my hair-brained analysis and concluded that they are "Unicorn dandruff". (Has as much reality as nanothermite to FHJ etc.)

Are the world's serious scientists now required to drop their serious work & jump to reanalyze dust samples? Are they required to debunk my paper? Or do they just go on doing serious work?



Yes, their analysis is completely faulty. I'm not even a chemist, and I know FOR CERTAIN that their analysis is amateurish & faulty.

Because none of them have ever done this specific analysis before. Which, by definition, makes them amateurs at this analysis.

As a result, their analysis is completely inconclusive. They report SUGGESTIONS of a substance that they've NEVER SEEN.

Here's their primary screw-up.

THINK ABOUT IT: why would they try to invent their own tests, when arson investigators - REAL experts - are often called upon to determine whether or not thermite has been used in a fire?

Is there a DEFINITIVE test for thermite? Not aluminum-oxide & iron. But thermite, pre & post ignition.

I found out in about 1/2 hour that the answer is "Yes". There is a test, X-ray diffraction test, that can be done at contract chem labs around the country that will tell you FOR CERTAIN whether this stuff is the COMPOUND thermite, or just some compound that includes iron, aluminum & oxygen, etc.

The test cost about $130 ea. if you prepare your own samples (i.e., grind them into powder). Or about $170 ea if the lab does it for you.

And you are allegedly looking for a specific compound that was used for a specific task: "blowing up" or compromising the columns of the towers. You don't go searching in "dust" that was spread all over Manhattan. Your chances of finding the tiny amounts (compared to the millions of tons of rubble) are absurdly small. You go to the SOURCE: the ends of the columns that are still stored at JFK.

[Of course, there is nothing that looks anything like a thermite cut on any of those beams. Or - from detailed photos available today - on any beam that was in the rubble pile. But don't let that annoying little fact slow down the stupid.]

You could test 50 samples from many columns, at 2 independent labs, for less than $20K. And in about 30 days.

And when you are done, you have a definitive, conclusive answer. Rather than a pile of amateur innuendo.

How's that for "falling off the tracks"?

Tom
 
So you're claiming that it's more likely they pulled several different materials from the WTC dust that were 1. magnetic, 2. layered red/gray and 3. showed very similar elemental compositions?

I am saying that with ovre 20 methodological errors it is impossible to say what they pulled from the wtc dust.

<snip>Nor does it make the iron-based and silicon-based microspheres vanish.

Please show me how nanothermite can make iron based or silicon based mircrosphere. How do groups like RJ Lee EXPECT TO FIND microspheres in the fire? Were they in on it? Why would they expect to find them?

But lets move on to another issue with the microspheres (which is off topic and shows your ignorance... but hey who am I to argue). Lets go back to basic experimental design and research methods. YOu cannot make a claim about ANYTHING until you have ELIMINATED what it cannot be. We know that iron microspheres are in fly ash, in concrete, in gypsum, and could have been created during the recovery period when they were using thermic lances.

Can you eliminate ANY of those for the creation of the microspheres? Yes or no? If not, then you cant' make any claims about them from thermite. Oopsie.

Even if you want to claim that the MEK chip is not the same as the others, there is clearly a highly energetic reaction taking place by which molten iron and silicon are being produced.

Highly energetic? It is all over the place in the 4 samples tested. How does a nano engineered substance have such wildly and vastly different reactions? That by itself shows it wasn't nano engineered.

Highly energetic compared to what? Paper, chocolate, wool and gasoline all have higher energy densities. That is highly energetic.

So far with the 20 major methodological errors it is impossible to say what this is... it could be (and probably is) dried out paint which is combusting in an oxygen rich envrionment. (one of those massive methodological errors). Throw out the junk and get some REAL science done.

The problem with your analysis is that you must ignore the corroboration of data (that an aluminothermic reaction is taking place) by denying that the components of aluminothermic material are present.

From the paper, we have NO PROOF of an aluminothermic reaction occuring. You want to prove it once and for all? Do the test again in an intert atmosphere (HUGE methodological error). Once you do that and can show it having an aluminothermic reaction, I'll be happy to acknowledge it. Until then, this is a craptacular pile o fail.

<snip>
We can all agree the HFJ team went into this looking for something suspicious. But unless you think they manufactured and seeded this material in the dust, then there's no denying they found something suspicious.

Not at all. Do you know what confirmation bias is? They don't have to manufacture or seed anything... they just have to use enough methodological errors to allow them to "find" what they want to find. You know, what they actually did.

It matters not a wit to the instruments what their intentions were.

Haven't you ever heard that old Mark Twain quote about "Lies, Damn Lies and Statistics?" It is applicable here.

If you have a experiment riddled with methodolocial errors, yoru test, findings and conclusions are not valid. It is crap. STart over.

Unless you think they are wholesale lying, there is no way around the fact that they found unexploded ordinance in the WTC dust.

False choice fallacy. It isn't one or the other. It is somethng much more basic and embarassing for them. They didn't do the work right, and made massive errors.

We don't know WHAT they found in the dust because of all the errors in the methodology. AGain and again, Why won't you all send any samples to truely independent labs? Why are truthers SOOOOOO afraid of independent analysis? (other than realizing that they are full of crap)

If you think they're just totally making up evidence, then there's no need to discuss this any further. Go and make a case for that conspiracy. Then write a paper about it and get it published.
YOu can recommend a very basic journal who will publish any vanity or regular crap... Bentham.

Of course, if it were me, I'd put it in a great psychology or experimental design journal discussing common misconceptions and misunderstandings of exprimental design among conspiracy theorists. But I don't feel like taking the time for something so trivial.

If you think they are manipulating the data, then there's no point having this discussion. You still can't dismiss their conclusions based on your feeling about their methods.

ROFLMAO. Yes you can. It isn't a "feeling about their methods." It is empirical evidence that they have a "paper" riddled with methodological errors.

here is a simple challenge to you. Call up your local university, ask to speak to whoever teaches research methods or experimental design. Now that you have done that (which you won't) then ask them a simple question. "There is someone who is trying to argue about the validity of a journal article. They keep pointing to the findings and conclusions. But there are a minimum of 10 major methodological errors in the paper. Can you take any of the findings, conclusions or experiments as being valid or accurate?"

See what they tell you. (I teach research methods, experimental design and education classes for a living.)

And they go to lengths to avoid being accused of doing anything tricky. For instance, they took a known source of Fe2O3 and tested its elemental composition for comparison to their calculations in the determination of the presence of Fe2O3 in the sample: pg. 19

Umm no they don't. They purposefully did the test in an oxygen rich environment and hand wave that away. They purposefully distort the spectographs so they look similar to thermite (even though they don't). They purposefully ignore or do the science in a faulty manner.
 
It's premature at minimum to insist that unexploded aluminothermic material found in the WTC dust had "zero impact on how the towers actually collapsed." At least you've come to terms with the existence of the material. That's a first step.


.

It is premature at minimum to insist that the materials recovered in the dust from the WTC collapse is thermitic. That would be due to the 20 methodological errors, the inability to replicate the findings by anyone, the inability to send off the materials for independent lab testing etc...

As for what the hypothetical nanothermite can do, using the energy density and the known properties of steel, yes it is very easy to determine the amount of layers necessary (as Dr. Greening has done).

At lesat you've need to come to terms with the truely horrendous pile o' fail that you keep trying to flog here.
 
It's premature at minimum to insist that unexploded aluminothermic material found in the WTC dust had "zero impact on how the towers actually collapsed." At least you've come to terms with the existence of the material. That's a first step.

Negative. The preponderance of the evidence very clearly demonstrates that the columns were not severed by any means other than impact force, not incendiaries. Which is my whole point: You are the one ignoring evidence when you refuse to come to terms with the existence of verified evidence. And when you attempt to offer poorly supported research who's conclusion has been very strongly and well refuted, then you are the one who is not approaching the issue logically or scientifically.

Harrit and Jones drew erroneous conclusions. But as I said, even if they had been accurate, and had found thermite, then it had no effect. The state of the recovered steel very, very clearly shows zero signs of melting from thermite.

You need to acknowledge the evidence. The evidence shows that even if thermite was present, it failed to function. You need to come to terms with that.

_______

And for the record: Why do you presume that I've "come to terms with the existence of the material"? Did you even read my post? I am very clearly on record as saying that the Jones, Harrit, et. al. is a shoddy work that not only failed to support its conclusion, but actually contradicts it. What I am confronting is the fantasy that you conspiracy peddlers continue to push despite the fact that it has been refuted.
 
Their paper demonstrates beyond any reasonable doubt that they have identified a highly energetic material in the WTC dust. They claim it is thermitic--as opposed to calling it thermite. Do you understand why they make that distinction? If you don't, then your entire line of reasoning is misplaced.
.

I remain baffled at your inability to see that whatever they claimed to have found was not highly energetic compared to a freaking potato chip.

Ah but they have covered themselves by calling it "thermitic.' Well my kids were eating something last night after practice, and I swept up the crumbs before bed. They were much more highly energetic compared to what the idiots found! As the crumbs were clearly not thermite, or super thermite, I am simply going to call them "Unobtainiumtic" in the off chance that they are in fact remains of whatever planet Jones came from.
 
The ways this topic is treated demonstrate well the unscientific habits that debunkers here participate in. Why? If the material Harrit, Farrer, Jones, et. al. found is so much nonsense, then why can't it just be handled head-on, without resorting to pretended lacks of understanding, circumstantial ad hominems, and distractions?

You don't like the journal it's published in? Fine. You don't like other things the authors have written? So what? None of that changes what they found.
Jay, you seem to be operating on an unestablished assumption. You assume that what they found is significant. What's been pointed out in this thread, and in others, is that the significance of the data is irrevocably coupled to the adherence to scientific principles and procedures. Random sampling, error modeling, appropriate methodology, control of variables, appropriate experimental design and others are the foundation for scientific inquiry. In the Harrit paper, they are all absent. They did nothing right. They wasted their time gathering data whose significance cannot be established.

You also seem to think that it is the job of the debunker to prove Jones's conclusions false. That's not how science works. In appropriate scientific methodology, it is up to the researcher to identify and control confounding variables in the experiment. When someone points out that some variable will affect the system that has not been accounted for, you throw out the data and try again. The significance of the data cannot be established if uncontrolled variables exist. It is up to the researcher to show that all of the variables are accounted for, and it is not the job of the reviewer or the critic to prove that the variables will affect the results.

We're criticizing the place where it is published because we know Jones wasn't interested in reviewing his results. A reviewer for Analytical Chemistry, Nature, Science, Geochemica Acta, or any other major journal would have pointed out the flaws in the research. Jones would have had the opportunity to redo the experiments or refine the conclusions and then resubmit the paper. This back and forth process is essential to the scientific method. Now why would Jones be so interested in circumventing it?

But let's look at the big question: What can be established about the collapse of the twin towers using a directed, non-random sampling of compositional, thermal, and morphological properties of particles collected from 4 locations?

Nothing.

Harrit and Jones are looking in the wrong place, using the wrong tools, and don't have access to the material necessary to establish their predetermined conclusion. They're using DSC in a reducing environment, and finding that carbonaceous materials combust at around 430 C. They're using XEDS to determine the composition of heterogeneous particles using fundamental parameters derived from bulk, homogeneous specimens. They're sampling the composition of a handful of particles from a series that contains billions upon billions upon billions of particles. Those samples were collected from a total sample size of trillions upon trillions upon trillions. No conclusions can be made based on the results. Or, at least none that wouldn't wind up being a joke at the statistician's Christmas party.
The little actual scientific debate of the merits of the research say basically that the chips were paint—DESPITE the fact that paint (especially in the WTC towers) could withstand temperatures of at least 800C.
False. Some of the paint could withstand temperatures of 800 C. What Jones has is a sample from a plume of ash, construction materials, organic char and unburned material. That material could have come from anywhere, and could have originally been attached to anything. Nothing from the data provided could be used to establish that the so called "paint chips" must have been from the WTC.
The thermitic chips in the WTC dust IGNITED at about 430C.
Something ignited at 430 C. There is no way to tell precisely what ignited.
Not only did they ignite, they formed iron microspheres. Imagine that.
Iron microspheres are common in all ashes and dusts. Frank Greening and I have pointed this out to Jones numerous times. The fact that Jones once again found iron in dust is incredibly uninteresting. It has no significance.
Does primer ignite at 430C? Can you show me a sample somewhere, anywhere, that ignites at 430C when dry?
False choice. Something ignited at 430 C, it did not have to be primer. There is no way, given the data provided, to show what ignited.
Much less a sample that produces metallic iron when ignited?
It produces nothing. The iron was present in the sample before it was ignited.
We all know it doesn’t exist.
That hasn't been established. It is up to Harrit et al to show that this is the case.
What would be the point? To make a REALLY unsafe primer that ignites at a very achievable office fire temperatures and proceeds to increase BEYOND the melting point of iron? Yea. Give that one to the sales department.
Nothing in the Harrit paper proves that the fire required iron melting temperatures to produce the ash.
Another standard response to this will no doubt be the uncontrollable urge to turn this into a debate over HOW the thermitic material could possibly have ended up in the towers. Now, that’s not a bad line of inquiry in itself IF it weren’t intended solely to be used as a means to reduce the premise to an absurdity and thus, dismiss it.
You're right. Nothing whatsoever in the paper could lead anyone to believe that there was unexploded thermite anywhere.
I'd love to know how and why it's in the dust.
You would first need to establish what is in the dust of a normal building. Then you would need to establish what is in the ash from a large multi-storey building fire. Then, you can establish, to some known level of statistical uncertainty, what baseline levels of iron, aluminum, silicon, etc, are in the non-altered dust. After that, you can build a time machine, collect a dust sample in a variety of randomly chosen, yet clean areas on 9/11, and then do a comparative study on the elemental and morphological distributions of the sample. If the difference of the mean values, according to standard hypothesis testing models, is shown to be above 95%, then you will know that something was different. And you'll know how different it was.
 
Since many of the responses are repetitious, I want to respond to a few overarching considerations in a single post:

One of the problems with having this conversation is that there is a misunderstanding (pretended or real) that the substance we are talking about is "thermite." It is clearly not. It is "thermitic." That distinction is made specifically to keep these substances from being confused--which is happening all too often in regard to the HFJ paper. From Wikipedia:
Because of their highly increased reaction rate, nanosized thermitic materials are being researched by the U.S. military with the aim of developing new types of bombs that are several times more powerful than conventional explosives.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metastable_intermolecular_composite

It cannot be emphasized enough that changing the size of the particles in aluminothermic reactions does indeed change the dynamics significantly. Because of the high cost and difficulty in manufacturing nano-sized elemental aluminum, these traces are anything but "conventional." The fact that they have been identified in the WTC dust signals the existence of a totally unaccounted energy source that can be highly tailored to a wide variety of applications.

What never seems to come up in terms of data fabrication or the supposed chain of custody issues is that if they were going to make something up, why not choose something more conventional? The fact that this substance, whatever it is, is NOT well understood leads only to more questions about it. If they wanted to fake it, they would have been much better off claiming conventional explosives. There are only a handful of labs in the US that can even produce elemental aluminum at these sizes.

Instead we see nanometer-sized iron, aluminum and silicon particles mixed very finely in a carbon-based matrix. The uniformity of these particles is startling, as most manufacturing processes on an industrial scale--paints, primers, corrosion protection coatings, etc., cannot afford to design these particles (most especially the aluminum) so precisely for use in products that do not require such specific size/mixture parameters. It would be an enormously wasteful endeavor to design paints or other common industrial coatings that don't require such fine particles. The mere prospect is laughable as there isn't a plant manager on the planet that would propose such an unnecessary move. It's not only a sure-fire way to get fired, it would ensure the company would eventually go out of business as well!

The fact that this material is NOT easily manufactured nor well understood should be a glaring red alarm to anyone who is not in complete denial. There is no good reason that this very unusual material should be found in regular construction material. And anyone who thinks this is some version of paint or an industrial coating is not paying much attention.

For those who doubt the chain of custody, there are roughly 2 possibilities: you must either believe:

1. that it is more probable that all 4 samples were contaminated with similarly strange material (!) or

2. that the HFJ research team unanimously decided to pull a fast one and attempted to implicate some other party in addition to (but separate from) the 19 hijackers as complicit in the murders of 3000 American citizens. (What purpose this last option would serve besides making the researchers very unpopular to the current power structure may be the deepest mystery of all.)

When combined with the extensive corroborative evidence of the strange exothermic properties of this material, its nanometer-sized particular makeup, comparative XEDS spectroscopy and comparative SE microscopy, both chain of custody options become significantly less probable than what the authors of the paper claim.

Since the only "evidence" of such a claim of contamination or misrepresentation of the samples is the doubt produced by the conclusions (which overwhelmingly implicate forces within the US power structure), then it should be pointed out that incredulity is a poor foundation for a claim against scientific evidence. Compared one-to-one, the science wins this one hands down. Claims to the contrary must bring more than just doubt to bear on this evidence.


.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom