The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

You know why at present I am barely able to find time to get on here as we are on a family vacation. You may just need to be a bit more patient with me. Sorry!

Then you have options that are respectful, Kathy.


You can get on and enjoy your holiday:this will keep, and many here would urge you to have fun and relaxation for obvious reasons. No-one will think the worse of you for not posting

Or you can devote some time to this forum and you can answer some of what you are asked. honestly.

What you cannot legitimately do is pop on and preach your little sermons then make excuses as to why you cannot actually engage with the points put to you. I addressed that waaay back in this thread talking to Christian Dude: the same points apply. And you do this a lot KK. It is just one excuse after another.
 
As for Sarah's sin, she was the one who got impatient waiting for God's promise and started a whole lot of trouble because of her disobedience. God never said it was okay for Abraham to sleep with Hagar!


He certainly didn't seem to mind it after the fact:

Genesis 21:12-13 said:
And God said unto Abraham, Let it not be grievous in thy sight because of the lad, and because of thy bondwoman; in all that Sarah hath said unto thee, hearken unto her voice; for in Isaac shall thy seed be called. And also of the son of the bondwoman will I make a nation, because he [is] thy seed.

He just didn't want anyone messing with Isaac. Well, anyone other than god himself (that whole sacrifice thing and all).
 
kurious_kathy,
if a Muslim person were to pray to Allah for work and subsequently found a job, would you think that Allah had intervened? Yes or no will be fine, thanks.

Are you trying to trick me? I have an opinion about what makes peoples prayers be hindered if you care to hear it?

Off the top of my head... I think unless one is made righteous through Christ living in him I do not think God answers all peoples prayers, not until someone is forgiven for their sins.(I could be wrong) Scripture says he causes the sun to rise on the just and the unjust so this makes my opinion a bit more complicated.

I believe God does know if a person has a heart to know him (but your allah and my God are not the same) I am concerned many get their blessings here and now but in the end they will have no reward because they are following false gods!

What does it profit a man if he gain the world but lose his soul?
 
your allah and my God are not the same
Really? Then which god is your god?

http://www.godallah.com/
The word "Allah" is the perfect description of the "One God" of monotheism for Jews, Christians and Muslims!

Is "Allah" only for Islam and Muslims?
[No! It is for All Three Abrahamic Faiths.]

"Allah" is the same word used by Christian Arabs and Jewish Arabs in their Bible, centuries before Islam came.

On page one [1] of Genesis in the Old Testament, we find the word "Allah" seventeen [17] times.

Every hotel and motel has a Bible. Next time you see one look in the introduction, you will find samples of the different languages they have translated. For Arabic they have translated the verse in the New Testament in Arabic from the famous verse in the Gospel John 3:16 -

"For God so loved the world..."
- and the word the translators used in Arabic for "God" is the very same word used by Muslims around the planet, "Allah."
 
I doubt that most Christians realize there might be a problem.
I think the standard answer would be to say, "Judge them by their Fruits."
If "W" is an example of a Christian, I think there might be a problem with that answer.
You have to Look at things on the grass roots level. At church, we got this little story about a missionary in a Muslim country who hired a local to help him. The guy told the missionary he did not know anyone who was so nice, and he decided to become a Christian too.
Missionaries are kind of special sometimes. I know a woman at my church who when she was in college, she volunteered to do a year of teaching English class in a foreign country. Beirut, Lebanon, in the middle of the civil war, when they were kidnapping westerners. I asked her if she was ever worried and she acted like she had no idea what I meant.
This kind of reinforces the point Kurious_Kathy has been working on. There really is no argument in favour of any specific religion or sect that you can't substitute another religion or sect into and leave it just as valid.
 
Well why then? Obviously this world has been affected by it and death is truly a reality because of it, so why do you choose not to believe in the concept of original sin?

People die because their bodies run down, because they get hit by a truck, washed away by a tidal wave, squashed in an earthquake, etc. Stuff just happens.

All living things die - there's nothing unusual or special about it. Why would anyone think that things last forever, NOTHING lasts forever, even mountains, even our sun. Sin's got nothing to do with it, death is just a fact of life. Without death, nothing would grow, nutrients wouldn't be returned to the soil, we'd overpopulate the earth and turn it into a ball of dust.

But people were so afraid of death that they had to come up with this idea that instead of finite beings we're eternal beings. But then some people come up with this idea that original sin isn't only going to turn you back into a somewhat finite being, but you're going to be tortured forever, UNLESS you buy into what they're selling. If they make you feel like a worthless person while they dangle this carrot of salvation in front of you, they have control over you and what you think.

Original sin is nothing but a tool that people use to control people through fear.
 
Off the top of my head... I think unless one is made righteous through Christ living in him I do not think God answers all peoples prayers, not until someone is forgiven for their sins.
Still it is the "US and Them" BS line. Why is your idea of a so-called god so limited.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Last edited:
Jesus speaks to us directly, as God in human form, in the Bible.

And Ahmed told me that Allah inspired the Qran directly. So he's one up on you guys already.

He is the living word that is the source, through the Spirit, of the written word. By the power of God, Jesus can tell us in his own words, what to believe. This is as direct a way as possible to hear the message that you are to believe.
Well, kinda. But Ahmed told me the same thing about the Qran. In fact, he missed out the Jesus part and explained that the Qran is directly inspired, and always studied in its original language. None of those messy translations. So if "direct way as possible" is your criteria, I'm afraid he's winning so far. In fact, I think Tom Cruise, relying on the teaching of on L. Ron Hubbard - a man who definitely existed, and wrote in Tom's mother tongue - also has one up on you on that basis.

How do you suggest I compare your claim with his? How do I know he's mislead, and your telling the truth? You still haven't explained. I mean look, to be honest, I'm suspicious of you both. I don't know who to believe. But I don't want to burn in hell.

So I need to know how to figure out who's telling the truth. What do you suggest?
 
Last edited:
Please, dispense with the marketing hype

I think you'll find that no-one here is suggesting that you "throw the Bible into the dustbin of history"... However, it would be conducive to meaningful discussion if you were to move it from the history section of your library and place it where it belongs: mythology

I'm just finishing up with Who Were the Early Israelites and Where Did They Come From? and had an epiphany (no, not that kind): the Old Testament is the Jews' national epic. If thought of in the same sense as Song of Roland, El Cid, The Iliad and the Odyssey, Beowulf, etc., it just makes sense. I am sure this is by no means an original concept, but it was one of those, "Wow, this fits beautifully" moments.

You know why at present I am barely able to find time to get on here as we are on a family vacation. You may just need to be a bit more patient with me. Sorry!

Then here's what you do - you politely further the conversation in which you are supposedly engaged by actually replying to posts sent to your attention.

You my dear SC are probably one of the hardest people to reach because what I'm hearing from you is you think you on good enough on your own merit so God should just let you into heaven.

Here's where I think you're wrong: I don't think Sun Countess wants God to just let her into heaven, because I don't think Sun Countess believes in the reality of either God or Heaven. I could be wrong and don't want to put words in her mouth, but I do think that is the sense of what she has been saying all along here.

kurious_kathy,
if a Muslim person were to pray to Allah for work and subsequently found a job, would you think that Allah had intervened? Yes or no will be fine, thanks.

Are you trying to trick me? I have an opinion about what makes peoples prayers be hindered if you care to hear it?

Off the top of my head... I think unless one is made righteous through Christ living in him I do not think God answers all peoples prayers, not until someone is forgiven for their sins.(I could be wrong) Scripture says he causes the sun to rise on the just and the unjust so this makes my opinion a bit more complicated.

I believe God does know if a person has a heart to know him (but your allah and my God are not the same) I am concerned many get their blessings here and now but in the end they will have no reward because they are following false gods!

What does it profit a man if he gain the world but lose his soul?

Wow, do you get out of breath side-stepping that fast? You did not answer the question. Please read it again and respond to the question asked.
 
Are you trying to trick me? I have an opinion about what makes peoples prayers be hindered if you care to hear it?

Off the top of my head... I think unless one is made righteous through Christ living in him I do not think God answers all peoples prayers, not until someone is forgiven for their sins.(I could be wrong) Scripture says he causes the sun to rise on the just and the unjust so this makes my opinion a bit more complicated.

I believe God does know if a person has a heart to know him (but your allah and my God are not the same) I am concerned many get their blessings here and now but in the end they will have no reward because they are following false gods!

What does it profit a man if he gain the world but lose his soul?

No, I am not trying to trick you, I'm asking for a YES or NO answer.

You have said that you and CD have prayed for him to find employment and you have indicated that if he were to be successful that you would credit God for helping him.

I'm asking if you are able to extend the same courtesy to Allah for helping a Muslim. Please remember the subject of this thread .

So, is it YES or NO?
 
KK said:
You my dear SC are probably one of the hardest people to reach because what I'm hearing from you is you think you on good enough on your own merit so God should just let you into heaven. Even the smallest little sin is bad. Ever lied? Ever stolen anything?? Ever had a bad thought towards anyone, especially God???
Elizabeth I is right; I don't believe in Heaven and have no intentions of going there. It's not about me being good enough to get into heaven, it's about me being good enough to not believe in any religion that tells me that I'm evil just for being born.

We probably all tell white lies and think bad thoughts on occasion - how is that so egregious to your god that he has to terrorize the earth with suffering and death? Why did your Jesus have to die so that I could think a few bad thoughts every once in awhile? Why not just allow humans to be human? As far as bad thoughts about god go....well, I will say he's one of the most evil fictional characters I've ever encountered.

And are you saying this god has never advocated rape? He's never told his followers to kill all the inhabitants of a village, but to save the young virgins for themselves so that they could use them as they pleased? That he didn't consider Lot a righteous man even though he offered up his own two virgin daughters for a good gangraping?
 
Just my two cents on the Original Sin thing, no, no, no I am in no way responsible for the actions of another person whom I did not influence in any way, especially people dead thousands of years before I was born.

Any being who would hold me responsible for the actions of my great, great grandfather, especially if he was a total innocent at time ie had no knowledge of good or evil is just pure evil. And I definately don't need or feel grateful for a blood sacrifice to absolve me for something that I never did or for being something I never chose to be.
 
Just my two cents on the Original Sin thing, no, no, no I am in no way responsible for the actions of another person whom I did not influence in any way, especially people dead thousands of years before I was born.

Any being who would hold me responsible for the actions of my great, great grandfather, especially if he was a total innocent at time ie had no knowledge of good or evil is just pure evil. And I definately don't need or feel grateful for a blood sacrifice to absolve me for something that I never did or for being something I never chose to be.


QFT

Welcome AdinDraco.
 
You my dear SC are probably one of the hardest people to reach because what I'm hearing from you is you think you on good enough on your own merit so God should just let you into heaven. Even the smallest little sin is bad. Ever lied? Ever stolen anything?? Ever had a bad thought towards anyone, especially God???

As for Sarah's sin, she was the one who got impatient waiting for God's promise and started a whole lot of trouble because of her disobedience. God never said it was okay for Abraham to sleep with Hagar!

You're trying to appeal to agnostics and atheists by appealing to their faith. Can't you see how ineffective that is ?
 
Off the top of my head... I think unless one is made righteous through Christ living in him I do not think God answers all peoples prayers, not until someone is forgiven for their sins

So all those people living in terrible conditions don't get any help because they have the wrong religion ?

That's why I hate gods. They're always so self-centered.
 
And Ahmed told me that Allah inspired the Qran directly. So he's one up on you guys already.

Well, kinda. But Ahmed told me the same thing about the Qran. In fact, he missed out the Jesus part and explained that the Qran is directly inspired, and always studied in its original language. None of those messy translations. So if "direct way as possible" is your criteria, I'm afraid he's winning so far. In fact, I think Tom Cruise, relying on the teaching of on L. Ron Hubbard - a man who definitely existed, and wrote in Tom's mother tongue - also has one up on you on that basis.

How do you suggest I compare your claim with his? How do I know he's mislead, and your telling the truth? You still haven't explained. I mean look, to be honest, I'm suspicious of you both. I don't know who to believe. But I don't want to burn in hell.

So I need to know how to figure out who's telling the truth. What do you suggest?

Theists and believers in general don't seem to be able to wrap their brains around the idea that belief itself is not evidence. For some reason they see others' beliefs as unjustified and their as true only because of the belief itself, which the other people also have, anyway. So, there seems to be no way of getting that through their skulls.
 
I bet those are some of the verses that are either not to be taken literally, or are culturally specific to the time and place and not to be taken as any kind of universal moral decree.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom