Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

T.A.M
My samples are full of chips which have nothing to do with the chips described in the articles. These are almost perfect doubles:
1) same appearance on one face : same red color!
2) same range of sizes
3) same composition: Carbon, oxygen, Iron, Aluminum, Silicium in the same proportion

almost because

1) Dont produce molten iron even when heated to more than 900°C
2) Have the same chemical composition after being heated to more than 900°C
3) Not double sided: red /red rather than red/shiny grey

According to the articles the red/grey chips should be numerous while in my articles the
red/red chips are more numerous...so i'm afraid there are only two possible ways for understanding this:

1) The red-gray chips were completely invented or the th truthers were provided with
fake samples to deceive them
2) My red-red chips were added and the genuine red/gray ones removed...

I dont know which way to understand these facts is the most paranoiac one...probably you know better than me.

To be Honest i should also follow a little bit the first paranoia way:

If 911 was an inside job, its not a problem to make the common citizen believe that Al Qaeda did it. If i were one of the perpetrators i could even travel and give conferences in the USA and in Europe with wonderful powerpoints (the architectes and ingeniers one for instance) and movies (for instance the italian movie: Zero) showing that 911 was an inside job, just for fun and to make money... indeed people are totally under control through the control of the medias. The important thing if you do that is to be sure that there are enough (not so many) absurd or silly claims in your presentation so that any honest expert in the concerned fields can explain why your are just an idiot conspirationist....and you can be sure the subject will remain as exotic as the UFOs, for long...

Much more problematic is to also deceive intelligence agencies from other countries : impossible ! these have their experts and the collapse of WTC7 is much more than sufficient to convince them that there is something wrong with the official story. But another kind of deception can take place which goal would be to hide the exact type of secret technology that was used to bring down the towers. Nanothermite or another technology based on the understanding kept secret for years by militaries of the new physics behind cold fusion for example?

Many features, in particular pure iron spheroids which crackled surfaces cooled down very rapidly are also commonly seen in experiments involving very powerful electric discharges ( The new physics that occurs there is the same as behind the historical electrolysis experiment that have shown extra production of heat: in these micro-discharges are also involved, in the palladium porous structure). These discharges produce what is often called "strange radiations": nobody (at least among searchers working in public labs today) understands this physics and these objects. These were discovered by many searchers independently all over the world and given different names (ectons, micro lighting-balls, Electrum Validum...and of course strange radiations) : much bigger ones are also naturally produced by much more powerful electric discharges in the atmosphere: lighting balls.
Some time ago i believed powerful discharges was used at the WTC using capacitors. The discharges may have been triggered by the piezoelectric effect: as you can see in the USGS data: the girder coatings have Titanium but also Baryum and strontium and i think its very hard to understand the high levels of baryum and strontium (quite the same) in these coatings.
As you know high capacitors commonly use baryum titanate often mixed with strontium titanate. My understanding for a long time was that the weakening and superficial melting of the column was obtained thanks to these discharges and the very large fluxes of the strange radiations they produced heating them very efficiently. But i progressively gave up the idea because of the discoveries of nanothermite red/gray chips.
The problem is now that i cant find them so i can suspect again that nanothermite was completely invented to hide the other technology which secret is believed crucial (as you probably know it was demonstrated by a Russian team that the half life of Uranium radionucleides is modified in presence of the strange radiations so you can imagine why it is kept secret!).

Nanothermite or something else?:
For anybody in the USA reading my post and whishing to understand better what happened on 911, it's very important to realize that checking the red/gray chips hypothesis is something anybody can do at home: its straightforward!

If you personally know a new_Yorker who still has WTC dust contact him (independently, discretely, no email , no phone). Then you just need a small magnet , a needle, a 50 dollars microscope and a kiln (or know someone who is doing pottery or ceramics). Find the red/gray chip yourself, heat it yourself in your kiln, check yourself the appearance of the metallic microspheres at less than 500°C...and help me do the same.
This is crucial to help me choose between my two paranoias !!

best

Fred






De : Frédéric Henry-Couannier <[email protected]>
À : Gregg Roberts <[email protected]>; Frank Legge <[email protected]>
Cc : [email protected]; Steven <[email protected]>; Keogh Justin <[email protected]>; Larsen Brad <[email protected]>; Ryan Kevin <[email protected]>; A Carson <[email protected]>; Shane Geiger <[email protected]>
Envoyé le : Mercredi, 17 Juin 2009, 11h10mn 59s
Objet : Re : Re : Problem !

The most recent sample i received with nothing but red-only chips (or may be red/orange as Keven says) inside was from Steve White (collected in a loft at 18 Warren street).

I'm wondering how many among you did themselves the crucial ignition test and have noticed themselves the appearance of iron microspheres...please clarify

Best

F

Fred;

Thank you for your civil reply. I apologize for the harshness of my comments earlier, but the suggestions you made at that time seemed to be ONLY in favor of someone planting the red only chips within your sample.

Here is what I suggest to clarify the matter. I provided you with 4 different papers. I am sure there are other labs besides these, who have WTC dust samples...especially medical labs, where they were analyzing the dust for toxins/teratogens etc...

My suggestion is that you approach as many labs as you can, and ask them for samples of their dust. These labs have no reason to manipulate the samples. As well, you need not be specific in what you are looking for when you sequester the samples...you just wish to perform an independent analysis of the dust...that is all.

In doing this you eliminate any contact with Dr. Jones, or the truth movement, or those who would want to, either way, taint the samples or the results.

Just a suggestion, as I can see that even though you may be someone who believes the govt was in on it (or not, you have not stated clearly your position), like Dr. F. Greening, you (unlike many others) seem to place the science above all else.

Good luck with your research...keep up updated.

On a side note, did you find any grey fragments, that might have represented the "grey side" of the dual layered chips. In other words, is it possible that the dual layered chips, came apart for some reason?

TAM:)
 
F

On a side note, did you find any grey fragments, that might have represented the "grey side" of the dual layered chips. In other words, is it possible that the dual layered chips, came apart for some reason?

TAM:)

Why the red part would not react and produce molten iron without the gray part?: the Aluminum is still there in those chips even after heating up to more than 900°C

I just want to stress that the frst hypothesis i follow in my previous message is of course very unlikely but only the analysis of new sample will allow me to clarify this.
 
Why the red part would not react and produce molten iron without the gray part?: the Aluminum is still there in those chips even after heating up to more than 900°C

I just want to stress that the frst hypothesis i follow in my previous message is of course very unlikely but only the analysis of new sample will allow me to clarify this.

Yes, and that is why I suggested requesting samples from multiple labs. My suggestion is request the samples from multiple labs, including some of the medical labs that analyzed the dust for toxins/teratogens. I am sure if you inform them you are a scientists in France who wishes to conduct some independent tests on the dust, some of them would be willing. Have the samples sent to an unnamed post office box, or have them sent to someone you trust.

Otherwise, I suspect you will never eliminate your suspicions of tampering.

TAM:)
 
Yes, and that is why I suggested requesting samples from multiple labs. My suggestion is request the samples from multiple labs, including some of the medical labs that analyzed the dust for toxins/teratogens. I am sure if you inform them you are a scientists in France who wishes to conduct some independent tests on the dust, some of them would be willing. Have the samples sent to an unnamed post office box, or have them sent to someone you trust.

Otherwise, I suspect you will never eliminate your suspicions of tampering.

TAM:)

Sometime ago one of my colleagues contacted repeatedly the USGS just asking for the raw data from the mass spectrometer (because this could be useful to search for isotopic anomalies, expected in case the enigmatic "cold fusion" physics took place somehow). No answer! If they were not ready to send data electronically , why should i hope they will send us dust samples? May be our english was too approximative and the demand did not sound serious enough. Why dont you try to contact them .. if you are more diplomatic than we are they will hopefully say they can send me this dust, and i'm of course ready to receive and analyze it.

Best

Fred
 
Thinking about it, there is a third posibility: intermediaries (the sender themelves ?) checked for the presence of the red/gray chips in my samples and doing this , removed the most interesting material (the more magnetic part) probably thinking that i would be able to find other chips in the remaining dust . They were probably not aware that the genuine
red/gray chips are actually quite rare, most of the chips not being the chips of interest...
 
