Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Alright cheers.

I'm sure it will not satisfy the resident loon on the forums but its there for everyone else to read too.

Thanks.
 
Yeah, Bentham has pretty much been established as a joke in the scientific community. Of course, this hasn't stopped the Truth Movement from crowing about their "peer-reviewed" paper. And I'm certain it never will.
 
Regardless of the authority or legitimacy of Bentham as a publication - judgements I fully agree with, by the way - I think it's better to point out that the work itself is flawed, as Sunstealer so excellently demonstrates. Many of us in those threads pointed out problems that have nothing to do with the publication house in question.

While I fully agree that Bentham is a vanity publication, that in and of itself does not mean that something published by them is false. It merely means that the publication has sloppy controls and an interest in not looking at material too closely, since they're being paid by the author of a paper to publish it. That injects doubt, but does not address the actual veracity of a paper published through them. But other critiques in the above linked threads do address that. Which is why I'm composing this terribly didactic post: We should be noting that the paper inherently is flawed, not merely that it's published in a vanity journal, and demonstrate what is flawed about it. That's why I pointed to Sunstealer's post.

[/stuffy pedanticism]
 
Regardless of the authority or legitimacy of Bentham as a publication - judgements I fully agree with, by the way - I think it's better to point out that the work itself is flawed, as Sunstealer so excellently demonstrates. Many of us in those threads pointed out problems that have nothing to do with the publication house in question.

While I fully agree that Bentham is a vanity publication, that in and of itself does not mean that something published by them is false. It merely means that the publication has sloppy controls and an interest in not looking at material too closely, since they're being paid by the author of a paper to publish it. That injects doubt, but does not address the actual veracity of a paper published through them. But other critiques in the above linked threads do address that. Which is why I'm composing this terribly didactic post: We should be noting that the paper inherently is flawed, not merely that it's published in a vanity journal, and demonstrate what is flawed about it. That's why I pointed to Sunstealer's post.

[/stuffy pedanticism]

well far be it for me to disagree, but pointing out that Bentham is a farking unbelievable joke of a farking farce is directly relevant to claims that the journal is "peer-reviewed" as the title of the post suggests.

I say prove it Jones ya freaking hack.
 
From Nature, 15 June 2009: http://www.nature.com/news/2009/090615/full/news.2009.571.html
Editor will quit over hoax paper

Computer-generated manuscript accepted for publication in open-access journal.

The editor-in-chief of a journal is to resign after claiming that the publisher, Bentham Science Publishing, accepted a hoax article for publication without his knowledge.

The fake, computer-generated manuscript was submitted to The Open Information Science Journal by Philip Davis, a graduate student in communication sciences at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York, and Kent Anderson, executive director of international business and product development at The New England Journal of Medicine.​
 
It seems that henryco sunk under the Kool-Aid:

La nanothermite serait donc essentiellement un leurre! Il est dailleurs évident que la nanothermite ne pouvait expliquer la destruction explosive des tours, seulement éventuellement l'initiation d'un effondrement d'apparance naturelle en ayant fragilisé (en les chauffant plus efficacement que les incendies) les structures d'Acier.

Quelle serait donc la technologie à maintenir secrête et qui aurait justifié toute cette mise en scène de publication scientifique faisant état de découverte de particules de nanothermite !? Je suis maintenant convaincu qu'il s'agit d'une physique mal comprise, celle de la fusion froide...

Roughly translated to:

So, the nanothermite would essentially be a trap! It's obvious that the nanothermite could explain the explosive destruction of the towers, only perhaps the initiation of a collapse apparently natural, while weakening (by heating more efficiently than fires) the steel structures.

What would be that technology to keep secret and would have justified all that comedy of scientific publication mentioning nanothermite particles!? I'm now convinced that it's misunderstood Physics, the COLD FUSION one

Source, pimped by Google Translations
 
Distortion of facts. The three professors didn't try to discredit anything. I'm norwegian and have listened to the interviews. They were asked to give their opinion on this spesific paper and they gave the opinion it was weak and not in any way conclusive.
And they weren't asked about Bush/Cheney/Laden, so of course they didn't give support of any "official conspiracy".

I have studied at the institute where Grande and Einarsrud are employed, even taken courses that Grande taught. These people are real experts in inorganic chemistry and nano-materials. They analyse and synthesize these compounds on a daily basis and educate master- and PhD-students on relevant subjects. If they say the paper is weak I'm almost tempted to pull an "argument from authority".

They're asking for replications and further analysis before concluding, just like any sane scientist would do.

Sorry to revive a thread that's a month old, but is the statements of the norwegian scientists available somewhere? I'm currently discussing this with a twoofer who claim the norwegians said Jones and Harrit produced good work that followed good scientific methods. Not exactly the impression you get after reading the above post of Leviath, so I would love to read or hear it for myself (since I'm swedish it would be no problem listening to audio clips).

Anyone that can help?
 
Sorry to revive a thread that's a month old, but is the statements of the norwegian scientists available somewhere? I'm currently discussing this with a twoofer who claim the norwegians said Jones and Harrit produced good work that followed good scientific methods. Not exactly the impression you get after reading the above post of Leviath, so I would love to read or hear it for myself (since I'm swedish it would be no problem listening to audio clips).

Anyone that can help?

Here's the link to the radio show, plus if you scroll down there's a dialogue between Prof. Nilson and STeven Jones.



http://zelikow.wordpress.com/2009/05/22/norwegian-state-radio-initiates-public-debate-on-911-truth/

And this is a link to the thread about Frederic Henry-Couannier

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=151009

hope this helps

AE
 
Here's the link to the radio show, plus if you scroll down there's a dialogue between Prof. Nilson and STeven Jones.



http://zelikow.wordpress.com/2009/05/22/norwegian-state-radio-initiates-public-debate-on-911-truth/

Heh:
Prof Nilsen: The formation of iron-rich spheres

"Again the experimental work seems to be of adequate quality. I see no reason to doubt the formation of iron-rich spheres. I miss a comment on what is happening to the gray layer, but that seems to be of minor importance. The effect on heating the organic binder in air seems not to be considered. The conclusion that heating a material containing intimately mixed particles of aluminum and iron oxide give rice to a thermitic reaction (Fe2O3 + Al → Al2O3 + Fe) is not unreasonable."

Prof Jones: "Thank you… we do say in the paper: “One possibility is that the organic material in the red layer is itself energetic.”

Ahum...
 
Hello,

See my www.darksideofgravity.com/redreds.pdf

i'm currently translating a french pdf i have describing the analyses and conclusions,... available tomorrow.

Not my preferred interpretation but it' s still possible that these red-red chips are of normal thermite in a gel which would expain why they did not ignite up to 900°C

I was asked to send one of those red-red chips to Steven group. I replied of course i would be glad to do so and would appreciate to receive a red/gray chip in turn ... i was told that they would feel better about the exchange if i
accepted to publish my results in a referee review instead of Jref. I cannot loose my time trying to convince a referee paid to make me loose my time so i decided to stop my communications with this group.

Best

Fred
 
Hello,

See my www.darksideofgravity.com/redreds.pdf

i'm currently translating a french pdf i have describing the analyses and conclusions,... available tomorrow.

Not my preferred interpretation but it' s still possible that these red-red chips are of normal thermite in a gel which would expain why they did not ignite up to 900°C

I was asked to send one of those red-red chips to Steven group. I replied of course i would be glad to do so and would appreciate to receive a red/gray chip in turn ... i was told that they would feel better about the exchange if i
accepted to publish my results in a referee review instead of Jref. I cannot loose my time trying to convince a referee paid to make me loose my time so i decided to stop my communications with this group.

Best

Fred

The translation is ready: find it here

www.darksideofgravity.com/marseille_gb.pdf

best

Fred
 
Thanks Fred;

As I have said before, the only way to rid yourself of this "confusion" or "potential deception" around reproducing nano-thermite results, is to obtain samples of the WTC dust, with the following stipulations,

1. Must be obtained independently of Jones and his associates
2. Must not be ANONYMOUSLY submitted.
3. Must have a KNOWN CHAIN OF CUSTODY.
4. Must eliminate other potential sources of the red-grey chips when analyzed.

Ultimately if you go into it thinking someone is purposely trying to obfuscate your results by tampering, then you could say the same could happen regardless of the methods used, and the procedure followed.

Who is to say that the person who submits the samples to you has not tampered with the dust in the first place?

TAM:)
 
Energetics

The DSC of the chips in an inert atmosphere is still the key experiment. Two of Jones' samples in the Bentham paper showed about 1.5 to 2 times the theoretical energy per unit mass of the thermite reaction. Jones, et al., invoke partial combustion of the binder in air as the energetic difference but this has not yet led to the obvious experiment.

My suspicion is that Jones and crew are stalling on the DSC because the exotherm at 440*C was due entirely to combustion and they don't want to admit it. Recently, I heard that they were now complaining of a deficiency of sample material. I think that this is the first step in an unfortunate shortage of true sample. No samples to analyze will prevent the truth [paint] from coming out and forever beatify the dedicated, heroic scientists after the men in black steal all their red chips. No other red chips will be valid samples, of course, because they were obviously planted by the reptilian-led, Zionist-Illuminati-Bilderberg NWO that owns the main stream media that the sheeple believe....etc.
 
Yes, you're correct. Conspiracy addicts were suckered into Jones's claims that either 1. The "nano" nature of nanothermite is what allowed for more energy release because it's tunable (which is a stupid argument; as you noted, the release was still in excess of what a thermite redox can produce), or 2. The "sol-gel" matrix provided the excess energy. Which of course raises the question of why thermite would be needed to begin with, if the medium that holds it can contribute far more energy to the reaction.

Yeah. Old hat. The energetics Jones put forth is pretty much pseudoscience for suckers.
 
Recently, I heard that they were now complaining of a deficiency of sample material. I think that this is the first step in an unfortunate shortage of true sample.

That, alone, is more or less fatal to the thermite hypothesis, if you think about it. For the hypothesis to have any credibility at all, this stuff would have to be highly abundant in the WTC dust.

Dave
 
Red/Gray Chips Are Not Paint

The ways this topic is treated demonstrate well the unscientific habits that debunkers here participate in. Why? If the material Harrit, Farrer, Jones, et. al. found is so much nonsense, then why can't it just be handled head-on, without resorting to pretended lacks of understanding, circumstantial ad hominems, and distractions?

You don't like the journal it's published in? Fine. You don't like other things the authors have written? So what? None of that changes what they found.

The little actual scientific debate of the merits of the research say basically that the chips were paint—DESPITE the fact that paint (especially in the WTC towers) could withstand temperatures of at least 800C. The thermitic chips in the WTC dust IGNITED at about 430C. Not only did they ignite, they formed iron microspheres. Imagine that.

Does primer ignite at 430C? Can you show me a sample somewhere, anywhere, that ignites at 430C when dry? Much less a sample that produces metallic iron when ignited? We all know it doesn’t exist. What would be the point? To make a REALLY unsafe primer that ignites at a very achievable office fire temperatures and proceeds to increase BEYOND the melting point of iron? Yea. Give that one to the sales department.

Another standard response to this will no doubt be the uncontrollable urge to turn this into a debate over HOW the thermitic material could possibly have ended up in the towers. Now, that’s not a bad line of inquiry in itself IF it weren’t intended solely to be used as a means to reduce the premise to an absurdity and thus, dismiss it.

I'd love to know how and why it's in the dust. But suggesting that because someone doesn't know exactly how it was used, we can therefore dismiss their scientific findings, is poor reasoning at best.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom