The ways this topic is treated demonstrate well the unscientific habits that debunkers here participate in. Why? If the material Harrit, Farrer, Jones, et. al. found is so much nonsense, then why can't it just be handled head-on, without resorting to pretended lacks of understanding, circumstantial ad hominems, and distractions?
You don't like the journal it's published in? Fine. You don't like other things the authors have written? So what? None of that changes what they found.
Jay, you seem to be operating on an unestablished assumption. You assume that what they found is significant. What's been pointed out in this thread, and in others, is that the significance of the data is irrevocably coupled to the adherence to scientific principles and procedures. Random sampling, error modeling, appropriate methodology, control of variables, appropriate experimental design and others are the foundation for scientific inquiry. In the Harrit paper, they are all absent. They did nothing right. They wasted their time gathering data whose significance cannot be established.
You also seem to think that it is the job of the debunker to prove Jones's conclusions false. That's not how science works. In appropriate scientific methodology, it is up to the researcher to identify and control confounding variables in the experiment. When someone points out that some variable will affect the system that has not been accounted for, you throw out the data and try again. The significance of the data cannot be established if uncontrolled variables exist. It is up to the researcher to show that all of the variables are accounted for, and it is not the job of the reviewer or the critic to prove that the variables will affect the results.
We're criticizing the place where it is published because we know Jones wasn't interested in reviewing his results. A reviewer for Analytical Chemistry, Nature, Science, Geochemica Acta, or any other major journal would have pointed out the flaws in the research. Jones would have had the opportunity to redo the experiments or refine the conclusions and then resubmit the paper. This back and forth process is essential to the scientific method. Now why would Jones be so interested in circumventing it?
But let's look at the big question: What can be established about the collapse of the twin towers using a directed, non-random sampling of compositional, thermal, and morphological properties of particles collected from 4 locations?
Nothing.
Harrit and Jones are looking in the wrong place, using the wrong tools, and don't have access to the material necessary to establish their predetermined conclusion. They're using DSC in a reducing environment, and finding that carbonaceous materials combust at around 430 C. They're using XEDS to determine the composition of heterogeneous particles using fundamental parameters derived from bulk, homogeneous specimens. They're sampling the composition of a handful of particles from a series that contains billions upon billions upon billions of particles. Those samples were collected from a total sample size of trillions upon trillions upon trillions. No conclusions can be made based on the results. Or, at least none that wouldn't wind up being a joke at the statistician's Christmas party.
The little actual scientific debate of the merits of the research say basically that the chips were paint—DESPITE the fact that paint (especially in the WTC towers) could withstand temperatures of at least 800C.
False. Some of the paint could withstand temperatures of 800 C. What Jones has is a sample from a plume of ash, construction materials, organic char and unburned material. That material could have come from anywhere, and could have originally been attached to anything. Nothing from the data provided could be used to establish that the so called "paint chips" must have been from the WTC.
The thermitic chips in the WTC dust IGNITED at about 430C.
Something ignited at 430 C. There is no way to tell precisely what ignited.
Not only did they ignite, they formed iron microspheres. Imagine that.
Iron microspheres are common in all ashes and dusts. Frank Greening and I have pointed this out to Jones numerous times. The fact that Jones once again found iron in dust is incredibly uninteresting. It has no significance.
Does primer ignite at 430C? Can you show me a sample somewhere, anywhere, that ignites at 430C when dry?
False choice. Something ignited at 430 C, it did not have to be primer. There is no way, given the data provided, to show what ignited.
Much less a sample that produces metallic iron when ignited?
It produces nothing. The iron was present in the sample before it was ignited.
We all know it doesn’t exist.
That hasn't been established. It is up to Harrit et al to show that this is the case.
What would be the point? To make a REALLY unsafe primer that ignites at a very achievable office fire temperatures and proceeds to increase BEYOND the melting point of iron? Yea. Give that one to the sales department.
Nothing in the Harrit paper proves that the fire required iron melting temperatures to produce the ash.
Another standard response to this will no doubt be the uncontrollable urge to turn this into a debate over HOW the thermitic material could possibly have ended up in the towers. Now, that’s not a bad line of inquiry in itself IF it weren’t intended solely to be used as a means to reduce the premise to an absurdity and thus, dismiss it.
You're right. Nothing whatsoever in the paper could lead anyone to believe that there was unexploded thermite anywhere.
I'd love to know how and why it's in the dust.
You would first need to establish what is in the dust of a normal building. Then you would need to establish what is in the ash from a large multi-storey building fire. Then, you can establish, to some known level of statistical uncertainty, what baseline levels of iron, aluminum, silicon, etc, are in the non-altered dust. After that, you can build a time machine, collect a dust sample in a variety of randomly chosen, yet clean areas on 9/11, and then do a comparative study on the elemental and morphological distributions of the sample. If the difference of the mean values, according to standard hypothesis testing models, is shown to be above 95%, then you will know that something was different. And you'll know how different it was.