Sometime ago one of my colleagues contacted repeatedly the USGS just asking for the raw data from the mass spectrometer (because this could be useful to search for isotopic anomalies, expected in case the enigmatic "cold fusion" physics took place somehow). No answer! If they were not ready to send data electronically , why should i hope they will send us dust samples? May be our english was too approximative and the demand did not sound serious enough. Why dont you try to contact them .. if you are more diplomatic than we are they will hopefully say they can send me this dust, and i'm of course ready to receive and analyze it.

Best

Fred

Well I am not saying they will be one of them, but that aside, do not forget that there data, their analysis, is what is worth something to them, not the samples themselves...so they may be more willing to part with a few grams of dust, compared to sending you their copyrighted data...just a thought.

I guess I am suggesting a shotgun approach to all the possible lab sources you can find, and see who agrees to send you samples.

TAM:)
 
Thinking about it, there is a third posibility: intermediaries (the sender themelves ?) checked for the presence of the red/gray chips in my samples and doing this , removed the most interesting material (the more magnetic part) probably thinking that i would be able to find other chips in the remaining dust . They were probably not aware that the genuine
red/gray chips are actually quite rare, most of the chips not being the chips of interest...

I was under the impression (perhaps falsely) that the red/gray chips were quite common in the samples that Jones etc... had.

Getting portions of unanalyzed, untouched dust samples would solve the problem...good luck with that.

TAM:)
 
Thinking about it, there is a third posibility: intermediaries (the sender themelves ?) checked for the presence of the red/gray chips in my samples and doing this , removed the most interesting material (the more magnetic part) probably thinking that i would be able to find other chips in the remaining dust . They were probably not aware that the genuine
red/gray chips are actually quite rare, most of the chips not being the chips of interest...

Doesnt it appear odd that the only samples in existence that are said to be abundant with evidence of 'thermite' are held by the very person claiming 'thermite'. He sourced them, analysed them, writes a paper on them yet nobody else on the planet can do the same. That material would be worth more than all the diamonds on the planet its so rare. Yet here we are, having been hooked, going into scientific analysis of a red/grey substance supposedly coming from the steel of the WTC and nobody else can find any?

Why oh why are the logical and intelligent members of this or any other forum even discussing it?
 
Doesnt it appear odd that the only samples in existence that are said to be abundant with evidence of 'thermite' are held by the very person claiming 'thermite'. He sourced them, analysed them, writes a paper on them yet nobody else on the planet can do the same. That material would be worth more than all the diamonds on the planet its so rare. Yet here we are, having been hooked, going into scientific analysis of a red/grey substance supposedly coming from the steel of the WTC and nobody else can find any?

Why oh why are the logical and intelligent members of this or any other forum even discussing it?

A well told lie seems to trump any number of facts.
 
Doesnt it appear odd that the only samples in existence that are said to be abundant with evidence of 'thermite' are held by the very person claiming 'thermite'. He sourced them, analysed them, writes a paper on them yet nobody else on the planet can do the same. That material would be worth more than all the diamonds on the planet its so rare. Yet here we are, having been hooked, going into scientific analysis of a red/grey substance supposedly coming from the steel of the WTC and nobody else can find any?

Why oh why are the logical and intelligent members of this or any other forum even discussing it?

Well just to be clear, Fred-Henry does claim to have found ONE red/grey chip in his samples originally, but he cannot find any now, If I am reading his explanations correctly.

TAM:)
 
3 Norwegian Scientists debate Dr. Jones

Details here: http://zelikow.wordpress.com/2009/05/22/norwegian-state-radio-initiates-public-debate-on-911-truth/

On Wednesday, May 20th 2009, more than 7 years after the 9/11-attacks, alternative perspectives penetrate the Nowegian State Broadcasting Corporation NRK, for the first time, in the program ‘Her og Nå’ (’Here and Now’ -ed.) on NRK Radio P1.

Three Norwegian scientists has publicly attempted to discredit the University of Copenhagen’s findings in a recent scientific paper covering an extensive analysis of dust from the attacks on Manhattan in 2001. The Norwegians do not express direct support for the Bush/Cheney-conspiracy theory about Usama bin Laden.

A reply from co-author Steven E. Jones is already in place right here1 and currently awaiting response.
 
Three Norwegian scientists has publicly attempted to discredit the University of Copenhagen’s findings in a recent scientific paper covering an extensive analysis of dust from the attacks on Manhattan in 2001. The Norwegians do not express direct support for the Bush/Cheney-conspiracy theory about Usama bin Laden.

Distortion of facts. The three professors didn't try to discredit anything. I'm norwegian and have listened to the interviews. They were asked to give their opinion on this spesific paper and they gave the opinion it was weak and not in any way conclusive.
And they weren't asked about Bush/Cheney/Laden, so of course they didn't give support of any "official conspiracy".

I have studied at the institute where Grande and Einarsrud are employed, even taken courses that Grande taught. These people are real experts in inorganic chemistry and nano-materials. They analyse and synthesize these compounds on a daily basis and educate master- and PhD-students on relevant subjects. If they say the paper is weak I'm almost tempted to pull an "argument from authority".

They're asking for replications and further analysis before concluding, just like any sane scientist would do.
 
Distortion of facts. The three professors didn't try to discredit anything. I'm norwegian and have listened to the interviews. They were asked to give their opinion on this spesific paper and they gave the opinion it was weak and not in any way conclusive.
And they weren't asked about Bush/Cheney/Laden, so of course they didn't give support of any "official conspiracy".

I have studied at the institute where Grande and Einarsrud are employed, even taken courses that Grande taught. These people are real experts in inorganic chemistry and nano-materials. They analyse and synthesize these compounds on a daily basis and educate master- and PhD-students on relevant subjects. If they say the paper is weak I'm almost tempted to pull an "argument from authority".

They're asking for replications and further analysis before concluding, just like any sane scientist would do.

Bingo.

Now maybe the smart thing for Fred Henry (or others looking for HONEST results) to do, would be to get in touch with these scientists, and provide them with samples.

I am guessing you won't see Jones or Harrit jumping at the chance...

A theory/theorist that works best in the shadows, will always avoid the sunlight.

TAM:)
 
This is your way or thinking, not mine!

Well I was not speaking of you. My way of thinking is Jones has had YEARS to have other truly independent labs verify his results. If his results were so earth shattering, so conclusive, so damning, he should have sent his samples to hundreds of labs, build a huge base of comparative results, and then (A) he would have got it published in a real peer reviewed journal, and (B) he would have garnished support from the scientific community.

IMO, he has not done so, because he knows when the sunlight of honest science and repeatability are placed on his results, on his samples, he will fail, and he will lose forever, his pet "thermite" theory.

Whether that is your opinion or not...not my call.

I am hoping that like Dr. F. Greening Fred/Henri, you will put the science above agenda, paranoia, or discontent with authority or the govt of the USA.

TAM:)
 
Yes, it's been dealt with here and here.

ETA: And yes, it's nothing really "new" in that it ceases to address the fact that thermite is contradicted by existing evidence. All this Bentham paper ends up being is an in-depth analysis of the supposed "thermite chips" Jones claims were discovered in the dust. The links above deal with that analysis.

ETA #2: Link to Sunstealer's first post going into detail on his criticisms of the Bentham paper's assertions: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4607894&postcount=1694 The second of the above linked threads goes into more depth on that.
 
Last edited:
This has been discussed here many times. Basically, Bentham isn't a legitimate journal. They will publish anything so long as they are payed $800. Somebody even got a paper consisting of nonsensical gibberish generated by a computer approved for publication.

The editor the one the garbage thermite paper was published in quit over the whole thing. Apparently she wasn't even aware of paper before it was published.
 
I believe Bentham is a vanity journal where all one has to do is pay the requisite amount to get published.

It is not, strictly speaking, a peer-reviewed journal.

Scholarly Kitchen proved that and there is also a closed thread here at JREF concerning Bentham.

ETA: Boy am I slow. . .need more coffee.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom