Regardless of the authority or legitimacy of Bentham as a publication - judgements I fully agree with, by the way - I think it's better to point out that the work itself is flawed, as Sunstealer so excellently demonstrates. Many of us in those threads pointed out problems that have nothing to do with the publication house in question.
While I fully agree that Bentham is a vanity publication, that in and of itself does not mean that something published by them is false. It merely means that the publication has sloppy controls and an interest in not looking at material too closely, since they're being paid by the author of a paper to publish it. That injects doubt, but does not address the actual veracity of a paper published through them. But other critiques in the above linked threads do address that. Which is why I'm composing this terribly didactic post: We should be noting that the paper inherently is flawed, not merely that it's published in a vanity journal, and demonstrate what is flawed about it. That's why I pointed to Sunstealer's post.
[/stuffy pedanticism]
La nanothermite serait donc essentiellement un leurre! Il est dailleurs évident que la nanothermite ne pouvait expliquer la destruction explosive des tours, seulement éventuellement l'initiation d'un effondrement d'apparance naturelle en ayant fragilisé (en les chauffant plus efficacement que les incendies) les structures d'Acier.
Quelle serait donc la technologie à maintenir secrête et qui aurait justifié toute cette mise en scène de publication scientifique faisant état de découverte de particules de nanothermite !? Je suis maintenant convaincu qu'il s'agit d'une physique mal comprise, celle de la fusion froide...
So, the nanothermite would essentially be a trap! It's obvious that the nanothermite could explain the explosive destruction of the towers, only perhaps the initiation of a collapse apparently natural, while weakening (by heating more efficiently than fires) the steel structures.
What would be that technology to keep secret and would have justified all that comedy of scientific publication mentioning nanothermite particles!? I'm now convinced that it's misunderstood Physics, the COLD FUSION one
Distortion of facts. The three professors didn't try to discredit anything. I'm norwegian and have listened to the interviews. They were asked to give their opinion on this spesific paper and they gave the opinion it was weak and not in any way conclusive.
And they weren't asked about Bush/Cheney/Laden, so of course they didn't give support of any "official conspiracy".
I have studied at the institute where Grande and Einarsrud are employed, even taken courses that Grande taught. These people are real experts in inorganic chemistry and nano-materials. They analyse and synthesize these compounds on a daily basis and educate master- and PhD-students on relevant subjects. If they say the paper is weak I'm almost tempted to pull an "argument from authority".
They're asking for replications and further analysis before concluding, just like any sane scientist would do.
Sorry to revive a thread that's a month old, but is the statements of the norwegian scientists available somewhere? I'm currently discussing this with a twoofer who claim the norwegians said Jones and Harrit produced good work that followed good scientific methods. Not exactly the impression you get after reading the above post of Leviath, so I would love to read or hear it for myself (since I'm swedish it would be no problem listening to audio clips).
Anyone that can help?
Here's the link to the radio show, plus if you scroll down there's a dialogue between Prof. Nilson and STeven Jones.
http://zelikow.wordpress.com/2009/05/22/norwegian-state-radio-initiates-public-debate-on-911-truth/
Hello,
See my www.darksideofgravity.com/redreds.pdf
i'm currently translating a french pdf i have describing the analyses and conclusions,... available tomorrow.
Not my preferred interpretation but it' s still possible that these red-red chips are of normal thermite in a gel which would expain why they did not ignite up to 900°C
I was asked to send one of those red-red chips to Steven group. I replied of course i would be glad to do so and would appreciate to receive a red/gray chip in turn ... i was told that they would feel better about the exchange if i
accepted to publish my results in a referee review instead of Jref. I cannot loose my time trying to convince a referee paid to make me loose my time so i decided to stop my communications with this group.
Best
Fred
Recently, I heard that they were now complaining of a deficiency of sample material. I think that this is the first step in an unfortunate shortage of true sample.